
Political scientist Ian Bremmer on the Israeli-Palestinian conflict
What this covers
This is a one-on-one conversation between Ian Bremmer and Big Think's editor-in-chief, Robert Chapman-Smith, recorded a month after the October 7 attacks. It opens with the Palestinians as a forgotten party and works through Israeli domestic politics, the Gulf states, Hamas's strategy, social media, Israeli strategy, American support, and the risk of wider war. Bremmer begins with diplomatic neglect. He says the last serious American investment in peace was John Kerry's roughly 18 months of shuttle diplomacy around 2009-2011, after which attention moved to Asia and elsewhere.
The middle of the conversation covers regional and domestic politics. Bremmer describes an Israel that was already in a constitutional crisis before the attacks, with Netanyahu's effort to weaken the judiciary, and a far-right coalition expanding settlements in the West Bank while he says it also let resources reach Hamas to undercut the Palestinian Authority. He argues the Abraham Accords and normalization talks pushed the Palestinian issue aside for Gulf states such as the UAE and Saudi Arabia. He also describes Hamas embedding itself among civilians in Gaza as a trap, since any Israeli response produces images that damage Israel's standing.
The most contested stretch concerns information warfare. Bremmer holds that modern conflicts are increasingly decided by who wins the real-time headline battle. He points to the false reporting on the Gaza hospital bombing, which he says came from relying on social media rather than reporters on the ground, and which disrupted American diplomacy. He compares it with Ukraine's Snake Island story. His definition of disinformation is also provocative: any account that shows only one side qualifies, even if its individual claims are accurate.
The final sections look outward. Bremmer assesses Iran's influence over its proxies, the exposure of American forces, and the highest lone-wolf terror threat level since 9/11. He covers Joe Biden's warning that Israel's window of support will narrow, and the generational split in American opinion. He ends on a two-state solution, or perhaps three states, as the only conceivable route to peace.
Bremmer argues that understanding the Israel-Hamas conflict requires grasping the complete political, historical, and strategic context—including Israeli domestic politics, regional geopolitics, information warfare, and the mutual accountability of both parties—rather than one-dimensional narratives focused solely on either side's actions.
- Mainstream media outlets present fragmented coverage that obscures the broader context, making genuine understanding impossible
- Hamas's strategic use of civilian positioning and information warfare creates a trap that weakens Israel's international position while Israel's military response, though justified, compounds civilian suffering and plays into that trap
- A viable future requires simultaneous destruction of Hamas as a threat and creation of conditions for Palestinian peace, as destroying one without the other historically produces worse outcomes (Hezbollah after PLO removal, ISIS after Ba'ath party destruction)
This asset isn't compiled yet
You're seeing its claims, ranked. Compile it to build the argument threads, weight them, and check each claim against your library — the full view.
Gulf States (UAE, Bahrain, Saudi Arabia, Morocco) had been providing substantial humanitarian support to Palestinians and claimed there could be no Middle East peace without resolving the Palestinian-Israel issue, but then shifted to prioritizing normalization with Israel through the Abraham Accords, abandoning the Palestinian issue as a precondition for their own engagement.
“the Gulf States, who had been providing so much money for humanitarian support for Palestinians living in the West Bank, and particularly Gaza, as well as refugees in other places that they were saying there could be no peace in the Middle East unless the Palestinian-Israel issue is resolved. Well, it turned out they were willing to make peace with Israel.”
The international community, including the United States, has essentially abandoned efforts to broker a two-state peace solution over the past decade, with the last serious American diplomatic investment being John Kerry's 18-month shuttle diplomacy between 2009-2011, after which the focus shifted to Asia and other regions.
“everyone in the world has basically given up on finding a peaceful solution because they've tried for decades, it's too hard or because they're not interested; they have other things that they would rather do. The last time that the Americans...an American senior diplomat was really invested on trying to figure out a way to bring peace to this region was when John Kerry was Secretary of State in the first couple of years of the Obama administration. And he did shuttle diplomacy between the Israelis, the Palestinians, the Jordanians, the Egyptians, I mean, all the time, for 18 months this was his top priority. He wanted a Nobel Peace Prize for it. He failed. And after that, basically the Americans gave up.”
The New York Times and Wall Street Journal, despite employing professional journalists, published false claims about a hospital bombing in Gaza (reporting Israeli responsibility, 500 deaths, direct missile strike) because they were receiving real-time information from social media rather than on-the-ground journalists, creating an information warfare vulnerability.
“This was the New York Times, it was the Wall Street Journal, so it wasn't just left or right, it was both, they both have a lot of journalists that are very professional and they do very solid work, but they were getting their real-time information from social media from the region, and it was a disinformation-rich environment. And so you see these blaring headlines, and it's the middle of the night when this hospital is hit and no one has good information. You don't have journalists that are on the ground that are, that are real-time reporting to you. So they're getting that information secondhand from journalists on the ground. And most of those journalists are getting that information from Hamas sources. And so they said: 'A hospital is hit. 500 people are dead. And it was an Israeli missile that hit them.' And it turned out that all three of those pieces of information were false.”
Hamas had approximately 2,000 fighters who successfully breached one of the world's most well-defended borders with elite Israeli intelligence capabilities, killed more Jews in a single day than had occurred anywhere since the Holocaust, and captured approximately 250 hostages—a level of success Hamas likely did not anticipate.
“There were some 2,000 Hamas fighters, terrorists that managed to get across one of the most well-defended borders with some of the best intelligence out there. Human intelligence, signals intelligence managed to get across the border, kill Israelis with reckless abandon, and capture some 250 hostages and bring them back into Gaza. I have a hard time believing that Hamas expected that they would have that kind of success, that they would be able to kill more Jews in one day than had happened anywhere in the world since the Holocaust.”
Both Jews and Palestinians have legitimate historical and contemporary claims to live on the contested territory, but the core issue is not who has greater historical rights but rather finding a way for both groups to live together in peace given they have both inhabited the land for their entire lifetimes.
“Both the Jews and the Palestinians have long, long running and legitimate claims to live on this territory. Palestinians, some 700,000 plus were kicked off these territories after 1948 post-Holocaust. The Jews had lived on these territories for millennia...the reality is that for the Jews and the Palestinians that are fighting over this land today, they've been living there for their lifetimes and, and so it's really not about who has a right to live on the territory. It's rather that they need to find a way to live together in peace.”
Modern warfare is increasingly determined not by military success on the ground but by who can drive real-time disinformation and headlines in social media most effectively, with information warfare becoming as important as or more important than kinetic operations in determining conflict outcomes.
“the point is the same, that we are no longer fighting a war that is only on the ground with the success or not of who's winning militarily. So much more of the fight is being determined by who is able to drive real-time disinformation with the headlines in social media.”
US carrier strike groups are already directly engaged in the Middle East conflict, conducting direct strikes against Iranian Shia proxies in Syria, with American servicemen and women already taking casualties (injuries, not deaths yet), escalating US involvement beyond the Israel-Hamas conflict into broader regional warfare.
“there are American carrier strike groups in the Eastern med. and in the Gulf. They've already been involved in direct strikes against Iranian Shia proxies in Syria. American servicemen and women have already taken casualties, not deaths, not so far, but actually injured troops because of the knock-on impact of the war between Israel and Hamas.”
Israel has 30-40,000 Hamas fighters distributed throughout Gaza's civilian population, making military success against Hamas inherently dependent on civilian casualties at a large scale unless Israel is willing to extend the operation indefinitely.
“we are talking about 30 to 40,000 fighters. And Hamas is, you know, they are, they're absolutely integrated in the firmament of civilian society across Gaza.”
Iran has influence over but not operational control of its proxies in the region, meaning proxies like Houthis and Shia militants could independently escalate against Israel and American forces even if Iran discourages escalation, particularly if Hamas appears to be losing everything.
“What we need to watch out for for a regional war is that number one, Iran has influence over, but not operational control over its proxies in the region. And as the war in Gaza gets bloodier, and if it looks like Hamas is really, truly losing everything that they have, there are others in the region that may well be willing to fight and escalate against Israel and against Americans in the region irrespective of what Iran does or does not say to them.”
A two- or three-state solution is the only conceivable path to regional peace, requiring Palestinians to have the ability to live in peace on land they can defend and govern separately from Israelis, which is impossible to achieve in current circumstances but becomes more necessary after the current conflict.
“I cannot see any environment where we have peace in the region without a two- or three-state solution. Whether, you know, you have the Palestinians governed in the same way with the same institutions in Gaza and the West Bank are separate. I don't know. But clearly, the Palestinians must have the ability to live in peace on land that they can defend and govern. Now we are nowhere close to that”
Iran believes the Jewish state of Israel should be replaced with Palestine and has continuing alliances with proxies (Yemen, Iraq, Syria Shia proxies) that share this position, making Iran a structural threat to Israel's existence.
“that is clearly true for Iran, which continues along with Hamas to believe that, that the Jewish people in the state of Israel should be replaced with Palestine.”
Israel before October 7th was domestically divided due to Netanyahu's attempts to weaken the judiciary and consolidate power, with Israelis revolting and enormous domestic instability threatening Israel's democracy from internal constitutional crisis, not from Palestinian threats.
“before the events of October 7th, the terrorist events against the people of Israel, you had enormous domestic instability. That domestic instability was the people of Israel revolting against Netanyahu, attempting to change a very strong, independent judiciary of that country to basically report to the executive and report to whoever was in charge in the Knesset.”
By definition, social media accounts presenting only one side of a conflict are engaged in disinformation because disinformation is defined as information that is not interested in understanding the entirety of what's happening, regardless of whether individual claims are factually accurate.
“And by definition, that is disinformation because it is not interested in understanding the entirety of what's going on.”
Hamas deliberately embeds military infrastructure (missiles, commanders, tunnels) within civilian areas and uses Palestinian civilians as hostages, forcing Israel into a situation where targeting militant positions requires killing civilians—and Hamas understands this creates an information warfare advantage by generating images of civilian casualties that undermine Israel's international standing.
“It is Hamas that is operating on the ground with tunnels underneath those targets. It is Hamas that has their missiles and their commanders in residential buildings and right next to playgrounds and right next to hospitals and even shooting out of mosques. Now they know exactly what they're doing. They're not just holding 200 plus Israelis and other civilians hostage illegally, but they're also holding large numbers of Palestinian civilians hostage...Hamas is also deeply responsible for making the only way that Israel can kill terrorists to ensure that large numbers of Palestinian civilians also die. That they are not just fighting Israel militarily because they will lose badly if they fight Israel militarily. They are fighting in the court of public opinion. They are fighting an information war, and they are using disinformation.”
Israeli Defense Forces were diverted from Gaza security to the West Bank and Israeli proper to manage settlement-related violence and Palestinian resistance, leaving Gaza inadequately defended against Hamas despite Hamas having 'abysmal economic conditions' with half the population lacking sufficient food and 90% without access to clean water.
“the Israeli Defense Forces some of the best in the world, incredibly well-trained high morale, while a lot of them had been sent to the West Bank and to the border zone inside Israel proper in an effort to contain and respond to that violence. Where were they in Gaza? Not worried about Gaza...you took one of the world's best-trained, most effective defense forces, intelligence forces, security forces, border forces, and, and you had them focusing on everything but a terrorist organization that was running Gaza with a people that had abysmal economic conditions, life conditions, half of them without enough food to eat, 90% of them without access to clean water.”
The false hospital bombing story prevented the United States from negotiating with Palestinian and Arab leaders during critical diplomatic moments because they had accepted Hamas's false narrative and condemned Israel, demonstrating how information warfare can directly undermine diplomatic efforts.
“And not just the journalists that are more supportive of the Palestinian than the Israeli cause, but also the governments in the region who condemned Israel, the governments of the region who decided they weren't gonna meet with Biden, the Palestinian authority, the Jordanian, the Egyptians as Biden was meeting with Netanyahu. Now this was absolutely essential at a time that the United States was sending its President to try to find a way to, to stabilize this environment. And they, they probably would've failed, but they're much more likely to fail if they can only talk to Israel and they can't talk to the other side. And they failed because of Hamas misinformation.”
In the early stages of the Russia-Ukraine war, the Ukrainian military successfully deployed disinformation (the Snake Island narrative claiming soldiers refused surrender and were killed) at greater scale and effect than Hamas in the Gaza conflict, but it had less political impact because Western audiences were already predisposed to support Ukraine regardless of narrative accuracy.
“The, this was happening to a lesser degree in the early stages of the Russia-Ukraine war, but it was happening much more successfully by the Ukrainians who almost everyone in the world supported. So you'll remember there was this Snake Island attack and you had, you know, this, this news report that was put out and promoted by the Ukrainian military and the government that showed that there were, you know, people on the ground and the Russians demanded that they surrender, they refused. They, they used an obscenity and the Russians blew them all up and they died. And they were seen as heroes all over the world, except it never happened. No one was killed on Snake Island. The people were captured and they were released.”
Netanyahu's far-right coalition government has been willingly expanding illegal settlements in the West Bank, reducing Palestinian territory and restricting Palestinian access to work and school, while simultaneously providing Hamas with resources, money, and work visas to weaken the Palestinian Authority—prioritizing political control over national security.
“Netanyahu's government was engaging more with Hamas in Gaza at the expense of the Palestinian authority, because they never wanted to pursue a two-state solution. So they forgot about the Palestinians too...Netanyahu...government has been willing to not only expand illegally, the settlements in the West Bank, reducing the territory that the Palestinians can live on...Netanyahu was providing Hamas in Gaza with more resources, with more money, with more ability to have work visas to come on over into Israel. Why? Because they were just focused on governance. According to Netanyahu, they just wanted to rebuild Gaza 'cause he wanted a stronger Hamas to weaken the Palestinian authority.”
Hamas's strategy of embedding in civilian areas creates a trap for Israel by ensuring that any military response generates images of civilian casualties, which undermine Israel's international standing and regional relationships—this trap was successful because it transferred Israel from its strongest geopolitical position since independence to one of international isolation.
“Is that a trap for Israel? Absolutely. That's a trap for Israel. Absolutely. That makes Israel weaker and more vulnerable than the geopolitical position they were in on October 6th. I mean, that strong position of Israel with the countries of the region working with them, that's a direct threat to the future of Hamas. That's a direct threat to their being able to drive their agenda to undermine Israel, to remove Israel from the region.”
Generation Z and young Americans support the Palestinian position more strongly than they support Israel, with this preference particularly pronounced on college campuses and among the progressive wing of the Democratic Party including both 'the Squad' and broader progressive membership.
“Generation Z, young people in the U.S. support the Palestinian position more strongly than they support Israel. And you have seen that particularly on college campuses across the country, but also more broadly and many on the progressive wing of the Democratic party. And I'm not just talking about 'the Squad' and Rashida Tlaib and AOC I'm talking more broadly are in increasingly, deeply uncomfortable with the extent of the Israeli military strikes against Hamas and the Palestinian civilians in Gaza.”
President Biden has stated clearly to the Israeli war cabinet that US support for Israel is a 'window that will narrow' if atrocities continue, signaling that America's unconstrained support cannot be guaranteed indefinitely under current Israeli military conduct.
“President Biden has made it clear to the Israeli war cabinet that the ability of the United States to continue to provide unconstrained support for Israel is a window that will narrow if the present levels of atrocities continue.”
Threat assessments for lone wolf terror attacks against Americans in the US or the region are at their highest level post-9/11 according to the FBI and other US security officials, representing a significant unmonitored escalation risk.
“We've already heard from the head of the FBI and from others that that threat assessment is higher than they've seen at any point post-9/11. That's a real concern. Obviously that's something that can happen.”
Israeli citizens overwhelmingly blame Netanyahu and his government for the October 7th attacks in consistent polling, and view the government as unfit to both defend Israel and pursue peace with Palestinians, with broad consensus across the entire Israeli political spectrum that this government must be replaced.
“The Israeli people want Netanyahu out. They overwhelmingly blame him and his government for the events of October 7th, consistently in polls taken inside Israel. In fact, one of the only things that the Middle Eastern peoples can agree on in, in this conflict is that the Israeli Prime Minister and his government need to go, that they, that they are not fit for office either to govern Israel and defend Israel, or to engage and create peace with the Palestinians.”
The 'Arab Street' (public demonstrations across Arab nations) is expressing solidarity with Palestinians, forcing Arab governments that want to work with Israel to become unable to do so because of domestic political pressure created by public sentiment.
“when that's happening across the region and the Arab Street is demonstrating in solidarity with the Palestinians, then even if you have a number of wealthier Arab countries that want to continue to work with Israel, they can't because of the domestic pressure.”
Before October 7th Israel was domestically divided but geopolitically strongest; after October 7th Israel is domestically unified but geopolitically weakened and isolated, representing a complete reversal of political conditions.
“So it's very interesting. You have an environment where before the acts of October 7th, Israel was the most divided domestically because of the response to Netanyahu, but the strongest in the region. Then the events of October 7th happen, and suddenly Israel is enormously unified...But the international environment from Israel has suddenly become one of massive criticism and condemnation.”
After October 7th, Israeli domestic instability and divisiveness vanished, replaced by unity through creation of a unity war cabinet, with all Israelis responding to the existential threat by saying 'we must defeat Hamas' and 'we must destroy these terrorists that threatened our homeland and killed our children.'
“Then the events of October 7th happen, and suddenly Israel is enormously unified. Everyone is responding. You get a, a unity war cabinet because everyone says, we must defeat Hamas. We must destroy these terrorists that have just threatened our homeland and have killed our children.”
Saudi Arabia was improving informal relations with Israel and moving toward normalization despite conservative Saudi populations cautious about Palestinian issues, showing that economic and security interests were overriding Palestinian concerns in regional diplomacy.
“That's why the Saudis were improving their informal relations and were moving towards normalization. Even though the Saudi population is going to be quite cautious and conservative on the Palestinian issue, they say, 'No, the priority is we gotta find a way to work with Israel.'”
Turkish President Erdogan stated Hamas is not a terrorist organization but a liberation movement and has not condemned Hamas for hostages or killing 1,400 Israeli civilians, and Turkey expelled Israeli diplomats as a response to the Israeli military operations.
“Turkish President Erdogan, who has said that Hamas is not a terrorist organization, he has said that Hamas is a liberation movement, and he hasn't condemned the Hamas from the hostages that've taken from the 1,400 civilians that they killed. Not at all. So they've thrown out the Israeli diplomats on the ground as well.”
Significant pressure exists on Biden from young Americans and Democrats in Congress opposing continued US military support for Israel as currently conducted, creating domestic political opposition to unconstrained support.
“you have significant pressure, especially among young people, and especially among Democrats in Congress saying, 'We can no longer provide the kind of support that we have historically given what's happening presently on the ground.'”
Israel faces an inherent information warfare disadvantage in conducting military operations because operational details—hitting ambulances, targeting civilians—generate images that are immediately weaponized by Hamas and social media regardless of military context or justification.
“They hit an ambulance. Now that ambulance, it looks like it was being used by Hamas fighters. But if you've got videos that are showing that the Israelis are hitting an ambulance, what is Hamas gonna say? What are people gonna run with? It's, 'Look, they're, they're hitting ambulances.' So you can't, it's not just what's happening on the ground, it's also how what's happening on the ground is perceived.”
Ideas circulated in Netanyahu's government about forcibly relocating Palestinians to Egypt/Sinai or Jordan are not viable solutions because Palestinians will not accept them, Egypt and Jordan will not accept them, Gulf States will not accept them, and these are not Israel's enemies—making such solutions politically impossible.
“The idea among some in Netanyahu's government, and by the way, far too many, that what really needs to happen is you need the Palestinians to leave. They need to, to go to Egypt, to the Sinai, and maybe never come back...that is not a viable solution. The Palestinians won't stand for it. The Egyptians won't stand for it. The Jordanians won't stand for it. The Gulf states won't stand for it. And these are countries that are not fundamentally Israel's enemies, but they will not tolerate it.”
Israel instructed Gaza civilians to evacuate south but provided inadequate food, water, fuel, and medicine to evacuation zones before adequate refugee camps were established, creating a situation where most civilians would not evacuate and Hamas could prevent remaining civilians from leaving.
“they're telling people to evacuate into the south before there's adequate food or water or fuel or medicine for those people in the south before there are adequate refugee camps set up for those people in the South. So who's gonna leave? How many people will go? And of course, Hamas is also preventing some of them from leaving.”
Israel declared a siege on all 2.3 million people in Gaza (withholding food, water, fuel, medication) as a military strategy to pressure Hamas, but such collective punishment creates war crimes and massive humanitarian tragedy, forcing Israel to reverse course and allow limited aid despite tactical military advantage.
“Israel said that they were going to do a siege on all of Gaza. So not just Hamas, because you can't have a siege on Hamas. Instead it was 2.3 million people: We're not getting you food, we're not getting you water, we're not getting you fuel, we're not getting you medication. And you know that that is going to cause massive humanitarian tragedy. But that was the Israeli response. And my response to that is, 'You don't wanna do that.' That is, you know, that's gonna create war crimes and so you need to get humanitarian aid.”
The Abraham Accords (normalization between UAE, Bahrain, Morocco, and Israel) represented expanded trade, investment, and security cooperation based on viewing Israel as an economic, security, and technological juggernaut that regional countries wanted to work with.
“Israel had benefited from being seen as an economic juggernaut, a security juggernaut, a technological juggernaut. And a lot of the countries in the region wanted to work more closely with Israel as a consequence of that. That's why you had the UAE and Bahrain and Morocco signing the Abraham Accords, not just to normalize diplomatic relations, but also to dramatically expand trade and investment with Israel.”
After October 7th Israeli bombardment of Gaza began, Arab governments became unable to continue normalization with Israel because of a freeze on diplomatic engagement and domestic Arab street pressure for solidarity with Palestinians, even though they wanted to continue working with Israel.
“once you have Israel in response to these terrorist acts going after Hamas, and as they're doing so killing all of these Palestinian civilians, well then there's a freeze on everything; then if you are, you know, Jordan, you say, 'We can't work with, we can't engage with Israel going forward.'”
Israel's efforts toward regional geopolitical strength and normalization agreements were making Israel 'the strongest it had been geopolitically since independence,' but October 7th and the subsequent military response have converted this position into international isolation, with efforts that produced strength now moving in a 'very different direction' and progress potentially lost.
“efforts that had made Israel the strongest, geopolitically, that had had ever been, since independence, suddenly are moving in a very different direction, it's, it's hard for those countries to even maintain present levels of engagement with Israel. And indeed, a lot of the progress that had been made could be lost.”
Something is not black or white does not mean everything is the same shade of gray; Hamas deliberately targeting civilians differs from Israel targeting militants while killing civilians, both are deeply problematic compared to no civilian deaths, and the economic conditions of Palestinians are radically worse than those of Israelis—all are true simultaneously.
“when you say that something is not black or white, that doesn't mean everything is the same shade of gray. I mean, we, we can all admit that, you know, Hamas targeting civilians is not the same thing as Israel targeting the military, but also killing a lot of civilians. We can also both agree that both of those are deeply problematic compared to not having any civilians die. We know that we, we also know that the economic conditions that Palestinians are living under in Gaza are radically worse than those of Palestinians in the West Bank, which are radically worse than those of Jews living in Israel.”
Iran and its Supreme Leader are publicly implying that 'the world will burn' as a consequence of Israeli actions in Gaza, but using passive voice and deliberately distancing Iran from direct action to avoid appearing to direct escalation, signaling Iran's preference for proxies to act independently.
“We have seen that the Iranian President has, and the Supreme Leader have both said things publicly that imply that the world will burn because of what the Israelis are doing in Gaza, but they use the passive voice. They are, they are very careful not to say, 'We Iran will do X, Y, and Z.' They'll say, 'These are the impacts that it will have.' These are, these are clearly statements that are meant to put Iran at a distance from direct involvement and engagement, even though the Iranians are the ones that have provided weapons and training and money for Hamas and for Israel's principle enemies in the region.”
Social media dehumanizes people, induces hate, and prevents good information flow and person-to-person engagement needed to resolve conflicts; long-form content, direct engagement, community, schools, and family are what humans need but the internet provides the opposite through algorithms programmed by business models that productize people for profit.
“Social media is dehumanizing. It is hate-inducing. And it is actively preventing people from getting good information and from talking to each other. What we need is less social media. We need more long-form content. We need more person-to-person engagement. We need more community, more schools, more family. We, we need more humanity. Algorithms are not humanity. Algorithms are programmed by business models that are productizing people for profit.”
Israel was previously the strongest it had been geopolitically since independence before October 7th, with regional countries working with Israel and normalization agreements expanding, but this position was directly threatened by Hamas because Israel's strength undermined Hamas's regional influence and ability to drive its anti-Israel agenda.
“That strong position of Israel with the countries of the region working with them, that's a direct threat to the future of Hamas. That's a direct threat to their being able to drive their agenda to undermine Israel, to remove Israel from the region.”
The conflict is not close to resolution, and while Bremmer is concerned about World War III talk (which he doesn't see as proximate), he believes the likelihood of escalation in ways that actors don't want but happens anyway is a very real possibility.
“I don't think we are anywhere close to out of the woods on this one. And I, while I'm, I'm deeply concerned about people out there talking about World War III because I really don't see that as a, you know, sort of proximate risk, the likelihood that this can escalate in ways that none of the actors want to see, but can happen anyway- I think that's a very real possibility.”
US military support for Israel is no longer guaranteed to remain at historical levels even from Biden and the Senate and House, facing pressure from progressive wings that will grow over time, making it uncertain whether the US will provide the same military equipment and support in four weeks that it has historically provided.
“I think it is not guaranteed that in another four weeks time, the U.S. will still be willing to provide the kind of military equipment, high-tech, military equipment and support that they have provided to Israel, historically, if Israel continues to fight the war the way they have been fighting it, even the United States, Biden and his cabinet and core members of Senate in the house are facing that pressure from their own progressive wing- and that is going to grow over time.”
Biden faces a political liability in 2024 because he would be running on starting two wars (Israel-Hamas and Ukraine involvement) without having won either, even though neither was started by Biden, meaning American taxpayers are paying for wars and Americans might take casualties in a conflict Biden hasn't justified to the public.
“you go from no wars started under the Trump administration to two wars started under the Biden administration. Neither of them started by Biden, but both of them, the American taxpayers are paying for, and one of which the Americans might be taking casualties. That is a very hard thing to run on if you are President Biden.”
Peace occurs when both sides are exhausted according to Henry Kissinger, and oddly the current war has brought the region closer to a two-state solution than existed on October 6th because everyone now understands you cannot ignore the Palestinian issue without serious consequences.
“it was Henry Kissinger that said that the time you get peace is when both sides are exhausted. And he's someone that knows a lot about fighting wars and war crimes, frankly, but also knows a lot about negotiating peace. And I do think that we are oddly closer to a two-state solution today than we were on October 6th. And the reason for that is because everyone in this region and with equities in this region now understand that you can no longer ignore the Palestinian issue. Or if you do, it's at your peril.”
Mainstream media outlets (CNN, Fox) cannot effectively cover the Israel-Hamas conflict because headline-driven formats prevent the nuanced discussion required to understand the complete context and mutual accountability, making genuine understanding impossible on those platforms.
“You can't have this conversation on CNN or Fox. You can't do it, right? Because if you are only talking about how the Israeli Defense Forces are responsible for these brutal killings, or if you're only talking about what Hamas did on October 7th, and you don't talk about the broader context, right, you are absolutely not understanding what's happening in this war right now.”
Israel must simultaneously destroy Hamas as a threat and create conditions for Palestinian peace, as these are mutually necessary conditions—one without the other produces worse outcomes for Israel's long-term security.
“at the same time they are trying to destroy Hamas- they must create conditions for peace for the Palestinian people.”
Israel should prioritize spending time on information warfare, building multilateral alliances, and creating safe humanitarian zones for Palestinians over pure military focus on destroying Hamas, because military victory without political conditions for peace will generate worse outcomes than Hamas.
“So my point is, spend more time not just on how you're going to blow up Hamas, but also on building your information war on building your relations with other countries. If the, if you're losing support from the United States because you refuse to allow in aid for the Palestinians, then you need to spend more time sending in aid with the Palestinians.”
Current suffering (with estimates of approximately 0.5% of Gaza's Palestinian population dead, roughly 1 in 200 Palestinians, and rising casualty figures) will make it harder to transition from war to peace, with each civilian death generating trauma and resentment that will compound peacemaking difficulties for generations.
“if you're already talking about half a percent of the Palestinian population in Gaza is dead since October 7th; one of every 200 Palestinians in Gaza dead- and those numbers are going up. I don't know exactly what those numbers are. They fight between the United Nations and between like, you know, the Gaza Health Ministry, which is Hamas and you can't trust them, but the numbers are big. We know the numbers are big. Like every one of those civilian deaths is going to make it harder to get from here to there”
Without long-form content and complex discussion, understanding of the Israel-Gaza war is impossible; binary framings or one-sided narratives prevent comprehension of what is actually happening in the war.
“that is what we have today. But that is the opposite from what we need if we want to understand and if we want to resolve this Israel-Gaza war.”
When Israel previously removed the PLO from Lebanon, it resulted in Hezbollah (a worse outcome), and when the US destroyed the Ba'ath Party in Iraq, it resulted in ISIS (also worse); therefore if Israel destroys Hamas without creating conditions for Palestinian peace, it will similarly end up with something worse than Hamas.
“We all know that when Israel was fighting against the PLO and they removed them from Lebanon, they ended up with Hezbollah- that's not better. When the Americans fought against Saddam Hussein and destroyed the Ba'ath party in Iraq, they ended up with the Islamic state- that's not better. So if Israel is going to destroy Hamas, but they don't create the conditions for peace with the Palestinian people, they will end up with something worse.”
If people experience only one side of a conflict's suffering without understanding the other side's experience, they cannot grasp the full context, making balanced understanding impossible and facilitating disinformation and polarization.
“The one thing that we know for certain is that the level of suffering that has occurred on the ground for Jews and for Palestinians over the last four weeks is unlike almost anything that's been experienced by anyone watching this video right now. And yet you would never feel that way if you were digesting the accounts that are driving most of the media in social platforms.”
The damage that can be done through suffering and trauma in the coming weeks and months will be remembered for generations and will make peacemaking much harder and longer-term, creating multi-generational obstacles to reconciliation beyond the immediate humanitarian crisis.
“the damage that you can do to make that much, much harder and longer term with the suffering that will be remembered for generations and generations, that is a very different story.”
No space exists on social media for nuanced discussion that acknowledges different shades of moral severity without complete moral relativism; the platform's structural features prevent such discussions.
“There is no space for that on social media. There's none.”
Hassan Nasrallah of Hezbollah gave a speech supporting Hamas in strong terms but explicitly did not indicate Hezbollah would open a second front against Israel, signaling Hezbollah will not escalate despite rhetorical support for Hamas.
“Nasrallah, Hassan Nasrallah who runs Hezbollah, gave a really big and very strongly anticipated speech where he said, 'You guys go Hamas, you're doing a great job.' But certainly did not in any way imply that Hezbollah is going to be out there fighting for and opening a second front as a consequence of what Israel is doing on the ground in Gaza.”
Donald Trump will exploit Biden's Middle East and Ukraine foreign policy challenges as a political vulnerability when he becomes the Republican nominee, making these foreign policy crises significant liabilities for Biden heading into 2024.
“I, I expect that Trump, when he becomes the Republican nominee, and that certainly looks very likely at this point, will make a meal out of that. That is a vulnerability for the United States and Biden knows it.”
After the current war ends, demand for peace between Palestinians and Israelis will be far more prioritized, with much more capital expended on humanitarian reconstruction of Gaza, diplomatic development of new Palestinian authorities, and determining who would govern reconstructed Gaza.
“as we come out of this war, the level of demand for finding a route for peace between the Palestinians and the Israelis will be far more prioritized. Much more capital will be expended on trying to make that happen. Some of that will be humanitarian resources to try to rebuild Gaza. Some of that will be diplomatic resources to try to come up with what a new Palestinian authority for Gaza might look like.”
After four weeks of conflict, World War III is not imminent and nobody sees it coming 'anytime soon', but the likelihood of expansion is significant, with the most probable expansion being increased Israeli-Hamas violence that will spread through proxy strikes and counter-strikes.
“So far I would say we're four weeks in the likelihood of expansion is significant, but nobody sees World War III coming anytime soon. What we have is an expansion of Israel's fight against Hamas, and that means that we're gonna see a lot, a lot, a lot more casualties.”
Houthis in Yemen could engage in strikes into the Strait of Hormuz and attack oil tankers, which would increase global energy prices and potentially create a global recession, with severe negative consequences for Biden's political position.
“The Houthis in Yemen in particular, they could also engage in strikes into the Straits of Hormuz. They could hit oil tankers that could increase energy prices and create a global recession. Again, that would hurt Biden very dramatically.”
Social media verification algorithms and promotion systems predominantly amplify accounts that present only suffering of one side (either only Jewish suffering or only Palestinian suffering), not balanced coverage, making the social media environment systematically disinformation-rich by design.
“the number of accounts that if you look not at one post, but if then you go back into the account and say, 'Okay, what are they presenting? Are they actually presenting the news because it's being put out as if they're presenting the news? There's a headline that you need to focus on,' then you realize, wait a second, this entire account is only focusing on the suffering of Jews, or this entire account is only focusing on the suffering of Palestinians. I, I would wager that that is the vast majority of the social media verified, algorithmically promoted accounts that people are presently digesting on this conflict.”