
How Generational Forces Have Set the Stage for a Retirement Crisis (w/ Neil Howe)
What this covers
This is a 2020 interview in which Ed Harrison of Real Vision questions demographer Neil Howe, filmed in February 2020, just before the pandemic recession. Howe lays out his generational framework: age on one axis and time on the other, with generations as bundles of parallel life paths. Generational archetypes recur in a fixed order, and he places civic crises roughly 80 to 90 years apart, running from the Revolution through the Civil War and the Depression and World War II to the present. He grounds the method in demography's forecasting strength, since fertility, mortality, and migration change slowly.
The middle of the conversation sets millennials beside the GI generation. Howe cites protective parenting, falling risk-taking in CDC survey indicators, and the highest rate of multigenerational living since the late 1930s. He also describes the cautious Silent generation, who did well by following rules. He contrasts these with Boomers, who he says enjoyed nearly free state universities funded by GI taxes but did not reinvest in public goods.
The politics are the most contested part. Howe argues that populism has historically meant authoritarianism, tracing the word back to Julius Caesar, and he lists leaders such as Narendra Modi and Xi Jinping as appealing to majority identity. He denies that Trump really offers millennials the order they want, and he compares tariffs now with Smoot-Hawley. He sees anti-trust returning as a 2020 issue, with younger Chicago-school economists backing stricter enforcement while neoliberalism loses credibility, a point Harrison also presses.
On economics, Howe cites Powell's worry that record deficits in good times leave the Fed near the zero bound when recession arrives. He predicts austerity will come at exactly the wrong moment, and he argues that big institutional ideas are both conceived and enacted in crises. Inequality, he adds, peaked in the late 1920s and bottomed around 1970.
Howe argues that generational archetypes follow predictable patterns that shape history through a cycle of civic crises and cultural awakenings, with millennials now driving a shift toward community, order, and collective investment similar to the GI generation of the 1930s, requiring major institutional restructuring during inevitable periods of crisis.
- Generational archetypes recur in predictable order and reshape every phase of life they move through, creating a closed system where history creates generations and generations create history
- Millennials' preference for security, order, and community over individualism parallels the GI generation's response to the Great Depression, manifesting in populism and anti-trust sentiment across the political spectrum
- Major institutional reforms only occur during crises when the rules can be completely rewritten; the coming recession will force difficult tradeoffs between unfunded liabilities and future investment
This asset isn't compiled yet
You're seeing its claims, ranked. Compile it to build the argument threads, weight them, and check each claim against your library — the full view.
The psychology of budget cutting is the opposite of economic logic: when recession hits and the economy is spiraling, the political response will be to cut deficits rather than expand counter-cyclical spending, forcing budget cuts precisely when they are economically wrong, creating perverse policy timing.
“That's my point. That's what's going to happen and you can just see it. Do you think we're suddenly going to say, oh, the economy's is massively spiraling into recession, let's just not tax for three years and run a 18% of GDP debt. No, that's not going to be the political response. The political response is going to be the opposite.”
Boomers attended state universities essentially for free (UC Berkeley/San Diego cost ~$85 per semester in the best universities), paid for by the GI generation's taxes, yet never invested back in infrastructure or public goods, instead tearing down infrastructure like dams and expecting younger generations to pay for their own education and unfunded liabilities.
“When boomers went to school, public paid for it, state colleges wherever are for free. I went to University of California and I went to San Diego and Berkeley and I think I paid $85 per semester. Best universities in the country. I paid almost nothing. Guess what, guess who paid for it? That generation we hated, the GI generation.”
Millennials were raised with protective parenting, given rules, assured everything would be fine, and encouraged not to take risks, making them the most risk-averse generation in modern times, reflected in CDC data showing 150 Youth Risk Surveillance Indicators all trending downward (declining drinking, smoking, crime).
“millennials were raised with order. They were stressed over by protective parents, given rules, assured that everything was going to go all right, everyone made sure that everything went fine with them. They were encouraged not to take any risks. Millennials are also famously risk averse generation.”
Inequality peaked in the late 1920s (similar to today) and reached its all-time low in the late 1960s and early 1970s (when the GI generation was retiring), showing cyclical inequality patterns tied to generational economic power.
“The actual trend in equality was very similar. That was a peak in the late 1920s. It's obviously very high today. It reached its all-time low by the way when the GI generation was right about to retire, late 1960s, early '70s was probably the low point of the Gini coefficient over the last century.”
Multigenerational living is resurging as millennials move back in with parents, with approximately 20% of 25-34 year-olds living with older generations, the highest rate since 1937-1938, reversing the nuclear family pattern that lasted only about one and a half generations and represented a brief historical anomaly.
“About 20% of 25- to 34-year-olds, that's getting into an old age bracket, are living with an older generation, typically their parents. This hasn't been true, by the way, since 1938, 1937, it's very high on historical terms.”
Demography has exceptional forecasting capability because demographic variables like fertility, mortality, and migration change slowly and are well-known, allowing demographers to predict population numbers decades in advance with high confidence.
“when you specify all these things, and a lot of them are known pretty well, they don't change very fast, you can be pretty certain about numbers in the population going way out. It's one of the very few certain things you can tell about the future.”
Current global leaders like Modi (focused on Hindu majority), Xi Jinping (promoting Han Chinese identity and culture), Shinzo Abe (reviving Shinto tradition), Bolsonaro, and Boris Johnson are all appealing to majoritarian ethnic or national identity and moving away from cosmopolitan universalism.
“Narendra Modi cares about the Hindus and that's his group. Everyone else can go to hell. Xi Jinping, he cares about the Han in Chinese, the great Han as he calls them, and everyone in China is going back to wearing an old Han clothing. They're eating Han food...You look the Shinzo Abe in Japan, he's the same thing. He's find a traditional, the Shinto, it's going back.”
Federal Reserve Chairman Jerome Powell warned that the Fed fears when recession hits, it will be out of ammunition (at zero bound, exhausted tools) precisely because Congress is running record deficits during low unemployment and economic expansion, creating a pro-cyclical deficit that prevents counter-cyclical spending when recession arrives.
“Jerome Powell, Chairman Jerome Powell, gave recently to the House Budget Committee...He said, I have one fear...he said, I have one fear and that is we're now running record low unemployment. We're running 5% of GDP deficit.”
Trump is not necessarily offering millennials the safety and order they seek; instead, his authoritarianism is driven by different values (economic nationalism, immigration restriction) that don't align with millennial desires for collective security and order within a fair system, which is why few millennials vote for Trump despite his authoritarian appeals.
“most people think that Trump as being authoritarian, and they think of him as being someone who is moving in that direction. That's true to a certain degree, but in terms of a lot of the things that the millennials want in terms of safety, he's not necessarily offering that.”
Smoot-Hawley tariff of the 1930s and Trump tariffs represent similar isolationist protectionist moments, suggesting contemporary trade policy reflects similar mood and crisis conditions as the 1930s.
“We had Smoot Hawley tariff. We have the Trump tariff.”
The GI generation, coming of age in the late 1920s and early 1930s, were similar to millennials in being civic-minded and community-oriented; approximately 85% voted for FDR and the New Deal in 1932 and 1936, marking the first wave of African-Americans voting Democratic instead of for the party of Lincoln.
“We had, by the way, a very similar generation back in the coming of age in the early 1930s, late 1920s. This was the GI generation. An estimated 85% of them voted for FDR in the New Deal. That was a massive tidal wave in 1932 and 1936. This is the first generation of African-Americans to vote for the Democratic Party, no longer for the party of Lincoln.”
The Silent generation (born during Great Depression, children during WWII) was famous for risk-aversion and 'don't upset the permanent record' attitudes, wearing three-piece suits in their twenties and playing by rules; they ultimately did very well economically because the rules rewarded compliance, and this generation today (in late 70s-80s) has defined-benefit pensions and is doing very well.
“the so-called silent generation, where the kids of worldwide joined the Great Depression. They were famous for, I don't want anything to go on my permanent record and they were very cautious. They were very risk averse. They all dressed in three-piece suits in their early 20s, they play by the rules. Ultimately, they did very well economically. They got rewarded by the rules.”
The prevailing neoliberal ideology in developed economies, shaped by Boomers and Gen Xers, is breaking down and losing credibility among younger generations globally.
“the particular social economic ideology, the prevailing ideology, let's call it neoliberalism as an example, which is very much in the Gen X form...It's breaking down. People are not believing in it in the way they used to.”
The new generation of Chicago school economists (post-Bork and post-Director) are reversing the laissez-faire anti-trust stance, with younger economists now favoring stricter anti-trust enforcement, reflecting millennial generation values entering academia and economics.
“If you look at the new generation of economists in Chicago, this is two generations after all of the great Chicago economists who got rid of anti-trust law...Robert Bork and Aaron Director and all the greats who basically just said we just should think about consumer welfare and just get rid of all this anti-trust stuff. If you look at the new generation 10 years to Chicago, they're all in favor of stricter anti-trust.”
The shift in European political messaging from 'A Europe that progresses' (15 years ago) to 'A Europe that protects' (current), reflects a generational shift from Boomer-Gen X values of advancing rights globally to millennial values of community protection and resistance to external change.
“In the last parliamentary election, the big slogan that all the mainstream parties used was 'A Europe that protects.' Europe qui protège, this was the slogan. 15 years ago, it was a Europe that progresses, a Europe that is doing great, that's advancing rights around the world. Now...it's this hunkering down mentality. It's like, we can't control the world and we don't want the world to bother us.”
Anti-trust enforcement is a major emerging issue in the 2020 election, with Bernie Sanders, Elizabeth Warren, and Amy Klobuchar all emphasizing anti-trust, addressing not just pricing power and monopoly power but also price discrimination practices by Big Pharma, colleges, and retailers.
“Anti-trust is a huge issue and both Bernie Sanders, Elizabeth Warren and Amy Klobuchar are both huge in anti-trust. This is probably I realize that lately hasn't got a lot of attention, but this is a big issue in this race now.”
Generational analysis uses a two-dimensional framework where age is on the Y axis and time on the X axis, creating diagonal lines representing individual life paths; generations are groups of parallel diagonal lines, while single events are vertical lines cutting across all cohorts, and historical phases are horizontal lines.
“if you have age on the Y axis and time on an X axis, we all live a diagonal line. A generation is a group of diagonal lines. A single event is a vertical line through all those diagonal lines. It hits people at different age.”
The conventional expectation that big ideas should be developed during times of plenty and implemented during crises is backwards; historically, big ideas are both conceived and implemented during crises, not developed in advance during prosperity.
“I think the idea that we wait for a time of plenty to come up with our big ideas, or implement big, bold new ideas, that's actually not how history works.”
The 1930s era saw populist dictators emerge globally (not just Hitler/Mussolini but Stalin) due to lack of global concert to restrain them, similar to today where NATO is toothless, no concert of nations exists, and no one is signing treaties, creating space for authoritarian leaders.
“That era was an era of populist dictators all around the world. I'm just saying, and it was very similar to the era we're having today. Remember, as they think back on the mood in the late '20s and '30s when you had no concert of nations anymore, that had been wiped out by World War I, and then you had the League of Nations, but it proved to be too foolish, that was Wilson's dream and it never did anything.”
Populism historically always means authoritarianism; the word 'populism' was first used to describe Julius Caesar, who was the authoritarian leader of the popularis faction opposing the optimists (senators), and this pattern has continued throughout history with leaders like Orban, Putin, Modi, Xi Jinping, Duterte appealing to mainstream majority communities while dismissing minorities.
“historically, populism always means authoritarianism. These two things go together ever since--the word populism, by the way, interestingly, was first used to describe Julius Caesar. He was head of the popularis, not the optimists. They were the good people. They were the senators. Julius Caesar was the authoritarian side of the populism. It has been true ever since.”
The emerging Hero archetype of civic generation (millennials) has a strong belief in gravitating toward community, which is manifesting globally in the new populism that combines community orientation with authoritarian leadership seeking to restore order.
“That's what I attribute of what we call this hero archetype of the civic generation. That is the strong belief of wanting to gravitate toward community. We're seeing that all around the world.”
Generational analysis extends demography by examining not just population numbers but how people are shaped by their childhood and coming-of-age experiences, and how those attitudes and behaviors age with cohorts through their entire lives, adding a qualitative dimension to population study.
“it's really not part of their field, but it is something that it's my other field that I've invented, you might say, is to look at populations, not just in terms of numbers and how many are in each age bracket, but also to look at how people are shaped in their attitudes and behaviors by their childhood and coming of age experiences and how those attitudes and behaviors age with those cohorts through life. These are what we call generations.”
Research going back to the 17th century shows that generations had very different collective personalities, with older generations expressing worries and apprehensions about younger generations, indicating that people were aware of generational differences not just as age but as fundamental differences in character.
“even going all the way back to the 17th century, the first old world migrants to the new world, we found that generations had very different collective personalities. The older generation had very different attitudes of how the young generation is growing up, all kinds of worries apprehensions because even back then, they knew generational differences, and they knew that it wasn't just that they were older, younger, they were never like them.”
Generational archetypes recur in the same order historically, such that heroic, history-making generations are typically followed by timid, risk-averse generations born during wars who are cautious about disrupting what was built.
“we found not only are people very aware of generational differences, but types of generations, what we later called archetypes tend to recur in the same order historically.”
Major civic crises that redefine American identity occur approximately once every 80-90 years (roughly one long human lifespan), following a pattern: American Revolution → Civil War → Great Depression/World War II → present day, with cultural awakenings occurring roughly halfway between these crises.
“we have major civic crises that redefine who we are as a nation politically, institutionally in very fundamental ways, about once every long human life, about 80 or 90 years. You look at the worst span of succession, it was probably the first great global war in European history, which happened way back around 1700, there was the Glorious Revolution in England, but it was a huge event in the colonies. Then about a lifetime after that, you had the American Revolution, lifetime after Civil War, lifetime after that, the Great Depression and World War II and a lifetime after that, you're here with us today.”
Single-payer healthcare appeals to millennials because it removes choice complexity (like an Apple phone or Google search—one best option) rather than offering variety; millennials are bothered by paradox of choice more than older generations and interpret multiple options as a failure of institutions to identify the best choice.
“When it comes to security and order you just think, no choices. Single payer healthcare. It's like your Apple phone. There's only one of them. They're not different models. There's just-- it's like a Google page. There's only one, you just go there and get your business done. Millennials are used to that”
Major fiscal and institutional restructuring will not happen during peaceful times but only during crises when people are under duress and forced to consider fundamental change; the Social Security Act of 1935 was one of 35 major pieces of legislation passed during the Great Depression crisis, not on a sunny day.
“Big things are done under duress, and that's when people have-- because when things are pleasant, if it ain't broke, don't fix it. No one wants to change anything.”
Sebastian Kurtz, Austria's 33-year-old Chancellor and first millennial leader of Europe, represents the emerging millennial political style: he uses 'nice' rhetoric, successfully reconciled the Conservative and Green parties despite their opposing ideologies by focusing on shared desire for security and order rather than left-right positioning, reflecting a millennial willingness to transcend traditional political divides.
“Sebastian Kurtz is the first millennial leader of Europe. 33 years old. He's Chancellor of Austria...He is so millennial. He is so nice. This guy is just uses nice in all of his interviews, and Austrians love him.”
Boomers and Gen Xers have no emotional attachment to their parents (boomer 20-year-olds in the 1960s did not call their GI generation parents and avoided living with them during recessions), whereas millennials and boomers have much closer relationships despite generational differences in values, with millennials calling parents daily.
“I think personally, in their personal family lives, I think boomers and millennials get along very well. You're going to see it. They're calling each other every day. You see the closeness is there. Boomers, by the way in their 20s, never called their GI generation parents. It wasn't because we didn't have cell phones either. We didn't want to talk to them.”
Society needs all generational archetypes to function: prophet generations (like Boomers) to reshape culture, and builder/civic generations to implement and maintain institutions; without this diversity of generational roles, society cannot sustain itself.
“you need a generation like a prophet archetype, like boomers to reshape the culture and think deep thoughts to come up with '60s music. Occasionally, you need that kind of generation. Then you also need a generation of builders and doers, you need all types.”
The lost generation, gilded generation, and cavaliers (going back to 17th century) are all examples of the Nomad/bad boy generational archetype that follows Prophet generations; these archetypes are fascinating and come in characteristic orders that are predictable.
“Gen Xers is not the first of this generation. The lost generation had that same, the gilded generation. These are all bad boy generations and not just by their names, lost, gilded, cavaliers is another one going back to the 17th century.”
Millennials' attraction to Bernie Sanders is not because of left-wing cultural ideas (as Boomers mistake) but because Sanders promises a strong middle class where they can belong to a team and not compete constantly, as they observe their Boomer and Gen X parents competing themselves to death.
“That's why they're flocking to Bernie. Not because they're attracted by any bizarre left wing cultural ideas, this is what boomers mistake when they look at the whole fascination with Bernie Sander. No. Bernie's promising them a strong middle land America that they can just belong to a team and not have to compete so much because they look up at their Xer parents and their boomer parents and they just see people are competing themselves to death.”
When one generational archetype passes away, it creates a functional void that another generation must fill, similar to how removing one plant from a glass enclosure causes another to grow into the empty space to reach the sunlight and fulfill the ecological role.
“one interesting rule of generations is that when one generation of one archetype passes away, it almost creates a void that another generation has to fill functionally. I often compare this to like, if you take one of these glass enclosures that you grow plants in and you tear one plant out, and you put a new plant in anywhere in there, it will always grow to the empty space.”
One reason Howe is optimistic about resolving intergenerational fiscal conflicts is that close family relationships between millennials and boomers will allow boomers to voluntarily relinquish third-party transfer payments (Social Security, Medicare) in favor of direct family care when crisis forces difficult resource allocation choices.
“I think one very positive tradeoff will be precisely because millennials and boomers get along so well in their family lives. It will allow, it will allow boomers to relinquish a lot of these third party transfer payments that they want to take. Because a lot of them now have young people around them in some form or another, helping to take care of them.”
Many GI generation members were dedicated to overthrowing capitalism and joined the Communist Party, making them more radical than contemporary millennials supporting Bernie Sanders; those concerned about millennial socialism should contextualize it against the 1930s when actual communist party membership was common.
“A lot of them joined the Communist Party. It's interesting because a lot of them were dedicated. A lot of the best and brightest of this generation were dedicated to the overthrow of capitalism in the United States. Whenever a boomer has problems with the millennials, because I think too many of them are voting for Bernie Sanders, would you prefer a generation like we had in the 1930s, where they actually were card carrying members of a party dedicated to our nation's overthrow?”
Britain's exit from the European Union (Brexit) occurred at a specific historical moment reflecting the timing of the generational transition toward millennial/Fourth Turning values, rather than being driven by purely economic or political factors unique to Brexit.
“It's interesting that Britain left when it did.”