What this covers

George Gammon works through the argument of former New York Fed trading desk head Joseph Wang, and the video is mostly a solo walkthrough of Wang's reasoning with Gammon's commentary. It starts with the pre-crisis mechanics: the Federal Reserve steered the fed funds rate by buying or selling securities to add or drain bank reserves. It then moves to what Ben Bernanke's quantitative easing did to that arrangement, taking the balance sheet from about $800 billion to over $8 trillion. It also covers the March 2020 elimination of reserve requirements for large banks, which turned excess reserves into simply interest on reserves (IOR)).

The middle of the video is about how banks make money. Gammon describes a widening gap between what the Fed pays banks and what they pay depositors, from roughly 20 basis points to as much as 800. He points to the flat deposit rates during the 2019 hikes under Jerome Powell as evidence. He also separates bank purchases of securities from non-banks, which create new money, from trades among banks or with the Treasury, which only shuffle reserves. A reduction in Treasury issuance since the debt ceiling debate is said to push banks toward buying from non-banks. Wang's more fringe claim is that hikes flatten the yield curve. Several of these claims are flagged as contested.

The later sections look at second-order effects. Rate hikes are said to work mainly through the financial channel, so equities and leveraged investors take the strain, and risk parity portfolios may be forced into selling during bond drawdowns. Gammon also cites household checking deposits tripling between 2019 and mid-2021. He then turns to Saule Omarova's proposal that the Fed buy stocks directly, which he treats as an example of central planning producing unintended consequences. The video closes on the contested forecast that the Fed can no longer tighten without systemic collapse. It also includes an aside criticizing Biden administration hiring.

Sharpest takeaway

George Gammon argues that structural changes to the banking system post-GFC have inverted monetary policy transmission, making rate hikes inflationary rather than deflationary by increasing bank profits without raising deposit costs, thereby encouraging credit expansion that floods the real economy with dollars.

  • Banks shifted from rate-sensitive money market funding to rate-insensitive retail deposits, severing the link between Fed rates and bank liability costs
  • Higher interest on reserves (IOR) increases bank profits without forcing them to pay depositors more, creating excess capital for asset purchases and lending
  • When banks buy securities from non-banks or increase lending, they inject new dollars into the economy chasing goods and services, creating inflation despite higher rates

The claims · ranked26 claims · weighted by value

This asset isn't compiled yet

You're seeing its claims, ranked. Compile it to build the argument threads, weight them, and check each claim against your library — the full view.

0.74

The Federal Reserve eliminated reserve requirements for large banks in March 2020, changing interest-on-excess-reserves (IOER) to simply interest-on-reserves (IOR), which technically removed the distinction between excess and required reserves but functionally allowed banks to hold unlimited reserves earning the Fed-set IOR rate.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 4/4· George Gammon

“back in the day it was interest on excess reserve so ioer but as you guys know in march of 2020 they got rid of reserve requirements entirely for these big banks so now it's just ior interest on reserves”

0.73

Joseph Wang, former Federal Reserve trading desk operator at the New York Fed, argues that if the Fed raises interest rates, inflation will soar rather than decrease, reversing the traditional relationship between rates and inflation.

factualhigh valuecontestednovelty 3/4durability 3/4· George Gammon

“what you have been led to believe is that lower interest rates actually increase inflation higher rates decrease the rate of inflation and he is saying that now it could be the exact opposite where if the fed raises interest rates inflation will soar higher”

0.73

When banks buy securities from non-bank entities, it is fundamentally different from when banks buy securities from other banks or directly from the Treasury, because transactions between banks just shuffle reserves while transactions with non-banks create new liabilities that count as money supply.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 2/4durability 4/4· George Gammon

“but if a bank buys treasuries from a non-bank entity in the real economy it's much much different than if a bank buys treasuries from a bank or from janet yellen directly”

0.68

Prior to the Global Financial Crisis, when the Fed wanted to adjust the federal funds rate, it would buy or sell Treasury securities and mortgage-backed securities from banks, creating or removing bank reserves to control the interest rate through supply and demand.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 0/4durability 4/4· George Gammon

“if the fed wanted the fed funds rate at let's say two percent and that's the rate at which banks lend to each other overnight the way they would adjust this up or down is they would either buy or sell treasury's mortgage-backed securities from the banks themselves”

0.68

If inflation spirals out of control and the Fed has no tool to fight it due to the inverted transmission mechanism, the situation would be uniquely dangerous compared to past inflation episodes.

forecasthigh valuecontestednovelty 2/4durability 3/4· George Gammon

“the fed no longer will have a tool to fight higher and higher inflation and this could mean that it spirals out of control”

0.68

Banks have shifted their funding structure away from rate-sensitive money market funding to rate-insensitive retail deposit funding, which is the structural change that dampened the transmission of monetary policy and potentially inverted it.

factualhigh valuecontestednovelty 2/4durability 3/4· George Gammon

“rate hikes now directly increase the asset returns of banks while leaving their funding costs unchanged effectively encouraging credit creation this is because banks have shifted their funding structure away from rate sensitive money market funding to rate insensitive retail deposit funding”

0.68

Ben Bernanke's quantitative easing program fundamentally changed the banking system's structure by massively expanding the Federal Reserve's balance sheet from $800 billion to over $8 trillion, flooding the system with bank reserves.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 0/4durability 4/4· George Gammon

“now they can't pay any attention to what's going on with the fed funds rate because they need to do 120 billion dollars with a qe every single month regardless of what the interest rate is that banks are charging one another so because they're doing so much quantitative easing because they're buying so many treasuries and printing up so many bank reserves their balance sheet has gone from 800 billion all the way up to over 8 trillion”

0.68

The entire Federal Reserve system has become dependent on continuous inflation via increased credit creation and money supply expansion, making it impossible for the Fed to ever truly tighten monetary conditions without causing systemic collapse.

forecasthigh valuecontestednovelty 2/4durability 3/4· George Gammon

“the fed no longer will have a tool to fight higher and higher inflation and this could mean that it spirals out of control”

0.62

Even when Jerome Powell raised interest rates to 2.25-2.5 percent in 2019, the interest rates banks paid to depositors remained essentially flat, demonstrating the structural break in the transmission mechanism Joseph Wang identified.

factualhigh valuecontestednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· George Gammon

“editor go ahead and throw up a chart that i took from joseph wang's blog post and we can see that even a couple years ago when jerome powell was increasing interest rates and he got them all the way up to 2.25 or maybe even 2.5 percent what happened to the amount of interest that banks were paying the depositors it pretty much stayed flat”

0.60

According to Joseph Wang's analysis, rate hikes under the new financial system structure lead to a flatter yield curve (rather than the steeper curve that would occur in a free market) because banks use their expanded profits to buy longer-term Treasury securities, increasing demand at the long end and pushing down long-term yields.

causalhigh valuefringenovelty 2/4durability 3/4· George Gammon

“rate hikes lead to a flatter yield curve lower nominal rates and potentially higher rates of inflation through increased credit creation”

0.60

Joseph Wang ran the trading desk at the New York Federal Reserve, which means he was in charge of quantitative easing operations and understands the plumbing of the banking system deeply.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 0/4durability 4/4· George Gammon

“his name is joseph wang he is someone i've interviewed before on the george gammon channel for the rebel capitalist show and he used to run the trading desk at the new york fed so what this means is he was actually in charge of quantitative easing”

0.60

Household checking deposit accounts in the US ballooned from $1.2 trillion at the end of 2019 to $3.6 trillion by mid-2021 due to stimulus checks and PPP loans, a tripling of money in circulation within six months.

normativehigh valueestablishednovelty 0/4durability 4/4· George Gammon

“the amount of dollars held by households and their checking deposit accounts starts around 400 billion pretty much flatline goes up a little bit after the gfc and kind of bounces back and forth we got up to a point around 1.2 trillion at the end of 2019 but when we had the stemi checks and the ppp loans go out this number goes parabolic look at this the amount of dollars that are in the checking deposits of households in the united states goes from 1.2 trillion up to 3.6 trillion and keep in mind this has happened within the span of about six months”

0.57

Saule Omarova, Biden's nominee to lead the Federal Reserve, proposed that the Fed should be able to directly buy stocks to raise the stock market to whatever level the central planners deemed appropriate.

factualhigh valuecontestednovelty 1/4durability 2/4· George Gammon

“but for the stock investors you have to look at amarova and not only get over the fact that the administration is pushing all these things that just don't matter but you have to look at her ideas she is a proponent of a central bank digital currency something i've talked about on this channel a lot additionally she argues for the fed being able to come in and buy stocks so they could raise the stock market to whatever level the central planners deemed appropriate”

0.52

The Federal Reserve has fundamentally different tools and transmission mechanisms in the post-GFC world than in the pre-GFC world, meaning conventional monetary policy wisdom no longer applies.

causalhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 3/4· George Gammon

“but let's not forget what we learned in step number one prior to the gfc when we had more of a free market let's say in banking if the fed funds rate went up so did the amount the banks would have to pay the depositors another way to think about this is if they're making more interest on the asset side of their balance sheet they would also have to pay out more expenses on the liability side but now we've had that paradigm shift we have a new system the financial plumbing is much different now than it was prior to the gfc”

0.52

Because banks are now drowning in bank reserves and are no longer competing for deposits, they have no incentive to pay depositors market rates, so they pay near-zero interest on checking accounts regardless of what the Fed funds rate or IOR is.

causalhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 3/4· George Gammon

“well now they don't need their deposits because they are flushed they're drowning in bank reserves they've got way too much balance sheet capacity and not enough people to lend to so the reserves are no longer their problem they don't care about those they've got way too many so they just tell the average joe who has become the average pissed off joe and you can understand why because they're saying we're just going to pay you zero percent or maybe a couple basis points”

0.52

The spread between what the Fed pays banks in interest (via IOR) and what banks pay depositors has widened dramatically: where it used to be about 20 basis points, it can now be 800 basis points or more when Fed rates are raised.

normativehigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 3/4· George Gammon

“the spread used to be 20 basis points but now it's eight percent well if the spread on lending is eight percent think about how much more risk the banks would be willing to accept because they're making way more profit on each loan”

0.52

When the Fed pays banks higher IOR (interest on reserves), those additional dollars become new bank reserves denominated in dollars, which banks then have incentive to deploy via asset purchases or lending, expanding the money supply in the real economy.

causalhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 3/4· George Gammon

“if jerome powell in this case is pay or maybe lael brainard coming up next but if we'll say she is paying the banks eight percent instead of two percent that means that there's more reserves going to the banks they're being paid these bank reserves to nominate it in dollars that's how they're getting the additional interest so there's nothing the fed is buying from them they're just basically giving them free money”

0.49

The primary impact of Fed rate hikes is now through the financial channel (affecting asset prices and leverage) rather than through the traditional consumption/investment channel, which means equity markets and leveraged investors bear the brunt of adjustment.

causalhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 2/4· George Gammon

“the primary impact of fed hikes will likely be through the financial channel every hike reduces the market value of fixed income investments with the losses transmitted more broadly through the often leveraged portfolio of the investors”

0.48

Risk parity portfolios, which employ a 60/40 split between bonds and stocks with leverage, become vulnerable to forced selling if bond prices fall when interest rates rise, because managers may face margin calls and will liquidate stocks (the more liquid asset) to cover losses.

causalhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 3/4· George Gammon

“so responsible ray is going to buy a lot of these bonds using leverage because if he can get just a one percent rate if he can use all of this leverage and buy more and more and more bonds with the same amount of cash out of pocket he can actually increase his yield but what happens if lael brainard raises interest rates well if rates go up that means prices of bonds go down so responsible ray could be put into a position where he even gets a margin call on some of these treasuries he owns with leverage and then he has to sell anything that's liquid well he most likely won't sell the bonds so what will he sell the stocks”

0.45

Treasury issuance has been reduced since the debt ceiling debate, so banks with excess capital cannot buy all the Treasuries they want directly from Janet Yellen (the Treasury), forcing them to buy from non-bank entities in the real economy instead.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 2/4· George Gammon

“we just got done with this big debt ceiling debate and although they kind of kicked the can down the road the treasury isn't issuing as many treasuries as they issued in 2020 so there's not as many treasuries being auctioned off by janet yellen so that means a lower supply of these treasuries so if the banks have all this additional purchasing power well they would have to most likely go to non-bank entities in the real economy to buy the treasuries that are on their balance sheet”

0.45

If the Fed were to begin buying stocks directly to manipulate market levels (as Omarova proposes), it would create enormous unintended consequences and malinvestment, leading to misallocation of resources that would lower the standard of living for society over time.

forecasthigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 2/4· George Gammon

“if all the economic distortions that we've gone over in this video are just a result of ben bernanke moving from kind of a market-based system where banks were lending to one another to something called ioer and quantitative easing just think the amount of distortions that would be created by ms omarova and pushing for the fed to come in and actually buy stocks to elevate the stock market to whatever level they the central planners deem appropriate this would not only create an imaginable unintended consequences but it would also create malinvestment a misallocation of resources that over time would lower the standard of living for the entire society”

0.34

Historically, when interest rates rise, corporate P/E ratios decline because the expected future profits of corporations are discounted using a higher discount rate, creating a headwind for stock valuations.

causalestablishednovelty 0/4durability 4/4· George Gammon

“additionally if rates go up historically the p e ratios go down because the expected profits for corporations decrease in the future”

0.29

Prior to the GFC, banks used to make 'big money' by originating loans because they had to compete for deposits and couldn't rely on deposit spreads, forcing them to focus on loan origination for profit.

factualestablishednovelty 0/4durability 3/4· George Gammon

“and that's where they used to make the big money”

0.28

The Biden administration's approach to hiring prioritizes demographic characteristics (sex and skin color) over merit, which is problematic and represents a departure from hiring based on qualifications.

normativecontestednovelty 0/4durability 2/4· George Gammon

“what makes her unique is not only is she the first woman that has been nominated to this position but she's also the first woman of color which is very important to the politicians today because they do not like to hire people based on merit they want to get the right person in the job to pander to their constituents so instead of judging someone based on their abilities oh no no that's old school thinking now we need to judge someone based on their sex and their skin color”

0.22

Saule Omarova is a proponent of central bank digital currency (CBDC) technology.

factualspeaker onlynovelty 0/4durability 2/4· George Gammon

“she is a proponent of a central bank digital currency something i've talked about on this channel a lot”

0.22

The traditional advice that 'if you hire woke people you go broke' now applies at the level of the entire U.S. economy, not just individual businesses, because central planners focused on political priorities rather than merit are making policy decisions that distort resource allocation.

normativecontestednovelty 0/4durability 2/4· George Gammon

“it goes back to that saying if you hire people like this and go woke you will definitely go broke the problem is now we're not referring to a single business or corporation we're referring to the entire us economy”