
The financial crisis no one is fixing | Business Beyond
What this covers
This DW News explainer runs about 21 minutes and follows the retirement funding problem from its origins to the individual saver. It starts with the history: pensions were invented in Germany in 1881 and New Zealand in 1898 as a way to move less productive older workers out of the labor force. Otto von Bismarck's original intent was efficiency, but pensions later became a cornerstone of the 20th-century welfare state and a symbol of solidarity. The video then explains why the pay-as-you-go pension system, the norm across the OECD), is structurally exposed when more people draw benefits for more years. It argues that the policy choices come down to raising revenues or cutting spending, and that most governments have cut. The voices include behavioral researcher Hal Hirshfield and Hiro Oawa, who studies the reemployment of retirees.
The middle of the piece looks at who bears the cost of later retirement. Life expectancy gaps are put at about six years between white-collar and manual workers in the UK and about seven between white and Black men in the US. The wealthiest groups also get roughly eight more years free of disability than the poorest. The video presents age discrimination as a hole in the policy logic: only 1 in 10 people laid off in their early 60s in the US finds equally paying work. A contested point is whether exemptions for disadvantaged groups could work at all, since deciding who qualifies is difficult. France's strikes over raising the retirement age from 62 to 64 illustrate the political backlash. Japan offers a counterpoint, where the retirement age is now 70 and many seniors work on. Oawa frames this as a silver dividend, while the video also notes financial necessity.
The last stretch turns to individual saving. Hirshfield's research says people treat their future selves like strangers. In his 2011 experiment, participants who met aged avatars in virtual reality wanted to save twice as much. The video also considers smaller nudges, such as saving "one more penny" per dollar. It qualifies these with the cost-of-living squeeze, and it closes by calling this the slowest-moving financial crisis, with no government yet a model for others.
The global retirement crisis stems from demographic decline creating unsustainable pay-as-you-go pension systems, forcing governments to choose between raising retirement ages, cutting benefits, or increasing revenues—choices that risk deepening inequality and breaking the social contract.
- The old-age dependency ratio in rich countries is soaring, with the percentage of retirees compared to working-age people rising from 6.66% globally in 2019 to projected 11.66% by 2050
- Governments have largely chosen to defer retirement rather than address the structural problem, but this solution disproportionately harms manual laborers and disadvantaged groups whose life expectancy is 6-8 years shorter than white-collar workers
- Individual savings gaps are massive—the average 65-year-old has saved enough to live until age 70 but is expected to live until 85+, creating trillions in missing retirement savings
This asset isn't compiled yet
You're seeing its claims, ranked. Compile it to build the argument threads, weight them, and check each claim against your library — the full view.
The core difficulty in solving the retirement crisis is that it requires making sacrifices today (higher taxes, lower benefits, longer work) for benefits that won't accrue until much later, creating a temporal mismatch that democracies struggle to accept.
“Part of the difficulty here is that really in a nutshell we have to make sacrifices today for some benefit that won't ACR to us until a much later period of time”
The purpose of pensions has fundamentally shifted from a device for removing unproductive older workers (Bismarck's original intent) to a social invention for dividing adult years between working years and retirement years, becoming a cornerstone of the 20th-century welfare state and symbol of social solidarity.
“if the purpose is to get rid of Deadwood then you say retirement is mandatory...but we pay you a pension for political and ethical grants...The thing about Ray Dalio's approach...Since then two things have happened people are living longer healthy lives...it's no longer a device for weeding out Deadwood it is a social invention for dividing um adult years between working years and retirement years...during the 20th century more and more people began to enjoy life after work in industrialized economies pensions became one of the cornerstones of the welfare state a symbol of solidarity and a pillar of the social contract”
Hal Hirshfield is researching additional behavioral interventions to increase retirement savings beyond avatar technology, such as asking people to save 'one more penny on every dollar earned' rather than asking them to 'save another percent,' which feels more concrete and psychologically manageable and has shown success.
“recently we're exploring uh asking people if they want to save just one more Penny on every dollar they earn that feels easier than asking them to save another percent or another another 2% and it's a little more concrete and we're finding success with that so that's another strategy another sort of tactic that governments or policy organizations could use or Banks uh to try to convince people to do more”
Retirement as a social institution did not exist until the late 19th century; both New Zealand (1898) and Germany (1881) independently invented pension systems to remove older, less-productive workers from the labor force and boost efficiency in competitive economies.
“there was a point when retirement did not exist when you either worked until you died or you worked until you could no longer work...New Zealand 1898 introduced a tax financed flat rate non-contributive pension for everybody aged 65...In Germany otan bismar the conservative Minister President of Prussia...In 1881 bismar argued for a state finan pension in the ra by the end of the decade retirement became a reality for Germans aged 70 and up”
Pay-as-you-go pension systems, the norm in OECD countries with an average retirement age of 64, require today's workers to pay into the system while today's retirees draw from it, creating an inherent structural vulnerability: when more older people draw from the system for more years, a shortfall mushrooms.
“now pay as you go pension systems are the norm in the oecd which is a club of rich countries with an average retirement age of 64 pay as you go means today's workers are paying into the system with a portion of their income at the same time today's retirees are drawing out of it...it also means that when you have more older people who are um drawing from those systems for more years you end up with a shortfall and that shortfall is mushrooming”
Life expectancy gains are not equally distributed across social groups: in the UK, men in white-collar jobs live 6 years longer than those in manual jobs; in the US, white men live approximately 7 years longer than Black men on average, creating disparities in ability to work longer.
“how far to raise the retirement age is a question that's going to play out differently in every country but the question I think that really unifies this debate across different countries with different systems is the question of who's left behind how long we live is linked to Social and economic privilege in the UK for example men in White Collar jobs are expected to live six years longer than those in manual jobs in the US white men live around seven years longer than black men on average”
In the UK and US, health inequality during old age is pronounced: the wealthiest men and women can expect to live an additional 8 years free from disability or illness compared to the poorest groups, meaning it is much easier to contemplate working longer if you have a desk job.
“we got these longer life years but were they good years and was your morbidity your state of health was it increasing at the same rate as your life expectancy was increasing in the UK and the US the wealthiest men and women can expect to live an additional 8 years free from disability or illness compared to the poorest group groups that means it's much easier to contemplate working longer if you have a desk job”
Age discrimination in the job market means older workers who lose their jobs struggle to find equivalent employment: in the US, only 1 in 10 people who lose their job in their early 60s ever again finds a job that pays as well, making the policy assumption that older workers can find work that doesn't erode their cognition and health unrealistic.
“age discrimination means older people struggle on the job market in a US study respondents aged 50 and over overwhelmingly agreed that their age has stood in the way of their career chances or even cost them their job...in the US you are um only one in 10 of people who loses the job in their late of their early 60s ever again has a job that pays as well as the one they lost only one in 10”
Humans have difficulty saving for retirement because our brains perceive our future selves as strangers rather than natural extensions of who we are now; on a neural level, the brain categorizes the future self more like 'other people' than like the current self, creating psychological distance that reduces motivation to save.
“the problem there is that you know as I and other people have found in some ways people don't necessarily think of their distant selves as if they are sort of just natural extensions of who they are now instead hell found that our brains sees our future self kind of like a stranger the brain not only can tell what's me and what's not me but it also says Hey My Future Self that person seems more like other people on some neural level”
Carving out exemptions for disadvantaged groups in retirement age policy creates practical implementation problems rooted in intersectionality: if you define different retirement ages for different groups, determining which group an individual belongs to is difficult—someone else may decide it for you, raising questions about the legitimacy of such categorizations.
“raising the standard retirement ages while carving out exemptions for disadvantaged groups is an option but not without its pitfalls people belong to many different groups in their lives that's the core of the idea of intersectionality is that each of us in our social location we have many different and interlocking social locations if you start to Define different retirement ages for different groups how do I decide which group I belong to does someone else decide that for me or how does that work”
Behind the policy push to raise retirement ages lies an unrealistic, unfounded hope that older workers can find jobs that employers want them for and that such jobs won't erode their cognition and health through stress; age discrimination prevents this hope from being realized.
“but it's not only when we stop working that has many experts worried it's also the nature of our work behind that call to raise a retirement age is an unrealistic unfounded hope that older people can find jobs that their employers want them and that the jobs they get won't erode their cognition their health um due to stress and and do the nature of their jobs age discrimination means older people struggle on the job market”
As a consequence of failed pension policy and age discrimination, governments' choice to raise retirement ages without addressing employment access will likely lead to increased older poverty rates and financial insecurity including debt increases in homes and credit cards, which is already being observed in the United States.
“so we can pretend that we we can lift a mandatory retirement age we can lower Social Security benefits and if people don't work we can say well it's just their own choice and so the other result of this conflict is that we'll have increasing older poverty rates or financial and food insecurity we're already seeing that in the United States we're seeing older people um becoming much more financially Fragile by increasing their debt in their homes and in their credit cards”
Governments have failed to prevent structural holes in pension systems, and as people will likely continue to live longer, individuals must increasingly take personal responsibility for their post-work lives through private savings, creating a problem because most people globally haven't made the financial decisions to support their future selves.
“governments have failed to prevent holes in our pension system at the same time we will likely continue to live even longer that means it will fall on people to take personal responsibility for their post-work lives with their own savings and that can become a problem because around the world we haven't made the types of financial decisions that will help our future selves”
Japan recently increased its retirement age to 70, and despite this, many elderly Japanese continue working; the re-employment rate among seniors has soared with more than three times as many retirees returning to work compared to the 1980s, reflecting both financial necessity and the 'silver dividend' of healthy aging workers contributing to the economy.
“in East Asia where populations are growing faster than anywhere else in the world elderly people already have to work longer in Japan the retirement age was recently increased to 70 and even then many elderly Japanese don't stop working the re-employment rate among seniors is soaring today more than three times as many retirees are returning to work than in the 1980s”
A retirement funding crisis is not inevitable from demographic change alone; it only becomes a crisis if policymakers delay and avoid making necessary fixes to ensure pension system robustness, indicating that the current crisis is partially a failure of policy response rather than pure demographic destiny.
“experts say it didn't have to be this way so population aging is a fact but it doesn't need to be a crisis it becomes a crisis if policy makers don't respond to it in a skillful way if they continue to you know put off and put off and put off the fixes that are needed”
There are only two ways to solve pension shortfalls created by demographic change: increase revenues (higher taxes or contribution rates) or decrease spending (lower monthly pensions or raise retirement ages), or some combination of the two.
“Financial pressure means that there are shortfalls in pension systems and there's basically only two ways to solve them you increase revenues or you decrease spending or some combination of those two one you can pay lower monthly pensions or two you can pay the same monthly pension but started at a later age which is another way of cutting benefits”
Despite behavioral interventions and savings tactics, the current cost of living crisis makes putting money aside impossible for many people, requiring a parallel strategy of meeting immediate needs (like putting on your own oxygen mask first on an airplane) before addressing long-term retirement security.
“doing more can be an insurmountable task despite new savings tactics the current cost of living crisis means putting money aside is Out Of Reach for many on an airplane they always say put on your own mask before you put on the mask of others in the same way take care of yourself right now because if you don't you're not going to be able to amass the resources to help your future self”
The retirement crisis is described as the slowest-moving financial crisis of our time, yet despite its leisurely development, governments have not solved the problem; no government serves as a successful model that others can replicate because the problem is expensive and until governments recognize this expense and are prepared to pay for it, nothing will be done and the situation will worsen.
“at the beginning of this video we describ the retirement crisis as the slowest moving financial crisis of our time what the experts we spoke to revealed is that despite its leisurely development governments have so far not solved the problem we actually have nowhere to look for to say oh they got it right and we can solve that problem because if is full stop an expensive problem and until we recognize that this is an expensive problem and are prepared to pay for it then nothing is going to be done and it's actually going to be worse”
Rather than raising revenues to bolster retirement budgets, many governments are cutting costs, making the primary policy response to raise retirement ages, which means some groups (manual laborers, those with shorter lifespans, those with chronic illnesses) will be left behind.
“instead of raising money to bolster retirement budgets many governments are cutting costs the main answer that policy makers have come up with is that we should work longer that solution means some will be left behind human bodies in terms of what we expect from a rich economies want to be able to retire to control the pace and content of your time and not die in your boots meaning die on the job”
Despite concerns about leaving people behind, there is also optimism about 'untapped work capacities' and a 'silver dividend'—healthy older workers can contribute to the economy for longer, providing a potential positive-sum solution if jobs are available and don't erode health.
“but it's also causing optimism I call it untapped work capacities I call it a silver dividend these healthy so they can contribute to the economy...it makes no sense in that world to say when you reach State and pension age you must retire you must retire completely”
Hiro Oawa, who has researched the economic benefits of retiree reemployment, argues that healthy older workers represent 'silver dividends'—the millions of people entering the labor market can make 'very very enlarged' contributions to the economy depending on the wages they receive.
“now Hiro oawa has been researching the EC ecomic benefits of retiree Reemployment I call it unta work capacities I call it a silver dividend these healthy so they can contribute to the economy several million people will be coming available for the labor market depending on what kind of earnings they they the wages they get the their final contribution to Japan economy is very very enlarged”
Raising the retirement age can be justified as a necessity to bolster pension system balance sheets, with economists arguing it makes no sense to mandate complete retirement at a given age when workers can choose among options: no pension and full-time work, partial pension and part-time work, or full pension and complete retirement.
“those in favor of increasing the retirement age see it as a necessity to bolster balance sheets...it makes no sense in that world to say when you reach State and pension age you must retire you must retire completely what you want to say is you cannot get a pension until you reach some minimum age and beyond that you can draw your you can take your pension and retire or you can defer your pension and work fulltime or you can work parttime”
Hal Hirshfield conducted an experiment in 2011 using 3D age-progressed virtual reality avatars where participants could meet their older selves; participants who experienced this intervention wanted to save twice as much for retirement as the control group, demonstrating that fostering emotional connection to the future self can improve savings behavior.
“in 2011 Hal conducted an experiment where he created a virtual reality in which participants could meet their older selves as avatars even if the avatars didn't look as lifelike in 2011 as they would today it worked participants wanted to save twice as much for retirement as the control group”
Retirement reform is one of the most charged policy debates in industrialized countries because raising retirement ages threatens the social contract; France's recent mass strikes against Macron's plan to raise the retirement age from 62 to 64 demonstrates explosive backlashes hampering reforms despite numerous policy proposals.
“retirement reform is one of the most charged policy debates in industrialized countries the problem is a retirement crisis in that there are politicians and business organizations that want to take away retirement from workers...France has seen another day of mass strikes as public anger at president macron's plans to raise the retirement age show no sign of subsiding...explosive backlashes hampering reforms despite plenty of proposals”
Nearly half of all OECD countries haven't passed legislation to increase the normal retirement age, indicating that political resistance is blocking the primary policy solution that governments and economists have proposed to address the pension crisis.
“despite plenty of proposals nearly half of all oecd countries haven't passed legislation to increase the normal retirement age”
Indigenous Australians die approximately 8 years before the rest of the population, making a standard retirement age of 67 unrealistic for them; indigenous people face chronic illnesses and disabilities that prevent traditional retirement, and a landmark legal case is being pursued to lower the pension age for indigenous Australians.
“Narita waight is running a landmark case against the Australian government her and her client's goal lowering the pension age for indigenous Australians indigenous people die about 8 years before the rest of the population...but something like retirement at 67 um is really unlikely for them um and then of course caus anxiousness cuz they deserve a life of dignity they deserve to retire and enjoy”
Governments are facing a $400 trillion global retirement savings gap in the coming decades, driven by demographic decline as industrialized countries experience soaring old-age dependency ratios (percentage of retirees to working-age people), with the global ratio projected to rise from 6.66% in 2019 to 11.66% by 2050.
“governments are steering towards a huge retirement savings Gap in the coming decades amounting to a total of $400 trillion and the root cause demographic decline...in 2019 6 and 66 people globally were aged 65 and over by 2050 it will be 11 and66”
Across OECD countries, governments are pushing back the point at which elderly people are eligible for full pensions, with many pegging retirement ages to life expectancy; countries like Portugal and Italy plan deferring retirement to the late 60s or early 70s by 2050, reflecting a global policy trend.
“across the oecd governments want to push back the point at which elderly people are eligible for a full pension more and more governments are pegging retirement ages to life expectancy some like Portugal and Italy plan on deferring retirement to the late 60s or even early 70s by 2050”
In most wealthy countries, the average 65-year-old has saved enough to maintain their quality of life only until their early 70s, while most are expected to live until their mid-80s or longer, creating a trillions-of-dollars savings gap between what people have saved and what they will need in retirement.
“in most wealthy countries the average 65-year-old has saved enough to keep up their quality of life until their early 70s but most are expected to live until their mid 80s or longer and that's trillions of dollars in missing savings”
Toyoki Yamada, a 73-year-old Japanese retiree who was formerly a sushi chef, now works as a gardener after learning tree trimming at a silver center (human resource agency), exemplifying the common pattern of retirees in rapidly aging Japan finding employment in low-paying, physically demanding jobs.
“toyoki Yamada is one of the many Japanese elderly returning to work to supplement a meager pension the 73-year-old used to be a sushi chef now he works as a gardener toyoki learned tree trimming at a human resource agency so-called silver centers have become a common site in the rapidly aging country they guide retirees through their Reemployment process in many cases they end up in low paying and physically demanding jobs”
The world's richest countries are facing historic demographic change with competing interpretations: some worry the cornerstone of the modern welfare state (pensions) is at risk of collapse, while others see it as a logical reshaping of working lives, but one certainty is that golden years will likely be less leisurely than expected.
“the world's richest countries are facing historic demographic change now some worry that the Cornerstone of the modern welfare state is at risk others see it as a logical reshaping of our working lives one thing we do know our golden years might be a lot less leisurely than we have come to expect”