
Collateral Shortage Hits Repo Market – What You Need to Know
What this covers
This is a single-narrator analysis from Eurodollar University that reads recent funding-market data as a stress signal. It starts with repo fails, which the New York Fed publishes and which the speaker treats as a timely gauge of trouble in the US dollar repo market. Fails rose from early August 2024, with the 8-week average reaching 253 billion in mid-October, the highest in over a year, even though Treasury bill issuance was heavy. The 4-week bill rate, which the speaker uses as a collateral circulation indicator, also compressed sharply in September. The more unusual step is bringing in the Japanese government bill: the 3-month rate fell from about 15.6 basis points on August 1 to near zero by October 8, persistently below the Bank of Japan's 25 basis point overnight rate.
The middle of the piece explains why Japan belongs in a US collateral story. The speaker traces the excess reserves that Japanese banks put into bills back to the BOJ's QQE bond buying. Then comes the carry-trade argument: when US repo is hard and collateral scarcity bites, carry traders move from repo to FX swaps, posting yen instead of Treasuries. Holding Treasury collateral in advance, as Mizuho is reported to be doing, is a defensive way to avoid that expensive swap route. The speaker presents this as evidence that participants don't trust the soft-landing story.
The historical claims are the most contested part. The speaker says the pairing of rising fails and falling Japanese bill rates recurs across episodes from 2016 through March 2023, including September 2019 and June 2022. The speaker also says the October 15, 2014 Treasury "flash crash," blamed by the Fed and government on computer trading, was really a collateral-driven buying panic. The forecast is that if recession or broader stress arrives, the fragility seen in early August could return in amplified form, with effects beyond US markets.
Rising US dollar repo fails since early August, corroborated by Japanese government bills trading below the Bank of Japan's overnight rate, signal ongoing global collateral scarcity and carry trade unwinding driven by persistent US recession concerns, contradicting mainstream optimism about a soft landing.
- Repo fails rose from ~100B to 250B+ 8-week average since August despite massive Treasury bill issuance, indicating collateral circulation problems
- 3-month Japanese government bills fell from 15.6 basis points in early August to near zero by October, historically validated as a signal of US dollar collateral stress transmitted through FX markets
- Japanese carry traders are repositioning defensively by stocking US Treasury collateral now rather than risk being forced into expensive FX swap markets again, revealing market participants do not believe soft landing narrative
This asset isn't compiled yet
You're seeing its claims, ranked. Compile it to build the argument threads, weight them, and check each claim against your library — the full view.
The Bank of Japan's continuous buying of Japanese government bonds through QQE (Quantitative and Qualitative Easing) created excess bank reserves that Japanese banks deploy into government bills.
“the constant buying of Japanese government bonds by the bank of Japan creating more Bank Reserves that Japanese banks have therefore they use to own uh Japanese bills”
When US dollar repo becomes difficult and collateral scarce, Japanese carry traders switch from sourcing US dollar funding through repo markets to sourcing it through FX swap markets, where they post Japanese Yen as collateral instead of US Treasuries.
“if something happens that makes US dollar funding more difficult where it's more difficult for us to acquire collateral so we own a junkie clo and we can't swap that for US Treasury suddenly we have more difficult funding terms for us we have an option if us repo and collateral becomes difficult becomes scarce to swap into us treasuries because treasuries are not circulating the way they you before we can swap our Yen for scarce us treasuries and we do that by borrowing in the FX markets instead of repo now in FX we're still borrowing US Dollars remember we're the Japanese carry Traders except here when we swap us we swap uh four US Dollars we're swapping Yen as collateral so the US dollar lender is lending US US Dollars and we're providing them Yen on the other side of the swap”
The October 15, 2014 'flash crash' in US Treasuries, attributed by the Fed and government to computer trading, was actually a collateral scarcity-driven buying panic that triggered observable impacts in Japanese government bill rates.
“October 2014 really September into October 2014 when there was a buying panic in us treasuries on the 15th of October which the fed and the government said was computer trading in treasuries what crap that was essentially you had a collateral scarcity leading to a panic buying in us treasuries and you see an impact in Japanese government B”
If widespread recession or financial stress emerges, the fragility revealed in early August (when repo fails spiked and collateral scarcity emerged) could resurface and be amplified, with global consequences beyond just US markets.
“so while everybody says the US recession risk is done it's gone soft Landing forever the marketplace itself this key part of the funding markets does not buy into it and so that is something to watch is both both a warning about the US recession possibilities and therefore the global consequences but also as we saw in early August we got a window into the potential fragility if we have more of a widespread Rec Awakening to what is a more than macro risk this is about money and collateral too”
The mainstream narrative of US economic resilience (strong payroll data, disinflation, soft landing expectations) contradicts the behavior of market participants in collateral and funding markets, who are signaling continued concern about US recession risk.
“as far as most people are concerned early August was a lifetime ago the US economy has since shown itself to be epically resilient a strong payroll number in September plus disinflation that somehow equals Goldilocks yet from carry Traders on out that's not the perception at all”
The pattern of rising US dollar repo fails corresponding with falling Japanese 3-month government bill rates has repeated historically multiple times since 2013, validating the FX/collateral transmission mechanism: March-April 2016, September-October 2016, December 2016, October 2018, September 2019, June 2022, September 2022, and March 2023.
“and this isn't something obviously that just showed up over the last couple months this has happened repeatedly going back to 2013 believe it or not in the immediate aftermath of QE number four in the United States”
The 3-month Japanese government bill rate has fallen from approximately 15.6 basis points on August 1st to near zero by October 8th, trading persistently below the Bank of Japan's overnight rate of 25 basis points, signaling extraordinary demand for that specific instrument unrelated to yield considerations.
“the 3-month Japanese Bill rate was only about 15.6 basis points on August 1st then stayed at that level on August 2nd even though the overnight rate had jumped to 25 basis point so already we seeing the signals that suggests an unusual amount of demand for three-month Japanese bills and by the end of September the three-month Japanese Bill rate was down to three and a half basis points and it kept on going get getting all the way to just about zero around October 8th and since then including last week it's been very close to zero well below the 25 bases points that the Japanese Bank of Japan has set for the overnight rate”
The 4-week US Treasury bill rate is a collateral circulation indicator that, in September 2024, showed sharp compression (plummeted), signaling acute collateral scarcity and shortage at that time.
“that has been corroborated by a number of indications including the behavior especially late August and early in the middle of September of the US treasury bill four-week rate that plummeted suggesting very sharp uh collateral scarcity and shortage at that time”
US dollar repo fails have risen since early August 2024, with the 8-week average reaching 253 billion in mid-October, the highest level since the previous year, despite massive US Treasury bill issuance.
“the latest data we got from the Federal Reserve Bank of New York picking up where we left off on that live stream we got fails going up again what I talked about then was the high amount of fails at the end of the quarter last week in September last full week in September he had almost 400 billion in fails combined which is an enormous amount and then the same amount almost 400 billion almost exactly the same amount the the last week in September getting into the first week in October then fails fell back as we expected the first week first full week in October before jumping back up to nearly 200 billion in the latest data which was the middle of October that brought the 8-week average up to 253 billion which is the highest since last year”
Federal Reserve Bank of New York data on repo fails is a reliable and timely source for monitoring collateral stress in US dollar repo markets.
“the latest data we got from the Federal Reserve Bank of New York”
The early August 2024 stress was significant enough to reset market expectations and trigger Mizuho and other carry traders to defensively reposition, demonstrating how quickly collateral stress can emerge and force behavior changes
“so we've seen a modest rise in US dollar repo files not anything huge but a noticeable change in Trend and it started in the early part of August that's what really catches our attention”
There were four or five quantitative easing programs implemented by the Federal Reserve through 2012.
“yes there were four qes actually probably five but at least four qes up until 2012”
The year 2016 was characterized by multiple funding bottlenecks and funding difficulties affecting global markets, with particular impact on China, Asia, Tokyo, and Japan.
“so 2016 a a year that was plagued by funding difficulties all over the world especially related to China in Asia Tokyo Japan all of that stuff”
Eurodollar University's deep dive analysis provides detailed coverage of collateral mechanics, background, and motivation behind these market signals, going beyond conventional wisdom and challenging widely held misconceptions about money and macro
“when we see these signals and indications it tells us about fragility something that observed in a very short run space back in early August now I mentioned all of this stuff especially repo fails on a live stream and where we left off with was the rising Trend in repo fails”