
Don Boudreaux on Energy Prices 06/16/2008
What this covers
Russ Roberts hosts Don Boudreaux of George Mason University in a conversation about the energy price surge of 2008. The episode centers on a fundamental disagreement about what rising oil and gasoline prices mean. Rather than treating them as harbingers of crisis, Boudreaux and Roberts argue that prices are signals of scarcity that already contain solutions within themselves. They contend that human ingenuity—through innovation in discovery, extraction, and substitution—has historically overcome resource constraints without central planning, and that the real peril lies in the political impulse to "do something" in response to price spikes.
The discussion draws on economic history and theory to build this case. Boudreaux invokes the failed prediction of William Stanley Jevons in 1865 that England would exhaust its coal, illustrating why even brilliant forecasters cannot predict genuine innovation. The speakers explain how rising prices create automatic incentives for substitution and new energy sources, citing the pistachio-room parable and long-term patterns in proved reserves to show that resources behave differently than doom-forecasters assume. They examine specific policy failures—particularly the ethanol mandate, described as a "bootleggers and Baptists" case where environmental concerns provide moral cover for agricultural profits—and argue that political processes are far slower than markets to correct mistakes.
The conversation ranges across psychology, environmental history, and comparisons between private and public sector decision-making. Boudreaux argues that modern prosperity creates a pessimism problem: humans evolved to expect scarcity, and in a wealthy society this psychology, filtered through politics, generates costly interventions. He contrasts this with the historical record, claiming capitalism has made the environment cleaner, not dirtier, and that predictions of resource exhaustion have failed repeatedly over more than a century. Throughout, both speakers contest the notion that current policy responses are necessary or wise.
Boudreaux and Roberts argue that rising oil and gasoline prices are signals of scarcity and prosperity rather than evidence of economic catastrophe, and that human ingenuity—not government intervention—reliably overcomes resource constraints, so the panic-driven impulse to 'do something' through policy is the real danger.
- Resource prices have historically fallen despite fixed physical supply because of innovation in discovery and extraction (proved reserves keep rising)
- Prices both respond to and create incentives for supply/demand changes, so high prices automatically induce substitution and new energy sources without planning
- Political processes translate natural human pessimism into destructive interventions (e.g., the ethanol mandate)
This asset isn't compiled yet
You're seeing its claims, ranked. Compile it to build the argument threads, weight them, and check each claim against your library — the full view.
William Stanley Jevons in 1865 wrongly predicted England's industry would soon halt due to coal exhaustion and that oil could not replace coal; he was a brilliant, non-ideological economist, yet his confident prediction now looks absurd—illustrating that even smart, sincere forecasters fail because genuine creative innovation cannot be predicted.
“Jevons wrote a book that supposedly in Japanese view proved that the growth of England's industry must soon grind to a halt due the exhaustion of England's coal”
The classic economic theory that a fixed-pool resource's price should rise at roughly the rate of interest (an arbitrage condition between extracting-and-investing versus storing in the ground) fails in the real world because it assumes fixed extraction costs; in reality, innovation in extraction and discovery has caused exhaustible resource prices to fall over long stretches.
“in a competitive industry price should rise roughly at the rate of interest because if it is rising at a slower rate than the rate of interest that encourages the owners of the resource to keep it in the ground invest their money instead”
People commonly confuse the two functions of price: price responds to consumer demand and producer supply, but it also creates a feedback incentive that affects demand and supply; failing to keep these straight leads to the false belief that observing higher prices alongside higher consumption violates the law of demand.
“price responds to consumer demand and productive producers supply and it also creates an incentive it has a feedback mechanism to affect demand and supply and people have a lot of trouble keeping that straight”
The pistachio-room parable shows that as a resource gets scarce, rising extraction (time/effort) costs make it economical to switch to alternatives long before the resource is physically exhausted—so we will likely never literally run out of oil but will leave some in the ground as substitutes become cheaper.
“the time cost that would take to sift through would eventually make it profitable for you to buy your pistachios and give up the free resource so that's what's going to happen with oil”
The fact that a larger share of the population dies of cancer today than in the 19th century actually proves rising prosperity, because cancer is primarily an old person's disease and we are living longer—plus cancer survival rates have silently improved markedly since the mid-1980s.
“that fact helped prove my point we're living longer and so as you live longer you have a greater prospect of getting cancer”
Proved/known reserves are like the amount of food in your cupboard—they reflect inventory held at current prices, not the total available; non-OPEC countries produced 460 billion barrels from a 200-billion base over 33 years yet still had 209 billion remaining, demonstrating that reserves are continually replenished by discovery rather than depleted.
“at end of 1970 non-opec countries had about 200 billion remaining improved reserves in the next 33 years these countries... produce 460 billion barrels and now have 209 billion remaining”
The US gasoline market has become increasingly fragmented over recent decades because different states impose different fuel-blend standards, which prevents the capture of economies of scale and prevents supply from flowing between regions to smooth local price spikes, raising costs.
“the market for gasoline has gone in the United States has become very fragmented... different states have different standards for gasoline and how... it can be refined”
Uncontrolled prices reflect an underlying reality (which may itself be distorted by policy like drilling bans); intervening to change the price rather than the underlying reality is like shooting the messenger—it does not change the message scarcity is conveying.
“intervening to change the price is like shooting a messenger it doesn't change the message that the messenger brings”
The ethanol mandate is a classic 'bootleggers and Baptists' story: well-meaning environmentalists (Baptists) provide moral cover while corn farmers (bootleggers) profit; the policy has been a catastrophe, raising food prices worldwide, possibly not even saving energy, while government is far slower than markets to purge such mistakes.
“it's a classic lucien though Baptists and bootleggers story... the bootleggers are the corn farmers I mean they're making out like bandits in this fiasco”
The private sector purges its product mistakes (Edsel, New Coke, Corfam, Olestra) quickly because failed voluntary ventures disappear fast, whereas political mistakes persist far longer due to vested interests and political inertia (e.g., sugar quotas benefit a tiny group at large expense yet endure).
“the emergent decentralized voluntary actions of individuals pursuing their own self-interest make their mistakes often... but they get purged pretty quickly the question is how long's it gonna take the political process to purchase mistake”
There is no scientific basis for claiming current gasoline taxes are too low on externality grounds; an externality from fossil fuels may exist, but since taxes already exist at the pump and along the production chain, careful calculation might show they are too high, too low, or just right—asserting they should be raised is a 'pretense of knowledge.'
“you can't simply say as a lot of people do oh there isn't there's a plausible externality in burning fossil fuels therefore we should raise taxes... maybe maybe not maybe we should lower them”
When the source of higher prices is increased demand (e.g., growing US and Chinese prosperity), we should expect a positive correlation between usage and price; recent slowing of US gasoline demand reflects a slowing economy, while Chinese demand growth is pushing global prices up.
“if the source the higher prices is the increased demand by citizens or users then we'd expect a Korell a positive correlation between usage and price”
If consumers truly did not respond to gasoline price increases (vertical demand curve), profit-maximizing oil companies would simply keep raising prices until people did respond; the fact that competition has historically driven gasoline prices down at the pump proves consumers do notice and respond to price.
“if people didn't respond to price and why wouldn't they just keep raising prices until they hit the point where people did start responding to them”
China's and India's rising oil demand is not a net loss to the US because they must pay for that oil by exporting valuable goods and services into world markets, which makes everyone wealthier; their increased demand stems from their genuine productivity gains following economic reform.
“China and India are producing valuable things for this oil and so we're made wealthier... whatever in increase in the cost that we have... is offset to some extent... by the increased output of goods and services from these countries”
Consumers respond to higher gasoline prices in subtle and varied ways—taking fewer trips, eventually buying more fuel-efficient cars, even moving closer to work—rather than simply ceasing to drive, and the long-run response is always stronger than the short-run response.
“what hope people do is they drive less and they or they can serve on on gasoline in these subtle ways they take fewer trips to the grocery they eventually buy a different car”
Rising real prices for energy, education, housing, and healthcare over the last 25 years are a sign of prosperity rather than harm, because it is our increased ability to afford these things—where supply responds slowly in the short run—that drives their prices up, not a violation of economic theory or an indictment of the economy.
“it's in fact exactly the opposite it's our ability to afford education housing and I would add healthcare that is pushing up the price it's not a violation of economic theory it's not an indictment of our economy and it's a sign of prosperity not the opposite”
Most resources fall in price over time because people have incentives to discover more and become more efficient at extraction, while the one resource that has consistently risen in real value is human labor, reflecting the increased productivity of human labor.
“the one resource that has consistently risen in real value price over time you know most resources consistently fall in price”
Saying oil is 'fixed' begins rather than ends the conversation, because the relevant question is the magnitude relative to use—like a mosquito on a balloon, whether the resource is the size of a marble or twenty Olympic swimming pools determines whether scarcity matters; rising proved reserves suggest oil behaves like a practically unlimited resource.
“from the perspective of the mosquito it's practically unlimited you can treat it as such... we don't know how much oil there is maybe we are the equivalent of the mosquito tapping into huge Olympic sized swimming pool”
Attempting to hurry along the transition to alternative energy through government picking technologies (e.g., ethanol) is more likely to produce costly mistakes than relying on the natural incentive of rising prices, which automatically induces decentralized private substitution.
“we're more likely to make a mistake and pick a technology by trying to override the market pick a technology that's a mistake that's actually more expensive which is what I think what we've done with ethanol”
Capitalism and commerce have made the environment dramatically cleaner, not dirtier: the lethal pollutants of the past (tuberculosis, cholera, malaria, smallpox) have been eliminated or sharply reduced, so we are privileged to worry about today's more speculative, slow-acting pollutants—and life expectancy continues to rise even as people claim society is more dangerous.
“capitalism isn't creating a more polluted environment capitalism is cleaning our environment”
Humans are likely evolved to be natural pessimists, which served a survival purpose under strict resource constraints, but in a modern great society this pessimism gets filtered through a distorting political process that translates it into harmful policies—the genuine danger.
“I'm pretty sure we're evolved to be natural pessimist in this sense and it probably does serve a good survival purpose in the past”
Predictions that oil and other resources would soon run out have been made repeatedly and wrongly for over a century—from John Strong Newberry, to James Akins (1973), to Jimmy Carter/CIA (1979), to recent NYT reports—making the current price spike just the latest iteration of a discredited crying-wolf pattern with no clear reason to think it is different.
“the alarm has been sauna repeatedly in many decades since in 1973 State Department analyst James Aikens then chief US policy maker on oil published quote the oil crisis this time the wolf is here”
A 'perfect political storm'—global warming concern, Middle East instability, and high gasoline prices—is creating intense pressure among educated, thoughtful people that 'something must be done,' but there is no evidence government can intervene wisely, making intervention dangerous.
“there's sort of a perfect political storm which I find very worrisome... there's an immense feeling on the part I think of educated thoughtful people that something has to be done”
The 'peak oil' thesis—that we are on a permanent downward production trend because the remaining amount is somehow less than before—is a non-economic concept, because there is always a limited stock and it is only price that adjusts to keep desire for oil in line with output.
“the peak oil thesis here which is this strange idea that economists don't understand... we're now on the downward trend that somehow the amount that's left is somehow less than then the amount that we used to have before we peaked”
Congress's bill to allow the US government to sue oil-producing countries that restrict supply is inconsistent political theater, since by that standard Congress itself should be sued for prohibiting drilling in ANWR—undermining trust that the same politicians will craft serious, beneficial energy policy.
“a bill that would allow... the US government to sue any country that would restrict the productive restrict the supply of oil... by this standard Congress itself should be sued because it doesn't allow drilling”
The death rate remains roughly one hundred percent for human beings, so the goal is to die of something relatively painless a long time from now—something we have gotten better at as economies develop.
“the death rate still remains about roughly a hundred percent for human being so... what you want to die of is something relatively painless a long time from now”
Nothing in the discussion is a defense of oil companies or a claim that oil is special; if a more effective energy source emerged the speakers would be thrilled to see every oil company go out of business, and oil deserves no protection or coddling.
“nothing we are saying today is the defense of oil companies... if something comes along that's more effective we'd be thrilled to see every roll company go out of business”
Gasoline is priced so inexpensively as a share of people's budgets that they can absorb large percentage increases.
“gasoline is priced so inexpensively it's such as minor part of people's budgets that they can afford to absorb relatively large percentage increases in it”