
David Rosenberg On The Current Economic Illusion And The Stock Market Bubble
What this covers
This is a one-hour conversation between host Julia La Roche and Dave Rosenberg of Rosenberg Research. It works through the gap between the official picture of the US economy and the data underneath it. Rosenberg accepts that the BLS figures show roughly 3% growth, but he treats government spending as the main support. He points to a deficit-to-GDP ratio above 6% for two straight years, set against a post-1960 norm of 3% and rarely above 4%, and to OECD peers running about 3%. Survey data modeled with ISM readings gives him something closer to 1.5%, which he labels a growth recession. He also questions the quality of payroll data, citing a survey response rate near 40%.
The middle of the discussion is about timing. Rosenberg leans on monetary policy transmission lags of 30 to 40 months and on the get-out-of-jail-free card) that borrowers who locked in low rates in 2020–21 received. He expects that protection to end at refinancing, when borrowers face payments 200 to 300 basis points higher. He compares this with 2007, when home equity extraction offset rate hikes until nearly the end. He also covers the 2017 tax cuts sunsetting as fiscal drag, Canada's early-1990s fiscal crisis, and the claim that fiscal policy turns contractionary near 130% debt-to-GDP.
The second half turns to markets. Rosenberg argues that a 22 forward multiple is hard to justify with bond yields above 4%, and that the equity risk premium has shrunk to about 45 basis points against a 300 basis point norm. He says the S&P's 34% gain reflects multiple expansion rather than earnings, and he cites passive flows as a self-reinforcing force. He quotes Irving Fisher's 1929 "permanently higher plateau" remark as a warning. The more contested claims include his dismissal of an AI-driven capital spending cycle and his argument that the 2008 recession caused the financial collapse rather than the reverse. He ends with positioning: long-duration Treasuries, gold, and caution on equities, especially for older investors.
Rosenberg argues that despite 3% official GDP growth, the US economy is in a growth recession because government spending inflates headline numbers while survey data, business conditions, and high-frequency indicators show underlying weakness; a recession has been delayed but not derailed by fiscal policy and locked-in low interest rates, and will likely materialize when debt refinancing pressures hit.
- Survey-based models show ~1.5% growth vs 3% GDP; Fed Beige Book tone matches 2008/2001/1991 recession severity despite reported 3% growth
- Government spending now drives GDP while private sector metrics (auto sales, retail, capex, home sales, industrial production) all run flat-to-negative year-over-year
- Rate hikes take 30-40 months to cause recessions; locked-in low rates delayed impact, but debt refinancing at 200-300bps higher will pressure households and businesses when renewal happens
This asset isn't compiled yet
You're seeing its claims, ranked. Compile it to build the argument threads, weight them, and check each claim against your library — the full view.
Everyone who locked in at low interest rates in 2020-2021 received a 'get out of jail free card' for a period, because when the Fed raised rates 500 basis points, debt service charges were held at bay due to the locked-in rates; however, this protection is temporary and ends when debt is refinanced.
“everybody locked in at those interest rate lows in 2020 2021 so what that means is whether you're a corporate or your consumer uh you did get a get at a jail free card for a period of time because the FED raised rates 500 basis points and people are astounded that it only had didn't even have a fairly perceptible impact on the economy um but that's because debt service charges uh were held at Bay because everybody had locked in but you all locked in forever”
If the equity market corrects from current levels, the negative wealth effect on consumer spending will be significant because household net worth is heavily concentrated in equities; if equities fall 40%+ from bubble peak (as in 1929 and 1999), combined with 10-year Treasury yields declining 300 basis points, savings rates will reverse and spending will collapse.
“if the equity Market ever realize the extent of its current excessive overvaluation or to correct that overvaluation for whatever reason we would have a very big negative equity wealth effect on spending and the savings rate that's only been coming down”
The Trump tax cuts of 2017, beyond the corporate income tax rate cut, will sunset by the end of next year, representing fiscal drag on the economy that may help restore budgetary sanity but will negatively impact GDP.
“a lot of the Trump tax cuts um you know not the corporate income tax rate but a lot of the other measures that he brought in in 2017 they sunset uh by the end of next year uh and that's going to represent fiscal drag on the economy”
In a declining interest rate environment (which Rosenberg forecasts), the yield curve will normalize and bond yields will decline; however, only the long end of the curve provides duration (price sensitivity to rate changes), while the short end provides no duration, so bonds should be positioned in the long end.
“the yel Curve will normalize Bond deals will come down Bond deals will come down the to the front end but there's no duration there so there's no price sensitivity the long end provides that for you so I'm advocating long-term bonds because every basis point decline is going to give you greater price appreciation”
A 22 multiple forward P/E makes sense only when bond yields are 1-2%, but with bond yields currently above 4%, a 22 multiple does not make sense; the long-run norm for equity risk premium is 300 basis points, but currently the equity risk premium is only 45 basis points.
“a 22 multiple from an equity risk premium perspective makes perfect sense when bond yields are 1 to 2% which is where they were a few years ago they don't make sense when bond yields are 4% plus the equity risk premium is a razor within 45 basis points whereas the long run Norm going back to Bob Federal's rule number one is closer to 300 basis points”
Despite AI hype, there has been no meaningful capital spending cycle in the US economy, and with housing in disarray, commercial real estate struggling, Germany heading into recession, and China in deep economic distress, exports will not provide a growth engine for the US.
“despite all the AI hype uh there's been no Capital spending cycle in the US economy there's really not been a capital spending cycle it it it it it boggles the mind uh the housing market is in varying levels of disarray we know what's happening with commercial real estate uh where exports going to go uh with Germany heading back into recession and dragging the rest of Europe along with it”
Passive index investing now represents 60% of equity market inflows (vs John Bogle's prediction of never exceeding 20%), and passive investing surpasses active investing; this creates a self-reinforcing mechanism where inflows must be allocated broadly, pushing prices higher regardless of fundamentals.
“the bubble in passive index Equity investing you know back in the mid to late 70s when John Bogle at Vanguard first unveiled this to the world index lowcost index investing he fam famously said that we would never see this Market get bigger than 20% of the overall market capitalization we're approaching 60% index investing passive not active passive investing in the equity market now surpasses active”
Fiscal policy becomes contractionary over time when the debt-to-GDP ratio reaches approximately 130%, creating negative multipliers and crowding out effects, but in the near term government spending provides a 'sugar high' that masks underlying weakness.
“when you're talking about the debt to GDP ratio heading towards 130% uh you end up getting contractionary effects on the economy from the government Lar yes in real time though because of course we're just focused on the here and now it gives you a sugar high uh and then the sugar high Fades”
The consumer has been sustained by stimulus checks (now in the rearview mirror) and is accessing shadow lending markets like private debt and credit cards, but the savings rate continues to decline and is facing headwinds from rising delinquency rates as credit card rates hit 13-year highs.
“the consumer has hung in and the consumer has continued to feed off uh you know those stimulus checks which have now are now in the rearview mirror uh and the savings rate is still coming down people are still accessing other forms of credit whether it's in the shadow lending market like uh private debt or credit cards although that is started to come under some downward pressure with the liquen rates at 13-year highs”
Canada's early 1990s fiscal crisis, where the currency went into a tailspin and the Canadian bond market became so dysfunctional that Canada almost had a failed auction, provides a template for understanding how fiscal crises manifest and eventually force austerity.
“Canada in the early 1990s is a pretty effective template as to what to look for when a fiscal crisis is coming down the pike and I think that you look at what's happening with your currency and what's happening with your Government Bond Market and in Canada the currency went into a tail spin and the Canadian bond market became so unmowed and unhinge that Canada almost had this is a G7 Advanced country almost had a failed auction uh back in uh 1994”
In 2007, the Fed raised the funds rate from 1% to 5.25%, an aggressive tightening cycle, yet till the very end the housing market was sustained by the household sector's ability and willingness to extract equity through cash-out refinancings and mortgage equity withdrawal (MEW), which offset the rate hikes.
“the FED took the funds rate from 04 to 06 from 1% to 5 and a quarter it was almost as pernicious a tiing cycle as this one and right Till The Bitter End what was the offset was the ongoing ability and willingness of the household sector to extract Equity out of their homes right till the very end Cash Out refinancings mortgage Equity withdrawal what we used to call Mew”
The Fed funds rate is currently 5%, but the average over the past 5 years is closer to 2%, a 300 basis point gap that represents how elevated current rates are; when debt rolls over at renewal, a similar 200-300 basis point gap exists between current rates households and businesses are paying and where they would pay if they refinance.
“we have a a funds rate at 5% but the average of the past 5 years is closer to 2% that's a 300 basis point gap between the current fed funds rate and where the normalized level was over the course of the past five years before covid during covid postco and if you look at the wide gamut of interest rates that households and businesses are paying uh that is basically uh where those interest rates are uh is about again a 200 300 basis point gap”
The response rate to payroll surveys has declined to almost 40%, resulting in very high sampling error terms in employment data; with such high error terms, employment reports should not be traded on, as revisions 3 months later will prove initial readings wrong.
“the response rate for the payroll survey is down to almost 40% uh so that's what we're dealing with the the the the error term the sampling error term has rarely if ever been as high as it is today uh so that's why we're getting a lot of these revisions because with the revisions comes you know the new information that the BLS didn't have at the time that they issued uh the initial report very wide error term uh around these numbers”
When survey data on consumer confidence and business sentiment is modeled alongside ISM data, it produces growth estimates of closer to 1.5%, which represents a growth recession rather than outright economic contraction.
“when we run this model that's premised on all the various surveys you know the isms and consumer confidence polls and we formulated into a model it's spitting out growth in the economy of closer to one and a half%”
Treasury bonds offer three key advantages: a yield cushion (4% currently), certainty of return at maturity with no credit risk (even with 130% debt-to-GDP, US cannot default without triggering pension fund/insurance company revolts), and potential for significant total return (15-20% over next year) if yields fall as expected.
“you can buy the bonds right now and at least get a yield which you couldn't three four years ago um so you you'll say you'll pick up your 4% um but the longer the duration of the bond is the greater the price appreciation is going to be on those bonds”
Irving Fisher famously said in 1929 that 'the stock market has achieved a new and permanently higher plateau,' and Rosenberg sees the same mentality today, which he views as a warning sign of irrational exuberance.
“In 1929 Irving Fischer famously said uh that uh the stock market has achieved a new and permanently higher plateau and that's the really the mentality the mentality that you have on your hands today”
Government spending is the primary component keeping GDP afloat; the deficit-to-GDP ratio has exceeded 6% for each of the past two years, compared to the historical post-1960 norm where government fought recessions by raising the deficit-to-GDP ratio to 3% rarely above 4%.
“for the second year in a row the deficit the GDP ratio is exceeding 6% you know you go back to 1960 and the federal government typically fought recessions by taking the deficit GDP ratio to 3% rarely above 4%”
The lags between when the Fed first starts raising rates and when the NBER-defined recession occurs have historically been 30 to 40 months, and we are currently approaching that timeframe (the Fed began tightening in March 2022, so 30-40 months would extend into 2024-2025).
“there's been periods in the past where those lags between when the FED first starts raising rates to the eventual NBR Define recession is 30 to 40 months and we're heading into that zone right now”
The equity market and the economy have a symbiotic relationship where they drive each other; rising equity wealth increases consumer confidence and spending through wealth effects, and strong consumer spending supports equity valuations.
“the symbiotic relationship between the equity market and the economy yes and of course you look at the equity market and you say well the equity Market's telling you that the economy is booming uh and if you look at the equity Market you'd see well the surge in equity wealth for a certain Strat of the population people are seeing their 401ks grow like Jack on the beant stock so if you're saying well my portfolio is expanding and I have a lot more confidence in my retirement savings I can spend more of my current income and that's also what's been happening for the economy is the decline in the savings rate in support of consumer spending and the question is and it's a symbiotic relationship between the equity market and the economy they both Drive each other”
The BLS data reveals a US economy expanding at a 3% annual rate, which is an uncontroverted fact, but this figure masks massive divergences among other economic indicators that tell a different story.
“there's absolutely no denying the fact that the BLS data uh which produces the GDP statistics uh are revealing a US economy that's expanding at a 3% annual rate uh that is a uncontr uncontroverted fact”
Corporate earnings growth is slowing: third quarter earnings are tracking 5-6% year-over-year growth, but the S&P 500 is up 34% in the past year, representing a 7x multiple on earnings growth—indicating the market move is driven by multiple expansion rather than earnings growth.
“earnings growth is actually slowing now the pundits on Bubble Vision will say well we're at an earnings driven rally and corporate earnings are still Rising yes indeed corporate earnings third quarter tracking 5 to 6% year-over-year growth the S&P 500 is up 34% it's like call it 7x”
The OECD countries excluding the US are running a deficit-to-GDP ratio of 3%, which is less than half the US level, meaning the US is out of line with other advanced economies on fiscal policy.
“the rest of the oecd is running a deficit GDP ratio of 3% less than half of what it is in the United States”
China is unveiling liquidity measures in response to deep economic morass and structural slowdown, but these measures address liquidity rather than fundamental factors undermining its growth potential.
“if China wasn't in a deep economic morass and the structural slowdown that you know Beijing wouldn't have been unveiling these flurry of measures me in the past couple of weeks but again those are measures more addressing liquidity than really the fundamental factors that are undermining its growth potential”
The financial collapse in 2008 did not cause the recession; rather, the recession caused the financial collapse by drying up cash flows needed to service debt.
“it was not the financial collapse that caused the recession the financial collapse really began with beer Sterns in March of '08 and then culminated with what happened on the summer of '08 September of 08 with Leman and AIG and Merill the collapses didn't cause the recession the recession called those caused those financial collapses by virtue of the fact what do recessions ultimately do they dry up cash flows needed to service the debts”
Bonds serve as portfolio ballast and will provide total return through price appreciation when Treasury yields decline 300 basis points from bubble peak, as is typical in major equity bubbles; the longer duration of the bond, the greater the price appreciation when yields fall.
“I want to have bonds as that balance in the portfolio not just basically that you'll get a huge total return as the price of these bonds accelerate but I also want that diversification uh away from the prospect that the PE multiple at some point pulls that Bob f rule number one mean reverse”
Gold bullion is held with the thesis that tailwinds will be instability, lower rates, and a weaker US dollar, all of which support gold; Rosenberg will maintain his long gold position until the tailwinds turn to headwinds.
“yes gold bullion 100% And The Tailwinds behind that I think the Tailwinds will be instability and will be lower rates and a weaker US dollar and that's all you need to know Bob's your uncle and you have to maintain your long position in gold and gold is inherently difficult un impossible to Value it doesn't generate a cash flow stream but it's really when the Tailwinds start to turn the headwinds that I'll start to pull my on that call”
Bob Farrell's 'rule number one' states that mean reversion of valuation multiples is a fundamental market principle; when multiples are at extremes (22 P/E), they will eventually revert to historical norms (16-18 P/E), with significant downside if this occurs without earnings growth.
“Bob frell who is my mentor at maril Lynch famously said the market makes the news the news does not make the markets”
The consensus did not call for recession until the summer of 2008, between the time Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac went into conservatorship and Lehman Brothers collapsed, and even then the NBER retroactively dated the recession to December 2007.
“the consensus did not start to call for recession until the summer of 2008 in between the time period that fany and Freddy went into conservatorship and the time that Leman collapsed and then people were surprised December of 08 that the NBR had the tarity to date the recession December of 2007”
Every recession in the post-WWII period was preceded by a Fed tightening cycle that not only raised interest rates but inverted the yield curve, establishing a consistent pattern across business cycles.
“every recession every recession in the pool World War II period was paged by a Fed Tiding cycle that not only raised interest rates but inverted the yield curve”
Rosenberg is concerned about bubble dynamics and references Benjamin Graham's 'Security Analysis' and Charles Mackay's 'Extraordinary Popular Delusions and the Madness of Crowds' as evidence that historical patterns of bubbles and manias repeat, suggesting current market behavior follows similar patterns.
“maybe I've read Benjamin Graham Masterpiece security analysis and maybe I've read Char McKay's uh popular extraordinary extraordinary popular delusions at The Madness of crowds maybe I've read those books far too many times however they keep me grounded especially today when I go to the circus and the stock markets become a circus”
The business cycle has not been repealed; the economy remains fundamentally interest-rate and credit-driven, and Rosenberg maintains conviction in his recession call because he believes the full lags from Fed tightening have not yet played out.
“the business cycle has been repealed you might as well tell me you know that the Earth is flat and the sun is not going to shine in the in the morning uh the business cycle not been repealed this is still an inherently interest great and credit driven economy and we just haven't seen the full lags play out yet but I I believe strongly that we will”
Government spending has grown 10% year-over-year this year, and both major political candidates for the November 5th election are campaigning on increased fiscal goodies including child care tax credits, low and middle-income household tax credits, business subsidies, and first-time homebuyer down payment assistance.
“government spending would be up 10% this year I was not anticipating we're going to have another year of 6% plus deficit GDP ratio”
The Fed's Beige Book, released every six weeks since 1970, showed heading into September that three-quarters of the country were in stagnation or contraction mode, with AI analysis of its tone and commentary matching the severity seen heading into the 2008, 2001, and 1990-91 recessions.
“heading into September even in the context of the BLS reporting 3% real GDP growth the bebook meanwhile was telling us that three three quarters of the country were either in stagnation or contraction mode and we run this AI model uh on the tone and the commentary out of the FED beige book and it was just as weak as it was heading into the 2008 recession the 2001 recession and the 1990 91 recession”
On a diffusion basis (measuring breadth of economic strength across sectors and regions), the US economy is deteriorating at a fairly rapid rate, with manufacturing flat, no capex cycle, and the housing market completely sclerotic due to existing homeowners locked in at generational low rates.
“on a diffusion basis the US economy is actually deteriorating at a fairly rapid rate uh I'm not talking about the average I'm not talking about the Agate 28 trillion sum again which is dominated by the consumer I'm just talking about if you took a look at the US economy on a diffusion basis um you know you you're seeing more Decay than meets the eye uh manufacturing is flat as a pancake no catback cycle the housing market can't get out of its own way and and part of that is because existing homeowners have become prolonged prisoners in their own units you know having locked in at those generational low rates a couple of years ago they can't move so the housing market is completely sclerotic”
The index of aggregate hours worked (total labor input combining hours and bodies) has been completely flat over the past 6 months through September, and actually declined 0.1% month-over-month on the most recent report, contradicting the bullish employment narrative.
“the most important metric coming out of the data is What's called the index of aggregate hours worked which is not just bodies but ours like if I hired you and I said I'm going to hire you not to do anything this month where's the economy going oh I hired you that's nice and you're idle um in actuality what happened was that the decline in hours worked was so significant that it offset the headline increase in the body count so the index of AR erors worked actually declined .1% month over month actually the index of AG erors worked which is important because it it it is total labor input into the real economy has been flat completely flat over the 6 months to September”
What extended the lags in the current cycle beyond normal were government fiscal policy spending, excess savings from stimulus checks continuing to be spent, and people being locked into low mortgage rates, all of which created offsets to monetary policy tightening.
“what caused the lags to be longer this time around was we said government fiscal policy the spending the excess savings being spent from the stimulus checks that was a Energizer bunny gift that kept on giving uh and of course the fact people had locked in so that clogged up the policy lags”
The average work week has declined to 34.2 hours, which is the same level that preceded each of the past three recessions, providing a leading indicator of recession risk.
“the work week which has been cut to 34.2 hours which by the way which by the way is the same level that bred each of the past three recessions”
If interest rates don't come down at the time of debt renewal, there will be a huge crunch to debt service costs that has not yet been seen, making it necessary for the Fed to cut rates substantially despite their focus on GDP and employment data.
“if if interest rates don't come down at the time of renewal rolling over that debt there's going to be a huge crunch to Debt Service cost that we haven't seen yet the operative word being yet that still steers Us in the face but it also tells me that to avert that Calamity the FED is still going to have to cut rate substantially”
The biggest price bubble in the stock market since 1929 and 1999 is occurring now, based on multiple valuation metrics (P/E, Price-to-Book, Price-to-Sales, Schiller PE all at or near all-time highs).
“the stock market in aggregate is the most overvalued top 10% overvalued of all time based on Price to Book price to earnings price to sales the Schiller PE take your pick”
Year-over-year trends in high-frequency data including auto sales, retail sales volumes, home sales, industrial production, real inflation-adjusted core capex orders and shipments are all running flat to negative, contradicting the 3% real GDP figure.
“the year- year Trend in the wide gamut of high frequency data uh that we get every month and look at the ear- year trend for example in Auto Sales and retail sales volumes and home sales and industrial production and real inflation adjusted core capex orders and shipments and they're all running flat to negative on a year-over-year basis”
The September employment report showed net 254,000 new jobs but businesses simultaneously cut the average work week by 0.3%, which is internally inconsistent and raises questions about the data's reliability.
“if you believe in the veracity of the September pay report you have to ask yourself the question how could we have hired net 254,000 people in that survey and yet businesses cut the work week by .3% so let me get this straight I'm going to hire you and I'm going to cut everybody's hours how how does that work how is that even rational”
The forward P/E multiple has expanded 4 points in 12 months, from 18 to 22, which Rosenberg characterizes as 'beyond weird' and a two standard deviation event that represents excessive multiple expansion.
“the Ford PE multiple has gone up four points in 12 months from 18 to 22 so this is not an earnings driven stock market any longer if it was the p500 would be at 4600 not 5,800 and change”
The consensus target for the S&P 500 at end of 2024 was 4,850 at the start of the year; the index has since risen over 1,000 points above that, and consensus has adjusted targets to 5,600 heading toward 6,000, representing analysts chasing performance rather than adjusting assumptions.
“at the end of last year the consensus for the S&P 500 for the end of this year was 4850 Julie we're we're a th000 points above that and of course like consensus playing catchup and marking the market here projections is now at 5600 on its way toward 6,000”
If equities correct, people over 65 who have retired expecting equity growth will be forced to look for jobs as cashiers at Walmart, creating broad social and economic dislocations that policymakers are not prepared for.
“you're going to find a lot of those people over the age of 65 that have retired are going to be applying for jobs as a cashier at Walmart there's going to be all sorts of Social and economic dislocations”
Rosenberg forecasts 15-20% total return potential from long-term bonds over the next year, with approximately 85% coming from capital appreciation and only 15% from yield, because yields are expected to fall significantly.
“it won't be difficult in my forecast to get a 15 to 20% Total return at the longer end of the curve over the course of the over the next year”
When equity market corrections occur (which is a matter of when, not if), the impact of negative wealth effects on spending combined with reversed savings rates will surprise many people because the economy and stock market are more inextricably linked today than ever before.
“when you're asking me well you know waiting waiting for godo and you know godo never shows up right however recessions do show up and I am very concerned that this is not I'm not I'm not talking about the fact that these are great companies especially in technology the stock market in aggregate is the most overvalued”
The early warning signs of a US fiscal crisis would be a destabilizing decline in the US dollar and sustained failures in Treasury auctions, similar to what happened in Canada in 1994.
“we'll know that we we'll know we'll know when the if the US dollar goes into a destabilizing decline and we start seeing the treasury auctions tail on a on a sustained basis um and that'll be the that'll be the uh the early sign poost”
Growth recession is characterized by 1.5% growth in the totality of economic data, as opposed to headline GDP; this was called a growth recession in the 1980s when Rosenberg started in the business, and people would ask when the real recession would start at such growth rates.
“1 and a half% we called that a growth recession and in fact when we got to 1 and a half% in the past I would get peppered with questions to so when's the real recession going to start”
The pain that Fed Chair Jay Powell warned about when rate hikes began in March 2022 has not materialized because people locked in low rates, but the pain is still ahead when those locked-in rates expire through refinancing.
“there's no denying where these households and businesses took on this debt and the interest rate they're carrying is two to 300 basis points below the current spot rate no matter what you're looking at corporate or household so that is still a big question mark over the economic Outlook that's still out there uh because there will be the the pain you see the pain that J Powell talked about when he first started raising rates in March 2022 all of a sudden no pain will then the analysis shows how many people actually locked in uh but they're not locked in forever so there's going to be um there there's going to be a payback at some point”
Over 70% of household sector asset mix in the United States is in equities, an unprecedented concentration that exceeded even the 1999 dot-com bubble peak (which was 68%), and diversification has become a 'dirty word' in financial sector vernacular.
“we have a situation where over 70% of the household sector asset mix in the United States is inequities 70 unpreceded at it that all other Market environments lead wow it takes it takes out 1999 wow attack bubble only eight% believe it or not”
The November 5th election outcome matters significantly: if there is split government, fiscal stimulus measures will not make their way through the system and the fiscal spigots will not be turned on as much; if one party has power, fiscal stimulus will continue until a financial accident occurs in the bond market or currency market.
“this is going to be like Halloween on steroids but the treat will turn to a trick if there's not one party power because all this stimulus is not going to make its way through the system if we have split government which I think should be a base case scenario okay if it isn't if it isn't then the fiscal spigots will just be wide open and will stay wide open until there's some sort of financial accident like most likely in the bomb Market or the currency”
In September 2024, the US economy added 785,000 government workers in a single month, which is seasonally adjusted and represents only the second-largest monthly bulge in government payrolls on record since 1948, the first being in June 2020 during the economic reopening.
“785,000 government jobs were created in the month of September which is insane uh only one other month and this is seasonally justed dat”
The US is running a propagate fiscal policy (imbalance) at a time when the unemployment rate is 4%, suggesting a 10-year bond yield of 8% would be justified if the economy were truly in equilibrium, rather than the current 4%.
“no country in the world running a propagate fiscal policy like the United States is you would think that the clment rate was at 8% looking at the fiscal laress not 4%”
For aging Baby Boomers (over 65), 60% of asset mix is equities when it should be between 30-40%, and nobody has rebalanced their portfolios despite a doubling of the stock market over the past 5 years and a 34% gain in the past year.
“60% of their asset mix is equities Julie it should be between 30 and 40% nobody has rebalanced the portfolio they are all in they are all in and everybody's got the new era second or bull market thinking”
The phrase 'delayed is not the same as derailed' captures Rosenberg's view that although recession has been delayed by government spending and locked-in mortgage rates, the underlying pressures that cause recessions remain in place and recession will eventually occur.
“my modotto is delayed is not the same as derailed and it's because as I said before everybody locked in at those interest rate lows in 2020 2021”
Portfolio construction principle: 'bunt for singles, not swing for fences'; play defense with safe positions rather than seek home runs, especially during periods of extreme valuation and recession risk.
“I'd say this is a time of the cycle to be bunting for singles not swigging for the fetes that's what I would suggest to approach your portfolio and your asset mix play it safe”
Rosenberg's current equity allocation is 20% of portfolio (compared to his age cohort's 60% and broader household sector's 70%) and has remained at this level since summer 2007, reflecting his consistent defensive positioning.
“My Equity allocation right now is about 20% in total it's not zero it's certainly not where people people my age are already 60% in equities the total household sector is 70% I'm a 20 I'm basically duly where I was back in the summer of 07”
All asset classes are currently priced for zero recession probability, but the true probability is neither zero nor 100%; however, higher probabilities of recession remain underpriced by markets.
“every asset class is basically priced 0% for a recession and I don't believe in zero and I don't believe in 100 um but we have to play the probabilities”
The Bank of America Global Fund Manager Survey shows tremendous sentiment and positioning at historically elevated levels, combined with concentration of risk on household balance sheets and especially among people over 65, which creates significant downside risk.
“take a look at the just released you know uh the global fund man survey that just got released by Bank America the sentiment is incredible but I'm not just looking at sentiment I'm looking at positioning and I'm looking at the fact that we have tremendous concentration of risk on household balance sheets and especially in the part of the demography people over the age of 65 uh has me really nervous”
His equity allocation focuses on defensive growth sectors (utilities, health care, consumer staples, telecom, defense aerospace) that have risen 30% in the past year while maintaining low beta, low cyclicality, and visible earnings/dividends, in contrast to cyclical stocks.
“I've been bullish on utilities really bullish on utilities and health care and Consumer Staples uh and Telecom uh and defense Aerospace goal miners those six areas are actually up 30% in the past year they've actually come close to matching the S&P 500 but they have visibility and they're very low beta and they have low cyclicality”
The recession Rosenberg expected in 2024 has likely been delayed to 2025, similar to how he was early calling for recession in 2000 (which came in 2001) and expected it in 2006 (which came by end of 2007), reflecting the natural lags in monetary policy transmission.
“the recession that I thought we were going to get this year probably has been delayed to next year the recession that I thought was going to take place in 06 finally took place by the end of 07”
Recession may actually be beneficial to 'wash out the craziness' from the economy, but this depends on whether split government prevents additional fiscal measures from being implemented.
“Could That recession be maybe this could be a terrible question maybe a good thing to wash out some of the craziness or if there is a one party sweep are we going to set ourselves up for even bigger problems”
Rosenberg produces multiple newsletters through Rosenberg Research, with 'Breakfast with Dave' being the flagship offering; a free trial is available and the firm provides strong client service.
“I produced more than just one newsletter by the way but uh my breakfast with Dave uh is still the equivalent of the Big Mac for our firm”