
A History of Philosophy | 62 Whitehead and Process Theology
What this covers
This is a classroom lecture in a college history-of-philosophy course, the sixty-second session, devoted to Whitehead and the process theology drawn from his work. The speaker is a lecturer who says he has worked on Whitehead for forty years. The transcript's speaker attribution is uncertain, with some passages credited to Charles Hartshorne or a similar process scholar. The lecture first sets out the metaphysical groundwork and then turns to theology. It begins with Event-Based Metaphysics, in which reality is made of events of any scale, from a fiftieth of a second to a class period or a national history, instead of enduring substances. Each event has three elements: data from prior events, eternal possibilities, and a decision that selects among them. The lecturer follows an event from its initiating prehension through its subjective aim to its satisfaction, using a biological analogy of conception, development, and birth.
The range is wider than the opening suggests. The lecture covers Whitehead's debts to Platonism and to the Alexandrian church fathers, among them Justin Martyr and Augustine. It also covers his ethic, in which the good serves beauty and evil is fragmentary or merely trivial. A personal example appears when Whitehead describes his son's death as a flier in World War I as a kind of aesthetic completion. The lecturer also argues that the question "who is the experiencer?" cannot be answered by pointing to a substantial thing, since a person, and God too, is a succession of events.
The contested ground is mostly theological. God is treated as an everlasting event whose three natures mirror the three elements of every event. This God conceives and orders possibilities and feels the world's happenings, but is not an efficient cause and so performs no miracles. The lecture also raises whether God is literally conscious and discusses whether panentheism is implied, noting that John Cobb and Hartshorne developed it more explicitly. The session closes with housekeeping: a preview of Science and the Modern World and a reminder about book reviews.
Whitehead's metaphysics conceives God not as a transcendent creator acting through efficient causation, but as the principle of order and concretion who works through formal and final causation—offering possibilities and luring the world toward harmony through love rather than coercive force.
- God's three natures (primordial, consequent, super-ejected) parallel the three elements of all events (objective data, eternal possibilities, decision), making God exemplary of, not exception to, Whitehead's metaphysical scheme
- God's role is formal cause (conceiving all logical possibilities in order) and final cause (luring through attractive possibilities), but explicitly not efficient cause, precluding miraculous intervention
- This framework recovers medieval teleology and the 'Galilean origin of Christianity' emphasizing tender love operating by quiet persuasion rather than imperial power or moral coercion
This asset isn't compiled yet
You're seeing its claims, ranked. Compile it to build the argument threads, weight them, and check each claim against your library — the full view.
The basic constituents of all reality are not substances with enduring unchanging identity, but rather events that can range from very small durations (one-fiftieth of a second, called actual occasions) to large-scale events like a class period, a college education, or the history of the United States.
“for Whitehead the basic constituents of all reality and not substances with an enduring unchanging identity but rather events events can be very moment hurry like one fiftieth of a second”
God, for Whitehead, is not an exception to metaphysical generalities but rather the supreme example of them—God is an everlasting event (without beginning or end) with three phases: primordial nature, consequent nature, and super-jected nature, which correspond to the three elements found in all events.
“the being we call God is like any other being an event an everlasting event is a an event without beginning and without it an everlasting event”
In Whitehead's metaphysics, God is the formal cause (conceiving all logical possibilities in order) and the final cause (luring events through attractive possibilities), but explicitly not the efficient cause, which means God does not act in the biblical sense of mighty acts, miracles, or intervention in history.
“in contrast to say Thomas Aquinas in Thomas Aquinas God is the efficient cause of creation the formal cause of creation the final cause of creation right there's no material cause because creation is ex nihilo now it seems to me that in Whitehead God is the formal and the final cause but not the efficient cause”
In conscious beings, the initial subjective aim (presented by natural causal process) can become a modified subjective aim, such that the being can resist or redirect what the causal influence upon it naturally suggests, giving beings with consciousness a degree of freedom.
“in the case of beings with consciousness that initial subjective aim can become a modified subjective aim the modified subjective a so that you might resist the effect of something upon you and Hindle they new input in some other way”
Eternal objects (eternal possibilities) are objective logical possibilities in the very nature of things that are not created or invented by any conscious being but rather exist whether or not anyone knows of them, and in conscious experience they are apprehended through conceptual prehension (which is cognitive).
“eternal possibilities are simply abstract logical possibilities which are if you like brought to bear by virtue of the objective data what's going to be the effect of this objective data of this new experience well they could go various ways alternative possibilities”
Every event, regardless of scale, consists of three constituent elements: objective data (the efficient causes from prior events), eternal possibilities (logical possibilities brought to bear by the objective data), and decision (the selectivity that determines which possibilities are actualized).
“all the events some can be described in terms of three constituent elements the three factors and as we indicated last time these three factors are the objective data which really amount to the the causes the efficient causes if you like objective data eternal possibilities and the decision”
God's consequent nature is God's experience of and responsiveness to what is happening in the world—God feels what is going on through physical prehension, meaning God is touched with the feeling of the world's events and is affected by them.
“as nature itself the world in the world's history development takes place natural events God who is all experiencing experience is the world and he can be touched with the feeling of what's going on in the world nothing so God feels what's going on”
Whitehead's theology emphasizes three historical streams of theistic thought: God as imperial ruler (Roman Senate divinized), God as personification of moral energy (Hebrew prophets), and God as ultimate philosophical principle (Aristotle), but Christian theology at its best ('Galilean origin of Christianity') emphasizes tender elements operating by love in the present kingdom rather than ruling power or moral force.
“in the great formative period of theistic philosophy which ended in the rise of Mohammedanism after a continuance coeval with civilization three streams of thought emerge you know it's noticeable how often he talks of three those dialectical triads you see three strings of thought emerge which amid many variations in detail respectively fashion first God in the image of an imperial ruler second God as a personification of moral energy third God in the image of an ultimate philosophical principle”
In the Galilean Christian tradition, the kingdom of God is immediate and present, not future-oriented; it finds its reward in the present immediacy, emphasizing how God attends to every sparrow that falls and numbers the hairs on every head—a God of tender care and attention to the particular and immediate rather than distant power.
“it finds purpose in the present immediacy of a kingdom that's not of this world it doesn't look to the future but find its reward in the immediate present the kingdom of God is a monkey yes Lee every sparrow when it falls is seen the hairs of your head are all numbered”
Whitehead's metaphysical scheme is influenced by three major traditions: Platonic philosophy (eternal forms), middle Platonism, and Alexandrian church fathers (particularly Justin Martyr, Augustine, Anselm, and Thomas Aquinas), who translated Platonic forms into the Logos language of Stoics and applied it to Christian theology.
“the third was these Alexandrian church fathers so in effect what Whitehead is doing is picking up on the Platonic theory of forms as it was translated through the middle Platonism into the Lagos language of the Stoics that the Christian Church adopted and applied to the Creator God and the incarnate got us in houma hid all treasures of wisdom and knowledge yes all Recio knees a terror all forms that's the way they explained his omniscience the third way was in the Alexandrian tradition in Justin Martyr in Agustin in Anselm in Thomas Aquinas the whole medieval tradition”
Physical prehension is not primarily cognitive experience but an affective, causal experience in which an entity accepts (or rejects through negative prehension) the objective data of prior events, making perceptual experience an affective encounter with causes rather than primarily with ideas or mental representations.
“in human consciousness we would say that the objective data are we're aware of them through what he calls physical prehension prehension of course is a lightness term it's the shortened version of apprehension or if you like comprehension but the pre hint something is simply to to accept it to be aware of it for it to affect you”
Whitehead's metaphysics employs teleological explanation throughout—events are fundamentally goal-directed rather than mechanistic—with each event having an intrinsic purpose (subjective aim) that directs it toward completion (satisfaction), making the entire world process teleological rather than deterministic or random.
“notice he's got a teleological explanation of everything a teleological explanation it's not a mechanistic universe it's a teleological one”
The good is instrumental toward beauty (aesthetic satisfaction), making Whitehead's ethic utilitarian in the sense that good is whatever contributes to harmonious beauty, while evil is fragmentary, transitory opposition to that harmony (either through resistance to emerging aim or through sheer triviality and boredom).
“the good is instrumental towards beauty explicitly for white his ethic is a utilitarian ethic good is a means to aesthetic aids and evil is the fragmentary transitory opposition to that harmony either by virtue of resisting the emerging aim with its grain synthesis or by virtue of sheer triviality that gets to be boring”
Satisfaction is the completion of an event, defined as an aesthetic satisfaction (in both the continental sense of sensory satisfaction and the English sense of aesthetic harmony) where all three elements of the event unite to provide a single unified feeling or experience—a harmony of contrasts where opposing elements (actuality and possibility) achieve ordered unity.
“the completion of the event then leads to what he calls satisfaction satisfaction and and again notice that that's a term drawn from conscious perceptual experience it's the paranoid you know what I mean by paradigm you have certain paradigm verbs in foreign language you see if you want to know how to conjugate a verb you go back to the paradigm a Moammar so Martin Thomas amatis amant”
Whitehead demonstrates evolutionary optimism regarding the problem of evil: when his son, a British Royal Flying Corps flier in World War I, was shot down in a dogfight over the trenches in France, Whitehead spoke of his son's life coming to a beautiful completion as it merged into history, suggesting that even tragic deaths can achieve aesthetic completion and meaning through integration into the larger historical whole.
“when white had talked about his son who was a flier with the British in World War 1 what they called the Royal Flying Corps back there what became the Royal Air Force his son was shot down and dogfight over the trenches in France when he talked about that he he talked of his life coming to a beautiful completion as it merged into history”
The question 'who is the experiencer' in a process philosophy cannot be answered by pointing to a substantial thing or entity; rather, a person (and by extension God) is a succession of events with unity and harmony—process philosophy replaces substance ontology with event ontology, so the experiencer is not a thing that thinks and feels but thinking and feeling themselves.
“you may be tempted to ask us a friend of mine does whenever I remember him discussing this sort of thing well who's the experiencer you think what is the experiencer to which whiteheads reply is all right in your case as a perceiver what isn't perceiver what is a person it's in the only thing we can say is a person is a succession of events with the unity and harmony to the whole that memory theory of personal identity because this is a process philosophy not a substance philosophy don't look for a substratum a stuff an entity a thing that thinks and feels no not a thing that thinks and feels but thinking and feeling that's what's real”
God is the principle of concretion (concrescence), the principle of order, and the principle of limitation—God keeps the harmony of the symphony going together, orders the creative process, and provides only limited (not infinite or self-destructive) possibilities available to the world process.
“it's um it's a God who orders God he says is the principle of order or to to use his term God is the principle of concretion now you look at that word concretions and I suppose you think concrete no don't never take his words at face value his technical terms come crashing seems to be his synonym for the word concrescence”
Whitehead uses a biological metaphor to describe events: each event has three phases analogous to conception, embryonic development, and birth—the causal stimulus initiates conception, possibilities merge and are selected during development, and the event achieves maturity when its subjective aim is satisfied, after which it gradually subsides in a process resembling death.
“the notion of a subjective aim is teleological where does that lead well that leads to the completion of the event if they and when the possibility inherent in this new data is achieved then okay that's the completion of the event it's as if there is a genetic process and and try the biological metaphor a genetic process so that you've got conception not in the cognitive sense but in the biological sense okay you've got conception because of the causal stimulus you have conception you have the mental process with the possibilities of merging and being selected during embryonic development if you like until the birth of the new event with the decision and the achievement in maturity his subjective aim and then of course the mature event gradually subside so you can see it like birth maturity death”
Some process theologians attempt to develop panentheism (God transcends while including the world) more explicitly, with Charles Hartshorne being perhaps the best-known process thinker who developed ideas parallel to Whitehead and articulated panentheism, and John Cobb being a prominent contemporary process theologian.
“and there are some process theologians who try to do that some who try to do that and I think I'm right in saying that Charles Hart Shawn is one who is perhaps the the best-known process think he was not himself influenced by Whitehead but developed sort of parallel to him and he taught or at Harvard for a number of years then at Chicago then in his retirement at Texas Hart Shawn did very much the pan in theist”
The lecturer has been working on Whitehead's thought for 40 years and has a book on Whitehead that he plans to complete upon retirement, which he wants to bring to fruition and in which he plans to examine the literature of 20th-century process theologians to see whether any have moved beyond Whitehead in substantive ways.
“it's telling somebody that when I retire that book I have up my sleeve is a white hit book I've been reading Whitehead working on Whitehead on and off for 40 years I'd like to bring it to fruition someone but one of the things I'd want to do is to go through all that literature you're seeing see if there's any of them who really do move beyond white and in that regard they may but certainly in the literature it's not at all evident”
God is consciousness and self-consciousness in Whitehead's system, though with some ambiguity about whether God is literally conscious or whether God might function as a ground of influence without consciousness.
“if yeah and that's a good question does he mean that God is actually a conscious and self conscious Ness I I think so but then but then on the other hand you know you have a shred of doubt could he be using it in terms of a degree of influence coming from something dad you see that he speaks off that way because that's the way he speaks of everything the paradigm being consciousness”
The lecturer plans to do commentary on Whitehead's book 'Science and the Modern World' in the next session and urges students to read it (if not thoroughly enough for review, at least a reading) so they can discuss topics they want to address.
“okay next time what I'd like to do and this is a pattern will follow on these books you're reading what I'd like to do is some commentary on his book science in the modern world so I urge you to give it a reading may not enough of her maybe not enough of a reading to do the review but give it a reading and we'll do some commentary on it and we can discuss things that you want to talk about”
Book reviews are assigned for the end of the semester, and students have now received the instructions for them three times, indicating they have been missed twice already.
“did everybody get a copy of the instructions for the book reviews to the end of the semester this is the third time I've been Hawking these which means that you people have missed two times”