
The Central Bank Digital Currency Paradigm Shift (w/ Ed Harrison and Bill Campbell)
What this covers
This is a conversation between Ed Harrison and Bill Campbell, who runs global bond strategy at DoubleLine, filmed on October 30, 2020. Campbell's starting point is that central banks are late, since most transactions are already digital and private firms like MasterCard and PayPal are creating digital money that is a liability of the company rather than the state. He argues that this pulls authorities into regulation for reasons of financial stability, and that money should be a public good with legal tender, store of value and unit-of-account properties. The talk then follows the consequences for banks, the dollar, and policy.
On the banking side, they discuss what happens if a central bank digital currency) gives individuals direct access to the Fed, which may be safer than commercial deposits. Cross-border payments, asset custody and large M&A settlements could also be commoditized, and Campbell suggests credit card pricing could shift if strong borrowers opt out. On the dollar, the argument is that bilateral settlement between countries would remove the need to hold dollar reserves, undercutting recycling of the US current account deficit and raising the prospect of imported inflation. Harrison presses on what that would force on the US, either higher rates or IMF assistance.
The policy discussion is the most contentious part. Campbell separates deficit spending with a fiscal offset from pure monetization, and sees the line between fiscal and monetary authorities already blurring through QE) and yield curve control. Harrison adds that with yields controlled, currencies become the release valve through competitive debasement. They also take up the privacy trade-offs of targeted CBDC spending, the risk of capital controls in emerging markets, and why institutional strength may become the main measure of country risk. Campbell closes on portfolios: at the lower bound, government bonds stop working as the safe leg of a 60/40 portfolio, and negative rates act as a tax on savers, though he still sees one last move lower in yields.
Central Bank Digital Currencies represent a historic paradigm shift that will reshape the global financial system, reserve currency dynamics, and investment frameworks—requiring portfolio managers to position ahead of structural changes in payment infrastructure, monetary policy transmission, and institutional credibility.
- CBDCs enable central banks to bypass the banking system and inject liquidity directly into individuals' accounts, creating new policy tools but also risks of financial disintermediation and currency instability
- CBDC implementation will allow countries to settle bilateral transactions without the US dollar, potentially eroding dollar hegemony and forcing structural rebalancing of global reserves and payment flows
- The shift from rate-based monetary policy to digital currency-based quasi-fiscal policy creates a critical distinction between deficit spending (fiscal offset) and pure monetization (debasement), with major inflation implications
This asset isn't compiled yet
You're seeing its claims, ranked. Compile it to build the argument threads, weight them, and check each claim against your library — the full view.
The critical distinction between deficit spending (with fiscal offset) and pure monetization (without fiscal offset) determines whether CBDC-enabled policy causes moderate fiscal expansion or runaway monetary inflation.
“Then we got to ask ourselves, this is the deficit spending versus debasement discussion, and the question is, what type of authority then is given to central banks when this new plumbing has been put in place? It really matters that if the new policy being put in place is funded by government spending tax increases, and there is the fiscal offset to it, then it is a new fiscal policy tool. The real concern and the real risk is that we will see a situation whereby debasement happens, and central banks will merely print the money to go directly into individuals' bank accounts without the offset on the sovereign government side, from the fiscal authority of the sovereign government. This is a big distinction, subtle, but big, because then that is outright monetization.”
In emerging markets with weak institutional strength, central banks might use digital currency and payment control to prevent capital flight and keep wealth trapped domestically, increasing inequality between the capital-connected and the population.
“My concern is that it gives a much stronger access to the government in all payments and all financial transactions, which then gives them more control and the ability to prevent capital and savings from leaving that country. In one respect, you could see a situation whereby if used incorrectly or if used for purely domestic political gains, there is the risk that it could increase the inequality issue, because capital that is already trapped in a weak system would then get even more so, and you would get into a very much a haves and have nots, so people with the wherewithal, either you already have existing savings outside of the country, or you have through political favor, could get savings out, you would be in a preferable situation compared to that domestic capital.”
If CBDC transaction data is decentralized to private banks, governments need warrants to access transaction records; but if centralized at the central bank, there is massive potential for abuse unless privacy protections are very strong.
“The Central Bank could print a digital currency and then could allow a private bank to use some of its reserve assets by the digital currency, and then that private bank can distribute the digital currency the way it sees fit. All of those transactions then would reside on a server at the private bank, such as Bank of America, and if there is a concern of taxation, money laundering, or whatever else, the government would have to first go to court, get a warrant, and then obtain those assets from a private party being Bank of America in this example. On the flip side, if you really want to be able to target outcomes, what happens if all of that information resides at the Central Bank, on a government server? Now, you really, really need to have confidence that the judiciary is going to protect personal privacy rights, because the potential for abuse is very high.”
To implement targeted CBDC spending outcomes, central banks need visibility into where currency is flowing through the payment infrastructure, which requires residents to give government extensive transparency into their digital transactions.
“In order for central banks to target outcomes, they need visibility into exactly the currency is going in the payment infrastructure. That privacy concern comes as to what type of visibility do we as citizens want to give to the government, as far as all of our digital payments?”
Institutional strength—measured by government unwillingness to monetize deficits, protection of privacy rights, and willingness to maintain open capital accounts—will become the dominant factor for evaluating country risk in a CBDC-enabled world.
“Ultimately, we are going to end up in a situation where you are going to look at countries and start to say, okay, institutional strength becomes a major factor of how we are evaluating the country. What I mean by institutional strength is the government's ability or lack of willingness not to monetize deficits, the government's protection of privacy rights, and also the government's willingness and ability to keep an open capital account to allow money to both come in, but also to leave and maybe go to either another public platform or a private platform.”
If the US dollar declines as a result of CBDC-enabled bilateral settlement, the US will face imported inflation as its current account deficit becomes harder to finance, potentially forcing a choice between raising interest rates (causing economic pain) or seeking IMF assistance.
“At some point, suddenly, the US people who have this massive current account deficit are importing goods that are in currencies that are appreciated against the US dollar, and therefore we are importing a massive amount of inflation into the US system. This is what happened to the Brits in the 1970s. At some point, they were forced to say, wait a minute, okay, either we jack up interest rates in order to get our currency up and stop this inflation from being imported, or we have to figure out some other way to get out of this problem, because it is killing our economy.”
Interest rates are not the true release valve for monetary inflation when central banks control yield curve; instead, currencies become the release valve where countries engage in competitive debasement to steal growth.
“By that, I mean when we are talking about debasement, direct monetization, the interest rate is not necessarily the release valve in the sense that the Central Bank can engage in yield curve control or any ability within its own domain to suppress interest rates, so-called financial repression, but you do have the currency there, the release valve.”
The US current account deficit, which is currently recycled into US asset purchases by foreign savers, will create structural pressure on the dollar downside if that recycling stops with the shift to bilateral CBDC settlement.
“Now, the US dollar, when we look at the US, we want a current account deficit, and right now, we also have the privilege that a lot of central banks and other individuals recycle their savings back into US assets, so they have that global reserve asset. When that disappears, I think that you, all of a sudden get the structural pressure, both from the rebalancing of the reserves from central banks, but also from the yearly flow of the negative US current account starts putting structural pressure to the downside on the dollar.”
The creation of private digital money by companies like MasterCard and PayPal creates financial stability concerns because this money is a liability of the private company, not the government, which will pull financial authorities into regulating digital currencies.
“One of the items that is starting to push central banks into this arena is the creation of digital money by these private actors. Whether it is MasterCard or PayPal, it is actually a liability of that particular company, and is not a liability of the government. Now, you start to creep into financial stability issues, which absolutely is going to pull the financial authorities into this discussion.”
Central Bank Digital Currencies with direct consumer access will create tensions with the banking sector because individuals might prefer to hold their deposits at the Federal Reserve rather than in commercial banks, given the Fed's safety advantage.
“When you think about, what is a banking reserve? It is a preferred asset. It is deemed as one of the safest assets in the banking sector that you can have. A lot of banks want to have it for safety reasons to keep themselves well-capitalized. Well, let us take that now one step further with the introduction of the digital currency to private depositors, you could end up in a situation where financial stability could become at risk as there could be a preference for people to say, hey, I would actually prefer to have all my assets custodied at the Federal Reserve.”
Credit disintermediation could occur if strong borrowers opt out of Visa and MasterCard in favor of debit-like systems, reducing the subsidy that strong borrowers provide to the system and causing interest rates on credit cards to spike for weaker borrowers.
“The use of Visa and MasterCard, and all of just the traditional electronic payment systems that we use, we all use it. You and I, all the way down, like across the borrower spectrum from strong borrowers to weak borrowers, we all use credit cards, and some of us pay it off quicker than others. You could see a situation whereby if you have very strong borrowers that say I really do not want the fees associated with Visa and MasterCard, and my preference would be to pay everything more on a debit card basis, you could have a situation whereby the interest rates that are already high for carrying balances on Visa and MasterCard go way up, because that final element of subsidy of the stronger borrowers in the system disappears.”
Private sector technology innovations like security tokens could help sectors that have not received credit, such as small businesses, access more funding—a potential positive side effect of payment system disruption.
“There is some good aspects of credit creation that are happening as well, like, I have seen the idea that using the private sector technology of security tokens can help sectors that have not received credit, such as small businesses, potentially start to receive more credit, more funding, and I think actually, you have another video that goes deep into detail on that.”
Negative interest rate policy on digital cash is fundamentally a tax on savers, requiring them to find new safe assets and creating demand for a new safe digital asset since traditional government bonds may no longer provide positive yields.
“Your demand deposit now can just start dwindling over time. Any savings you have, you are going to have to invest in something. You are going to have to get it out of the cash-- be out of this digital cash system as quickly as possible.”
Central Bank Digital Currencies will allow countries to bypass the US dollar in their international bilateral transactions by enabling instantaneous government-backed settlement between pairs of countries.
“What I envision is in not the first iteration, but as we start walking through time, we are going to see a system whereby the new electronic payments platform that is going to be implemented across the globe by each country's central bank will all talk to each other. Ultimately, what that is going to do is it is going to allow countries to be able to bypass the US dollar in their international transactions.”
Money should be a public good and a liability of the central bank with the properties of legal tender, store of value, and unit of account—properties that private digital currencies have not yet reliably demonstrated.
“What is money, and really, money should be a public good. It is a public good, and it should be a liability of the central bank. It should be a medium of exchange that is legal tender for each economy...It will be legal tender for each economy, not only the US, but each economy is going to implement their own digital currency. It has the property of a store of value...it needs to be a common unit of account.”
Countries with stronger privacy rights protections and institutional frameworks that protect judicial independence will be preferred for capital investment in a CBDC-enabled world compared to countries without such protections.
“This then becomes a situation whereby country by country, we can start to say does this country actually protect individual privacy rights? Do they have that type of strong institutional strength? Getting back to potential market implications, I would believe that countries with stronger privacy rights and an institutional framework would be preferred for capital in that new environment versus countries that do not.”
Countries accumulate dollars in foreign exchange reserves not because of the dollar's intrinsic value but because trade must be settled in dollars, creating artificial demand that would disappear if bilateral CBDC settlement became possible.
“Countries right now, because they know trade needs to be settled, and all their international transactions need to be settled in dollars, they are hoarding dollars in their FX reserves at the Central Bank, for example. The dollar is the dominant allocation in FX reserves.”
As CBDC-enabled bilateral settlement removes the need for countries to accumulate dollars, central banks will begin diversifying FX reserves away from dollars, creating structural downward pressure on the dollar.
“What I have just described to you is a situation where central banks now will see the payments actually matched the true balance of payments transactions, instead of payments, the transactions being a lot more diverse, but the settlement being in dollars, now, it is all going to be a much more diverse mix. That is going to start to remove the need for banks to accumulate dollars.”
CBDC-enabled bilateral country settlement creates the privilege for countries to print money and settle short-term payment gaps, a power currently monopolized by the US through dollar printing.
“On the flip side too is countries are allowed to settle bilateral transactions just between each other. That gives them the additional privilege that the US only had and does not really use, but you can print money to settle the payment if you are just a little bit short.”
New government payment systems and private structures will commoditize and simplify large bank-facilitated transactions like cross-border M&A settlements, disintermediating banks from a significant revenue source.
“Governments are going to get more involved. What is ultimately going to happen is they are going to increase operational efficiency, both internally and externally. You are going to see a lot of these larger transactions that banks now facilitate become much more commoditized, become much easier to do in either new government payment systems and new private structures, and that is going to disintermediate a revenue source from banks as well, who, especially for large cross border M&A activity for the final payment settlements, I think that there is a big potential for the new architecture that is coming in with these Central Bank Digital Currencies and their companion payment systems to displace banks in that in area of credit creation as well.”
Central Bank Digital Currencies represent a historic sea change and revamping of the global financial system that will have major implications for international investors and portfolio managers.
“This is actually a historic time for global financial markets. I think that the ideas that are being brought forward by central banks right now and the BIS has been putting working groups of central banks together on how the central banks are going to implement the new Central Bank Digital Currencies is going to be a historic sea change. It is going to be a revamping of the global financial system.”
Once the effective lower bound on interest rates is hit, government bonds can no longer appreciate in price due to falling yields, so they lose their traditional role as the safe asset in a 60/40 portfolio.
“Once the effective lower bound is hit, it cannot rally any-- the idea that developed market government bonds and treasuries are the last safe asset on the world is due to the fact that you think that there still is room for capital appreciation or enough money is going to go into the government bond market to cause rates to rally and make that security appreciate in a time of risk-off.”
The hard line between fiscal and monetary authorities has been eroding through QE, yield curve control, and other quasi-fiscal policies, making it increasingly difficult to distinguish where policy ends and political spending begins.
“I think that that is such a slippery slope, and that line, that hard line that has been in between the fiscal versus the central bank, the fiscal versus monetary authorities, it has been eroding over time through the quasi-fiscal help from quantitative easing, yield curve control and all of these policies.”
The US has accumulated a very large negative net international investment position, meaning the majority of global savings is denominated in US dollars both officially (central banks) and privately (investors), which will create massive repatriation pressure if the dollar depreciates.
“The US runs a very large negative net international investment position, and that is just a long winded technical way of saying, the majority of global savings is a large portion of global savings sits in the US dollar, so not just on the official side, but on the private side as well. When you start to see the dollar come off, I could see a lot of that savings come back home and come back out.”
Gold and Bitcoin should be characterized as debasement assets, not volatility hedges, because they sell off during volatility spikes and only appreciate after central banks implement massive stimulus—making them correlated with debasement risk rather than uncorrelated with equities.
“What I would say to you there is my opinion is that gold and Bitcoin are two natural candidates maybe to replace treasuries in that 60/40 portfolio. What I would say to you there is my opinion is that gold and Bitcoin are debasement assets. I say that because when I look at scenarios where volatility spikes and let us put Bitcoin out for a second and just stick with gold. In 2000, when we had the true volatility spike, you had the deflationary scares, whereby breakevens rallied much more than nominals and caused real yields to push up. What happened there? Gold sold off. In March, we saw a similar with flash in the pan of that, that exact same scenario. Vol spiked, and what happened? Gold was actually sold. In a 60/40 portfolio, that safety asset is supposed to offset the fall in the risk-on asset in those spikes of volatility, but what actually ends up happening in the case of gold is gold does not rally until you get the commensurate or the follow-on of the central bank or fiscal authorities then implementing massive stimulus measure. In effect, it is not trading the vol trade. It is trading the debasement trade.”
Central bank digital currencies would allow central banks to provide liquidity and currency not only to the banking system but directly to individuals through their reserve accounts, completing the 'final mile' of monetary transmission.
“That is where the digital currency offers that new potential policy toolkit of being able to go that final mile, allowing central banks to not only provide currency and liquidity to the banking system, which it currently does, but it will now be able, through a Central Bank Digital Currency, to provide that to the individual.”
The British pound's 30-year decline from World War II deficit spending to the 1976 IMF crisis provides a historical template for what might happen to the US dollar as CBDC-enabled reserve diversification accumulates.
“The British pound was in decline for quite some time before it came to that point. It was really a 30-year march from the massive amount of deficit spending that they did in World War II to the period where they had the IMF problem in 1976.”
With quantitative easing, central banks credit bank reserve accounts and leave it up to banks to allocate reserves to the real economy; however, credit creation has not happened, velocity of money has fallen, and the liquidity remains stuck in the banking system rather than reaching end consumers.
“With the quantitative easing that is happening, basically, what you see is central banks are purchasing assets from the private banking system, but then they credit their reserve account, and it is up to the banks to decide how they are going to allocate those reserves to the real economy. Are they going to buy a financial asset, market make? Are they going to give a loan? Unfortunately, what we have seen is that, that credit creation really is not happening. We have seen the velocity of money fall across pretty much all economies.”
A new safe digital asset is needed that can be used by most people, once government bond yields hit effective lower bounds and CBDCs enable negative interest rate policy, breaking the traditional safe asset framework.
“Right now, with government bond yields hitting their effective lower bounds across developed markets, and with the risk that you could implement a negative rate policy on cash when Central Bank Digital Currencies are implemented, creates that need for a new safe asset, and I do not know what it will be, but it is got to be a digital safe asset that is usable by most people.”
Competition between private digital currencies and state money can emerge in emerging market countries where the credit risk of a private payment system like Libra might be preferable to the credit risk of a weak government.
“When we start to move into emerging market countries, and I know we are going to get into a lot of these issues about institutional strength and trust in the government, all of a sudden, when we do the credit analysis, you might get into a situation where you do have a private end-to-end system like Libra being preferable to state currency.”
Once governments gain new policy tools, they always seem to use them and never unwind them because taking them off-ramps requires political will that central banks have never shown, even when opportunities arise.
“I think it was obvious to see that the fact that central banks gain those new policy tools, and they always said that they understand the economy better than all of the rest of us, and they will be able to unwind extraordinary policy, always seem like a fantasy to me, because when we did see opportunities for them to take that off-ramp even marginally, they never did.”
Governments have been able to implement negative interest rate policies without public backlash because they are disguised as monetary policy rather than presented as the explicit tax that they are.
“Governments have been able to get away now with charging or effectively implementing a new tax on their population. They are implementing policies that just are not working, that are not proving to generate a reflationary strong growth and inflation impulses and wage increases that all of these policies are targeted at.”
If central banks implement negative policy rates, the long end of government bond curves still has one potential 'last gasp' of capital appreciation left, as illustrated by the German bund market under ECB negative rates.
“I am using the German bund as a playbook with the ECB for that, that basically, once the negative policy rate is implemented, once that Rubicon has been crossed, you have the long end of the curve has one potential last gasp of capital appreciation or rally left in it.”
Central bank reserve rebalancing and negative US current account flows would initially overwhelm currency side effects, causing dollar depreciation before inflationary pressure manifests, creating a lag between currency moves and domestic inflation.
“Well, not near term, but in the initial phases of this, given the large stock of foreign savings in the US, the capital account outflows are going to overwhelm on the currency side full stop.”
If individuals demand custody accounts at the Federal Reserve and the Fed must accommodate them, this could cascade into a system where the Fed competes with commercial banks for deposits, fundamentally questioning fractional reserve banking and potentially requiring bank nationalization.
“One of the questions right now is, will central banks allow individuals to have custody accounts, demand deposit accounts at the Central Bank? Loretta Mester actually said, look, there is some legislation that is looking at that as a worst case scenario, that we may have a situation whereby we need to provide payments to individuals and potentially, we could pass legislation that would then mandate that all people have an account at the Fed...You could walk yourself down the line where you say, then, nationalizing banks, and that situation would make sense, because now the government is going to provide the credibility that those institutions will custody those assets safely.”
If central banks engage in direct monetization with CBDC transfers to individuals, they get both the benefit of injecting money into targeted sectors and depreciating their currency to steal growth—creating a compounding incentive toward debasement.
“We get the double benefit of A, direct injection to the places that we want the money to go and B, the release valve being the currency, and we can therefore steal growth from the global community by having a weaker currency.”
Negative interest rate policy is not actually stimulating growth and inflation as intended; instead it acts as a hidden tax that people rationally accept as an insurance premium on safe assets while seeking growth elsewhere.
“I think that negative interest rates do not stimulate growth and inflation. I think that applies for dramatic effect, but I think that at the heart of it, you get to a situation where people, all of a sudden, are-- I have heard some very smart people start to say negative interest rates on what were safe assets, I just want to find the least negative interest rate because it is still help store value in a situation whereby growth remains uncertain. I do not necessarily want to put all my money to risk in the credit markets or the equity market. It is almost like an insurance premium that you are paying, and it is a shame, but that is where the world is.”
East Asian countries have outperformed other emerging markets because they have both controlled COVID outcomes and are linked to technology and healthcare equipment supply chains that are in high demand.
“Absolutely Asia, it is not only the COVID outcomes, but it is actually their linkages to the supply chains that are more technology linked. When we are looking at the Asian, a lot of the Asian strength, not only have they been able to get COVID under control, but they have also been linked to this recent demand for both technology and healthcare equipment.”
Approximately 95% of all transactions are already being done digitally, meaning the government is behind the starting block on digital payments despite having led the way for years.
“When you include all of that, right now, about 95% of all transactions are being done digitally. A lot of them are being done via digital platforms, whether-- ... include all of that, right now, about 95% of all transactions are being done digitally. A lot of them are being done via digital platforms, whether it is Visa, MasterCard, a bank credit card. In a lot of ways, the government is behind the starting block after it has already led the way on this for years.”
Central banks have exhausted the traditional policy toolkit of using interest rates and unorthodox policies like buying government bonds, private bonds, and equities, which creates a pressing need for new policy tools like CBDCs.
“When we think about where central banks are today, we have reached a limit, really, as far as exhausting the traditional policy toolkit of using interest rates to try to set monetary policy, the unorthodox monetary policy toolkit of buying both government bonds, private bonds, in some cases, equities...We are at a historic point on the policy side, whereby central banks' toolkits have been exhausted, and this would actually potentially provide a new tool for them in order to affect that.”
The COVID-19 crisis, structural unemployment concerns from technology disruption, and the need to coordinate between monetary and fiscal policy are all accelerating central bank interest in CBDCs as a new policy mechanism.
“We are in the middle of a historic crisis of COVID, where, right now, we are starting to see the second wave of lockdowns come through Europe, and I think you guys have done a good job of covering that issue. There is also the concern that structural unemployment might be much higher going forward given the proliferation and pull forward of a lot of technologies and the disrupting of supply chains that are happening due to the coronavirus.”
Central bank liquidity since March 2020 has primarily gone to wealthy individuals through asset price appreciation and to large corporations through debt issuance, leaving small businesses out of the benefits.
“I think one of the issues I pointed to of the current central bank policy is what have we seen since March is we have seen the majority of Central Bank liquidity go to either wealthy individuals through asset price appreciation, or go to large companies as debt has been issued by corporations, and it has really left out the small business sector.”
True monetary debasement via central bank monetization carries greater risks of inflation spiraling out of control than any benefit from currency depreciation, making it an inferior policy choice to deficit spending with fiscal offsets.
“I would push back a little bit. I see exactly what you are saying with that as a potential risk. First of all, I totally agree that quantitative easing and extraordinary monetary policy is about the currency and is about gaining market share and benefit from currency depreciation. I go back to the risk that I said that I believe, if you get into true debasement via monetization, that the risk of monetary inflation getting out of control is so much greater than the benefit you would get from any currency depreciation in that scenario. In my opinion, that is not the policy prescription because of that tradeoff.”
Russia and China, which have already implemented alternative global payment systems competing with Swift, are also increasing their gold reserves, anticipating the debasement risks from future CBDC-enabled monetary expansion.
“Interestingly, the two countries who have already implemented global payment systems that are in competition with Swift are Russia and China. What are Russia and China doing? They are increasing their allocation to their reserves in gold. That is a trend that is likely to continue and be accelerated by what is likely to come in a new global payments infrastructure.”
The Japanese yen is one of the few assets that provides genuine risk-off protection due to its safe haven properties and low correlation with equities during volatility spikes, making it suitable for a new 60/40 portfolio construction.
“I still think the yen, which, by the way, I will take one just brief aside here, I like the allocation of the yen on the risk-off property that it has, and it is one of the few assets out there that you can start to think about in a vol shock would provide some of that offset that you are looking for in the 60/40 reallocation.”
In March 2020 and in negative-yielding countries, the 60/40 portfolio had no offset because both equities and negative-yielding bonds fell together during the volatility spike, leaving investors with double losses rather than the hedging they expected.
“He was writing up about the fact that actually, you can see from that March event that the negative yielding countries, there was no offset in their 60/40 portfolio as the market melted down. You had the huge vol spike, equities were plummeting, and actually, those negative yielding assets did nothing. Sometimes, they actually added to your pain. Whereas only in the countries that had positive yields, and those positive yields were very miniscule, and have reduced since then, did you see any offset.”
In the near term, the dollar will continue to serve as a safe haven asset despite longer-term structural pressures from CBDC-enabled reserve diversification, particularly during periods of global economic uncertainty.
“The dollar, I think, in its current status still will serve as a safe haven asset near term. This is a medium term structural item that we need to pay attention to that has the potential to have huge ramifications for a dollar downside.”
The UK's Ways and Means facility and Indonesia's direct central bank purchases are examples of governments and central banks testing the boundary between fiscal spending and monetary debasement through quasi-fiscal arrangements.
“We have seen a little bit of testing of monetization on central banks and governments. The UK has the Ways and Means facility, but that is a direct payment. It is like an overdraft account that the UK government can use, but if they were they take money from the central bank to fund a current emergency program, but then they promised to pay it back quickly. You are seeing Indonesia do direct-- they are getting around it by saying, well, we are issuing a note to the Central Bank that the Central Bank could then sell to the market. We promised that it is a priority claim. We will pay it back as well.”
Bitcoin's correlation with risk assets during risk-off environments (2018, March 2020) resembles gold's behavior, suggesting Bitcoin trades debasement risk rather than volatility deflation risk, making it unsuitable as a hedging asset for the current portfolio context.
“When I look at the Bitcoin correlations with risk assets during risk-off environments to 2018, March of 2020, I see a very high correlation to the way gold behaves in those. That it appears to me that it is trading more that debasement risk, rather than the volatility deflation risk that you are trying to get.”
True monetary inflation (debasement) from CBDC-enabled central bank money printing without fiscal offset would open the floodgates to inflation where gold and Bitcoin could serve as legitimate protections.
“This would, in my opinion, open the floodgates to monetary inflation where you really start to see inflation starts increasing because of true money printing and debasement, and this is where I think Bitcoin and gold can absolutely protect you in these scenarios.”
The US dollar currently represents 88% of one side of global currency transactions and 85% of international settlements through Swift, giving the dollar extraordinary weight in the global system.
“The dollar, the BIS said that in 2019, the dollar was about 88% of one side of all currency transactions, with the number two and three being Euro at like 30%, 32%, and yen at 17%...the current global payment system that is used across the globe is Swift, where Swift connects banks internationally and allows international settlements and it looks like about 85% of all international settlements through Swift are dollar settled as well.”
Loretta Mester, the Cleveland Federal Reserve president, stated that in a worst-case scenario, the Fed might need to pass legislation mandating that all people have accounts at the Fed to provide payments during emergencies.
“Loretta Mester actually said, look, there is some legislation that is looking at that as a worst case scenario, that we may have a situation whereby we need to provide payments to individuals and potentially, we could pass legislation that would then mandate that all people have an account at the Fed, but then you get into this issue that you could have a preference for assets being tested at the Fed versus at Deutsche Bank or Bank of America, JP Morgan, which then starts to create issues for those banks as they would lose their deposit base.”
Negative interest rate policy on cash might encourage banks to offer preferential private cash demand deposit accounts to regain deposits by offering rates slightly less negative than the government system.
“This might be where banks could get creative and offer their private cash demand deposit account, and then create a preferential treatment to try to regain some assets.”
Portfolio managers should avoid overweighting higher-risk assets near term because there is significant probability of a double-dip recession given building COVID shutdowns and rising cases, especially in the US and Europe.
“We are much more defensive near term because of these building risks versus valuations that we think maybe discounting a little too much for the time being.”
Private coins are still too volatile and too much in their infancy to meet the store of value standard that money requires, though sophisticated people may disagree.
“I know there is a lot of discussion on the store of value, and whether some of the new private coins can meet that standard, and I would argue that the private coins are still too volatile, and they are still a little bit too much in their infancy to truly meet that standard, although I am sure that there are some very sophisticated people who might want to take the other side of that argument.”
Most emerging market currencies face near-term pressure and are better positioned defensively, but Mexico and Russia offer interesting entry points after volatility spikes if growth risks pass.
“I think the near term to most emerging market currencies is a bit lower, but if we can get through the election and get through a risk hurdle, a growth hurdle in the near term, I think you are still going to have interesting plays in Mexico, you are going to have interesting plays elsewhere, where these higher beta, still liquid emerging market countries can no longer be viewed in a basket, but the ones that we are interested right now in watching, we have not gone into them, would be Mexico and Russia for potential entry points after we get a little bit of spike in volatility.”
Government bond curves in countries that have not yet implemented negative rates (Australia, New Zealand, UK) offer attractive duration exposure opportunities, especially if central banks implement negative rates which would create one last appreciation spike.
“The interesting places, again, are the government bond curves where central banks have not quite gone negative yet. Looking at duration in Australia, New Zealand, I think even the UK is interesting, especially if they have a little bit-- a messy Brexit would be best for the long end of the UK tee, because that way, you would actually have the Central Bank implement negative policy rates which might give you a little bit of juice on that trade.”
Campbell remains cautious about entering China despite excitement about its potential as a safe asset because the government's liberalization appears recent and unproven, requiring a test case before risking investor capital.
“I know there is a lot of excitement about China and China being potentially a safe asset, I still get concerned that the authorities, although they appear to be liberalizing a little bit more, I want to see a true test case of that before I put any investor money to risk in China, but absolutely Asia, it is not only the COVID outcomes, but it is actually their linkages to the supply chains that are more technology linked.”
In a 2018 DoubleLine piece titled 'Quantitative Easing: Welcome to the Hotel California,' Campbell argued that central banks lack the courage to unwind QE despite the acute credit crisis ending years ago, setting up a permanent expansion dynamic.
“Here is the quote that I want, it goes like this, "the acute phase of the credit crisis ended years ago, giving way to nearly a decade of global economic growth. The central banks, however, have lacked the courage to unwind QE." That quote is from a gentleman by the name of Bill Campbell, it is from the year 2018 in a DoubleLine piece called, "Quantitative Easing: Welcome to the Hotel California."”