What this covers

This is the first of two interviews in which Keith Martin Smith talks with Doshin Roshi, who appears in the material under the names Doge and Dogen Roshi. The conversation starts from a practical problem for spiritual teachers. Dogen Roshi says the traditional method of awakening through rigorous challenge no longer works, because it violates some specific boundaries, and that nothing has replaced it. He also says he could not find a strong enough container to do the deep work he needed in order to teach. From there the talk turns to what makes a container trustworthy: a lineage holder with integral consciousness, practices developed through experiment, and the skill to tell productive breakdown from overwhelm.

The middle of the conversation is developmental. Doge draws on Daniel Brown to describe the milestones of secure attachment: safety, attunement, delight, and implicit trust in learning. He argues that safety is essential for infants but becomes a trap for adults. The claim that attunement exists fully only in First Nation cultures is flagged as contested. Nassim Taleb's antifragility supplies the case for strategic discomfort. The discussion of victim-rescuer codependency and radical responsibility covers a victim story that is real and needs to be heard, internalized oppression as a way of staying in the victim role, and perpetrators and rescuers who need others to stay victims.

The contentious stretches are worth noting. Doge calls postmodern egalitarian culture "kindergarten," criticizes university "coddling," and says women's voices were suppressed for 10,000 years while male voices are now being suppressed. He also presents post-traumatic growth next to post-traumatic stress as a dialectical process, while acknowledging that this framing can seem to shame people who don't grow. Elsewhere he argues that the Buddhist teaching of non-self does not erase trauma or oppression but removes the victim identity that blocks effective action. He also links Hegel's "negate and preserve" to Wilber's transcend and include.

Sharpest takeaway

Doge argues that contemporary culture's emphasis on safety, equality, and avoiding discomfort undermines genuine spiritual growth and human development, which requires strategic challenge that navigates between traumatization and breakthrough through integral consciousness and skilled container leadership.

  • Safety-focused spirituality leaves practitioners frozen and unable to take risks, learn, or grow; while infants need safety as a developmental foundation, adults require strategic discomfort to progress
  • Postmodern egalitarian relativism creates codependency dynamics (rescuer-victim-perpetrator) that prevent individuals from taking radical responsibility and developing agency
  • Effective spiritual containers require: integral consciousness in the lineage holder, explicit practices developed through trial-and-error experimentation, strong boundaries around realness over niceness, and skilled trauma discernment to distinguish productive breakdown from overwhelming breakdown

The claims · ranked41 claims · weighted by value

This asset isn't compiled yet

You're seeing its claims, ranked. Compile it to build the argument threads, weight them, and check each claim against your library — the full view.

0.80

Discernment about safety in deep spiritual work requires careful attention to whether people are being overwhelmed and falling into deep attachment insecurity (where they need protection) versus being challenged into growth; this requires understanding Daniel Brown's attachment theory and the checkpoints of secure attachment.

normativehigh valueestablishednovelty 2/4durability 4/4· Doge

“when you get down to the deepest work it has to do with safety and this is where you need discernment as a leader of such a group to discern where people are in the process of being overwhelmed because they're not safe which is really triggering deep attachment insecure attachment issues this is where Daniel Browns attachment theory in his textbook come in it's just so important”

0.77

In this contemporary age, the traditional method of spiritual awakening through rigorous challenge 'doesn't work' because it 'violates some boundaries some very specific rules,' yet there is 'nothing to replace it that does work'—creating a real crisis for spiritual teachers.

factualhigh valuecontestednovelty 3/4durability 3/4· Dogen Roshi

“now in in this age that doesn't work it violates some boundaries some some very specific rules but there's nothing to replace it that does work that's a real problem that every spiritual teacher is struggling with”

0.69

Fundamental safety in infancy is the first critical milestone in attachment theory; without it, infants are likely to develop psychosis, and growth remains stuck at that developmental level—but safety becomes problematic once one is no longer an infant.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Doge

“and yet a degree of fundamental safety is crucial this is the first milestone in attachment theory if you don't have safety as a newborn infant you're not gonna get anything in fact you're very likely to develop a psychosis if that safety is interrupted radically and never stabilized your growth is stuck at that out right at that developmental level so safety is crucial and yet as were not infants anymore it becomes problematic”

0.69

Nassim Taleb articulated the concept of antifragility, which re-expresses old wisdom about 'no pain, no gain' in a new way, showing that exposure to challenge and stressors beyond one's comfort zone is necessary for growth.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Doge

“there's an idea that a gentleman by the name of Anathem Talib came out with called anti fragility now this is one of those rare rare new ideas that he articulated some old wisdom some grandmother type wisdom in a new way that's just incredible so no pain no gain is a way of looking at this”

0.69

A victim story that is activated (where someone's agency has been violated) is real and true: it needs to be heard, the victimized person carries shame, their volition and agency have been violated, and suppressed anger from this violation becomes internalized and manifests as self-loathing and violence toward self.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Doge

“when someone has a victim story that's activated the archetype of the victim is activated there actually is sake sacrificial lamb that truth needs to be spoken they're carrying a tremendous amount of shame their volition and their agency their ability to set boundaries and get angry and take a stand have been violated and they have been victimized and they've given up the power this creates an incredible amount of shame because that anger can't get out and it needs to go somewhere where does it go and it goes in internalized and it it becomes self-loathing right violence towards self right”

0.68

Parental bonding patterns (related concepts: transference, countertransference, and shadow projection) become the relational pattern one recreates in every relationship; these patterns must be worked through via inner dialogue to resolve.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 0/4durability 4/4· Doge

“the relationship with the parents is relived in every relationship that we have and this is where how stone and is his voice dialogue you know says that these parental bonding patterns which are really another way of talking about transference and countertransference which is just another way of talking about shadow projection those parental bonding patterns become the pattern that we live relive in every relationship we ever have and we can work that all the way down to this level of making room for where your boundaries were violated as a child or an infant”

0.68

Post-traumatic growth syndrome exists alongside post-traumatic stress syndrome: some people experience trauma and breakthrough to a new level of growth, described as a dialectical process (thesis-antithesis-synthesis) of breaking down or breaking through, but this idea is controversial because it appears to shame those who don't experience growth.

factualhigh valuecontestednovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Doge

“there is post-traumatic stress syndrome you have to be very careful not to traumatize somebody or activate trauma that's already there so that they become overwhelmed and totally shut down but there's also something that is not well known that's post-traumatic growth syndrome where you actually break through so this is actually dialectical you know Hegel's thesis antithesis new thesis break down or break down or break through break down a break through and and that's a very controversial I know that that idea there is evidence for it and trauma work that some people experience trauma and they explode into a new level of growth but it's very controversial because people feel it shames the people that don't”

0.68

Women's voices have been 'throttled for 10,000 years,' and Doge encourages every woman finding her voice to speak her truth; however, culturally there is a contradiction where in empowering individual women, the culture is simultaneously suppressing male voices, which Doge views as equally tragic.

factualhigh valuecontestednovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Doge

“it's ironic because right now women want to find their voice and speak their truth I'm all for that but my god they their voice has been throttled for 10,000 years I I encourage every woman that I I I see trying to speaker truth to speak your truth I make room for that and I'm very conscious that it's so easy to traumatize or retry mad eyes them that I give them room to speak but I notice that culturally what's happening there's one thing happening for the individual who's finding her voice there's another thing that's happening for the culture that's suppressing male voices and that is also tragic sort of the becoming the thing that they hate the most”

0.68

The sense of separate self—the belief that 'I'm here and you're there'—is taught at infancy and is a delusion; when someone awakens, they realize this persistent sense of self 'is just a persistent delusion that keeps arising,' and this delusion is the cause of endless suffering.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 0/4durability 4/4· Doge

“the belief that I'm here and you're there which were taught at infancy is a delusion you know this an awake someone who awakens and realizes the deepest truth of we are realizes that this sense of self is it just a persistent delusion that keeps arising and I believe it it's just simply not true and it is the cause of endless suffering in my life in your life in the world”

0.68

When a rescuer stops rescuing and the victim must take responsibility, the rescuer is no longer able to fulfill the rescuer identification; this breaks the codependent dynamic, but codependency is writ large in culture, especially in universities where they're 'coddling' people in victim mode.

factualhigh valuecontestednovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Doge

“other people trying to rescue me just enhance that victim mode they they're no longer can fulfill the identification with being a rescuer if I stop being a victim so rather than teaching me how to take responsibility...I will remain in victim...and that's happening it seems writ large for a culture especially universities and places where they're really coddling yes a victim in the sense of keeping them in the victim please”

0.66

Hegelian 'negate and preserve' and Wilber's 'transcendence include' describe the same process: to reach a higher level of consciousness, one must negate the lower level to solidify the higher level; the old consciousness is then included in the new consciousness in a practical way.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 4/4· Doge

“it's transcendence include this is an idea you know Hegel said negate and preserve you know Wilber says transcendence include they're both part of the same process negate and preserve when I when I actually make it to a higher level of consciousness I have to negate the lower level of consciousness in order to solidify the higher level of consciousness and that is it can be viewed in a positive way as transcend and then the the older level of consciousness is included in the newer level of consciousness in a very practical thing”

0.64

When dissociation occurs—when someone's 'light goes out' and they retreat into a cave of safety—this is a form of psychological shutdown where the person is no longer present, and continued intensity will cause trauma rather than growth.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 0/4durability 4/4· Doge

“a form of dissociation right and this has been very difficult for me to learn as a teacher it goes a grant against the way that I personally learned”

0.64

Secure attachment in infancy has four primary milestones: (1) Safety—the infant feels safe; (2) Attunement—the mother knows the infant's needs before they cry; (3) Delight—the mother reflects back and encourages the infant's learning and joy; and (4) implicit trust that it is safe to learn new things.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 0/4durability 4/4· Doge

“you can go right down the list secure attachment means that the milestone of safety gets a checkbox were you safe when you were an infant no I wasn't either no checkbox problem that will come out later in every relationship we have yes absolutely the next thing is attunement so a 2-month is where your mother was so in tuned with you as an infant that she knew what you needed before you needed it you didn't even have to cry she was right there you didn't even have to cry if you were hungry she fed you you know this is attunement...and the third one is delight you know when a child is learning a newborn infant is learning 10 billion things a day and every time they learn they react just like you and I do when we learn something new the light shines in their eyes and their mother is right there to reflect it back to them encourage the learning encourage the delight if that's not reflected back the light goes out”

0.63

Attunement—where a caregiver knows a child's needs before they cry—is only found in First Nation cultures with simple living and complete devotion to children without civilization's complications; neither Doge nor Keith had mothers who were sufficiently attuned to their needs.

factualhigh valuecontestednovelty 2/4durability 2/4· Doge

“this is only found in First Nation cultures where they're simple and they can completely devote themselves to the children there's no complications of civilization my mother wasn't always in tune with what I needed was yours not at all no checkbox”

0.57

Safety is the most unsafe spiritual path because it leaves practitioners frozen in fear, unable to take risks, unable to try anything new, and unable to learn from mistakes, making it a horrible strategy for either spiritual or human growth.

causalhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 3/4durability 3/4· Doge

“safety is the most unsafe spiritual path you can take it leaves you frozen and fear unable to take risks unable to try anything new unable to learn from your mistakes it is a horrible strategy for spiritual growth or for human growth it is just doesn't work”

0.56

The idea that the self is not real (Buddhism) doesn't negate trauma, oppression, or systemic problems; rather, understanding non-self enhances one's capacity to recognize and address these issues because it removes the victim identification that prevents responsible action.

causalhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 4/4· Doge

“so when you're working with someone then you're you're acknowledging that there might be both systemic and personal not only trauma but also oppression happening and one of the ways that you're offering a solution if you will is by showing that the self is it real of course it's called Buddhism and I've heard that and that there's this radical responsibility piece that doesn't negate those are their truth it doesn't negate anything right it actually enhances it”

0.55

If a teacher hasn't done their own victim and perpetrator work, they will lack both the sensitivity to recognize when students have disappeared and the wisdom to help them—they will keep pushing even when the student needs support.

causalhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Dogen Roshi

“if I don't I not only don't have the sensitivity to recognize when they've disappeared so I keep pushing I don't have the wisdom to help them”

0.55

Dogen had to do 'deep work' to be an effective teacher, but couldn't find 'any place that was strong enough' to do this work; there were no containers capable of holding the intensity of work required to 'fulfill my vows as a priest to benefit all beings let alone a Roshi.'

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Dogen Roshi

“I had some deep work that I had to do in order to be an effective teacher and I looked around and I couldn't find any place that I can do this work in there were no containers that were strong enough for me to do the deep work that I needed to do in order to fulfill my vows as a priest to benefit all beings let alone a Roshi”

0.52

The postmodern egalitarian relativist ideology emphasizes safety, equality, entitlement, and positive emotions while suppressing aggression, anger, and challenge, which Doge characterizes as 'kindergarten' in its approach to human development and spiritual growth.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Doge

“postmodern egalitarian relativism it's a set of beliefs and values that is really an ideology that has a certain set of beliefs and values that we could identify that is very popular especially in America... everyone has to be equal even if they're not we have to pretend that they are everybody has to be safe everybody can only have positive emotions we cannot allow any aggression any anger and the sounds like kindergarten well it is kindergarten from my perspective”

0.52

In the perpetrator role, one can be virtuous, self-righteous, and morally superior while actually perpetrating victimhood in others; rescuing requires that others remain victims to fulfill the rescuer's identity.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Doge

“that I can be the human it to be virtuous and self-righteous and moral and pretend that I'm not perpetrating our victimhood right which I am”

0.52

When Keith plays it safe—avoiding vulnerability, not getting on demanding meditation retreats, avoiding physical conflict practice, avoiding writing books that expose him—things don't really happen; growth requires stepping away from safety.

causalhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Keith Martin Smith

“you know here we are in this postmodern era and you know I've certainly felt this in my own life as a as an author and as a martial artist and as a ZEM practitioner that my relationship to safety when I play it safe things don't really happen you know if I get on the cushion and I want to be in a safe container then I wouldn't go to his own retreat where you have to get up at 5 in the morning... if I wanted to play it safe I wouldn't have gone into an embodiment practice that emphasized in his actual physical conflict actual fighting and writing books is incredibly vulnerable and difficult and exposes you in a way that can be very uncomfortable”

0.52

Culture and individuality are in direct opposition: culture creates rules to maintain order, while creativity emerges through individuals breaking existing rules and generating novel emergence, which the culture then duplicates because it works.

causalhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Doge

“the cultural collective rules are to keep order mm-hmm the individual breaks those rules causes trouble too that's what creativity is how do we create new culture we break the existing rules and there's an emergence the novel emergence exactly yeah that is duplicated because it works so we find culture and individuality and direct opposition to each other right right”

0.52

Doge has learned through teaching that most people do not learn the way he does (through intense challenge and directness); he must discern when someone is 'resisting a lie they're telling themselves' (a moment to increase intensity) versus when 'the light goes out of their eyes' and they've retreated into dissociation (a moment to back off entirely).

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Doge

“when I'm working with people it was really hard for me to learn that everybody doesn't learn like I do you can't kick everybody in the head but I finally have learned that I've learned that when someone is stubbornly resisting a lie they're telling themselves that's a time to enchant density but when all of a sudden I watched the light go out of their eyes as though they've crawled back into a cave to be safe that I must completely back off energetically and I must make great room and treat them with tender care”

0.52

The pursuit of niceness at the expense of realness has become a cultural problem; authentic growth requires honesty and directness rather than the suppression of truth to avoid discomfort.

normativehigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Doge

“it's become being nice at the expense of being real has become what to do and it's tragic but the consequences are tragic nice at the expense of being real yes another way would be to say that would be being nice instead of speaking the truth well that's part of being real speaking the truth”

0.52

Accepting radical responsibility is terrifying to someone who identifies as a victim or as a rescuer because it removes the identity structure that these identifications provide.

causalhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Doge

“it's it's terrifying to someone who identifies with being a victim or identifies with being a rescuer so if I identify with rescuing victims”

0.52

Internalized oppression (self-beating and preemptive self-attack) is a strategy to remain in victim mode: if the victim beats themselves up, others don't have to, and the victim identity is maintained; this prevents learning affect regulation and responsibility.

causalhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Doge

“it's often kind of a preemptive strike to if I beat myself up then you don't have to beat me up and it keeps me in victim mode and other people trying to rescue me just enhance that victim mode they they're no longer can fulfill the identification with being a rescuer if I stop being a victim so rather than teaching me how to take responsibility and learning affect regulation you know learning to control my my setting boundaries without getting angry taking responsibility for the boundaries I need to set I will remain in victim rather than taking responsibility”

0.52

In spiritual practice, particularly Zen, the container is primary; a strong container emphasizes being real, honest, vulnerable, and truthful (rather than being safe and feeling good), and this allows deeper shadow work, growing up, and waking up.

normativehigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Doge

“in spiritual practice in Zen in particular but in any spiritual discipline at all the the primacy of container is huge that we have uh that we have a strong container that can hold us as practitioners yes in an organization that's more towards the postmodern egalitarian mindset the container the emphasis is going to be obviously on safety and that people feel good so those are those would be the sort of two things that the container would try to emphasize or that it would try to protect maybe the most those are the worst things”

0.52

What is needed to create an effective spiritual container is a combination of four elements: (1) an 'integrally-informed' lineage holder (Roshi) who can understand evolutionary consciousness development, (2) a strong container, (3) practices that work, and (4) a nurturing community—and currently only the first element is in place.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Dogen Roshi

“so what we've ended up with is not only do we need a strong container in integrals em we need an intrical ian formed Roshi or lineage holder right now we only have one we're looking for a replacement I'm about ready to retire there's no retirement don't get that idea and we need practices we need practices that are practical and really work and we have tons of practices we developed in that laboratory and we need something that I am NOT very good at it's a nurturing community”

0.52

The postmodern-egalitarian-relativist approach is actually quite good at creating 'nurturing community'—they excel at this—so Dogen consciously brings them back in to help develop that essential fourth ingredient while keeping the other three elements (integrally-informed leadership, strong container, effective practices) as the foundation.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Dogen Roshi

“this is where the postmodern a Galit Aryan relativism people that are attracted to those beliefs and values happen to be really good at building nurturing communities so this is where we let them back in to help us because they're good at it”

0.51

The way contemporary culture enculturates people as they come to spiritual practice is 'hopelessly ineffective as a spiritual path' because of the identification with 'safety with equality with entitlement'—entitled to not earn or take responsibility for anything.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Dogen Roshi

“would you say it's particularly challenging as a spiritual teacher the way people are enculturated now as they come to you and what they have as opposed to say 20 years ago or 30 years ago it is hopelessly ineffective as a spiritual path hopelessly ineffective because of the identification with safety with equality with safety with equality with entitlement uh-huh entitled to not get something without having to have any skin in the game and earn it without needing to take responsibility for anything”

0.49

The controversy about post-traumatic growth only arises at a 'certain altitude of consciousness'—specifically, it is controversial to the 'postmodern liberal' worldview, not to higher levels of consciousness.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 2/4· Dogen Roshi

“it's only controversial at a certain altitude of consciousness the postmodern liberal”

0.48

An Enneagram 8 (the Challenger/Boss type) naturally triggers people with liberal-leaning beliefs because eights challenge and are direct; this directness violates the cultural prescription to be safe and nice, creating inevitable conflict.

causalhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Doge

“I'm an 8 on the india gram which is what I'm a Challenger some would call it the boss some would call it the [ __ ] it's actually the antithesis of what the ideal type person would be and what I would call the more liberal cultural view you know Trump is an 8 ha ha so he triggers people a little bit H just naturally being themselves will trigger people that have a liberal-leaning to their beliefs and values”

0.48

Taking responsibility for the impact one's energy and actions are having on everything and everyone is a sign of maturity; those identified with safety, equality, entitlement, and feeling good are abdicating responsibility entirely.

normativehigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Doge

“we must take responsibility for the impact our energy is having on everything each other...taking responsibility for the impact everything the whole of everything that I'm doing is having on others is a sign of maturity and if I'm so concerned about being safe and being equal and being entitled and feeling good I'm totally abdicating my responsibility”

0.48

Daniel Brown's attachment theory textbook is 'so important' because it provides a framework for recognizing developmental milestones (secure attachment, attunement, delight) and identifying what was missing in practitioners' early development.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Dogen Roshi

“this is where Daniel Browns attachment theory in his textbook come in it's just so important you know you can go right down the list secure attachment means that the milestone of safety gets a checkbox”

0.47

People claim they want to do shadow work but actually want to feel good; when shadow work requires genuine discomfort, they are shocked and leave; self-selection occurs quickly once one states clearly that total willingness to be uncomfortable and radically honest is required for the deeper work.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Doge

“even though I told people we were gonna do deep shadow work and people said yeah I want to do that they really didn't want to do that they wanted to feel good they thought shadow work would make them feel good and they were shocked when they had to be uncomfortable to do shadow work so they left right away you know pretty soon it was self-selecting all I had to do was say are you really willing to be totally uncomfortable and radically honest with all of us well maybe not that's what it takes to create a strong enough container to do the deeper work”

0.47

Doge and Keith both lacked the secure attachment milestones in childhood; they had to become strong enough to be safe for themselves, which is post-traumatic growth—growing because they weren't given what they needed—but this required extensive relationship cleanup and inner work throughout their lives.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Doge

“did you always get delight reflected back to you not so much again you and I aren't doing so good me too I needed safety I had to be strong enough to be safe right you too yeah yeah uh what a gift that was that that was an example of Proust traumatic growth syndrome uh-huh we grew because we weren't safe we didn't get those check boxes checked but you know we'd really had to do cleanup in our relationships I suspect oh yeah yeah I know a little bit of your path a little bit of my paths we've been busy doing that”

0.47

An 'integrally-informed' lineage holder must have integral consciousness that can see evolutionary development of consciousness structurally (not just awakening), allowing them to perceive problems other people can't see.

normativehigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Doge

“a lineage holder that's an integrally informed that can see the problems that other people can't see without without being able to see the evolutionary nature of consciousness which a structural way not just an awakening way so an integrally informed lineage holder”

0.45

As an Enneagram 8, Doge identifies with being a perpetrator or troublemaker, which makes him predictably singled out and attacked, but 'if it doesn't kill me it makes me stronger'; this is preferable to identifying with being a victim or rescuer.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Doge

“now being an aide I actually identify with being a perpetrator or a troublemaker so of course I'm singled out and attacked ruthlessly which is okay it just makes if it doesn't kill me it makes me stronger”

0.43

Doge is tired of 'pussyfooting around' and is getting into 'trouble' for not adapting to postmodern cultural norms of safety and niceness.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Doge

“yeah trouble is alive for me right now I'm actually tired of pussyfooting around and I'm not as sophisticated as you are”

0.43

Creating a strong spiritual container requires learning through trial and error; there is no way to learn critical lessons except through failing and adjusting, which is messy and disorganized in practice even though history books present it as clean and organized.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Doge

“don't know any other way to learn these critical lessons than trial and error you know when the the history books are written it sounds so pretty it sounds so organized when the truth is always we just [ __ ] tried and failed until we figured it out yeah it's a big mess it's a big mess it's always messy”

0.42

Keith Martin Smith is an author, Zen priest, martial arts lineage holder, and someone who has a different learning style than Doge (more intelligent and sophisticated in his approach, less direct-challenge-based).

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 0/4durability 4/4· Doge

“my name is Keith Martin Smith and I'm a zen priest and an author and a martial arts lynnie lineage holder...Much more intelligent Wow we'll see or sophisticated mine was pretty simple yeah”