What this covers

This conversation between Diane Ravitch and Russ Roberts centers on Ravitch's argument that the two dominant education reforms of the past two decades—test-based accountability and school choice—have produced harmful unintended consequences while leaving the root causes of educational inequality untouched. The discussion draws on evidence from Ravitch's book The Death and Life of the Great American School System and examines why reforms she once supported have, in her view, failed to deliver on their promises. Roberts poses skeptical questions throughout, offering counterarguments rooted in market logic and incentive theory, while Ravitch pushes back with empirical findings and case studies from New York City and other districts.

The conversation spans several interlocking failures. High-stakes testing has narrowed curricula to reading and math while paradoxically failing to improve even those subjects on the National Assessment of Educational Progress (NAEP), the metric Ravitch treats as most reliable. Instead, the regime has spawned institutionalized cheating—score inflation through redefined proficiency levels and lowered cut scores—alongside a multibillion-dollar test-prep industry that diverts resources from instruction. Charter schools and vouchers have not outperformed traditional public schools on the NAEP and often serve a smaller, less disadvantaged population through selective enrollment practices. Ravitch argues that both reforms graft market language onto bureaucratic systems incapable of genuine market operation, producing consultant profits and curricular vendor sales rather than systemic improvement. Underlying her entire critique is a sociological claim: socioeconomic status is the single most reliable predictor of achievement across fifty years of research, and schools operating in isolation cannot overcome poverty, family disengagement, and the competing demands of electronic culture. The conversation closes with Ravitch's sketch of an alternative: professionalize teaching through subject mastery, rigorous examination, and master-teacher leadership rather than testing students relentlessly.

Sharpest takeaway

Ravitch argues that test-based accountability and school choice—reforms she once championed—have failed to improve American education because they ignore the dominant role of poverty, family, and culture, and because market language has been grafted onto bureaucratic systems lacking real market processes.

  • High-stakes testing narrows curriculum to reading and math and induces institutionalized fraud rather than genuine learning gains
  • Vouchers and charter schools have not outperformed regular public schools on the NAEP and serve only a small fraction of students
  • Socioeconomic status is the single most reliable predictor of achievement, so reforms targeting schools alone cannot fix outcomes

The claims · ranked29 claims · weighted by value

This asset isn't compiled yet

You're seeing its claims, ranked. Compile it to build the argument threads, weight them, and check each claim against your library — the full view.

0.79

Schools cannot be detached from the surrounding society; teachers in urban schools effectively operate in a 'war zone' contending with non-English-speaking children, dysfunctional or neglectful families, and a pervasive popular culture (the average 8-18 year old spends 7.5 hours/day with electronic devices) that overwhelms the few hours spent with a teacher.

causalhigh valueestablishednovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Diane Ravitch

“the average child from ages 8 to 18 spend seven and a half hours a day with electronic devices”

0.78

Testing is useful for information and diagnostic purposes, but attaching punishments to scores warps the entire system: because people will deliver the demanded scores, the scores become meaningless and the accountability regime induces institutionalized fraud (cheating, redefining proficiency levels, lowering cut scores).

causalhigh valuecontestednovelty 3/4durability 4/4· Diane Ravitch

“when you begin punishing people for not getting the right scores you did you warp the testing he warp the accountability you warp Everett you warp the whole thing you're trying to measure because people will give you the scores and the scores will be meaningless because they cheat what you do is induce institutionalized fraud”

0.78

Government education policy adopts the language of markets—incentives and rewards/punishments—but grafts them onto bureaucratic arrangements lacking any real market process, so the incentives misfire; the main beneficiaries become consultants and curricular add-on vendors, much like the failed government-created California energy market.

causalhigh valuecontestednovelty 3/4durability 4/4· Russ Roberts

“too often government policy takes the language of markets which are which is fundamentally about incentives... and then tries to graph them into institutional arrangements where there's no market process there's bureaucracy or government mandates”

0.77

The success of Catholic schools rests less on tuition incentives than on a spiritual commitment to each child as 'a child of God,' producing intensive, caring, whatever-it-takes adult engagement—an approach that demonstrably works (graduation rates in the high 90s for impoverished students) but is not scalable to a public system.

causalhigh valuecontestednovelty 3/4durability 3/4· Diane Ravitch

“I think their most fundamental value is what makes them successful which is that the people involving have education have a spiritual commitment to each child”

0.77

Charter schools have drifted from their original 1988 vision (Shanker/Budde: teacher-led schools taking the hardest cases and feeding innovations back to public schools) into a voucher substitute and, in places like NYC, into aggressive competitors seeking to displace public schools entirely, dissolving the concept of a neighborhood community school.

factualhigh valuecontestednovelty 3/4durability 3/4· Diane Ravitch

“they no longer subscribe to the original vision of we're here to help public schools get better in many places they see themselves as not just competitors but we're out to kill public education”

0.73

When testing carries high stakes and only reading and math basic skills in grades 3-8 are measured, schools are incentivized to teach only those subjects, abandoning arts, science, history, geography, and literature—yet despite this narrowing, basic-skills achievement on the valid federal NAEP test has not actually improved.

causalhigh valuecontestednovelty 3/4durability 3/4· Diane Ravitch

“if you're only measuring reading and math basic skills grades 3 through 8 that's all you're incentivizing people to teach”

0.73

Just as William Easterly documented a succession of failed development fads (investment, human capital) that never solved poverty, education reform cycles through fads (accountability, choice, standards, facilities) none of which touch the only proven mechanism for learning: first-rate teachers with a great curriculum interacting with students.

causalhigh valuecontestednovelty 3/4durability 3/4· Russ Roberts

“the only way we know to get children to learn and think they have to have first-rate teachers with a great curriculum which you talk a lot about I think very well none of those fads whether their accountability choice standards the physical schoolroom etc none of those fats touch those things in any direct way so it suggests we're looking in the wrong place”

0.73

The single most reliable predictor of educational achievement over 50+ years of social science research is socioeconomic status; college-educated parents pass advantages to their children, so the odds favor high scores for rich kids and low scores for poor kids, even though exceptional schools and teachers occasionally overcome these odds.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 2/4durability 4/4· Diane Ravitch

“the single most reliable predictor of educational achievement is socioeconomic status and college-educated parents tend to pass along their advantages to their kids”

0.70

Reformers and the smartest education minds focus on the 3% of students in charter schools while neglecting the 97% in regular public schools, where the real systemic challenge lies.

factualhigh valuecontestednovelty 3/4durability 3/4· Diane Ravitch

“97% of the kids are in the regular public schools and it seems like all the really smart brains in this country who care about education or focus on the 3% and nobody's thinking about what to do about the 97%”

0.70

The term 'failing school' is misleading because in most cases such schools simply enroll large numbers of very low-achieving students at intake (e.g., high schoolers who cannot read); the proper response is a diagnostic evaluation team identifying the specific causes per school rather than blanket closure or privatization of the bottom 5,000 schools, which is draconian and demoralizing.

normativehigh valuecontestednovelty 3/4durability 3/4· Diane Ravitch

“the school let's call a failing school is one that has a lot of kids who come in it was very very low achievement levels they can't read they can't write they can't do math”

0.69

In adopting balanced literacy, Klein discounted a private letter from seven eminent reading professors warning the program was unproven for disadvantaged students, instead citing a public letter of support from a hundred education professors—many with no expertise in reading—illustrating how appeals to numbers can override relevant expertise.

factualhigh valuecontestednovelty 3/4durability 2/4· Diane Ravitch

“the seven eminent Rose reading people were discounted and the hundred who were teaching a million a zillion other things reconfirmed his decision”

0.69

New York City manufactured apparent test-score improvement through methods including redefining the lowest proficiency level, taking credit for a score jump that occurred before the mayor implemented any program, and the state lowering the passing cut score—analogous to Enron-style accounting that shows spectacular results until a day of reckoning.

factualhigh valuecontestednovelty 3/4durability 2/4· Diane Ravitch

“they have still to this day take the baseline is the minute he took control before he'd even decided what he was going to do”

0.69

No Child Left Behind spawned a multibillion-dollar test-prep and teacher-training consultancy industry; while it may create jobs, the money is diverted from instruction into preparing kids to take tests, representing a distraction from genuine education with insiders close to the Department of Education profiting from curricular materials.

causalhigh valuecontestednovelty 3/4durability 2/4· Diane Ravitch

“the test prep industry is now a billion-dollar industry and maybe that creates jobs but it's the wrong jobs where instead of pumping all that money into preparing kids to take tests which they should be getting instruction this is all great diversion”

0.69

Many charter schools cherry-pick students by under-enrolling the hardest-to-educate (English-language learners, immigrants, homeless, special-ed kids), concentrating those students in neighborhood public schools and making fair comparisons difficult; on the NAEP from 2003-2009 charters have never outperformed regular public schools for black, Hispanic, or low-income students.

factualhigh valuecontestednovelty 3/4durability 2/4· Diane Ravitch

“the charter schools do not have their fair share of the kids who are hardest to educate”

0.68

American education has been perpetually framed as being 'in crisis' throughout the 20th century, with each decade's crisis talk used to drive a particular favored reform (progressivism, vocational education, school construction, collective social reconstruction, federal aid, desegregation).

factualhigh valuecontestednovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Diane Ravitch

“what I've always noticed from the very beginning was the American education always seems to be in crisis and the crisis talk is used to drive some particular change”

0.68

Undergraduate education degrees are largely a fruitless requirement; what young teachers actually need is classroom management and the ability to translate their subject knowledge into terms accessible to students—a brilliant Ivy-League/Oxford graduate failed as a teacher because she lacked these skills, not subject knowledge.

normativehigh valuecontestednovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Diane Ravitch

“I don't believe that undergraduate education agrees I think that it's unfortunate”

0.68

Giving education away for free in the US may undermine parental investment, because people value things less when they get them for free than when they pay out of pocket—possibly contributing to weaker parental engagement.

causalhigh valuecontestednovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Russ Roberts

“when you get something for free you don't value it as much as if you pay for it out of your own pocket do you think that's important”

0.68

A genuine improvement strategy should professionalize teaching over a 20-year plan: require teachers to have a bachelor's degree (or double major) in the subject they teach, pass rigorous subject and literacy/numeracy exams, and be led by master teachers as principals and experienced superintendents who make hiring, tenure, and curriculum decisions.

normativehigh valuecontestednovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Diane Ravitch

“anyone who comes in teaching should have a bachelor's degree in the subject they plan to teach and possibly in two different subjects double major”

0.66

No Child Left Behind set the utopian goal that 100% of children would be proficient by 2014 with escalating penalties (closure, privatization, charter conversion, mass firing) for any subgroup that fails to progress; a senator privately admitted no one really believed the goal was reachable but thought 'it's good to have goals'—a setup that, by punishing the impossible, predictably encourages cheating.

causalhigh valuecontestednovelty 3/4durability 3/4· Diane Ravitch

“a senator whom I know and respect said no we don't really think that but we think it's good to have goals”

0.64

School vouchers, despite 30-50 years of advocacy since Friedman's 1955 paper, have not produced dramatic improvement in Milwaukee, Cleveland, or DC; conclusive data showing big gains is absent, supply of seats is insufficient, and only ~30,000 children participate—so vouchers cannot be the systemic solution for 50 million students.

factualhigh valuecontestednovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Diane Ravitch

“I don't think there's anybody who says the vouchers have made a dramatic difference neither in Milwaukee nor Cleveland and the reason the battles go on is because there is no conclusive data”

0.63

Bloomberg and Klein, despite the mayor campaigning on back-to-basics, implemented a 'left-right' hybrid in NYC: a constructivist/progressive curriculum (balanced literacy, Everyday Math) paired with businesslike management techniques, and constructivist programs like Everyday Math (banned in California) fail to teach basic skills, leaving many students unable to do basic arithmetic.

factualhigh valuecontestednovelty 2/4durability 2/4· Diane Ravitch

“the state of California is literally prohibited every day math because it's a very constructivist program”

0.63

On the NAEP, NYC made zero progress in reading from 2003 to 2007 (eighth-grade scale score essentially flat at ~264), demonstrating that the heavily promoted reforms produced no real gains on the one test Ravitch considers valid.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 2/4durability 2/4· Diane Ravitch

“in 2007 that the National Assessment scores came out showing that New York City made zero progress and reading from 2003 to 2007”

0.62

When Chicago closed underperforming schools, researchers found about 42% of displaced students moved to other low-performing schools and on average there was no improvement, indicating mass closure does not solve the underlying problem.

factualhigh valuecontestednovelty 3/4durability 2/4· Diane Ravitch

“in Chicago the researchers found that about 40 and what was 42 percent of the kids from the close schools went to other local performing schools and on average there was no improvement”

0.57

Every child should have the opportunity to play a musical instrument because doing so teaches the importance of practice, self-discipline, independent effort, and collaboration—skills transferable to all other learning—and the visible, undeniable improvement from practice contrasts sharply with the fudgeable, dishonest statistics of standardized tests.

normativehigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 3/4durability 3/4· Diane Ravitch

“if you play a musical instrument you learn the importance of practice you learn self-discipline you have to do it alone no one can do it for you and then at some point you do it with others it teaches almost everything you need to know”

0.55

The public school system has shown no ability to improve through any fad, suggesting the most radical solution would be to get government out of education entirely and let many approaches compete—though Roberts concedes this could turn out worse and he has no idea what an ungoverned system would look like.

normativehigh valuefringenovelty 3/4durability 2/4· Russ Roberts

“my system which would be to get the government out of education entirely would be better it could be worse”

0.38

The very metrics used to measure 'success' in education reform are flawed—for example, graduation rates count students who then enter college needing remediation, so they are not good measures of genuine learning.

factualestablishednovelty 1/4durability 2/4· Russ Roberts

“using graduation rates where the kids graduate and then go into college need remediation yeah oh that's not a very good man”

0.35

The Nation at Risk report (1983) recommended rigorous high school graduation requirements, a balanced curriculum (English, history, literature, science, arts), and well-prepared, well-paid teachers, rather than the school prayer Reagan had wanted, and became an unusually widely distributed government education report that set the reform agenda.

factualestablishednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Diane Ravitch

“what the report said was we need to have a real high school graduation requirements expectations that kiss will study English and history and literature and science and the arts”

0.35

The six national education goals set under the first Bush administration and the governors (e.g., America leading the world in math and science by 2000, 90% graduation rates) were all unmet.

factualestablishednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Diane Ravitch

“we have not reached any of the goals that were set for the year 2000”

0.12

I love living in a free-market society and would not live in any other.

normative· Diane Ravitch

“I'm not antagonistic those are in capitalism I would not live in any other society I love living in a free-market society”