
New Data Suggest Hiring Has NEVER Been this Bad
What this covers
This is a 17-minute solo video from Eurodollar University that argues against a common picture of recession: mass layoffs and crashing consumer spending. The speaker, who is not identified in the material, leans on three sources: a New York Times piece on why jobs are harder to find even though layoffs are few, an August 2024 release from Challenger Gray & Christmas, and a 2005 paper by Robert Shimer. The line of inquiry runs from the academic literature on how unemployment actually rises, through the 2024 hiring and retail data, to a critique of how policymakers are reading the moment.
The Shimer material carries most of the theory. Using US data from 1948 to 2004, he found that job-finding probability swings widely over the business cycle while the separation rate is comparatively flat. He attributed nearly all of the unemployment rise in the 1991 and 2000-2001 recessions to falling job-finding. He also argued that models built around Mortensen & Pissarides had looked at the wrong side of the problem. The speaker pairs this with a firm-level mechanism: when sales weaken, the cheapest first cost cut is to stop hiring, which then spreads into reduced capital spending and a vicious cycle.
On the 2024 evidence, the speaker cites Challenger hiring announcements down about 40% year to date, below even early 2008. He also cites real retail sales averaging roughly negative 0.36% over six months, which he says creates a margin squeeze. Historical comparisons show nominal retail sales staying positive through the 1970s, early 1980s, 1990-91 and 2007-08 recessions. The most contested claims are the 3% threshold for the recession danger zone and the criticism of FOMC members, including Claudia Sahm, who treat rising unemployment without layoffs as benign. Andrew Challenger is cited on the opposing side: unemployment begets unemployment.
Recessions are triggered by a collapse in hiring, not layoffs; warning signs are visible in 2024 data showing hiring announcements down 41% year-over-year and real retail sales negative, placing the economy in the recession danger zone despite mainstream dismissal.
- Hiring collapses precede layoffs; layoffs are a lagging indicator, not a leading one
- Real retail sales under 3% nominal growth signal the danger zone where cost-cutting becomes self-reinforcing
- 2024 data mirrors 2008 pre-crisis patterns: weak hiring and stagnant real spending despite positive nominal headlines
This asset isn't compiled yet
You're seeing its claims, ranked. Compile it to build the argument threads, weight them, and check each claim against your library — the full view.
Unemployment can rise without a surge in layoffs when businesses stop hiring new workers, even as they retain existing staff; this is the actual recession mechanism.
“it's the lack of hiring that causes the downturn to spiral leading to a Slowdown in spending”
Employees who have jobs but see it becoming harder to find jobs develop a chilling effect on spending, leading to slowdowns in consumer spending on goods and services even before widespread layoffs occur.
“as workers find it more difficult to get jobs and as more workers who have jobs realize it's it's difficult to get jobs and begin to fear what would happen if they're let go it has this chilling effect all across the economy and you see that in a Slowdown in consumer spending on Goods as well as Services”
In the early stages of recession, businesses stop hiring and separated workers cannot find new jobs, leading to unemployment accumulation and the start of the self-reinforcing vicious cycle.
“what happens during recessions in the early stages of recession as shimer showed is that businesses stop hiring therefore the number of unemployed that are become unemployed and involuntarily separated from their jobs start to pile up and that piling up where they can't find a new job leads to the consequences that we see reduction in spending therefore redu further reductions in hiring the Vicious Cycle of recession”
During the 2007-2008 Great Financial Crisis, nominal retail sales remained between 1-3% year-over-year throughout the first half of the recession and even in December 2007, showing positive growth despite serious economic contraction.
“2007 and 2008 the first half of the great knot recession retail sales nominal retail sales were at 2.9% in December 2007 and then between 1 and 2% during the first half really up until August of 2008 so even during the first half of the great KN recession which was on its own right a pretty substantial contraction had Rising unemployment then too nominal retail sales were not Contracting”
When businesses confront general economic weakness, the easiest cost-cutting measure before resorting to layoffs is to simply stop hiring new workers while retaining the existing payroll.
“when confronted with weakness in the general economy what they will do is cut hours of the workers they do have in certain cases but what what's the easiest thing to do overall is to simply not hire anyone else to go with the payrolls that you have and the employees that you have at the time”
Robert Shimer, quoted in a New York Times article, stated that hiring managers deciding not to fill positions doesn't make headlines like plant closures, but these decisions, multiplied across the economy, drive rising joblessness during recessions.
“when a hiring manager decides not to fill a position that doesn't tend to make headlines the way a plant closing M said Robert shimer who's a University of Chicago Economist but those decisions multiplied across the economy can lead to rising joblessness”
The 1970s, early 1980s, and 1990-1991 recessions all featured periods where nominal retail sales remained positive (above zero) but real retail sales declined, showing that nominal growth doesn't capture actual economic stress.
“what you see again is the 1970s recessions early 1980s recessions you don't get a nominal decline in retail sales but you do get real retail sales declining that's the key here that's the one that distinguishes like hiring that's the one that distinguishes recessions for example 1990 91 nominal retail sales are hanging around 3% year-over-year before finally falling off in January but in throughout the entire recession retail sales were mostly positive in their annual comparisons”
Recessions are triggered by a collapse in hiring, not by layoffs; layoffs are a lagging indicator that comes after businesses stop adding workers and spending begins to decline.
“contrary to popular perception recession is all about hiring not firing when hiring vanishes that's the trigger the layoffs come later on and during the past several recessions over the last 30 years layoffs don't show up until much later unemployment starts to rise and goes up significantly because employers stop adding workers”
Real retail sales (adjusted for inflation) are the key spending indicator to watch, not nominal sales; when nominal retail sales fall below 3% year-over-year, that's the recession danger zone.
“recessions happen when nominal retail sales get under 3% and sales have been consistently under that level all year they don't even need to contract because what really matters is volumes real retail sales have been sliding lower and that's the key just like hiring is the critical measure of the labor market real retail sales are what you need to pay attention to in terms of actual spending”
Shimer's 2005 research, using US data from 1948-2004, found substantial fluctuations in unemployed workers' job-finding probability during business cycles, while employed workers' separation rates remained relatively acyclic, especially in recent decades.
“what shimer wrote in 2005 was using United States data from 1948 to 2004 I find that there are substantial fluctuations in unemployed workers job finding probability at business cycle frequencies while employed workers separation probability is comparative as cyclic this is particularly true in the last two decades during which period the separation probability has steadily declined despite two spikes in the unemployment rate both recessions”
Shimer concluded that virtually all of the increase in unemployment and decrease in employment during the 1991 and 2000-2001 recessions resulted from reductions in job-finding probability, not increases in separation rates.
“virtually all of the increase in unemployment and decrease in employment during the 1991 and 2000 recessions was a consequence of a reduction in the job finding probability”
When unemployed workers are separated from jobs during economic booms, they find new employment easily and briefly experience unemployment; this churn is normal and not recessionary.
“there's always churn in the labor market there are always people who are being separated from their positions either voluntarily or involuntarily and when you're involuntary separate separated from a employment opportunity during a boom period it's easy to go and find another one so maybe you're unemployed for a little bit that's certainly an inconvenience but it isn't overall devastating to the economy”
Multiple data sources (JOLTS hiring surveys, Challenger Gray & Christmas announcements, retail sales) all tell a consistent story of economic weakness in 2024, making the recession narrative robust across different measurement methods.
“now we've been talking about hiring all along especially where it comes to jolts the government's data on specifically hiring in the jolt survey most people pay attention to job openings which is one of the most worthless statistics there is it's really the hiring number that should stand out that's the one that people need to focus on and what it has been saying is that over the last year hiring has absolutely crashed and now we get confirmation from another data source Challenger gray and Christmas”
The FOMC and its members, including Claudia Sahm, have stated that rising unemployment rates in 2024 are not concerning because they are not being driven by layoffs, but this reasoning misses the actual recession trigger: lack of hiring.
“even the fomc's past statement and speeches by its members have referenced that we shouldn't worry about the unemployment rate because it isn't being driven by layoffs even Claudia s of s rule infamy has said so herself”
Shimer argued that the macroeconomic models developed over the past 15 years (as of 2005), including papers by Mortensen & Pissarides and others, have been misdirected by focusing on the cause of job loss rather than the difficulty of job finding during recessions.
“I argue this misinterpretation that being that layoffs are the cause of recession has profoundly influenced the development of macroeconomic models of the labor market during the past 15 years including such well-known papers as mortensson and pisides and cabayo and hamur subsequent research has focused on the cause of job loss during recessions rather than the difficulty of finding a job”
There is substantial research showing business cycles are not determined by layoffs but by hiring behavior; layoffs are merely a byproduct of the cycle.
“there is a ton of research which shows business Cycles aren't determined by layoffs those are just a byproduct”
A business that maintains nominal sales growth below 3% while selling fewer actual goods (negative real sales) faces a margin squeeze that forces cost-cutting, including hiring freezes, without requiring a demand shock.
“below 3% nominal terms Contracting in real terms for what should be obvious reasons because businesses are getting very little nominal growth at the same time they're selling fewer actual Goods that's a combination that no employer wants to find themselves in therefore they're going to stop hiring new workers”
Robert Shimer, a University of Chicago economist, published a 2005 study on business cycles and labor market dynamics that has over 1,750 citations and is one of the most important studies on how recessions impact labor markets.
“Robert shimer isn't just some generic Economist that they pulled off the street in 2005 he authored one of the most important studies on recession business cycles and every and how they react and how they how they impact the labor market more so where they come from”
US employer hiring announcements are down 40% year-to-date compared to last year, the lowest level in 20 years of Challenger Gray & Christmas tracking data, lower than even the first eight months of 2008.
“new data suggests that hiring has never been this bad year-to-date announcements by us employers are down 40% compared to just last year that's lower than even the first eight months of 2008 it's the worst in 20 years of data”
Layoffs tend to decline during summer months seasonally, yet layoffs over the past couple of years have held at substantial levels compared to the 2010s and 2021-2022, indicating labor market weakness.
“there's season to layoffs they tend to go down during the summer months so layoffs over the last couple years have been holding at pretty substantial numbers certainly compared to the 2010s as well as 2021 into 2022”
Once businesses stop hiring, they also cut back costs in other ways including reducing capital investment, as evidenced by recent declines in non-residential construction.
“if they're not hiring they're also cutting back costs in a whole number of other ways including they're investing less and we've seen that cyclical signal too in terms of non-residential Construction non-residential Construction has fallen off recently too”
The Andrew Challenger referenced in the transcript is the Senior Vice President at Challenger Gray & Christmas, an outplacement firm that tracks labor data, and has stated that unemployment rising without layoffs still reflects recession conditions because 'unemployment begets unemployment.'
“that's according to Andrew Challenger who's the senior vice president at Challenger gra Christmas which is an outplacement firm that tracks labor data as I just went over unemployment can rise even without a surge in layoffs what really distinguishes a recession isn't job losses but a Slowdown in hiring”
When hiring has collapsed and spending is slowing (as in 2024), waiting for layoff data to confirm recession means you have 'waited way too long'—the early warning signals are already present.
“if you're waiting for the layoffs you've waited way too long real retail sales not nominal but even nominal retail sales when they're below 3% that's in the danger zone and the danger zone is where we get all of these processes becoming self-reinforcing to the point that it leads to further consequences second and third order effects and it becomes the Vicious Cycle of recession”
Real retail sales in 2024 have averaged negative 0.36% over six months, meaning Americans are buying less actual goods while paying slightly more, creating a margin squeeze for businesses.
“real retail sales continue to be negative in most months as well six-month average change in real retail sales here in 2024 minus 0.36% so Americans are buying less stuff and having to pay a little bit more for it and from the business perspective they're shipping less stuff they're making less stuff they're selling less stuff and not really getting that much more in Revenue”
All the recession confirmation signals in 2024 (hiring collapse, weak retail sales) have developed over the past five to six months, indicating the economy is already in early recession stages despite not yet showing the visible signs (mass layoffs) that the public expects.
“we've already seen all of this stuff developed over the last five and six months to the point that we've got enough recession confirmation even if it's missing what popular imagination imagines a recession looks like what a recession actually looks like is lack of hiring and a Slowdown in spending we got those”
In 2024 year-to-date, nominal retail sales have been under 3% year-over-year in every month except March (3.63%), with a six-month average of 2.73%, placing the economy within the recession danger zone.
“so far in 2024 nominal retail sales have been under 3% year-over-year in every single month except March and March was only at 3.63% this six-month average for nominal retail sales is just 2.73% which is well within the danger zone”
Challenger Gray & Christmas data shows that in August 2024, announced job cuts totaled 75,619, a 193% increase from July and already the most for any August outside of 2020 in 20 years of data.
“according to Challenger gray and Christmas us employers have announced 75,6 191 which by the way is already the most for any August outside of 2020 in their data which goes back 20 years so already not a good sign and that's 193% increase from July”
Companies all across the economic spectrum are complaining about customer and consumer spending weakness, providing qualitative corporate guidance that corroborates the quantitative hiring and retail sales data.
“economic data as well as corporate reports they keep warning about customers and consumers and spending”
Mainstream media has consistently misinterpreted August 2024 retail sales as positive (calling them 'resilience' and 'stronger than expected'), when the data actually confirms recession danger zone conditions in both hiring and spending.
“when is the mainstream ever not anything but glowingly positive about the economy today's retail sales report was actually another confirmation along the same lines as what we're seeing in hiring”
Mainstream media and policy establishment have 'moved the goalpost' on recession assessment, pivoting from claiming the economy is fine to claiming any downturn will be minor, without acknowledging the systemic weakness now evident in hiring and spending data.
“everybody in the mainstream and elsewhere who told you that everything was fine all year now they're going to move the goalpost and say well it's just a little minor slowdown the unemployment rates Rising but for positive reasons nothing could be further from the truth”
The retail sales data series was substantially revised/restructured in 2001, so the current BLS retail sales survey only has comparable data back to 1992, requiring the use of older survey data to examine pre-1992 recessions.
“the retail sales uh series was redone and jiggered in 2001 so the current data that we have only goes back to 1992 so we're going to use the old retail sales Sur survey for the period before 1992”
The New York Times has been 'forced to confront' that something is wrong with the economy, suggesting even mainstream outlets are beginning to acknowledge economic weakness.
“even the New York Times is forced to confront the fact that there's something wrong with the economy”
The FOMC's September 2024 meeting is described as 'the most important FOMC meeting in all of history,' with the critical question being whether the Fed will cut rates by 25 or 50 basis points.
“well tomorrow is the most important fomc meeting in all of history will the FED do 25 or 50 and should we even care”