
What this covers
Alvin Rabushka of the Hoover Institution sits down with host Russ Roberts to build the economic and political case for replacing the current U.S. tax code—all 66,000 pages—with a single flat rate and no deductions beyond personal allowances. The conversation walks through the mechanics of such a system, its claimed advantages, and the objections most commonly raised against it. Rabushka draws on his co-authorship of the original flat-tax proposal in 1981, international evidence from countries that have since adopted versions of it, and a careful dissection of how the current code's complexity creates perverse incentives and hidden costs.
The core of the discussion separates what Rabushka sees as misunderstanding from legitimate disagreement. He distinguishes between a flat marginal rate and an average tax rate, showing how a single rate combined with a personal allowance still produces progressivity—a point he argues opponents routinely bungle. He then turns inward to the tax code itself: the mortgage interest deduction, which costs the wealthy far more in absolute dollars than modest earners; tax-free fringe benefits, whose prevalence traces to wartime wage freezes and now consumes roughly one-third of total compensation; and the artificial incentives created when business and individual income face different rates. On the objection that a flat tax would hurt charity and homeownership, he marshals data suggesting giving tracks income and wealth more than tax subsidies do, and that countries without mortgage deductions maintain comparable homeownership rates. He also covers the political economy of reform—why vested interests resist even systems most would prefer if starting fresh—and the international track record, where flat-tax adopters have seen revenue and growth rise rather than fall.
Rabushka argues that a single-rate flat tax with a large personal allowance—eliminating deductions, double taxation of business income, and complexity—would be simpler, progressive in average rates, growth-enhancing, and revenue-neutral, and that most objections (favoring the rich, killing charity, hurting homeowners) misunderstand the system or rest on weak evidence.
- A single rate for businesses and individuals eliminates incentives to shift income and deductions, collapsing the tax-planning industry
- A flat rate with a personal allowance is still progressive in average tax rate, rising from 0% toward the flat rate as income grows
- International adoption (Russia, Estonia, etc.) shows revenue and growth rising rather than falling under flat taxes
This asset isn't compiled yet
You're seeing its claims, ranked. Compile it to build the argument threads, weight them, and check each claim against your library — the full view.
Progressivity is properly defined as richer people paying a higher proportion (not merely a higher amount) of income in taxes; a flat rate combined with a personal allowance produces this progressivity in average rate, distinct from a graduated rate schedule—a distinction most people fail to grasp.
“the formal definition is that richer people pay a higher proportion of their income in taxes not not repeat not that they pay more”
The 'tax cut for the rich' charge is effective demagoguery precisely because it fits in one sound bite while the correct rebuttal requires half an hour, creating an asymmetry that makes the flat tax politically hard to defend.
“you just charge in one sound bite the tax cut get a wealthy it's unfair the correct answer needs a half an hour”
There is no objective or optimal level of progressivity: the top federal income tax rate has fluctuated wildly from 7% (1916) up to 77%, down to 25% (1920s), back to 91% (Korean War), then 70%, 50%, 28%, 31%, and 39.6%, so no one can credibly claim any particular year's schedule achieves ideal social equity.
“I'm hard pressed to see that anybody could pick any specific year from 1916 to 2007 and say that's it that's the kind of progressivity we like in the tax code”
The mortgage interest deduction is perversely regressive: a modest-income borrower at a 15% marginal rate on a $100,000 mortgage saves only ~$750, while a wealthy borrower at ~40% on a $1,000,000 mortgage saves ~$20,000—so the richer you are, the bigger the benefit, contradicting critics who oppose flat taxes for favoring the rich.
“somebody in the lower rate deduct seven fifty somebody in the higher rate can deduct twenty thousand right off the time... it creates the perverse situation that the richer you are the bigger the benefit”
Tax-free fringe benefits originated in the WWII wage-and-salary freeze, when employers couldn't raise pay but could offer untaxed benefits; the ratio of fringe benefits to cash compensation has since risen from about 1% to roughly one-in-three, driven by tax advantages rather than inherent value.
“The origin of fringe benefits dates to World War Two when there was a freeze on wages and salaries... they could give them untaxed income fringe benefits”
There is a crucial distinction between tax rates and tax revenue: people conflate 'lowering my taxes' (the size of the check sent to Washington) with lowering tax rates, and the media routinely treats these very different things as the same, causing confusion in the fairness debate.
“there is a big difference between tax rates and tax revenue we often say well this will lower my taxes usually when we mean that we mean a change in the size of the check”
Tax reform faces a 'vested interest' barrier because existing beneficiaries fear that what they give up in a reform negotiation won't be matched by what they gain, making reform a risky proposition even though most would agree a low simple flat tax makes sense if designed from scratch (the Mayflower Compact analogy).
“anything they give up might not be matched by something they gained and as a result it's a risky business to go into a reform process”
A single rate applied equally to business and individual income is essential because differing rates create incentives to shift deductions to where rates are highest and income to where rates are lowest; with one rate, income source becomes tax-irrelevant and tax planning becomes pointless.
“if you have a different rate for business and a different rate for individuals then people will move deductions to where the rate is the highest and income to where the rate is lowest”
The top marginal rate overstates what the wealthy actually pay, because the 39.6% rate applies only to the next dollar earned and the current system contains many exemptions, deductions, credits, and loopholes that reduce the income actually subject to that rate.
“that is what we call the marginal rate meaning the next dollar that a person earns is taxed at that rate but earlier dollars... they're taxed at the lower rate”
From a clean-slate perspective there is no economic justification for the mortgage interest deduction: it has no externality, merely encouraging people to buy bigger houses and subsidizing the construction industry, while misallocating capital from more productive uses into personal housing consumption.
“why would we ever think it's a good idea to encourage people to have bigger houses which is what the mortgage deduction does”
Income redistribution, if society wants it, is better accomplished through the expenditure side of the budget than through the tax code, because hidden tax-code benefits escape scrutiny while open spending can be debated—which is precisely why most Washington lobbying targets tax-code benefits rather than spending.
“the best way to do that is through the expenditure side of the budget the problem is it's out of the open and people can rail against it... so a lot easier to hide features in the tax code”
Charitable giving involves two opposing effects of a rate cut—a higher 'price' of giving (lower deduction value reduces giving) and higher after-tax income (which increases giving)—making the net effect an empirical question, but the last four decades of evidence favor giving rising when rates are cut.
“there's two effects they work in opposite directions it's an empirical question which one is larger”
High marginal rates (e.g., 39.6%) make tax-free fringe benefits attractive, whereas a low 19% rate greatly reduces the incentive to take compensation in kind because workers would prefer more cash to buy what they want directly.
“at 39.6% I want more vacation pay and I want a better health care plan... I want more money at 19% I'll go buy what I want”
The mortgage interest deduction is not an important factor in home affordability, evidenced by Canada, Australia, and New Zealand having no mortgage interest deduction yet roughly the same homeownership rates as the US; income level matters far more.
“Canada Australia and New Zealand do not allow mortgage interest reduction the incidence of homeownership among their populations is about the same as ours”
Post-Soviet flat-tax adopters faced fewer interest-group obstacles than the US because their tax systems never developed the US's morass of deductions and exemptions, so their business communities lobbied for pro-investment, incentive-based systems rather than to preserve exemptions.
“they didn't quite have the morass of deductions and exemptions we have so that was less of a problem for them... there were fewer interest groups who tried to preserve the current system”
Using the tax code to address social problems—education, daycare, energy, healthcare—via targeted credits progressively misallocates resources by funneling investment and money into preferentially treated areas rather than the most productive uses, compounding into the current mess.
“we have an educational problem to give children tax credits we have a daycare problem give people tax credits... each one of these further Mis allocate resources”
Corporations don't pay taxes—people do; corporations are merely legal entities collecting revenue on behalf of owners, so business income taxes ultimately fall on the disproportionately wealthy owners who receive business income.
“businesses don't pay taxes people do and the people who own the businesses pay the taxes on the income from those businesses”
Deductions can be eroded by Congress without compensating rate cuts, as shown by the elimination of credit card interest deductibility, the capture of state/local tax deductions by the AMT (a 28% flat tax), the cap of mortgage interest deductibility at $1 million of borrowing, and proposals to lower that cap to median home value.
“not too long ago we used to be able to write off credit card interest we can't do that anymore we used to be able to write off state and local taxes but on that gets caught by the alternative minimum tax which is a 28 percent flat tax”
Under a flat tax with a $40,000 allowance for a family of four, the average tax rate rises continuously from 0% (at $40,000) toward 19% as income grows (e.g., ~2% at $50,000), so for most Americans up to ~$300,000 the average rate stays well below the 19% marginal rate—demonstrating built-in progressivity.
“if you made $50,000 you would pay 1,900 on that last 10,000... your total tax would be 1,900 on 50,000 which would be just under 2%”
The original 19% rate was derived to be revenue-neutral: taking current corporate and personal income tax revenue, providing a personal allowance at least equal to the standard deduction plus personal exemption, and solving for the rate that generates the same revenue on the remaining base.
“we then wanted to provide households with a personal allowance that was at least equal to the standard deduction in the personal exemption... and what would generate the same amount of revenue”
Empirical evidence from the 1950s-1980s shows that when tax rates were cut and incomes and equity prices rose, charitable giving increased in absolute terms, while higher rates with larger tax subsidies were associated with less giving—indicating giving tracks wealth and income more than the tax subsidy.
“when rates get cut and real incomes and equity prices go up people give more but when the rates were higher people give less even though the tax subsidy is greater”
Today about half of all business income escapes taxation; the flat tax sets up an 'airtight' business tax that fully taxes all business income, which—because business income disproportionately accrues to the wealthy—shifts the tax burden toward business and reduces the share from wages and salaries.
“today we don't fully tax all business income about half of it escapes taxation”
Studies suggest fringe benefits are worth only about 80% of their dollar cost in the open market—a roughly 20% waste factor attributable to the tax subsidy distorting consumption away from what people would freely choose.
“if individuals were to buy the same services that the fringe benefits purchased they would only buy 80 percent as much in the open market which meant there was a 20 percent waste factor”
Across flat-tax countries, revenue has risen rather than fallen, growth has increased, and there is no popular clamor to return to graduated 'soak-the-rich' rates; the average growth rate in flat-tax countries is 2 percentage points higher than in non-adopting Eastern European countries.
“the average rate of economic growth and the flat tax countries is 2 percent higher than the average rate of growth in the countries in Eastern Europe that have not yet adopted the flat tax”
Estonia's flat tax (from 26% in 1994 down toward 18%, with the corporate income tax abolished so only distributed dividends are taxed) produced five consecutive budget surpluses, ~11% annual growth, 15% annual flat-tax revenue growth, and labor importation from Finland.
“The first was Estonia in 1994 it began at 26%... they've abolished the corporate income tax... the economy is growing at 11 percent a year”
Russia's 2001 adoption of a 13% flat tax, following defaults and depression under its prior three-rate system (12/22/30%) plagued by evasion and capital flight, more than doubled inflation-adjusted revenue in five years, produced budget surpluses, paid off foreign debt, and attracted foreign investment.
“in 2001 they adopted a 13% flat tax in the five years it's been in place revenue has more than doubled adjusted for inflation the budget is in surplus they paid off all their foreign debt”
The payroll tax creates an illusion that workers are funding their own Social Security benefits when in fact all money goes into the same pot; it is regressive because earnings above roughly $100,000 are not taxed for Social Security.
“it gives the illusion that you are funding your Social Security payment when in fact it all goes into the same pot”
A flat tax simplifies compliance so dramatically that both businesses and individuals could file on a single postcard in about five minutes, because almost all deductions, exclusions, exemptions, and credits are eliminated and only a personal allowance plus a single rate remain.
“instead of complicated long forms a business requires a simple postcard and an individual requires a simple postcard”
The mortgage deduction in effect subsidizes homeowners at the expense of renters, who tend to be lower-income, which makes no social sense.
“generally speaking renters represent lower income groups in the economy as opposed to homeowners... you're subsidizing home workers with expensive renter”
Losing the mortgage interest deduction would be largely offset by the much lower flat tax rate, so housing affordability and home prices would not change much in the long run, since prices are determined by real incomes, demand, and supply rather than the deduction.
“if you're losing the deduction of 35 or 39 percent that's more than offset by only paying tax of 19%”
A low flat rate below 20% would increase economic efficiency and growth by strengthening incentives for work, savings, investment, and entrepreneurial risk-taking, leading in the long run to more and better-paying jobs and higher standards of living, with most economists agreeing the net effect is positive.
“By dropping the rate to below twenty percent most taxpayers and most businesses would receive a very strong inducement to expand their economic activity”
Roughly 99% of financial planners (396 of 400 surveyed in Silicon Valley) said they would have to find new work under a simple flat tax, illustrating that a vast amount of skilled labor is devoted purely to reducing clients' taxes—an unseen waste that reform would redirect to productive activity.
“out of the 400 who attend... about four one percent said that they could probably keep doing what they're doing... the other 396 said they'd have to go find something else to do”
Keeping the rate below 20% is strategically important as a psychological and political barrier, because crossing 20% would invite incremental creep upward (20.5%, 21%) just as sales tax rates tend to ratchet up over time.
“we want to see 20 percent as a barrier that would be too difficult to cross our fear would be that if we went to 20 somebody might propose well let's go 20 and a half or let's go 21”
The payroll tax was deliberately left out of the flat tax proposal because tackling it simultaneously would politically doom the reform, as opponents would frame any change as depriving the elderly of Social Security; combining them would yield a single ~25% rate but is politically a pipe dream.
“We made a decision in 1981 that the attempt to deal with the payroll tax at the same time would so complicate the discussion as to make it impossible to focus on the inefficiencies of the income tax”
Tax competition from Eastern European flat-tax countries—attracting investment away from Germany, France, and Italy—will pressure Western Europe to lower rates; if one major Western country adopts a successful flat tax, US criticism will lose its bite by example.
“I'm hopeful the tax pressure and tax competition will bring the idea of the flat tax to Western Europe my hope would be that if just one big major important country in Western Europe adopted... most of the criticism in the United States will gradually lose its bite”
The current US federal tax code is about 66,000 pages long, and because the flat-tax postcard is self-explanatory, it would eliminate the need for hundreds of pages of regulations explaining how to fill out returns.
“the current US federal tax code being sixty-six thousand pages long with its various forms and regulations... the postcard it's self-explanatory”
The 1986 Tax Reform Act partly reflected flat-tax thinking, reducing the top rate to 28% with just two rates (15% and 28%), down from a 14-70% schedule, but it kept most deductions and complexity because reformers felt they couldn't go all the way.
“in 1986 we adopted the Tax Reform Act which reduced the top rate to 28% we had two rates 15 and 28”
Virtually all economists agree a flat tax would produce a net benefit to economic growth, which over time would generate more revenue than the current system—meaning it could reduce deficits, fund more spending, or allow the rate to drop below 19%.
“virtually all economists agree there would be a net benefit to economic growth from such a flat tax and that over time it would result in more revenue compared with the current tax system”
Filling out a tax form is unpleasant.
“a lot of people in the wake of April 15th or muttering and complaining about how unpleasant it is to fill out a tax form”