
US election: America is at war with itself | Ian Bremmer | GZERO Live
What this covers
This is a short excerpt, about three minutes, from Ian Bremmer's annual "State of the World" speech at the 2024 GZERO Summit Japan in Tokyo. It is a solo address, not a conversation, and it is given over to the United States on the eve of the November 5th election. Bremmer frames his country as "at war with itself" and as far from being the envy of anyone else in the world. He locates the problem in the widening gap between the parties, voters, and the institutions meant to hold democracy together. He says that whoever wins, tens of millions of Americans will find evidence that their political system is broken, and that they would not be wrong.
The rest is mostly forecast. Bremmer expects an extremely close race in which both sides claim victory, so the winner may not be known on election night and possibly not for a week. He then sketches the lawsuits that would follow. Democrats would allege voter harassment and intimidation that suppressed turnout, and Republicans would allege illegal voting and vote stuffing that altered the result. These predictions are his own and are not tied to any cited polling or legal analysis.
The most contested turn comes when he describes how the courts fit in. He expects the judiciary to reject or overturn the competing suits, yet argues that the litigation itself will leave voters and political leaders convinced the election was stolen, even where the legal challenges have technically been resolved. He also traces a deeper source of illegitimacy that predates the vote: deep-pocketed interest groups distorting law and policymaking toward a system that represents dollars over citizens. The excerpt closes on the claim that the post-election period is uniquely dangerous, because nearly half the country will see the outcome as illegitimate.
The speaker argues that the 2024 U.S. election is structurally positioned to be perceived as illegitimate by nearly half the country, creating a uniquely dangerous post-election period where institutional breakdown and political delegitimization are highly probable outcomes regardless of who wins.
- Election will likely be extremely close with both sides claiming victory, triggering competing lawsuits that erode confidence in outcomes
- Deep-pocketed interest groups distort policymaking away from citizen representation, creating systemic illegitimacy that predates the election
- Post-election judicial processes will be viewed as stealing the election by the losing side, regardless of legal merit
This asset isn't compiled yet
You're seeing its claims, ranked. Compile it to build the argument threads, weight them, and check each claim against your library — the full view.
Deep-pocketed interest groups are distorting law and policymaking to create a system that represents dollars over its own citizens.
“Deep pocketed interest groups are distorting law and policymaking to create a system that represents dollars over its own citizens.”
The judicial system will ultimately reject or overturn these competing post-election lawsuits, but the process of litigation will create a political environment where voters believe their election has been stolen and their democracy has been subverted.
“And the judicial system still works in the US. So those court cases will be thrown out or they'll be overturned. But that will create an environment where the people, the voters will say, 'You are stealing my election. You are subverting my democracy.'”
The judicial process of deciding election lawsuits will have an effect on political leaders, causing them to view the election as stolen even though courts have technically resolved the legal challenges.
“And that will have effect on the political leaders. And when you finally get a president, the opponents to that president, not just the citizens, but a lot of the members of that party and the politically elected officials will say, this is not my president.”
The post-election period is uniquely dangerous because the election outcome will be perceived as illegitimate by nearly half of the country.
“The post-election period is uniquely dangerous, as we are about to have an election whose outcome will be perceived as illegitimate by nearly half of the country.”
The United States political system is today at war with itself and is far from being the envy of anyone else in the world.
“My country, the United States, is today at war with itself. Its political system is far from the envy of anyone else in the world.”
No matter who wins the November 5th election, tens of millions of Americans will find evidence that their political system is broken, and they are not wrong about that assessment.
“And no matter who wins on November 5th, tens of millions of Americans will find evidence that their political system is broken. And they are not wrong about that.”
When a close election occurs, both sides will file lawsuits with different legal arguments: Democrats will claim voter harassment and intimidation prevented voting, while Republicans will claim illegal voting and vote stuffing altered the result.
“and then there'll be lawsuits and there'll be different lawsuits. The Democrats will have lawsuits in some states where they say that there was voter harassment and intimidation, they couldn't get to the polls. They'll say that, there was a wrong certification by local elected officials who decided to go political. The Republicans will say that Democrats shouldn't have won in some states because illegals were allowed to vote, and that they had a win and then it was overturned by vote stuffing, and it was rigged.”
The 2024 election will likely be extremely close with both sides claiming victory, preventing anyone from knowing the winner on November 5th and possibly not for a week afterward.
“I mean, not on November 5th. We won't know on the day who's going to win. We might not know in a week. It's most likely that it's going to be so close that both sides will say that they have won”