
Record Millions Of US Adults Giving Up On Ever Finding Work | Nicholas Eberstadt
What this covers
This is an interview in which Adam Taggart of Wealthion questions Nick Eberstadt of the American Enterprise Institute, author of Men Without Work, about people who sit outside the headline jobs numbers. The conversation starts from the gap in the 3.7 percent unemployment rate, which leaves out roughly 100 million adults who are not in labor force. Eberstadt argues that the unemployment statistics were built for a 1940s, Depression-era context and no longer measure labor market health. He also notes that unfilled jobs have risen by about 4 million while the workforce is about 4 million smaller than pre-pandemic trends implied.
The middle of the discussion goes through the evidence on why men withdraw. Eberstadt rejects poverty, ill health, and childcare as explanations: in 1965 the share of men outside the workforce was a third of today's, and women cite childcare far more often than men. He points to pandemic transfers that raised disposable income and savings, and to a disability system in which the fastest-growing categories, musculoskeletal and psychological complaints, are hard to verify. The picture of how non-working men spend their time is bleak: about 2,000 hours a year on screens, almost half taking pain medication daily, and little volunteering or Civil Society involvement. Related ground includes the collapse of teenage summer jobs, the estimated 25-30 million Americans with felony records and the lack of data to guide re-entry policy, and a growing group of prime-age women who are also outside work and family.
The more contested turns come near the end. Eberstadt links the pandemic savings glut to people substituting savings for job searching. He also argues against Universal Basic Income as a response to automation, since time-use data suggest it would institutionalize what idle men already do. He is uncertain whether automation is "this time different," but says either outcome argues for building skills. Mothers returning to work serve as his example that long absences need not be permanent.
Nicholas Eberstadt argues that a growing cohort of prime-age men have withdrawn from the labor force not due to lack of jobs but due to systemic policy failures, cultural shifts, and perverse incentives that make non-work more attractive than work, creating an 'invisible crisis' with severe individual and societal consequences.
- Over 6 million prime-age men (25-54) are neither employed nor seeking work despite unprecedented job availability, representing a crisis invisible to standard unemployment statistics
- Government policies including pandemic transfers, disability programs, and welfare incentives have created conditions where non-work is economically viable and culturally normalized
- These men spend their time on screen-based consumption and pain medication rather than productive activity, signaling psychological and social dysfunction rather than rational leisure choice
This asset isn't compiled yet
You're seeing its claims, ranked. Compile it to build the argument threads, weight them, and check each claim against your library — the full view.
Years 2020 and 2021 are the only time in recorded history when disposable income for a population in the middle of a national economic crisis actually increased
“the years 2020 and 2021 are I think the only time in recorded history when disposable income for a population in the middle of a national economic crisis actually increased went up”
Non-working men do almost no volunteering, charitable activity, or civil society participation despite having abundant free time, indicating degradation rather than productive use of time
“they basically say they don't do Civil Society there's almost no worship or volunteering or charitable uh activity um they've got a lot of time on their hands but they don't do a whole lot of help around the house either with household chores or with people at home”
The death of the summer job for teenagers is a major problem: from 1970s onward, the proportion of 15-17 year-olds with summer jobs has dropped from over 60% to under 30%, delaying economic reality and work-ethic adjustment into the 20s
“back uh back near the beginning of time when I was a young and uh summer work was a thing for guys and girls who were teens and it was great because you you made some pocket money you could put it aside for school you're independent from your parents you could do things things that you want to on your own right um from the 70s when we started to collect these numbers uh you know through the Census Bureau to today we've seen the proportion of 15 and 17 Euro 15 to 17 year olds in July who were looking for a job or had a job dropped from over 60 percent to well under 30 percent down towards 25”
Mothers represent an existence proof that people can be out of the labor force for years and successfully re-enter, demonstrating they develop critical workforce skills (reliability, timeliness, customer service, management) that employers value regardless of educational attainment
“we've got this existence proof in post-war America that people can be out of the labor force for a long period of time for years and years and get back in quite successful they're called women and they're more specifically called mothers but think of what skills a mother has to have to be a mom if you don't get sick days you don't get to call a vacation when you want you have to be reliable ready timely and one of these are skills no matter what the educational attainment level that employers appreciate right”
The consequences of male workforce withdrawal include slower economic growth, bigger income and wealth gaps, more dependence on social programs, more public debt, more pressure on fragile families, less social mobility, less civil society contact, and less trust in public institutions
“just take down the tick down the list uh slower economic growth bigger income and wealth gaps uh more dependence on social programs probably more public debt more pressure on fragile families less social Mobility less contact with civil society less trust in our public institutions I mean there's just nothing good that comes out of this”
The unemployment statistics were designed to measure conditions during the Great Depression and are now obsolete for measuring labor market health, as they were built for a 1940s context
“our unemployment and employment statistics the monthly uh jobs report that uh our policy makers and our financial markets depend upon for information this is a statistical system that was put together to fight the last war it was put together at the end of the Great Depression to measure conditions in progression depression and back in the uh back in the uh very early 1940s right before World War II”
In 1965, when society was poorer, less healthy, and less educated than today, the proportion of men not in the workforce was one-third the current level, suggesting health or poverty cannot explain the increase
“back in 1965 uh when our society was poorer than this today less healthy than it is today less educated than it is today the proportion of guys not in the workforce was a third as high as it is today um so what has changed”
Work is a service to others that helps complete humans; humans are social creatures who need connection through family, work, community, or faith to avoid being 'unhinged and untethered' and suffering negative outcomes
“there's a you know uh the the argument for being in the workforce if you can I think wins on its own merits their non-pecuniary merits but the pecuniary is an added benefit there right right um and I sort of think of it as the individual versus the society right you just gave a lot of the individual benefits as a society and that's why I was sort of looking at those Social Security numbers oh yeah yeah you're looking at that and you're saying wow we're losing this war and if I have to put my my resources to effective use but just to make it really clear I actually found my way to your work through Mike Rowe who is you know today's prince in a stage for the personal benefits of work so I'm a thousand percent on the uh yeah yeah God bless the work he does he's he's um there was one stat and this was straight from the Social Security uh programs website ssa.gov this blew my mind and I don't want to Rat Hole on this but I just love to get your opinion on it says in talking about disability about one in four of today's 20 year olds will become disabled before reaching age 67. that blew my mind is that really accurate well you know again it depends what you mean by disabled by disabled do you mean someone who becomes a beneficiary of the disability program or do you mean somebody who is disabled I think they mean somebody who becomes a beneficiary of the disability program exactly I believe that's why they have it here too but one in four yeah yeah well I mean I um on the face of it it sounds to me as if this is a good reason for An Inspector General I mean we do have a lot of health problems in our country we've got a we've had uh the deaths of Despair problem we've had a slow down and stagnation and life expectancy improvements uh so it's not as if nothing bad is going on there uh but I think we can be mindful of health problems in America and also mindful of where is the Inspector General plays yeah I agreed um I just I I I I if we are indeed taking one out of every four people out of the workforce on disability between 20 and 67. something's going really wrong because we don't we don't have the you know if this were 18 you know 23 and people were getting run over by you know stage coaches and getting color runs to I get it right but we're in the modern era here um if you're all right let's go we may go a little bit over the hour here because I still have a couple key questions before we get to your your recommended uh reforms one of which is um I am sure one of the things that the uh the the pandemic response did um because we pumped so much uh stimulus into the system is it gave people the ability to to get out of the workforce right they were getting checks in the mail there was eviction protection there's still student loan repayment protection there's all sorts of their child increased child care tax credits all sorts of stuff like that that pumped a lot of excess uh money into the system uh there's been a hot debate on how much of that pig is still left in the python um I just finally saw a chart of it last week actually that I'll try to put up again here it shows that there's maybe still a little over a trillion that's still making its way out but it looks like it'll be out it'll be used up by about mid 2023. that sounds right um so you know that allowed existing work some existing workers to eject but it it led to the great resignation um which was yes some people quitting their job and saying I'm just gonna take my luck at home for a while but it also led to a whole bunch of people retiring right because up until the end of last year you know asset prices were on a mad Terror and they were at record highs right um how much of the issue we're talking about um in this 18 to 54 or sorry 25 to 54 range is people who retired early it it's much more as if it's people over 55 who were retiring okay early I would say prematurely and I'd also suspect unsustainably uh as we uh as the wealth effects uh subside you you mentioned uh yes the asset uh asset prices as well though they're well down obviously um there were uh a considerable number of people over 55 who had rather rather small net worth net worth of under 25 000 as just the Census Bureau measures this uh who may have been part of this population that exited the labor for us um one of the things that we um I think failed at pretty badly as a country or a society uh in our uh post Cold War era was including the bottom half of America in this wealth updraft that we've enjoyed in our country you know on the eve of the covet pandemic the real um the real net worth of the bottom half of American households per household was no higher than it was when the Berlin Wall came down and if you think about what else happened with Assets in America over that period that's pretty stunning um which is to say that there were a lot of people who um For Whom the covet windfall was a great big deal doubling their net worth and uh 20 an extra 25 000 may not seem like a way of kind of like building a long-term retirement but it may be enough to keep people out of the workforce as you were saying for a year or so okay um wow well uh again provided there's no other massive liquidity injection you know in the next six months it looks like that will have dissipated through the system and of course you know TBD what's going to happen with the stock markets I've had a rough year this year but if we continue to go into recession and the bear Market continues next year as I've been saying for a while sounds like you're sort of have similar thoughts is the great resignation May remorph into the great”
The unemployment rate of 3.7 percent completely ignores 100 million U.S. adults categorized as not in the labor force who do not work and are not looking for work, representing one out of every three U.S. adults
“those calculations completely ignore the 100 million U.S adults categorized as not in the labor force who do not work and are not looking for work that's pretty much one out of every three U.S adults”
Male childcare is not the reason for workforce withdrawal: there is 'a care chasm' where women cite childcare as reason for non-work at an order of magnitude larger rate than men do
“there's like a care Chasm between guys and girls even still to this day and so the it's an order of magnitude larger for women than it is for prime age men so it's got to be it's not for staying home taking care of people”
The real net worth of the bottom half of American households per household in 2020 was no higher than when the Berlin Wall fell, despite decades of asset appreciation
“on the eve of the covet pandemic the real um the real net worth of the bottom half of American households per household was no higher than it was when the Berlin Wall came down and if you think about what else happened with Assets in America over that period that's pretty stunning”
Government transfer payments and interventions during COVID-2021 caused unintended consequences including a doubling of the personal savings rate and accumulation of over $2.5 trillion in excess wealth that has allowed people to substitute work with savings rather than search for employment
“massive interventions have massive unintended consequences uh in the quest to rescue the pandemic economy during Lockdown... our policy maker is overshot and um the years 2020 and 2021 are I think the only time in recorded history when disposable income for a population in the middle of a national economic crisis actually increased went up... our savings rate in 2020 and 2021 doubled... the public put together a nest egg in addition of a transfer payment Nest Egg of over two and a half trillion dollars”
The government has not collected data on the population with felony records, making an estimated 25-30 million American citizens statisticaly invisible and precluding evidence-based re-entry policies
“There is only a tiny bit of information uh on the employment patterns of x-com uh ex-cons in America today uh or even people who've been who have been sentenced to felony and haven't gone to prison for it but it's exactly what you would think uh they do materially worse from what we can see materially worse in the job market than um then High School dropouts who are the kind of like the lowest wrong in general um and we might be able to do a lot more about what's called re-entry if we had uh you know evidence-based policies on re-entry I mean especially now that we've got this labor shortage right um but you can't have evidence-based policies if you don't have the evidence and I think that it is absolutely unjustifiable that we have this kind that we have tasked these tens of millions of American citizens into this statistical invisibility”
Non-working men spend approximately 2,000 hours per year watching screens, which is equivalent to a full-time job, according to Labor Department time-use surveys
“what they say they're doing is watching they say they're watching screens and the surveys won't tell us what they're watching or what type of screens but at like 2 000 hours a year I mean like a like a fairly full-time job this is their vocation”
One in six prime working age men has no paid work at all
“a growing number of them especially men between 25 and 54 years old are voluntarily giving up finding work it's gotten to the point where one in six Prime working age men has no paid work at all”
The two categories rising most rapidly as reasons for disability eligibility are musculoskeletal problems and psychological difficulties, which are inherently subjective and cannot be objectively verified by physicians
“the two categories that have um risen most rapidly as reasons for eligibility to uh to disability benefits are what's called musculoskeletal problems and a psychological difficulties now if you or I go to a doctor they can tell us whether we got a broken leg if you or I go to a doctor they can tell us whether we have covet if you or I go to a doctor they cannot tell they cannot tell whether we have back pain or not whether you know if we claim we have back pain and a doctor cannot tell whether I had sad feelings or not”
The mobility between non-labor-force status and employment for men is very small—most men who drop out become 'long-termers,' unlike unemployed workers who typically return within weeks
“it's a very different thing for people for guys in particular who drop out of the workforce uh they are most likely to become long termers the mobility between the not in labor force group and the employed population is very very very small uh for men”
The argument about whether automation is 'this time different' is uncertain, but both scenarios (continuation of labor-saving or Great Disruption) make a strong case for increasing skills of population and young people
“I can't tell you whether this time is different or not um there are arguments both ways that this this is just the continuation of the labor saving that we've seen Lift us out of absolute poverty into affluence or that this is going to be the great disruption and I don't have an intelligent opinion about which way uh which way we're actually going at this point both whichever argument is correct they're both strong Arguments for increasing the skills of our population and our young people”
Ex-felons do materially worse in the job market than high school dropouts and face severe employment barriers even though many want to reintegrate into society and the labor force
“they do materially worse from what we can see materially worse in the job market than um then High School dropouts who are the kind of like the lowest wrong in general um and we might be able to do a lot more about what's called re-entry if we had uh you know evidence-based policies on re-entry”
Universal Basic Income would be problematic as a response to automation because time-use data shows what non-working men currently do with their time is 'not a heartening picture,' suggesting UBI would just institutionalize screen consumption and despair
“there's a big cautionary in the uh time use numbers that I used for you about looking at Universal basic income as a way of dealing with mass automation I mean you know we see already what guys who are neither working nor looking for work do with their time it's not a heartening picture I don't think we should want to be buying more of that through public policy”
The number of unfilled job positions in the United States has jumped by about 4 million since before the pandemic while the number of people in the workforce is about 4 million fewer than pre-pandemic trends would predict, creating a mirroring imbalance that violates basic market economics
“with still over 10 million almost 11 million uh slots unfilled the number of unfilled positions in the United States is jumped by about 4 million since before the pandemic and by a strange of mirroring process the number of people in the workforce is about 4 million fewer than we would have expected on pre-covet Trends”
Almost half of non-working men take pain medication every day, according to pre-pandemic surveys, indicating drug-medicated screen consumption rather than simple leisure
“before the uh before the pandemic asked people are you taking pain medication and the you know the men without work that we're talking about um almost half of them said yeah I'm taking I'm taking pain medication every day”
Prime-age women with no children at home, not in labor force, not married, and not in education/training now exceed 3 million and this group has been growing exponentially, showing a concerning yellow cautionary light
“these are the prime age women who have no children at home are not in the labor force neither uh neither employed in education or training and are not currently married and this group is not as big as the checked out prime age men that I mentioned but it has been growing exponentially for the last couple of decades and it is now over 3 million”
Approximately one in four of today's 20-year-olds will become disabled before reaching age 67, according to Social Security Administration data
“there was one stat and this was straight from the Social Security uh programs website ssa.gov this blew my mind and I don't want to Rat Hole on this but I just love to get your opinion on it says in talking about disability about one in four of today's 20 year olds will become disabled before reaching age 67”
For thousands of generations men aged 25-54 have been society's natural providers; casting them in the role of permanent dependent is unnatural and deeply disheartening
“for thousands of generations men 25 to 54 years of age have been our society's providers it's like natural providers and to be cast in the role of sort of permanent dependent uh in those ages for those men is not only kind of unnatural but I think it's really disheartening”
Government should implement evidence-based felony reentry and re-entry programs for the tens of millions with felony records, using current labor shortages as an opportunity to integrate this population into workforce while respecting that many reentrants genuinely want to reintegrate
“there's that enormous invisible population of x-cons in America um you know they shouldn't be just uh you know they've paid their they paid their debt to society there's this is the this is the population that's been sentenced and is out right um some of them will be recidivists but many of them will want to reintegrate into families into society into the labor force if we will let them and now that we've got this screaming labor shortage and think that this would be an excellent time for that”
In 1950, the ratio of workers to Social Security retirees was 16 to 1; today it is 2.7 to 1, and by 2035 it will be down to 2 to 1, placing increasing unsustainable weight on current workers
“in 1950 the number of uh workers per Social Security retiree was 16 to 1. right it was it was actually even a lot higher in the 40s but that's because this program was just starting and a lot of folks hadn't retired yet and they didn't live as long um it's now down to 2.7 if I believe correctly”
Social Security's demographics are on a Ponzi scheme trajectory with no sugar-coated path from pay-as-you-go to self-financing retirement without creating an 'unlucky cohort' of losers
“the demographics of a Ponzi scheme is not diplomatic and I mean I'm I don't think I'm going to tell you anything that you haven't thought of yourself or that other people haven't written about there has to be a transition to uh self-financing retirement uh uh it's somebody is somebody is going to there's going to be an unlucky cohort in the transition from the pay as you go to the self-financing one and there's kind of not a good way of sugar coating that because it's hard to figure out how you uh you know end up with the kind of Pareto optimal all winners no losers in that one”
Non-working men are not secretly 'moonlighting' with hidden income; they are in a dependent condition that is fairly penurious, but not the poorest segment of society—spending patterns suggest they are in the second quintile rather than bottom fifth
“it's not there is doubtless some Moonlighting there Adam but it's not the people are you know getting second homes with the hidden income that they're uh that they're generating um it's a it's a dependent condition and it's fairly penurious uh that being said um the men without work from what I could research in my studies are not the poorest segment of our society if we look at kind of like spending patterns which I think are a much better proxy for living standards than reported income if you look at spending patterns the bottom fifth in our society is disproportionately single moms they have a really hard time yeah um the the men without work fall in the stratum above that like maybe the second uh quintile the of 20 to 40 percent group it's ironic but that's kind of like what we used to think of as the working class this is like the unworking class”
One in seven adult men in the United States has a felony conviction in his background, and it is slightly worse for prime-age men
“there's a little bit of other work but probably one in seven adult men in the United States today has a felony conviction in his background and it's probably a little higher a little worse than one in seven for prime age man”
When surveyed about why they are not in the workforce, only about 5-10 percent of men out of work for a year or more cite lack of available jobs, while the vast majority cite 'other reasons,' disproving the argument that jobs are unavailable
“if you ask the men who were not in the workforce for a year or more we do this in our you know um in our uh Bureau of Labor Statistics surveys once a year you know what is the reason that you're not in the workforce a tiny fraction well I mean now I don't know what it's like uh around five percent it's usually around 10 percent say that it's because there's no work to be had so it's for they say it is for other reasons”
Over half of non-working men are obtaining at least one disability benefit, and about two-thirds of them live in homes obtaining at least one benefit, creating a system where disability programs function as de facto welfare
“I think I can show that over half of these um worthless men are obtaining at least one benefit and about two-thirds of them live in homes that are obtaining at least one of these benefits”
People over 55 who worked until the pandemic have been exiting the labor force prematurely and unsustainably due to asset price appreciation creating temporary wealth effects
“it's much more as if it's people over 55 who were retiring okay early I would say prematurely and I'd also suspect unsustainably uh as we uh as the wealth effects uh subside”
In some counties, approximately 90 percent of all scripts for disability eligibility are issued by just a couple of doctors, suggesting a 'pay for a disability stamp' system in certain areas
“there certainly have been studies that I've heard where you know they've looked at certain counties and realized that like you know 90 of all the the scripts that get somebody on disability are being issued by just a couple of doctors”
Key differences between 1965 and today include: almost all prime-age men in 1965 were married with children under the same roof; almost all had military service (many in WWII or Korean War); the welfare state was still a dream; drug use was heavily punished
“I mean mainly when I look at the differences I think about this back in 65 almost all prime age guys were married and most of them had children under the same roof as them there's a provider impulse there that many many many men don't have these days almost all of the guys in 65 had served in the military and a lot of them had served in World War II or in the Korean War the situation is obviously very different today back in 65 the uh uh the Great Society our current American welfare state was still just mainly a dream in Lyndon Johnson's eye it hadn't rolled out yet um and back in 65 you know if you were playing around with drugs you've gotten a lot of trouble”
Reintroducing summer jobs for young people would have positive long-term impacts on society by providing early workforce experience and skill-building, but this should be done by civil society rather than government to avoid unintended consequences
“and also connected to the um kind of reintroduction of summer jobs for young people which I think will have a very positive long-term impact on our society if we can encourage that more that's not something that I would want Uncle Sam to do uh they're always unintended consequences to uncles interventions but it's something that the rest of us might you know want to do our own little bits where we can”
Proposed reform 3: Government should reform K-12 education to ensure all graduates have marketable skills; currently the educational establishment has omitted 'vocational' education from acceptable discourse and assumes everyone should go to college
“the first of course would be more skills imparting more skills on our young people and on our working age population um it's a kind of a ongoing Scandal that our public K-12 school system is so desperately spotty about graduating people who have skills and it's also I think a a bit of a self-condemnation that the educational establishment has omerited the word vocational it's not no longer politically correct to say vocational I mean so okay uh yeah you look in the mirror and you think everybody should go to college um if they should be like you um College isn't for everybody but everybody should graduate with a skill of some sort that you can support yourself with”
Proposed reform 1: Civil society (outside government) should commit to truth about importance of work—both for economic and non-pecuniary reasons—and encourage those who can work to do so
“to begin with I think we'd want to encourage people who were not part of government outside of government in Civil Society to commit truth in public and to commit truth around the dinner table and to say what we all know about the importance of work uh you know yes for money but not just for money in uh in our society not everybody can work but if people can work and they uh want to work they should be encouraged to do so”
Mandatory national service (military or Americorps equivalent) is worth experimenting with if it can be protected from turning into ideological indoctrination, though Eberstadt expresses concern about political polarization preventing this
“if we weren't so horribly politicized at the moment I'd be a little bit less worried about the unintended consequences of this sort of an initiative let me ask you this in the scenario where your Emperor do you do this so you get to control the politics well if I get to control the politics um that's that's getting we're getting awfully totalitarian there and I don't like the totalitarian part of that um if we had a if we had a different world um yes maybe this could be this could be a good program for a different world but the the part that I'm concerned about is it unless we have a big change in our uh in our government and a big change in um a big change in our culture I mean remember part of what we have seen over our lifetimes has been the death of Truth in the Public Square”
Proposed reform 4: Reform disability programs along 'work-first' principles similar to 1990s welfare reform for single mothers, recognizing that many non-working men would return to work with policy changes but acknowledging this is difficult to prove
“a reform of our broken um dysfunctional disability archipelago along the lines of the welfare reform that we had back in the 90s I realized back in the 90s Democrats and Republicans could play nice together and get things done bipartisan and you know that doesn't seem to be so easy nowadays but um a a reform of our wealth of our of our disability system to a work first principle I think would be a change that would it would create some problems I imagine but the problems would be replacing bigger problems with smaller problems if we could do this it's easier said than done but I think it's worth trying”
The 'Great Resignation' may remorph into a 'Great Un-retirement' or 'Great Please May I Have My Job Back' party as asset prices decline and pandemic stimulus is exhausted
“sounds like you're sort of have similar thoughts is the great resignation May remorph into the great unretirement party or the great please may I have my job back party”