
Former MI6 boss on Trump, Putin and a 'new era' for international relations
What this covers
This is a short Newsnight discussion between Alex Younger, the former head of MI6, and Catherine Belton, a former Financial Times Moscow correspondent. It was recorded after Donald Trump called Volodymyr Zelenskyy a "dictator" and as US–Russia talks began. The conversation opens on the clash between the two leaders, including Zelenskyy's response to Trump's claim about his approval rating. It then widens to ask what kind of international order is replacing the one that followed the unipolar moment. Younger draws a comparison with Yalta, where major powers settled the fate of smaller countries.
The middle of the discussion centres on mismatched aims. Younger argues that Trump treats Ukraine as a territorial problem, in the manner of a Real Estate Developer Mindset, while Vladimir Putin objects to Ukrainian sovereignty itself. He adds that Russian demands, such as rolling NATO back to its 1997 borders, go well beyond anything Trump appears to have considered. He also warns that handing Putin a visible win would signal to Xi Jinping that the US abandons allies, with Taiwan as the implied test.
The speakers disagree, or at least qualify each other, on how much leverage Washington holds. Younger and Belton cite Russia's sky-high inflation, spiraling interest rates, and a military machine that may be sustainable for only about another year, plus heavy casualties. Younger also recalls Trump conceding early in the Afghanistan talks, while Belton points to his walking away from Kim Jong Un as evidence that he can refuse a bad deal. Both argue that Europe is far richer than Russia and could rebuild its forces if it chooses to. The closing turn is practical: Belton says Europe must present a united position, ideally backed by von der Leyen's proposed 700 billion euro defence fund, before Keir Starmer goes to Washington.
The international order is transitioning from a rules-based, multilateral system anchored in American unipolarity to a 'spheres of influence' model dominated by great powers making bilateral deals, with Trump embodying this shift and Russia viewing it as an opportunity to reassert control over its neighbors.
- American relative power and will to enforce global rules have declined, making the old system unsustainable
- Trump, Putin, and Xi Jinping all think in terms of strong-man dealmaking and spheres of influence, not multilateral rules
- Putin views Ukraine's sovereignty as negotiable within a Russian sphere, while Trump views it as real estate—a fundamental mismatch that makes a sustainable deal extremely difficult
This asset isn't compiled yet
You're seeing its claims, ranked. Compile it to build the argument threads, weight them, and check each claim against your library — the full view.
Trump and Putin are talking about different things: Trump thinks this is about territory and land (characteristically as a real estate developer), while Putin insists it is about sovereignty—Ukraine's existence as a sovereign country is what Putin finds unacceptable.
“Trump thinks this is about territory characteristically as a real estate guy it's about land giving land to Russia in return for peace it's not about territory and Putin said it's about sovereignty Putin was super clear when he started this war that the existence of Ukraine as a sovereign and free country was an unacceptable affront to Russian security he will not stop until Ukraine isn't a country anymore and that is that is a completely different conversation”
If Trump gives away Ukraine's sovereignty to Putin and Putin is seen to win, this sets a precedent for Xi Jinping regarding Taiwan, demonstrating that the US will abandon its allies.
“that goes straight into into into shining's mind so these are the things that I would be advising the prime minister to dwell on although I'm sure he's got a lot of ideas of his own”
We are transitioning from a rules-based international order backed by multilateral institutions to a great-power system where international relations are determined by strong men and deals, comparable to the Yalta Conference model where powerful nations divided the fate of smaller countries.
“I think we are in a new era where by and large international relations aren't going to be determined by rules and multilateral institutions they're going to be determined by strong men and Deals I think of the yelta treaty at the end of 1945 where three strong men as they were then uh on behalf of the the big countries the strong countries decided the fate of small countries”
Trump responded negatively to Zelenskyy's accusation that he lives in a disinformation space, specifically attacking Zelenskyy after the Ukrainian president referenced Trump's false claim that Zelenskyy's approval rating was only 4%, and Zelenskyy provided evidence that these numbers originated from Russian-US discussions.
“Donald Trump's attack on president zilinsky came after Ukraine's leader accused the US president of living in a disinformation space and he specifically referred to Mr Trump's false claim that Mr zelinsky's approval rating among ukrainians is only 4%”
The previous rules-based order was possible only because America had both the means and the will to assert itself across the world, creating globalization and the international security structure, but America is now a significantly smaller relative player with diminished will to enforce global rules, though it remains a prodigious country whose ability to make rules globally has declined.
“the one we had before was based on the unipolar moment where America had both the means and the will to ass itself across the world it created what we call globalization the International Security structure it's now a significantly smaller relative player relative to others than it was and of course um it's will its will to be that person has has diminished”
The previous rules-based international order was based on the unipolar moment where America had both the means and the will to assert itself across the world, creating globalization and the international security structure, but America is now a significantly smaller relative player with diminished will to enforce these rules.
“because the one we had before was based on the unipolar moment where America had both the means and the will to ass itself across the world it created what we call globalization the International Security structure it's now a significantly smaller relative player relative to others than it was and of course um it's will its will to be that person has has diminished”
Europe does not need to be as worried because Europe and NATO are 10 times richer than Russia and have the absolute capability to build up the necessary military forces to resist Russia, but only if Europe chooses to do so.
“the reason we don't need to be that worried is we are 10 times richer as European NATO than Russia we absolutely have the capability to build up the necessary military forces to resist this but if we don't do that then yes this is the stuff of nightmares”
International relations are transitioning from being determined by rules and multilateral institutions to being determined by strong men and deals, modeled on the Yalta framework where the three major powers divided the fate of smaller countries.
“by and large international relations aren't going to be determined by rules and multilateral institutions they're going to be determined by strong men and Deals I think of the yelta treaty at the end of 1945 where three strong men as they were then uh on behalf of the the big countries the strong countries decided the fate of small countries”
The Russian position includes demands that Europe put NATO constraints on its presence in Eastern Europe and go back to previous borders in 1997, which is well out of scope for what Trump has clearly thought about.
“there's Europe putting NATO putting constraints on its presence in Eastern Europe and going back to previous borders in 97 this is well out of scope I don't think it's stuff that Donald Trump has clearly thought about”
The Russian military has performed poorly and will not march into Warsaw tomorrow, but it will be emboldened by the current situation and will build up capabilities over time.
“now I do not want to exaggerate the Russian army has performed ridly it's not going to March into Warsaw tomorrow but nor should we obscure the fact that this will be hugely emboldening and over time they will build up their capabilities”
Putin is viewing the current moment as 'the era of strong men' where great powers get to divvy up the world between themselves over the heads of smaller countries like Ukraine and Europe.
“tycoons close to Putin in Moscow uh hailing the dawn of this new era uh where why they believe that precisely this that this is the era of strong men the return of great Powers who get to uh divvy up the world between themselves over the heads of smaller countries like Ukraine and over the heads of Europe”
Russia currently has sky-high inflation and spiraling interest rates, with the economy definitely slowing down, and can likely only continue the current level of military production for another year before the situation deteriorates.
“they've got Skyhigh inflation interest rates are spiraling uh the economy is definitely slowing down and probably they can only continue to perpetuate the level of military production for another year before things start going uh pearshaped”
Trump has already said that Putin should not be allowed to be seen to win, suggesting Trump understands this concept, even though his tone toward Russia has changed.
“Trump has already said that he that Putin should not be allowed to be seen to win he seems to understand that as a concept although I accept that his tone has changed”
Before Starmer goes to Washington, Europe must have its act together and present a unified position, otherwise Trump won't take anything he says seriously.
“we would have to hope that Europe has its act together before he goes there there has to be a unified position otherwise Trump isn't going to take anything he says seriously”
Even in his first term, Trump demonstrated a pattern of giving away major concessions early in negotiations, as seen in Afghanistan where he gave away the biggest concession before talks even started, setting a concerning precedent for how he negotiates.
“I saw this happen in Afghanistan where he gave away the biggest concession before we even started it's a strange art of the deal honestly there look um zilinski and Trump they're in their way different politicians zinski had no choice I think but to respond when he was accused of lacking Democratic legitimacy and Donald Trump is notoriously thin skinned”
European NATO is 10 times richer than Russia and absolutely has the capability to build up the necessary military forces to resist Russian expansion, so the threat is not inevitable if Europe makes the necessary investments.
“We are 10 times richer as European NATO than Russia We absolutely have the capability to build up the necessary military forces to resist this but if we don't do that then yes this is the stuff of nightmares”
Trump has considerable leverage in negotiations with Russia because the Russian economy is in terrible shape and cannot sustain current spending for more than another year, and Putin has suffered 800,000 killed or wounded which even for an autocrat must have political consequences.
“Trump has quite considerable Leverage as Katherine said the reality is that the Russian economy is grossly out of shape and cannot be run like this for more than another year and Putin has lost 800,000 killed or wounded which even for an autocrat like him has got to have an effect”
Trump previously met with the North Korea leader Kim Jong Un twice in his first term but did not reach a deal because Trump walked away when he didn't get what he wanted, suggesting Trump does have the capacity to end negotiations when unsatisfied.
“President Trump met the North Korea leader twice there was no deal because president Trump then in the first term didn't get what he wanted and he walked away”
Russia brought itself out of isolation from the West through the recent meeting in Riyadh, which was significant in terms of diplomatic status even before Trump's most recent statements.
“even before Trump spoke today even before the meeting yesterday in Riyad which brought Russia out of its isolation from the West”
Trump met the North Korea leader twice in his first term, there was no deal because he didn't get what he wanted and he walked away, demonstrating a willingness to not accept bad deals.
“President Trump met the North Korea leader twice there was no deal because president Trump then in the first term didn't get what he wanted and he walked away so we have seen that side of him as well”
Ursula von der Leyen has spoken about the need to create a 700 billion euro defense fund for Europe, and if that finally gets off the ground, Starmer will speak from a position of being respected by Trump.
“we've already heard Ura ferion uh speak about the need to create a 700 billion uh Euro uh defense fund uh and if that finally gets off the ground then yes starma will be speaking from a position where he can be respected”
Trump has considerable leverage because Russia's economy is grossly out of shape and cannot be run like this for more than another year.
“I think Trump has quite considerable Leverage as Katherine said the reality is that the Russian economy is grossly out of shape and cannot be run like this for more than another year”
A few weeks ago Trump was attempting to act tough on Russia, saying Russia's economy was weakened with sky-high inflation and spiraling interest rates, and the Russian economy is definitely slowing down and can probably only sustain current military production for another year before things start going poorly.
“Trump was still trying to act tough in relation to Russia saying that its economy was weakened which is certainly true they've got Skyhigh inflation interest rates are spiraling uh the economy is definitely slowing down and probably they can only continue to perpetuate the level of military production for another year before things start going uh pearshaped”
Trump and Putin are negotiating about fundamentally different things: Trump sees the conflict as a real estate problem requiring territorial concessions from Ukraine to achieve peace, while Putin views the conflict as fundamentally about eliminating Ukraine's sovereignty because he sees Ukraine's existence as a sovereign nation as an unacceptable affront to Russian security.
“Trump thinks this is about territory characteristically as a real estate guy it's about land giving land to Russia in return for peace it's not about territory and Putin said it's about sovereignty Putin was super clear when he started this war that the existence of Ukraine as a sovereign and free country was an unacceptable affront to Russian security he will not stop until Ukraine isn't a country anymore”
Trump, Putin, and Xi Jinping all operate from a great-power mindset where strong nations divide spheres of influence, but this is not Europe's mindset, creating a fundamental divergence in how different actors view international order.
“I think that's Donald Trump's mindset it's certainly Putin's mindset it's xiin Ping's mindset it's not Europe's mindset that's the world we're going into”
The fundamental problem between Trump's proposed solution and Russian objectives still feels irreconcilable despite all the rhetoric, complexity, and uncertainty.
“it still feels for all of this Bluster fundamentally irreconcilable problem right”
Putin has lost 800,000 killed or wounded in the war, which even for an autocrat like him must have some effect on his calculation.
“Putin has lost 800,000 killed or wounded which even for an autocrat like him has got to have an effect”
Evidence shows that the false 4% approval rating figure for Zelinsky is coming from Russia and has been discussed between America and Russia.
“we have seen this disinformation we understand that it is coming from Russia we understand and we have evidence that these numbers are being discussed between America and Russia”
The fact that Trump repeats Russian disinformation about Zelenskyy's approval ratings significantly diminishes Trump's leverage in negotiations because the Russians likely believe he has actually accepted their narrative, similar to how Trump gave away major concessions in Afghanistan negotiations before talks even began.
“I think it's unfortunate and I agree with Katherine this would be emboldening to Putin I don't know whether Donald Trump actually buys the Russian line but I I think the Russians probably think he does and I think that significantly diminishes his leverage and I saw this happen in Afghanistan where he gave away the biggest concession before we even started it's a strange art of the deal honestly”
If Trump can establish in his own mind that a residual free Ukraine is his bargaining point—that the preservation of Ukrainian sovereignty is what he should extract in return—then Trump can secure a good deal that preserves the outcome he cares about.
“if it can be firmly established in Donald Trump's mind that having a residual free Ukraine is his bargaining point he can get that and I think if that happens we're going to be okay”
The entry ticket to negotiations in the great-power system is hard power, not soft power or values, which creates a fundamental challenge for Europe if it wants to get a seat at the negotiating table.
“there's an entry ticket to this conversation it appears and sadly it's not our soft power or our values it's hard power and it leaves the category challenge for us in Europe how do we develop that to get ourselves a seat in this conversation”
Trump cannot afford another foreign policy fiasco like Afghanistan because it would damage his credibility, and moreover, setting a precedent of surrendering to Russian demands would directly signal to Xi Jinping that abandoning Ukraine is acceptable, which would embolden Chinese aggression toward Taiwan.
“he can't own a fiasco like that and then think of the example this sets for shiin Ping sitting across the Taiwan straight from Taiwan I mean uh that would that goes straight into into into shining's mind”
The outcome of Trump-Putin negotiations is wide open; it can be either a fair and sustainable settlement or something worse, but it is not predetermined.
“I think it's wide open so I think it can be and actually I think Trump has quite considerable Leverage”
Russia stated today that they would not accept Western troops in Ukraine because they are determined that Ukraine should be an undefended basket case, while security guarantees are a necessary endgame.
“Russia came out today and said they wouldn't accept Western troops in Ukraine of course they said that they are determined that Ukraine should be an undefended basket case but we're talking about security guarantees as a necessary endgame”
Putin is enthusiastic about the current direction because Russian tycoons close to Putin see this as the era of great powers dividing the world, and they believe Trump's claims to Greenland, Panama, and Canada validate their own claim to a Russian sphere of strategic interest in Ukraine and Central Asia.
“Putin is cheering he's very happy at what he's heard even before uh Trump spoke today even before the meeting yesterday in Riyad which brought Russia out of its isolation from the West ever since the world began already you had uh tycoons close to Putin in Moscow uh hailing the dawn of this new era uh where why they believe that precisely this that this is the era of strong men the return of great Powers who get to uh divvy up the world between themselves”
The current moment is a huge psychological opportunity for Putin who has been waiting for years for Trump to come to power, and if Trump turns out not to be the opportunity Russia expects, Russia has no alternative plan, which gives Trump additional leverage.
“this is a huge psychological moment for Putin he's been waiting for years for Trump to get in and if Trump actually turns out not to be the opportunity the Russ expect they don't have another plan so there's quite a lot of Leverage here”
Russia may be dangling hundreds of billions of dollars in deals in front of Trump and appealing to his sensibilities as a businessman and real estate developer, which may be a factor in his recent softening toward Russia.
“whether it's the offer of hundreds of billions of dollars in deals that they seem to be dangling in front of trump and appealing to his sensibilities as a businessman and a real estate developer I mean Trump is in acquisition phase now”
Russia has gone maximal in its negotiating demands to the point where it may have overreached, making it very difficult for Trump to cut through and produce a settlement that doesn't constitute an abject humiliation for the US or its allies.
“Russia has gone maximal to the point that they may even have overreached it's going to be very very hard uh for Trump to cut through this in a way that produces anything that isn't an abject humiliation”
Whether or not Trump actually believes the Russian disinformation about Zelinsky, the Russians probably think he does, which significantly diminishes Trump's leverage.
“I think it's unfortunate and I agree with Katherine this would be emboldening to Putin I don't know whether Donald Trump actually buys the Russian line but I I think the Russians probably think he does and I think that significantly diminishes his leverage”
A Russian tycoon close to Putin (and sanctioned by the US) stated that if the US claims the right to rule the Western Hemisphere (referencing Trump's claims on Greenland, Panama, and Canada), then Russia should have the right to a sphere of strategic interest in Ukraine and Central Asia.
“I was speaking to one Tycoon close to Putin who's sanctioned by the US who was basically saying well uh Trump has now laid claim to Greenland to Panama uh the Panama Canal he's laid claim to uh Canada to Gaza if he wants us to recognize his claims in the Western Hemisphere the US's right to rule the Western half of the world then they must recognize our sphere of strategic interest in Ukraine and also in Central Asia”
This is a huge psychological moment for Putin because he has been waiting for years for Trump to get back in power, and if Trump turns out not to be the opportunity Russia expects, Putin doesn't have another plan.
“I think that this is a huge psychological moment for Putin he's been waiting for years for Trump to get in and if Trump actually turns out not to be the opportunity the Russ expect they don't have another plan”
Trump has attacked Zelinsky, has not condemned Russia's invasion, and did not ask Russia to stop attacks on Ukrainians before the meeting in Riyadh, which must be emboldening to Putin.
“Donald Trump has as we know attacked president zalinsky today he hasn't condemned Russia's Invasion he didn't ask them to stop the attacks on ukrainians before that meeting in Riyad yesterday”
The Russian army has performed poorly, it will not march into Warsaw tomorrow, but Western complacency would be misplaced because Russian military successes in Ukraine will be hugely emboldening and over time Russia will rebuild its military capabilities.
“the Russian army has performed ridly it's not going to March into Warsaw tomorrow but nor should we obscure the fact that this will be hugely emboldening and over time they will build up their capabilities”
Before British Prime Minister Starmer goes to Washington to meet Trump, Europe must have its act together and present a unified position, or Trump will not take anything Starmer says seriously.
“I think first of all we would have to hope that Europe has its act together before he goes there there has to be a unified position otherwise Trump isn't going to take anything he says seriously”
Ursula von der Leyen has called for the creation of a 700 billion Euro defense fund, and if that finally gets off the ground, then Starmer will be speaking from a position of respect when meeting Trump; if not, the meeting will be meaningless chitchat.
“we've already heard Ura ferion uh speak about the need to create a 700 billion uh Euro uh defense fund uh and if that finally gets off the ground then yes starma will be speaking from a position where he can be respected if not it's going to be just the usual chitchat and might not mean anything”
Russia explicitly stated it would not accept Western troops in Ukraine as security guarantees, which means Russia is determined that Ukraine should remain an undefended country, fundamentally incompatible with what Ukraine and the West would need for security.
“Russia came out today and said they wouldn't accept Western troops in Ukraine of course they said that they are determined that Ukraine should be an undefended basket case but we're talking about security guarantees as a necessary endgame”
Only the US and Europe have not fully woken up to the reality that international relations are now determined by spheres of influence and great-power deals, while other major powers have already adapted to this new paradigm.
“I think we are seeing um deals we're seeing a conversation about spheres of influence and I think the only people who haven't woken up to this reality is is US Europe”
The situation represents a massive wakeup call for Europe that it will own more of the consequences and responsibilities at the end than it did at the beginning, regardless of how the negotiations turn out.
“as a European it's it's it's a massive wakeup call whatever you think about this all the smoke and dust and mirrors and complexity and I don't know how it's going to end I know one thing for certain which is that Europe will own more of this at the end than it did at the beginning”
Prime Minister Starmer should tell Trump two things: first, that Europe needs to organize to effect and develop hard power, and second, that giving away Ukraine as a country and its sovereignty would be a devastating mistake because Putin's goal is to eliminate Ukraine entirely, not accept territorial compromise.
“the British prime minister should be saying to Donald Trump so two things first of all I absolutely agree with Katherine we need to organize to effect to demonstrate that we're prepared to play a role take control of our own environment recognize that we've got to develop hard power and that's going to happen quickly... the other thing is what I have just said I think you need to explain to Donald Trump why uh giving away Euro um Ukraine as a country giving away its sovereignty would be a devastating mistake”
If it can be firmly established in Trump's mind that maintaining a residual free Ukraine is his bargaining point, he can achieve a deal that satisfies his goals, and if that happens, Europe will be okay.
“I think if um if it can be firmly established in Donald Trump's mind that having a residual free Ukraine is his bargaining point he can get that and I think if that happens we're going to be okay”
The only people who haven't woken up to the reality of spheres of influence are the US and Europe, and the entry ticket to this conversation is hard power, not soft power or values.
“I think we are seeing um deals we're seeing a conversation about spheres of influence and I think the only people who haven't woken up to this reality is is US Europe yeah and there's an entry ticket to this conversation it appears and sadly it's not our soft power or our values it's hard power”
For Europe, the critical challenge is how to develop hard power to get itself a seat in this new conversation of spheres of influence.
“it leaves the category challenge for us in Europe how do we develop that to get ourselves a seat in this conversation”
Europe will own more of this situation at the end than it did at the beginning, regardless of how things unfold with Trump and Putin.
“I know one thing for certain which is that Europe will own more of this at the end than it did at the beginning”
Russia has also demanded that NATO restrict its presence in Eastern Europe and return to pre-1997 borders, which goes significantly beyond what Trump appears to have considered, raising questions about whether Trump has thought through the full scope of Russian demands.
“there's Europe putting NATO putting constraints on its presence in Eastern Europe and going back to previous borders in 97 this is well out of scope I don't think it's stuff that Donald Trump has clearly thought about”
Trump had a strong hand against Russia a few weeks ago, showing readiness to threaten additional sanctions, but in the space of a few weeks his rhetoric has changed, possibly due to Putin's flattery or offers of hundreds of billions of dollars in deals.
“Trump was still trying to act tough in relation to Russia saying that its economy was weakened... Trump had a strong hand and he was apparently showing he was ready to leverage that saying there'll be more sanctions... but now uh literally in the space of a few weeks whether he's responded to Putin's flattery of him uh just a few weeks ago Putin had said that Trump uh should have won had won the 2020 election... and whether that's to some degree worked in softening Trump up or whether it's the offer of hundreds of billions of dollars in deals that they seem to be dangling in front of trump”
Zelinsky accused Trump of living in a disinformation space and specifically referred to Trump's false claim that Zelinsky's approval rating among Ukrainians is only 4%.
“Donald Trump's attack on president zilinsky came after Ukraine's leader accused the US president of living in a disinformation space and he specifically referred to Mr Trump's false claim that Mr zelinsky's approval rating among ukrainians is only 4%”
Putin had previously flattered Trump by claiming Trump had actually won the 2020 election and would still be president if Democrats had not stolen it from him, and this flattery may have worked in softening Trump's position toward Russia.
“whether he's responded to Putin's flattery of him uh just a few weeks ago Putin had said that Trump uh should have won had won the 2020 election and he would still have been president had not the Democrats stolen it from him”
Trump is currently in an acquisition phase, laying claim to Greenland, Panama, and Canada, suggesting an expansionist mindset that Russia can manipulate and exploit.
“Trump is in acquisition phase now we've seen him laying claim to all these different countries and I think you know he's certainly looking at Russia too and and Russia is able to manipulate him and flatter him uh very easily”
Russian tycoons close to Putin are sanctioned by the US and are openly discussing the new era of great-power division, indicating elite consensus in Russia about the strategic opportunity being presented.
“I was speaking to one Tycoon close to Putin who's sanctioned by the US who was basically saying”
A French businessman based in Moscow working with Kremlin tycoons reported that even the FSB has celebrated Trump's return to power, with Russians raising toasts, suggesting Trump's election was viewed very positively by Russian security services.
“there's a French businessman I speak to who's based in Moscow also working with uh tycoons very close to the F Kremlin and they're saying everyone loves Trump here even the FSB we all raised a toast when he became president”
Trump gave away the biggest concession before negotiations even started in Afghanistan, which he then blamed on Biden, and similarly he cannot own another fiasco and then think of the example this sets for Xi Jinping.
“I saw this happen in Afghanistan where he gave away the biggest concession before we even started it's a strange art of the deal honestly... Trump has already said that he that Putin should not be allowed to be seen to win... he was quite complicit in Afghanistan even though he pinned on Joe Biden he gave away the farm before it even started and that led to the Fiasco he can't own a fiasco like that”
The situation is a wakeup call and a huge tragedy for people who will be left behind at the frozen front line, but Europe can manage it if Trump maintains leverage rather than capitulating.
“it is a huge tragedy for people who will be left behind the Frozen front line but we can deal with that if um if it's do a deal at any cost get out and give it to the Europeans then I think that's a big problem”
It is a tragedy for people who will be left at the frozen front line in any settlement, but this tragedy is manageable if Europe organizes to defend itself; however, if Trump simply gives away Ukraine and passes the problem to Europeans, that constitutes a major strategic failure.
“it is a huge tragedy for people who will be left behind the Frozen front line but we can deal with that if um if it's do a deal at any cost get out and give it to the Europeans then I think that's a big problem”
Previous approaches to Gaza and Ukraine weren't working, so Trump's instinct to disrupt this is not intrinsically wrong, and having a conversation is not necessarily a bad thing if Trump maintains leverage.
“our approach to either Gaza or Ukraine take your pick wasn't working so I don't I don't intrinsically reject his instinct to disrupt this okay nor do I even think that having a conversation is a bad thing if what you've just said is in his Armory”
Trump had a strong negotiating hand with Russia and was demonstrating willingness to leverage it by threatening more sanctions if a deal wasn't reached, but then changed course in the space of just a few weeks.
“and you know Trump had a strong hand and he was apparently showing he was ready to leverage that saying there'll be more sanctions we don't get the deal that we that we want uh but now uh literally in the space of a few weeks”
The speaker does not believe a fair and sustainable settlement will result from current negotiations because the situation is fundamentally wide open, meaning outcomes are unpredictable and contingent on many factors.
“no no no I think it's wide open so I think it can be and actually I think Trump has quite considerable Leverage as Katherine said”
The current approach to both Gaza and Ukraine was not working, so Trump's instinct to disrupt these situations is not intrinsically wrongheaded, and having a conversation about alternatives is itself not a bad thing if Trump understands what he's trying to achieve.
“our approach to either Gaza or Ukraine take your pick wasn't working so I don't I don't intrinsically reject his instinct to disrupt this okay nor do I even think that having a conversation is a bad thing if what you've just said is in his Armory”
Trump was complicit in Afghanistan by giving away the farm before negotiations started, then pinned the failure on Biden, and he cannot own a second fiasco.
“he was quite complicit in Afghanistan even though he pinned on Joe Biden he gave away the farm before it even started and that led to the Fiasco he can't own a fiasco like that”
Russian elites are saying that everyone loves Trump in Russia, even the FSB, and they raised toasts when he became president, finding it almost beyond their dreams how quickly his rhetoric has changed toward Russia.
“I speak to who's based in Moscow also working with uh tycoons very close to the F Kremlin and they're saying everyone loves Trump here even the FSB we all raised a toast when he became president and I think it's almost sort of beyond their dreams too about how quickly the rhetoric has changed”
Trump is in an acquisition phase and is laying claim to various countries (Greenland, Panama, etc.), and Russia is able to manipulate and flatter him very easily.
“Trump is in acquisition phase now we've seen him laying claim to all these different countries and I think you know he's certainly looking at Russia too and and Russia is able to manipulate him and flatter him uh very easily”
America still remains a prodigious country but has lost its ability to make the rules across the world.
“Still Remains a prodigious country you underestimating America at your peril but its ability to make the rules across the world that's not there now”
The visit of British Prime Minister Starmer to Washington next week becomes more acute given the current situation with Trump and Russia.
“the visit of the British prime minister sakir starma to Washington next week I mean there's already a lot of attention and focus on that but it becomes more acute I suppose now”
The speaker has stepped back from all the rhetoric of the last seven days and is speaking in moderate, measured terms, suggesting skepticism about recent claims.
“you are speaking in moderate terms you're very measured it sounds like you are completely stepping back from all this rhetoric of the last seven days”