
What this covers
Patrick Boyle works through the claim that Europe is losing its manufacturing base and asks whether the continent should accept a future as the world's museum. He leans on two sources: the report by Mario Draghi, who warns of "an existential challenge" and a "slow agony" if nothing changes, and a counter-argument from Nico Palesch of Oxford Economics, who reads recent output declines as an industrial recession rather than deindustrialization. The evidence offered for that milder reading is specific: German car production rose 11% last year, manufacturing value-added held steady while output fell, and the energy-intensive sectors that have contracted account for only 4% of the German economy.
The energy section is the most detailed. Boyle explains how the Marginal Pricing Model lets expensive gas set the price paid to every supplier, why carbon costs make up about a tenth of industrial electricity prices, and why demand-shifting cannot help factories that run around the clock. He also covers chemicals, which depend on hydrocarbons as both fuel and feedstock, and argues that shutting down heavy industry merely moves pollution elsewhere, often to dirtier producers. The list of at-risk sectors includes textiles, paper, refining, plastics, metals and chemicals.
Other threads widen the picture. He traces how the export-led growth model and Chinese demand for European capital goods helped German exporters, while Russia came to supply 41% of EU gas. He also points out that not every economy can run a trade surplus. The productivity gap with the US is attributed largely to Europe missing the digital revolution, with scale-ups drawn to American venture capital. Further topics are Germany's weak public investment and its aversion to debt, its steep working-age population decline, sick-leave costs, automation as a response to ageing, and the likelihood of tariffs and subsidies in US trade politics. Several of these claims, including the commercialization diagnosis and the automation upside, are contested.
Europe's industrial decline is primarily a cyclical industrial recession driven by high energy costs, productivity gaps with the US in tech sectors, unfavorable global demand rebalancing, and structural challenges rather than fundamental deindustrialization, though sustained competitiveness requires urgent reforms in energy markets, infrastructure investment, and regulatory streamlining.
- Industrial output declines are concentrated in energy-intensive sectors while high-skill manufacturing remains competitive
- Europe's core problem is a productivity gap in digital/tech sectors, not manufacturing capacity itself
- Energy costs 2-5x higher than US make European production uncompetitive, but this is a market-structure problem solvable through energy reform
This asset isn't compiled yet
You're seeing its claims, ranked. Compile it to build the argument threads, weight them, and check each claim against your library — the full view.
Europe uses a marginal pricing model for electricity where if a mix of sources are used, the price paid is set by the most expensive fuel required to meet projected demand, so even if solar power is cheap, if some energy needed is expensive natural gas, all suppliers get paid the natural gas price.
“The way power is priced in Europe is complex, they use a marginal model, which means that if a mix of sources are used, the price paid is set at the price of the most expensive fuel required to meet projected demand. So even if solar power is cheap – but some of the energy needed is natural gas – which is expensive in Europe – all suppliers end up getting paid the price of natural gas.”
Demand-shifting solutions (using smart meters to charge electric cars when solar energy is cheap) may work for certain types of users but do not work for factories that need to run 24 hours a day, limiting the effectiveness of demand management as a solution to intermittency.
“The Economists other solution of shifting demand to hours when energy is plentiful and cheap (using things like smart -meters) may work for certain types of user – your electric car (for example) could be set up to charge itself in the middle of the day while solar energy is cheap and you are at work – but that still doesn't work for a factory that needs to be running twenty four hours a day.”
The productivity gap between the EU and the United States over the last 25 years is largely explained by the tech sector, with Europe mostly missing out on the digital revolution and the productivity gains it brought.
“Lower European productivity is however not just explained by extra sick days, according to Mario Draghi, the productivity gap between the EU and The United States over the last twenty-five years is largely explained by the tech sector. Europe mostly missed out on the digital revolution and the productivity gains that it brought.”
Due to Europe's aging workforce, by 2040 the population will start to lose 2 million working people per year, which will mask the effects of lower growth but without growth Europe will not be able to finance its social model and will have to scale back some or all of its ambitions.
“He says that due to the ageing European workforce by 2040 the population will start to lose 2 million working people per year, which will mask the effects of lower growth. But without growth Europe will not be able to finance its social model and will have to scale back some, if not all, of its ambitions.”
Europe's manufacturing strengths lie in highly complex, specialized areas that require a highly educated workforce, benefit from network effects and institutional knowledge, have cumulative advantages from decades of IP, patents, and physical capital investment, and have barriers to entry from research costs and customer trust, making these industries resilient.
“He points out that Europe's strengths lie in highly complex, specialized areas of manufacturing and these areas require a highly educated workforce (which Europe has), they benefit from network effects, institutional knowledge, and the cumulative impact of decades of investment in intellectual property, patents and physical capital. There are further barriers to entry too - in the form of research costs and building trust amongst potential customers.”
A more efficient European energy market could be established through three mechanisms: 1) sending energy to areas where there is no surplus; 2) shifting demand to hours when energy is plentiful; and 3) storing energy as electricity, fuel or heat.
“An Economist piece on renewables and the European energy market makes the point that at times European energy is very cheap. They argue that firms and regulators are simply not making the most of this and that there are three ways a more efficient market could be established: 1) sending energy to areas where there is no surplus; 2) shifting demand to hours when energy is plentiful, and 3) storing energy as electricity, fuel or heat.”
The export-led growth model is an economic strategy pioneered by Germany and Japan in the post-war period that aimed to grow productive capacity by focusing on foreign rather than domestic markets, rising to prominence in the late 1970s largely driven by its success in Japan and becoming part of a new consensus among economists about the benefits of economic openness.
“The export-led growth model is an economic strategy pioneered by Germany and Japan in the post war period that aimed to grow productive capacity by focusing on foreign – rather than domestic markets. It rose to prominence in the late 1970s – largely driven by its success in Japan and became part of a new consensus among economists about the benefits of economic openness.”
Nico Palesch of Oxford Economics argues that the decline in European industrial output in recent years is more of an industrial recession than deindustrialization, with Europe's shrinking share of global industrial output being driven more by increased output from Asia than by decreased competitiveness in Europe.
“Nico Palesch at Oxford Economics argues that the decline in European industrial output in recent years is more of an industrial recession than deindustrialization. He says that Europe's shrinking share of global industrial output is more driven by increased output from Asia than by decreased competitiveness in Europe.”
From 1999 through the pandemic, euro area exporters—particularly German firms—benefited from strong growth in China which fueled demand for European capital goods, while over the same period Europe shifted from being self-sufficient in energy production to becoming the world's largest importer of natural gas, with Russia supplying 41% of EU natural gas needs.
“From the launch of the Euro in 1999 through to the start of the pandemic euro area exporters – and German firms in particular – benefited from strong growth in China which fueled demand for European capital goods. Over the same period Europe switched from being self-sufficient in energy production to becoming the largest importer of natural gas in the world. Russia was the cheapest supplier, and the EU relied on it for 41% of its natural gas needs.”
Every economy around the world plans on growth through exports with no one planning on running a trade deficit, but this simply cannot work—if everyone is exporting, someone has to be importing.
“One of the problems today is that every economy around the world seems to plan on growth through exports – with no one planning on running a trade deficit – and that simply can't work – If everyone is exporting, someone has to be importing.”
The chemicals industry faces the biggest challenge because it is extremely reliant on hydrocarbons for both energy and as raw materials, with one 42-gallon barrel of crude oil producing just under 20 gallons of gasoline while the rest (more than half) is used to make products ranging from ink to antihistamines to fabrics, detergents, and paints.
“The chemicals industry faces the biggest challenge as it is extremely reliant on hydrocarbons both for energy and because thousands of necessary products are derived from crude oil. One 42-gallon barrel of crude oil creates just under twenty gallons of gasoline and the rest (more than half) is used to make everything from ink to antihistamines to fabrics, detergents, paints – the list goes on…”
Shutting down energy-intensive industries in Europe and importing steel, cement, and petrochemicals from other regions means pollution occurs elsewhere, often in a dirtier manner than in Europe, making neither environmental nor economic sense.
“The problem is that shutting down those industries in Europe and importing steel cement and petrochemicals just means that the pollution occurs in other parts of the world – where these processes are often done in a dirtier manner than they are done in Europe. It makes neither environmental nor economic sense.”
Germany's projected decline in working-age population is much worse than expected in Japan, the rest of the EU, and the UK, representing a greater demographic challenge than for other developed economies.
“They say that the biggest problems for Germany are a projected decline in Germanys working age population – which this chart shows is much worse than is expected in Japan the rest of the EU and the UK.”
Carbon costs account for around 10% of EU industrial retail electricity prices as of 2023, with marginal price-setters being fossil fuel sources charged a carbon tax, which is embedded in the price and boosts what is paid to renewable energy producers in the mix.
“According to the report, carbon costs accounted for around 10% of the EU industrial retail electricity price in 2023. One issue mentioned in Mario Draghi's report is that marginal price-setters are often fossil fuel sources who are charged a carbon tax which is embedded in the price that they charge. This higher price then boosts what is paid to the renewable energy producers in the mix.”
The Financial Times reported this week that German business executives are warning that high levels of sick leave are damaging their competitiveness and compounding the country's economic woes, with a study finding that if not for above-average sick days, the German economy would have grown by half a percent last year instead of shrinking 0.3%.
“The FT reported this week that German business executives are now warning that high levels of sick leave are damaging their competitiveness and compounding the country's economic woes. A study found that were it not for the country's above-average number of sick days, the German economy would have grown by half a percent last year, rather than shrinking 0.3 percent.”
Automobile production in Germany rose 11% last year, and manufacturing value-added remained steady even as industrial production fell because manufacturers adapted to the energy crisis and supply-chain disruptions by shifting into higher value-added products that use fewer intermediate inputs.
“Automobile production on the other hand rose 11 per cent last year. They highlight that "manufacturing value-added" remained steady even as industrial production fell because manufacturers adapted to the energy crisis and supply-chain disruptions by shifting into higher value-added products that use fewer intermediate inputs.”
Concerns for the longer-term future of German industry are exaggerated because while energy-intensive industries like chemicals, metals, and paper manufacturing have contracted, they only make up 4% of the German economy.
“They argue that concerns for the longer-term future of German industry are exaggerated. While energy-intensive industries like chemicals, metals, and paper manufacturing have contracted, they only make up 4% of the German economy.”
Regardless of which party wins the upcoming US election, trade can be expected to be a huge political issue going forward, with both Democrats and Republicans offering different solutions, but protectionism, tariffs, and subsidies all appearing to be in the cards.
“No matter who wins in the upcoming US election – trade can be expected be a huge political issue going forward in the United States and while the Democrats and Republicans may offer different solutions, protectionism, tariffs and subsidies do appear to be in the cards.”
Industries at risk of decline include textiles and clothing, paper manufacturing, refining, plastics, metals, and chemicals—sectors vulnerable to competition and the green transition.
“Certain industries he says are at risk like textiles and clothing, paper manufacturing, refining, plastics, metals and chemicals.”
Europe's energy market needs to be quickly reformed so that end-users can see the benefits of clean energy in their bills, with the key challenge being that taxes, levies, and carbon fees mask the underlying cost reductions from renewables.
“He says that Europe's energy market has to be quickly reformed so that end-users can see the benefits of clean energy in their bills. Industrial energy prices in the EU are impacted by taxes, levies carbon fees and other charges which when combined account for a substantial portion of the final energy cost which is substantially higher than in other global regions.”
Europe does not lack ideas or ambition, but innovation is blocked at the commercialization stage: innovative firms that want to scale up are hindered by inconsistent and restrictive regulations, and many European entrepreneurs prefer to seek financing from American venture capitalists and scale up in the American market rather than in Europe.
“He says that the problem is not that Europe lacks ideas or ambition. But innovation is blocked at the next stage: it is not translated into commercialization, and innovative firms that want to scale up are hindered by inconsistent and restrictive regulations. Many European entrepreneurs he says prefer to seek financing from American venture capitalists and scale up in the American market.”
German productivity has been dragged down by inadequate investment in public infrastructure, with Germany near the bottom of advanced economies in terms of public investment, mostly driven by the German aversion to debt, though borrowing for necessary infrastructure that boosts national productivity makes economic sense.
“They argue that German productivity has been dragged down by inadequate investment in public infrastructure, where Germany is near the bottom of advanced economies in terms of public investment. This is mostly driven by the German aversion to debt. While borrowing for the sake of borrowing makes no sense – borrowing to pay for necessary infrastructure that will boost the nations productivity does make sense.”
Europe's aging workforce creates an incentive for greater factory automation, and Germany is a leader in automation technology, positioning it well for the shift toward capital-intensive rather than labor-intensive manufacturing.
“Europe's ageing workforce according to Palesch – puts in place an incentive for greater factory automation, which he points out Germany is a leader in.”
Mario Draghi, former ECB president, wrote that the European Union faces 'an existential challenge' and if it doesn't change, it will be condemned to 'a slow agony,' with real disposable income per capita having grown almost twice as much in the United States as in Europe since 2000.
“Mario Draghi wrote in a report last month that The European Union today faces "an existential challenge" and if it doesn't change, it will be condemned to "a slow agony." He wrote that "Real disposable income per capita has grown almost twice as much in the United States as in Europe since 2000," and, as things stand, there's no reason for this downward slide to stop.”
Economist Thomas Palley argues that the export-led growth model stopped working after the 2008 financial crisis because of changed conditions in both developing and developed economies: high debt in the United States, fiscal austerity in Europe, and supply-side stimulus in emerging markets led to a global demand shortage.
“The Economist Thomas Palley argues that there are reasons to believe that the export-led growth model stopped working after the 2008 financial crisis because of changed conditions in both developing and developed economies. High debt in the United States, fiscal austerity in Europe and supply side stimulus in emerging markets led to a global demand shortage.”
In 2020, renewables overtook fossil fuels for the first time in Europe to become the leading source of power, but wind and solar power cannot generate enough power to account for 100% of demand year-round even in the most favorable climate conditions.
“In 2020, renewables overtook fossil fuels to become the leading source of power in Europe for the first time ever. But wind and solar power are incapable of generating enough power to account for 100 percent of demand year-round, even in the most favorable climate conditions.”
With energy prices likely to stay high for a while, 2-3% of Germany's industrial companies using energy-intensive processes will likely relocate abroad, according to the chief economist of Berenberg private bank.
“The chief economist of Berenberg, a private bank told the economist last year that, with energy prices likely to stay high for a while, 2-3% of Germany's industrial companies that use energy-intensive processes will likely relocate abroad.”
Natural gas prices are three to five times higher in Europe than in the United States, and industrial electricity prices are two to three times higher in Europe than in the US and China, representing a persistent competitive disadvantage for European manufacturing.
“Natural gas prices are three to five times higher in Europe than they are in the United States and electricity prices – specifically those for industrial sectors – are currently two to three times those in the US and China. Now, European energy prices have always been higher, but this issue has worsened over time.”
Part of the case made to European voters skeptical of green transition was that it would do more than fend off climate change—it would make Europe less dependent on Russian gas and create lots of new green tech jobs.
“Part of the case made to European voters who were skeptical of the need for a green transition was that going green would do more than just fend off climate change. It would make Europe less dependent on Russian gas and create lots of new green tech jobs.”
The industrial share of GDP only declined slightly in 2022 and 2023, indicating that the current industrial troubles should be seen within the context of a broadly weak economy, and this is not deindustrialization but rather cyclical weakness.
“He points out that the industrial share of GDP only declined slightly in 2022 and 2023 indicating that the current industrial troubles should be seen within the context of a broadly weak economy, and this is not deindustrialization.”
After a big spike in 2022, wholesale gas prices fell back to 2018 levels, indicating the problem was not the loss of Russian gas but rather the post-pandemic rebalancing of global demand from manufactured goods (Germany's specialty) toward services, which was unfavorable for Germany's economy.
“After a big spike in 2022, wholesale gas prices fell back to 2018 levels – they say that it was not the loss of Russian gas - but that the post-pandemic rebalancing of global demand from manufactured goods – which Germany specializes in - towards services was unfavorable for Germany's economy.”
Restructuring toward domestic demand-led growth may impact emerging markets much more than Europe because they may not be able to rely on the United States to absorb their excess production the way they could in the past.
“This might impact emerging markets much more than Europe as they may not be able to rely on the United States to absorb their excess production in the way they could in the past.”
UK labor unions are arguing that green policies are hollowing out working-class communities and that the government needs to stop decarbonization through deindustrialization.
“Labor unions in the UK are arguing that green policies are hollowing out working class communities and that the government needs to stop decarbonization through deindustrialization.”
German industrial production has contracted by 14% since its peak and is now back to a level last seen in 2006, excluding the sharp pandemic decline, with the output trend moving downwards since 2017.
“Since its peak, German industrial production has contracted by 14% and it is now back to a level last seen in 2006 (if we exclude the sharp decline seen globally during the pandemic). This manufacturing downshift can be seen when factories are shuttered or firms reduce headcount, but it also shows up more subtly when firms scale back their expansion and investment plans or decide to grow their operations in other parts of the world.”
US companies have seen earnings per share grow 290% since 2010 while European earnings only grew 60% over the same period, demonstrating that superior US stock market performance is not merely a valuation phenomenon but reflects genuine earnings divergence.
“US companies have seen earnings per share grow 290 percent since 2010 when European earnings only grew 60 percent over the same period.”
Industrial production fell by 2.2% in the eurozone and 1.7% in the European Union year-over-year, with all four largest economies (Germany, France, Italy, Spain) recording year-on-year drops in capital goods and consumer durables production.
“Eurostat data released last month shows that industrial production fell by 2.2% in the eurozone and 1.7% in the European Union over the prior year. Germany, France, Italy and Spain (Europe's four largest economies) all recorded a year-on-year drop in the production of capital goods and consumer durables.”
Denmark had the fastest industrial growth in Europe—up almost 20% over a twelve-month period driven by its booming pharmaceutical industry which has produced popular weight loss drugs and an mpox vaccine.
“Denmark had the fastest industrial growth in Europe – up almost 20% over the twelve-month period driven by its booming pharmaceutical industry which has produced popular weight loss drugs and an mpox vaccine.”
Europe has a highly educated workforce capable of high-tech production and innovation, and unlike some critics, the speaker does not expect the continent to turn into a museum or become a green energy version of Easter Island where it keeps buying solar panels from China until the economy grinds to a halt.
“There are lots of challenges ahead for Europe – as there are for the rest of the world too, but Europe has a highly educated workforce capable of high-tech production and innovation. Unlike some of the critics, I don't expect the continent to turn into the worlds museum or become some sort of green energy version of Easter Island where they keep buying solar panels from China until the whole economy grinds to a halt.”
Sending electricity to areas where it's needed requires expensive grid upgrades, energy storage requires expensive battery packs or hydrogen systems or hydro-pumping infrastructure, and all solutions can be held up for years in planning, making it disingenuous to claim renewables are cheap without including infrastructure costs.
“The problem with those solutions is that sending electricity to places where it's needed involves expensive grid upgrades, storage involves expensive battery packs – or building out hydrogen storage systems or systems where excess solar energy is used to pump water up a hill, and that water can be used later for hydro power when there is not enough solar energy – but once again all of this is expensive – and all of these solutions can be held up for years in planning. It is slightly disingenuous to claim that the renewables are cheap – if they only provide reliable power after a bunch of really expensive upgrades are made.”
The automotive sector employs 13 million people in Europe and accounts for 7% of total employment, so it is unsurprising to see the EU pushing back against massive subsidized imports.
“The automotive sector employs thirteen million people in Europe and makes up 7% of total employment in the region, so it's no surprise to see the EU pushing back against massive, subsidized imports.”
Volkswagen, Germany's biggest employer, announced plans to close at least three factories, eliminate thousands of jobs, and slash wages for tens of thousands of German workers, marking the first time in the company's history that it has closed a factory in its home country, with planned salary cuts potentially affecting as many as 140,000 workers.
“Last week Volkswagen – which is Germanys biggest employer - announced plans to close at least three factories, eliminate thousands of jobs and slash wages for tens of thousands of German workers. This would be the first time in the company's history that they have closed a factory in their home country and the planned salary cuts could affect as many as 140,000 German workers.”
China has overtaken Japan to become the largest car exporter in the world, with Chinese exports stepping up as its economy has slowed—China's leader's solution to dropping domestic demand was to manufacture the same amount of goods as when the economy was booming and export the surplus.
“I made a video about a year ago on how China overtook Japan to become the largest car exporter in the world. Chinas exports have been stepping up as its economy has slowed – as its leader's solution to a drop in domestic demand has been to manufacture the same amount of goods as when the economy was booming and export the surplus.”
The European Commission imposed tariffs of up to 35% on Chinese electric vehicles on top of the existing 10% duty in response to massive, subsidized Chinese EV imports.
“As a result, the European Commission, imposed new tariffs of up to 35 per cent on Chinese EVs on top of the existing 10 per cent duty.”
Volkswagen symbolizes Europe's industrial challenge as it struggles to compete with foreign rivals, balance demands of shareholders, unions and government, manage high energy costs, and grapple with an expensive transition to greener technology that end customers are not necessarily demanding.
“It could be argued that Volkswagen can be seen as symbol of Europe's battle for industrial relevance as it struggles to compete with foreign rivals, balance the demands of shareholders, unions and government, deals with high energy costs and grapples with an expensive transition to greener technology that its end customers are not necessarily demanding.”
The European Commission rejected Spain's appeal against the marginal pricing system, arguing that other systems like a pay-as-bid approach have been analyzed and actually led to higher energy prices where they were implemented.
“The European commission have rejected their appeal saying that other systems like a pay-as-bid approach have been analyzed and actually led to higher energy prices in places where they've been implemented.”
Volkswagen's emissions cheating scandal in 2015 tarnished its reputation with customers, regulators and investors.
“Volkswagens emissions cheating scandal in 2015, tarnished its reputation with customers, regulators and investors.”
Volkswagen's focus on manufacturing expensive SUVs and exporting to China has not worked out.
“Its focus on manufacturing expensive SUV's and exporting to China has not worked out.”
Almost every problem with Volkswagen is summed up by its new electric bus, which has numerous design failures including wrong front design, inadequate branding, wrong roof design, wrong wheels, hybrid rather than pure EV, and overpricing at $70,000 for a minibus.
“I would argue that almost every problem with Volkswagen is summed up with it's new electric bus... Firstly they got the front wrong – it needs to look like the original one… We'll need a bigger logo next, then they got the top wrong – we need all those windows back… We need to get the wheels right next, and this doesn't make a ton of sense if you are taking family trips – it should probably be a hybrid… And of course – this is the worst part… Seventy thousand dollars… It's a minibus – not an s class…”