
WBD Live in Miami - The Money Printing Debate with Jeff Snider and Lyn Alden
What this covers
This is a live-staged debate hosted by Peter McCormack, with Jeff Snider of Atlas Financial Advisors and Lyn Alden, a macroeconomist, on opposite sides of a question that shapes the rest of the hour: is quantitative easing (QE)) really money printing? Alden describes QE as an asset swap whose effect depends on whether the money reaches circulation, through fiscal deficits or bank lending. Snider argues that the binding limit is not bank reserves but banks' capacity and willingness to take on settlement liability. He points out that before Lehman Brothers the system held almost no reserves, and that $4 trillion in reserves has not ended the dollar shortage.
The middle of the conversation turns to history and market plumbing. They disagree about March 2020. Snider says the Treasury market did not break; the dollar system seized up, and foreign reserve managers sold off-the-run Treasuries. Alden points to the Dollar Claims Mismatch, citing a ratio of roughly 64 to 1 between dollar claims and reserves before 2008. They also cover why the eurodollar system grew up outside regulation, why the dollar became dominant through network effects rather than hardness, and how gold gave way to faster claims once telecommunications improved. The Bank of England's September 2022 gilt episode and the Basel III rules, which Alden says push banks into government bonds, serve as examples of regulators fighting the last war.
The last part asks what better money would look like. Alden favors a hard, fast, fixed-supply system such as Bitcoin, which she argues makes excess debt difficult to build. Snider prefers money whose supply adjusts to demand. They also ask whether a fiat system needs a central bank at all, and whether Bitcoin can overcome the dollar's head start. Audience questions cover international banking rules, the elasticity of money, rule of law, and whether bail-ins could work. Alden's view is that a bail-in leaves the liquidity problem unsolved, because someone still has to buy the equity from depositors who want to leave.
Snider and Alden debate whether QE constitutes money printing, but both agree the eurodollar system is fundamentally broken; the real issue is whether money supply is constrained by central bank reserves or commercial bank capacity and willingness to create credit, which determines whether QE is inflationary.
- QE is only inflationary when combined with fiscal spending that puts money into circulation; absent commercial bank lending or fiscal transfers, QE remains a sterile asset swap
- The limiting factor in money creation is not central bank reserves but commercial bank liquidity constraints and their willingness to extend credit, making the eurodollar system dependent on private bank behavior
- Money is what actually circulates in the economy, not the monetary base; central banks cannot force circulation, so QE effectiveness depends entirely on whether commercial banks choose to lend
This asset isn't compiled yet
You're seeing its claims, ranked. Compile it to build the argument threads, weight them, and check each claim against your library — the full view.
The banking system is fundamentally based on faith that not too many depositors will request their funds back simultaneously; when over 100 trillion dollars of assets (stocks, real estate, bonds) exist but far fewer actual dollars are available, a systemic liquidity crisis occurs if more than a small percentage of asset holders try to convert simultaneously
“if you're running a bank, you're kind of running a base on based on faith uh that not too many people are going to come back and ask for dollars back at the same time where you're holding all of these illiquid securities”
The eurodollar system was created and flourished because financial institutions were incentivized by banks to facilitate offshore dollar lending, and it has been successful precisely because banks operated outside regulatory constraints that would have limited their profitability
“one of the reasons why the euro-dollar system was so successful to begin with was to get out from under regulations cuz there's always some place else you can go. But politicians can't let the public know that cuz then it would sound like that we they have absolutely no control and authority”
The dollar became the dominant global currency not primarily because it is 'harder' than alternatives, but because of network effects: the US was the largest economy post-WWII with geopolitical power, and the dollar became widely available through banking networks that other currencies lacked
“the dollar system pervaded everything. It penetrated everywhere precisely because the banks were incentivized to do that... the eurodollar became usable because it became available... if you don't have a currency that's available, it's not usable”
Every time government debt reaches 90-100% of GDP, the central bank becomes one of the largest buyers of government bonds because the market cannot absorb the debt issuance, requiring the creation of money to purchase them
“Every single time when a government gets over, say, 90 to 100% debt to GDP, one of the biggest buyers of the government bonds becomes a central bank. And it's because you start to get so lopsided in terms of how many debt securities are in the market versus how much money's in the in the market, that you need to create more money to buy those bonds”
In March 2020, the problem was not that the Treasury market broke down, but that the dollar system seized up due to a massive dollar shortage, which forced foreign reserve managers to sell off-the-run Treasuries they had parked for long-term holdings; the on-the-run market remained relatively liquid
“foreign reserve managers parked their reserve assets because they don't trust the Fed and they don't trust the Eurodollar system, nor should they in either one. They parked their assets in illiquid off-the-run Treasuries because they don't need to be liquid. You're just holding them until maturity, recycling through them. Maybe you have to sell one every once in a while. And in March 2020, as you pointed out, because of a massive dollar shortage, reserve managers had to suddenly sell these Treasuries in which there was no ready market available for them. So, the Treasury market didn't break down, the dollar system did, which precipitated the selling. The on-the-run market was still functioning relatively well because the on-the-run market was where all the demand was”
The problem is not a shortage of bank reserves but a shortage of bank capacity and willingness to take on settlement liability; banks have internal constraints (volatility, capital, liquidity) that prevent them from expanding even when reserves are abundant, which is why 4 trillion in reserves has not solved the fundamental dollar shortage
“there's a shortage of bank capacity, or really banks willing to take on that settlement liability. So, it's a shortage of banks, not a shortage of bank reserves”
Just before the 2008 financial crisis, the ratio of claims on dollars (debt) to available bank reserves was approximately 64 to 1, meaning 64 times as many dollars were contractually owed to security holders as actual dollars existed in the system
“I think there were 64 Like, if you look at how much debt was in the system compared to bank reserves, there was like a ratio of like 64 to 1. So, there's like 64 claims on dollars just from debt, let alone equity, just from debt, like dollars that are literally contractually owed to you in the future at a ti- at a at a specific time. There were 64 times as many dollars owed to security holders as there were dollars”
Commercial banks have historically not needed bank reserves; before Lehman Brothers, there were practically no reserves in the system (less than 10 billion), and banks settled transactions using their own private liquidity mechanisms and correspondent banking
“commercial banks don't need reserves. If they were free from constraints, they wouldn't need any reserves at all. They would just use the same forms of liquidity that they used for decades. That's why there were practically no bank reserves in the system before Lehman Brothers. It was never more than 10 billion, because commercial banks settled based on their own practices”
Money is fundamentally an emergent phenomenon; even when governments create fiat currencies top-down, some currencies are globally accepted and others are not, based on free market choices by users (e.g., Egyptians choosing to hold dollars over Egyptian pounds)
“I think I think that's where I I go to the Austrian view that money is an emergent phenomenon. And even when you have top-down designs of money, like fiat currencies, it's not an accident that some of those monies are accepted in other countries and ones are not. So, there's a reason that the dollar is accepted more places than the yuan. There's a reason that, you know, like the Nigerian currency is not accepted everywhere. Um there's a reason that certain currencies are accepted more often than others and it's because those are actually kind of free market choices”
The UK gilt crisis in September 2022 occurred because the Bank of England announced QT (quantitative tightening) while simultaneously the government announced a larger budget deficit; foreigners and UK pension funds holding gilts on leverage were forced to sell, creating a liquidity cascade that the central bank had to reverse
“the worst example was hap- was was what happened in the UK, where they come out, there's high inflation, they're try- they're about to pivot and start doing QT. And then they come out and say, "Hey, we have this new budget, bigger deficits, we're going to issue a ton more gilts, uh UK sovereign bonds." The market throws an absolute fit, yields spike, but then of course, the problem is that all these pools of capital hold these assets on leverage, all these pension funds. So, they have to start selling”
A bail-in system (converting deposits to equity) would not solve the underlying liquidity problem because it still requires someone to buy the equity from depositors who want to exit; if all depositors want to sell simultaneously, there is no solution unless liquidity exists elsewhere
“you still have the liquidity problem. I think that's a no... you now own a basket of securities that is supposed to pay you dollars or euros in the future. And the question is, where do they get those dollars and euros from? There's still more claims than there are underlying units. And then two, to his point, if everyone wants to sell If people don't want to hold that equity, they don't want to hold that. Nobody's going to hold And so, when they sell it, the question is, who's got the dollars or who's got the euros to buy all those claims from?”
Fractional reserve banking emerged as a solution to the problem of physical settlement and speed mismatch between gold transfers; banks discovered they could issue claims on gold (deposits) and have those claims settle faster than physical gold, creating a faster money system
“they basically increased the the it reduced the friction and the verification of moving gold around or other types of of foundational money. So there was kind of this like increasing type of technology is kind of proto-banking and then full banking to try to speed up the fact that we just had limited the physical qualities of money were limited”
Gold was the dominant global monetary system until telecommunications technology was developed (submarine cables in the second half of 1800s), which allowed faster settlement and settlement-speed arbitrage that made gold-backed currencies (like the pound and dollar) preferable to physical gold
“people were on a gold standard. Gold is harder money than the dollar. You know for most of commodity money history harder money kept replacing softer money. So you know you you kind of went up the the stack and you found gold was like the hardest money. And then why was it beat by the dollar and to some extent the British pound which was technically a softer money. And one of the answers was speed. So when they when they made the telecommunication systems in the second half of the 1800s they laid down the sea cables. All these banks from around the world could communicate with each other. And gold was super slow”
The problem with the current monetary system is not that QE itself is flawed, but that regulators perpetually fight the last war by imposing rules that inadvertently create new vulnerabilities; Basel III required banks to hold more Treasuries, making them vulnerable when Treasury yields rose
“regulators are usually fighting the last battle. So if a fire happened they want to put out the fire and they want to make sure that type of fire didn't happen again. Whereas the problem is that usually the next fire comes from something they're not expecting. Right? So it's kind of like this current environment where they said hey banks should hold more treasuries and then now ironically treasuries are what's giving them like a problem”
Banks could theoretically borrow in repo markets against illiquid assets (like Treasuries) rather than relying on deposit runs or Fed support; SVB could have done this, but apparently did not, suggesting either repo markets were unavailable or banks had lost confidence in the collateral
“All you really need to do, if you have a bunch of illiquid assets on your book, is liquidate them. Package them in some form of collateral package, go to Goldman Sachs and say, "I want to swap Treasuries and borrow funds in the in the repo market." Why didn't they do that? Why didn't SVB go to the Federal Reserve?”
QE is not money printing in the conventional sense; it is an asset swap where the central bank creates bank reserves and exchanges them for government bonds, but the critical question is whether commercial banks then circulate that money through lending
“QE is basically when the central bank creates more bank reserves, and then swaps them for some sort of asset, usually a government bond, or mortgage-backed security”
During the COVID crisis in March 2020, there was a massive spike in both bank deposits and bank reserves because the government issued stimulus and the Federal Reserve monetized it; this injection of money to consumers without pulling it from elsewhere created genuine monetary expansion in circulation
“during COVID, there was a huge spike in um bank deposits. So, not just bank reserves, but bank deposits. And so, if you you know, there were people, for example, you're working as a school teacher, you had $10,000 in the bank, the government sends you money, it shows up in the bank. Now, if that was not financed by QE, it'd be coming out of other bank reserves somewhere, or it'd come out of bank deposits and bank reserves. But because they were able to inject that with now without pulling it out of anywhere else, they actually increased the amount of broad money in the system”
In a fiat currency system, a central bank is technically necessary because a fiat currency by definition is a liability of the central bank (in physical form or as bank reserves); without a central bank, there would be no defined unit of account for the system
“when the dollar was created it was defined as a certain amount of silver... when it shifted over to the fiat currency system basically a dollar is defined as like a liability of the Fed in one way or another either physical form or bank reserve form. And so obviously Bitcoin you don't need a central bank. A Bitcoin is a Bitcoin is backed up by energy of from the miners and is backed up by the nodes. But if you try to run a fiat currency system without a central bank that's kind of a challenge”
The 1792 founding of the US dollar provided a centuries-long network effect and trust foundation that gave the dollar a massive head start that Bitcoin, despite technical superiority, cannot easily replicate without comparable geopolitical advantages.
“when the, you know, dollar was defined, right? So, it's like these you had this long build-up network effect in the United States”
Money printing only occurs when QE is combined with large fiscal deficits that directly transfer money to consumers or businesses, causing that money to circulate; QE alone without fiscal stimulus is not inflationary because the money never enters circulation
“if you're just doing QE without super large deficits, or if there's loan destruction like defaults that are happening that are bigger than the deficits, then it won't be inflationary, because you're not just sending money to people. The biggest kind of combo that really becomes money printing is when you have a very very large fiscal deficit, especially ones that are direct to, you know, not the top 1%. If you're actually sending people PPP loans to turn into grants, if you're sending them stimulus checks, and then you're financing that by QE”
The eurodollar system persists because it combines slow devaluation (attractive to borrowers who want to buy real assets and deleverage over time) with opaqueness (which allows continued expansion of credit), creating a profitable niche even as the system becomes increasingly unstable.
“if you have a currency that devalues slowly, like a developed market fiat currency, then lenders want to lend in it because they can borrow it even cheaper, and borrowers want to borrow it to buy something harder or to to do something with it. And so, the combination of a gradually gradually devaluing currency and then the opaqueness and the fact that you can keep lending more of this into existence is been a really rough combination.”
A hard money system that is fast (like Bitcoin) and cannot be diluted makes it difficult for excessive debt to accumulate because the settlement medium is not elastic; combined with low debt, deflation becomes a non-problem, allowing for a stable, low-crisis system.
“if you did not have a highly indebted system, which I think you you would have if you had a money that's both fast and hard, so it's one that it can't be diluted, and two, it can be pulled around and verified very quickly when need be, it's very hard to build debt on top of that system. And when you have less debt, deflation's less of a problem.”
Financial regulation under Basel III and similar frameworks has become a mechanism to force pools of capital (banks, pension funds) to hold larger quantities of government bonds, effectively monetizing government spending through regulatory mandate rather than voluntary lending.
“Basel III does and and kind of similar types of regulation is it's like various ways to have banks and other financial institutions hold more government debt... they keep finding ways to have more types of pools of capital need to hold more government debt”
A 'perfect money' or ideal money would match money supply to money demand dynamically without creating friction; however, no such system exists, and speakers differ on whether a self-adjusting elastic system (Snider's view) or a fixed supply system (Alden's view) is preferable
“You want a system that's able to dynamically match money supply and money demand. Right? Because those are dynamic forces that change all the time. And the way to best most efficiently do that will lead to the best most efficient economic outcomes”
Bitcoin is already in the top 10 globally accepted currencies by saleability (ability to exchange for goods/services) despite being only 14 years old and having no local monopoly like the dollar or euro; the trend of acceptance is rising despite volatility
“Bitcoin's already in the top 10. It might be number five or something, but at the bare minimum, it's in the top 10. And that's despite the fact that it's a 14-year-old currency. And so, unlike the dollar, the euro, it doesn't have any sort of like local monopoly where it has this like dense like very dense degree of acceptance. I mean, maybe now El Salvador is an an exception. But you don't really have these dense areas of acceptance. Instead, it's it's a digital currency they can bring in many places around the world, especially urban cities, and it's already a top 10 currency by saleability despite no no monopoly, nobody enforcing it, and despite the fact it's still very young and the trend is up”
Elasticity in money supply has historically been used by policymakers to paper over deflationary problems caused by excessive debt, but the real issue is that fixed or inelastic money systems lead to black markets and non-monetary adjustments (firing workers) because prices cannot adjust fast enough
“fixed money systems do two things. First thing is they lead to huge black markets. So, you're always going to have quasi money floating around the edges of a fixed money system anyway... So, you're never going to have a can true fixed money system to begin with, but even assuming that you could, you're asking the system to adjust through prices, and usually the system doesn't adjust through prices. It adjust through activity. So, if you get into a deflationary period where the the monetary system is not elastic enough to expand, then what you end up having is entrepreneurs have to fire all their workers cuz they don't have the funds to pay them. That's why deflationary deflation and depressions historically go together”
In a non-fiat system (like the gold standard), central banks do not exist or are not necessary; the eurodollar market's best performance was when the Fed was essentially dormant and did not attempt to manage credit; central banks are political institutions masquerading as economic necessities
“central banks are superfluous in every single way. Um, even just the idea, set aside any functional differences that we have, just the idea that we need a public utility to manage either the supply of money or the price of money is just stupid. I mean, it's just literally stupid. And the reason the only reason we have it is not an economic argument so much as it is a political one”
Bitcoin represents the first alternative to centralized currency issuance that doesn't require trust in a specific institution or government; it automates rule of law through code rather than enforcement, allowing anyone to run a node and verify the monetary supply
“2009 represented kind of the first alternative that says hey you don't need to do that. But it's not like when it's born we can just all get it. You know it's not like world coin we can go around and scan everybody's eyeballs and give them all the currency. Instead it's like there's this emergent thing that's growing and the world has to slowly figure out what this is and decide whether or not they want to exchange other value for it”
In the current high-debt environment, people and governments fear deflation because it makes debt service harder in nominal terms; but in a low-debt system, deflation would be harmless or beneficial, suggesting that debt reduction is the first-order priority.
“when you have a really hard money, it makes it that that's impossible. And that's a good thing for the user perspective...when you have a very So, deflation normally is a good thing...so, you have this kind of like fiat systems or central planning systems, even even gold-based systems, when you have like a gold is the asset...all this credit creation happens, and then when [ __ ] hits the fan, it's never credit that's allowed to fully contract down to the amount of base money. It's that they decide they re- they redefine what base money is.”
Treasury auctions show liquidity stress through 'fat tails'—when the first securities sold in an auction and the last securities sold have significantly different prices, it indicates insufficient buyers and poor liquidity; this occurred in March 2020 and September 2022
“a sign of a successful auction is that, you know, when you're bidding the the Treasuries out, you know, the first price and the last price shouldn't be very different, right? Because it's kind of like there's there's plenty There's far more buyers than you're selling... When you have like a sloppy auction, there's like not enough buyers kind of, and it's like it's just like really shaky, there's bad liquidity, you get a long tail where like the final security sells for a much worse price than the initial security”
Bitcoin will gradually displace the eurodollar system as adoption grows and liquidity increases, making it less volatile and more stable; this process will not happen overnight but will occur as individuals (especially in developing countries) choose to hold Bitcoin instead of fiat or physical dollars
“I think that slowly over time displaces the system. You know, right now there are people in developing countries that just literally will hold physical cash dollars as one of their key mechanisms of savings. And I think that that over time becomes increasingly unworkable and undesirable compared to holding Bitcoin as as their, you know, long-term. And it And it's been in this state where it's it's very volatile because it's still very low allocated to globally. But I think as you get more and more adoption, and it becomes larger and more liquid and less volatile, people more and more people That kind of fuels itself because then more people view it as something reliable that they can hold”
Gold was successful as money because it obeyed 'rule of law with law being nature'—the supply of gold had immutable rules set by physics, not by human decision, making it trustworthy across jurisdictions and time periods
“gold was successful because it had a rule of law with law being nature. It was just the the rule of how physics works that made gold, you know, the supply of gold had a certain rules to it. It's not that humans decided It just had rules”
In a Bitcoin-based system, financial services companies would shrink in importance and move from the center of the economic system to the periphery, competing to provide useful services rather than extracting rents through regulatory arbitrage and political cover
“the idea is that banks or whatever their successor are move from the center of the system to the periphery. And they have to compete to actually perform useful roles in order to survive. Whereas today they perform rent seeking and political cover which is the opposite of what we want. So a non-bank world should be far more efficient because it moves banks to where they should be and makes them actually perform a useful role”
Central bankers deliberately mislead the public by claiming QE is money printing when it technically is not, because they want credit for economic growth they did not cause and want to obscure the fact that their policy tools have limited effectiveness
“nobody more than a central banker wants you to think that QE's not money printing. So, of course, the central banks are going to say it's not money printing”
High debt and economic growth correlate historically, raising the question of whether limiting debt would reduce growth; the counterfactual is unknowable—what would the world look like without 2008 but also without the pre-2008 leverage and growth
“is it worth it to limit the inevitable deflationary downfall to shave off economic growth on the upside? What What What would 2008 have looked like if if we didn't have a 2008, but we didn't have all the economic growth from the '80s and '90s forward? And that's really the argument I think”
Capital ratios and liquidity coverage ratios have repeatedly failed to prevent bank failures; banks failed in 2023 with 'sterling' (excellent) capital ratios and liquidity coverage ratios, showing these metrics are meaningless and regulators will simply invent new ones to maintain the appearance of control
“They created the capital ratios, and all these banks failed with sterling capital ratios. We created the liquidity coverage ratios and other things in Basel 3 and 1/2. Then we just had a bunch of banks fail with terrific sterling liquidity coverage ratio. They're going to come out in the next several years. I think there's a Basel 4 in the works now. They'll come out with the next several several years with a Basel 4 and 1/2 that will come up with some other metric that will be completely horse [ __ ] too”
Bitcoin can be accepted for payments in locations that don't accept it by establishing acceptance within approximately 3 minutes, demonstrating that adoption is constrained by willingness and infrastructure rather than technical necessity.
“If they don't accept Bitcoin, I can have them accept it within about 3 minutes. No, but you can. You can teach them to”