
Fareed Zakaria | Age of Revolutions
What this covers
This hour-long Commonwealth Club conversation pairs Fareed Zakaria, discussing his book Age of Revolutions, with Mustafa Suleyman of Microsoft AI as interlocutor. The history runs from the 17th-century Dutch, whose water management, tall ships, and joint stock companies Zakaria credits with ending a long flat stretch in human income, through the French and American Revolutions to the Industrial Revolution, which he frames as an energy revolution: steam engines doing the work of 1,300 horses. He contrasts the durable, bottom-up change of industrialization with revolutions imposed from above, and he argues the American Revolution was really a war of independence that left social structures intact.
The middle of the talk moves to the present. Zakaria notes that Obama's approval stayed flat despite recovery after 2008, and that voting now tracks the three G's better than income. He cites immigration figures (4% foreign-born in 1975, 15% today), America's rapid secularization, and the upheaval of women's roles as drivers of cultural backlash. Northern Europe's generous welfare states have not prevented right-wing populism, which he offers as evidence that economic fixes are not enough. He also notes that the 2020 Republican convention adopted no platform, and that Joe Biden's strong economic record has not shifted an election fought on cultural ground.
Several turns are contested. Zakaria argues that Roe v. Wade removed abortion from democratic bargaining and produced decades of backlash, while Europe settled around 14 to 15 weeks. He says Ukraine should prioritize anchoring itself in Western institutions over maximizing territory, pointing to Poland's growth since 1990 as the comparison. The conversation also covers AI and its pressure on journalism, and a focus-group result suggesting that a deepfake damages a politician's favorability even after viewers are told it is fake. Zakaria ends hopeful that the liberal international order can be revived.
Zakaria argues that modern politics has shifted from left-right economic division to open-versus-closed cultural division, and societies navigating rapid technological and social change face a choice between managed reform from the bottom-up or reactive backlash that destabilizes institutions.
- Post-2008 economic recovery did not correlate with rising approval ratings, suggesting economic models no longer predict political outcomes
- Cultural backlash to change (immigration, women's roles, multiculturalism) now drives voting behavior more than economic self-interest
- Successful revolutions are bottom-up (Industrial Revolution) while top-down efforts fail (French Revolution); modern democracies must navigate this tension
This asset isn't compiled yet
You're seeing its claims, ranked. Compile it to build the argument threads, weight them, and check each claim against your library — the full view.
Ten years ago, US politics began moving off the familiar pattern when despite economic recovery after the Great Recession by 2014-2015, President Obama's approval ratings remained flat, breaking the historical correlation between economic improvement and rising presidential approval that had held since polling existed.
“about ten years ago, I noticed that our politics seem to be moving off kilter... by 20 1415, it was absolutely clear the US had come out of it better than any other country in the world. Obama's approval ratings were absolutely flat, were not moving... which was a break from a pattern that had been around ever since polling existed, which was the economy got better, people's sense of the economy got better. President's approval ratings rose, and that just wasn't happening.”
Journalism faces a structural challenge from AI: AI trains on massive amounts of data produced by journalists and other experts, but then is able to mimic that content, raising profound questions about how journalism sustains itself when AI can generate similar outputs without the original investigative work.
“journalism, first of all has a structural challenge of relating to all of this, which is the you know, if you thought the model had been disrupted enough by by Google and Facebook and all of that, it's now going to get disrupted by A.I. in all kinds of different ways. And so there's big structural challenge, which, you know, how do you handle what what do you do about it? I trains on one a lot of data produced by journalists. But then what? Both by journalists, by writers, by historians, by experts, but then is able to mimic that that stuff and, you know, how do you.”
Assimilation in America happens so fast that the biggest challenge for immigrant parents is not how to get children to assimilate but how to hold onto a sliver of the old country, as children become Americanized breathtakingly quickly through unconscious social processes.
“My view, they will all be overcome, you know, as the parent of of three kids, you know, I can tell you the biggest challenge when you're raising, you know, and then I'm going into is raising his children is not how are you going to get them to assimilate to America is how can you hold on to a little sliver of the old country? You know, is there like little thing that they are going to they get Americanized so fast that it's breathtaking? I mean, that's something this country does unconsciously so well.”
Economic politics in earlier periods was largely based on income and occupation—blue-collar workers making less than median income generally voted left, while others voted right—but with the rise of cultural politics, people's voting behavior is now much better predicted by their positions on what Zakaria calls 'the three G's: God, guns, and gays' rather than by economics.
“the earlier Left-Right division was largely based on economics. It was, you know, you could tell how somebody would vote based on how much money they made and what kind of job they had. If you were blue collar and you made less than the median income, generally speaking, you voted left. And if you were the other way around, you voted right. And that was true in Europe. That was true in the United States. When we have had this rise of cultural politics, it's much more complicated. People's you can predict people's polling behavior based on where they stand on what I call the three G's God, guns and gays.”
The Industrial Revolution was fundamentally an energy revolution in which humans discovered how to use inanimate energy to power work for the first time, transitioning from relying on human or animal labor, with steam engines capable of doing the work of 1,300 horses and modern airplanes doing the work of 350,000 horses.
“The industrial Revolution was fundamental, really an energy revolution. It was it was really a revolution where for the first time human beings found a way to use inanimate energy to power their lives... the engine that what has it has designed is able to, as I recall, do the work of 1300 horses... And then you can go to Hyman Rickover, who calculated that a modern airplane does the work of something 350,000 horses.”
The Dutch phrase 'God may have created the world, but the Dutch created the Netherlands' reflects how water management and land reclamation were such significant achievements that the Dutch viewed their entire nation as a human creation through technological innovation.
“there's a wonderful phrase that the Dutch have. They say, God may have created the world, but the Dutch created the Netherlands because they reclaimed so much land that they felt it was really their their act.”
The Iranian revolution can be understood as 30-35 years of backlash to the Shah's modernization and dictatorship, showing how authoritarian modernization can trigger cultural and religious counter-movements.
“the Iranian revolution in the sense is at 30 years, we're in 35 years of backlash to the Shah's modernization and and dictatorship. You know, as a combination of the two”
Northern Europe has done an enormous amount in terms of redistribution, social safety nets, welfare states, and worker retraining while not hollowing out the middle class, yet it still has significant right-wing populism; Sweden's second largest party is derived directly from 1930s fascists, the Dutch have the populist Geert Wilders as probably the next prime minister, and France's Le Pen (whose party draws from a fascist past) would win if an election were held today—demonstrating that economic solutions alone cannot prevent cultural backlash.
“More and more concretely, as we've spent a lot of time trying to get the economics right, and I think that's very important. And I don't want to discount it at all. But I will point out to you that look at Northern Europe, which really has done an enormous amount in terms of redistribution, in terms of, you know, social safety nets, in terms of welfare states and worker retraining and looking after workers and not hollowing out the middle class. They still have right wing populism. They I mean, Sweden's second largest party now is a party that derives directly from the from the fascists of the 1930s. The Dutch have good builders as the probably next prime minister. This is a you know, probably on the furthest right of right wing populism. If France were to hold an election today, the polls tell us that Le Pen would win.”
In the last 30 or 40 years, there has been an explosion of globalization much greater than anything ever seen before, with China and India—representing 2.5 billion people—joining the world economy, compared to Japan's 60 million and South Korea's 30-40 million in the 1950s-60s, creating unprecedented social and cultural change alongside technological transformation.
“the explosion of globalization over the last 30 or 40 years, much more than anything anyone had ever seen before, I mean, you had take China and India just joining the world economy. That's two and a half billion people. You know, in the 1950s, maybe Japan came online that 60 million people, maybe South Korea of 30 or 40 million are now two and a half billion.”
In the Industrial Revolution, most people (95-98%) in the United States and Britain in 1600 were engaged in agriculture, but by around 1850 this had transformed into a world of workers, craftsmen, and tradesmen; this fundamental shift in the nature of work and economy had to force politics to change because it was enduring and came from the bottom up.
“In the industrial revolution, it completely transforms the world. It was a world of agriculture, you know, I mean, most people don't don't think about that. But 95, 98% of the people in in between the United States and Britain and say 1600 were in agriculture, but by I don't know, about 1850, you have a whole world of workers and craftsmen and tradesmen. You know, you've created an entirely different economy.”
The 2020 Republican National Convention had no platform for the first time in party history—the platform was one paragraph saying 'whatever Donald Trump says is the Republican Party platform'—and the convention did not invite a single Republican president or past nominee but reserved five primetime speaking slots for the Trump family, representing an unprecedented transformation of a major political party.
“the 2020 Republican National Convention. The Republican Party had no platform for the first time in its history. The platform was one paragraph that said whatever Donald Trump says is is is the Republican Party platform. It did not invite a single Republican president, former president, a single past Republican presidential nominee, but there were in primetime five speaking slots saved for the Trump family.”
A focus group shown a deepfake video of a politician engaged in compromising behavior and then told it was fake still showed a 30% drop in favorability toward that politician, suggesting that visual information has psychological power independent of logical debunking.
“an experiment they ran where they showed a bunch of people, a focus group, a videotape of a prominent politician... having sex, you know, some kind of adulterous sex... Then they tell the people that this was a deepfake, that this was a fake video. And then a few minutes later they asked them what is your opinion... there's a 30% drop in the favorability rating even after you tell them that this was a fake? Because at some level, you know, you you trust your eyes.”
The information age—where controlling the world of atoms (physical reality) is fundamentally unlocked by the world of bits and bytes (digital information)—is as big a transformation as the Industrial Revolution, and there is nothing else in human history quite as big as these two transformations.
“I would argue that the information age fundamentally unlocking the information, you know, creating a world of bits and bytes that controls the world of atoms is is as big. We've never. There's nothing other than the industrial revolution, nothing, nothing quite as big.”
In 1975, 4% of Americans were foreign-born; today that number is 15%; in Sweden it has risen from 2.5% to 22%, and Sweden has a higher proportion of foreign-born residents than the United States, as does Canada, yet the US takes 1 million illegal immigrants per year, which is more than the entire OECD put together.
“In 1975, 4% of Americans were foreign born. Today, 15% of Americans are foreign born. In Sweden. That number is something goes something like from two and a half percent to 22%. Sweden has more foreign born people than the United States, by the way. So does Canada, by the way. And I think so... the big story about immigration, the the rational story is the United States needs more because we are, you know, one of our greatest strengths compared to other countries around the world is that alone among rich countries, we are not in demographic doom. If you look at every other rich country, they basically look like Florida... the United States, on the other hand, takes 1 million illegal immigrants every year, which is more than the entire OECD put together.”
The Republican Party has won the popular vote only once in the last 24 years (2004 Bush), yet continues to pursue policies that appeal to the same base rather than trying to be more inclusive and adjust policy after losing popular votes, partly because of the Electoral College which masks the fact that they're losing.
“over the last 20 years, they have only won the popular vote one time in the last 24 years, 2004 Bush, Bush, v Gore. He lost the popular vote. Trump lost the popular vote... there would be in an effort to adjust policy and be more inclusive and all that. But because of two things... the Electoral College, which means you don't actually face the brunt. You know, I mean, there's something weird about the Electoral College where it doesn't make you realize you're losing your positions on popular.”
America has become dramatically more secular since 2007, with the percentage of people claiming no religious affiliation rising from near 0% to approximately 30% in 30 years, making the US by one count the 12th least religious country of the 50 surveyed, a dramatic shift from being the most religious among rich democracies.
“From 2007, America has become dramatically more secular. So the number of people who say they have no, you know, the nuns and or any snide nuance has dramatically gone up, roughly speaking, in 30 years from 0 to 30%. Now, the number of people who say they go to church by one count, the United States is today the 12th least religious country in the world, or at least of the 50 that were surveyed in that survey.”
Europe found compromise on abortion through muddling and democratic process, settling around 14-15 weeks in most countries, which has avoided the poisonous 35-year backlash that followed the US Supreme Court's Roe v. Wade decision, which extracted abortion from democratic politics and made it a constitutional right.
“Europe approached abortion, for example, in a very different way than we did. We had the court ruling, which essentially took it out of the realm of politics, made it a constitutional right, and it produced a 35 year massive right wing mobilization in reaction that elected Ronald Reagan... The Europeans muddled through and found a compromise around 14, 15 weeks in most European societies. And they have had none of that poisonous politics because they kind of worked it through the system. You know, it wasn't a case where it was decreed from on high. Then people felt that their you know, that they they had no voice in the process.”
The Supreme Court's Roe v. Wade decision and subsequent conservative backlash elected thousands of right-wing politicians and appointed many right-wing judges who have been ideologically extreme on issues far beyond abortion, creating decades of lasting political consequences beyond the original issue.
“probably elected thousands and thousands of very right wing politicians who then appointed all these right wing judges who, by the way, have been right wing in a whole bunch of other stuff entirely outside of abortion. So there's been a huge legacy beyond that.”
Human average income was essentially flat for 1700-2000 years until around the time of the Dutch rise in the 17th century, when it began to grow exponentially, rising from a few hundred dollars per capita GDP to approximately 72,000 dollars today, driven by Dutch innovation in water management, tall ships, financial instruments, and the first joint stock companies.
“the a wonderful historian, Angus Maddison, who's done this work for 1700 years, it's a flat line... And for everything we know, if we have been able to go back another 5 to 2000 years, we've been that and then around the time of the Dutch, the rise of the Dutch, you start to see it go and then it goes, It's a hockey stick and you go from about a few hundred dollars per capita GDP to now, you know, we're at 72,000.”
Women having been second-class citizens or the property of men throughout almost all of human history until a few hundred years ago represents an enormous transformation of society, particularly when considering that this change affects the family—the basic unit of society—and fundamentally alters power structures within it, thus inevitably producing backlash.
“Every society in human history going back thousands and thousands of years, some group is on top, some group is at the bottom... But in all of them, women were second class citizens. In almost every society in human history, women have been the property of men until a few hundred years ago. Right. And basically in the last 40 years, I would say that finally changed... But the but think about what an enormous transformation that is. Right. And you're taking something that was the basic unit of society, the family, and changing the dynamic, the power structure within that within that unit. That's big change. And so it is going to produce a backlash.”
The American Revolution was not a true revolution in the sense of a fundamental transformation of society, because it was primarily a war of independence that preserved existing social and economic structures—the Declaration of Independence was about restoring lost rights of Englishmen rather than creating new ones, and feudal structures in both North and South remained intact.
“I argue that the American Revolution is not really a revolution in that sense. Why do I say that? It was a war of independence... what people were asking for the revolutionaries themselves was a return to the rights of Englishmen that were enjoyed before George The third usurped them... The social structure did not change at all. In fact, in the South, the deeply feudal slave structure was kept entirely intact in the north. The feudal structure was kept entirely intact.”
The fundamental goal for Ukraine should be to become anchored in the West and part of Western economic and security structures, which is more important than whether it achieves this with 86% or 94% of its territory, suggesting that institutional integration matters more than territorial maximalism.
“the goal of Ukraine should be to be part of the West, whether it does it with 86% of its territory or 94% of its territory, seems to me a less important goal. The goal of being anchored in the West in some sense part of the economic and security structures of the West. That should be the goal.”
Ukraine and Poland started with the same per capita GDP in 1990-1991, but Poland is now 4.5 times wealthier because Poland joined the European Union and NATO while Ukraine remained in Russia's sphere, demonstrating the material and political benefits of liberal democracy and Western institutional integration.
“1990, 1991, when the Soviet Union collapses, Ukraine and Poland have the same per capita GDP. Poland goes west, becomes a member of the European Union, becomes a member of NATO, reforms its economy, reforms its politics. Ukraine is not able to do that... Today, Poland's per capita income is four and a half times that of Ukraine. They started it in the same place in 1990.”
Biden has managed the economy competently and the US economic performance is objectively strong (unemployment at 50-year lows, inflation at ~3%, manufacturing up, inequality declining, Black labor force participation now exceeds white participation for the first time), yet the 2024 election is being fought on cultural issues (immigration, multiculturalism) where Democrats are playing defense.
“Biden has frankly done an extraordinarily good and competent job in managing the economy. We have come out of the COVID, you know, recession or whatever you want to call it, much better than any other major economy in the world. The US is you know, is the statistics are actually almost stunning. We have unemployment at the lowest it's been in 50 years. Inflation is now down to about 3%... But black participation in the labor force is now slightly higher than white participation in the labor force. That has never happened before. Inequality has gone down for the last four or five years running.”
People who see immigrants and are afraid are not necessarily racist but are experiencing fear about their world going away, and this fear is legitimate even if the underlying premises may not be empirically sound, so Democrats need to address this fear rather than dismissing it as racism.
“you know, they see somebody who's different and sounds different and worships different gods and they get scared and, you know, don't always st that is racist. That that is somebody is fear of that world going away.”
The goal of DEI bureaucracies should be to eliminate themselves, with the ultimate aim of reaching a colorblind society, a standard that progressives have failed to articulate, leaving them vulnerable to the charge that they're obsessed with racial and gender categorization.
“the goal of all these D-I bureaucracies is to eliminate the bureaucracies. Like that has to be the goal that we want to be in a colorblind society. And we're not there yet and we need to work.”
Despite the narrative of middle-class stagnation in the West, most people have actually done better over the last 30-40 years when accounting for dramatic declines in the cost of living for technology, food, and clothing, plus government redistribution; however, there is deep cultural unease about the world we are entering that populists everywhere exploit.
“the truth of the matter is the data suggests that most people have actually done better over the last 30 or 40 years, particularly when once you put it in to take into account two important things. One is the dramatic changes in standards of living, decline of costs, for example, of technology, food, clothing. And the second is the degree to which you have been able to get government reduced to the redistribution... once you take into account income, after all, government redistribution is taking into account that that picture of middle class stagnation is not entirely true more.”
Currently, AI is mostly in the 'text-to-text' phase (question/answer with language models like ChatGPT), but the real transformation will come with the 'text-to-action' phase when AI directs software and hardware to actually change things on the ground, at which point job displacement will become severe.
“for the next few years I think we're still in the phase of trying to figure out how I transforms things. You know, right now we're still mostly in the kind of text to text world of AI, by which I mean I asked Chad GPT or Bart or Gemini I have a question. It answers me back something I'm dazzled by... But the real transformation is when you go from text to action, when you tell the AI to do something and it then interacts with some piece of software that then interacts with some piece of hardware and it actually changes things on the ground that I think we're still a bit of a away from”
The Democrats play at a disadvantage on cultural issues because they don't articulate the critique of identity politics excess, leaving room for Republicans to exploit that space with voters who 'see some of this craziness' in their world but don't hear it acknowledged by Democratic leaders.
“That I think the Democrats play at a disadvantage on this. But just take one more question that's related to this from the audience, which is how did the Republicans convince blue collar workers that it was actually their party? And what should Biden do to fight back? Well, it's the same thing, which is it was a wonderful book called What's the Matter with Kansas, which is basically making the case all these people are voting against their economic interests. But I would argue that, you know, it's slightly patronizing to think that like being being they're misguided. And if only they knew, because my guess is that almost everybody in this room is voting against his or her economic interests and have been doing that for a while.”
Donald Trump is a revolutionary figure seeking to take the country back to the 1950s (before 'uppity women' and before racial and ethnic diversity in positions of power), making him a 'reactionary revolutionary'—someone who calls for destruction and overturning of existing systems but intends to restore an imagined past rather than build something new.
“So he's a revolutionary who says, my goal is to take you back to the 1950s when before you had all these uppity women and all you seeing all these brownface black faces in these rooms, right? So this that something fast. And that is actually a pattern that a lot of people who think of themselves as revolution areas are actually reactionaries because at some level a counterrevolution is a revolution itself.”
Steve Bannon admires Lenin because both seek to destroy and break the system, though they differ in what they want to put in its place; the real question is whether the movement is forward or backward, which is what distinguishes a genuine revolutionary from a reactionary.
“Steve Bannon often talks about how he admires Lenin. Now the reason is, you know, again, Lenin's goal was to destroy was to break the system. Bannon's goal is also to destroy, to break the system, I suppose the changes the difference is what are you then trying to put in its place and is that a move? You know, that's why I say you can be just entirely analytic here. Is that a movement forward or is it a movement backward?”
The Republican Party has adopted a narrative of betrayal by its own elites that has produced successive waves of attempted destruction (Newt Gingrich, Tea Party, Trump), all rooted in the belief that if only leaders hadn't lied and compromised, the post-New Deal welfare state could have been dismantled.
“within the Republican Party, there is a narrative of betrayal that if only our elites, if only our leaders hadn't lied to us. And so it has become this this is what produced the Newt Gingrich revolution. This is what produced the Tea Party, the sense that we were betrayed by our own and we have to destroy the Republican Party. So the apotheosis of that is Donald Trump”
Working-class people voting against their strict economic interests is not necessarily irrational but reflects the reality that most people in the audience also vote against their economic interests, suggesting all people have multiple identities and values that override 'simple, crass calculation' of pure economic self-interest.
“it's slightly patronizing to think that like being being they're misguided. And if only they knew... almost everybody in this room is voting against his or her economic interests and have been doing that for a while. You are consistently voting for the party that is going to tax you more. Right. And if you are simply maximizing your economic advantage, you wouldn't be doing that. But you are you have many identities, you have many values and you know, some are some or outweigh that simple, crass calculation. So do they do you know, do working class people the honor of recognizing the same may be true for them?”
Politics in the West has shifted from a left-versus-right division (based on economics and income level) to an open-versus-closed division (based on cultural attitudes toward change, immigration, and tradition), and this shift makes compromise harder because economic trade-offs are divisible while cultural values feel binary.
“we are moving from a politics of left versus right to open versus closed”
After periods of rapid innovation and wealth creation, societies experience cultural backlash and politicians emerge promising to restore a mythologized past, as seen in the Netherlands in the 1670s with politicians saying 'make Netherlands great again,' and in modern times with Modi in India, Erdogan in Turkey, Xi Jinping in China, and Trump in the US.
“you get people start to say, you know, in the Netherlands at the time, you know, this is this is too much. We've changed our old ways. This is terrible. Let's go back to the good old days. And there are politicians who tell you they're going to take you back and make Netherlands great again”
Japan is the only rich country without significant right-wing populism, which the data supports because Japan does not accept immigrants (thus has no reactionary immigration backlash) and women's roles remain more traditional than other rich countries, suggesting that countries with less cultural change in these two domains experience less populist backlash.
“the one rich country in the world that doesn't have right wing populism where the same establishment continues to rule? You know, pretty much undeterred. It's Japan now. Japan has every problem that every advanced industrial society has except one They don't take in immigrants... And so they have no reaction to immigrants because they've basically don't take them in the first place. And by the way, the second point I would make is women's roles in Japan remain very traditional while there has been some progress. So if you think about those as two key drivers of cultural reaction, it's interesting to note that the one country, the one rich country that has not moved very far in that area has the same LDP party that has been ruling now for 75 years.”
As AI systems become more capable, their decision-making processes become less interpretable and understandable to humans, creating a situation where humans must trust black-box systems without being able to explain why they recommend specific actions, reverting to a pre-Enlightenment epistemology where 'the oracle says so.'
“as the AI gets better and better, we won't understand the answers it's providing we won't understand why it's doing what it's doing... you have to do these things and you don't know why. It's because the machine is telling you, the black box is telling you. And and the truth is, most AI research will tell you they're struggling to figure out exactly how the AI works. What are the weights being assigned in this neural network? And I the psychology of that is probably, you know, it almost takes you back to a pre enlightenment model where you say, why does the sun come up? Because there's a sun God, you know, In other words, you have some free, rational explanation for it. Well, why are we doing why are we following this path? Well, because the black box tells us we have to do it.”
The fundamental challenge for journalists in a fractured polity is that they practice public education, but cannot educate people who explicitly reject being educated and refuse to participate in shared fact-finding procedures.
“I think of journalism as public education. How do you do that with somebody with somebody who says, I don't want to be educated, you know? And so that's the bigger challenge”
The redistribution challenge posed by AI automation is that labor and the value it produces will be converted into capital that is manifested in intellectual property and bits rather than physical commodities, making it harder to redistribute wealth at the individual level without fundamentally rethinking national redistribution policy.
“labor and the value that labor produces is going to be converted into capital. And that capital in the past has been manifested in commodities, raw physical atoms that we move around in the universe. And in the future it's going to be manifested in bits. Yeah, and intellectual capital... and that really raises the question of sort of how do we redistribute the benefits of that over the longer term.”
Liberal democracy's challenge is that it offers individuals the freedom to pursue their own version of happiness, which is unsatisfying because people want to feel part of a larger project or cause, a role that religion, nationalism, and communism traditionally filled by providing transcendent meaning and justifying sacrifice.
“the essence of liberal democracy is it says to you, you know, how the church used to tell you what what the meaning of life was and what a good life was... the communists told you that... we in liberal democracies say that is your private affair. You pursue whatever you think is your version of happiness... And that's very unsatisfying, you know, because at some level people want that sense of being part of a larger project project.”
Successful revolutions that transform societies for the better are those driven by bottom-up change in economics and technology that then forces social and political structures to adapt, whereas failed revolutions like the French Revolution attempt top-down modernization imposed by political elites without underlying economic and technological drivers.
“The revolutions that seem to endure and that transform societies and transform them... are ones where you have this change that takes place from the bottom up. You know, you have economics, changing technology, changing societies, globalization spreading. And these changes are very deep, very structural. And they then change the social and political structures and the social and political structures have to adapt to this to this process.”
The intensity of feeling about cultural change is often more important than the aggregate numbers of people on either side, with closed/traditional groups feeling their world is disappearing intensely while open groups believe things are 'complicated but we'll muddle through,' creating an asymmetric emotional mobilization.
“It's the intensity of feeling often that is more important than the aggregate numbers on one side or the other... there's an enormous amount of open information system, open trade, open... that open side, there are a lot of people for whom this is this is deeply unnerving and it feels like their world is disappearing and their place in that world is this. And they feel this much more intensely than than the other side, which feels like, yeah, this is complicated, but we'll be all right. We'll muddle through.”
The election denial belief may not be primarily about literal conviction that fraud occurred, but rather a form of political refusal ('F-you') expressing unwillingness to participate in the established system and narrative, suggesting that institutional distrust is deeper than disagreement about facts.
“if you ask me why is it I don't even know that I'm completely confident that they actually believe the 2020 election was was was was fraudulent. I think it's their way of saying F-you, it's their way of saying we simply are not going to play your game. We're not going to buy into your narrative.”
Biden should make a 'Sister Souljah' moment speech arguing that multiculturalism has 'gone too far' with excessive 'slicing and dicing people on the basis of sex and race and color of skin,' and that the goal should ultimately be a colorblind society, to signal to non-college-educated and culturally conservative voters that Democrats understand their concerns.
“I think he should do a Sister Souljah like speech on the whole multiculturalism thing and make a case you know, make the case we want to down too far down this rabbit hole of slicing and dicing people on the basis of sex and race and color of skin and ethnic... we've gotten to a point where it's just it's all came out of a good place, but it's gone too far.”
Religious fundamentalism movements globally—from Islamic fundamentalism to Christian fundamentalism to the ultra-Orthodox in Israel—appear animated by the desire to put women back in traditional roles, and Xi Jinping has explicitly urged women to return to traditional roles and have more babies, showing that even authoritarian modernizers play on cultural unease about rapid change.
“if you look at the religious fundamentalism around the world, from Islamic fundamentalism to Christian fundamentalism to the ultra-Orthodox in Israel, they all seem animated by this one great desire, which is to put women back in the kitchen. Xi Jinping gave a speech recently in which he was he said women need to return to their traditional roles. They need to have more babies.”
Trump lies repeatedly about major issues (election fraud, etc.), but the bigger challenge for journalism is that his supporters don't care that he's lying and that refuting lies has no consequence, suggesting a deeper crisis of institutional trust where facts no longer compel belief.
“there is the familiar problem we now have, which is what to do about, you know, one candidate who's just going to lie. And what do you do, most importantly about the fact that the people who support him most ardently don't care that he's lying? That's actually a much bigger challenge because it's not that difficult to point out he's lying. The problem is you feel like a broken record having no consequence when it makes no difference.”
European nations will need to embrace the concept of strong nation-state redistribution to handle AI-driven inequality, which is more familiar in Europe than in the US, but the principle will need to be accepted globally.
“from a kind of European perspective, it's more familiar to talk about the centrality of the nation state being, you know, the source of redistribution. But I think we're going to have to get very comfortable with that the world over.”
There are two great dangers in navigating modern change: a right-wing reactionary counterrevolution that can undermine existing institutions, and a left-wing desire to push change too fast and too far by decree (like the Jacobins), which doesn't work because societies cannot digest that much change at that pace and instead lose the society.
“there are two great dangers. One is of a of a of a right wing reactionary counterrevolution, which can be very deep and undermine the entire structure of what has been in place. But there is also the danger of a left wing, overly zealous, you know, kind of French Revolution style desire to get to push as far as you can, as fast as you can, and to do it all by decree, because God knows virtue is on your side. You know, that is what the Jacobins did. And it doesn't work out very well because societies cannot digest that much change, that cannot take that pace of change.”
Deepfakes and generated media will enable novel forms of manipulation that are more dangerous at the subtle level (videos that don't explicitly lie but create false impressions through edited context) than at the obvious level (obviously fake videos of politicians).
“the subtle versions of the things I worry more about when you see Joe Biden saying something that, you know, he obviously didn't say maybe this they'll be reporting around it. But the things I worry about is so, for instance, the Republican response... was a video which was about the picture of rampant crime and lawlessness... It all looked very grim... the whole thing was computer generated and it looked like they were you know, they didn't set any point. We are, you know, the images are seeing are real images from America. But that was the implication. Right. And they were all made up.”
Biden needs to take a more symbolically aggressive stance on immigration by declaring a national emergency and sending the National Guard to the border (even if courts overturn it) to show that he is trying to address chaos, following Bill Clinton's principle that 'the American people don't always care whether you succeed, but they want to catch you trying.'
“Biden needs to be much, much more symbolically tough on him on immigration, by which I mean this, you know, largely a kind of a this is a this is a kind of show of force, a show of are you willing to deal the chaos of the border? Because the truth is, the Republicans are not giving him the tools he needs to actually make the structural changes. But you got to deal with that. You are president. And so I would declare a national emergency, go down, send the National Guard to the border... Bill Clinton once had a great line in politics. He said the American people don't always care whether you succeed, but they want to catch you trying”
Biden will confidently win the popular vote by at least 8 million votes in 2024, but this outcome might still be preordained to lose the election due to the Electoral College, highlighting how the US electoral system produces outcomes divorced from popular preference.
“what I think I can confidently predict is Joe Biden will win the popular vote by at least 8 million votes. Right. Which is a funny thing to think about. Like you, you know, he's going to win, which we in any other country would mean the outcome is preordained, but of course not in ours because we have this bizarre system.”
If the UK were to join the US as a state based on per capita income, it would rank 51st (below Mississippi), with UK per capita income of approximately 46,000 versus Mississippi's 47,000, illustrating the strength of US economic performance.
“if the UK where you you you spend much of your life. Mustafa the UK would have joined the United States as the 51st state on a per capita income basis, it would be 51st. Wow. It would be below Mississippi. Yeah, you can look this up. Mississippi's about 47,000. It is 46,000.”
Ukrainians are fighting the Russian invasion with undeterred morale despite horrendous battlefield losses (which they don't publicly reveal) because they do not want to be a Russian colony and want to be part of the West, suggesting that the desire for liberal democracy and Western integration is genuine and deeply held beyond material calculation.
“their morale is undeterred. I mean, they they will they will fight until the end because they do not want to be a Russian colony. They want to be free... And I from my reading of the situation, is their morale is undeterred. I mean, they they will they will fight until the end because they do not want to be a Russian colony. They want to be free and, you know, we should we should learn something from that.”
Trump is a shrewd character and a good salesman (though a bad businessman) who understands where people are; on abortion he has moved away from the extreme right-wing position of a federal total ban and is now saying let the states decide (14-15 weeks), recognizing this is a losing position for Republicans.
“Trump, who is who is a shrewd character, I mean, don't don't, don't he's a he was a bad businessman, but he's a good salesman and a good like any good salesman, he understands, you know, where people are. So on abortion, he has very much moved away from the, you know, the kind of right wing extreme view, which is that you want to have a federal ban, a total ban. He's more in the 1415 weaker and is trying to say let the states decide. And some states want to be more liberal. That's you know, that's because he can see that this is a losing position for the above for the Republicans.”
The Republican Party's two-seat House majority requires compromise, but the party is governing as if it has a two-thirds supermajority, which is a fundamental mismatch that prevents productive legislation.
“when you have a two seat majority, you have to compromise. I mean... it is trying to govern as if it is the you know, it has a two thirds majority in the House of Representatives when actually it has a two seat majority in the House of Representatives.”