What this covers

This is a moderated year-end conversation, recorded Dec. 12, 2022, between Jeff Gundlach of DoubleLine and Felix Zulauf of Zulauf Consulting, with DoubleLine's Sam Garza asking the questions. It opens with what 2022 taught them. Gundlach points to investment-grade bonds having their worst year on record, a roughly 50% drawdown in the 30-year Treasury, and a Federal Reserve (Fed)) that went from hesitant to four straight 75-basis-point hikes. Zulauf concedes that inflation overshot his own forecast of about 4% by a wide margin. From there the talk moves to inflation, geopolitics, the dollar, and where capital might go next.

The range is wider than a markets outlook. On the macro side, Gundlach cites inverted yield curves, including a global sovereign inversion, and a Deutsche Bank study linking tighter lending standards to high-yield defaults about nine months later, implying defaults near 8%. He also argues that real-rate analysis misleads because it ignores the quantity of money. On the geopolitical side, Zulauf describes a structural bifurcation of world trade toward China, Saudi Arabia's drift toward Beijing, and a permanent energy cost disadvantage for Europe. Gundlach questions how a heavily indebted U.S. can fund proxy conflicts with Russia and a commitment to Taiwan.

The most contested turns concern what central banks do next. Zulauf expects a policy pivot once recession arrives, with bond markets pushing back, and he treats the Liz Truss gilt episode as a preview of trouble from 2024. He calls the notion that central banks can print indefinitely a delusion whose reckoning lies beyond 2023. They disagree on whether negative yields could return: Gundlach won't rule it out, Zulauf rates it very unlikely. The closing stretch covers valuation and reversals of decade-long trends. Growth is lagging value, the NASDAQ is trailing the broader market, and U.S. leadership over foreign and emerging stocks may be ending. Zulauf adds that European equities look better to buy in the first half of 2023.

Sharpest takeaway

Gundlach and Zoltan argue that 2023 will bring a global recession with deflation in the first half followed by policy-driven reflation, creating a volatile but opportunity-rich environment where long treasuries and emerging market equities will outperform as inflation surprises downward then upward again.

  • Central banks tightened aggressively in 2022 but will pivot to stimulus in recession, driving a boom-bust cycle
  • Inflation will overshoot downward just as it overshot upward, creating duration opportunities in bonds
  • Dollar-driven commodity and EM underperformance are reversing as dollar weakens and geopolitical bifurcation accelerates

The claims · ranked66 claims · weighted by value

This asset isn't compiled yet

You're seeing its claims, ranked. Compile it to build the argument threads, weight them, and check each claim against your library — the full view.

0.75

The Ukraine war represents a fundamental geopolitical shift that clarifies the world has changed, with significant ramifications for global economy and inflation, which most analysts have not adequately considered.

factualhigh valuecontestednovelty 2/4durability 4/4· Felix Zulauf

“the war in the Ukraine Ukraine really made it clearer to many that the world has changed from a geopolitical standpoint and I think that is very important to keep in mind be taught because it has ramifications for the world economy and for inflation rates along with timeout and how the economies will function”

0.75

A Deutsche Bank study shows that the tightening of lending standards for commercial and industrial loans is highly correlated (high R-square) with default rates 9 months forward, and current lending standard tightening is consistent with high-yield default rates reaching around 8% within 9 months.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Jeffrey Gundlach

“they compare the standards that are reported The Lending standards on Commercial and Industrial loans and whether they're tightening or loosening and these are recorded from the lenders and uh they they move around and the chart shows the uh U.S high yield default rate uh nine months later so if when you go through tightening of lending standards significant you see an uptick in default rates uh it's pretty highly correlated the R square is very high uh to the default rates on high yield going up and the lending standards have tightened very significantly over the past I would say a year and a half and in particular you're now at a level of of lending standards tightening which is consistent with how you'll default rates of around eight percent or so nine months forward”

0.75

President Xi speaking at a recent Arab conference instead of the US President, and Saudi Arabia moving closer to China, are important geopolitical factors that investors don't account for in their analysis.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Felix Zoltan

“it was very interesting that just a few days ago there was the Arab conference in the Middle East and usually the U.S president holds is the keynote speaker and this year the keynote speaker was President XI from China and you also see that China has won uh Saudi Arabia has won much more closely to China to that camp and away from the U.S so there are things important factors in the world politically geopolitically changing that we do not take into account”

0.71

The geopolitical shift is structural: 20 years ago the world map was mostly blue (countries trading more with US than China) with only China and a few Asian economies in red; today most of the world is red (trading more with China), reflecting a fundamental bifurcation that will accelerate as US-China conflict intensifies.

factualhigh valuecontestednovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Felix Zoltan

“when you look at the map and you at the world map and you divide the world in two colors blue for the countries that do more trade with the US than with China and red with the countries that do more trade with China than the US 20 years ago the world map was essentially blue and you had one big spot in in red that was China and a few small Asian economies and that was it when you look at it today you have in blue North America Canada the U.S Middle America Great Britain um three countries or four countries in Europe and the rest of the world map is red”

0.69

Inflation is a lagging indicator, and central banks will clearly focus on fighting recession rather than inflation in 2023, making growth the priority and deficits acceptable during recession.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Felix Zoltan

“inflation is a lagging indicator so uh the central banks had forgotten that this year and and I think it's very clear that if the economy weakens to the degree I expect and we are in a serious recession that the central banks will focus on fighting the recession and not inflation that's very clear to me that that is no question about it”

0.69

The Fed moved from being almost scared to raise interest rates to suddenly raising 75 basis points four times in a row, a move that had less than one percent odds of occurring entering 2022 according to betting markets.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Jeffrey Gundlach

“the massive fed uh move from just being almost scared to raise interest rates to then suddenly going 75 basis points four times in a row I I think the odds entering 2022 the Fed was going to raise rates 75 basis points four meetings in a row I think you would have gotten odds below one percent is what a betting Market would have said”

0.69

Inflation in the U.S. rose to 9% and in Europe to over 10%, far exceeding the 4% forecasts that Zoltan and most economists expected, overshooting by at least 4 percentage points.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Felix Zoltan

“I was thinking about the four percent or even slightly above four percent and we went to nine percent in the US and ten percent over 10 percent in Europe uh that was dramatic”

0.69

Multiple leading economic indicators—yield curve inversion, unemployment approaching its 12-month moving average, and other signals—are flashing potential recessionary warnings, all consistent with falling inflation and economic weakness ahead.

causalhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Jeffrey Gundlach

“there's a lot of sets of weakness in the economy and so all of these things seem to gather together to suggest a lower inflation rate...the yield curve inversion perhaps we're getting close to to unemployment Crossing it's 12-month moving average I can go on and on”

0.69

For the first time in decades, there is a global yield curve inversion on the sovereign level, with an index of global sovereign yields inverted, and the US has a sustained massive inversion with the 10-year yielding 85 basis points less than the 2-year.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Jeffrey Gundlach

“for the first time in decades we actually have a yield curve inversion on a global global level there's an index of of global yield of global Sovereign yields and it's actually inverted first time ever I think and the United States of course is in a massive yield curve inversion which is sustained now for a sufficient period of time that suggests a recession I mean at these yield levels to have the 10-year treasury yielding something like 85 basis points less than the two-year treasury is is pretty remarkable”

0.69

At the inflation peak in 2021, there were nearly 18 trillion dollars in negative-yielding debt globally; today there is none outside of Japan, reflecting a dramatic shift in financial conditions.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Sam Garza

“at the peak we saw nearly 18 trillion and negative yielding debt today there's none outside of Japan”

0.69

High-yield bonds have never been repaid in the market since they emerged in the early 1980s—they either default or are refinanced, usually at higher spreads, so in a rising-rate environment they face significant pressure.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Jeffrey Gundlach

“has any high yield Bond ever been repaid in the in the market since it came into existence in the early 80s sort of no I mean either default or they refinance so what happens but suddenly you're you have to uh Finance yourself at higher rates at higher spreads”

0.69

Lending standard tightening is occurring not only in the US but also in Europe, as loan officers recognize deteriorating business outlooks and pull back credit availability (the 'umbrella in the rain' effect).

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Felix Zoltan

“the tightening of the landing standards is not only uh occurring in the U.S it's also a fact in Europe you know it's the same thing is going on in Europe and of course the the loan officers they see that the outlook for business is deteriorating and therefore they are taking the umbrella they are taking the umbrella back you know they give you the umbrella when the sun shines and they take it back when it begins to rain”

0.68

Three simultaneous inflation cycles are present: goods inflation, services inflation (related to US labor market), and geopolitical inflation (from Russia-Ukraine war disruptions), each with different characteristics.

definitionhigh valueestablishednovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Sam Garza

“we have these three Cycles going on we have Goods inflation we have the services particularly in the US which I think is very much related to the employment Market which we'll get to and then we have the geopolitics primarily the Russia Ukraine war”

0.68

Investment-grade U.S. bonds had the worst year in history in 2022, and the 30-year treasury bond experienced a 50% drawdown from its late 2021 high price.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 0/4durability 4/4· Jeffrey Gundlach

“bonds had the worst year for investment grade U.S Bonds in history uh the 30-year treasury bond had a 50 drawdown from its high price uh late in 2021”

0.68

If the Fed follows through on quantitative tightening and maintains a higher terminal rate while inflation has downside momentum, inflation will likely undershoot the consensus forecasts and decline below 2-2.5% at least temporarily, similar to how it overshot on the upside.

causalhigh valuecontestednovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Jeffrey Gundlach

“if the FED really follows through on its rhetoric if it really keeps doing quantitative tightening and if it really keeps going forward with a higher terminal rate that the rhetorically anyway are committed to keeping at that level for a significant period of time I've got a feeling that if these economists and if the CPI fixings in the market are correct and the headline CPI does make it down to two and a half or so I don't see any reason to believe it's going to stop there if you have that kind of momentum on the downside it's just not going to stop like your hip breaks on a car you don't just stop you know in your tracks right there that you have momentum going”

0.68

The energy sourcing change for Europe, particularly Germany, is structural and not cyclical, lasting for several years, and puts European domestic producers at a large cost disadvantage versus producers with reliable access to cheap energy, hurting European competitiveness.

factualhigh valuecontestednovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Felix Zoltan

“the change in energy uh sourcing for Europe and particularly Germany which is the largest economy in Europe uh is structural in nature not cyclical uh and that will last for several years which means that the German industry and several other European Industries have to pay multiple maybe three times as much for energy than you as producers and manufactures and I think this is weakening competitiveness”

0.68

The Liz Truss UK pension crisis and gilt market vigilante action in late 2022 was a 'foreplay' of larger bond market dynamics to come in 2024 and beyond, signaling that the perpetual government-central bank partnership is breaking down.

forecasthigh valuecontestednovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Felix Zoltan

“the problem we had in the British Market in the guild Market uh when uh Liz truss came out with her budget and the bond market Vigilantes uh killed that right away that was in my view just a foreplay of what we are going to see sometimes in 24 onwards you know beyond 24 and Beyond because I I believe that the perpetu mobile that um the central banks and the governments seem to believe to have discovered namely that they could underwrite the economy and print as much money as needed to pay for that debt that it takes that will not work that will backfire very badly that game is over”

0.68

The United States appears intent on fighting proxy wars with Russia and arming Taiwan, yet has chronic deficit problems that worsen with every recession, raising questions about how a 350-million-person nation can finance simultaneous conflicts with Russia and China.

factualhigh valuecontestednovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Jeffrey Gundlach

“the United States seems hell-bent on increasing the rhetoric of we're going to fight a proxy war with Russia which we're already doing and we're more than happy to apparently defend Taiwan or at least start buying weapon systems for them or we say selling them to them I got a feeling that uh going to be more like giving them to them and I don't understand how a nation with such uh chronic deficit problem that keeps getting worse with every recession response thinks with its 350 million people or so it's going to fight and finance a war with Russia which doesn't have that many people but they've got a lot of weapons and with China which has a lot of weapons and a lot of people”

0.68

Real interest rate analysis is misleading because it focuses on rate levels (prices) rather than quantity of money, which is the true driver of economic effects; Jay Powell pushes quantity of money aside in favor of rate pricing, but quantity sends a much bearish signal.

factualhigh valuecontestednovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Jeffrey Gundlach

“in real terms it's the biggest decline since the Great Depression that we have that we have... and you see that with many monetary Aggregates it's really a much more intense tightening that has been applied to the system than the um the markets or the economies the economic economies Community is aware of because many look at real interest rates and I think that is misleading and when you listen to Jay Powell he always refers to the prices price of interest rates price of money and he always pushes quantity of money to the site because the message by the quantity of money indicators is a very bearish one for the U.S economy”

0.68

Central banks and fiscal authorities will swing around (pivot policy) when they realize the world is in recession, stimulating again as they always do, which will create more excess liquidity; unlike before, the bond market is now aware of this problem and will resist by demanding higher yields.

forecasthigh valuecontestednovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Felix Zulauf

“I I believe that the central banks and all sorts of fiscal authorities will swing around when they realize that we are in a recession and they will stimulate again as they always do and unlike in previous periods this time the bond market is aware of the problem and the excess liquidity that is being created then by central banks will flow into scales assets”

0.65

The perpetual-motion-machine delusion (that central banks can underwrite the economy and print unlimited money to service debt) will not work and will backfire badly; this game is over, creating a problem for 2024 onwards, not 2023.

forecasthigh valuefringenovelty 3/4durability 3/4· Felix Zulauf

“I I believe that the perpetu mobile that um the central banks and the governments seem to believe to have discovered namely that they could underwrite the economy and print as much money as needed to pay for that debt that it takes that will not work that will backfire very badly that game is over and I think that's a problem for 24 and Beyond and not for 23. 23 you will have a recession and then the bond market has no problem uh for central banks to intervene and for budget deficits to grow the problem will come when the economy begins to uh uh turn around”

0.64

The UK is experiencing a pension crisis and faces a difficult dilemma: inflation is expected to be higher in the UK than in mainland Europe or the US, while growth expectations are worse, forcing central banks to choose which problem to address first (growth vs inflation).

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 2/4· Sam Garza

“a lot of people are looking at the UK as a Harbinger perhaps of things to come across a developed world uh well obviously we have the pension crisis a couple months ago and if you look at Global numbers and expectations for 2023 inflation is expected to be quite high in the UK higher than Mainland Europe and the US and growth is expected to be worse”

0.64

In 2022, the S&P 500 was trading at valuations in the top percentile or top couple percentile on virtually every metric—P/E ratio, CAPE ratio, price-to-book, price-to-sales—versus its own multi-decade valuation framework, making it highly overvalued at year start.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 2/4· Jeffrey Gundlach

“the S P 500 is a proxy for stocks the United States was so unusually overvalued versus its own historical evaluation framework so looking at uh p e ratio the cape ratio Price to Book price to sales all this there's actually a few dozen of these types of indicators they all showed the S P 500 was highly overvalued like top percentile or top couple percentile on virtually every metric versus its own multi-decade valuation framework”

0.63

Despite S&P 500 extreme overvaluation on traditional metrics, stocks were actually cheap relative to 10-year Treasury yields using the classic benchmark of yield-on-stocks (inverse P/E) versus Treasury yield.

factualhigh valuecontestednovelty 2/4durability 2/4· Jeffrey Gundlach

“it was cheap to the 10-year treasury using a classic Benchmark of the yield on the 10-year treasury to the uh inverse of the PE the yield on stocks was actually quite a bit below average was the S P 500 versus the 10-year”

0.63

Bond market has likely already seen cycle highs, and the Fed may deliver only 50 basis points in the current meeting and possibly no more hikes in the cycle.

forecasthigh valuecontestednovelty 2/4durability 2/4· Felix Zulauf

“I think the Bond Market has most likely already seen the highs for the cycle um and and we may we may all only see um 50 basis points this week by the fed and it may be the last hike in this cycle”

0.63

US stocks have outperformed emerging markets and foreign stocks by 4-4.5x over the past 10-15 years, but trend reversals are already evident: NASDAQ underperformed S&P, growth underperformed value, and European stocks (hedged for currency) and emerging markets are showing early signs of outperformance.

factualhigh valuecontestednovelty 2/4durability 2/4· Jeffrey Gundlach

“Felix mentioned that U.S stocks had outperformed foreign stocks emerging market stocks in particular for they'll pass basically 10 15 years non-stop by multiple times like four four and a half X or something like this versus Emerging Markets well I have a feeling that those Trends have already have already reversed and I talked about this two years ago when we saw the peak in the NASDAQ versus the s p the peak and growth versus value and all of these things are reversing even European stocks if you hedge out the currency are not underperforming the us anymore on a basket with Morgan Stanley index they actually modestly outperformed the last couple of years and it looks to me like Emerging Markets have also had their uh apogee of underperformance if you will versus the s p”

0.63

The Fed is currently tightening into a declining PMI (below 50), which is unprecedented in Zulauf's experience and strongly suggests global recession in the first half of 2023.

factualhigh valuecontestednovelty 2/4durability 2/4· Felix Zulauf

“for the first time as long as I can remember the U.S fed is tightening into a declining PMI indicator below 50. that's new I think all of that really suggests that we will have a worldwide recession in the first half of next year”

0.62

Negative yields are unlikely to return in the near few years, and the current decline in yields is a mini-cycle counter to the longer-term rising trend, so we won't see the lows again that were seen in the negative-yield era.

forecasthigh valuecontestednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Felix Zoltan

“I wouldn't like to go out that far so I I do not believe that the current decline in Marlins which is a mini cycle and it's counter to the longer term Rising Trend in yields and interest rates uh I do not believe that we will see the lows again that we have seen”

0.62

Buying Chinese assets is economically and monetarily justified but is foolish politically for US citizens because either the investments will be confiscated if successful or held with losses if unsuccessful—making Chinese equities a no-win situation.

normativehigh valuecontestednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Jeffrey Gundlach

“I would buy China for for for for for economic and monetary reasons but would you buy China for political reasons absolutely not as a U.S citizen I I think you have no way of winning in buying Chinese uh Investments because if they work they're going to confiscate them and so if they don't work we're holding the bag and if they work the Chinese are going to own them”

0.61

Central banks around the world realized they were 'far behind the curve' on inflation in 2022 and tightened very aggressively in response, contributing to bear markets in both stocks and bonds

causalhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Felix Zulauf

“central banks around the world realized that they were far behind the curve and then they tightened very aggressively uh and that gave us the bear Market in stocks and in bonds as well”

0.61

The copper-to-gold price ratio is a reliable indicator of 10-year Treasury yield fair value because copper rises with inflation (economic input) and gold is a flight-to-safety asset; the current ratio suggests 10-year Treasury fair value is around 2-2.5%, well below current levels.

factualhigh valuecontestednovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Jeffrey Gundlach

“our favorite starting point for the 10-year treasury of the United States which is the ratio of the price of copper to the price of gold the copper gold ratio and that's not an arbitrarily chosen commodity pairing it has to do with what drives the prices of copper and gold copper obviously is an important economic input and will go up with inflation and gold of course is a flight to safety asset at least at times and so the numerator going up correlates to uh 10 year yields going up and the denominator going up correlates to 10 years going down and right now uh the copper gold ratio is completely out of whack with where the 10-year treasury yield is”

0.60

The U.S. consumer is already on 'borrowed time', attempting to sustain spending levels by drawing on more debt while savings rates are already at their lowest possible levels

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 2/4· Felix Zulauf

“I think the consumer is already on borrowed time because he tries to sustain his level of of spending by drawing on more and more debt and and the savings rate is down as as far down as he can go”

0.60

There has been a 'buyer strike' in the bond market as prices kept declining, which is understandable, though this may reverse; the resulting market structure stress is very problematic given quantitative tightening and elevated bond issuance

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 2/4· Jeffrey Gunlock

“there's been a buyer strike understandably in the bond market because prices just go down until recently uh although that may reverse I I quite frankly I don't know”

0.59

Central banks have limited tools available: negative interest rates and free money (QE), and they have shown willingness to use both more brazenly each time crisis occurs, so negative yields are not impossible in the future.

factualhigh valuecontestednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Jeffrey Gundlach

“I I certainly think that it's possible um again there's the tools are so blunt and limited they've got negative interest rates and they've got free money and that's that's about it and they've shown every inclination to use them more brazenly every time it's needed so I I wouldn't rule it out”

0.57

The dollar has turned and is in a medium-term correction; it may bounce in the next few months into Q1, but after that bounce the dollar is due to decline into 2024.

forecasthigh valuecontestednovelty 1/4durability 2/4· Felix Zoltan

“I think the dollar has has turned and we have we have a medium term correct action in place I think in the next few months next first quarter the dollar will try to bounce and whether it will go back to the highs or slightly above I do not know but I think after that bounce the dollar is due to decline into 2024”

0.57

S&P 500 earnings will decline 20-25% in 2023, with declines in overseas earnings expected to be deeper than US declines, and this earnings correction (distinct from valuation correction) will drive the next leg down in equities.

forecasthigh valuecontestednovelty 1/4durability 2/4· Felix Zoltan

“I wouldn't be surprised to see 20 25 down in 23 in S P 500 earnings uh keep in mind that about half of it comes from overseas we have the recession uh will be deeper than in the U.S so I think that is going to give us the next leg down”

0.57

The Fed will cut rates in 2023 with greater than 75% probability, as the minute economic conditions weaken they will pivot, following their 20-year pattern of doing so quickly when faced with adversity.

forecasthigh valuecontestednovelty 1/4durability 2/4· Jeffrey Gundlach

“absolutely I would bet I think I think the odds are are probably greater than 75 percent that there's a rate cut in 2023 the way these things work Felix is right they talk tough that they're fighting inflation but the minute that something starts to change on the ground in the economy we've seen some pretty epic pivots on interest rates in just the last few years I I'll hearken back to 2018. where Jay Powell said in the fourth quarter of 2018 that he was going to be quantitative tightening was on I don't know if he used exactly the word autopilot but that was the meaning and he was going to raise interest rates sequentially during 2019 and that lasted about three weeks”

0.57

Growth stocks will have one strong rally early in the cycle but will then 'die and go into hibernation for several years,' while commodity-related stocks will outperform later.

forecasthigh valuecontestednovelty 1/4durability 2/4· Felix Zoltan

“I think the first move up from the lows one we hit it in the stock market the growth stocks will have one hell of a rally but just one after that they will die and and go into hibernation for several years uh and and after that it will be more the commodity related stocks that will perform very well”

0.56

Bloomberg maintains a Treasury market liquidity index measuring bid-ask spreads across maturities; this index has been elevated all year, indicating sustained poor liquidity in the Treasury market despite it being the deepest, most liquid market.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 2/4· Jeffrey Gundlach

“there's an index that Bloomberg maintains that talks about the liquidity in the treasury market by comparing bid ass spreads across the treasury market uh maturities and it's been when the index goes up it means liquidity is going down and the index has been elevated all year long”

0.56

Fixed income opportunities began in September-October 2022 when Treasury yields exceeded 4%, economic growth was slowing, and credit yields rose even more than Treasury yields, creating the best opportunity in 10 years.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 2/4· Jeffrey Gundlach

“it started out it was really in September into October where we had probably the best opportunity in fixed income in 10 years and that was because treasury yields were up above four percent economy slowing and we had credit as you go down into various pockets of the credit Market had yields go up even more than Treasurer yields”

0.53

The observation that Gunlock and Zulauf 'think you know during 40 Years of declining interest rates' needs to be questioned; people must look in the mirror at how things will behave in the coming years when rates are rising

normativehigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 4/4· Jeffrey Gunlock

“it's all part of the same theme that what you think you know during 40 Years of declining interest rates maybe you're supposed to be looking in the mirror as how things are going to behave uh in the in the Years coming up ahead”

0.53

European equities have experienced a 20%+ rally recently despite very negative news, and will likely test lows again and go even lower in the first half of 2023, presenting a better entry opportunity.

forecasthigh valuecontestednovelty 1/4durability 1/4· Felix Zoltan

“we just had over 20 percent rally in European stocks in the midst of very gloomy gloomy news and I think the European Equity Market really is near an end and we will probably touch the lows again and go even lower sometimes in the first half of next year by that time that would be the opportunity to enter the European Equity Market”

0.52

The consequences of 2020-2021 policies (lockdown stimulus, deficit spending) are finally materializing in 2022-2023 due to a long lag, as crypto scams, banking crises, and other instabilities surface from policies that were sown years ago.

causalhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Jeffrey Gundlach

“we put all these policies in place in response to economic lockdowns and so forth in 2020 and 2021 and it always happens in markets and in in life frankly you kind of should know what's going to happen when you have all this money giveaway and all of this deficit spending but it takes much longer than people think or that they have patience for and so all of a sudden you know the chickens come home to roost but it's it's after a period with a sufficient lag that people give up on the idea that there's going to be negative consequences then all of a sudden they start piling up...we've seen so many stocks that have just fallen into mine shaft type of declines we see that the the bank of England situation you know where they have no idea that the uh the problem that they have with the leverage in the system and and the policies being changed abruptly and all of a sudden there's this crisis and then we have uh this crypto situation”

0.52

The US budget deficit is currently about 4% of GDP and will rise further just from Fed losses due to higher interest rates and economic softening—but this is the first time we've had this level of deficit with unemployment at a low level, indicating unsustainable fiscal policy.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Jeffrey Gundlach

“here we are the budget deficit United States is down to about four percent of GDP right now but it's going to go up just on the fed's losses and interest rates going up and the economy softening but this is the first time ever we've had this kind of a deficit with unemployment at a low level uh usually when you have this type of deficit it's in response to recession”

0.52

The current market consensus forecasts that headline CPI will fall at exactly the same pace as it rose, then magically stop at around 2-3% and remain flat at roughly 2.5% for the next 3-4 years with no variation, a pattern that has never occurred in inflation history.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Jeffrey Gundlach

“the consensus in the market and the consensus among economists is that the CPI the headline CPI is going to fall just as fast as it went up and it might with all the things that the FED is doing and some of the weaknesses generating the commodity sector and the economy but what's interesting about the forecast is it's forecast to decline at exactly the same Pace as it went up and then magically just stop at around two or three percent and go dead sideways at about that two and a half percent level for the next three or four years with absolutely no variation which of course has never happened in the history of inflation Series”

0.52

World dollar liquidity (US monetary base plus US Treasury holdings by foreign central banks) has declined to minus 12, a level never seen before, indicating quantitative tightening is far more severe than most people realize when they only look at real interest rates.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Felix Zoltan

“there is a proxy I look at that is not followed very broadly which is World dollar liquidity which is basically the U.S monetary base plus U.S treasury is held by Foreign central banks and uh and that uh Series has declined to now minus 12 I have never seen such a number this tells me that the quantitative tightening that has been going on is much more severe than what people see when they just look at real interest rates”

0.52

The 1980s bear market in bonds saw yields fall from 14% to 10%, then spike back up to double digits, and that second move was what 'really got people's psyche messed up'—a similar pattern could repeat in reverse where yields fall from current levels and people won't believe it.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Jeffrey Gundlach

“when I started in the bond market you know we had double digit yields and uh no one really it was the opposite of and appropriately so because that was a bull market beginning it's the opposite of what you're describing now but it's it's the same effect and that is that the yields drop drop from about 14 down to 10 and then they went right back up and that double whammy that second move up was what really got people's psyche uh messed up I guess I would say”

0.52

European multinationals can mitigate energy costs by reassuring production to places with reliable access to cheap energy, making European stocks cheaper than US but requiring focus on multinational producers rather than domestic-only players.

normativehigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Felix Zoltan

“for domestic producers it's a problem uh but I think multinational companies they are moving around and they are reassuring uh some of the factories to other places where they have reliable access to energy at the low price and therefore if you concentrate on European equities that are cheaper than us equities you have to focus on multinationals that have the option to really Outsource part of their production to other places where it's cheaper to produce”

0.51

The valuation rotation in 2022 was extreme: beginning with fixed income 'ridiculously overvalued' and equities 'very overvalued', it flipped to bonds becoming 'drastically cheap' to equities by the lows

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 1/4· Jeffrey Gunlock

“we started this year with fixed income ridiculously overvalued and equities just very overvalued well that all rotated in the first nine months of 2022 to the point where uh bonds this type of mix of bonds that I'm referring to became drastically cheap to the opportunity in inequities”

0.51

China is in a deep economic crisis and serious recession, and will provide deflation benefits to the rest of the world due to its size

factualhigh valuecontestednovelty 1/4durability 2/4· Felix Zulauf

“I think China is in a deep economic crisis a serious recession and I think we will benefit to get the reef of deflation out of China”

0.50

If central banks try to avoid higher bond yields through yield curve control, they will trigger a currency crash; if they try to avoid a currency crash, they enter a different geopolitical/economic ball game entirely

causalhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Felix Zulauf

“if the the central banks try to avoid that then we have a currency crash then if they try to avoid that and go to automatic yield curve control then we have a Calamity in the currency markets and when you have a meltdown in the currency markets sooner or later you enter a completely different ball game”

0.45

There is more to come in terms of policy consequences; the 'cockroach' problem is real—when you see one cockroach, there are always more hiding in the baseboards, implying more crises ahead.

forecasthigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Jeffrey Gundlach

“I'd certainly agree that when it comes to these types of of developments it's like the old saying that there's never one cockroach and there's going to be more there's more cockroaches down in the baseboards that are going to be revealed”

0.45

Gundlach's biggest investment opportunity coming will be emerging market equities, not yet at buy stage but approaching it; emerging markets should be held for a multi-year horizon.

normativehigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Jeffrey Gundlach

“I do like long treasuries and I I think the biggest opportunity coming will be an emerging market equities I don't think it's too early to buy them now but I you'll probably be able to buy them cheaper but I'm talking about a multi-year holding period”

0.45

Fixed income opportunities in 2023 will exist in credit and duration, mixing long treasuries (which will appreciate with economic weakness) with credit assets (high-yield, emerging market bonds, asset-backed securities) to create a balanced portfolio with offsets.

normativehigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 2/4· Jeffrey Gundlach

“the opportunity is to mix the assets so you can own the long treasuries which will provide price gains under economic weakness and dropping inflation and you can buy Credit in these sort of single B Double B category and uh sometimes at times high yield bonds were attractive Emerging Market bonds certainly got attractive...you could offset them with the treasuries and what's that the and to nail that point down it's it's already worked it doesn't mean it'll continue to work as well but we've seen treasury prices go up pretty significantly”

0.45

After the earnings correction completes the first cyclical correction, there will be an opportunity to enter the market again in the first half of 2023, which Zoltan is trying to position his clients to catch.

normativehigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 2/4· Felix Zoltan

“and then there is an opportunity and I try to get my clients in again at the next opportunity sometimes in the first half”

0.44

Crude oil could spike to $150 in the first half of 2023, but in 2025 could trade closer to $200 as secondary inflation waves and commodity scarcity accelerate.

forecasthigh valuefringenovelty 1/4durability 1/4· Felix Zoltan

“I do not exclude crude oil heating 50 in the first half at some point of time but I think in 25 crude oil will trade closer to 200”

0.44

The Treasury is approaching the debt ceiling and running behind on issuance, drawing down the general account at the Fed to avoid hitting the ceiling, which is temporarily injecting liquidity to the credit system but will reverse in a catch-up phase that could spike the bond market.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 2/4· Felix Zoltan

“the treasury is approaching its debt ceiling again and therefore it is running behind in the issuance it should actually issue another 300 billion between now and year end and it can probably not do so because it fears to hit that ceiling and therefore the treasury is really drawing down the general account at the fed and that that is actually adding and injecting liquidity to the credit system which is short-term bullish for risk assets but it actually means that they are running and falling more and more behind and once the catch-up phase begins then the market will be flooded with huge amounts of paper issued by the treasury”

0.42

Even US investors should consider investing outside the US in 2023 given the dollar decline outlook and emerging market turnaround potential.

normativehigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 2/4· Felix Zulauf

“so I think even U.S investors should consider investing uh somewhat outside for 2023 once again”

0.39

Gundlach and DoubleLine are buying the longest-duration long-term treasuries (30-year and 10-year) and have the longest duration in their flagship products since DoubleLine's founding 13+ years ago.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 2/4· Jeffrey Gundlach

“don't listen to what I say look at what I do and we entered this year very negative on on bonds uh very low duration constantly going up in quality and starting in September we started buying long-term treasures and we bought them several times we now have the longest duration in some of our uh some of our Flagship products that we've had since we found a double line over 13 years ago”

0.39

Zulauf turned bearish on the stock market about a year before this discussion (mid-2021) and had been bearish on bonds even longer, expecting inflation to rise above 4% due to unsustainable zero interest rate policy.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 2/4· Felix Zulauf

“as we you know just about a year ago or so I turned bearish on the stock market and uh and I have been bearish on the bond market before uh I thought that the uh zero interest rate policy in the U.S and even negative interest rate policy in Europe could not continue because I expected inflation rates to rise”

0.39

Zulauf agrees with Gunlock on not buying Chinese assets due to political risk, aligning with his earlier thesis about U.S.-China superpower conflict and bloc formation

normativehigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 0/4durability 3/4· Felix Zulauf

“yeah okay we are we are in agreement as well here right Jeffrey”

0.36

Bonds are currently cheaper to stocks than they were at the lows in October 2022, though the relative valuation gap has compressed as stock prices have risen while bond prices have declined somewhat from their lows

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 1/4· Jeffrey Gunlock

“I still think that bonds are cheap to stocks at this point in time uh just not as cheap as they were at the lows”

0.35

The 30-year US Treasury is Zoltan's favorite investment for 2023, expected to deliver significant returns as yields fall.

normativehigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 0/4durability 2/4· Felix Zoltan

“I think the third year treasury will be a fantastic investment for for next year”

0.13

Gundlach previously tweeted that yields would peak in Q4 2022, which has been validated by market action; he also agrees with Zulauf that the two have been arriving at similar conclusions throughout the discussion.

factualspeaker onlynovelty 0/4durability 1/4· Jeffrey Gundlach

“I think I even tweeted this out uh at the beginning of the fourth quarter I think yields are going to Peak sometime in the fourth quarter of 2022 and I think I do agree with Felix the problem with having uh conversations with Felix is we agree we agree on too many things so we don't have that points of contention I I absolutely am pleased that Felix brought up this tension between the U.S and China”

0.13

The situation is highly dynamic and dramatic with numerous opportunities for investors who can play market swings as they come, similar to how markets swung one way up in 2020-2021 and one way down in 2022.

factualspeaker onlynovelty 0/4durability 1/4· Felix Zulauf

“I think this is all highly Dynamic and highly dramatic in a way and it offers a lot of opportunities for those investors who can play the market swings as as it comes so I'm I'm excited about what's ahead for next year”

0.13

Zulauf does not look at individual credit asset class differentiation and is not sophisticated enough to navigate different segments within credit, preferring instead to play directional (macro) movements like the 200-basis-point Treasury yield decline he expects.

factualspeaker onlynovelty 0/4durability 1/4· Felix Zulauf

“I I do not look at the different I I mean I look at the different quality spreads and I think the quality spreads really in general widen from here... I'm not sophisticated enough in the different asset classes inside the creative markets”