
Silicon Bites #88 - 'Revolution is Coming' - Girkin Strelkov Forecasts Collapse of the Russian Army.
What this covers
This episode of Silicon Bites is a short commentary adapted from a report on Michael N's YouTube channel. The host summarizes and paraphrases a recent assessment by Igor Girkin, the former FSB officer known as Strelkov. The host frames him bluntly: he went to Donbas with backing from oligarch Konstantin Malev, started the provocations and killings that opened the way for Russian intervention, and is now jailed for discrediting the army and challenging Vladimir Putin, not for his crimes against Ukraine. His criticism, the host notes, comes from fear that the war is run neither efficiently nor ruthlessly enough, and not from any objection to the invasion itself. The host also points to his earlier forecast of a Russian collapse in Syria, which came true, as a reason to take his assessments seriously.
The substance is a scorecard of Russian aims after three years. Girkin argues that Volodymyr Zelenskyy holds power more firmly than in 2022 and that demilitarization has failed, since Ukraine now fields an experienced army of several hundred thousand. He adds that Ukrainian hostility toward Russia has grown rather than faded, that Kyiv and the right bank of the Dnieper remain firmly Ukrainian, and that much of the annexed regions is still outside Russian control. Ukrainian missile and drone stocks are rising, strikes reach industry and energy sites beyond the Volga, and Ukrainian troops still hold ground in Kursk despite Russian and North Korean efforts.
The most contested turn is mobilization. Girkin concedes that Russia has untapped potential, because it never formally declared war, but doubts that the Ministry of Defense could equip and organize the half a million to two million additional troops that a strategic victory would need. He also questions whether an exhausted society and depleted equipment stocks could support such a push. He ends with a warning that continuing as now could cost Russia the state itself. The episode also notes China blocking tankers carrying Russian oil as a sign of limited Chinese support.
Igor Girkin, imprisoned for criticizing the Russian military, assesses Russia's war in Ukraine as strategically failed with no path to military victory, predicting potential state collapse if current conditions persist.
- Russia has failed to achieve any of its stated war goals after three years of conflict despite massive casualties and resource expenditure
- Ukraine's military has grown stronger with Western support and reserves, making Russian victory increasingly impossible
- Russia faces potential internal collapse from mobilization resistance and economic exhaustion similar to 1917 Petrograd
This asset isn't compiled yet
You're seeing its claims, ranked. Compile it to build the argument threads, weight them, and check each claim against your library — the full view.
Russia theoretically possesses significant mobilization potential because the country has never been declared to be in a state of war; only the army is fighting, and mobilization of armed forces, industry, rear, and the entire economy was not carried out comprehensively.
“do we and the enemy have reserves stov asks in the first case the answer is ambiguous theoretically yes there are and very significant ones our country is still not technically at War only the Army is fighting the mobilization of the Armed Forces and Industry the rear the entire economy and so on was not carried out except for or individual non-comprehensive onetime measures as a result we still have significant mobilization potential which theoretically could be used”
By the end of the third year of war, Russia has accomplished none of its stated military objectives: Zelenskyy's regime has not been overthrown but holds power more firmly than in 2022, Ukraine continues forced russification at an accelerated pace despite war, and Nazi propaganda has brainwashed Ukraine's population into increased hatred toward Russia.
“the situation for the Russian Federation is of a largely negative character by the end of the third year of War none of the tasks that were enshrined as goals have been accomplished or are close to being accomplished zelinsky's regime has not been overthrown but is holding on tighter than it was in 2022 under the conditions of war the Dr russification of Ukraine continued at an accelerated Pace not even the so-called densification of Ukraine but girkin has not let go of the false tropes of Putin's regime however he says Nazi propaganda is brainwashing the population of Ukraine hatred towards Russia has not decreased but has increased many times over”
Igor Girkin was imprisoned not for war crimes against Ukraine but for discrediting the Russian army and challenging Putin's authority, reflecting the punitive structure of Putin's Russia where even regime loyalists face punishment for disloyalty.
“his prison sent is for discrediting the Russian army and challenging the authority of the killer in the Kremlin there is a certain irony in Gerkin toov falling foul of the regime he fought for but this kind of irony is familiar from Russian history and reflects the punitive structure of Putin's Russia”
Half a million new fighters must be delivered to the front all at once to be effective, not in single glasses and single doses as has occurred, and this requirement creates an organizational challenge beyond Russia's demonstrated capacity.
“moreover this half a million needs to be delivered to the front not as they bring water in single glasses and single doses but all at once in addition to technical issues”
Igor Girkin was the main initiator of the full-scale war in Ukraine, kicking off the violence that characterizes the current conflict.
“girkin the probably the initiator the main initiator of the incredible violence that we see the fullscale war in Ukraine he was the one that kicked it all off”
Girkin predicted the collapse of Russian military power in Syria, and this prediction came to pass—Russia was ejected from Syria.
“much of what he said previously was negative but his prediction for the collapse of Russian military power in Syria has come to pass he's also talked about Russia's adventures in Africa also possibly having a cell byby date the Russian army has actually of course been ejected from Syria”
Girkin was an FSB officer who went to Donbas with oligarch Constantine Malev's support, started provocations and murders there, and blazed a trail for Russian military intervention.
“he was an FSB officer he went to donbass with a gang of thugs supported by resources from oligarch Constantin malev and started provocations and murders there he blazed a trail for the Russian army to intervene and for today's full scale Invasion”
Girkin is imprisoned not for war crimes against Ukraine but for disloyalty to Putin's regime—specifically for discrediting the Russian army and challenging Kremlin authority.
“his prison sent is for discrediting the Russian army and challenging the authority of the killer in the Kremlin”
Girkin believes Russia faces not just military defeat but potential state collapse due to how the Russian army fights, how the Russian elite behaves, and the decisions of Vladimir Putin.
“Russia May face not just defeat but a form of collapse this is possible because of how the Russian army fights how the Russian Elite behaves and the decisions of Vladimir Putin he says”
Ukraine has not been demilitarized but instead has developed an experienced army of several hundred thousand troops, better armed, better organized, better trained, and more experienced than before the invasion, with no signs of imminent disintegration despite fatigue and losses.
“no demilitarization of Ukraine has been achieved on the contrary it now has an experienced Army of several hundred thousand armed perhaps better than before the start of the fullscale invasion better organized better trained experienced and far more assistant despite fatigue and losses from war there are no signs of imminent disintegration of the Ukrainian Armed Forces”
Ukraine is conducting military operations on Russian territory, occupying parts of the Kursk region, and Russian troops combined with North Korean forces have not been able to dislodge them for almost six months.
“Ukraine is conducting military operations on the territory of the Russian Federation occupying parts of the ksk region Russian troops combined with North Koreans have not been able to dislodge the enemy for almost six whole months”
Ukraine is increasing its stocks of missiles and drones, mounting attacks deep in the rear of Russian forces beyond the Volga, and striking Russian industrial infrastructure and energy facilities on an ever greater scale month by month.
“The Armed Forces of Ukraine are increasing their capabilities and stocks of missiles and drones they can mount attack deep in in the rear of Russian troops to the vulgar and further Ukraine is striking industrial infrastructure and energy facilities on an Ever greater scale month by month”
China has shown willingness to comply with US sanctions against Russia by blocking five tankers with Russian oil in Chinese territorial waters.
“China has shown its Readiness to comply with us sanctions against our Fleet by blocking five tankers with Russian oil in China's territorial Waters”
In practice, Russia is not receiving timely and sufficient means to maintain a decisive victory, the army is being bled dry, and while it has enough to hold the front and advance slowly in some places achieving costly tactical successes, the prospects of achieving strategic victory and forcing Ukraine to sign peace are more than doubtful.
“in practice we have completely the opposite it is a depressing picture we do not receive timely and sufficient means to maintain a decisive Victory the Russian army is being bled dry it is still enough to hold the front and even Advance at a snail's pace in some places with difficulty they Advanced forward achieving purely tactical but very costly successes but the prospects of achieving a strategic Victory defeating the opposing enemy forces and forcing Ukraine to sign peace on our terms are more than doubtful”
Girkin questions whether general mobilization would help Russia, given that the country, army, and population are already exhausted after three years of bloody and unsuccessful military campaign, industry faces acute shortages of technical resources, and military equipment reserves are likely close to extinction.
“will General mobilization help us now he asks I find it difficult to answer this question unequivocally the country its armies and the population are already very tired of the three-year bloody and not very successful to put it mildly military campaign industry is acutely aware of the shortage of Technical Resources and the reserves of military equipment likely are close to extinction”
The Ministry of Defense may lack capacity to arm, clothe, shoe, train, organize, feed, and form into units at least half a million more fighters needed for strategic victory, possibly one and a half to two million more.
“I do not have the information but I have doubts whether the ministry of Defense can arm clothes Shoe Train organize feed form to units and formations and then introduce into battle at least half a million more Fighters for a strategic victory of Ukraine alone no less than this is needed possibly one and a half to two times more than that”
China has demonstrated its readiness to comply with US sanctions against Russia's fleet by blocking five tankers carrying Russian oil in Chinese territorial waters, and has shown through its actions that it is far from supporting Russia's special military operation.
“also China has shown its Readiness to comply with us sanctions against our Fleet by blocking five tankers with Russian oil in China's territorial Waters the fact that China is far from supporting the current special military operation has been clear to me for a long time he claims”
Igor Girkin was the main initiator of the fullscale war in Ukraine and was an FSB officer who went to Donbass with thugs supported by oligarch Constantin Malev, initiating provocations and murders that blazed the trail for Russian army intervention and today's invasion.
“girkin the probably the initiator the main initiator of the incredible violence that we see the fullscale war in Ukraine he was the one that kicked it all off”
Girkin's previous predictions about the collapse of Russian military power in Syria have come to pass, with the Russian army having been ejected from Syria as he forecast.
“much of what he said previously was negative but his prediction for the collapse of Russian military power in Syria has come to pass he's also talked about Russia's adventures in Africa also possibly having a cell byby date the Russian army has actually of course been ejected from Syria”
Ukraine did not become more disposed toward Russia as a result of Russian invasion, with Ukrainian hatred toward Russia not decreasing but increasing many times over—contrary to any Russian assumption that military victory could achieve political integration.
“well why would this surprise him at all when Russia invaded Ukraine to destroy its cities torture its people kill its soldiers and kidnap its children Ukraine did not become more disposed towards Russia because Russia destroyed many Ukrainian cities and a large number of Ukrainian citizens”
By the end of the third year of war, Russia has accomplished none of its stated war goals, and Ukraine's government is holding power more firmly than in 2022.
“the situation for the Russian Federation is of a largely negative character by the end of the third year of War none of the tasks that were enshrined as goals have been accomplished or are close to being accomplished zelinsky's regime has not been overthrown but is holding on tighter than it was in 2022”
Ukraine's military has grown from 2022 levels into an experienced army of several hundred thousand, better armed, organized, and trained than before the invasion despite fatigue and losses.
“no demilitarization of Ukraine has been achieved on the contrary it now has an experienced Army of several hundred thousand armed perhaps better than before the start of the fullscale invasion better organized better trained experienced and far more assistant despite fatigue and losses from war”
Ukraine's hatred toward Russia has not decreased but increased many times over, a consequence of Russian invasion, city destruction, torture, murder of soldiers, and kidnapping of children.
“hatred towards Russia has not decreased but has increased many times over well why would this surprise him at all when Russia invaded Ukraine to destroy its cities torture its people kill its soldiers and kidnap its children”
One-third of the annexed regions that Russia claims has not been liberated from Ukrainian control; Ukraine firmly holds Kyiv, the right bank of the Dnieper, and significant parts of the Zaporizhzhia region.
“a third of the territory of the annexed regions that Russia makes claim to has not been liberated from Ukrainian control Ukraine firmly holds the capital and the right Bank of the hon region as well as significant parts of the zapara region”
In practice, despite theoretical reserves, Russia's actual situation is depressing: the military is being bled dry, cannot maintain decisive victory, and troops can only hold the front and advance at a snail's pace with purely tactical but costly successes.
“in practice we have completely the opposite it is a depressing picture we do not receive timely and sufficient means to maintain a decisive Victory the Russian army is being bled dry it is still enough to hold the front and even Advance at a snail's pace in some places with difficulty they Advanced forward achieving purely tactical but very costly successes but the prospects of achieving a strategic Victory defeating the opposing enemy forces and forcing Ukraine to sign peace on our terms are more than doubtful”
Russia's only ally is North Korea, which cannot solve Russia's strategic isolation or provide meaningful backing for continued war prosecution.
“how to get out of this wonderful situation having only North Korea as an ally it is unclear to me stov writes especially considering that Society is not mobilized at all and is already very tired of the war and does not feel any enthusiasm for its further continuation”
Ukraine shows no signs of imminent disintegration of its armed forces despite fatigue and losses, and is conducting operations on Russian territory and occupying parts of the Kursk region.
“there are no signs of imminent disintegration of the Ukrainian Armed Forces Ukraine is conducting military operations on the territory of the Russian Federation occupying parts of the ksk region”
Russian troops combined with North Korean forces have failed to dislodge Ukrainian forces from occupied territories for almost six months, despite being dedicated to this task.
“Russian troops combined with North Koreans have not been able to dislodge the enemy for almost six whole months”
Ukraine is increasing its missile and drone capabilities and can strike deep into Russian territory, expanding attacks on industrial infrastructure and energy facilities month by month.
“The Armed Forces of Ukraine are increasing their capabilities and stocks of missiles and drones they can mount attack deep in in the rear of Russian troops to the vulgar and further Ukraine is striking industrial infrastructure and energy facilities on an Ever greater scale month by month”
Russia controls only about two-thirds of the annexed regions it claims, with one-third still held by Ukraine, including the capital and right bank of the Kherson region plus significant parts of Zaporizhzhia.
“a third of the territory of the annexed regions that Russia makes claim to has not been liberated from Ukrainian control Ukraine firmly holds the capital and the right Bank of the hon region as well as significant parts of the zapara region”
Ukraine has 150,000 to 300,000 newly mobilized servicemen undergoing combat training in EU countries, and even subtracting 100,000 for deserters and draft dodgers, may have 200,000 additional soldiers at the front by spring 2025.
“according to VAR sources they have from 150 to 3,000 newly mobilized servicemen undergoing combat training in EU countries let's subtract say 100,000 deserters draft Dodgers and the like for good measure even so Ukraine may end up with another 200,000 soldiers at the front by the spring of 2025”
Girkin predicts that a ceasefire agreement would provide no respite for Russia because Ukraine would not observe it, would continue building fortifications and concentrating troops, and NATO would introduce troops during any ceasefire period.
“it will not be a respite for Russia he says the enemy will not observe the ceasefire at all there will be no respite for our army they will shoot at us they will build fortifications before our eyes concentrate troops and then NATO troops will be bought in”
China has long been unwilling to support Russia's special military operation and is now showing irritation and transparently hinting to Moscow that it is time to end the war.
“the fact that China is far from supporting the current special military operation has been clear to me for a long time he claims it has also long been clear that China's patience in connection with the aforementioned inconveniences of the SV or is either running out or has expired complet completely Russian Victory and the end of the military conflict on terms that suit Moscow are not even on the horizon Beijing is showing its irritation and transparently hinting to Moscow that is time to end the war under any circumstances”
Ukraine may end up with an additional 200,000 soldiers at the front by spring 2025 from 150,000-300,000 newly mobilized servicemen undergoing combat training in EU countries, after subtracting deserters and draft dodgers.
“strelkov's assessment of Ukraine strengths is at variance to what we often hear in the mainstream Western media and even propagandistic channels while waging a total War the Ukrainian armed forces have reserves he says according to VAR sources they have from 150 to 3,000 newly mobilized servicemen undergoing combat training in EU countries let's subtract say 100,000 deserters draft Dodgers and the like for good measure even so Ukraine may end up with another 200,000 soldiers at the front by the spring of 2025”
There is no chance that all the constitutional territories of the Russian Federation can be liberated by military means in the near future; Russia has failed and did not achieve its goals.
“he concludes that there is no chance that all the Constitutional territories of the Russian Federation can be liberated by military means in the near future Russia failed and did not achieve its goals writes stov”
The Russian majority will swallow any retreat under the slogan that there should be no more war, but two critical problems remain: first, how the army will react to retreat; second and more importantly, who will guarantee that Western powers will not immediately break any peace guarantees once Russia occupies the southern claimed regions.
“of course with certain propaganda efforts the majority will swallow any Retreat under the slogan so that there should be no more war but two problems Remain the first is how the Army will react to this the second is more important who will guarantee that having occupied the south of these regions that we claim as our own that Kev and its Partners will not immediately spit on these very guarantees”
Girkin assumes any peace would be just as much a contingency arrangement for Western allies as it obviously would be for Russia, meaning there is no trust and therefore no genuine possibility of a stable peace deal.
“girin is here assuming that any peace may be just as much a contingency arrangement for the Western allies as it obviously would be for the Russians there is no trust here so how can there be a deal How can there be any peace”
Girkin predicts that after a quarter century of thoughtlessly living off the legacy of Soviet ancestors, Russia will face a severe sobering up where people will have to fight en masse and work hard simply for basic subsistence—bread, heat, and electricity—during long winters.
“clinging to the ghost of a happy past is typical of aging and decrepid declining States and civilizations we are in for a very cruel sobering up after a quarter of a century of thoughtlessly living the legacy of our ancestors soon people will probably have to fight on mass and work hard not for ideas but simply for a piece of bread and a little heat and electricity during The Long Winter”
Girkin questions whether the country and population would respond to general mobilization with fresh reserves for the front or instead with potential revolt similar to the February 1917 revolution in Petrograd, suggesting records of such sentiment exist among Russian elites.
“a second question arises how will the country the people react to General mobilization now after 3 years of bloody tedium will we receive instead of the long awaited large reserves to the front fuel for a Revolt of the mobilized like what happened in petrograd in February 1917 he asks record isit for this exist I am more than sure of this and I'm ready to initiate such a Revolt of force in the so-called Elite”
Girkin questions how Russia can exit the war with only North Korea as an ally, given that Russian society is not mobilized and is already very tired of the war, expressing doubt about whether it will sustain enthusiasm for continued conflict.
“and how to get out of this wonderful situation having only North Korea as an ally it is unclear to me stov writes especially considering that Society is not mobilized at all and is already very tired of the war and does not feel any enthusiasm for its further continuation”
Russian society is not mobilized for war and is already very tired, lacking enthusiasm for continued conflict, though propaganda can convince the population to accept retreat if framed as achieving peace.
“Society is not mobilized at all and is already very tired of the war and does not feel any enthusiasm for its further continuation of course with certain propaganda efforts the majority will swallow any Retreat under the slogan so that there should be no more war”
China's patience regarding the inconveniences caused by Russia's special military operation has either run out or is expiring completely, and Beijing is showing irritation while transparently hinting to Moscow that it is time to end the war under any circumstances.
“China's patience in connection with the aforementioned inconveniences of the SV or is either running out or has expired complet completely Russian Victory and the end of the military conflict on terms that suit Moscow are not even on the horizon Beijing is showing its irritation and transparently hinting to Moscow that is time to end the war under any circumstances”
Moscow will respond to any peace settlement with dismal protests and claims of being deceived and swindled, repeating the rhetoric of betrayal familiar from Putin's speeches, reflecting a pattern of illusory grievances and perceived Western slights.
“Moscow will respond with dismal protests he says and then someone will again say with an offended voice how he was led by the nose we were simply deceived again they tricked us they swindled us they rudely tricked us all this is very familiar from Putin's speeches”
Girkin's commentary represents 'weaponized whining' and 'screeches of protest' directed at the Russian army's incompetence and its leaders' callousness rather than at Ukrainian targets.
“in this respect gin is closer to priorin in that his screeches of protest and weaponized whining are most often directed towards the Russian army not the ukrainians and its callous incompetent leaders”
Girkin's critical statements about the Russian army, during the full-scale war, were nearly uniformly negative, but not because he disapproves of invasion—rather because he believes the war is not being conducted efficiently or ruthlessly enough.
“during the fullscale war stv's assessment of the actions of the Russian army were nearly uniformally negative these statements are not because he disapproves of the invasion but because he fears it is neither being conducted efficiently nor ruthlessly enough”
There is no chance Russia can liberate all the constitutional territories it claims by military means in the near future, therefore Russia has failed to achieve its stated goals.
“there is no chance that all the Constitutional territories of the Russian Federation can be liberated by military means in the near future Russia failed and did not achieve its goals writes stov”
Girkin's assessments of Russian military problems have often reflected real issues and his forecasts about the army have corresponded to how events later played out, making him more reliable than other Z-bloggers who mostly repeat propaganda.
“his assessments have often reflected real problems that exist in the Russian army some of his forecasts for that Army correspond to how change later played out”
Despite Russia's extensive bombing and military operations, no Russification of Ukraine has occurred; instead, Ukraine's densification has accelerated under wartime conditions.
“under the conditions of war the Dr russification of Ukraine continued at an accelerated Pace not even the so-called densification of Ukraine”
The Russian military may reject any retreat or peace settlement, and without guarantees that Western allies won't violate agreements, any peace arrangement with the West becomes impossible to conclude.
“but two problems Remain the first is how the Army will react to this the second is more important who will guarantee that having occupied the south of these regions that we claim as our own that Kev and its Partners will not immediately spit on these very guarantees girin is here assuming that any peace may be just as much a contingency arrangement for the Western allies as it obviously would be for the Russians there is no trust here so how can there be a deal How can there be any peace”
Girkin predicts that this year will bring massive changes so profound that current realities will seem like ancient myths, and Russia faces a 'cruel sobering up' after a quarter-century of living off ancestors' legacy.
“this year so much will probably change that all current realities will seem wild and a mirage or a legend of ancient times he said clinging to the ghost of a happy past is typical of aging and decrepid declining States and civilizations we are in for a very cruel sobering up after a quarter of a century of thoughtlessly living the legacy of our ancestors”
After three years of bloody, unsuccessful war, Russian society is exhausted and may revolt if forced to undergo general mobilization, risking a repeat of February 1917 Petrograd uprising.
“how will the country the people react to General mobilization now after 3 years of bloody tedium will we receive instead of the long awaited large reserves to the front fuel for a Revolt of the mobilized like what happened in petrograd in February 1917 he asks record isit for this exist I am more than sure of this and I'm ready to initiate such a Revolt of force in the so-called Elite”
Girkin sees no reason for optimism about Russia's future prospects—either his own life, the empire he longs for, or the Russian army—given current conditions represent no victory for Russia.
“the situation at the front and Beyond does not provide stov gin any reason for optimism either about his own life the life of an imperial Russian that he Longs for and the Russian army as well from his point of view what is happening now cannot be called a victory for Russia”
Girkin predicts Ukraine will not agree to any unfavorable peace settlement because it is receiving equipment from the US and Europe, and even if weapons supplies were cut off, adequate supplies will likely continue with 99% probability for the next 4-6 months, ensuring no genuine ceasefire in 2025.
“why would it agree to a bad piece even if suddenly the supply of weapons and equipment from the US Canada Britain France Germany are turned off eventually at least in 20125 adequate supplies will continue to be provided with a probability of 99% that is in the next 4 to 6 months there will be no truce for sure concludes gkin”
Romania's participation in liquidating Transnistria is very likely, with Girkin comparing it to the difference between talking about a volcanic eruption and being caught in one.
“Romania's participation in the liquidation of transist is very likely he says it is one thing to talk about the inevitability of a volcanic eruption and quite another to be caught in it unfortunately he writes”
Girkin is incarcerated in Russia as a war criminal, bearing even more responsibility for the horrific war than most Russians, but his prison letters occasionally escape and may contain insights into the state of the Russian army closer to reality than manipulative discourse from Russian propagandists.
“occasionally from his prison in Russia he apparently gets letters out and it is these letters we'll be reviewing today stov is back with more pronouncements it has been many months since the timely reports of his demise spread around the Zed bloggosphere and of course we are not concerned about his health or even his welfare he is a war criminal and bears even more responsibility for this horrific War than most Russians do his views on the state of the Russian army however May hold some interest and he has been known to occasionally give critical assessments of the competence and performance of the Russian army some of which has been far closer to reality than the manipulative discourse of Russian propagandists”
The situation at the front and beyond provides Girkin no reason for optimism about his own life as an imperial Russian, the future of the Russian empire he longs for, or the Russian army, making what is happening untenable as a Russian victory.
“the situation at the front and Beyond does not provide stov gin any reason for optimism either about his own life the life of an imperial Russian that he Longs for and the Russian army as well from his point of view what is happening now cannot be called a victory for Russia”
Girkin predicts that if current conditions persist, Russia will face not just military defeat but potential state collapse, driven by how the Russian army fights, elite behavior, and Putin's decisions.
“the situation has got worse what's more Russia May face not just defeat but a form of collapse this is possible because of how the Russian army fights how the Russian Elite behaves and the decisions of Vladimir Putin”
Russia theoretically possesses significant mobilization reserves—the country is not technically at war, only the army is fighting, and industry and the economy have not been fully mobilized.
“do we and the enemy have reserves stov asks in the first case the answer is ambiguous theoretically yes there are and very significant ones our country is still not technically at War only the Army is fighting the mobilization of the Armed Forces and Industry the rear the entire economy and so on was not carried out except for or individual non-comprehensive onetime measures as a result we still have significant mobilization potential which theoretically could be used”
Girkin warns that any ceasefire will not provide respite for Russia because Ukraine will not observe it—the enemy will continue shooting, build fortifications, concentrate troops, and NATO will eventually be brought in.
“the enemy will not observe the ceasefire at all there will be no respite for our army they will shoot at us they will build fortifications before our eyes concentrate troops and then NATO troops will be bought in”
General mobilization of 500,000 troops is the minimum needed for a strategic Russian victory, and possibly 1.5 to 2 million more, but Russia may lack the capacity to equip, train, organize, and deploy this force effectively.
“for a strategic victory of Ukraine alone no less than this is needed possibly one and a half to two times more than that moreover this half a million needs to be delivered to the front not as they bring water in single glasses and single doses but all at once in addition to technical issues”
Even if supplies of weapons from the US, Canada, Britain, France, and Germany were cut off, adequate supplies will likely continue with 99% probability for the next 4-6 months, and there will be no ceasefire.
“eventually at least in 20125 adequate supplies will continue to be provided with a probability of 99% that is in the next 4 to 6 months there will be no truce for sure concludes gkin”
Girkin predicts that soon Russians will have to fight and work simply for survival—for bread, heat, and electricity—rather than for ideological goals, particularly during harsh winters.
“soon people will probably have to fight on mass and work hard not for ideas but simply for a piece of bread and a little heat and electricity during The Long Winter”
Romania's participation in the destruction of Transnistria is very likely, and engaging in such a conflict is different from merely predicting it theoretically.
“Romania's participation in the liquidation of transist is very likely he says it is one thing to talk about the inevitability of a volcanic eruption and quite another to be caught in it unfortunately”
Girkin doubts Moscow will survive to see even a bad peace, implying potential state failure before any negotiated settlement becomes possible.
“as is well known a bad peace is better than a good War but will Moscow live to see this very bad piece personally I doubt it he says”
Girkin predicts Ukraine will likely not agree to any peace treaty if weapons supplies continue, because Ukraine has no incentive to accept a 'bad peace' when military supply is assured.
“if they can defend Ukraine's lines it will likely not agree to any truth at all why would it agree to a bad piece even if suddenly the supply of weapons and equipment from the US Canada Britain France Germany are turned off”
Girkin's realistic military assessment, in contrast to propagandistic Russian narratives, demonstrates that Russia is now in a no-win scenario, and this realism is something the analyst hopes more Russians will embrace in 2025.
“and that is a kind of realism that hopefully more Russians will start to embrace in 2025 that Russia is now in a no win scenario”
The episode is adapted from a report that appeared on Michael N's YouTube channel in Russian and was subsequently edited and translated for this English-language episode.
“this episode is adapted from a report that appeared on Michael n's YouTube channel in Russian and I will put a video link in the description of the video”
Host notes that Girkin's characterization of Western betrayal narratives reflects language familiar from Putin's speeches, suggesting Z-bloggers often repeat defense ministry propaganda scripts rather than offering independent analysis.
“in this respect gin is closer to priorin in that his screeches of protest and weaponized whining are most often directed towards the Russian army not the ukrainians and its callous incompetent leaders”
The channel thanks supporters of a recent trip to Ukraine where events were recorded and asks for continued financial support through Patreon or Buy Me a Coffee to complete editing and processing of videos.
“thank you to everyone who has supported our recent trip to Ukraine we recorded all of the events that we were planning and in fact several more so thank you to everyone who has helped we are almost there at the Target to help pay for the editing processing Etc of the videos so to everyone who's helped so far thank you to anyone else who can chip in it is greatly appreciated on patreon or the campaign we're running on by me a coffee”
The analyst notes that letters occasionally smuggled from Girkin's prison cell appear in reports, suggesting active communication channels despite his imprisonment.
“this video today summarizes several letters recently penned by it trov and apparently smuggled out of his prison cell”
Host characterizes Putin as 'an incredible loser' and 'a prolate despot' who has executed an 'absurd strategy at incredible cost,' summarizing Girkin's implicit assessment of Putin's strategic judgment.
“Putin is an incredible loser a proplate despot who has executed an absurd strategy at Incredible cost”