
What this covers
This is a roughly half-hour video essay from Money & Macro, narrated by economist Joeri Schasfoort. It starts with the problems of money as it works today, then sets out the case for a central bank digital currency (CBDC)), then the dangers, and ends with a short discussion. It first separates wholesale CBDC, which already exists for interbank payments, from retail CBDC, which would sit publicly alongside cash and bank money. Cash, private digital bank money and a possible CBDC are then compared on a star-style scorecard covering privacy, safety, accessibility and cost.
The advantages are taken one at a time. On accessibility, the video cites the share of people without bank accounts, plus "debanking" cases such as Nigel Farage and the Canadian truckers whose accounts were frozen. On safety, it points to Greek ATM queues as a reminder that bank money is a promise to pay central bank money. On cost, it covers card-network fees of up to 3.5% for merchants and the chain of correspondent banks in cross-border payments. It presents Project Dunbar as an example of cross-border CBDC that could remove those intermediaries. Russia's exclusion from Western banking is offered as the geopolitical motive. The Bahamas' Sand Dollar and Nigeria's low-limit anonymous cards serve as real implementations.
The contentious material gets equal space. Dr. Monica Crowley's Fox News warnings of a cashless society with blocked transactions and enforced spending rules are set against China's pilot of expiring money. The video compares that expiring money to existing vouchers. It also notes that the ECB revised its digital euro plan, adding pseudonymous offline payments and legal protection for cash, after public concern. Its closing argument is historical: railroads, tanks and television were kept from enabling authoritarianism by institutions that hold governments accountable, not by the technology itself.
Central bank digital currencies (CBDCs) are neither inherently good nor bad; the critical question is how to design them with democratic values that improve citizens' lives rather than enabling government control, while addressing valid privacy and financial stability concerns.
- CBDCs can provide privacy, accessibility, safety, cost reduction, and geopolitical benefits when designed democratically, but identical technology can enable authoritarian control
- Concerns about programable money, financial stability, and privacy, though sometimes sensationalized, are legitimate and have already influenced central banks to improve proposals
- Democratic institutions, regulations, and accountability mechanisms—not technology itself—determine whether government tools become instruments of freedom or control
This asset isn't compiled yet
You're seeing its claims, ranked. Compile it to build the argument threads, weight them, and check each claim against your library — the full view.
Wholesale CBDCs already exist in most economies as digital currencies issued by central banks accessible only to banks for inter-bank payments, but the emerging discussion concerns retail CBDCs that would be publicly accessible as a complementary payment option alongside physical cash and private bank digital money.
“In most economies, the central bank already issues a digital currency besides cash. However, this cbdc, also known as a wholesale CBDC, is not accessible to the public. It is only available to banks who use it to pay each other. And so the discussion that follows will be about the so-called retail cbdc, which will be accessible to the public as a public digital payment option, complementing physical money and private bank digital money.”
Vouchers—money that can only be spent on certain things or expires—already exist in modern economies, suggesting that expiring CBDC money is not a fundamentally new concept but a formalized version of existing constraints.
“while this sounds really scary expire about money or money that can only be spent on certain things already exists today and we know it under the far less scary name of a voucher.”
What has historically protected democratic countries from government overreach with technology (railroads, tanks, television) is not the technology itself, but institutional rules, regulations, and accountability mechanisms separate from government that hold government accountable; this pattern suggests CBDCs similarly depend on governance structures, not technology, to prevent authoritarianism.
“After all, there have been many new governments owned technologies ranging from railroads to tanks to television that have made some dictatorships more powerful and yet have not led. Every country that adopted these technologies to become an authoritarian dystopia. Instead, what has protected these countries from government overreach in the past has more often been about rules, regulations and institutions that are separate from the government and which hold the government accountable.”
Approximately 6% to 30% of the population in advanced and emerging economies respectively lacks bank account access, with additional cases of people being 'debanked' for engaging in legal but bank-perceived-risky activities like sex work, pot growing, or holding controversial political views, as seen with Nigel Farage in the United Kingdom and truckers in Canada during COVID-19 protests.
“Research shows that roughly 6% and 30% of the population in advance and emerging economies, respectively, does not have access to a bank account. Even more worryingly, there have been quite a few high profile cases of people getting debugged, meaning that they lost their bank account. For example, in the United States. Companies and people whose activities were legal but banks found to be risky, such as sex workers and pot growing, were often refused. A bank account. And perhaps even more worryingly, in the United Kingdom. Controversial politician Nigel Farage lost his bank account briefly because his values did not align with that of the bank. And in Canada, the government even forced private banks to freeze the bank accounts of truckers that were protesting against COVID 19 vaccinations.”
Cash payments receive a two-star privacy score due to large transaction reporting requirements in many countries, though research shows people generally accept privacy tradeoffs to fight crime and terrorism, and physical cash becomes highly valued in authoritarian countries as evidenced by Hong Kong protesters choosing cash over digital cards.
“while cash is almost untraceable, many countries have laws that forbid large cash transactions or require them to be reported to the authorities. So I'd say cash is also not perfect and gets a two star score for privacy. While noting that actually many people don't mind giving up some privacy to fight crime and terrorism. That being said, I think this striking photo of Hong Kong protesters queuing up to use cash rather than digital or public transportation cards reveals that if a country turns authoritarian, people may suddenly really appreciate that physical money is there as an option.”
CBDCs can be implemented in either authoritarian or democratic ways, with many current proposals in the United States, United Kingdom, and Europe aligning with OECD principles of 'CBDCs with democratic values' aimed at improving citizen lives rather than increasing government control.
“a cbdc is a technology that can be implemented in many different ways. Of course, it can be implemented in a highly authoritarian way, which we will talk about later in this video. But actually many of the current proposals in countries like the United States, the United Kingdom and Europe have more in common with what the OECD calls cbdcs, with democratic values, of which the main aim is to make the lives of citizens better rather than to increase government control.”
China's CBDC pilot project has already implemented money that expires, forcing spending rather than savings, as a mechanism to make economic stimulus more effective by guaranteeing stimulus checks are spent, though critics argue this reduces economic freedom.
“the Chinese CBDC pilot project included money that could expire, something that could make economic stimulus much more effective as it guarantees stimulus checks will actually be spent. But as critics pointed out, if your money can expire and therefore you have to spend it, this certainly reduces your freedom.”
CBDCs could make payments cheaper by eliminating intermediaries like Visa and MasterCard (reducing merchant transaction costs from up to 3.5%) and especially by reducing international transaction costs through cross-border CBDC projects like Project Dunbar, where banks can hold foreign central bank digital currencies directly, eliminating New York or London intermediary fees.
“by cutting out the middleman like Visa and MasterCard, the central bank digital currency payments could be quite a bit cheaper for merchants who now face transaction costs, sometimes up to 3.5%...Project Dunbar, Australia, South Africa, Malaysia and Singapore work together to give their banks access to the cbdcs of each other. So for example, in this project, an Australian bank could hold digital rands at the South African Reserve Bank and a South African bank could hold digital Australian dollars at the Reserve Bank of Australia. Therefore, if a South African wine exporter now wanted to export wine to Australia, its bank could just directly receive rands from the client's bank in Australia. And in the current model, this transaction between banks would likely have gone through intermediaries in New York or London, hence being quite a bit more expensive.”
CBDCs could improve safety by combining cash's role as an ultimate safe asset in crises with digital money's theft/loss resistance, achieving a three-star safety rating that exceeds both cash and private digital bank money, though this depends on design choices like holding limits.
“Remember that cash is the ultimate safe asset in a crisis and digital bank money is less likely to be stolen or lost. Well, A CBDC could actually combine both of these traits, and so it could score a three star rating here better than both cash and digital private bank money...financial stability concerns can be limited if people can only hold small sums of cbdc money as has been proposed in, for example, Europe and the United Kingdom.”
The European Central Bank updated its digital euro proposal to include pseudonymous offline payments and legislation safeguarding the role of cash, ensuring it remains widely accepted and easily accessible, moving the proposal closer to democratic CBDC principles in direct response to public concerns.
“Some of them, like the European Central Bank, have updated their proposals to reflect these concerns, moving their proposed CBDC closer to the CBDC with democratic values...the proposal for the digital euro now includes pseudo anonymous offline payments and is backed with a legislation that aims to safeguard the role of cash, ensure it's widely accepted as a means of payment and remains easily accessible for people and businesses across the euro area.”
During the Greek financial crisis, people queued at ATMs because they rediscovered that digital private bank money is fundamentally a promise to pay physical central bank money, making physical cash safer in financial crises when the promise cannot be fulfilled.
“if there is a financial crisis, people often rediscover that actually digital private bank money is a promise to pay physical central bank money. So in such a scenario, physical money is a way safer still in most cases.”
Russia's recent exclusion from Western banking systems demonstrates that relying on foreign banking infrastructure creates geopolitical vulnerability, motivating central bank investment in domestic CBDC infrastructure to reduce dependence on foreign financial institutions.
“After all, as Russia has recently found out the hard way, relying on the dominant banking systems of other countries can be quite risky. After all, if global payments run through foreign banking systems, then you can be excluded from those systems.”
Digital private bank money costs are hidden to consumers but fall on merchants through payment processing fees (the speaker notes they are not truly free), while cash costs to merchants (storage, administration, bank deposits) are substantial and ultimately paid by consumers through higher prices.
“As a consumer, you probably don't think it matters since both digital and cash payments appear to be free. However, from the merchants side, they most definitely are not free after. After all, cash needs to be stored safely administered and deposited at a bank every now and then. And all of that is actually quite expensive. On the flipside, a merchant does also pay a small fee to banks and card companies every time that you swipe your cards. And so you can be sure that actually as a consumer, you are probably paying slightly higher prices because merchants have these payment costs.”
Current digital bank money involves multiple data collectors—banks store transaction information, card companies like Visa and MasterCard keep transaction records, and governments have easy access if they suspect tax evasion, terrorism financing, or money laundering, receiving a one-star privacy score.
“If you pay for something while using your bank issued card, then various institutions are potentially getting access to this data. First of all, your bank stores, all of this information. And second, card companies like Visa and MasterCard also often keep records of transactions made with your card. Sure. In many cases, this data is never accessed by anyone. However, occasionally both banks and card companies have been caught selling or accidentally leaking data. But perhaps more importantly, governments have easy access to this data as well.”
Poorly designed CBDCs could be so clunky and inaccessible that they become less functional than private digital money, a concern economist and politicians have raised, though recent successes in India show governments can build payment systems people love.
“given that governments don't have a great track record of implementing good software, a poorly designed CBDC could be so clunky and bad that it ends up being a less accessible than private digital money...However, a simple counter-argument to these points would, of course, be that recent successes in India have shown that governments can actually build an online payment system that people love”
Cash is extremely accessible requiring only convincing someone to give it to you, whereas bank cards require identity verification, credit assessment, and legal compliance checks that exclude people engaged in legal but bank-perceived-risky activities or those without identity documents.
“As money, cash is extremely accessible, after all, to hold this piece of paper. All you need to do is convince someone to give it to you. However, if you want a card like this one, then you will need to convince a bank that you are who you say you are by presenting your I.D. and that you are not going to use it to do anything illegal.”
Online shopping is almost impossible with cash, requiring consumers to use digital payment methods, and merchants must choose payment methods based partly on transaction costs, which is why PayPal often appears lower on payment option lists despite being a payment choice.
“it's almost impossible to use cash to buy stuff online...why are some payment methods featured more prominently here than others? Well, as a small business owner, I can tell you that it has to do with the final money consideration, and that is costs. Where the reason that, for example, PayPal is often so low on your screen is that they charge ridiculous fees to merchants.”
Transaction fees in international payments are high because specialized messaging companies charge high fees and banks use multiple intermediaries (correspondent banks in financial centers like New York or London), increasing the number of fee-collecting intermediaries.
“a specialized messaging company that charges high fees is needed to make all of this work behind the scenes and to make this all even worse. Banks often use more intermediaries, such as correspondent banks in big financial centers like New York or London to make the foreign exchange transactions work behind the scenes, meaning that there will be even more fees.”
Physical cash usage is declining globally as digital payments become more convenient, with UK cash payments dropping from 55% in 2012 to 50% currently while card and other digital payments have rapidly increased.
“check out this graph from the United Kingdom where you can see that the value of cash payments has declined from 55% in 2012 to only 50% today. While card and other payments have rapidly increased.”
Fox News commentators like Dr. Monica Crowley argue CBDCs are designed to enable a cashless society where governments, political opponents, and the Fed gain control over all transaction data, potentially allowing selective transaction blocking based on political alignment or enforced spending restrictions like EV-only purchases or bug-based meat mandates.
“the ultimate objective is to move us to a cashless society so you will no longer have that hard asset of that $20 bill or a $10 bill. Your money will essentially be software. It will be a number in a program that the Fed, Treasury, the government, your political opponents will all have access to...this is about power and control because the government, such as it is, will have access to all of the information related to every single transaction you make. You buy a stick of gum. The government will know, you buy a new car, the government will know, you bought the wrong car, you didn't buy an EV. Now you're going to get penalized.”
The Bahamas launched the Sand Dollar as the first retail CBDC with explicit focus on accessibility, designed to provide financial services access to remote communities and unbanked populations who lack access to commercial banking.
“the first retail CBDC to ever be introduced, the Bahamas sent a dollar was introduced with accessibility in mind as they explained in their promotional video. In many of our remote communities. There's very limited access to financial services on a daily basis. It helps those unbanked members of our population who don't have access to commercial banking facilities.”
Nigeria's CBDC implementation includes anonymous cards purchasable in stores that can hold only small sums of money, achieving privacy equivalent to cash for small transactions while reducing fraud risk through holding limits.
“In Nigeria, which recently launched a Cbdc, you can buy CBDC cards that are almost completely anonymous and that can only hold small sums of money, making it equally private as cash for small transactions.”
The Canadian government forced private banks to freeze the bank accounts of truckers protesting COVID-19 vaccinations, demonstrating government use of banking system control for political purposes.
“in Canada, the government even forced private banks to freeze the bank accounts of truckers that were protesting against COVID 19 vaccinations.”
A democratically designed CBDC could protect people like Nigel Farage from being unbanked based on political beliefs by establishing universal equal accessibility without restrictions based on user profiles or usage conditions.
“the OECD writes that universal equal accessibility for all citizens to a digital version of sovereign currency are both prerequisites for this to happen. No undue restrictions should be imposed related to user profiles and or conditions to the use of CBDC seized by any and all citizens. In other words, a democratically designed CBDC could, in theory, protect people like Nigel Farage from being unbanked for having different political values”
The speaker explicitly urges continued critical vigilance on CBDCs to ensure they serve citizens rather than enable government control, positioning critical debate as necessary and valuable rather than as obstruction to progress.
“I hope that all of you will remain critical so that we end up with a cbdc that improves our lives rather than helping our governments to control it.”
The current public debate around CBDCs is characterized as 'a hot mess' where benefits are unclear to most people while valid privacy and financial stability concerns have been drowned out by sensationalized conspiracy theories.
“I've come to the conclusion that the current debate around CBDC is, frankly, a hot mess. On the one side, the benefits of Cbdcs are still not clear to most people. And on the other side, valid concerns about privacy and financial stability have been drowned out by hyper sensationalized conspiracy theories.”
The speaker watched numerous anti-CBDC conspiracy videos and found that they 'brought up a lot of good points,' indicating that while presented in sensationalized ways, critics raise valid underlying concerns about privacy and control that deserve serious consideration rather than dismissal.
“And while it may be easy to dismiss this as just another conspiracy, I did actually watch many of these types of videos and discovered that they brought up a lot of good points.”
For merchants, collecting digital payments saves significant administrative work and eliminates trips to the bank to deposit cash, making it more convenient than managing physical cash.
“Similarly, if you are a merchant, then collecting digital payments saves you a ton of administrative works and trips to the bank to deposit all of that cash.”
Consumers in recent surveys stated they appreciate having the option of cash available, even if they don't use it regularly, suggesting people value cash as an alternative to digital payments.
“in surveys they say that they do really appreciate the option that cash is around.”
A CBDC does not bring anything new in terms of convenience or online shopping benefits compared to private digital money, since digital payments already dominate online commerce.
“For convenience and online shopping, A CBDC does not bring anything new to the table and would be just as good as private digital money.”