What this covers

In this six-minute CNN commentary, Fareed Zakaria places the 2024 contest between Kamala Harris and Donald Trump inside a longer story. Drawing on his book Age of Revolutions, he ties the current realignment to decades of upheaval from globalization and the information revolution. He treats the election as a symptom of that shift and forecasts that the resulting cultural landscape will shape American politics for decades whoever wins. He also expects Harris could do better with white voters than Biden did, since gender and class now outweigh race.

The middle of the piece looks at race. Zakaria describes race as a durable factor since the Civil Rights era, then argues it is weakening. He cites gen forward polling showing a quarter of young Black men and 44% of young Latino men supporting Trump. He then turns to Democratic strategy. The Economist called the American economy the world's strongest, yet Biden's approval was weak, and the party's shift toward a populist left on tariffs and manufacturing subsidies has not won back non-college men. He notes that Bernie Sanders polls better with educated Democrats than with working-class voters.

The sharpest and most contested claims concern Democratic elites. Zakaria says they cling to the idea that the working class has been conned, when the party's real problem is having moved too far left on cultural issues. He adds that elites treat economics as a matter of choice and social questions as matters of rights, and that the party cannot explain its quiet shifts, such as on immigration. He sets Republican weaknesses against this: a Trump personality cult and a fundraising gap in the most economically vibrant areas. The Hulk Hogan appearance at the RNC serves as his shorthand for the cultural appeal gap.

Sharpest takeaway

The speaker argues that American politics are undergoing a fundamental realignment away from economic class toward social class (defined by education), with new dividing lines around education, geography, religion, and gender replacing traditional race and economics-based voting patterns.

  • College education now better predicts voting behavior than race or income, creating a professional-secular-female left and less-educated-rural-religious-male right
  • Black and Hispanic men are moving to Republicans in historic numbers, contradicting the assumption that economic self-interest drives voting
  • Democratic policy shifts on economics have failed to win back working-class voters because the real divide is now cultural, not economic

The claims · ranked21 claims · weighted by value

This asset isn't compiled yet

You're seeing its claims, ranked. Compile it to build the argument threads, weight them, and check each claim against your library — the full view.

0.71

In 'Age of Revolutions,' the speaker argues that decades of revolutionary change—including massive expansion of globalization and the information revolution—have upended politics, creating a realignment in which old categories of economic status and race are giving way to new categories like social status and cultural divides around gender.

factualhigh valuecontestednovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Unidentified Speaker — Fareed Zakaria explains why we are seeing a political reali… [DQJIRE2cZFU]

“in my latest book age of revolutions I argue that Decades of revolutionary change the massive expansion of globalization the information revolution have upended our politics we're seeing a realignment in which the old categories of econ economic status and race are giving way to new categories like social status and cultural divides around gender”

0.71

It is likely that we are at the beginning of a transformation of the political landscape, moving from a period where it was relatively easy to predict a person's voting pattern based on economics (rich and upper middle class voting right, poor and working class voting left) to a new era where social class defined by college education becomes the primary predictor.

forecasthigh valuecontestednovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Unidentified Speaker — Fareed Zakaria explains why we are seeing a political reali… [DQJIRE2cZFU]

“we are likely at the beginning of this transformation of the political landscape it used to be relatively easy to predict a person's voting pattern based on economics the rich and upper middle class voted right the poor and working class voted left”

0.69

For the Democrats, the problem is that non-college-educated voters still make up the majority—around 65% of registered voters in 2020—and they may feel alienated by some of the ivy league liberalism, regardless of whether Harris or Trump wins.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Unidentified Speaker — Fareed Zakaria explains why we are seeing a political reali… [DQJIRE2cZFU]

“for the Democrats the problem is that non college educated voters still make up the majority around 65% of registered voters in 2020 and they may feel alienated by some of the ivy league liberalism”

0.66

Today, a more prominent divide than race exists in America: professionals appear far more likely to vote for Harris, and blue-collar working-class voters have become the new solid base of the Republican party.

factualhigh valuecontestednovelty 2/4durability 2/4· Unidentified Speaker — Fareed Zakaria explains why we are seeing a political reali… [DQJIRE2cZFU]

“but today there seems to be a more prominent divide than race professionals appear far more likely to vote for Harris and blue collar workingclass voters have become the new solid base of the Republican party”

0.66

New divisions around social class, gender, geography, and religion are even overwhelming the deepest of divides: race and ethnicity, with more and more Black and Hispanic men finding themselves comfortable with the Republican party, especially pronounced among young people.

factualhigh valuecontestednovelty 2/4durability 2/4· Unidentified Speaker — Fareed Zakaria explains why we are seeing a political reali… [DQJIRE2cZFU]

“these new divisions are even overwhelming those deepest of divides race and ethnicity more and more Black and Hispanic men are finding themselves comfortable with the Republic Republican party and it's especially pronounced with young people”

0.66

The Great Divide in America today is not economic class but social class defined by college education, with other strong predictors of voting behavior being gender, geography, and religion.

factualhigh valuecontestednovelty 2/4durability 2/4· Unidentified Speaker — Fareed Zakaria explains why we are seeing a political reali… [DQJIRE2cZFU]

“you see the Great Divide in America today is not economic class but social class defined by college education the other strong predictors of a person's voting behavior other than College education are gender geography and religion”

0.66

Race was a durable political factor after the Civil Rights Movement, with white people disproportionately voting for Republicans and people of color largely voting Democratic, but this stability is now being disrupted.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 0/4durability 3/4· Unidentified Speaker — Fareed Zakaria explains why we are seeing a political reali… [DQJIRE2cZFU]

“race was another durable Factor after the Civil Rights Movement white people disproportionately voted for republic Republicans people of color largely voted Democratic”

0.61

Democratic elites do not want to believe that their problem is not that they moved too far right on economic policy but rather that they moved too far left on social and cultural issues.

factualhigh valuecontestednovelty 1/4durability 2/4· Unidentified Speaker — Fareed Zakaria explains why we are seeing a political reali… [DQJIRE2cZFU]

“Democratic Elites do not want to believe that their problem is not that they move too far right on economic policy but rather that they move too far left on social and cultural issues”

0.61

Democratic elites have been slow to understand the shift in the political landscape, persisting in believing that the working class is somehow deluded or has been conned by the right into voting against its own interests.

factualhigh valuecontestednovelty 1/4durability 2/4· Unidentified Speaker — Fareed Zakaria explains why we are seeing a political reali… [DQJIRE2cZFU]

“Democratic Elites have been slow to understand the shift they have persisted in believing that the workingclass is somehow deluded or has been conned by the right into voting against its own interests”

0.59

The Biden administration's economic policies were specifically designed to benefit the working class made up largely of men without college degrees, and these policies have disproportionately benefited this group, yet the Democratic nominee is on track to receive the lowest share of this group's votes in decades with a deficit nine points worse than Biden's in 2020.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 1/4· Unidentified Speaker — Fareed Zakaria explains why we are seeing a political reali… [DQJIRE2cZFU]

“the Biden administration's economic policies have been specifically designed to benefit the working class made up largely of men without a college degree and they' have disproportionately benefited this group and yet the Democratic nominee is on track to receive the lowest share of this group's votes in decades with a deficit nine points worth than Biden's in 2020 according to New York Times polls”

0.59

The Economist's cover story highlighted that the American economy is the strongest in the world and the envy of the world, yet this economic success has not translated into political rewards for President Biden, who had the second worst third-year average approval rating of any modern president.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 1/4· Unidentified Speaker — Fareed Zakaria explains why we are seeing a political reali… [DQJIRE2cZFU]

“last week's cover of The Economist was a special report on the American economy the headline the Envy of the world yet the strongest economy in the world has not paid off for President Biden who had the second worst third-year average approval rating of any modern president”

0.59

Under Biden, the Democratic party made a broad shift to the populist left on economic policy, from tariffs to manufacturing subsidies, yet this has not wooed back the working class, and polling has often shown that Bernie Sanders and his economic policies are much more popular with educated elites in the Democratic party than with working-class voters.

factualhigh valuecontestednovelty 2/4durability 1/4· Unidentified Speaker — Fareed Zakaria explains why we are seeing a political reali… [DQJIRE2cZFU]

“that's why the party under Biden has made a broad shift to the populist left on economic policy from tariffs to manufacturing sub subsidies and yet it has not wooed back the working class in fact polling has often shown that Bernie Sanders and his economic policies are much more popular with the educated Elites in the Democratic party than with workingclass voters”

0.55

For Democratic elites, economic policy is a matter of choice—practical decisions that can easily be changed—while social issues are a matter of core rights, and to be against them is to be a bad and bigoted person.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Unidentified Speaker — Fareed Zakaria explains why we are seeing a political reali… [DQJIRE2cZFU]

“you see for them economic policy is a matter of choice practical decisions that can easily be changed social issues are a matter of core rights and to be against them is to be a bad and bigoted person”

0.55

Whether Harris or Trump wins, the new cultural landscape will define American politics for decades to come.

forecasthigh valuecontestednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Unidentified Speaker — Fareed Zakaria explains why we are seeing a political reali… [DQJIRE2cZFU]

“whether Harris or Trump wins this new cultural landscape will Define American politics for decades to come”

0.53

The Republican party is enthralled to a personality cult of Donald Trump whose extreme positions and rhetoric turn off many voters, particularly in the most economically vibrant parts of America that are trending left.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 0/4durability 1/4· Unidentified Speaker — Fareed Zakaria explains why we are seeing a political reali… [DQJIRE2cZFU]

“the right has its own problems it is enthralled to a personality Cult of Donald Trump whose extreme positions and rhetoric turn off many voters with the most economically vibrant parts of America trending left”

0.53

Harris has outraised Trump in donations in recent months by more than 3 to 1 margins in September, reflecting that the most economically vibrant parts of America are trending left.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 0/4durability 1/4· Unidentified Speaker — Fareed Zakaria explains why we are seeing a political reali… [DQJIRE2cZFU]

“Harris has far outraised Trump in donations in recent months by more than 3 to1 margins in September”

0.51

Polling shows that Black and Hispanic men are moving away from the Democratic party in historic numbers, with a recent gen forward poll finding that a quarter of young black men and 44% of young Latino men are voting for Trump.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 1/4· Unidentified Speaker — Fareed Zakaria explains why we are seeing a political reali… [DQJIRE2cZFU]

“a recent gen forward poll had a quarter of young black men and 44% of young Latino men voting for Trump”

0.51

The new party bases in America consist of an educated, urban, secular, and female left and a less educated, rural, religious, and male right.

factualhigh valuecontestednovelty 1/4durability 2/4· Unidentified Speaker — Fareed Zakaria explains why we are seeing a political reali… [DQJIRE2cZFU]

“the new party bases in America are an educated Urban secular and female left and a less educated rural religious and male right”

0.45

Kamala Harris, a biracial woman, may yet receive more of the white vote than did Joe Biden, an old white guy, because social class and gender trump race in determining voting patterns.

forecasthigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 1/4· Unidentified Speaker — Fareed Zakaria explains why we are seeing a political reali… [DQJIRE2cZFU]

“Kamala Harris a biracial woman May yet receive more of the white vote than did Joe Biden an old white guy professional white women see themselves represented by Harris because social class and gender Trump race”

0.45

Even when Democrats quietly shift policy on issues like immigration, they cannot bring themselves to articulate why they are making these changes, preventing them from regaining credibility with voters who have moved away.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 2/4· Unidentified Speaker — Fareed Zakaria explains why we are seeing a political reali… [DQJIRE2cZFU]

“and so even when Democrats quietly shift policy as they did on immigration they cannot bring themselves to articulate why”

0.39

The appeal of figures like Hulk Hogan tearing off his shirt at the RNC may hold more appeal to working-class voters than talk of unisex bathrooms and gender-affirming treatments.

causalhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 1/4· Unidentified Speaker — Fareed Zakaria explains why we are seeing a political reali… [DQJIRE2cZFU]

“Hulk Hogan tearing off his shirt at the RNC May hold more appeal than talk of unisex bathrooms and gender affirming treatments”