
Friedman on the “Two Chinas” and How Putin Saves Face
What this covers
This is a conversation between George Friedman and Ed D'Agostino, host of a Mauldin Economics interview series. It moves through three theaters: the war in Ukraine, the state of China, and the overlapping conflicts in the Middle East. Friedman's Ukraine discussion turns on what Vladimir Putin wants. He ties Putin's outlook to his years as a KGB officer in Germany when the Wall fell, and to his view of the Soviet collapse as a catastrophe. Friedman says a Russian win that put its forces at the border of NATO members such as Poland, Romania, and Hungary would recreate Cold War conditions, and he argues Putin would then have reason to push further west. That claim is contested. He also explains why Ukraine, as a mainly infantry army with thin logistics and air support, cannot mount major offensives into Russia. The closing segment looks at what the United States got right in Ukraine.
The China material is the longest and the most contested. Friedman describes two Chinas, a prosperous coast around Shanghai and a poor interior, and treats this coastal-interior divide) as a problem that Mao and Deng Xiaoping never solved and that Xi Jinping has inherited. He argues that an export-based economy cannot be sustained without owning the customers, compares China to Japan's lost decade, and calls its superpower image an illusion built on fake growth. He raises the historical pattern of coastal-versus-interior civil war, and he argues that Western observers wrongly project coherence and single-leader control onto China. He also explains why he thinks China will not invade Taiwan: the crossing of an amphibious assault would take long enough for US satellites and Guam-based missiles to destroy the fleet.
The last stretch covers the Middle East, which Friedman describes as several overlapping conflicts rather than a two-sided war. He treats October 2023 as an intelligence failure that ended Israeli claims of infallibility. He argues that Hamas must be destroyed militarily, that the war may not end quickly, and that Israel will eventually face concessions it has long resisted, including a Palestinian state.
Friedman argues that three major geopolitical crises—the unresolved Russia-Ukraine stalemate, China's structural economic collapse and potential internal fragmentation, and Israel's vulnerability following intelligence failures—will reshape global power dynamics and require fundamental strategic recalibrations by the United States.
- Russia cannot make peace without a battlefield victory but has failed to achieve one after two years, trapping the conflict in a costly stalemate that none of the parties can sustain
- China's export-dependent economy is unsustainable and has reached a crisis point comparable to historic Chinese civil wars, making it unable to support great power ambitions
- Israel's myth of invincibility has been shattered by the October 2023 intelligence failure, forcing a psychological reckoning and eventual political settlement with Palestinians
This asset isn't compiled yet
You're seeing its claims, ranked. Compile it to build the argument threads, weight them, and check each claim against your library — the full view.
Historically, China has frequently experienced civil wars that were fought between the interior agricultural regions and coastal regions; a similar dynamic could emerge if the current system fragments.
“what probably happens in the history of China is Civil War China historically has been filled with Civil War and the Civil War has been in general between the interior part of the company Agricultural and the coastal region Mount Tong came from the coastal region on a long march into the agricultural region came back took the country”
When an exporting power's customers either lack resources to buy or lose interest in its goods, the exporting economy faces collapse, as demonstrated by Japan's lost decade and the pattern that is now occurring with China.
“when you have an exporting power you're looking at an accident that will happen they are dependent on this internal cap ability of their customers and when the customers either no longer have the resources to buy or when they're not interested or whatever some fad we saw Japan have its lost year lost decade uh this is what happens with exporters”
The Middle East conflict is not a two-sided war between Israel and Hamas, but rather a series of overlapping conflicts: Hamas versus Israel, Iran-Iraq historical enmity, and Houthi attacks on shipping.
“the divisions among the Arabs or islamists or whatever you want to call them um no one came to help Hamas there was expectation of the Iranians sending up they got no help they were left out there to be hammered by the Israelis so the thing to understand about the region is that this is not a two-sided War there is the war against Israel by one faction Hamas and then Wars uh for example between Iran and Iraq which had been going on for a long time and them hitting each other and then there are the hoodies who are sinking ships”
Israel cannot deny that it had an intelligence failure in 2023 because it was the second major failure in 50 years, meaning the Israeli intelligence community can no longer claim infallibility and must acknowledge the possibility of error.
“so this is the second time and they can't deny it that they had this intelligence failure and as a result of that had to do things they shouldn't have done in Gaza and elsewhere”
Israeli intelligence and military organizations must be prepared for bad news at all times and cannot afford to be off guard even internally; however, this constant vigilance is very difficult to sustain, making some level of surprise inevitable.
“the problem of a nation and an intelligence organization it has to be prepared at all times for bad news and that's very hard to be so Israel cannot be on line all the time just internally and the pressure is going to grow inside of Israel for a permanent settlement”
Deng Xiaoping was perceived as very successful because he stabilized China, but he did not solve the fundamental problems dividing the country (coastal-interior divide), leaving those problems for his successors.
“D xao pin came in everybody called him very successful yes he was except he hadn't solved the fundamental problems dividing the country and it has now been left to poor G to try to figure out how to get out of this”
The collapse of the Soviet Union was described by Putin as the greatest disaster in history, and Putin was a KGB officer in Germany when the Wall came down, creating a formative memory that shapes his view of Soviet collapse and desire to restore the Russian Empire.
“Putin once said that the collapse of the Soviet Union was the greatest disaster in history when he spoke toiet union he didn't mean just Russia he meant the Russian Empire he was a KGB officer in Germany when the Wall came down and he's always remembered that moment I think”
The US perspective on China treats it as an organized country with a single leader in a Western manner, but China has a very different history and structure; it is not organized this way and Western projections of coherence onto China are inaccurate.
“we think of China as as an organized country with a single leader and very much Western it isn't it is a country with a very different history”
China needs American investment to resolve its economic crisis, and the US offers two negotiating positions: one demands China become a de facto US vessel; the other asks China to accept US investment with US government guarantees, which China cannot politically accept because either option is too costly.
“right now the situation is that they have to talk to the Americans there are meetings going on between the Americans and the Chinese XI does not appear to be at the meetings but he's somewhere I assume but the real question is they need American Investment the only thing that's going to bail them out here is investment and they can't gener domestically so are the Americans interested yes we want everything from them all their weapons all their wives everything that are available we want them taken immediately Americans are very reasonable negotiators so the problem they have is the American price essentially is becoming sort of a vassel of the United States Chinese can't do that the Chinese price uh is that the United States invest and they guarantee those Investments which is not worth much”
The Middle East is characterized by constantly shifting alliances and internal pressures from new groups, making stability impossible and requiring continuous security vigilance.
“the problem is that nothing is permanent in the region nothing is permanent anywhere but in this region you have constantly shifting alliances internal pressures by new groups and so on so whatever is promised this week if is Promised may not be true next week”
Israel suffered a massive intelligence failure in October 2023 when Hamas attacked from Gaza, which is particularly shocking because Gaza is immediately across the street from Israel and Hamas must have been preparing for months.
“you have to understand that on the other hand you have to understand this this is the second time that Israel has had had a massive intelligence failure in 1973 the Egyptians and the syrians attacked Israel and their intelligence organization didn't see a massive formation developing the same thing happened here Gaza South Gaza is across the street you know they must have been working for months”
The United States has shifted its military strategy to focus heavily on China and has built an extensive alliance system (Philippines, Papua New Guinea, Indonesia, Australia) that creates a continuous blocking position against Chinese expansion.
“the US military stance which has been heavily focused on China the United States has formed allines of the Philippines Papua New Guinea we have a blocking system all the way to the Lucian Islands down to Australia”
There are two distinct economic and social regions in China: the prosperous coastal areas (like Shanghai) engaged in global business, and the impoverished interior regions (the north) trapped in third-world poverty; this fundamental divide has not been bridged despite attempts by previous leaders.
“there are two Chinas there's China that you see in Shanghai there's the one you see way to the north China is in that part a poor country of extreme third world poverty the other one is doing business deals all over the world so that that's the division and that's the old division in China”
Previous Chinese leaders including Mao and Deng Xiaoping were unable to permanently solve the fundamental problems dividing China, and this challenge has now been inherited by Xi Jinping, suggesting the underlying structural contradictions are potentially insurmountable.
“that Ma try to suppress and the great and greatly forward in various other operations he couldn't do it quite but he created Terror D xao pin came in everybody called him very successful yes he was except he hadn't solved the fundamental problems dividing the country and it has now been left to poor G to try to figure out how to get out of this”
Hamas's attack on Israel was particularly brutal in targeting children as hostages and parading them internally, which the Israeli state found particularly difficult to handle.
“Hamas attacked in as ruthless and brutal a way as it could doing the one thing that the israelit couldn't handle children as hostages and parading them internally”
Despite being militarily capable, China will not invade Taiwan because an amphibious assault would take a minimum of 10 hours to cross, during which US satellites would detect the fleet and Guam-based anti-ship missiles could destroy it.
“An amphibious assault against Taiwan would take a minimum of 10 hours to cross during that time the US satellites would see that fleet. Guam is loaded with anti-ship missiles that could take them out”
Ukraine cannot launch major offensive operations into Russian territory because it is primarily an infantry army with limited logistics capability and air support, and major offensive operations require much more sophisticated combined arms coordination than defensive warfare.
“to go on offensive there has to be a much more sophisticated Ukrainian Force defense defending is relatively easy attacking is hard because you have to deliver your Logistics get them there on time coordinate with air strikes everything else the Ukrainian Army is an infantry Army that has been quite good at a defensive position”
China cannot sustain reliable economic growth because it is based primarily on exports, and you cannot sustain an export-based economy unless you own the countries you are exporting to—which China does not.
“this is why we forecast a while ago that China can't sustain its growth because you cannot sustain reliably uh an Economy based primarily on export s unless you own the countries you're exporting to and they don't and the United States had the Great Depression and what we're having now is a greater depression in in China”
Israel will be forced to make concessions it never thought it would make, including an independent Palestinian state and redefinition of Jerusalem and Mount ownership, because it can no longer simply brush aside these demands.
“Israel has to make a political settlement to stop it and it has to make concessions it never thought it would make what might those concessions look like an independent Palestinian State a redefinition of Jerusalem of what and the mount and these things these have been things that the Israelites have been able to brush aside you know simply saying no we're not going to do that they're entering a world in which they can't just brush it aside”
China's appearance as a superpower is an illusion built on fake growth that lacked real infrastructure and coherent financial systems beneath it, making China's capacity actually much weaker than commonly believed.
“the problem that I saw was that in the beginning that China was an illusion China had its ability but there was no infrastructure beneath it no Financial system that was coherent underneath it and while it showed enormous growth a lot of that was fake not in the sense that it didn't happen but in the sense that it was based on a a hill of sand”
If Russia were to win and take territory at the border of Ukraine, it would immediately face NATO countries (Poland, Romania, Hungary), recreating Cold War conditions, and Putin would have strong incentives to push further into Western Europe.
“if Russia suddenly broke out and took position on the border of Ukraine it would be facing Poland Romania Hungary NATO we would be back in the Cold War now remember that Putin once said that the collapse of the Soviet Union was the greatest disaster in history when he spoke to the soviet union he didn't mean just Russia he meant the Russian Empire he was a KGB officer in Germany when the Wall came down and he's always remembered that moment I think and so the problem is that if he wins in Ukraine and really opens the door uh he has every motive to go farther”
There cannot be peace with Hamas externally; Israel must destroy Hamas as a military force, which is why Israel's military campaign is focused on eliminating Hamas to send a message to other Arab parties about the costs of attacking Israel.
“there cannot be a peace with Hamas externally has got to be one there got to be some sort of understanding and and this is frequently the pr of War which is the anger so deep that the war can't end it goes on Israel's intention is to destroy Hamas that's why he's going to the north to destroy Hamas so that the messageer sent to the other Arab parties that this is what happens to you if you attack us”
The war between Israel and Hamas cannot end quickly because the anger is so deep and mutual that perpetual conflict becomes a probable outcome unless political settlement intervenes.
“this is frequently the pr of War which is the anger so deep that the war can't end it goes on”
The only way Ukraine would go on offensive into Russia is if the United States directly sent American forces to fight, which is not going to happen.
“the only way to go into Russia is the Americans going into Russia and that's not going to happen”
The Chinese government is conducting major internal security crackdowns including lockdowns and checking people's homes, which combined with the economic crisis may trigger internal conflict or civil war.
“there's also unrest developing inside of China all sorts of demonstrations uh major lockdowns on security going into people's houses checking them for what they have there and so on so you have the situation there where China must break out of its seclusion and can't”
Some Israelis are seeking US visas, indicating a loss of confidence in Israel's future stability and suggesting potential capital flight and brain drain from the country.
“I would guess from some friends of mine they're seeking visas to the United States”
The US military is the most capable in the world, possessing the most sophisticated naval power, most sophisticated air force, and largest army, giving it deterrent power against direct confrontation.
“basically our military force is highly capable the most capable in the world um it has the most sophisticated Naval power most sophisticated Air Force and largest army so I mean when you look at everything there's a reason why Taiwan was never invaded they wouldn't risk it”
Egypt has been hurt economically by reduction in traffic through the Suez Canal due to Houthi attacks, yet has maintained relative quiet on the Israeli border, suggesting Egyptian calculation of interests.
“you know if anything Egypt's being hurt because of traffic not going through the Suez Canal it seems like there might be a willingness at least on the part of some countries in the Middle East to accept that Israel is here”
Many banks in the United States and globally invested directly or indirectly in China or made bets on its growth; if China does not recover, these exposures represent significant losses across the financial system.
“a lot of banks including in the United States if they did not invest directly they invested indirectly or laid a bed on on something it's a lot of money out there”
The United States lacks sufficient munitions stockpiles to support Ukraine indefinitely, but the Ukraine strategy of arming a motivated ally to do the fighting resulted in very minimal American casualties (only two CIA operatives killed) compared to the cost of direct American military involvement.
“we would have had to act to block the Ukraine the Russians no matter what we came up with a solution in which only two Americans from the CIA have been killed in this war and it was actually a very very bright solution they had a motivated enemy uh friend they gave him all the weapons they could and no no losses so really when our strategy was very good it's tapped our ability to have shells and Rockets and so on but it's other wind would have done the same and then worse”
China pulled the world out of a global recession in 2007-2008, so the inverse question of whether the world can avoid recession if China collapses is fundamentally important.
“if you think back to 2007 8 n i mean China pulled the world out of a global recession uh is the opposite true can can can the world avoid a recession if China doesn't have growth”
The attack on Israel came from the Lebanon area from groups that did not ask Lebanese permission to use Lebanese territory, suggesting external interference in internal politics.
“and the attack came from the north from the Lebanon area that always had good relations and the people who attack didn't ask Lebanese if they could they could use their territory”
Hamas's attack has demonstrated that Israel can be beaten or at least hurt very badly, in contrast to the 1973 war where Egyptian and Syrian forces were quickly bottled up and defeated.
“what Hamas has done is revealed that it's monstrous but Israel can be beaten or at least hurt very badly the Egyptians and the syrians didn't manage to do that they were find very quickly bottled up this one is still going on”
The United States supports Ukraine primarily because it prefers to fight Russia there on Ukrainian territory rather than face direct armor battles in Poland or the NATO heartland.
“and that's one of the reasons the Americans are so eager to support them to support Ukraine because they'd rather fight them there in the Ukrainian grounds than have a swirling armor battle in Poland or something like that in the middle of those politicians the Americans want to se peace they really had enough of this but the Russians are not ready to make a peace under the current circumstances”
The UAE will be a significant power after Middle East conflict resolution because it will lend the money needed for reconstruction and will demand a restructured Middle East that serves its economic interests.
“and when you with this over they're going to be lending the money that's going to save everybody else and they are going to want a very different Middle East so I'm looking at UAE as being a very significant player”
No Arab country came to Hamas's aid despite expectations that Iran might intervene; Hamas was left to face Israel alone, demonstrating the weakness of Arab solidarity.
“the things I remember is the divisions among the Arabs or islamists or whatever you want to call them um no one came to help Hamas there was expectation of the Iranians sending up they got no help they were left out there to be hammered by the Israelis”
The universal belief that China would inevitably rise as a superpower has now evaporated, and investors who were eager to capture China's growth are now trying to exit their investments.
“the prospect of what China was going to become that for some reason was universally believed uh has really gone way and all of the people who wanted to get to China are trying to get out all the investors”
The current military situation on the ground in Ukraine is a stalemate that has existed for two years, in which Russia has never achieved a position to completely dominate Ukraine and crush its military, and Ukraine has never faced defeat.
“the problem is stalemate is a defeat for Russia it it's right now we are in stalemate we have been for two years and at no point did the Russians get into a position to completely dominate Ukraine and crushes military at no time did the ukrainians face defeat”
China's debt levels by an order of magnitude exceed the debt levels the United States had in 2007, and China also faces an active real estate crisis and stock market pressure.
“I've been doing a lot of work on the economics of China and the amount of Leverage amount of debt in their system eclipses by an order of magnitude the amount of debt that we had in our system in 2007 uh so you've got a real estate crisis underway there you've got a stock market that's under a lot of pressure”
China is not currently at the point where civil war will happen immediately, and it may not happen, but it will not be settled in a clean way; the government will try to hold together as long as possible before factional conflict emerges.
“It's very hard to say that there's going to be civil war but on the other hand when you sit down and exclude everything else that's possible you take see this as they're going to have to fight with each other to settle this and they're going to try to hold together as long as possible but the problem that I saw was that in the beginning that China was an illusion”
Israel has a built-in culture born of historical successes that creates an illusion of regional invincibility and superpower status, despite actually being a moderately capable regional power.
“Israel has a built-in culture built out of successes that sees itself as kind of a regional superpower and economically in other ways it really is but it also built a illusion of being invincible and that really hurts okay so when that breaks then the people have to redefine who they are”
China is threatening Taiwan invasion constantly and publicly, which is strategically stupid because successful amphibious invasions are not telegraphed in advance—the Japanese succeeded by attacking without warning, whereas announcing intentions allows time for preparation.
“the Chinese won't do it is another reason the Chinese won't do it if you're going to invade somebody from sea Do not announce it beforehand they have been announcing this war forever and everybody's been backing them up in the in the western media but you come out of nowhere like the Japanese did”
US military doctrine has evolved to be more sophisticated than the Vietnam approach of directly throwing American forces into combat; the Ukraine model of supporting willing local defenders is the new template.
“but we've also now reached a point of sophistication unlike Vietnam where we throw our own forces directly into the cauldron and start taking casualties and then up the anti we are more subtle in terms of how we handle the battle and I think the Ukraine model is going to be one we'll be looking at for a long time if they won't defend themselves do not join them if they will defend themselves send everything you got”
The solution to China's crisis requires American investment, but large American corporations can invest anywhere and are unwilling to accept the risk of investing in China where CEOs frequently disappear, unless the Chinese government provides major subsidies.
“the real question is they need American Investment the only thing that's going to bail them out here is investment and they can't gener domestically so are the Americans interested yes we want everything from them all their weapons all their wives everything that are available we want them taken immediately Americans are very reasonable negotiators so the problem they have is the American price essentially is becoming sort of a vassel of the United States Chinese can't do that the Chinese price uh is that the United States invest and they guarantee those Investments which is not worth much”
China has reached the same structural position as the United States after the Civil War—an exporting power that generated 50% of world exports—which created unsustainable dependence on foreign demand and eventually led to the Great Depression.
“they've arrived at the place that the United States did after the Civil War after the Civil War we started being an exporting power and we did very well 50% of the world's GDP uh sorry 50% of the world's exports came from the US until World War I broke out and nobody could buy any and we went into Great Depression so when you have an exporting power you're looking at an accident that will happen they are dependent on this internal cap ability of their customers”
Putin needs a battlefield victory to make peace because he has spent significant time, money, and lives in the invasion attempt, and without a visible win he cannot justify the war domestically or make peace as equals with Ukraine.
“Putin needs a win to make peace he spent a lot of time a lot of money a lot of lives and he's failed to defeat the Ukrainians that's embarrassing so what he's trying to do and I don't think we're unwilling to help him is to score a win and use that as a basis for a settlement”
Europe and the United States are more resilient during economic crises than commonly believed, whereas China lacks this resilience and is in genuine trouble, creating a fundamental asymmetry in crisis management.
“Europe and the United States are far more resilient than Americans like to believe uh we're an operatic country there always the fat lady dying oh my God oh my God but that doesn't happen China doesn't have that Comfort this is not fooling around they're really in trouble”
Xi Jinping came to power during China's economic miracle when it appeared China would economically overwhelm the world, but has since created a disaster because he pursued both foreign economic expansion and aggressive foreign policy simultaneously—a combination that is economically impossible.
“he came in as the Prime Minister as the president of a time when they were the economic Miracle of the world where it was clear that they were going to overwhelm the world with everything you know invade the United States and with everything that he at this point has created a disaster now it's not really his fault is not an economic policy that could have been averted you cannot build your economy on foreign purchases and maintain an aggressive foreign policy at the same time”
China's involvement in the Ukraine conflict is very limited because over the past two years China's economy has deteriorated significantly and it can no longer afford to maintain expensive military capabilities like its naval fleet.
“very little but when the conflict began China was a much more important country what has happened over the past two years has been the dysfunction of the Chinese economy to a point that it cannot support many other things for example uh the naval capability that it has okay it's quite expensive to maintain they're not doing that”
Israel can be angry and pursue the destruction of Hamas, but if this makes Israel appear weak and foundering, the regional actors will interpret weakness as opportunity to probe further, creating a self-defeating cycle.
“Israel's intention is to destroy Hamas that's why he's going to the north to destroy Hamas so that the messageer sent to the other Arab parties that this is what happens to you if you attack us the problem is that what they saw was not the destruction of Hamas that they saw Israel weak in foundering now I learned this from my schoolyard in the Bronx even if you're going to be be beat up do not cry do not look weak do not do that and so the problem is with the Israelis is a weakness has been revealed and they're going to keep poking at that weakness”
China faces paralysis in its geopolitical options because every upside option (like a military victory against India) carries huge downside risks, and the upside gains are insufficient to justify the risks, preventing decisive action.
“every one of its options on the upside has a huge downside if they hit that and so what you've noticed is paralysis they're not quite able to get themselves together because you sit there and you say okay what are the risks rewards and the rewards are there but are not big enough to float them the risk there is high enough to sink them”
As a result of the intelligence failure, Israel was forced to undertake military operations it shouldn't have done in Gaza and elsewhere, suggesting desperation rather than strategic confidence.
“they are now facing the fact that they are a small country in the Middle East and they can be surprised and can they can be out thought so the Israeli went into this war with the SS you know 1973 was kind of an out outrider they are now facing the fact that they are a small country in the Middle East and they can be surprised and can they can be out thought so the Israeli perception of themselves was not Superman that other states it it simply was we are a highly competent modern military the Arabs or not will take them yeah but at what price now so this is the second time and they can't deny it that they had this intelligence failure and as a result of that had to do things they shouldn't have done in Gaza”
Netanyahu is not going to remain in political charge for long, and the next Israeli leader will face a painful question: whether Israel can survive in its current position in the Middle East or whether it has become confused about its identity and position.
“Netanyahu is incapable politically of making a decision so the next question is who replaces him and does that person understand that we've seen the weakness sounds like that's the only way that a resolution can even begin to stop start is that by having a a political a regime change”
China's military position has shifted to a purely defensive mode, and while China may make threats, these should be dismissed as bluster rather than serious military intentions.
“the military Dimension has shifted to a purely defensive mode for the Chinese so but they will threaten you will hear threats please ignore them”
There is an internal political crisis in Israel over identity and security where citizens must redefine who Israel is and what position it holds regionally, moving from the illusion of invincibility to realistic assessment.
“an internal battle that's shaping up in Israel because Netanyahu is not going to be in charge for long and the question that they're going to have is a very painful one one are we in a position to survive in this region two have we forgotten who we were which is a small country trying to hang on and confuse ourselves into superpower so that's an internal crisis inside of Israel a psychological crisis where the sense of security dissolves”
Guaranteeing peace in the Middle East is a terrible idea for the United States, representing one of the worst possible foreign policy commitments.
“and I would say that is about as bad an idea as there can be guaranteeing peace in the Middle East very bad”
This US military containment system for China happened on Xi Jinping's watch and he was unable to stop it, suggesting China's loss of strategic initiative.
“now when you take a look at that that was that happened on X's watch and they couldn't really stop it”
The illusion that the United States was not more militarily powerful than China was always amusing, as evidenced by the fact that the 7th Fleet is deployed in the region and China will not engage it.
“the illusion that the United States wasn't was always amusing but the seventh fleet is out there and they're not going to mess with it”
Mao came from the coastal region, led a long march into the agricultural interior, and then returned to take the country, establishing the historical pattern of civil war in China between coastal and interior regions.
“Mount Tong came from the coastal region on a long march into the agricultural region came back took the country”
Taiwan was never invaded because China would not risk military confrontation with the US, and the US has the capability to deter such an invasion.
“there's a reason why Taiwan was never invaded they wouldn't risk it”