
Space is dead: A challenge to the standard model of quantum mechanics | Lee Smolin | Big Think
What this covers
This is a single-speaker talk in which Lee Smolin argues for a realist reading of quantum mechanics. He defines realism as the view that the world has an exactly understandable state independent of our knowledge or intervention, so that any event admits a complete causal description. He sets this against anti-realism, which holds that such ambition is too great because our concepts come from macroscopic experience. On that view science should describe only what happens when we measure and interact with atomic systems. Smolin traces the historical background: anti-realism was the prevailing outlook among educated Europeans in the 1920s and 1930s, and the standard formulation settled around 1927 along those lines and became the textbook version.
The middle of the talk covers the physics that anti-realism leaves unexplained. Smolin describes Niels Bohr's complementarity and Louis de Broglie's extension of wave-particle duality to electrons. He notes that standard theory gives only probability distributions, for example for where a photoelectric electron is found or when a nucleus decays. Pilot wave theory, developed in the same years, posits real waves and real particles guided by them. Smolin says it reproduces the standard predictions and explains how, why and when individual events occur.
The contentious part concerns entanglement and locality. Smolin recounts how Einstein found entanglement while trying to expose a logical flaw in quantum theory, and how Bell's theorem later made locality testable. He traces experiments from early Berkeley and Harvard results to a conclusive Paris test around 1980. He claims standard quantum mechanics is structurally unable to say how information passes between entangled particles, while a realist theory must confront that question and accept the apparent conflict with light-speed limits. He also notes that the individual outcomes look random, so the connection cannot be used to send signals.
Realism in quantum mechanics—the view that physical systems have definite properties independent of observation—is not only philosophically justified but empirically vindicated; pilot wave theory demonstrates that a complete, deterministic description of quantum phenomena is possible, and Bell's theorem experimentally proves that locality is false, revealing that space and spatial separation are not fundamental to how nature works.
- Pilot wave theory explains all quantum phenomena deterministically, including cases standard quantum mechanics only describes probabilistically (e.g., radioactive decay timing, electron trajectories)
- Bell's theorem and subsequent experiments prove locality is violated: the properties of one particle can depend on measurements performed on a distant particle, independent of light-speed limitations
- A realist interpretation eliminates quantum mechanics' structural inability to explain how information transfers between entangled systems, revealing that non-local connections rather than spatial separation determine physical relationships
This asset isn't compiled yet
You're seeing its claims, ranked. Compile it to build the argument threads, weight them, and check each claim against your library — the full view.
Anti-realists view scientific concepts like wave, particle, law, causality, and energy as representing human intuitions and useful for describing interactions between atomic systems and measurement devices, not as extending to concepts that stand alone or have meaning when applied to atomic systems without experimental context.
“the concepts that we use, like wave or particle or law or causality or energy, represent our own intuitions, and are useful to describe what happens when an atomic system interacts with a measurement device. But are not -- do not extend to concepts that stand alone, have meaning when applied just to the atomic system without the context of the experiment.”
Anti-realists propose that instead of trying to understand what quantum objects really are, science should lower its ambition and pragmatically describe what happens when we measure and interact with quantum systems, abandoning the goal of discovering mind-independent reality.
“And instead says, 'Well, let's lower our ambition. Let's just say we're pragmatically describing what happens when we measure and interact with these things.”
Niels Bohr proposed complementarity as a general principle to express how contradictory concepts (such as wave and particle, or justice and love) can both be true and part of a whole without logical contradiction, applying this principle across science, human life, religion, and art.
“And he said, 'Maybe there's a general concept to carry these way -- to express the way that these contradictory concepts seem part of the whole. And he called that complementarity. And he proposed that this was a new principle for science, for human life, for religion, for art, for everything.'”
Pilot wave theory provides complete deterministic explanations of everything that happens in quantum mechanics, telling exactly how, why, when, and how quantum processes occur, whereas standard quantum mechanics is fundamentally probabilistic with chance and uncertainty as foundational features and statistics as necessary.
“The pilot wave theory tells you, in detail, everything. Exactly how, why, and when. So the regular theory is probabilistic. Chance is fundamental. Uncertainty is fundamental. Statistics is necessary. The pilot wave theory is deterministic, like old-fashioned Newtonian physics.”
Realist alternatives to quantum mechanics like pilot wave theory must explicitly address the question of how information is transferred between entangled particles and acknowledge that this transfer violates the assumption that nothing can travel faster than light.
“But Pilot Wave theory, and other alternatives to quantum mechanics that are realistic, have to address that question explicitly. They have to show you how the two systems talk to each other. And when they do, yes, they do violate the possibility that nothing can travel faster than light.”
Realism means there is an exactly understandable way the world is, which is independent of our intervention, knowledge, and existence, and it is possible to give a complete individual description of any process or event in nature and understand the causal processes behind those events.
“I believe that there is an exactly understandable way the world is, which is independent of our intervention, independent of our existence, our knowledge. It's possible for everything that happens in nature, to give a complete individual description to that process or those events. And thence, to understand what -- the causal processes behind those events”
Anti-realists argue that realism is too ambitious and too hard because our concepts derive from experience with macroscopic objects, yet at the quantum scale electrons, nuclei, protons, neutrons, and quarks do not behave like balls or waves as we intuitively understand them, causing confusion about what these entities actually are.
“What it means to be not a realist is that realism is too ambitious and too hard. We don't have it -- they would say something like, 'Our concepts come from our experience.' Our experiences of the world are the big things we throw them. They bounce back and forth... But what are these things? What-- and we get very confused when we try to understand what they are. And it is indeed confusing. They're not balls like a baseball or a soccer ball. They're not waves like a breeze kicking up some ripples on a lake.”
Standard quantum mechanics provides no explanation for non-locality and entanglement; it is structurally designed so that the question of how information is transferred between entangled particles cannot be answered within the framework.
“In quantum mechanics, there is no explanation of it. It just comes out that way. If you want to have a theory like Pilot Wave theory that gives a complete description-- in other words, if you're not a realist, it's set up so that one of the questions you can't answer is how the information is transferred back and forth. Quantum mechanics is structurally built so you can't get at that question.”
Pilot wave theory explains phenomena that standard quantum mechanics describes only probabilistically: it specifies exactly when and why a radioactive nucleus will decay, whereas standard mechanics only predicts the probability per unit time without explaining the specific moment or reason for decay.
“Everything that ordinary quantum mechanics explains, the Pilot Wave theory explains, but the reverse is not true because there's a long list of things that the regular theory does not explain. Regular theory does not explain, if you have a radioactive nuclei, exactly when it will decay. It just predicts that there is a certain probability per unit time that the atom or the nuclei will decay. But it doesn't tell you why and when it decays.”
The standard formulation of quantum mechanics adopted in roughly 1927 was finalized along anti-realist lines, becoming the textbook presentation and current teaching standard.
“the way that quantum mechanics was textbook formulated, and the way that we teach it now, was finalized in 1927, roughly. And that was done along an anti-realist line.”
Pilot wave theory proposes that both waves and particles exist as real entities: waves propagate through space while particles follow the waves they are guided by, allowing waves to 'pilot' or guide particles around their trajectories.
“he could explain the paradox that Bohr wrestled with by saying there are waves and there are particles. Both exist, both are real. The waves propagate and the particles follow the waves. And this is what he called the Pilot Wave theory because the waves are guiding, or piloting, the particles around.”
Entanglement is a property of quantum systems where there exist true facts about the combined system that have no corresponding facts about either individual particle, such as correlations that cannot be reduced to individual particle properties.
“So in this state called opposite, there's no thing which is true for certain about particle one or particle two separately, but there are things which are true about their combination. And we call this entanglement.”
Locality is the principle that to affect a system, you must physically interact with it directly (by touching it, sending a light signal, or sending a physical object); you cannot affect something far away like Alpha Centauri by your actions here without sending something to it.
“Locality means that to affect a system, you have to go over and tickle it or touch it. I can't affect something in Alpha Centauri here just by something that I do here. I have to send a light signal or a piece of information, or a bomb or something to Alpha Centauri. And then, when it gets there, it has the effect.”
Bell's theorem and its experimental confirmation prove that locality is false as a matter of nature, independent of interpretation: there exist states of entangled particle pairs where the measured properties of one particle depend on what is measured on the other particle, showing that spatial separation does not prevent causal or informational dependence.
“This has nothing to do with whether you believe in quantum mechanics or not. Nothing to do with anything because Bell's theorem has nothing in it but a few obvious assumptions, like the probabilities are numbers between 0 and 1... the experiments, together with that theorem, tell us that locality is false. That is, there are states of pairs of particles where what the properties of particle B over here turn out to do depend on what you choose to measure or manipulate with particle A.”
The predominant view among educated people in Europe in the 1920s and 1930s was anti-realism, rejecting the possibility of understanding nature as it exists independently, and instead viewing science as describing human interactions with and interventions in nature rather than nature itself.
“the predominant view among educated people in Europe in the 1920s and 1930s was not-- was not realism. They didn't believe that realism was possible. They thought that science was a way of speaking about our interactions within our interventions in nature.”
Pilot wave theory was developed in the late 1920s at the same time as the standard anti-realist formulation, predicts all the same outcomes as standard quantum mechanics, and explains at least as much, if not more, than the standard version.
“He developed it in the late '20s at the same time as the other theory was developed. It predicts -- it gives all the same predictions, and explains at least as much, if not more, than the standard version of quantum mechanics.”
Standard quantum mechanics does not explain how an electron absorbs the specific energy of a photon, how it reacts to that energy, or how it jumps out of an atom during photoelectric absorption; it only describes a probability distribution of where the electron might be found, not where it actually is or how it moves.
“the standard theory just says there is a wave function, which is a probability distribution, to find the electron somewhere in the vicinity of the atom. But it doesn't tell you where it is or how it's moving. And then a photon comes and knocks it out of the atom. It doesn't tell you exactly how it absorbed the energy of that photon, how it reacted to it, and how it jumped out of the atom.”
Non-locality is not testable for practical information transmission because the outcomes of individual measurements of entangled particles appear completely random on either side, so taken separately, the measurements look like random noise distributions and cannot convey information about what happened on the other side.
“At first, no, because these measurements are all random. Just taking what you measure on this side or what you measure on this side, just taken by themselves just look like random distribution, so you can't get any information about them. About anything, let alone what happening over here. So it looks bad for sending information faster than light.”
In quantum systems with two or more particles, there can exist properties of the system as a whole that are not properties of either particle individually; you can construct a combined system property that is correlated in a way that no individual particle property could be.
“It turns out that you can choose properties to describe the two put together that are not properties of either of them separately. For example, there is a property called opposite.”
In the early 1970s, experimentalists realized they could test Bell's theorem by creating pairs of entangled particles or photons, letting them separate, and measuring their polarizations, energy, or flight direction to directly test the principle of locality.
“by the early 1970s, there were some experimentalists who realized they could test this consequence of Bell's theorem in a real experiment. You could make a pair of particles or a pair of photons, let them separate and study their polarizations or their energy, or the direction of their flight. And you could actually test the principle of locality very directly.”
Initial Bell test experiments at Berkeley yielded muddy results that were not reliable; later experiments at Harvard were conducted; finally, a definitive experimental result came from a group in Paris led by [Alain Aspect, though speaker name is inaudible] around 1980, proving that locality is false.
“these were experiments carried out first at Berkeley, I think, and they were muddy, and the results weren't reliable. And then at Harvard. Then finally, a group of people in Paris led by [INAUDIBLE] -- I think we're talking about roughly 1980 now -- got definitive results. And the definitive results are that locality is false.”
Einstein first identified entanglement in the 1930s as part of his attempt to find a logical inconsistency in quantum mechanics, intending to discredit the theory, but what he actually discovered was not a logical flaw but a new feature of nature itself.
“It's a property of quantum systems that Einstein first chanced upon in the 1930s as part of his mission to basically find a flaw a logical inconsistency in the theory. And it turned out that what he was on the trail of was not a logical inconsistency, but this new feature of nature which he chanced upon and wrote about in the 1930s.”
John Bell formulated locality precisely as follows: if you measure properties of particle A and particle B, the probabilities for the outcome of measuring particle B cannot depend on what you choose to do with particle A, because that would imply action at a distance.
“John Bell made a precise formulation of locality as follows. If you have two particles and you want to measure particle A and particle B, then the probabilities for the outcome of measuring probability B -- whatever you measure probability B -- can't depend on what you choose to do with particle A.”
Bell's theorem was proven in 1964 and contained only obvious assumptions such as that probabilities are numbers between 0 and 1, plus one assumption of locality; the theorem is remarkable in its sparseness and minimal assumptions.
“Bell is the 1960s. His theorem is 1964... Bell's theorem has nothing in it but a few obvious assumptions, like the probabilities are numbers between 0 and 1. And this one assumption of locality. It's a beautiful theorem in its sparseness.”
Electrons display complementary wave-like and particle-like properties depending on experimental context: in some experiments they diffract and show wavelength properties like water waves, while in others they bounce and show energy and momentum properties like material particles, creating an apparent contradiction that anti-realists accept as fundamental.
“We put it in a certain kind of experiment and we can diffract and measure its wavelength just as if it was a water wave or a sound wave. We put it in another experiment and we can bounce and measure its energy and momentum. So it seems to be a material particle. And then we wonder, can we contradict ourselves?”
De Broglie was the first physicist to propose that the wave-particle duality applies not only to light but also to electrons and all material particles, as well as radiation—an idea that was accepted and earned him the Nobel Prize.
“he was the first person to say that the duality between waves and particles applies to everything -- all material particles, as well as radiation and light. And that was accepted, and for that, he was given the Nobel Prize.”
Bell derived a mathematical inequality from the assumption of locality; he then proved that this inequality is contradicted by quantum mechanics, meaning that if quantum mechanics is true, then Bell's formulation of locality must be false.
“Bell derived a consequence from that, a certain mathematical inequality that we don't need to get into. And then he proved one thing about that consequence. It was contradicted by quantum mechanics. So if quantum mechanics is true, that assumption of Bell Locality, as Bell formulated it, is false.”
In an entangled quantum state called 'opposite,' measurements of corresponding properties on two separated particles are individually completely random and unpredictable, but can be guaranteed to be opposite to each other: if particle one shows momentum in one direction, particle two will show momentum in the opposite direction.
“If you measure the same thing on each particle, it's totally random. It's totally unpredictable what you'll get for each of those measurements. But you can guarantee, in the state opposite, that they'll be opposite. So if you measure the momentum of particle one and it's going that way, particle two will be going this way.”
If realism is true, locality is dead and space as a fundamental organizing principle is discredited; something deeper than spatial separation welds the world together, having to do with the histories of interactions and relationships ('who talked with who') rather than spatial distance.
“Space is now a discredited concept. And something deeper is going on. Something welds the world together, which has to do with the histories of who talked with who. It doesn't have to do with how far away things are from each other.”
The logic that histories of interactions determine physical relationships rather than spatial distance is the real lesson of Bell's theorem and non-locality for many physicists and philosophers.
“That logic of that histories telling you who talks to you, rather than locality telling you who talks to who, is the real lesson here, many of us think.”
Simultaneously with the adoption of anti-realist quantum mechanics in 1927, a small number of good physicists, including some who were or would become Nobel Prize winners, invented realist alternative theories to quantum mechanics.
“But simultaneously, there were a handful of physicists -- and these were not quacks. These were good physicists. Some of them were Nobel Prize winners, or shortly to be, who invented realist alternatives.”
Louis de Broglie was a French aristocrat and wealthy physicist who developed pilot wave theory in the late 1920s, and his social isolation (as a Frenchman and aristocrat) may have enabled him to pursue an unconventional idea that others rejected.
“one of those that I talk about is what's called the pilot wave theory of Louis de Broglie, who was a Frenchman, which apparently put him socially a little bit in the outgroup anyway at this period. And he was wealthy. In fact, he was an aristocrat, which also put out of the social group. So he wasn't really hanging out. And there's a whole lot to say about how that separation let him have an idea that nobody else had”
Even if practically achieving a far-from-equilibrium phase in pilot wave systems is impossible currently, it remains a possible state of the system in principle, which proves that non-local connections and information transfer are always latent possibilities in quantum mechanics.
“It proves that you always have to be able to do that. Although practically, we may not be able to throw it into a non-equilibrium state, that it is a possible state of the system. And that tells you that if you're a realist, then locality is dead, and the idea, basically, that space is dead.”
Despite being developed by a famous physicist (de Broglie) and predicting quantum phenomena as well as or better than standard quantum mechanics, pilot wave theory was completely ignored and virtually never developed further, except among a small circle of adherents in Paris around de Broglie, and even de Broglie himself eventually abandoned belief in it.
“It was done by somebody who was quite famous, and to his other work, and yet it was ignored -- completely ignored. So there's no textbook. Except for a small school of accolades in France, in Paris, around him, there was virtually nobody who developed his idea. And in fact, he even came to disbelieve in it.”
Niels Bohr was the most radical of anti-realist thinkers in quantum mechanics philosophy.
“And I'm trying to talk here the way that Niels Bohr talked because he was the most radical of these anti-realist thinkers.”
In quantum mechanics, a fundamental principle is that if you have a complete list of all properties a particle has, you can only know half of them at any one time; you can choose which half you will measure, an aspect of the uncertainty principle.
“an important principle of quantum mechanics is that if you have the list of all the properties some particle has, you can only know half of them at any one time. That's called the uncertainty principle. That's part of the uncertainty principle. But you can choose which half it will.”
Some physicists like Anthony Valentini have speculated that pilot wave theory could be thrown into a disordered, far-from-equilibrium phase (like complex systems transition between order and chaos, equilibrium and non-equilibrium), in which case real signals could be sent between entangled particles.
“a few physicists -- for example, a guy called Anthony Valentini-- have speculated you could throw the pilot wave theory into a kind of phase, like those complex systems people talk about different phases, order and chaotic, and equilibrium and non-equilibrium. He speculates that you can throw the particle wave system into a kind of disordered, far from equilibrium phase, where all of a sudden, you can send real signals between the two particles.”
The violation of locality proved by Bell's theorem is 'the most crazy shocking thing' one could hear in science, revealing that nature operates via non-local connections rather than requiring spatial proximity for causal relationships.
“And that's just true about nature. That's the most -- if that's not the most crazy shocking thing you've ever heard in science, I got to repeat everything I just said.”