
DOOMBERG | The U.S. Is Running A Dangerous Experiment, Consumer, Economy, Sanctions, Bonds, BRICS, $
What this covers
This is a 33-minute interview, recorded on 9 May 2024, in which Gary B of Metals and Miners questions Doomberg, the pseudonymous writer behind a widely read finance Substack. It is billed as part one. The conversation starts with the near-term economy: a consumer whose savings rate has fallen to about 3% against a historical 8%, with credit card debt at record levels and rates of 20-25%. Doomberg's bullish case rests on cheap US natural gas, at roughly $2 per million BTU, which he calls a stimulus for households and heavy industry. He also points to a manufacturing and construction boom driven by Pentagon interest in reshoring and friend-shoring. He names geopolitical escalation as the main risk to that outlook, with oil possibly reaching $150-$200.
The middle of the discussion concerns Sanctions and commodities. Doomberg argues that cutting a producer's volume raises prices, and so can raise its revenue. He sets this against Joe Biden's Strategic Petroleum Reserve releases, which he says halved oil prices, and he uses price elasticity of demand to explain why small supply gaps move prices so sharply. His prescription is to flood markets, including by lifting sanctions on Iran and Venezuela. He also stresses Chinese chokepoints in magnesium and in solar supply chains. The talk turns to deterrence, using a bar-room analogy, to nuclear powers, and to Lindsey Graham's calls for bombing Iranian refineries, which he dismisses. He also reads Antony Blinken's China trip as a sign of lost American credibility.
The closing stretch covers money and debt. Doomberg distinguishes the Reserve currency from the Reserve asset and forecasts that gold will slowly, then perhaps suddenly, displace Treasuries in the second role. He cites gold flowing out of ETF vaults to China, though he and the claim's framing are contested. He describes a trillion dollars of new debt every 90 days, a political habit of Extend and Pretend through the election, and no politician offering austerity. From this he concludes that sustained inflation is certain, and he says he holds gold, land, and collectibles as hedges. He adds that inflation falls hardest on the poor.
Doomberg argues that the US is conducting an unprecedented fiscal and monetary experiment that will likely result in currency devaluation and gold replacing US treasuries as the neutral reserve asset, driven by geopolitical instability, energy economics, and structural debt dynamics that make inflation inevitable.
- Sanctions on Russia and confiscation of reserves have destroyed the perceived neutrality of US treasuries, forcing central banks to shift reserves toward gold
- Structural energy economics and commodity supply chains mean the US cannot effectively sanction major commodity producers, making current geopolitical strategy counterproductive
- Record non-wartime deficits of $1 trillion in interest payments annually with no political will for austerity make currency devaluation mathematically inevitable
This asset isn't compiled yet
You're seeing its claims, ranked. Compile it to build the argument threads, weight them, and check each claim against your library — the full view.
Sanctioning a major commodity player's volume without expecting a backfire violates basic commodity economics: sanctions that reduce supply typically increase prices, and since commodity producers only maximize revenue during price spikes, reducing their exports while prices rise increases their revenue rather than reducing it.
“you can't can't sanction a major commodity player's volume and expect to reduce their revenue anybody who spend five minutes in the commodity sector and clearly nobody in government has understands that you make all your money during price bikes and the price elasticity of demand for oil is such that 1 two 3 four 5% Supply deficits double and triple and quadruple the price”
China controls magnesium production; without magnesium you cannot make aluminum composites, and without those composites you cannot make cars, yet the US wants to manufacture cars.
“China controls magnesium without magnesium you can't make aluminum composits without those composits you can't make cars do we want to make cars yeah”
The analogy of game-theoretic deterrence: if you and another person walk into a bar and there's a large, physically intimidating man wearing a Hell's Angels jacket with visible injuries, you would think twice about confronting him; this principle applies to geopolitics—you must assess the strength and willingness of your potential enemy before deciding to escalate.
“the analogy of use like you know Gary if you and I walk into a bar and there's a 6 foot6 strapping guy at the bar and he's his T-shirt is cut at the sleeves and he's wearing a Hell's Angels jacket and he's got tattoos and he's ripped and he's clearly had a few drinks and he says anybody sits in this stool next to me I'm gonna I'm going to take care of you you and I might think twice about whether we'd go sit next to that stool like might is right is one of the geopolitical inputs into uh Game Theory right I mean you have to assess the strength of your potential enemy before you decide whether you want to walk up and spit in their face or punch their nose”
A $20-per-barrel oil price would likely result in losses for Russia (making it unsustainable for the regime), whereas $100-per-barrel oil would generate five times more revenue, demonstrating the clear mechanism for reducing Putin's revenue capacity.
“if oil is a $100 a barrel he's going to make five times as much money well actually know five times as much revenue than if oil is at $20 a barrel and at $20 a barrel he's probably losing money and there's a way to to bring the price of oil down it's to pump more”
Biden's release of 1 million barrels per day from the Strategic Petroleum Reserve for six months (1% of daily global supply over that period) successfully cut oil prices in half, demonstrating that flooding the market with commodities works to reduce prices—the opposite of what sanctions accomplish.
“Joe Biden released controversially and in a raw political move ahead of the midterm election it must be said he released 1 million barrels a day from the Strategic petrole for six months that's 1% of daily Supply over that period or a half a percent of global demand for the year the price have all got cut in half right it doesn't take much”
Inflation disproportionately hits the economically disadvantaged because the rich have ways to hedge against inflation that struggling people do not have.
“the consumer is certainly struggling I think inflation is hitting um the economically disadvantage disproportionately as it always does the rich have ways the Hedge against inflation that the those who are struggling don't”
The US energy glut, particularly cheap natural gas at $2 per million BTU and abundant hydrocarbons, is driving US economic resilience despite aggressive Fed rate hikes, and this cheap energy serves as a stimulus for the consumer and heavy industry.
“the energy glut in the US um is driving economic resilience that I don't think few people had on their radar especially in the face of the FED aggressively hiking interest rates and keeping them higher for longer than the market has generally predicted”
Anytime you are at war, you must proactively manage public opinion, and governments disseminate propaganda to maintain domestic support for war efforts.
“anytime you're at War you have to proactively manage public opinion I mean no combatant in a war and we're at War”
The US dollar is the reserve currency but US treasuries are the reserve asset, and treasuries were known as a neutral reserve asset used to settle imbalances in international trade, but doomberg believes gold will slowly, and perhaps suddenly, replace treasuries as that neutral reserve asset.
“the US dollar might be the reserve currency but us treasuries are the reserve asset and they used to be known as a neutral Reserve asset to quote a phrase from our friend Luke Roman um and we believe that the trend is that gold will replace treasuries uh slowly at first yeah and perhaps suddenly all at once as that neutral Reserve asset”
The U.S. should pursue commodity supply flooding to reduce geopolitical rival revenues, including lifting sanctions on Iran and Venezuela, reducing environmental regulations, and leveraging allies and partners to increase coal, natural gas, and oil production globally.
“it doesn't take much produce get rid of environmental regulations go around the world and lean on your allies and your foes to produce um lift the sanctions on Iran lift the sanctions on Venezuela lean on Australia and Canada to flood the market with commodities with coal with natural gas with oil”
There is a manufacturing resurgence in the US driven by the Department of Defense's interest in reshoring, near-shoring, and friend-shoring, which is creating a manufacturing and construction boom that will eventually lead to manufacturing job increases.
“there's a manufacturing Resurgence I think the Department of Defense is keenly interested in in reshoring and near Shoring and friend Shoring and we're seeing sort of a manufacturing construction boom which will eventually make its way into manufacturing job bursts”
The only meaningful risk to the bullish near-term outlook is geopolitical war and escalation; an escalatory misunderstanding could lead to oil at $150-$200/barrel, significant inflation, and global economic shocks.
“the only risk on the board to the bare side of things is is war and geopol geopolitics um we think that an escalatory misunderstanding could lead to significant economic shocks um oil $150 $200 um significant inflation and so on um and so we're bearish uh about geopolitics and if um everything sort of settles down if peace were to break out in the Middle East if peace were to break out in the war in Ukraine I think um oil prices could fall substantially from where they are”
The U.S. is snowplowing problems ahead of the shovel; a trillion dollars in debt accumulates every 90 days and is fundamentally unsustainable, but the immediate political incentive is to extend and pretend through the election.
“are we snowplowing problems um ahead of the shovel of course is a trillion dollars in debt every 90 days sustainable no um and so all of those things are real it all depends on your time frame like if I'm looking three to six months out which is what matters for the election I think the FED can extend and pretend”
Price elasticity of demand for oil is such that 1-5% supply deficits cause prices to double, triple, and quadruple.
“the price elasticity of demand for oil is such that 1 two 3 four 5% Supply deficits double and triple and quadruple the price”
Once a country acquires nuclear weapons, it must be treated differently in geopolitical calculations because it becomes an existential threat that cannot be defeated militarily without mutual annihilation.
“there's a reason why we care so much about nuclear proliferation because once a country gets nuclear weapons you have to treat them differently right Russia has the largest and most technically sophisticated stockpile of nuclear weapons on Earth”
No politician is talking about austerity despite the US running the largest non-wartime deficits in history, which is unsustainable, yet this reality is being avoided in political discourse.
“but doomberg it seems that all governments do is cater to their electorate they pledge and they spend ridiculous amounts of money and at the same time no one really wants to pay taxes there are massive increases in entitlements defense spending and interest payments on the debt it's all leading to this record non-w wartime deficits that you know everyone is uh talking about no politician anywhere though is talking about austerity nobody”
China owns 98% of the key parts of the global solar supply chain, giving them overwhelming control over renewable energy infrastructure.
“they that you name it and by the way as we wrote um in a recent piece going to crack the semiconductor mystery like I've seen this movie before I they're going to win the semiconductor War we're going to lose the semiconductor War as measured by our desire to stop China from being able to be self-sufficient in semiconductors uh a piece we wrote last week called Chip Shot if you're interested to read uh on that and they use a very standard Playbook they they trick or crol Western companies and they're giving up all their IP they steal the rest they combine it all in some new magical that then becomes a world beater we're seeing electric vehicles today PD has a $10,000 electric vehicle that can go 200 miles there no way the automakers can compete against that no no”
The premium for physical gold delivery in China versus New York and London has come down, explaining some of the relative weakness in gold prices in recent weeks, but Chinese control over gold pricing suggests potential for manipulation.
“one of the things that we're watching very closely is the premium in China to um New York and London for physical delivery of gold that has come down a bit which explains some of the relative weakness in gold in the past few weeks but the Chinese basically control the price of gold in our view um and U and they're systematically call calling the bluff of the sort of paper gold market because if if the price of gold is being suppressed in the west then China will just stand for delivery of it”
There is no question that the US will face sustained inflation because it cannot default on its debt and therefore must inflate the currency, forcing Doomberg to own gold, land, and collectibles as hedges against currency devaluation.
“when you can't repay your debts you either default or or inflate and the US is not going to default and so we're and we can't pay back our debts and so we're going to inflate look I mean I own a ton of gold I own a ton of land I own a ton of Collectibles um I I I'm hedged and by the way gold is the one asset I own that it bothers me when it goes up too quickly um because that usually foretells uh darker things in the economy”
The US consumer has run out of excess savings from pandemic stimulus, with the historical savings rate around 8% but currently at 3% (a multi-generational low), while credit card debt is at historic highs with Americans paying 20-25% interest rates.
“the US consumer they've run out of excess savings from the pandemic stimulus error the historical savings rate is close to 8% and today it's down to around 3% which is a multi-generational low at the same time credit card debt is higher than ever before and the kicker is that Americans are willing to pay 20 to 25% interest on the debt”
Gold ETF vaults are being emptied with physical gold flowing to China, suggesting China is systematically taking delivery and draining Western gold supplies.
“we're seeing the emptying of the ETF vaults and all that Gold's going to China”
Shipping disruptions in the Middle East causing container ship rerouting will increase prices as products take longer routes, creating inflationary pressure on the economy.
“I think the challenges with the shipping in the Middle East um causing all the rerouting of these container ships is going to find its way into prices”
Lindsey Graham's calls for carpet bombing of Iranian refineries ignore the reality that adversaries can punch back with increasingly diverse and devastating methods, making escalation a losing strategy against nuclear or peer military powers.
“there's many brilliant people in DC a think tanks I I don't know how they don't see this now I think there are some very smart people who do see this and are urging caution but our political leaders and the neocons and and the Lindsey Grahams of the world who are calling for carpet bombing of Iranian refineries as though like this is just going to go unresponded to like in lindsy Graham's World nobody ever punches back yeah right like I I it's just so bizarre to me”
Secretary of State Antony Blinken visited China recently to warn and threaten Chinese officials about supporting Russia, but the Chinese responded by laughing, daring the US to take action, and didn't even walk them to the airport, demonstrating a loss of US diplomatic credibility.
“we see blinkin go to China last week to warn and threaten the Chinese on we're going to sanction them because they're helping the Russians and the Chinese laughed at them and they sent them home and they dared them to do something about it they didn't even walk they show at the airport right they just it's incredible can you imagine James Baker getting that treatment can you imagine Henry Kissinger getting that treatment of course not”
The US is running an unprecedented experiment analogous to a singularity where the laws of physics break down, and this experiment involves running fiscal deficits and monetary policy that are unsustainable, with no way to predict what happens on the other side.
“like we are running an experiment that is unprecedented and in a singularity the laws of physics break down and you can't predict what happens on the other side of that Singularity we believe we're about to run that experiment here”
Doomberg predicted early in the Ukraine war that sanctions on Russia would backfire, while Yale economists published a non-peer-reviewed study claiming sanctions would cripple the Russian economy—this prediction turned out to be completely wrong in every way.
“we published a piece called crazy pills where we predicted that not only would the sanctions not work but they would backfire yeah and this is one of the great mysteries of our time Gary um I happen to I happen to know the lead author of that study at least peripherally um he wouldn't remember me and back in my days in the commodity sector I happened to have dinner with him”
Democracies have outsourced key parts of their military supply chains to China, and they naively assume China will continue supplying these critical components even if the US goes to war with China, which is strategically irrational.
“China is the new Arsenal democracy because all of the democracies have outsourced key parts of their military supply chains to China and we just assume rather stupidly to be honest that they'll just keep supplying us this stuff if we go to war with them like I I don't get it”
The freezing of Russian reserves and confiscation of US Treasury bonds has undermined the perceived neutrality of US treasuries as a reserve asset, causing central banks to shift reserves toward gold due to counterparty risk.
“the sanctions on Russia and the confiscation of their US Treasury bonds has really put the US in a tough spot to sell their bonds to foreign countries as those foreign countries are now looking at this and saying what happens if the US doesn't agree with us in three five 10 years with what we're doing you know will they confiscate our bonds as well so why should we store our reserves in their bonds that have all this counterparty risk so they've been choosing gold central banks are buying record amounts of gold over the last 3 years”
The Democratic Convention in Chicago in August could become a real fiasco due to conflict over the Israeli-Palestinian issue, as Biden has painted himself into a corner and faces pressure from pro-Palestinian Democratic voters.
“the Democratic Convention in Chicago this August is going to be potentially a real Fiasco especially with the U Palestinian Israeli conflict uh President Biden seems to have painted himself in a real corner here U you know lots of ways we can go with this Gary”
The analogy that the US should avoid being Chamberlain and be like Churchill ignores that if France, Germany, and the UK had possessed nuclear weapons, World War II would not have unfolded as it did, and therefore this historical analogy is invalid when applied to nuclear powers like Russia.
“this whole dangerous analogy of you don't want to be a Chamberlain and you'd rather be Churchill look if France and Germany had nuclear weapons and the UK had nuclear weapons do you think World War II would have unfolded the way it did of course not”
Gold is not an investment vehicle for speculation but rather a hedge and liquidity source during crises; two or twenty gold eagles will buy a nice midsize SUV today and should buy the same in 15 years, representing gold's true utility as a store of purchasing power.
“I don't own gold as an investment I own gold as a hedge and a liquidity source during a crisis and and I treat it as such so when I see I don't even actually look at the price of gold other than as an indication for the weakness of the dollar um I I view my gold Holdings as as you know look two or 20 Gold Eagles will buy you a a nice midsize SUV today and in 15 years 20 Gold Eagles will buy you a nice midsize SUV like that's what gold does gold is not a vehicle for speculation gold is a vehicle for savings and excess savings for us are swept into real assets”
The rhetorical question 'why do we tax if we can just print' highlights the logical contradiction in modern fiscal policy where governments choose to print money rather than tax to fund spending.
“why do we tax if we can just print it's a good question yeah why we just print”
Rampant speculation in markets (with Dogecoin trading at tens of billions of dollars and Nvidia moving $100 billion in a single day) mirrors the insanities described in 'When Money Dies' about Weimar Republic hyperinflation.
“um you know when you see Dogecoin trading for you know tens of billions of dollars of market cap and and you see you know uh Nvidia moving a hundred billion dollars inad day like a billion used to be a lot of money yeah you know and um and so you know it it's we are running a very dangerous experiment”
The AI boom is real and will support economic growth in the US over the near-to-medium term, contributing to the US avoiding recession at least until the election.
“the AI boom is real um I think by and large the US will avoid a recession at least up and until the election and uh then we'll go from there”
BYD has a $10,000 electric vehicle that can go 200 miles on a charge, and Western automakers have no way to compete against this price point.
“we're seeing electric vehicles today PD has a $10,000 electric vehicle that can go 200 miles there no way the automakers can compete against that no no”
Record non-wartime deficits combined with no political appetite for austerity and annual interest payments exceeding $1 trillion make currency devaluation a mathematical certainty.
“I mean old enough to remember well not quite but I was a young child when we ran our first trillion dollar budget right you know um it just it's just I don't I don't know how this ends I mean I guess we all know how it ends um this is why when we observe rampant speculation in the market um we wonder whether we're seeing a carbon copy of the famous book when money dies which captures insanities around the Yar Republic and the hyperinflation”
China has been very smart in how it has pursued supply chain dominance, while the Western world has looked only at short-term dollar signs and failed to recognize long-term strategic vulnerabilities, now facing the consequences as the chickens come home to roost.
“China's been very smart in how they've gone about it and um and the Western you know world has really not been very smart they've looked at the dollar sign only and um it's now looking like the chickens are going to come home to roost”
Russian and Chinese internal propaganda describes the current situation as World War III—they view themselves as at war with the US and the West—while the US internally treats it as a distant geopolitical issue that doesn't impact daily American life.
“if you read the Russian newspapers and you read the Chinese newspapers they are describing this internally as World War II they are at war with the US they're at war with the west and we're not internally this is a far away um you know sometimes it shows up on CNN and MSNBC but it isn't really impacting the daily lives of of Americans or Canadians Australians”
China is winning the semiconductor war, and Western restrictions on semiconductor exports to China will ultimately fail because China uses a standard playbook: tricking or coercing Western companies into transferring IP, stealing the rest, combining it all, and creating a world-class product.
“I've seen this movie before I they're going to win the semiconductor War we're going to lose the semiconductor War as measured by our desire to stop China from being able to be self-sufficient in semiconductors uh a piece we wrote last week called Chip Shot if you're interested to read uh on that and they use a very standard Playbook they they trick or crol Western companies and they're giving up all their IP they steal the rest they combine it all in some new magical that then becomes a world beater”
Political unrest in the US is the base case, with a high probability that roughly half the country will not believe election results, and this poses a significant risk to economic and social stability.
“I think political unrest in the US is the base case I don't know how we get through the election without half the country not believing the results and I don't think that's very good um and so post elction all bets are off I think recession risk is very high”
The article by Yale and other economists was formatted to appear rigorous and appeared in prestigious journals but was actually self-published and non-peer-reviewed, creating the false appearance of academic rigor.
“it was formatted to give the appearance of a rigorous academic study that one might find in a prestigious Journal but the authors painted a they painted a dim picture of life in Russia in the aftermath of President Putin's invasion of Ukraine”
Professor Jeff Sunstein from Yale was the lead author of the sanctions study, and Doomberg finds it peculiar that someone of his stature would lead such a comprehensively incorrect economic analysis.
“I happen to know the lead author of that study at least peripherally um he wouldn't remember me and back in my days in the commodity sector I happened to have dinner with him and if You' have asked me to name 10,000 people who would lead a 118 page economic study about this the situation in Russia Vis A V sanctions I would not have gotten to Professor Jeff sunen Shin at Yale uh given 10,000 attempts and yet here he was um the lead author of this study”
When gold prices rise quickly, it bothers Doomberg because rapid gold price appreciation typically foretells darker economic events like crisis or major devaluation.
“I I'm hedged and by the way gold is the one asset I own that it bothers me when it goes up too quickly um because that usually foretells uh darker things in the economy”
The Federal Reserve will likely be forced to keep rates higher for longer due to ongoing inflation, unless Trump is likely to win, in which case Doomberg expects the Fed to become overtly political and cut rates before the election.
“I think the FED is going to be forced to keep rates higher for longer unless it looks like Trump is going to win at which point I expect the FED to get overtly political and to cut into the election”
All of Washington DC is oriented around keeping Trump out of the White House, which Doomberg presents as an objective geopolitical fact rather than a political statement.
“all of Washington DC is oriented around keeping the orange man of the White House and um that's just the pieces on the board that's not a political statement I think as an analyst that's that's undeniable that that's what's going on”
Zelensky's term as Ukrainian president technically ends on May 21st, and although he will continue to claim the presidency, this date may be important to Russian strategy and could trigger geopolitical escalation.
“one is galinsky's term in Ukraine technically ends on May 21st that's is under reported in the west he will you know continue to claim to be president but um to the Russians I think that is a pretty important date and that might cause some issues let's just say”
The US ruling class is populated by idiots who will eventually be wiped away or die off due to their age (many are in their 80s and 90s), and America's future remains bright despite current poor leadership.
“we have a a ruling class of idiots in DC right now that will be eventually wiped away or they'll just literally die off because they're all in their late 80s and 90s um and The Rebirth of the US is something we want to participate in”
The market routinely and regularly underestimates what the Fed will do—it has undersold the Fed's willingness to raise rates and oversold the speed of rate cuts, yet by listening to Jerome Powell and trading accordingly, investors could have made substantial money over the past 18 months.
“it's really amazing to see how the market routinely and regularly underestimates What drum Pal's going to do um they have um under sold the extent to which he would is willing to raise rates and they have oversold the speed with which they assumed he would have to cut yes and um perpetually even today the markets are catching up to what the FED is trying to tell them what to do which is something we've observed for the past 18 months and if you had just listened to Jerome pal and traded you know interest rates accordingly You'd have made a ton of money”
Europe is still reeling from the echoes of the energy crisis, and Germany in particular is undergoing deindustrialization due to energy costs and energy security issues.
“Europe is still reeling from The Echoes of the energy crisis and Germany in particular is in the process of deindustrialization um as macro analyst the fundamental question we always think um is the most important one and that not enough people ask is what is the state of the primary energy markets”
The amount of government spending required to fudge economic numbers to show growth during an election year is a topic of debate, and there are serious questions about whether reported GDP numbers in an election year are genuinely accurate.
“and there's lots of debate about whether the government is fudging the numbers in election year and all of those things in my in our view um cheap energy fiscal stimulus um indirect sort of stimulus”
Trump's trial is preventing him from campaigning normally (only allowed on Wednesdays), making the 2024 election unusually dysfunctional and creating elevated risks regardless of outcome.
“you have Trum on trial and can only campaign on Wednesdays you know it's it's just you couldn't make it up like this is not how you imagine the US political situation unfolding”
The Doomberg Substack is one of the most widely read if not the number one Finance newsletter on Substack, having grown rapidly through their deep expertise and content quality.
“the publication has quickly grown to be one of the most widely read if not the number one Finance newsletter on substack”
Doomberg and their team have deep expertise in heavy industry, private equity, hard sciences, and have worked with family offices and C-suite executives, positioning them to deliver innovative thinking on complex problems.
“the publication is their 100% passion and the content is born out of their team's deep exper experience in heavy industry private equity and the hard Sciences family offices and seite Executives hire them to deliver Innovative thinking and Clarity to complex problems”
Doomberg holds significant physical gold and also owns the Sprott Physical Gold Trust (SRU) to diversify their gold holdings, explicitly disclosing this financial interest in gold to avoid the appearance of talking their book.
“we're long gold full disclosure um a lot of physical and also in the form of the Sprat physical gold trust um so everybody should know um maybe you will assume that we're talking our books but I'd like to disclose when on the rare occasions where we do have a financial interest in what we're dis discussing”
The 'broken record' piece discussing the failed sanctions analysis is free to all subscribers at doomberg.com/newsletters/broken-record.
“the piece we published broken record came out yesterday and it's free to all subscribers”