
Why Chinese Say They Are In ‘Garbage Time’ | China Economy: New Stimulus | Unemployment
What this covers
This 14-minute China Update video has two parts. In the first, host Tony walks through the September 24, 2024 stimulus announcement and the labor-market data behind it. In the second, starting around the 8:43 mark, he turns to a commentary by Minxin Pei, a Claremont McKenna professor and author of The Sentinel States, titled "The Game Isn't Over for China but It Is Garbage Time." The video's own commentary stays with economists' assessments of the stimulus. Pei supplies the political explanation for why policy may not change.
The stimulus section covers a 0.5 percentage point cut to the reserve requirement ratio (RRR)), a lower policy rate, and measures to bring existing mortgage rates close to those on new loans. The central bank said it would inject roughly 141 billion USD in long-term liquidity. Markets reacted: Hong Kong stocks rose more than 2% at the open, after the CSI 300 index had fallen to a five-year low. Economists quoted are skeptical. Shan Mong says the RRR cut barely lowers financing costs, and Ting Li of Nomura argues that conventional monetary policy has hit its limits and fiscal policy and reforms should lead. The host also notes that mortgage relief eases pressure on households while squeezing already thin bank margins.
The labor-market segment is the most vivid. Youth unemployment reached 18.8% in August, a record for the series. Dan Wong of HSBC ties this to contraction in real estate, finance, and IT. Anecdotes include a physics master's graduate hired as a school janitor, Meituan denying that 80,000 of its couriers hold master's degrees, and universities enrolling more postgraduates than undergraduates.
Pei's argument is the most contested. He links the property collapse to a negative wealth effect on middle-class consumption, compares China's trajectory to the Soviet Union's stagnation from the mid-1970s, and contrasts the 2008–2009 credit surge with today's inertia. Because power under Xi Jinping is highly personalized, he argues, reversing failing policies is far harder than it was under earlier collective leadership.
China's economy faces a structural crisis driven by prolonged property sector collapse and deflationary pressure, but Beijing's latest monetary stimulus measures are insufficient and market confidence will remain subdued until Beijing signals willingness to undertake genuine economic and political reforms.
- China announced rate cuts and liquidity injections on September 24, 2024, but analysts assess these as insufficient given the depth of economic problems
- Youth unemployment hit record 18.8% in August 2024, reflecting a structural weakening of labor demand across key sectors like real estate, finance, and tech
- Political scientist Minxin Pei argues China has entered 'garbage time'—a state of economic and political stagnation unlikely to improve under Xi's centralized, inflexible leadership
This asset isn't compiled yet
You're seeing its claims, ranked. Compile it to build the argument threads, weight them, and check each claim against your library — the full view.
Chinese universities are promoting postgraduate studies to help students build credentials and reduce immediate employment pressure, with universities like Lanzhou University and the University of Science and Technology of China now enrolling more postgraduate students than undergraduates.
“Chinese universities are promoting postgraduate uate studies to help students build their credentials and reduce immediate employment pressure universities like Lan Joel University and the University of Science and Technology of China are now enrolling more post-graduate students than undergraduates as many young people opt to delay their entry into the workforce”
On Tuesday, September 24, 2024, Beijing's central bank chief Pangong Shung announced a 0.5 percentage point cut to the reserve requirement ratio and cuts to the policy interest rate, coupled with measures to lower existing mortgage loan rates, with the intent to inject approximately 141 billion USD in long-term liquidity into the financial market.
“today Tuesday Beijing made a series of announcements about new measures hoped to stabilize China's slow and painful economic slowdown”
Beijing will lower the interest rates of existing mortgage loans and unify down payment ratios for mortgage loans, guiding commercial banks to lower existing mortgage interest rates to the vicinity of newly issued loan rates.
“Beijing would quote lower the interest rates of existing mortgage loans and unify the down payment ratios for mortgage loans end quote it will also quote guide commercial Banks to lower the interest rates of existing mortgage loans to the vicinity of the interest rates of newly issued loans end quote”
Meituan, a popular food delivery app, had to deny a report claiming that 80,000 of their delivery drivers have master's degrees.
“recently Maan a popular food delivery app had to deny a report that claimed 80,000 of their delivery drivers have master's degrees”
Mortgage relief measures including lower interest rates on existing mortgage loans will ease pressure on households but will put further pressure on already historically low bank profit margins.
“these final moves have been debated for some time as we've discussed in previous videos this will ease some pressure for households but will put further pressure on already historically low Bank profit margins”
Companies in the once-booming real estate, internet, and tutoring sectors—which used to be major employers for young people—have been shrinking their payroll due to regulatory tightening and economic slowdown.
“companies in the once booming real estate internet and tutoring sectors used to be major employers for young people but many have been shrinking their payroll due to regular tightening and the economic slowdown”
As China's job market contracts, graduates are finding it increasingly difficult to secure meaningful employment, forcing them to lower their career aspirations and salary expectations.
“as China's job market contracts you graduates are finding it increasingly difficult to secure meaningful employment forcing them to lower their career aspirations and celery expectations”
A 24-year-old physics Master's student in Suzhou was hired as a high school janitor, a decision that drew widespread attention online and highlighted the severity of youth unemployment in China.
“this challenge was highlighted recently when a 24-year-old physics Master's student in suo was hired as a High School Janitor the decision Drew widespread attention online as youth unemployment in China remains at a record High”
Many young Chinese graduates have turned to food delivery jobs as a socially acceptable and flexible alternative to traditional employment, though even this sector is now becoming oversaturated.
“businesses continued to struggle further reducing hiring demand and adding to the difficulties for Young Job seekers in response to the shrinking job market many graduates have turned to jobs like delivery driving which had become socially acceptable and flexible but even that sector is now oversaturated”
On the surface, pessimism in China is driven by economic woes: the collapse of the real estate sector has shrunk the net worth of the middle class, and the resulting negative wealth effect has crumbled consumption and exacerbated economic slump while threatening deflation.
“on the surface such pessimism is driven by economic woes the collapse of the real estate sector has shrunk the net worth of the middle class the resulting negative wealth effect has crumbled consumption exacerbating the slump and threatening deflation”
During the 2008-2009 financial crisis, the Chinese government pumped bank credit equal to 25% of GDP into the economy within a year, making China one of the few bright spots globally while Western economies fell into recession.
“they could look forward to China joining the World Trade Organization such faith in the country's leadership was redeemed again when in 2008 through 2009 financial crisis plunged Western economies into recession the government pumped Bank credit equal to 25% of GDP into the economy within a year and made China one of the few bright spots globally”
Minxin Pei, professor of government at Claremont McKenna College and author of 'The Sentinel States: Surveillance and the Survival of Dictatorship in China', published a commentary this week called 'The Game Isn't Over for China but It Is Garbage Time' that examines themes regarding China's political-economic stagnation.
“I wanted to examine a commentary published this week by Min a professor of government at clar Mount McKenna College an author of The Sentinel States surveillance and the survival of dictatorship in China P has been quite critical of Beijing in recent years so we note his leaning here but he is also a respected authority of Chinese Politics the piece he published this week is called the game isn't over for China but it is garbage time”
China's economic slowdown is being driven by a prolonged property sector debt crisis, continued deflationary pressure, and high unemployment.
“as we anticipated in yesterday's video today Tuesday Beijing made a series of announcements about new measures hoped to stabilize China's slow and painful economic slowdown as it is battered by a prolonged property sector debt crisis continued deflationary pressure and high unemployment”
Dan Wong, Chief Economist at HSBC, explained that it is increasingly hard for young people to find high-paying jobs because in the past 3 years, high value-added city service sectors which used to absorb many fresh graduates have been in sharp contraction, particularly real estate, finance, and IT.
“Dan Wong Chief Economist at HSBC yesterday explained to clients quote it's increasingly hard for young people to find high-paying jobs as before because in the past 3 years the high value added City service sectors which used to absorb many fresh graduates were in sharp contraction in particular real estate finance and it end quote”
According to Shan Mong, cutting the required reserve ratio will unleash more cash to lend out but its impact on lowering financing costs is rather small, and therefore its impact on stimulating loan demand from companies and residents is limited.
“cutting the tri R will unleash more cash to lend out but its impact on lowering financing costs is rather small and therefore its impact on stimulating loan demand from companies and residents is limited too”
In the past, collective leadership and competition for power among rival factions created space for policy flexibility and reversals, because no single leader was powerful enough to force the regime to stick to demonstrably counterproductive policies.
“in the past Collective leadership and competition for power among rival factions created some space for policy flexibility and reversals no single leader was powerful enough to force the regime to stick to demonstrably counterproductive policies”
The fall of the Soviet regime was no accident; it entered its own 'garbage time of history' in the mid-1970s when Soviet leaders refused to adopt much-needed economic and political reforms.
“in retrospect the fall of the Soviet regime was no accident it entered its own garbage time of history in the mid 1970s when Soviet leaders refused to adopt much needed economic and political reforms”
According to Nomura's Chief China Economist Ting Li, despite surging government bond financing, infrastructure investment growth has slowed markedly as local governments are constrained by tight fiscal conditions, and conventional monetary policies have reached their limits, so fiscal policies and reforms should take the front seat.
“in a recent note namor's Chief China Economist Ting L someone who is always worth listening to expressed quote despite the surging Government Bond financing infrastructure investment growth slowed markedly as local governments are constrained by tight fiscal conditions We Believe China's economy potentially faces a second wave of shocks under these new shocks conventional monetary policies reach their limits so fiscal policies and reforms should take take the front seat end quote”
Under Xi Jinping, the Chinese Communist Party is ruled by a highly centralized, if not personalized leadership, making it extremely difficult or impossible to change or reverse policies, as evidenced by the absence of major policy shifts since China's economic struggles began in mid-2023.
“under she the party is ruled by a highly centralized if not personalized leadership changing or reversing policies is extremely hard if not impossible as evidenced by the absence of major shifts since China's recent economic struggles began in mid 2023”
The monetary policy announced on September 24, 2024 will do little to reverse China's economic slowdown according to analysis from economists like Nomura's Ting Li.
“thus the monetary policy announced today will do little to reverse the Slowdown according to this analysis”
Consumer confidence and economic sentiment in China have deteriorated significantly, with home prices posting their steepest decline in 9 years as of August 2024, and bond yields on 10-year government bonds plummeting to new lows indicating investor pessimism.
“home prices in August posted their steepest decline in 9 years and yields on 10year Chinese government bonds have plummeted to new lows indicating investors are souring on the economy's prospects”
Consumer confidence sank in July 2024, inflation remains near zero, business surveys in August recorded sinking profits in Chinese manufacturers, inventories are swelling, car sales have been dropping, retail sales growth has slowed sharply, home prices in August posted their steepest decline in 9 years, and yields on 10-year Chinese government bonds have plummeted to new lows.
“consumer confidence sank in July while inflation remains near zero business surveys in August recorded sinking profits in Chinese manufacturers inventories are swelling Car Sales have been dropping and retail sales growth has slowed sharply home prices in August posted their steepest decline in 9 years and yields on 10year Chinese government bonds have plummeted to new lows indicating investors are souring on the economy's prospects”
In response to China's monetary announcements, Asian stocks rose, with equity benchmarks in Hong Kong jumping more than 2% at the open and onshore Chinese stocks also gaining, partly because China announced brokerages and funds could tap the central bank's funding to buy stocks following the CSI 300 index falling to more than a 5-year low.
“Asian stocks Rose in response to the development indicating the market in the short term at least is happy with the news Equity benchmarks in Hong Kong jumped more than 2% at the open while onshore Chinese stocks also gained this is partly because China also announced that it will allow brokerages and funds to tap the central bank's funding to buy stocks adding support after the CSI 300 index fell to more than a 5-year low”
The surveyed urban unemployment rate for Chinese people aged 16 to 24 (youth unemployment, excluding students) climbed to 18.8% in August 2024, the highest since the data series was first released in January 2023, surpassing July's 17.1% to set a record for the second consecutive month.
“according to new official data from the National Bureau of Statistics the surveyed Urban unemployment rate for Chinese people aged between 16 and 24 youth unemployment this excludes students climbed to the highest in August since the data series was first released in January the rate came in at 18.8% surpassing July's 17.1% to set a record for the second consecutive month”
The summer of 2024 saw an estimated 11.8 million new graduates from Chinese universities entering what is described as China's weakest job market in years, as companies in various sectors downsize to cut costs amid slowdown in economic growth and weak market confidence.
“the summer of 2024 saw a large proportion of an estimated 11.8 million new graduates entering quote what is arguably China's weakest job market in years as companies in various sectors downsize to cut costs amid a Slowdown in economic growth and weak Market confidence end quote”
Shan Mong, director at Chanon and Co, observed that measures to support the stock market cannot directly change company earnings trajectories and cannot directly guide investor decisions, so while they may be good for the stock market in the mid to long term, they lack substantial basis in the near term.
“Shan Mong director at uh chanon and Co who observed today quote measures to support stock market can't directly change company's earnings trajectory and can't directly guide investors decisions so while they may be good for the stock market in the mid to long term they lack substantial basis in the near term”
Wong HW Hong, head of institutional equities at Maybank Securities, expressed that the announced measures are not the 'bazooka' stimulus package market participants were waiting for, market reaction from clients is quite limited, and the market consensus is those expecting consumption-boosting moves would not see them until after the US elections.
“Wong HW Hong head of institutional equities at Maybank Securities told clients today quote it is not the Bazooka that those looking at Hong Kong China were waiting for and the reaction from some clients is quite limited market participants would like to see more perhaps other moves to boost consumption and the general consensus seemed to be those would not be forthcoming until after the US elections Hong Kong stocks Rose but we will have to see if those gains can hold end quote”
There is a striking disconnect between the Chinese people and their modern leaders, with President Xi Jinping hailing a thriving nation destined to become a prosperous superpower by 2049, while ordinary Chinese see their country entering a different period captured in the phrase 'garbage time of history'.
“it is hard to recall a more striking disconnect between the Chinese people and their modern leaders when President Xi Jinping marks the 75th anniversary of the founding of the People's Republic of China on the 1st of October he will hail a thriving Nation destined to become a prosperous superpower by its Centennial in 2049 ordinary Chinese on the other hand see their country entering quite a different period captured in a recent coined phrase the garbage time of history”
Many in China are convinced their country is trapped in a simple, futile dead end, with prospects unlikely to brighten as long as its direction remains unchanged.
“many in China are convinced their country is trapped in a simly futile dead end its prospects unlikely to brighten as long as its direction remains unchanged”
Now Chinese are not only dissatisfied with government decisions, but more importantly, they see no possibility of improvement because the leadership of the Chinese Communist Party has repeatedly signaled that it intends to maintain the same domestic and foreign policies that have led to economic stagnation at home and geopolitical tensions abroad.
“Now Chinese are not only dissatisfied with government decisions more importantly they see no possibility of improvement because the leadership of the Chinese Communist party has repeatedly signaled that it intends to maintain the same domestic and foreign policies that have led to economic stagnation in home and geopolitical tensions abroad”
The phrase 'garbage time of history' is a thinly veiled dig at Xi's open-ended rule, implying that the sorry state of affairs will not change as long as he stays in power.
“the phrase garbage time of History thus is a thinly veiled dig at she's open-ended rule implying that the sorry State of Affairs will not change as long as he stays in power”
Lowering tensions with China's neighbors and the US is a minimum first step toward restoring optimism, and implementing real economic reforms such as diverting resources from high-end manufacturing to stimulating consumption would boost sentiment.
“lowering tensions with China's Neighbors in the US is a minimum First Step implementing real economic reforms for example diverting resources from highend manufacturing to stimulating consumption would boost sentiment”
If Xi relinquished some of his positions in top decision-making bodies—he currently chairs at least five central commissions and three leading groups—he would signal a willingness to share power, which is unlikely but necessary to avoid China's spiral into stagnation.
“if she relinquished some of his positions in top decision-making bodies he currently chairs at least five central commissions and three leading groups he would signal a willingness to share power as unlikely as those options may seem the alternative path will not be pretty”
Beijing may be waiting to see who will be in the White House after the US election before deciding which stimulus measures and fiscal policies to pursue, a point previously covered in earlier episodes.
“it could well be that Beijing is waiting to see who will be in the white house after the US election before they decide which stimulus measures and fiscal policies to turn to”
Official Chinese media and propagandists have strongly denounced the phrase 'garbage time of history', but restoring a sense of optimism will require something more than censorship.
“not surprisingly official media and propagandists have strongly denounced the phrase restoring a sense of optimism will require something more than censorship however”
Geopolitical tensions with the West have diminished China's prospects, and most Chinese people simply do not see when and how relations with the US and other important trading partners will return to normal.
“more over geopolitical tensions with the West have diminished the country's prospects and most Chinese people simply do not see when and how relations with their most important trading partners will return to normal”
The Communist Party of China surely doesn't want to meet the same fate as the Soviet Union, and to avoid it Xi Jinping and the Party will have to rethink their game plan.
“the CCP surely doesn't want to meet the same fate to avoid it she and the party will have to rethink their game plan here ends the direct quote and today's episode of China update”
The malaise in China has deeper political roots than economic woes alone; the country has experienced much worse economic times before without disappearing, but the difference is that previous citizens believed in the competence of reformist leadership and accepted that decisive action was necessary.
“the malaise however has deeper political Roots the country has gone through much worse Economic Times before without disappearing tens of thousands of state-owned Enterprises were liquidated and more than 30 million workers laid off at the end of the 1990s still ordinary Chinese remained optimistic about the future the difference is that those citizens believed in the competence of the reformist then Premier jongi they accepted that the government needed to take decisive action”
Jun Rong Yip, market strategist at IG Asia, observed that market participants may like the announced stimulus, as the effects could drive a short-term rebound in Chinese equities by dispelling previous concerns around government inaction.
“Jun Rong Yip a market strategist at IG Asia expressed today quote Market participants may like what they see today the effects could drive a short-term Rebound in Chinese equities as the latest move dispels previous concerns around the authorities in action end quote”
Market reaction to the announced stimulus measures may not be sustainable, as evidenced by Hong Kong stocks rising but observers noting uncertainty about whether those gains will hold.
“but is this Market reaction sustainable Jun Rong Yip a market strategist at IG Asia expressed today quote Market participants may like what they see today the effects could drive a short-term Rebound in Chinese equities as the latest move dispels previous concerns around the authorities in action end quote Wong HW Hong head of institutional equities at Maybank Securities told clients today quote it is not the Bazooka that those looking at Hong Kong China were waiting for and the reaction from some clients is quite limited market participants would like to see more perhaps other moves to boost consumption and the general consensus seemed to be those would not be forthcoming until after the US elections Hong Kong stocks Rose but we will have to see if those gains can hold end quote”
Leo Shin, former deputy head of the development Research Center at the state Council, is calling for at least 10 trillion yuan (approximately 1.42 trillion USD) in ultra-long-term government bonds to be sold to save the economy.
“yesterday we covered former deputy head of the development Research Center at the state Council Leo Shin's call for at least 10 trillion yen 1.42 trillion doar in ultr Long government bonds to be sold to save the economy”
At 75 years old, the People's Liberation Army has already beaten the longevity record of the Soviet Union by one year.
“at 75 years old the PLC has already beaten the longevity record of the Soviet Union by one year”
In sports, garbage time refers to the point in a game in which one team trails so badly that defeat is no longer in doubt, and the remainder of the contest is filled with pointless, low-quality play.
“in sports garbage time refers to the point in the game in which one team Trails so badly that defeat is no longer in doubt the remainder of the contest is filled with pointless lowquality play”