
What Comes After the Dollar dies
What this covers
This is a single-presenter talk by Jeff Snider of Eurodollar University, with a short interjection from a speaker identified as Josh. It traces ledger money across several centuries, from medieval money changers and goldsmiths who began mingling coins and valuables, through the 19th-century correspondent networks and the National Banking era, to the modern eurodollar. Snider's recurring point is that banks are bookkeepers rather than storage facilities. Each stage, he argues, came from commerce wanting mobile, efficient settlement while officials kept their attention on gold coins and bank notes. He cites the National Banking era, when banks could issue Treasury-backed notes but kept choosing demand deposits.
The middle of the talk covers the eurodollar's own history and how it was misread. Snider cites Robert Russa's 1984 description of "new networks of interbank relations" outside Fed control. He treats the 2008 crisis as a global monetary breakdown rather than a subprime story, pointing to Ben Bernanke's admission of a "global dollar problem." He argues that quantitative easing concealed the dysfunction instead of fixing it. He also reads Zhou Xiaochuan's 2009 paper as an acknowledgment that the system had broken, not an attack on the dollar. Some of this is contested, and his claim that FDR's 1933 gold confiscation freed ledger money to evolve is likely to draw pushback.
The final stretch turns to Bitcoin. Snider applies the three pillars of reserve currency function (confidence, liquidity, adjustability) and argues Bitcoin's store-of-value emphasis is a wrong turn. He says stablecoins come closer to solving the payments problem, though with structural flaws of their own. Josh's example is Argentines preferring physical $100 bills because they can be deposited into the eurodollar system. Snider closes by saying fiscal and Fed excesses should be handled at the ballot box, not by hoping for a currency collapse.
The global monetary system has evolved through centuries toward increasingly sophisticated ledger-based money systems, and Bitcoin has taken a wrong turn by prioritizing store-of-value over the medium-of-exchange and payment-system utility that the free market actually demands; the next evolutionary step requires a peer-to-peer ledger system focused on practical commercial adoption, not price appreciation.
- Ledger money has dominated commerce for centuries because it's more efficient than physical currency for sophisticated economies
- The eurodollar's dominance stems from widespread availability and acceptability as a practical payment medium, not government mandate
- Bitcoin's focus on store-of-value and price gains contradicts the commercial adoption pattern that previous ledger money systems achieved in 15-year periods
This asset isn't compiled yet
You're seeing its claims, ranked. Compile it to build the argument threads, weight them, and check each claim against your library — the full view.
During the National Banking era (1864 onwards), banks had the profitable ability to print their own US dollar currency through Treasury-backed note issuance, yet consistently chose demand deposits (ledger money) instead, revealing that commerce preferred ledger mobility over physical currency
“Banks had the ability to to print currency as they saw fit paper currency uh fractional Reserve lending... Banks had this option to print their own currency and it was profitable for them to do so uh we know this from uh firsthand Accounts at the time”
A global reserve currency must satisfy three conditions: confidence, liquidity, and ability to adjust with changing times; rigid systems will simply drive commercial activity into shadow money innovations
“Robert Solomon described what Reserve currencies especially International Reserve currencies must do first of all you have to have confidence in the reserve currency which seems self-evident second thing is liquidity because in order to be able to operate a ledger system you have to have liquidity in the system because it's a dynamic very changing environment and the first thing is it has to be able to adjust with the times”
A reserve currency succeeds by being widely available and widely acceptable as an intermediate medium for transactions between parties with different local currencies, enabling efficient settlement without requiring bilateral currency conversion
“in order to be a useful medium it has to be widely available is ALS is also and also be widely acceptable what does that mean let's do a simple example here so you've got a Swedish export firm that wants to sell its goods to somebody in Japan so Japan's going to import the goods from Sweden what Japan has to pay for those goods is Yen and Sweden wants to get paid in croner well the Japanese don't have croner and if they send them Yen the swedes have nothing they have no use for Yen so how can we get these two parties to transact”
Medieval money changers solved a real commercial problem by providing exchange services to merchants traveling through Italy and Europe, making cumbersome currency-conversion processes more efficient through voluntary deposit and exchange arrangements
“in medieval Italy for example you had a sophisticated money changing Network which was all about Merchants who traveled all throughout Italy or even Europe you would need different forms of payment at every stop along the way so money changers basically made what was a a cumbersome inefficient oftentimes very expensive process a little bit less cumbersome and expensive by offering monetary services”
Robert Russa in 1984 described the eurodollar system as 'new networks of interbank relations' existing outside Federal Reserve control, while the Fed continued discussing bank reserves and physical cash, revealing the structural gap between official understanding and actual money systems
“as Robert Russa said 1984 new networks of interbank relations which perfectly describes what we're talking about Ledger money here but outside the control of the federal Reserve because Federal Reserve is still talking about Bank Reserves and physical cash”
Goldsmiths became quasi-banks not because of their vaults, but because they began mingling coins and valuables to perform monetary and financial services—this shift from storage to financial intermediation marks the origin of banking.
“a vault doesn't make you a bank so when a wealthy individuals began storing their coins in these vaults if they were strictly if they were strictly interested in store value they would store their their coins or valuables or whatever it was under ailment which just meant you I put my property in your Vault and you don't touch it's just there for safekeeping that does not make you a bank what made these Artisans start to become quasi Banks was when they began to mingle their coins and other valuables and and perform financial and monetary services”
In 2008, the crisis was not caused by subprime mortgages but was fundamentally a global monetary breakdown in the eurodollar system, which Ben Bernanke acknowledged in 2010 by admitting to Congress that 'there was a global dollar problem.'
“so 20 08 wasn't subprime mortgages it was a global monetary breakdown which means if we have a global monetary breakdown we should try to fix the global monetary breakdown that actually happened”
FDR's 1933 gold confiscation did not establish government monetary monopoly because government never had monopoly control of money; instead, it unleashed the next stage of ledger money evolution by removing gold constraints and allowing banks to experiment with purely ledger-based systems
“when FDR came in in the early 1930s and confiscated gold cont contrary to what maybe most people think um it did not lead to reestablishing the Monopoly of government money because there was no Monopoly of government money”
Humanity has been moving toward ledger-based money systems for centuries, not just decades, and this trajectory has opened the door to cryptocurrencies as a logical evolutionary step
“we have been moving toward a ledger money system not for years not for decades but for centuries and that has opened the door to other types of of efficient Ledger money including cryptocurrencies starting with Bitcoin”
The current global monetary system based on the eurodollar has reached the end of its useful life and something must replace it, but replacement requires understanding that money systems are fundamentally about ledger-keeping and efficient payment settlement, not about physical stores of value
“current Global monetary system the reserve currency euro dollar not dollar has reached the end of its useful life and that means something else needs to replace it but what the key distinction between dollar and Euro dollar is about Ledger money and really who keeps The Ledger”
Bitcoin has taken a wrong turn in its development by focusing on store-of-value characteristics rather than on ledger-based medium-of-exchange functionality and payment system efficiency that the free market actually demands
“did Bitcoin take a wrong turn in its attempt to take over as the latest Evolution and the latest evolutionary step in Humanity's drive toward Ledger money”
In hyperinflationary countries like Argentina, people overwhelmingly prefer physical US $100 bills over gold, silver, or Bitcoin because bills can be deposited in banks to access the eurodollar system, revealing that practical commercial utility trumps monetary theory
“we drove across Argentina with the hopes of just using Gold Silver and Bitcoin because it's so easy to come up here on stage and theorize upon what would happen if the dollar hyper inflates or a currency hyper inflates of course everyone's just going to use the hard money”
In feudal Europe and primitive economies, store-of-value function dominated monetary demand because commerce was limited and localized, but as economies industrialized and integrated, commerce shifted demand toward mobile, efficient ledger-based media of exchange
“store value money was always the most important because in early societies you had no reason to exchange money think about in feudal Europe you don't need a mobile monetary system or currency system sore value was Supreme because that's what the most that's what the that's what most people were worried about”
The Federal Government's fiscal irresponsibility and the Federal Reserve's monetary experimentation should be addressed through political mechanisms (the ballot box), not through hopes for currency system collapse or dollar replacement
“if you want to get control over federal government spending or overreach because those two things go hand inand don't look to the dollar to solve your problem for you don't look for the destruction of the treasury market to solve your problem for you that has to be done at The Ballot Box”
The correspondent network of the latter 19th century was a primitive telecommunications-based ledger system that created the world's largest non-cash payment system while policy makers remained focused on gold coins and national bank notes
“the correspondent Network which is really is really just a ledger system which you have independent ledgers that are integrated together through telecommunications they're able to settle wide wide handle large volumes and settle on a wide geographical footprint you had the world's largest non-cash payment system in the Primitive economy of the latter half of the 19th century”
The eurodollar system emerged because international commerce required a ledger-based payment mechanism that could span global boundaries and integrate multiple national banking ledgers into a coherent international settlement system
“the euro dollar took this another step even further and it makes sense because when you think about what money actually is and what it needs to do it communicates a need I need to be paid because I've done something for you or I've given you something and the exchange of money settles that transaction”
Most eurodollar lending occurs between non-US entities, with international commerce participants borrowing dollars from other non-US participants and redistributing them to third parties, meaning the eurodollar system is driven by non-US international trade, not US monetary policy
“most of the access to the EUR dollar system isn't with from Americans at all it's International Commerce International free markets most of the euro dollar is people outside the US borrowing dollars dollars quote unquote dollars from other people who are outside the US and then redistributing those dollars to someone else outside the United States it is truly an international Ledger money system”
Zhou Xiaochuan's 2009 IMF publication suggesting consideration of alternative reserve currencies was misinterpreted as China attacking the dollar when he was actually acknowledging that the eurodollar system had broken down and required fixing
“the governor of the People's Bank of China was saying you didn't fix anything Joe Shout Twan in 2009 wrote a I think it was a speech but it became a publication of the IMF where he basically said you know this euro dollar systems you guys have just kind of broke down in a very big way maybe we should consider thinking about something else and of course this made big news in March of 2009 cuz here was China attacking the dollar when really all he was saying is something bad happened we should consider it fix consider fixing it”
The Federal Reserve's post-2008 Quantitative Easing policies did not actually fix the global monetary breakdown; instead, they concealed the underlying eurodollar system dysfunction through liquidity injections while policy makers misunderstood the actual nature of the problem
“another bureaucrat who's completely fullish told you that I fixed everything with QE but he also told you that subprime mortgages was contained at a Fallout from subprime mortgages contained”
Banks operate as bookkeepers and ledger-keepers, not storage facilities, and invest in telecommunications and computer infrastructure to maintain the protocols and standards that make ledger networks useful for commerce
“they're not stores of value they're not storage facilities they're bookkeepers they're Ledger Keepers so we have sophisticated banks that invest in sophisticated infrastructure mostly computers and Telecommunications technology they they handle the standards they handle the protocols they keep the network they keep the network running”
The eurodollar system is a bottom-up free market innovation driven by international commerce, not top-down government creation, and therefore resists replacement because it solves real problems that any alternative must solve at least as well
“the euro dollar system is highly motivated as well as really good at integrating all of these ledgers all across the world now we don't just have a national payment system on a ledger basis we've got an international payment system”
Three common misconceptions driving Bitcoin's development are store-value supremacy, dollar doomism (belief that bitcoin will emerge when dollar collapses), and confusing price appreciation with actual commercial progress
“what's been driving Bitcoin and I think a lot of people's interest in Bitcoin there's three common I'll call them miss one is obviously the store value Supremacy... another argument you hear from Bitcoin is that they just simply need to wait for the dollar to destroy itself... and then the third thing is that people I think are confusing the price of Bitcoin for Progress”
Bitcoin advocates should refocus from price appreciation toward the three pillars of reserve currency function (confidence, liquidity, and flexibility), starting from the bottom up to demonstrate that free markets will voluntarily adopt the system
“in order to get step three right we got to understand what step three actually is... I think there are still tremendous capabilities and capacities in Bitcoin... we got to get this thing working the right way moving towards more useful more mobile more flexible ledger money”
The Austrian school emphasis on commodity money and 'hard money' reflects historical fears appropriate to feudal economies and does not align with the actual demands of modern integrated commercial systems.
“there's really three functions or three roles for money there's store value there's Medi of exchange and unit of account and store value money was always the most important because in early societies you had no reason to exchange money think about in feudal Europe... but as feudal Europe we went through Renaissance period Mercantile expansion Innovation all that kind of stuff money as as economic systems became more sophisticated you had to become more s money had to become more sophisticated and mobile too”
Stable coins are closer to solving the payments problem than Bitcoin because they prioritize liquidity and adjustability (flexibility), which are two of the three pillars of effective reserve currencies, though stable coins have their own structural problems
“stable coins are closer to meeting that need of a payment system a flexible Dynamic medium than Bitcoin is but there's also a number of problems with stable coins stable coins essentially are in many ways especially reserved stable coins just an extension of the euro dollar system”
Governments and academic economists historically failed to recognize ledger money as actual money despite its commercial dominance, calling it shadow money or shadow banking, because ledger systems exist outside official policy perception and understanding
“most officials and most U government especially in the government and economists they didn't consider it money at all again this is just goes back to what I was saying earlier about a blank spot where it comes to ledgers for most people they didn't consider this Ledger form of money money at all including the assistant Secretary of State”
Physical hand-to-hand currency was never the dominant form of money even under the classical gold standard—ledger-based bank deposits were already dominant in the 19th century, contradicting mythology about commodity money dominance.
“Ledger money especially in the L half of 19th century and of course you see the 20th century where it really starts to go uh almost parabolic at that point but in you know in 1867 at the end of the Greenback era you got one one a172 in demand deposits for every dollar that circulates in handhand currency”
Between 80-90% of all forex (foreign exchange) transactions involve the dollar on one side, and while the Chinese yuan's share has increased, this represents yuan replacing the yen (with dollars still on the other side), not yuan replacing the dollar as reserve currency.
“when you look at the Forex markets about 86 or 80 really between 80 and 90% of all Forex uh uh transactions are doll the dollar is on the other side of almost every single one so if you look at the black line there which is other other is really China's Yuan you see that China's yuan is going up that's not the Yuan replacing the dollar that's actually the Yuan replacing the Yen on the other side of these transactions with dollars because the dollar Remains the dominant denomination”
A logarithmic forex chart shows a massive change in trend beginning in 2008, indicating a 'massive change in Trend' that suggests dollar dysfunction in terms of capacity and capability, which opens the door to potential competing systems.
“I will point out too this is a logarithmic scale you notice the change in Trend massive change in Trend right in 2008 which means that's another measure of dollar dysfunction but not in terms of its capabilities in terms of its capacities so that has opened the door to some competing system”
Predictions that China will replace the dollar (2011 bilateral trade agreements, 2018 Petrodollar, 2021 digital yuan, BRICS gold standard) have repeatedly failed because these alternatives lack the technological infrastructure and global network integration that the eurodollar provides
“they're not doing anything close to to investing in the technology and resources that would be required in order to undertake the roles of a true Reserve currency”
The most eurodollar information available is still measured through foreign exchange markets, which represent the most important modern aspect of the eurodollar system, driven by approximately 85-90% currency derivative transactions.
“what information we do have shows the dollar is as dominant As It Ever Was from the bis and really if you want to understand um how the euro dollar system works in and put together FX markets are now the most important aspect of it one of the biggest reasons why the euro dollar has survived is because it's constantly evolving too and we'll get to that in just a second why that's important but we now have an FX which means derivative driven uh monetary system that's the payment networks and financial flows and everything else it's driven by Forex derivatives in the is on the other side of almost every single transaction”
Predictions of dollar collapse and replacement have persisted for 15 years without materializing because people misunderstand that reserve currency dominance reflects practical utility, not government power, and the dollar remains useful despite government fiscal problems
“we've been hearing these Arguments for 15 years and really longer than that you've been hearing about how the dollar is going to be destroyed there isn't a day that goes by you don't hear some news item that people are going to spin into this is the thing that blow destroys the dollar yet every time still here”
Bitcoin still has 'tremendous capabilities and capacities' and could theoretically succeed as the next evolutionary step if the community redirects focus from store-of-value ideology toward liquidity and adjustability.
“that doesn't mean that Bitcoin is finished that there's no chance I think there are still tremendous capabilities and capacities in Bitcoin I still believe in the idea of Bitcoin I am still a fan of Bitcoin what I'm saying here is that I don't think that Bitcoin went in the right direction”
If stage-three monetary evolution is achieved correctly, the results would unleash prosperity comparable to previous evolutionary steps—creating 'sustainable economic advance' and 'wealth building' on a global scale.
“if we do this right it's like the last two the last two evolutionary steps Unleashed more prosperity across more of the world than human beings had ever been able to imagine before that's the opportunity that awaits us if we do this right we get step three right we ditch this depression stuff we ditch this instability and the world looks a whole lot better we can go through another period of prosperous really prosperous wealth building sustainable economic advance”