YouTube21m· Oct 2022· cataloged

Inflation is about money and that means and has meant eurodollar, not the Federal Reserve.


What this covers

In this 21-minute talk, Jeff Snider builds a historical comparison between three periods: the late 1940s, the 1970s, and the present. He starts from the distinction between a monetary event and a price event, then asks what each period did with a supply shock. The 1940s serve as the case where nothing monetary followed. In August 1948, Fed Chairman Thomas McCabe warned Congress that credit expansion might feed rising prices, which Snider says sounds just like Jay Powell now. Congress granted temporary power to raise reserve requirements, the Fed used it sparingly, and a recession began that November.

The 1970s are the contrasting case, and most of the talk goes there. Snider covers the 1973 oil embargo, the jump in exporters' reserves to 34 billion dollars in 1974, and the early development of LIBOR so that poor oil producers could reach dollar credit. His claim is that London banks took those deposits and lent them to oil importers, a process he calls credit redistribution. He cites John Karlik's 1977 congressional testimony on the eurocurrency market's role. In his account this channel turned a supply shock into true inflation, and without it the decade would have been a recession. He also rejects the "petrodollar" label, saying the deposits were eurodollars held offshore rather than US Treasuries.

The last part applies this to today, and it is where the claims turn most contentious. Snider argues that 2021 price increases were transitory because 2020 involved no money printing, and that Japan's price rises are a supply shock its yen cannot sustain. He reads the strong dollar, collapsing yen and yuan, and swelling Swiss National Bank dollar swap demand (from 3 billion to over 11 billion) as signs of a dollar shortage. He also argues that the Fed has historically conflated money with inflation.

Sharpest takeaway

Current consumer price increases are not true inflation but supply-driven price shocks; without the eurodollar credit redistribution system functioning (as it did in the 1970s), we face a monetary shortage resembling the 1940s rather than the monetary excess of the 1970s.

  • Milton Friedman's definition of inflation as a purely monetary phenomenon distinguishes between money printing and supply-driven consumer price acceleration
  • The 1970s saw eurodollar banks redistribute petrodollar deposits from oil exporters back to oil importers, enabling credit expansion that made a supply shock inflationary; today that system is broken, creating dollar shortage instead
  • Currency valuations reveal the truth: 1970s saw dollar weakness as other currencies rose; today dollar strength and other currency collapse signals monetary shortage, not surplus

The claims · ranked19 claims · weighted by value

This asset isn't compiled yet

You're seeing its claims, ranked. Compile it to build the argument threads, weight them, and check each claim against your library — the full view.

0.74

Milton Friedman, after exhaustive investigation of economies and systems worldwide, defined inflation as always and everywhere a monetary phenomenon, meaning too much money chasing too few goods, which is distinct from situations where consumer prices can increase systemically without being true inflation.

definitionhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 4/4· Jeff Snider

“it is quote-unquote inflation in the form of consumer price acceleration and consumer price increases but it's not the same thing as inflation as Milton Friedman said a very long time ago and he wasn't just throwing darts at the wall here after exhaustive investigation of economies and systems all over the world he said inflation is always and everywhere a monetary [0:31] phenomena which means the old adage too much money chasing too few goods but there are other situations when consumer prices can increase even systemically for what appears to be a sustained period of time that is not inflation it's not due to too much money”

0.74

After the 1973 OPEC oil embargo, oil prices surged, and oil-exporting nations' combined reserves increased by 34 billion dollars in 1974 (a massive sum at the time), up from only 2-3 billion in 1972-1973, shifting them from poor to wealthy positions.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 4/4· Jeff Snider

“this is the the 45th annual bis report from 1975 which shows that oil exporting Nations they had um reported reserves of about 3 billion 4 billion in 1972-73 so before the Embargo their increased reserves was a couple billion dollars not all that much but then in 1974 suddenly their their combined [5:45] reserves go up by 34 billion when 34 billion was a hell of a lot of money back then so they had very little funds actual funds of their own these are deposits not loans uh in before 1972 1973 so before the Embargo the 1974 suddenly 34 billion they're rich they've got a lot of deposits a lot of their own money”

0.74

Eurodollar banks that accepted oil exporter deposits offered competitive interest rates and then re-lent those funds to oil-importing countries, thereby closing the credit circuit and redistributing the monetary gains from oil price increases to those who needed dollar liquidity.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 4/4· Jeff Snider

“now that these oil exporting countries have all these deposits they leave them on deposit in the euro currency Market because the euro dollar banks that take in those deposits offer them competitive [9:23] interest and then they re-lend those funds to the oil importing countries closing the circuit”

0.74

Dr. John Karlik, senior economist of Congress's Joint Economic Committee and former Federal Reserve economist, testified to Congress in February 1977 that the eurocurrency market provided vital service by accepting large oil producer deposits and lending to hard-pressed oil-importing developing nations, without which they could not contend with increased energy and food costs.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 4/4· Jeff Snider

“from Dr John karlik who was testifying for congress Congress has joined economic committee he was not just a joint joint economic committee's senior economist he was also a former senior Economist at the Federal Reserve what he told Congress in February 1977 just to put a [12:00] Finishing Touch on our inflation is money Story the euro currency Market provided a vital service in accepting large deposits from oil producing countries and lending the funds to hard-pressed oil importing Nations developing countries contending with increased energy and food costs and subsequently with a drop in earnings for their own commodity exports have been especially aided by credits obtained in the euro dollar market”

0.74

Congress approved the Federal Reserve's temporary authority to raise reserve requirements in response to McCabe's 1948 warning; the Fed acted sparingly in August 1948, but the recession of 1948-1949 officially began in November 1948, just months later, showing supply-driven price pressures resolved naturally.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 4/4· Jeff Snider

“Congress approved the federal reserve's temporary authority to raise reluctantly said you know what consumer prices have [16:43] been going up you're right there may be a danger that it's going to continue granted them Authority they use the reserve requirements in August of 1948 very sparingly though but it didn't matter because the recession of 4849 which officially began in November of 1948 so barely barely months after the FED started to move we already saw the downturn in prices begin the month before McCabe went to [17:13] Congress whereas a tier I have in my notes wholesale prices had been or consumer prices had been 9.9 percent the CPI was rising at 9.9 percent in July of 1948 it was already 8.9 percent by the time Congress or by the time McKay went to Congress and it was two percent by January 1949 because the recession was already underway the supply shock had taken care of [17:44] quote unquote inflation before it ever became actual inflation in fact there was really no danger of that actually happening”

0.73

The world has been experiencing a dollar shortage, not a surplus, contrary to popular belief, particularly evident in Japan's difficulty securing sufficient dollars to pay for higher import costs of oil, food, and other goods.

factualhigh valuecontestednovelty 3/4durability 3/4· Jeff Snider

“Japan had to pay for higher [3:36] import costs because the supply restriction and oil and food and some other Goods meant that Japan needed a whole lot of dollars but Japan can't get the whole lot of dollars and has is is having an enormous amount of trouble securing those dollars because there aren't that many available contrary to popular to popular belief the world has been experiencing a dollar shortage not a surplus”

0.73

Oil-importing nations' reserve growth was cut off because they had to use their reserves to pay for higher oil prices; without eurodollar bank redistribution, the economy would have ground to a halt and the situation would have automatically rebalanced as a recession, preventing the inflationary 1970s that actually occurred.

causalhigh valuecontestednovelty 3/4durability 3/4· Jeff Snider

“in order to pay for a lot more of the higher oil prices to pay for all the oil that they were importing they had to use a lot of their reserves or what would have been Reserve growth however that wrist shutting off the the [8:23] money and credit that would normally flow to the internal capacity of each of these oil importing countries economy but there was a solution there that solution was redistribution of the euro dollar system”

0.71

Japan experiencing consumer price increases now is not inflation but a supply shock, and the Japanese Yen lacks sufficient money supply to sustain those price increases, causing major economic problems.

causalhigh valuecontestednovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Jeff Snider

“Japan as we went through yesterday provides the perfect counter example for why this isn't inflation and Japan is experiencing now the Consumer Price shock that most of the rest of the world has experienced already now it's starting to seep into a wider variety of goods in Japan because up until just recently this year the Japanese economy had been held back by coronavirus restrictions and advisements from the government lack of movement lack of economic um flow through but now that the Japanese are actually experiencing consumer prices it's leading to all sorts of problems that we see around the rest of the world including the fact is in the Japanese Yen there isn't enough money to sustain the price increases”

0.69

There was no money printing in 2020; consumer price increases in 2021 resulted from supply shocks—inability of the global economy to respond to rebounding demand accelerated by government intervention—which was temporary and transitory because it did not lead to the money printing necessary to turn a supply shock into actual inflation.

causalhigh valuecontestednovelty 3/4durability 2/4· Jeff Snider

“but there are other situations when consumer prices can increase even systemically for what appears to be a sustained period of time that is not inflation it's not due to too much money the problem that we have nowadays is that we look at March of 2020 and all the government interference the Federal Reserve and everything else and everybody says well there was too much money printing in 2020 and therefore [1:01] consumer price increase Consumer Price inflation by 2021 but no there was no money printing in 2020 we have the data to back that up and the consumer price increases in 2021 we're about everything that you've heard Supply shock the lack of the the inability of the global economy to respond to the rebound in demand which was accelerated to a certain extent probably a good extent by government intervention but that was temporary transitory because it didn't [1:33] lead to the kind of money printing that would be necessary to turn a supply shock into actual inflation”

0.69

Today, unlike the 1970s, the eurodollar system is not functioning to redistribute money from commodity producers to commodity importers; therefore commodity-importing currencies are crashing and countries are experiencing major monetary and financial issues without the credit channel to absorb the shock.

causalhigh valuecontestednovelty 3/4durability 2/4· Jeff Snider

“without the euro dollar market without the introduction the expansion of credit [12:31] and money that the euro dollar system supplied you just have a transitory Supply shock it sounds very familiar doesn't it except the difference as I showed yesterday in Japan but not just Japan Japan is just one example among many we don't have the euro dollar countries standing in between redistributing or what did carlux say um contending with increased energy and [13:02] food costs subsequently with a drop in earnings for their own commodity exports have been especially aided by credits obtained in the euro dollar market not this time the credits in the euro dollar market are hard to come by and what have we seen we have seen those commodity those currencies crash those currencies go down as the difficulties in obtaining money and credits from the euro dollar system go way up”

0.68

The 1970s was inflationary specifically because eurodollar banks redistributed credit and created money that would have otherwise been cut off from oil-importing countries; inflation is a monetary phenomenon, and without the money and credit growth through the eurodollar channel, the 1970s would have been a recession instead.

causalhigh valuecontestednovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Jeff Snider

“that's why in good part the 1970s was inflationary because as these oil importing countries were deprived of their money and resources to pay higher oil prices which is one of the least productive economic uh economic developments that you can possibly imagine [10:55] there would be the economy in those oil important countries would just grind to a halt and the all the whole thing would just turn into a recession which would rebalance everything the way it's supposed to go it's only with the introduction of money and credit growth through the euro dollar channel that allowed the inflationary environment to flourish inflation is always an everywhere a monetary phenomenon take away those euro dollar Banks take away that credit redistribution oil exporters would have [11:27] been rich they would have gotten more money for higher oil prices but it would have been dare I say transitory as it was in the 1940s”

0.68

Without money creation, a supply shock is inherently transitory, as demonstrated in the 1940s and in the case of Japan today; the Federal Reserve consistently mistakes supply-driven price increases for monetary inflation and therefore always thinks it must do something, even when natural economic forces are self-correcting.

causalhigh valuecontestednovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Jeff Snider

“without the money you end up with a supply shot case like 1946 1947 1948 to 1949 which was a transitory Supply shock inflation case so even though it lasted from 1946 to 19 oh two years it was [18:15] still transitory and the FEDS still thought it had to do something else the psychology crap would end up causing more problems than it did but as we see in the contrast between say Japan or India or some other countries around the world today versus the 1970s if you don't have the euro dollar money Credit in between to redistribute cash flow back in the direction from where it came think of what karlik said 1977 1977 [18:46] without that money you end up with something like the 1940s which is which ends also very familiar with monetary shortages credit disruptions Financial instability and economic recession”

0.66

In the early 1970s, before the 1973 oil embargo, oil-producing states were relatively poor with very low oil prices and scarce investment; banks in London and the eurodollar market developed a benchmark rate (LIBOR) to allow poor oil producers to access eurodollar credit at decent rates so they could participate in the dollar credit expansion.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 4/4· Jeff Snider

“back in the early 70s before 1973's Oil Embargo oil producing states were relatively poor they had a very difficult time because oil prices were exceedingly low and investment was hard to come by in fact that's the reason we have Library uh just to digress a little bit 1969 banks in especially in London in the euro dollar market wanted to develop a [4:40] way to allow these these poor oil producers to at least be able to Source euro dollar money in credit at a relatively decent rate so they had to come up with essentially a benchmark rate to allow some of these poor oil producers to participate in the dollar credit expansion of that time”

0.65

Swiss National Bank dollar swaps started at 3 billion across 9 counterparties in early October and have grown to 17 banks bidding for over 11 billion, signifying a global dollar shortage and the breakdown of normal dollar credit channels.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 2/4durability 1/4· Jeff Snider

“Swiss National Bank dollar swaps [14:04] very significant sign of global dollar shortage started out with 3 billion first week in October nine counterparties and last week as I mentioned we're up to 15 counterparties and 6.3 billion and as of just a couple hours ago the Swiss National Bank now tells us it's 17 Banks bidding for over 11 billion Global dollar shortage”

0.63

Current economic issues (currency accelerations in Switzerland, weakness of Chinese Yuan and Japanese Yen, major money and financial issues) are not primarily inflationary but stem from the breakdown of eurodollar credit redistribution and resulting dollar shortage.

causalhigh valuecontestednovelty 2/4durability 2/4· Jeff Snider

“there's a lot that history can teach us about what we're going through now it's just that most people don't know the history and most people don't know the monetary system either so thank you for watching as always I'm [20:51] Jeff from your dollar University check us out at eurodollar.university for memberships always a special thank you to euro dollar University members we'll scroll some names at the end of this at the end of this of the video here and uh subscriptions research products all that kind of stuff all the information available at euro dollar dot University until next time take care”

0.56

The 34 billion in oil exporter deposits was placed in the eurocurrency market through London subsidiaries, not domestic US treasuries; this was not a 'petrodollar' but eurodollars functioning in their proper redistributive capacity.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 4/4· Jeff Snider

“of that 34 billion as the bis annual report says the great bulk of their Reserve gains was placed in the euro currency Market because where else was it going to go most people think dollars means domestic or it means U.S treasuries but it actually did mean U.S treasuries but not inside the United States they were sold mostly through London subsidiaries so this money these dollars what people mistakenly believe as a Petro dollar it's not a petrodollar actually it's the euro dollar functioning in the way it's [6:46] supposed to be”

0.52

In August 1948, Federal Reserve Chairman Thomas McCabe told Congress that a supply shock threatened to become sustained inflation unless action was taken, stating 'further credit expansion might add to the right pressure for Rising prices'—sounding exactly like Jay Powell today.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Jeff Snider

“now in August of 1948 consumer prices had been high for a couple years by then and at one point in 1947 the CPI was rising at almost a 20 percent annual rate 20 makes what we're going through now seem quaint August 1948 Federal Reserve chairman Thomas McCabe goes to Congress and tells them we got to do something here because if we don't do something this Supply shock is in danger of becoming inflation [15:07] sounds familiar sounds really familiar here's what he said in Congress 1940 August 1948 in view of the pressure of current demands the continued shortages of many Goods The Limited capacity for out increased output and the available accumulations of liquid assets sounds so damn familiar further credit expansion might add to the right pressure for Rising prices it's like Jay Powell I mean he sounds exactly like Jay Powell [15:40] today we have a supply shock issue that if we don't do something about it could turn into rapid inflation it could turn into uncontrolled inflation Thomas McCabe J Powell never seen him in the same room maybe that's maybe it's because there's 80 different 80 years difference in between 75 years difference between but they sound very familiar anyway”

0.52

The Federal Reserve throughout most of its history has believed money equals inflation, but this is a conceptual error; the institution is a very recent modern invention compared to its tortured actual history of misunderstanding monetary systems.

normativehigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Jeff Snider

“people don't realize that this this [19:18] invention of a modern Federal Reserve a capable technocratic institution is as I said a very recent modern invention the Federal Reserve throughout most of its history it's been a very tortured history money is inflation and what we see around the world not just today but especially today over the last year and a half it's not what they said it's not a surplus of money it's a shortage”

0.52

In the 1970s, the US dollar was weak against other currencies (dollar down, others up); today the dollar is very strong while all other currencies are collapsing, demonstrating that currency direction reveals the true monetary condition: today is a shortage, not a surplus.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Jeff Snider

“what did the US [19:49] dollars exchange value do against all these other currencies back in the 1970s the dollar was way down against these other currencies that went way up today we have the dollar going way up all the other currencies going way down so even if we can't see what is happening in the monetary system directly just the currency Direction tells us a good deal about what's really going on monetary no money no inflation that simple [20:19] that doesn't mean we don't have lots of problems it just means we have very different problems than what many people are expecting”