What this covers

This is an end-of-year conversation on the Forward Guidance feed (the show is On the Margin), in which a host and a co-host question Brent Johnson, CEO of Santiago Capital and author of the "dollar milkshake" idea. They begin with 2022, when a dollar that rose about 20% in the first nine months pushed through bonds, equities and gold. Johnson attributes the move to the rate hikes and expectations of them rather than to fundamentals. He treats the bear market rallies of the year as normal bear-market behavior, short squeezes of 15-20% rather than a turn, and stays cautious on risk assets going into 2023. The hosts also ask whether the Fed lost credibility, noting it was criticized for unlimited money printing in 2020 and again for hiking too slowly.

The middle of the conversation moves from the Fed to the central banks that must live with its policy. Johnson spends the most time on the Bank of Japan. He argues it faces incompatible goals: QE) to suppress JGB) yields weakens the yen, while defending the yen requires higher rates that would hurt the bond market. He ties this to the September interventions by the Bank of England in gilts and by Japan in currency markets, and to the European Central Bank hiking while also buying bonds because of widening spreads. His general claim is that governments can hold both currency and bonds for a while, but eventually sacrifice the currency.

The final third widens into Triffin's Dilemma and the Fourth Turning. Here Johnson makes his more contested claims: that the dollar is a deliberate geopolitical weapon, that Europe is being de-industrialized to keep it from aligning with Russia and China, and that a strongman may emerge before any loss of empire. The host raises the Roman transition from republic to empire as a precedent. The talk closes with Johnson's 2023 calls, including his expectation that something important will break within one to two years and his preference for US equities over those of the rest of the world.

Sharpest takeaway

Brent Johnson argues that the US faces a fundamental conflict between domestic inflation control and global dollar supply needs (Triffin's dilemma), forcing central banks worldwide into crisis management, while the US maintains relative advantage through weaponized dollar policy that de-industrializes competitors and preserves imperial hierarchy.

  • Fed rate hikes export inflation globally while restricting domestic dollar supply, creating divergent policy needs between US and world economies
  • Central banks face impossible choices between defending currencies or bond markets—they cannot save both long-term, forcing them to sacrifice currencies
  • US uses dollar as geopolitical weapon to maintain hegemony, deliberately de-industrializing allies like Europe to prevent competing power blocs

The claims · ranked34 claims · weighted by value

This asset isn't compiled yet

You're seeing its claims, ranked. Compile it to build the argument threads, weight them, and check each claim against your library — the full view.

0.84

We are in the heart of Triffin's dilemma—when a country's currency is used as the global reserve currency, the needs of the domestic country eventually come into conflict with the needs of the international community.

definitionhigh valueestablishednovelty 2/4durability 4/4· Brent Johnson

“we are in the heart of triffin's dilemma if an individual country's currency is also used for the global Reserve currency there will come a point at which the needs of the domestic country come into conflict with the needs of the International Community”

0.74

The loss of faith in institutions (Fed, media, health organizations, education) is the unifying theme of 2022 and major symptom of the fourth turning crisis.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 4/4· Unknown Speaker (likely Michael)

“a big three point is loss of faith in a myriad of different institutions that support Everyday Life Society as a whole the FED... media mainstream media... health organizations... education system”

0.73

Japanese banks, insurance companies, and financial institutions held long-term JGBs with zero or negative yields; when yields rose 25 basis points in first three quarters of 2022, bond prices fell sharply due to high convexity, creating crisis in Japanese banking system.

causalhigh valueestablishednovelty 2/4durability 4/4· Brent Johnson

“Japanese Banks insurance companies endowments financial institutions have been buying long-term Japanese government bonds that either have zero yield or issued with a negative yield... as interest rates rise bond prices fall... with all the inflationary pressures that the world has felt over the last call at 12 to 24 months... that inflationary pressure even started to show up in Japan and as a result the jgb yield the yield in Japan Rose 25 basis points in the first three quarters of this year but the reason that's a problem is because there's so much convexity in these long-term bonds that if interest rates rise even a little bit the price drops a lot”

0.72

Fed rate hikes export inflation to the rest of the world; by raising rates to fight domestic inflation, Powell is removing dollars from global supply, forcing other countries to suffer inflation while the US controls it domestically.

causalhigh valuecontestednovelty 2/4durability 4/4· Brent Johnson

“even though the U.S needs to restrict dollars to combat local inflationary pressures the rest of the world needs dollars to continue operating and so the U.S domestic Market is able to withstand a tighter money market than the International Community... when Powell says we are going to raise rates because we need to inflate these inflationary pressures what he is actually doing is exporting the inflation that we have to the rest of the world”

0.69

The dollar strengthened 20% in the first nine months of 2022 due to Fed rate hike expectations; the movement was driven by rate hikes themselves, not economic fundamentals.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Brent Johnson

“at the end of the Q3 you know it I think it was up 20 for the year at that point and it was due for a pullback”

0.66

The Bank of England had to intervene in gilt market and Bank of Japan in JGB/FX market at end of September; ECB raised rates for first time in 10 years but simultaneously announced bond purchases because peripheral spreads were widening, indicating central bank coordination around global financial stress.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 4/4· Brent Johnson

“at the end of September so so so we had... the bank of Japan had to intervene in the jgb and currency Market they had to try to save both of them at the same time the bank of England had to intervene in the guilt Market... at the end of July the the European Central Bank raised interest rates for the first time in like 10 years but at the same meeting they announced that they had to start buying peripheral bonds because the periphery countries Bonds were starting to widen out”

0.66

The transition from Roman Republic to Roman Empire took ~700 years before the system collapsed; it is not impossible for the U.S. to make a similar transition from republic to autocracy, despite how improbable it seems from today's perspective.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 4/4· Unknown Speaker (host)

“there's a great book that was actually written on this by a guy named Tom Holland called Rubicon which uh covered in depth the transition of late stages of Roman Republic to very early stages of Empire...Rome had been around for I believe like 700 years before it ended up making that transition it was it was is impossible to them back then as it would be to us today”

0.65

Powell now has 4.5% in Fed funds rate (vs Bernanke's 3.5% before 2008), giving him more room to cut before hitting zero, thus more ammunition to fight future crises.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Brent Johnson

“Fed fund's rate was around three and a half percent you know they ultimately had to cut a lot and go to QE but you know Powell now has it at four and a half percent so he has more you know leeway to cut before getting to zero”

0.65

Bear market rallies (15-20% runs over 1-2 months) are characteristic of bear markets, not bull markets; they occur as shorts get squeezed and index-tracking participants struggle to keep up.

definitionhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Brent Johnson

“the always the amazing thing to me in Bear markets is the bear Market rallies bear Market rallies are just Killers for Bears... you typically don't get these 15 20 runs over a month or two in Bull markets you typically get those in Bear markets as the shorts get squeezed”

0.63

Before the US loses its empire, a strongman will rise to power, becoming more dictatorial, aggressive, and nationalist—this is the fourth turning pattern; the US will use all empire resources to strengthen rather than weaken itself.

forecasthigh valuefringenovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Brent Johnson

“what really kind of to be honest with what scares me the most is you know we talked about the fourth turning typically in the fourth turning before all hope is lost a strong man comes to power and kind of becomes more dictatorial becomes more aggressive becomes more nationalistic... I would expect that to happen here you know I would expect us to go from a republic to a you know Caesar shows up right Caesar shows up and imposes his will and then uses all the resources of the Empire to you know make the Empire stronger rather than weaker”

0.61

The Fed has been criticized from both sides: for unlimited QE and money printing in 2020, and for being slow to taper and too slow to hike in 2021-2022, leading to record inflation.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Unknown Speaker (likely Michael)

“we had sort of unlimited QE forever the QE bazooka money printer go Burr... the criticism over the the course of this that was that was an overreaction right... now the FED is sort of getting criticized on the other side of that right so we saw record inflation the Fed was arguably you know slow to the draw essentially in terms of petering off QE and uh hiking interest rates”

0.60

The Bank of Japan faced two incompatible policy goals: expanding QE to suppress JGB yields and save the bond market, but this weakened the yen 20% YTD, forcing currency intervention, which requires rate increases—the exact opposite of what's needed to save the bond market.

causalhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 3/4durability 4/4· Brent Johnson

“they put more yen into the market and that's why you saw the Yen was down like 20 in the year and the yin fell so much that it at the end of September this was that they had to come out and artificially support the Yen... because you know and to save the Yen you have to raise rates or you need less of it to save the bond market you need lower rates right and you need to buy them in order to keep those rates low and so they're at Cross purposes”

0.60

The Bank of Japan has been conducting extraordinarily loose monetary policy longer than Europe and the US, pioneering negative rates and quantitative easing, making it a canary in the coal mine for consequences of extreme policy.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 0/4durability 4/4· Brent Johnson

“the bank of Japan has been doing these extraordinary voluntary policies far longer than Europe and the United States they're kind of the pioneer with all of this stuff but they've had negative rates for a number they had negative rates for a number of years”

0.60

There is no doubt the Fed is using the US dollar as a weapon in the geopolitical competition; the US deliberately de-industrializes Europe to keep it as a vassal state and prevent it from partnering with Russia and China.

causalhigh valuefringenovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Brent Johnson

“it's no there's no doubt in my mind that the FED is using in the U.S has used the US dollar as a weapon um of course they are... one is it keeps them below you it keeps them a vassal state number two it keeps them from partnering with Russia and China”

0.56

The real political/social tension is not Republican vs Democrat but between institutional incumbents trying to maintain power and people who no longer trust institutions; revolutions happen when people are cold, hungry, and see no other path forward.

normativehigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 4/4· Brent Johnson

“people who are in institutions today or in institutional positions of power they're sort of clinging to that power even though the institutions no longer make sense... when you're hungry when you're cold we no longer think that the that the institutions have your best interests at heart and you just see no other way that's when you lash out that's when you push back that's when revolutions happen”

0.55

The fourth turning thesis (generational cycles, institutional crisis every ~80 years) is correct and provides a predictive framework; we are in a global fourth turning affecting all institutions.

factualhigh valuefringenovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Brent Johnson

“I I I think he's right on I mean I I read his book 10 years ago but it was written 20 years ago 25 years ago and it's it's amazing how prescient he was... it's kind of a global forth turning you know I don't think this is just happening in the United States I mean if you look at Europe you're seeing the same things the faith and Institution in Europe are failing the faith and institutions in Asia are failing”

0.55

Something important is likely to break in the next 1-2 years; this is not a period of stability but accelerating transition; maps will look different in 10 years.

forecasthigh valuefringenovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Brent Johnson

“I'm fairly highly confident in is that the map will look different 10 years from now than it will today and um I think uh borders will be redrawn unfortunately and and I don't think it will be a peaceful transition to those to that new map”

0.52

Powell believes the Fed and government have sufficient tools (rate cuts, QE) to save markets if a recession occurs; Johnson thinks this belief is overly arrogant and will get Powell in trouble.

causalhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Brent Johnson

“from the big picture I I think in his mind he believes that if if the market does go into a recession that he and his colleagues and the central bankers and the governments they have enough tools to then go in and save the market so to speak now that I think is probably an over exaggeration probably too arrogant for my taste and I think that will end up getting him in trouble”

0.52

Allies pushed back on the strong dollar in August and September 2022 because it was killing them; Powell's slowing of hikes was partly responsive to this geopolitical pressure.

causalhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Brent Johnson

“I've had meetings with people that I know for a fact that our allies abroad are pushing back on the strong dollar and they were pushing back hard in August and September no doubt about it because the strong dollar was just killing them and so I I my guess is that actually plays a little bit into Powell slowing down a little bit”

0.52

People mistakenly believe the US will lose its empire because it 'deserves' to fail morally, which clouds their judgment about whether the US can succeed structurally; emotion and morality should be removed from analysis of which system will win.

normativehigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 4/4· Brent Johnson

“over the last 10 years certainly the last 20 you know people have kind of started to realize that maybe the US isn't quite as squeaky squeaky clean and the White Knight that it holds out itself to be and as a result you know we kind of have this comeuppance coming towards us and we deserved uh when the chickens come home to roost we're going to deserve it and as a result then I think people think that because it's deserved that it's going to happen or it's going to happen right away and I think that's kind of the wrong way to think about it um I think that view clouds people's judgment”

0.51

You can temporarily save both currency and bond market through central bank intervention, but over long periods you must choose one; governments historically always sacrifice the currency to save the bond market because bond market is how government raises revenue.

causalhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 4/4· Brent Johnson

“you can save both of them for a short period of time but over a long period of time you have to choose one... governments always say we will not sacrifice the currency and then they always sacrifice the person always do it's just it's played out so many times in history... if they were to let the currency strengthen but collapse the banking system then you have another crisis... if you let the currency appreciate and you sacrifice the the bond market then you can't raise money anymore that's the bond market is the method by which the government gets money if the bond market collapses there's no more method by which the government can get money”

0.48

The US has structural advantages over the rest of the world and will weather economic storms better than its competitors, making US equities preferable to rest-of-world equities despite global challenges.

causalhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Brent Johnson

“I think the rest of the world is uh in worse shape than the United States and I think that the United States has a number of advantages whether they're deserved or not is kind of irrelevant I think we have them and I think that allows us to kind of weather the storm a little better”

0.48

Powell is determined to get inflation under control and will not pivot early even if it causes a recession; he will wait for the market to turn lower significantly before pivoting.

causalhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Brent Johnson

“I think Powell is bound and determined to get inflation under control I don't think he cares if he causes a recession to do it and I think there's great risk to to not only him personally but the FED as an institution if they were to Pivot too early and inflation were to re-accelerate... I don't think that he has the the guts so to speak to Pivot early so I think he will wait for the market to turn lower”

0.47

The constraint between saving currency and saving bond markets is not unique to Japan; it is coming to all major developed economies (US allies: Eurozone, UK; adversaries: China), and has long been a problem for emerging markets.

forecasthigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Brent Johnson

“basically there's this there's this tension that every country is going to have to solve at some point in between saving the currency Market saving the bond market that has Emerging Markets frankly been dealing with that for a long time but it's starting to come to Big United States allies right it's coming to the Eurozone it's coming to Japan not necessarily an ally but it's also coming to China”

0.46

The trade to 'short the dollar and go long emerging markets' is recommended every year by major institutions like Goldman Sachs but consistently fails to work out; Johnson does not expect it to work in 2023.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 2/4· Brent Johnson

“every year the trade of the year for the coming year is going to be short the dollar and go long Emerging Markets and somebody told me that Goldman kind of put out that recommendation a week or so ago but and I I don't know whether this is the case now but at in my mind this is the trade every year that everybody's supposed to do um and it just never works out now someday it will work out but so far it just hasn't”

0.43

Volatility will increase significantly going into 2023; markets will experience constant swings between inflation and deflation scenarios as central banks lose control.

forecasthigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Unknown Speaker (likely Michael)

“there's going to be this kind of let's call it long volatility going into this new year right where we're constantly moving in between inflation versus deflation”

0.43

Powell deserves credit for executing on his stated policy (consistent rate hikes despite market volatility) even though this has caused asset prices to decline 15-30%, because his goal was explicitly to kill demand and reduce froth without collapsing the system.

normativehigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Brent Johnson

“Powell wants that to happen I mean that's what he is trying to do he is trying to get asset prices down he's trying to get growth down he's trying to kill demand in order to get inflation under control now what he doesn't want is the system to collapse right and so if you measure him by I want to get rates higher I want to slow growth I want to get asset prices under control and get the froth out of the market without collapsing the economy so far again to be determined in the future but so far he has successfully done that”

0.43

Johnson recommends viewing the coming chaos with optimism rather than despair because the chaos will create tremendous opportunities; the key is maintaining openness to new ways of thinking.

normativehigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Brent Johnson

“I'm actually an optimist I'm actually taking I think there's good detail this chaos that I see coming is actually going to create great opportunity um I think you're going to have to keep a very open mind you're going to have to be open to new ways of thinking to but if you can do that I think the opportunities are tremendous”

0.43

We are at a key historical point where 'all the cards are on the table' and 'this is the really big game'; this is the game for all the marbles.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Brent Johnson

“I really feel like we're at this key point in history where all the cards are on the table and this is the really big game and this is kind of the game for all the Marvels right”

0.42

Gold will remain under pressure and trade lower in 2023; however, Johnson owns gold and recommends everyone own it as most important portfolio asset, expecting eventual payoff.

forecasthigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 2/4· Brent Johnson

“I think gold it will remain Under Pressure I do think that it's uh I think it will trade lower I think again I own gold I think everybody should own gold I'm not a gold hater I'm actually a gold lover I think it's the most important asset in your portfolio but I don't necessarily think it's going to pay off right away”

0.39

Oil faces short-term demand shock but medium-to-long term will rise much higher; military conflicts in 2023 would be very good for oil by constraining supply.

forecasthigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 2/4· Brent Johnson

“I think there's some short-term problems for oil... I think there could be some price pressure on oil in the short term but I think in the medium to long term I think oil goes much much higher I think it's possible we get into some military conflicts at some point in 2023 more military conflicts I'm already having I think that would be very good for oil and essentially if you get into the situation where Supply is constrained for any reason ultimately that's going to be good for the long-term price of oil”

0.39

US bonds will likely come under pressure early 2023 but end year better; foreign treasuries will face continued pressure with lower confidence.

forecasthigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 2/4· Brent Johnson

“I think we could probably see some decreases early in the year but by the end of the year at least in the U.S I think bond market will do better by the end of the year I don't have the same level of uh confidence for foreign treasuries I think foreign treasuries could continue to come under under pressure”

0.35

If buying equities in 2023, favor US large-cap over small-cap or emerging markets; some big tech is acceptable but general bias against small-cap and EM equities.

normativehigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 0/4durability 2/4· Brent Johnson

“I continue to favor if I am going to go on equities anywhere in the world I want to own them in the United States I want to own the big um I I don't have a an opposition to some of the bigger Tech names but I I I'm I'm not in general I wouldn't be buying small cap or emerging market stocks”

0.21

If central banks create liquidity in 2023, crypto could become interesting again as cyclical play; Johnson would pivot to owning crypto if liquidity conditions reversed.

forecastspeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 2/4· Brent Johnson

“I'm always open to buying something that for a short-term trade or for a speculation you know... if we got into a position 2023 where the central banks came in came in started to yeah well said”