What this covers

This is a single-speaker YouTube monologue from Michael Bordenaro, running about 17 minutes. It works through a series of local data points and news items to argue that the housing market is turning toward buyers. The case is built mostly from downtown San Francisco's 94105 ZIP code, where the speaker says prices are down 20% over a decade and inventory is now about 100 homes against roughly 50 in 2017. He also says renting is about 39% cheaper than owning there, at roughly $54,000 a year versus $75,000. The Millennium Tower, which is sinking and tilting, serves as the extreme case. One unit sold in 2011 and failed to resell at higher asking prices in 2018 and 2020, and a penthouse bought for $13 million in 2016 is put by Redfin at about $6.2 million.

The second thread is a rebuttal of rate-driven urgency. The speaker points to Barbara Corcoran and others who urged buying before rates fell, then notes that rates dropped about two points from October's peak without reviving demand. He cites Fannie Mae forecasts of only modest further declines. He also argues that "marry the house, date the rate" fails where prices are falling, since owners with small down payments may lack the equity to refinance. One conditional runs the other way: if rates fell below 5%, owners locked into low rates might finally list. He expects them to price at yesterday's levels.

The remaining turns are more contentious. He rejects the housing shortage story, citing a claimed 31% of Mission Beach housing that is investor-owned short-term rentals, and he forecasts devastation for those investors if prices slip or cities ban them. The last stretch covers a Florida homeowner denied flood insurance coverage after tropical storm Debbie because a previous owner's claim went unrepaired. He argues for broader disclosure rules, proof of repairs, and the right to sue prior owners for what he calls insurance fraud.

Sharpest takeaway

The speaker argues that real estate markets are fundamentally broken: agents push false narratives about rate drops spurring demand, Millennium Tower exemplifies structural collapse of luxury markets, and widespread investor speculation in short-term rentals masks the real supply crisis—making home purchases a trap for most buyers.

  • Mortgage rates dropped 2% from October peak yet housing demand did not recover, contradicting agent claims
  • Millennium Tower sinking and tilting caused 40-67% losses in unit values despite luxury positioning
  • 31% of Mission Beach housing is Airbnb listings during supposed housing shortage—proving supply problem is investor hoarding, not scarcity

The claims · ranked33 claims · weighted by value

This asset isn't compiled yet

You're seeing its claims, ranked. Compile it to build the argument threads, weight them, and check each claim against your library — the full view.

0.80

Millennium Tower in San Francisco is physically sinking and tilting into the ground due to major engineering problems, causing a 40% loss in unit values compared to prices 10 years ago when units sold for over $1 million and now sell for $600,000.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 2/4durability 4/4· Unidentified Speaker — DRAMATIC 50% PRICE CUTS IN CALIFORNIA! MAJOR HOUSING CRASH [AEVAmxXb8B0]

“this building is literally sinking into the ground...not only is it sinking into the ground but also it's tilting and this is a massive engineering problem...a unit there at Millennium tower that just sold for a little over 600,000 and 10 years ago it sold for over a million dollar guys so we're talking a 40% discount”

0.69

A two-bedroom, three-bathroom unit at Millennium Tower is currently asking $3.97 million, but was sold in 2011 for $3.232 million, tried for resale in 2018 at $5.6 million (failed), in 2020 at $4.9 million (failed), and is now listed at $3.9 million—showing ongoing price declines as the building continues deteriorating.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Unidentified Speaker — DRAMATIC 50% PRICE CUTS IN CALIFORNIA! MAJOR HOUSING CRASH [AEVAmxXb8B0]

“they're asking 3.97 million for a two-bedroom three bath unit and take a look at this in 2011 it was sold for 3 232 million...tried selling it in 2018 for 5.6 million didn't work out Tred it again in 2020 3 for 4.9 million that didn't work out now they're down to 3.9 million”

0.66

A 5,000 square-foot penthouse unit at Millennium Tower was purchased in 2016 for $13 million and is now estimated by Redfin at only $6.2 million—a loss of approximately two-thirds of its value.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 4/4· Unidentified Speaker — DRAMATIC 50% PRICE CUTS IN CALIFORNIA! MAJOR HOUSING CRASH [AEVAmxXb8B0]

“they bought this place back in 2016 for $13 million look what red finin values it at today only 62 million guys...this place has literally lost like 2third of its value”

0.56

In downtown San Francisco ZIP code 94105, home prices have fallen 20% over the past 10 years—from an average of $1.2 million in 2014 to $1 million today, contradicting the common belief that real estate always appreciates.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 4/4· Unidentified Speaker — DRAMATIC 50% PRICE CUTS IN CALIFORNIA! MAJOR HOUSING CRASH [AEVAmxXb8B0]

“back in 2014 the average home price in this ZIP code was about 1.2 million today it's down to 1 million so home prices here have fallen 20% in this neighborhood...over the past 10 years”

0.55

Fannie Mae is predicting that mortgage rates will remain around 6% through the end of 2024 (official prediction 6.2%) and will still be at approximately 5.7% by the end of 2025—meaning only a 0.3-0.5 percentage point decline, which is insufficient to revive housing demand.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 1/4· Unidentified Speaker — DRAMATIC 50% PRICE CUTS IN CALIFORNIA! MAJOR HOUSING CRASH [AEVAmxXb8B0]

“even Fanny May they're predicting that mortgage rates are going to remain around 6% throughout the end of the year in fact their official prediction is 6.2% so it may actually go lower than their prediction but they're also predicting by the same time next year guys towards the end of 2025 that we're still going to be sitting at 5.7% mortgage rates”

0.52

The reason mortgage rate declines from 8% to 6% did not trigger housing market recovery is that 6% is still not affordable for most people—prices have not fallen enough to restore affordability even at lower rates.

causalhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Unidentified Speaker — DRAMATIC 50% PRICE CUTS IN CALIFORNIA! MAJOR HOUSING CRASH [AEVAmxXb8B0]

“that's a 2 percentage Point drop in 30-year rates and the housing market is slower than ever the reality is 6% is still not enough for most people to afford a home”

0.52

If mortgage rates fall below 5% in the next 6-12 months, inventory could increase substantially because approximately 76% of homeowners have mortgage rates below 5%, and lower current rates could entice these owners to finally sell.

causalhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Unidentified Speaker — DRAMATIC 50% PRICE CUTS IN CALIFORNIA! MAJOR HOUSING CRASH [AEVAmxXb8B0]

“if interest rates do fall below 5% in the near future and I'm talking like in the next 6 to 12 months then we could see inventory pick up even further because right now 76% of people have a mortgage rate below 5%”

0.52

When inventory increases because sellers begin listing homes, those sellers will typically list at yesterday's prices rather than current market prices, failing to account for the fact that new inventory increases supply and puts downward pressure on values.

causalhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Unidentified Speaker — DRAMATIC 50% PRICE CUTS IN CALIFORNIA! MAJOR HOUSING CRASH [AEVAmxXb8B0]

“a lot of those people will probably list their homes for sale at yesterday's prices that's typically what sellers do they're going to list thinking that they can still get a tremendous amount of money for those homes when in fact the values have already come down because the inventory is at or near pre-pandemic Levels”

0.52

Most people who refinance mortgages when rates decline do so unprofitably unless they have rates at 7.5-8% or higher, and even if they do refinance, they may not qualify if they only put down 5-10% (like most buyers) and prices have already declined—preventing them from using the 'marry the house and date the rate' strategy.

causalhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Unidentified Speaker — DRAMATIC 50% PRICE CUTS IN CALIFORNIA! MAJOR HOUSING CRASH [AEVAmxXb8B0]

“naturally mortgage brokers try to get people to refinance right now since the rates are coming down but it's not worth it for most people to refinance unless you have a rate at 7 and a half or 8% and you bought a year ago...but guess what if you're in one of these places where the values are already coming down you may not be able to refinance especially if you only put five or 10% down like the vast majority of buyers do guys”

0.52

Property investors and Airbnb speculators who thought they would make fortunes flipping homes or becoming millionaires through short-term rental arbitrage are now contributing to massive home price declines as their investments fail.

causalhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Unidentified Speaker — DRAMATIC 50% PRICE CUTS IN CALIFORNIA! MAJOR HOUSING CRASH [AEVAmxXb8B0]

“one thing that's definitely going to continue to contribute to this massive downfall in home prices is all the investors who thought they were going to make a fortune flipping Properties or people who thought they were going to make a fortune doing Airbnb and have all these Airbnb listings and just become a millionaire in a couple of years”

0.52

In Mission Beach, San Diego, if Airbnb short-term rental prices decline due to oversaturation, or if cities like Dallas, New York City, or Maui ban short-term rentals, all investors holding Airbnb properties will be completely devastated financially because they cannot convert them back to standard rentals without accepting massive losses.

forecasthigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Unidentified Speaker — DRAMATIC 50% PRICE CUTS IN CALIFORNIA! MAJOR HOUSING CRASH [AEVAmxXb8B0]

“if if the price for these airbnbs continues to go down because too many people are doing it and it's oversaturated people can't make money or say they do what Dallas or New York City or Maui Hawaii and they just come out and start Banning short-term rentals what happens then you know all these people that have these short-term r rentals in San Diego are going to be completely screwed”

0.52

Florida passed a law requiring disclosure of previous flood insurance claims on properties, but the current system is problematic: when a previous owner filed a flood claim but failed to complete repairs, the current owner can still be denied coverage or held liable for unrepaired damage—creating an unfair liability cascade.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Unidentified Speaker — DRAMATIC 50% PRICE CUTS IN CALIFORNIA! MAJOR HOUSING CRASH [AEVAmxXb8B0]

“Florida got hit with tropical storm Debbie...a lot of people thought that their home was protected with flood insurance...they talked to one woman who said she spent $8,600 on a policy...when the insurance adjusters came through they denied her claim outright...they said a prior loss report discovered that the previous owner filed a flood insurance claim but did not complete the repairs with the claim payout”

0.52

A homeowner with a paid flood insurance policy was denied coverage and held liable for over $100,000 in damage after tropical storm Debbie because insurance adjusters discovered that the previous owner had filed a flood claim but never completed the repairs—despite the current owner having purchased the property in good faith.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Unidentified Speaker — DRAMATIC 50% PRICE CUTS IN CALIFORNIA! MAJOR HOUSING CRASH [AEVAmxXb8B0]

“the adjusters came in and verified that nothing was actually done from the previous repair and now this person is on the hook for over $100,000 in Damages from tropical storm Debbie”

0.52

The advice to 'marry the house and date the rate'—implying that buyers should prioritize home ownership and expect to refinance as rates drop—is failing as a strategy because in markets where prices are declining, buyers cannot refinance even if rates fall due to insufficient equity.

causalhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Unidentified Speaker — DRAMATIC 50% PRICE CUTS IN CALIFORNIA! MAJOR HOUSING CRASH [AEVAmxXb8B0]

“even if you were somebody who has sold that lie that you can marry the house and date the rate you may no longer be able to actually do that so please if you are somebody who's being pressured by a real estate agent right now”

0.52

Real estate agents, including Barbara Corcoran and economists like Lawrence Summers, told people to buy before interest rates drop to avoid missing out, but mortgage rates have since fallen 2 percentage points from October's 8% peak to 6% today, and instead of triggering buyer demand, the housing market is slower than ever.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Unidentified Speaker — DRAMATIC 50% PRICE CUTS IN CALIFORNIA! MAJOR HOUSING CRASH [AEVAmxXb8B0]

“all the real estate agents are telling people to buy right now before the interest rates drop further...last October 30-year mortgage rates peaked at around 8% today you can get a 30-year mortgage close to 6% that's a 2 percentage Point drop in 30-year rates and the housing market is slower than ever”

0.52

Buyers must verify whether a property they are purchasing had a previous flood insurance claim and, if so, must obtain proof that all necessary repairs were completed—because if repairs were not completed, the current owner can face claim denials and liability for damage.

normativehigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Unidentified Speaker — DRAMATIC 50% PRICE CUTS IN CALIFORNIA! MAJOR HOUSING CRASH [AEVAmxXb8B0]

“so now this is yet another Pitfall that people have to watch out for and wonder or verify if the property that you're looking at purchasing had a previous flood insurance claim and if in fact it did were the necessary repairs actually made to the property”

0.50

Inventory levels in downtown San Francisco ZIP code 94105 have never dropped below pre-pandemic levels; in fact, they are currently above pre-pandemic levels—with approximately 100 homes for sale today versus about 50 homes in 2017, contradicting the 'housing shortage' narrative.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Unidentified Speaker — DRAMATIC 50% PRICE CUTS IN CALIFORNIA! MAJOR HOUSING CRASH [AEVAmxXb8B0]

“when you look at the amount of inventory available just in this ZIP code alone where I'm walking guys 94105 it is actually above pre pandemic levels okay in fact the inventory levels never actually dropped here...you can see back in 2017 there was maybe 50 homes for sale on the market today there's 100 it's double”

0.49

In downtown San Francisco's ZIP code 94105, even with 20% home price declines, renting is cheaper than buying: annual rental costs are approximately $54,000 per year, while annual ownership costs are approximately $75,000 per year—making renting 39% cheaper.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 2/4· Unidentified Speaker — DRAMATIC 50% PRICE CUTS IN CALIFORNIA! MAJOR HOUSING CRASH [AEVAmxXb8B0]

“when you look at the cost of renting versus buying down here even with this tremendous drop in home values in this ZIP code it is still actually cheaper to be a renter okay the annual cost to be a renter here is about $54,000 a year whereas if you were to own a property here you're looking at about $75,000 a year so even with these plummeting housing values it's still 39% cheaper to be a renter”

0.49

The same penthouse unit at Millennium Tower rents for only $7,250 per month, which is less expensive than renting a small house in Miami or elsewhere, making it economically illogical to own at such deflated prices when rental yields are minimal.

causalhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 2/4· Unidentified Speaker — DRAMATIC 50% PRICE CUTS IN CALIFORNIA! MAJOR HOUSING CRASH [AEVAmxXb8B0]

“even look at the rental price guys I actually just tried renting it in June of this year it was for rent for only 7250 a month you can't even rent like a small house or something like that in Miami anymore for that price”

0.49

In Mission Beach, San Diego, 31% of the entire residential housing supply consists of Airbnb short-term rentals, which are all investor-owned, demonstrating massive oversaturation and proving that the 'housing shortage' narrative is false—the shortage is not of homes but of homes available for sale.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 2/4· Unidentified Speaker — DRAMATIC 50% PRICE CUTS IN CALIFORNIA! MAJOR HOUSING CRASH [AEVAmxXb8B0]

“I found this on X it shows all the airbnbs in Mission Beach in San Diego and what you can see is 31% of the housing Supply here is UN hosted short-term rentals and which are all Investments this is all during a supposed housing shortage right so this whole notion of a housing shortage is an absolute lie there is no housing shortage”

0.48

The current owner should be able to sue the previous owner for failing to disclose a prior flood claim and for failing to complete the required repairs, because the previous owner received insurance payouts to make repairs but never did, which constitutes insurance fraud.

normativehigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Unidentified Speaker — DRAMATIC 50% PRICE CUTS IN CALIFORNIA! MAJOR HOUSING CRASH [AEVAmxXb8B0]

“in my opinion which is just my opinion I'm not a lawyer or an attorney I would think that this person would be eligible to sue the previous owner of the property for number one not disclosing that there was a previous flood and also not making the the repairs and essentially committing insurance fraud you know that person received the money to make the repairs but they never did it”

0.48

Currently, Florida is the only state (to the speaker's knowledge) that requires disclosure of previous flood claims on properties, but this protection should be expanded to all states and buyers should demand proof of repairs before purchasing.

normativehigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Unidentified Speaker — DRAMATIC 50% PRICE CUTS IN CALIFORNIA! MAJOR HOUSING CRASH [AEVAmxXb8B0]

“I'm not aware of any other states requiring this to be disclosed right now other than Florida but at least this gives you an extra layer of protection if you're a buyer right now in Florida buying in a high flood risk zone”

0.48

Real estate agents continue to push the narrative that rates will trigger mass demand, but this advice is the worst possible advice a buyer can receive right now, and many people are already being burned by this lie with more expected to be harmed as the market continues to decline.

normativehigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Unidentified Speaker — DRAMATIC 50% PRICE CUTS IN CALIFORNIA! MAJOR HOUSING CRASH [AEVAmxXb8B0]

“please if you are somebody who's being pressured by a real estate agent right now and they're telling you that the prices are going to shoot through the roof as soon as the rates drop a little bit more or you should just marry the house and date the rate guys please don't believe it because that is the worst advice you can Poss possibly get right now so many people are actually getting burned by this right now”

0.47

Real estate agents are promoting the idea that people need to buy immediately because interest rate declines will trigger mass buyer demand, but this narrative has proven false: rates dropped 2% and the market slowed, not accelerated, so agents now need to drop this lie or stop misleading buyers.

normativehigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Unidentified Speaker — DRAMATIC 50% PRICE CUTS IN CALIFORNIA! MAJOR HOUSING CRASH [AEVAmxXb8B0]

“before interest rates started dropping real estate agents Barbara corkran all the economists even Lawrence Young over at n says if you don't buy now before the rates start coming down...well guess what guys last October 30-year mortgage rates peaked at around 8% today you can get a 30-year mortgage close to 6%...and the housing market is slower than ever”

0.42

The year-over-year decline in home values in downtown San Francisco ZIP code 94105 is currently 15%, and prices have been declining since 2015-2016.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 2/4· Unidentified Speaker — DRAMATIC 50% PRICE CUTS IN CALIFORNIA! MAJOR HOUSING CRASH [AEVAmxXb8B0]

“just look at the five growth and home value in this area and how much it's down right now currently just year-over-year it's down 15% but it has literally been sinking since about 2015 2016”

0.39

Downtown San Francisco currently has inventory at approximately 75% of pre-pandemic levels, and only a modest increase in listings would restore inventory to full pre-pandemic levels, which would put substantial downward pressure on prices.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 2/4· Unidentified Speaker — DRAMATIC 50% PRICE CUTS IN CALIFORNIA! MAJOR HOUSING CRASH [AEVAmxXb8B0]

“the inventory is at or near pre-pandemic Levels by then I mean we're already at 75% or so of pre pandemic level inventory and it won't take a whole lot more people listing their homes for sale to get us right back up there”

0.39

For mortgage rates to attract buyers back into the market, rates would need to fall back to pre-pandemic lows of 2-3%, which is probably never going to happen; therefore, prices will need to fall significantly in the long run instead.

forecasthigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 2/4· Unidentified Speaker — DRAMATIC 50% PRICE CUTS IN CALIFORNIA! MAJOR HOUSING CRASH [AEVAmxXb8B0]

“I think a lot of people would tell you right now that in order to get them rejuvenated and reinvigorated about the housing market they would need to see prices and or interest rates come back down to where it was pre pandemic you know interest rates coming down to the lows again of like the 2 and 3% interest rates to get people interested which is probably never going to happen and that's why we know that it's more likely that we're going to see prices fall in the long run instead”

0.26

Empty retail space in downtown San Francisco is pervasive, consistent with what is seen across the city and region, indicating structural commercial real estate decline alongside residential decline.

factualspeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 2/4· Unidentified Speaker — DRAMATIC 50% PRICE CUTS IN CALIFORNIA! MAJOR HOUSING CRASH [AEVAmxXb8B0]

“I see right across the street you have empty retail space which is probably the case pretty much everywhere around here from what I've heard”

0.22

Homeless activity in downtown San Francisco is concentrated in certain areas, and the area where the speaker is filming (around Millennium Tower) is not one of the heavily affected zones, despite widespread media coverage suggesting pervasive homelessness downtown.

factualspeaker onlynovelty 0/4durability 2/4· Unidentified Speaker — DRAMATIC 50% PRICE CUTS IN CALIFORNIA! MAJOR HOUSING CRASH [AEVAmxXb8B0]

“the homeless activity is not nearly as bad as you would think it would be from all the things you've seen on the news but there's spots right they they congregate in certain areas and apparently right here isn't one of them”

0.20

Millennium Tower, across from the Salesforce Tower (the tallest building on the west coast of the United States), is positioned as a luxury building with a doorman and other high-end amenities, despite its structural problems.

factualspeaker onlynovelty 0/4durability 3/4· Unidentified Speaker — DRAMATIC 50% PRICE CUTS IN CALIFORNIA! MAJOR HOUSING CRASH [AEVAmxXb8B0]

“this place is supposed to be all about luxury they have a door man it's literally right across from the Salesforce Tower here which is the tallest building on the west coast of the United States”

0.17

Windows have reportedly fallen out of Millennium Tower due to structural problems, indicating safety hazards beyond just sinking and tilting.

factualspeaker onlynovelty 0/4durability 2/4· Unidentified Speaker — DRAMATIC 50% PRICE CUTS IN CALIFORNIA! MAJOR HOUSING CRASH [AEVAmxXb8B0]

“I've heard stories of Windows falling out of this place and all kinds of things like that”

0.17

Downtown San Francisco is 'kind of dead' with limited activity compared to what a downtown area should be, though it is not completely dead and some activity still occurs.

factualspeaker onlynovelty 0/4durability 2/4· Unidentified Speaker — DRAMATIC 50% PRICE CUTS IN CALIFORNIA! MAJOR HOUSING CRASH [AEVAmxXb8B0]

“a lot of people moved away during the pandemic and um I got say it is kind of dead down here for a downtown but it's not completely dead you do still see some activity”

0.17

It is easier to build modern skyscrapers than to demolish them, which is why Millennium Tower was not demolished despite serious structural problems.

factualspeaker onlynovelty 0/4durability 2/4· Unidentified Speaker — DRAMATIC 50% PRICE CUTS IN CALIFORNIA! MAJOR HOUSING CRASH [AEVAmxXb8B0]

“it seems like it's easier to build these skyscrapers than it is to demolish one and that's probably like the last resort they really don't want to do that”