
How To Invest During Recession
What this covers
This 14-minute PensionCraft video, narrated by a single unidentified speaker, starts from the 2019 backdrop of fading global growth, talk of central bank rate cuts, and an inverted US yield curve. It asks what a recession would do to UK portfolios. The Bank of England and Federal Reserve (U.S.)) are cited as blaming the slowdown mainly on trade tensions and the US-China trade war, which have weakened business confidence and hit manufacturing. Firms uneasy about trade policy invest less, though consumption has held up.
The video then widens into history and definitions. It traces UK recessions from wars, poor harvests, investment manias like canals and turnpikes, and bank failures before 1850, through a sharp drop in frequency afterward. It also covers the postwar cycle of roughly three years down and three years up reported by Hills, Thomas, and Dimmesdale. It notes that the National Bureau of Economic Research (NBER)) uses a broader definition than two consecutive quarters of falling GDP.
On forecasting, the Cleveland Federal Reserve Bank model is examined. Inversion has preceded recessions within about a year, but it has produced false positives in 1966 and 1998, has no underlying theory, and rests on only about ten postwar observations.
The video then turns to what has held up in past downturns. Treasuries, gold and UK gilts did, through Flight-to-Safety de-risking, and the speaker suggests hedged Treasury funds to avoid currency swings. The contentious conclusion is that skilled managers don't beat the alternative: a Schroder dynamic multi-asset portfolio trails the fixed-allocation Life Strategy (fund family)) 80% fund despite higher fees. The recommended answer is Fixed Allocation with Rebalancing once a year, with low fees and little attention to the news.
Investors cannot reliably predict recessions, so the optimal strategy is to maintain a diversified portfolio with fixed asset allocation and annual rebalancing rather than attempt dynamic market timing.
- Yield curve inversion and other indicators have low predictive power and notable false positives (1966, 1998)
- Professional multi-asset fund managers consistently underperform simple fixed-allocation strategies despite higher fees and expertise
- Historical data shows markets always recover from crashes, making buy-and-hold diversified investing the most reliable approach for long-term investors
This asset isn't compiled yet
You're seeing its claims, ranked. Compile it to build the argument threads, weight them, and check each claim against your library — the full view.
Historically, the Bank of England data shows that before the early 1800s, major wars were a big cause of recessions, and the UK spent about half its time in war, resulting in continual recessions.
“The Bank of England has data on UK growth going back all the way to 1700 and a big cause of recessions in the past was war here they've shaded the major wall periods in blue and he can see that before the early 1800s we spent about half our time in one wall or another and as a result we had this continual onslaught of recessions”
Before 1850, UK recessions were also caused by poor harvests and investment fads such as canals, toll roads, and turnpikes, as well as large bank failures.
“recessions before the 1850s also depended on things like poor harvests because the UK economy used to depend more on agriculture but there were also investment fads for example investing in canals toll roads or Turnpike's as we used to call them and they're also very large and significant bank failures”
The fundamental problem with recession-timing strategies is that we cannot predict when recessions will happen; central banks and economists also do not know, and there is no perfect model of recessions.
“the fundamental problem is that we can't predict when recessions will happen of course we can look up here my indices and we can listen to central bank's but unfortunately they don't know either and there's no perfect model of recessions”
The U.S. National Bureau of Economic Research uses a broader definition of recession than just two consecutive quarters of GDP decline; they also consider other monthly indicators, timeliness of data, and the magnitude of the decline.
“the National Bureau of Economic Research has a slightly different definition and they're the ones tasked with actually defining a u.s. recession they say that they don't just use real GDP they also use a range of other indicators particularly indicators which arrive every month that allows them to create a more timely definition of when activity starts to decline and finally they also consider how large the decline is and the reason they give for this is that the phrase is a significant decline in activity”
Between 1952 and 1992, according to Hills, Thomas, and Dimmesdale (2010), the average UK downturn lasted about three years, followed by an upturn also lasting three years, for an overall cycle of approximately six years.
“in the most recent period between 1952 and 92 the average downturn lasted about three years followed by an upturn also lasting three years among kids an overall cycle of upturn and down turn of just under six years”
When companies are worried about economic policy, particularly trade policy, they are less likely to invest, which slows economic growth, but consumption growth has remained resilient.
“when companies are worried about economic policy and in particular trade policy they're less likely to invest and in turn that slows down economic growth but fortunately consumption growth has remained resilient”
There is no economic theory explaining why yield curve inversion predicts recessions; it is merely an empirical relationship observed in the data, and the statistical basis is weak because there have been relatively few recessions since World War II (about 10 data points).
“there's no economic theory behind this observation it's just a relationship that people have noticed in the data and another problem is that there really aren't that many data points there haven't been that many recessions since the Second World War so really we've only got about ten data points to work with so the statistics aren't particularly robust”
These underperformance patterns for multi-asset funds should be a warning that extremely expert, intelligent, and well-paid fund managers have consistently failed to beat simple fixed-allocation life strategy funds.
“that should be a warning to you that these extremely expert multi asset fund managers have failed to beat these fairly simple fixed allocation life strategy funds and if those well resourced intelligent and very well paid fund managers failed to beat a fixed allocation fund then you and I would probably also fail to do so”
The simplest and most effective strategy for most people is to create a diversified portfolio, find a risk level they are happy with, fix the equity-bond allocation accordingly, keep fees low, and drip-feed money into investments over a lifetime while ignoring news.
“the simplest thing you can do is to create a diversified portfolio find a risk level you're happy with and use that to fix your equity bond allocation and keep your fees low then simply drip-feed your money into your investments over your lifetime and completely ignore the news”
Among a broader range of asset indices from 1995-2019, gold is the only asset that produced positive median returns during periods of U.S. recession, making it a safe haven like Treasuries.
“the only one of these assets where the return turned positive during periods of recession was gold and that's because gold is also seen as a safe haven during periods of financial crisis”
After 1850, the frequency of recessions dropped quite dramatically, though the First and Second World Wars still produced recessions.
“after 1850 the frequency of recessions dropped quite dramatically but the First World War and the Second World War also had their as recessions”
The reason Treasuries outperform during recessions is that investors sell equities and buy Treasuries because they are perceived as much safer with lower volatility and almost zero credit risk; this is called 'de-risking' in a portfolio.
“the reason for that is that during a recession people sell equities and they buy Treasuries because they're seen as much safer they have a much lower volatility and they carry almost zero credit risk in the United States we call that selling of equity and the buying of government bonds do you risk in a portfolio”
The Cleveland Fed yield curve model is not perfect; there have been two notable false positives where the yield curve inverted but no recession followed: in late 1966 and in 1998.
“the model is certainly not perfect as they say there have been two notable false positives in late 1966 the US yield curve inverted but there was no recession and the same thing happened in 1998”
As investors de-risk during recessions, money moves out of risky assets (particularly emerging market stocks) and into safer fixed income, with government bonds representing the safest portion of the fixed income universe.
“if we did have time series stretching back further in time for these funds what we'd see would be a very clear split as investors de-risk they'd move their money into safer funds and I would typically be fixed income and the safest part of the fixed income universe would be government bonds...but...the assets that would sell off would be the risky ones and that's the equity funds particularly the most risky which our emerging market stocks”
The Cleveland Federal Reserve Bank publishes a model that takes the difference in yield between short-term and long-term bonds and forecasts GDP growth and the probability of recession in the coming year.
“the Cleveland Federal Reserve Bank publishes this model which takes the difference in yield between short term bonds and long term bonds and as an output it forecasts GDP growth and the probability of a recession in the coming year”
During recession periods, U.S. Treasury bond returns show a significant positive shift compared to growth periods: the distribution of monthly returns shifts to the right with more large positive returns (around 10%), while growth periods show small positive returns.
“what happens during a recession is that the average return increases significantly and you can see that as a shift to the right of this distribution and an increase in the size of the upside tail you get more large positive returns during a recession”
U.S. Treasury funds have such low volatility that they are swamped by currency volatility, so if investors want to hold a U.S. Treasury fund as a recession hedge, they should probably use the hedged version to eliminate currency risk.
“if you do want to say version of a US Treasury you'd probably have to go for the hedged version to get rid of the currency risk because for US Treasury funds the volatility is so small that it's swamped by the currency volatility”
Normally the yield curve is upward sloping because investors demand a higher rate of interest for locking in fixed-rate borrowing for longer periods, but the U.S. yield curve has inverted, which is unusual.
“normally the yield curve is upward sloping because investors demand a higher rate of interest for locking in a fixed rate of borrowing for a longer period now in the US the yield curve is turned out to be a fairly good predictor of economic growth”
For most investors, a good response to recession risk is to keep strategic asset allocations and rebalance once a year, which allows investors to see through volatility if they have a long-term horizon.
“for most of us is probably best to go with a fixed allocation that suits our appetite for risk and our capacity for risk so even though it doesn't seem very sophisticated a good response to a recession is simply to keep your strategic allocations and then just rebalance once a year because that way you can just see through that volatility if you're a long-term investor”
Among iShares exchange-traded funds analyzed from the global financial crisis forward, UK gilts were the only fund that maintained value during periods of U.S. recession, while European equities, UK corporate bonds, the Footsie 100, and S&P 500 tracker all sold off.
“UK gilts were the only fund which kept their value during periods of US recession the median is roughly the same during periods of recession and growth whereas European equity showed much larger volatility or variation in returns during periods of recession and the median return was also negative UK corporate bonds also sold off during periods of US recessions as did European equity the footsie 100 and the S&P 500 tracker”
Over the very long term, shares produce bumpy returns with crashes, but if investors simply keep money invested, markets always recover and erase periods of large loss; this is true for both equities and bonds.
“over the very long term shares may give you a bumpy ride with crashes but if you simply keep your money invested markets always recover and erase those periods of large loss and that's true for equities in red but also true of bonds in blue”
Schroders' dynamic planner portfolio underperforms the simple fixed-allocation Life Strategy 80% fund despite having considerably higher fees, demonstrating that expert market timing fails to beat simple diversified strategies.
“this Schroder dynamic planner portfolio actually under performs that fixed allocation for something like a life strategy 80% fund which is in blue even though his fee is considerably higher than life strategy”
The Invested cautious managed fund also underperformed Life Strategy 60, and the Artemis Income Fund, one of the best performing funds, runs roughly neck-and-neck with the cheaper and less sophisticated Life Strategy 80% fund.
“that invested cautious managed fund has also underperformed life strategy 60 and even one of the best performing funds like Artemis Income Fund is running roughly neck-and-neck with the cheaper and fairly dumb life strategy 80% fund”
The Bank of England and Federal Reserve attributed the economic slowdown primarily to trade tensions and the U.S.-China trade war, with direct effects on bilateral goods trade and broader effects through reduced global business confidence, particularly affecting the manufacturing sector.
“when discussing the reasons for this fall the Bank of England but also the Federal Reserve in the United States point the finger at trade tensions and in particular the trade war between the US and China the direct effect of this has been on the bilateral goods trade between those two countries but the broader effect has been due to reduced global business confidence and what's been particularly hard-hit is the manufacturing sector”
On the whole, when the yield curve inverts in the U.S., a recession normally occurs within one year; this happened in the early 1980s, early 1990s, early 2000s, and before the global financial crisis, and is happening again at the time of recording (2019).
“on the whole when the yield curve inverts we normally get a recession within one year it happened here in the 80s in the early 1990s in the early 2000s and then before the global financial crisis and you can see it's happening again now”
An alternative to buy-and-hold is a dynamic strategy where allocation varies according to market predictions, implemented by multi-asset funds with expert managers who charge high fees to time the market for investors.
“an alternative is to have a dynamic strategy where you vary your allocation according to what you thinks about to happen in markets that's exactly what dynamic multi-asset funds will be doing on your behalf with these multi asset funds you often pay a fairly high fee for very expert fund managers to do that fiddling for you”
Equity returns (S&P 500) show the opposite pattern from Treasuries during recessions: growth periods show stronger returns while recession periods show negative average returns with a large downside tail of large negative returns.
“if instead we look at equities in particular the S&P 500 the pattern is exactly the opposite during periods of growth the returns on the equity market tend to be stronger but during a recession the average return is negative and if you look at the distribution of returns you can see that it's grown a large downside tail in other words during a recession you're much more likely to have a large negative return”
Despite yield curve inversion, U.S. economic data remains relatively strong, with very strong employment data, fairly brisk wage growth, and PMI indicator still above 50.
“the US data is still ok they've got very strong employment data and fairly brisk wage growth and their PMI indicator is still above 50”
Purchasing Managers Index (PMI) manufacturing components have fallen below 50, indicating contraction, while the composite PMI combining manufacturing and services is still above 50, pointing to continued fallen GDP.
“here we're looking at the Purchasing Managers indices the manufacturing components have fallen below 50 which is a sign of contraction but the composite which combines manufacturing and services is still above 50 so those PMI indices point to were continued fallen GDP”
The UK National Institute of Economic and Social Research (NIESR) indicated in 2019 that there is a significant risk the UK economy was already in recession beginning in April, and a no-deal Brexit would pose clear possibility of material downturn.
“the National Institute of Economic and Social Research Nissa says that there's a significant risk that the economies already in a recession that began in April and that if we get a no deal brexit there's the clear possibility of a more material downturn”
In the United States, the yield curve shows the cost of government borrowing from one month to 30 years; as of August 2019 (when the video was made), a 10-year government bond paid 1.54%, which is less than shorter-term borrowing rates.
“this is the yield curve this is how much it costs the US government to borrow over one month three months all the way up to 30 years the Green Line is the latest yield curve so if you buying ten-year government bond on a day I made this video in August 2019 you'd be paid one point five four percent by the US government”
Global growth is slowing down and the U.S. yield curve has inverted, which usually signals that a recession is coming in the next year.
“global growth is slowing down and we've also seen the u.s. yield curve invert which usually signals that we're going to get a recession in the coming year”
If investors had perfect recession prediction ability, the optimal strategy would be to de-risk just before recession hits and then switch back into equities as the recession ends, but this perfect foresight does not exist.
“if we had a crystal ball that can predict recessions which we don't then the best strategy would be to de-risk just before recession hits and then just as the recession is ending we'd switch back into our witty”
The Bank of England's May 2019 inflation report showed a marked decrease in economic activity for both emerging markets and advanced economies.
“if you read the Bank of England's inflation report for May 2019 the first graph in the report shows this quite marked decrease in economic activity for both emerging markets but also advanced economies”
The Cleveland Fed model currently forecasts a 40% probability of recession in the year to come (as of August 2019).
“the model currently forecasts are 40% chance recession in the year to come”
The most recent significant recession was the 2008-2009 financial crisis.
“most recently the most significant recession was the 2008 2009 financial crisis”
The most frequently used definition of recession is two consecutive quarters of decline in real GDP, where GDP is the total amount of goods and services produced by a country.
“the most frequently used definition is that it's two consecutive quarters of decline in real GDP that's gross domestic product where gross domestic product is a total amount of goods and services produced by a country”