
Peter Zeihan Says Maritime Shipping Is Collapsing | Better Call Sal!
What this covers
This is a rebuttal episode. Salmer Kagan, a maritime historian and former merchant mariner, works through two videos by Peter Zeihan on the supposed end of oceanic shipping. He agrees with some of Zeihan's points and rejects others, and he does not treat the whole system as doomed. He starts with history. The post-WWII order, protected by naval power, replaced national merchant fleets with open registries such as Panama, Liberia, and the Marshall Islands. Together with containerization, this made shipping cheap enough that every country now depends on the sea. He cites cargo volume doubling from 6 to 12 billion tons between 2000 and 2025 as evidence of that resilience.
The middle of the episode goes through Zeihan's specific claims. Kagan treats the Eagle S incident, in which Finland interdicted and inspected a vessel, as a real signal that Nordic ship inspection regimes could spread in the Baltic Sea and threaten free passage. He pushes back on the idea that the sinking of the Ursa Major disabled Russia's whole icebreaker fleet, since it affected only the cargo for the newest vessel. He also objects to Zeihan's use of "bulk cargo," which refers to oil, gas, ore, and grain rather than stereos. He adds that a true shutdown would hit US bulk exports to Asia hardest.
The contested ground is security. Zeihan's figure of roughly 700 destroyers needed to guard the sea lanes is, in Kagan's view, a misreading of maritime protection as a unilateral US burden when it is a collective effort. Kagan also describes shipping as water finding cracks in a sidewalk, a resilience model) he supports with the Red Sea diversions and rising ton-miles. He notes that war-risk insurance on Red Sea transits has been profitable, and that regional LNG realignment is under way. He also says black swan events cannot be predicted in their specific form, even if their existence is plausible.
Salmer Kagan argues that while maritime shipping faces significant regional pressures from geopolitical conflicts (Houthis, Russia, Baltic states), these challenges will not collapse intercontinental shipping as Peter Zeihan claims; instead, shipping will adapt and regionalize while maintaining global ton-mile increases.
- Maritime shipping has proven resilient through previous crises (Suez Canal closures, COVID-19 disruptions, Houthi blockades), adapting routes and increasing ton-miles despite disruptions
- Regional trade realignment and increased naval protection are structural shifts rather than system collapse; historical precedent shows shipping always depends on protection structures
- Current geopolitical challenges (Houthis, Baltic inspections, Russian limitations) create pressure but not irreversible breakdown of intercontinental trade flows
This asset isn't compiled yet
You're seeing its claims, ranked. Compile it to build the argument threads, weight them, and check each claim against your library — the full view.
Post-World War II maritime order created open registries (Panama, Liberia, Marshall Islands), containerization, ultra-large vessel classes, and dramatically lower shipping costs, which enabled countries to access lower labor and manufacturing costs globally, making every nation on Earth dependent on maritime shipping in ways that were previously impossible.
“post World War II the order changes uh you create these open Registries Panama Liberia eventually the Marshall Islands you create very cheap shipping you create new technologies that allow you to move Goods at a much much lower rate containerization uh you you kind of suers siize ships so you get the very large and ultra-large container ships and eventually very large ultra-large uh crude carriers you just make the cost to move Goods around the world cheaper which means that you can capitalize on Lower production cost cost lower labor costs lower um uh manufacturing costs in countries that you normally could not access before and that means every country on the planet today is absolutely dependent on Maritime shipping”
Kagan argues that maritime shipping has doubled cargo volume from 6 billion tons to 12 billion tons between 2000 and 2025, demonstrating the system's resilience and capacity for growth despite geopolitical pressures.
“just from 2000 to 2025 we have overdoubled the amount of cargo we moved from 6 billion tons to 12 billion tons on the world's oceans”
Kagan argues that the shift from national merchant marines to open registry systems (Panama, Liberia, Marshall Islands) was driven by cost reduction and enabled by post-WWII establishment of globally protected shipping, making shipping much cheaper and enabling access to lower-cost production centers worldwide.
“post World War II the order changes uh you create these open Registries Panama Liberia eventually the Marshall Islands you create very cheap shipping you create new technologies that allow you to move Goods at a much much lower rate containerization...you just make the cost to move Goods around the world cheaper which means that you can capitalize on Lower production cost cost lower labor costs”
Every nation on the planet today is absolutely dependent on maritime shipping because globalization has enabled the movement of goods anywhere in the world at any time and with any partner to access any commodity or product, creating economic interconnections that were previously impossible.
“and that means every country on the planet today is absolutely dependent on Maritime shipping uh one of the many many things that globalization has been very successful about is about making it so that anyone can sail anywhere at any time and interface with any partner to access any commodity or any product and that has engendered not just global trade as We Know now but the expansion of various economic sectors in a way that just simply wasn't possible before”
Kagan disagrees with Zeihan's claim that the sinking of the Ursa Major (which carried hatch covers for a new Russian icebreaker) means the entire Russian icebreaker fleet is now inactive; this is an overstatement, as the loss affects only the newest icebreaker, not the whole fleet.
“there is a comment in the video where Peter talks about when Ursa Major was sunk this is the cargo ship I did a whole video on that was sunk it was carrying hatch covers for the newest Icebreaker he magnifies that to the entire Russian Icebreaker Fleet now is is inactive that's not true this is for the newest built Icebreaker these hatch covers that have to go over the engine compartment we sunk on Ursa Major that doesn't mean that the the the Russian Merchant Marine is no longer operating”
For the past decade, it has been unclear whether the US had the will, interest, or ability to maintain the global order, leading rival nations to challenge US dominance at various points, thinking they could carve out advantages while the US guaranteed overall stability.
“we've been in this weird little hole pattern globally for the last decade roughly where it wasn't apparent that the Americans had the will the interest or the ability to maintain the global order and lots of countries that are American Rivals started challenging the US and various points thinking that the future was the Americans will keep the world safe for everyone but they can carve out whatever they want for themselves”
Black Swan events in shipping cannot be predicted, so while Zeihan correctly identifies that trust-breaking events exist, the specific form they take (Israel-Houthis, shadow fleets) was not and could not be predicted, and multiple potential triggers exist.
“I I must admit having Israel and the houthis or the fins and the shadow Fleet on the bingo card not specific things I predicted that goes to the issues of Black Swan events we never know what the issue is going to be that is going to Tri Tri the issue in shipping”
Kagan argues that the post-WWII shift from bipolar (USSR vs NATO) to multipolar order has created new competitive dynamics where regional powers are now challenging the system in ways they weren't during the Cold War.
“yes after World War II the US Navy was the largest Navy in the world it then got into a bipolar relationship with the USSR and then we had the Warsaw pack versus Nato the first world versus the second world but now one of the things we're seeing is challenges arise”
Kagan disputes Zeihan's projection of Russian icebreaker fleet collapse, noting that while the Ursa Major sinking damaged hatch covers for one new icebreaker, this does not mean the entire Russian Icebreaker Fleet is now inactive or that the Russian Merchant Marine is incapacitated.
“Peter talks about when Ursa Major was sunk this is the cargo ship...was sunk it was carrying hatch covers for the newest Icebreaker he magnifies that to the entire Russian Icebreaker Fleet now is is inactive that's not true this is for the newest built Icebreaker these hatch covers that have to go over the engine compartment we sunk on Ursa Major that doesn't mean that the the the Russian Merchant Marine is no longer operating”
Kagan argues that Zeihan's assessment that disruptions will create catastrophic impact understates the specificity of disruption types: bulk cargo (oil, gas, ore, grain) is more economically consequential than manufactured goods, making US export markets to Asia particularly vulnerable to shipping disruptions.
“I think Peter also misjudges the impact this has because when you talk about bulk we're not talking about stereos we're talking about bulk material oil and gas and ore and grain the US is a massive exporter of that largely over to Asia and so any shutdown on the system is going to create problems”
Maritime security is a collective effort among multiple nations (EU, NATO, India, China, Japan, South Korea, Australia, South America) working together to ensure world oceans are safe for free movement of cargo, not a unilateral U.S. responsibility.
“it is a combined effort of all Nations together ensuring that the world oceans are safe for the free movement of cargo and so it's the European Union it's NATO it is India it is uh China it is Japan South Korea Australia it's the South America it's everybody everyone has to contribute to it”
Maintaining global sea lanes would require the U.S. Navy to have approximately 700 destroyers, a claim Zeihan makes that Kagan characterizes as a misunderstanding of collective maritime security.
“Peter talks about in his book he talks about the idea that the US would need like 700 destroyers to guard the sea lanes and and the concept that the US is the guarantor of the world's sea Lanes is a mistake in my opinion”
Kagan argues that maritime systems before WWII required national merchant marines because unless you could provide naval security for your ships, you simply didn't sail somewhere or did so without insurance or confidence, making it very risky business.
“one of the things that we had in the world before World War II was unless you could provide Naval security for your ships uh you just didn't sail somewhere or if you did you did so without any insurance or confidence uh that the ship could make it uh it was very very Risky Business okay I think that's a little bit of a misunderstanding of of History”
Throughout human history, civilizations have never voluntarily severed ties to the sea; maritime commerce is fundamental to all advanced societies.
“at no point in human history have we ever tied ourselves away from the sea we haven't I ancient civilizations have been tied into”
Kagan argues that maritime shipping is like water on a sidewalk—when you block one route, it finds alternative pathways—and he uses the Suez Canal closure as evidence that even an 8-year complete blockade was overcome through adaptation.
“global Shipping is very resilient it's like water on a sidewalk it's going to find the cracks uh you shut down the Suz canal the Red Sea shipping is going to find an alternative and that's what we see”
Regionalism in shipping is increasing: the US has increased LNG exports to Europe, Qatar and Australia have redirected liquefied natural gas exports, creating regional supply chains; ton-miles (total distance cargo travels) are increasing due to disruptions forcing longer alternative routes.
“one of the things we are seeing is regionalism you know America has increased its LG exports to Europe uh Qatar and Australia have adjusted where their liquefied natural gas goes to we are seeing those Regional differences playing a role as Peter said but we're also seeing ton miles increase the amount of cargo a ton of cargo moves on the ocean has increased and that's being caused by disruptions by the houthi by the Black SE by the Baltic by potentially the South China Sea”
Kagan argues that war risk insurance for Red Sea shipping has been highly profitable because the premiums paid by ships transiting the Red Sea over the past year far exceed the actual losses paid out (two ships sunk, four merchant mariners killed).
“War risk insurance right now is raking in profits I I mean the insurance industry to understand shipping you have to understand insurance and the normal above the normal insurance is this war Risk insurance and War risk and there's been plenty of stories in Lloyd's list and many other Maritime trade Publications that have talked about this that they are raking in the massive profits the amount of War risk that's been paid by all the ships going through the Red Sea over the past year is much more than they've paid out for the loss of two ships and the death of four Merchant Mariners”
If the Baltic states (Finland, Sweden, Estonia) conduct stricter ship inspections through a new Nordic league, it would signal the end of the globalized system as currently structured, because it breaks the principle of free passage.
“if the nordics do this it is the end of the globalized system as we know it”
Countries began challenging the U.S. global order during a period when it was not apparent that Americans had the will, interest, or ability to maintain global order, thinking they could carve out their own spheres while Americans kept the world safe for everyone.
“we've been in this weird little hole pattern globally for the last decade roughly where it wasn't apparent that the Americans had the will the interest or the ability to maintain the global order and lots of countries that are American Rivals started challenging the US and various points thinking that the future was the Americans will keep the world safe for everyone but they can carve out whatever they want for themselves”
Peter Zeihan's claim that bulk cargo like stereos would be disrupted by shipping collapse is imprecise—bulk shipping refers to oil, gas, ore, and grain (low-margin commodities), not consumer goods; the US is a massive exporter of bulk commodities to Asia, so any real shutdown would have catastrophic economic impact.
“I I think Peter also misjudges the impact this has because when you talk about bulk we're not talking about stereos we're talking about bulk material oil and gas and ore and grain the US is a massive exporter of that largely over to Asia and so any shutdown on the system is going to create problems”
The potential for Baltic states (Finland, Sweden, Poland) to conduct ship inspections of vessels traveling through their waters represents a significant threat to the global shipping system, as it could establish a precedent for unilateral maritime enforcement that undermines the open-registry model.
“in this he's talking specifically about the potential in the black excuse me in the Baltic Sea for Finland and Estonia and all these countries to do ship inspections now what's interesting to note is is Peter filmed this before the event took place with eagle s but I want to get to his real big conclusion of this that if the Baltic states this new htic league that we have do the ship inspections what it means means going forward and so if the nordics do this it is the end of the globalized system as we know it now”
Russia has recently bought one-way ships to deliver cargo to Syria and now faces a logistics problem getting cargo out of Syria, illustrating real constraints on Russian maritime capacity without requiring exaggeration.
“there's a story out today about the fact that the Russian military bought a batch of one-way ships to deliver cargo to Syria and now they're in trouble with now they have to get the cargo out of Syria and they don't have ships to do it”
Finland's interdiction and inspection of the Eagle S vessel demonstrates that Nordic states are now willing to conduct ship inspections, validating Zeihan's concern that this mechanism could spread as a tool of geopolitical leverage.
“Finland stopped the vessel boarded The Vessel took the vessel into its harbor uh we now know that the swedes have recovered the anchor from The Vessel so we have the the proof from that and the inspection is being done on the vessel as we speak so very elaborate process is going on regarding this”
The Suez blockade by Houthis has been partially resolved as shipping has adjusted routing; increased ton-miles (distance cargo travels) rather than decreased cargo volume shows the system adapting.
“the Suz has been partially blocked because the houthi for a year we we're overcoming it we're we're adjusting”
Human civilization has never severed its ties to the sea—ancient and historical civilizations were all dependent on maritime trade; the current shift toward regionalism is a realignment rather than abandonment of maritime shipping, making complete collapse historically anomalous.
“at no point in human history have we ever tied ourselves away from the sea we haven't I ancient civilizations have been tied into and I think what we're seeing here is a realignment major shift”
Zeihan argues that it is unknown what specific trigger event will break the maritime system, but the system is fragile enough that multiple actors (Finland, Israel, Russia) have the capability to fire 'the shot that formally breaks this system' if they choose.
“and it's going to be interesting to see whether it's Finland or Israel or Russia that fires the shot that formerly breaks this system but these are just three examples of how easy it would be for this whole thing to come Unwound”
The concept that the United States alone is the guarantor of world sea lanes is a fundamental misunderstanding—maritime security is a combined effort by NATO, EU, India, China, Japan, South Korea, Australia, and South American nations, not a unilateral American responsibility.
“the concept that the US is the guarantor of the world's sea Lanes is a mistake in my opinion I mean it is it is a joint effort or a combined effort to use the correct terminology for the military it is a combined effort of all Nations together ensuring that the world oceans are safe for the free movement of cargo and so it's the European Union it's NATO it is India it is uh China it is Japan South Korea Australia it's the South America it's everybody everyone has to contribute to it the idea that the US should be the sole guarantor for that is a mistake”
Salmer Kagan argues that maritime shipping is much more than just trust—it's maintained by a system of registries, classification societies, insurance mechanisms, and operational standards that create structural redundancy and prevent total collapse even when specific trust-based elements fail.
“I'd argue it's more than just trust there are measures that are put in place to ensure that shipping operates the way it does you have the registries you have classification societies you have insurance there is a myriad of issues that are in place to ensure that shipping operates the way it's supposed to do”
Open registries (Panama, Liberia, Marshall Islands flags) exist because they are cheap and ships under these flags receive no naval protection from those states; the Panamanian Navy will not rescue ships, so open registries are a cost optimization that assumes US (or allied) naval protection.
“why are ships sailing under Panama Liberia Marshall island flags because it's cheap it's cheap and one of the reasons it's cheap is they don't pay for navies because if you're in a Panamanian ship and you get in trouble the Panamanian Navy ain't coming to save you uh if you think the US Navy is going to come to save you then the US has to rethink the way it it structures its Navy”
Kagan argues that modern naval expansion by China, India, Japan, and South Korea is fundamentally about protecting their own trade routes, not about competing with the US Navy directly, reflecting a return to mercantilist principles where navies exist to protect national commerce.
“that's one of the reasons that you see China India Japan Korea build such large navies is really to protect their trade that's what they're doing if you look at the Chinese Navy it doesn't make a lot of sense to go toe-to-toe against the US Navy it makes a lot of sense if it is a Navy designed to protect its trade in many ways China has more mercantilistic than capitalistic or communistic”
Kagan disputes Zeihan's characterization, arguing that maritime shipping is not primarily based on trust but rather on multiple structural safeguards including registries, classification societies, and insurance systems that ensure shipping operates as intended.
“I'd argue it's more than just trust there are measures that are put in place to ensure that shipping operates the way it does you have the registries you have classification societies you have insurance there is a myriad of issues that are in place to ensure that shipping operates the way it's supposed to do”
Zeihan argues that the future system will be composed of regional powers that can guarantee regional security for the waves, resulting in regional trade systems and national trade systems, ending the era of long-haul multi-continental shipping that has dominated since 1950.
“the future on the other side of this from my point of view is pretty clear you basically have Regional powers that can guarantee Regional security for the waves uh and so you can have regional trade systems or national trade systems but the days of Long Haul multi Continental shipping that have dominated manufacturing Agriculture and energy since 1950 we're at the very end of that”
Shipping cargo volume has more than doubled from 2000 to 2025, increasing from 6 billion tons to 12 billion tons, demonstrating the system's ability to expand capacity and resilience despite historical and ongoing disruptions.
“just from 2000 to 2025 we have overd doubled the amount of cargo we moved from 6 billion tons to 12 billion tons on the world's oceans”
Disruptions in 2020-2022 (global supply chain), Baltimore bridge collapse (2024), and Houthi Red Sea allocation caused significant problems but not systemic maritime shipping collapse.
“we saw this we saw it during the disruption of the global supply chain in 2020 to 2022 we saw it on a smaller scale when the dolly took out the bridge in Baltimore and we had disruptions in a port uh we've seen it with the uh allocation of shipping due to the houthi in the Red Sea”
Global shipping operates under a resilience model where it adapts like water finding cracks in sidewalk—when one route closes, shipping finds alternatives and continues operations, contrary to fragile collapse models.
“global Shipping is very resilient it's like water on a sidewalk it's going to find the cracks uh you shut down the Suz canal the Red Sea shipping is going to find an alternative and that's what we see”
War risk insurance for Red Sea shipping is currently highly profitable, with premiums collected from all ships transiting the Red Sea over the past year far exceeding the payouts for two total loss ships and four merchant mariner deaths, indicating the insurance system can absorb significant maritime disruption without becoming unprofitable.
“War risk insurance right now is raking in profits I I mean the insurance industry to understand shipping you have to understand insurance and the normal above the normal insurance is this war Risk Insurance and War risk and there's been plenty of stories in Lloyd's list and many other Maritime trade Publications that have talked about this that they are raking in the massive profits the amount of War risk that's been paid by all the ships going through the Red Sea over the past year is much more than they've paid out for the loss of two ships and the death of four Merchant Mariners”
Peter Zeihan argues that the maritime order is fundamentally based on trust—trust that ships will arrive, trust that Americans will enforce the system, and trust that no one will challenge the order—and all of that is now falling apart.
“the maritime order is based on trust the trust that your ship will get there the trust that the Americans will enforce the ceilings the trust that no one will challenge that and all of that is now falling apart”
Pre-World War II shipping relied on national merchant marines where each nation defended its own shipping, with trade and security inseparable, versus post-WWII open registry system where security is supposedly externalized to US Navy; in reality, major trading nations (China, India, Japan, Korea) now build large navies to protect their own trade in mercantilistic fashion.
“if you go back to the Paradigm that existed pre World War II you had National Merchant Marines I mean every nation large Nation small nation had its own Merchant Marine and you would defend your Merchant Marine uh post World War II the order changes uh you create these open Registries”
The Russian Merchant Marine is the 22nd largest in the world (with the US at 21st), indicating Russia maintains a substantial merchant fleet despite current challenges and sanctions pressure.
“the Russian Merchant Marine is the 22nd largest in the world uh us is 21st”
Manufacturing in the US will be the first sector to feel disruption from maritime shipping breakdown, while for the rest of the world it will be a race between energy (oil/gas) and agriculture to see which sector faces shortage first.
“manufacturing is definitely the sector where we will feel it first uh in the United States for most of the rest of the world it's going to be a race between energy and agriculture”
Peter Zeihan argues that maritime shipping is heading toward collapse because the trust-based system undergirding global shipping is breaking down, citing simultaneous crises in the Black Sea, Baltic Sea, and Red Sea, plus the loss of Russian icebreaker capability and challenges from Finland, Israel, and Russia.
“the maritime order is based on trust the trust that your ship will get there the trust that the Americans will enforce the ceilings the trust that no one will challenge that and all of that is now falling apart”
The Houthi disruptions in the Red Sea have caused increases in cargo rates and logistical disruptions, but these have not caused collapse of intercontinental maritime shipping as a system—they represent manageable stress on a resilient system.
“the houthi have thrown a massive wrench into the movement of cargo around the world inflating cargo rates and causing disruptions... however I don't don't think it's the end of InterContinental Maritime shipping as we know it”
Zeihan's characterization that Peter filmed his predictions before the Eagle S incident occurred, yet they were accurate, demonstrates Zeihan's analytical accuracy about maritime system stress, lending credibility to his structural diagnosis even if timeline is disputed.
“no Peter filmed that on Christmas Day and then literally that day we had the dragging of the eagle s... Peter you know again I I I I don't doubt him even though the the video was released a week later he releases videos earlier for his patreons uh he was very very much on The Cutting Edge of estimating what was going to happen there”
The current moment represents the 'witching hour' of the global maritime system, where multiple threats are present and small variations in how they unfold could determine whether the system restructures smoothly or experiences severe disruption.
“we are in the Witching Hour of this system right now and based on how any of these issues unfold could get really Rocky really quick”
Zeihan is being 'a little bit tiny bit little hyperbolic' on maritime collapse; 'maybe...propping in a bit too much over that' versus being fundamentally wrong.
“we're going to break down those videos talk about them and discuss whether or not Peter may be just a little bit tiny bit little hyperbolic on that may may maybe prop in a bit too much over that”
Kagan acknowledges Zeihan's ability to identify emerging risks (like Nordic ship inspections) validates his analytical perspective, but Kagan expresses skepticism that Zeihan predicts imminent dramatic collapse ('if you're coming back from New Zealand the world is going to crap').
“yikes okay how fraking long are you staying in New Zealand I hope it's a long time I hope you have moved to New Zealand and don't plan to come back anytime soon Peter because the way he phrases that is like hey I'm coming back from New Zealand and the world is going to crap”
Peter Zeihan does a great job raising awareness of maritime shipping issues through sensationalist framing, which Kagan appreciates even while disagreeing with collapse conclusions.
“I think Peter does a great job in doing that however I study global Shipping and let me be clear global Shipping is very resilient”
Kagan notes that Zeihan's earlier claim about the Ursa Major sinking taking out hatch covers for an icebreaker was filmed before the incident actually occurred, showing Zeihan was making a prediction that subsequently came true.
“Peter filmed this before the event took place with eagle s but I want to get to his real big conclusion”
Kagan argues that the implication of Zeihan's thesis (that the maritime system will collapse) is that the future will be defined by Zeihan choosing to remain in New Zealand rather than returning to the US, a tongue-in-cheek way of saying he finds the collapse prediction alarmist.
“so do I think this is the demise of global Shipping like Peter said no I I I think Peter's being a little bit kind of dramatic there...if it is Peter stay in New Zealand don't come back I'm sorry it just if you coming back from New Zealand means the end of InterContinental transoceanic shipping I I'm sorry Peter you got to stay in New Zeal I'm sorry there's just no other choice”
Kagan acknowledges that Peter Zeihan 'has to' run a travel channel because of the extensive amount of travel and filming locations he uses in his videos, suggesting Zeihan has a significant video production operation beyond geopolitical analysis.
“Peter you must run a travel channel I don't know about right I mean he has to I mean the amount of travel this man does and the amount of film he has from everywhere around the world there is a YouTube channel with Peter Zion just doing like like scenes right I mean if he's not he's missing a golden opportunity here”