YouTube2h 34m· Feb 2023· cataloged

Charlie Munger On BYD, Tesla, Alibaba and Bitcoin — Daily Journal’s Shareholders Meeting — 2/15/2023


What this covers

This is the Daily Journal Corporation's annual shareholders meeting, with Charlie Munger answering questions at length. Stephen Michael Jones of Journal Technologies joins him, and Becky Quick relays shareholder questions. The company's own future is the anchor: Munger says it lies in court-automation software rather than publishing, since the internet broke the newspaper monopoly. Jones adds that enterprise software has to be treated as continuous change management, funded by a large enough licensee base to pay for proactive R&D. Munger also describes newspaper publishing as dying across the industry.

The investing material is the widest part. Munger credits Ben Graham with seeing the value of great businesses but notes that Graham made more than half his money on one great business, GEICO, which cut against his own teaching. He and Warren Buffett look at business quality first and management second. He calls BYD under Wang Chuanfu the most remarkable venture capital success in history and says Tesla has lost ground to it in China. Costco is a business he will never sell, even at 40 times earnings. He is skeptical of semiconductors, which force constant reinvestment, and of AI, which he calls overhyped. Denial comes up as the main driver of bad decisions, along with the Darwinian point that every business eventually dies.

Beyond stocks, he takes on several other subjects. He says few managers are worth "two and twenty" fees, and he treats the move of 401(k) plans toward index funds as sensible. He compares replacing national currencies with cryptocurrency to replacing national air. He condemns General Electric's mix of huge executive pay and managed earnings. The more contested positions are that most people cannot be educated into better judgment and that inflation will persist because of democratic politics. He also dismisses the population-disaster predictions of Paul Ehrlich, and he spends time praising Ben Franklin as a model of a well-lived life.

Sharpest takeaway

Munger argues that rational decision-making, delayed gratification, fiduciary responsibility, and focus on great businesses rather than great managers are the core principles for investment success and a well-lived life, while warning against speculative excesses like cryptocurrency and excessive executive compensation.

  • Most people fail to think rationally and consistently, giving those who do a massive competitive advantage
  • Great businesses with strong competitive moats and management cultures (like Costco, BYD) compound wealth far better than mediocre businesses with exceptional managers
  • Long-term fiduciary duty and loyalty to stakeholders, paired with avoiding denial about business disruption, separates durable wealth-builders from failures

The claims · ranked121 claims · weighted by value

This asset isn't compiled yet

You're seeing its claims, ranked. Compile it to build the argument threads, weight them, and check each claim against your library — the full view.

0.75

Ben Graham recognized that greatness was good and understood the value of great businesses, but he didn't evolve his theory during his lifetime; he made more than half his money from a single stock (GEICO), a great business, showing that his own practice contradicted his teaching.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Charlie Munger

“Ben Graham actually made more than half of all the money he made in his life out of one stock and that stock was Geico which was a great business so if you actually look at the great man's own life you see that what he taught wasn't the way he got rich himself and by the way he told that story on himself late in life carefully computed how much he'd made in Geico compared to everything he had ever done in his previous life and so you can argue that Ben Graham himself woke up once”

0.74

When evaluating companies for investment, Munger and Buffett prioritize the quality of the business first, then the quality of management; they have not achieved success by investing in great managers to turn around lousy businesses, but rather depend on great businesses.

normativehigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 4/4· Charlie Munger

“I think we like the business great first and then second we want a great manager but we we have not made a huge success by investing on grade managers to take over lousy businesses that is not the way we Rose”

0.73

Denial is the dominant factor in bad decision-making: when the truth is unpleasant, people's minds play tricks on them and they rationalize it away, causing enormous business destruction as exemplified by people continuing to invest in obsolete industries.

causalhigh valueestablishednovelty 2/4durability 4/4· Charlie Munger

“what if I had a name one factor that dominates doing bad decisions it would be what I call denial if the truth is unpleasant enough people kind of their mind plays tricks on them and they think it it isn't really happening and of course that causes enormous destruction of business where people go on throwing money into the way they used to do things”

0.73

From the perspective of Darwinian evolution, all businesses eventually die just like all species and animals do in nature as they are replaced by other species; recognizing this pattern helped Munger become a better investor.

causalhigh valueestablishednovelty 2/4durability 4/4· Charlie Munger

“how much dies the business world is very much like the physical world where all the animals die in the course of improving all the species so they can live in niches and so forth all the animals die and eventually all the species die that's the system”

0.73

The future of Daily Journal Corporation is not in the publishing business but in the Journal Technologies software business because the internet destroyed the newspaper publishing monopoly, and Journal Technologies has the opportunity to serve a huge global market of courts still in the Stone Age in terms of automation with modern technology.

causalhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Charlie Munger

“the future of this business is not in the publishing side it's on the it's on the general technology side and the good news is that we're in a huge Market because all the courts of the world are in the Stone Age still in terms of automating with modern technology”

0.69

Newspaper publishing businesses, particularly those dependent on newsprint, are broadly dying across the industry; only a few small and mid-cap newspaper publishers remain viable, and most major newspaper empires like Gannett have shrunk to pale shadows of their former dominance.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Charlie Munger

“by and large the safe rule is they're all dying it's just in different states of near death”

0.69

Artificial intelligence is overhyped and is not a cure-all; while it has been used effectively in some specific domains like insurance underwriting, it is a mixed blessing with significant limitations and nonsense surrounding it.

normativehigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Charlie Munger

“I think artificial intelligence is very important but is also a lot of crazy hype on the subject artificial intelligence is not going to cure cancer it's not going to do everything that we want done and there's a lot of nonsense in it too so I regard it as a mixed blessing”

0.69

Costco is a nearly perfect business with a wonderful culture, strong competitive moat, excellent leadership, and will have a marvelous future despite trading at 40 times earnings; Munger will never sell a share.

normativehigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Charlie Munger

“as long as Costco keeps the faith the strong culture and their extreme low markup policy I don't see any stopping it the trouble with Costco's it's 40 times earnings but but except for that it's a perfect damn comedy and it has a marvelous future and it has a wonderful culture and it's been run by wonderful people and I I I I love everything about Costco I'm a total addict and I'm never going to sell a share”

0.69

Warren Buffett has a strong fiduciary gene and exceptional loyalty to shareholders—both Warren and Munger were lucky that early shareholders who didn't know them trusted them when they were young and unknown, creating mutual exceptional loyalty that helps their investment performance.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Charlie Munger

“Born is not only a very good good thinker and a good learner which is important but Warren has a big strong fiduciary Gene he cares about what happens to the shareholders Lauren and I were lucky and that the early shareholders were people who trusted us when we were young and didn't have a reputation and so on and naturally we feel an exceptional loyalty to those people”

0.69

Finding great businesses that don't require great managers is difficult because all the obviously great businesses have been picked over and analyzed extensively by many investors, so they trade at high multiples (25-35x earnings), creating significant downside risk if execution fails.

causalhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Charlie Munger

“the trouble with it is you will find when you get into those good businesses in a place is picked over and analyzed as American stocks are you can imagine the amount of time spent thinking about American stocks and you will find by and large in America it's really a great business it's at least 25 times earnings and maybe 30 or 35 or something so that makes it a much harder of course because if something goes wrong you can lose a lot of your investment”

0.69

BYD is the most remarkable venture capital success in history: the company went from being a bankrupt small automotive company under the leadership of Wang Chuanfu to selling more electric vehicles than any competitor globally this year, generating over $2 billion in after-tax profits in the automotive business alone.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Charlie Munger

“last year what happened byd last year made more than two billion dollars after taxes in the auto business in China who in the hell makes two billion dollars it was a brand new intern really in the auto business for all practical purposes it's incredible what's happened”

0.68

Currency systems have done more good to the human race than anything else—they enabled the transition from successful apes to modern humans and human civilization; someone trying to replace national currencies with cryptocurrency is like trying to replace national air.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 0/4durability 4/4· Charles T. Munger

“you can think of hardly nothing on Earth that has done more good to the human race than currency National currencies they were absolutely required to turn man from a goddamn successful ape model modern successful humans in human civilization does it enabled all these convenient exchanges so if somebody says I'm going to create something that sort of replaces the national currency it's like saying I'm going to replace the National Air”

0.66

Most people cannot be educated into better decision-making; some people have foundational capacity that can be improved at the margins, but many people lack the baseline cognitive or motivational capacity to learn good judgment, and education cannot fix this.

normativehigh valuecontestednovelty 1/4durability 4/4· Charlie Munger

“it's that's a good question because it's a big question and if you have good judgment your life will work a lot better than if you have bad judgment and you get good judgment gradually over time partly they're making bad judgments and having them not work out poorly um so my counsel has always been to start trying to be better and keep doing keep trying to improve all your life and you've got about half a chance if you don't do that you've got like no chance and so I it's I I used to say I could only teach with the other person almost knows then I can just trim over the brink when he's hanging on the edge but if a guy is not within miles of even starting I never make any any public I never succeed so when removing idiocy I have no I have a 100 fail”

0.66

Good government requires most property to be in private hands with efficient incentives for owners to care for that property; this drives GDP per capita growth through enabling exchanges and allowing people to spend their own money on their own businesses.

causalhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 4/4· Charlie Munger

“you've got to do if you want growing GDP per capita which is what everybody should want you've got to have most of the property in private hands so most of the people who are making decisions about how properties do he cared for own the property in question and that makes the whole system so efficient that GDP per capita grows in a system where you have easy exchanges due to a currency system”

0.64

Tesla has lost significant competitive advantage in China to BYD: Tesla reduced prices twice in China last year while BYD increased prices, demonstrating BYD's stronger market position and pricing power.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 2/4· Charlie Munger

“Tesla last year reduced its prices in China twice byd increased its prices we're direct competitors we're so much ahead of by ATD I mean byd is so much ahead of Tesla in China it's like a it's just it's almost ridiculous”

0.63

General Electric in its heyday exemplified how excessive executive compensation became an enabler of fraudulent earnings management: the company paid enormous compensation packages while phoning up the earnings to pay for it, which was disgusting and threatens civilization if such behavior creeps in everywhere.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 0/4durability 3/4· Charlie Munger

“take General Electric in its Heyday think of all the big compensation packages they paid and think of how they were phoning up the earnings and so forth to pay for it it was disgusting and and of course if that kind of crap Creeps in everywhere in our civilization the civilization will perish we need more on or not less”

0.63

Bill Gates has stated that when really disruptive technology comes along, incumbents almost inevitably screw up their reaction to it; it's hard to change your ways when they've been successful for a long time.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 0/4durability 3/4· Charlie Munger

“I've heard Bill Gates say that it's almost the rule and a really disruptive technology comes along the incumbents screw up their reaction to it it's hard to change your ways when they've been successful for a long time and go into a totally different way of behaving”

0.63

Ben Franklin is one of the most remarkable people in history: starting from absolute poverty and with minimal formal education (2-3 years), he became his nation's best inventor, best scientist, best writer, best diplomat, and invented numerous products still in use (bifocal glasses, Franklin stove), played four musical instruments including one he invented, and established trust funds for Philadelphia and Boston that still pay out centuries later.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 0/4durability 3/4· Charlie Munger

“he was a genius it was a small country but remember he started in absolute poverty his father made soap out of the carcasses of dead animals that stank now that is a very low place to start from and he was almost entirely self-educated two or three years of primary school and after that he had to learn all himself well the rise from that kind of a starting position and become by the time he died he was the best inventor in his country the best scientist in his country the best writer in this country the best Diplomat in this country you know thing after thing after thing he was the best there was in the whole United States”

0.63

Semiconductor manufacturing is a difficult industry where companies must reinvest all profits continuously with each new generation of chips, making it compulsory to throw back all previous earnings just to stay competitive—Munger dislikes such businesses.

causalhigh valueestablishednovelty 0/4durability 3/4· Charlie Munger

“you have to take all the money you've made and and with each new generation of chips you throw in all the money you previously made so it's compulsory investment of everything you want to stay in the game naturally I hate a business like that”

0.63

Most 401(k) plans now sensibly require or heavily feature index funds as the default investment option, which is a logical outcome of the demonstrated difficulty of active management to beat passive indices.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 0/4durability 3/4· Charlie Munger

“if you said look at the Daily Journal Corporation we just put in a 401K plan what are the investment options for the people that work zero it's all index funds and if you have a percentage of American what percentage of American 401ks have our plan index funds required about zero am I right or am I wrong of course I'm right it's a logical thing to do”

0.63

Very few investment managers are worth their 'two and twenty' fee structure (2% management fee plus 20% of profits); being worth such fees requires being in the top 5 percent of managers, which is rare.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 0/4durability 3/4· Charlie Munger

“what percentage of American 401ks have our plan index funds required about zero am I right or am I wrong of course I'm right it's a logical thing to do okay so percent worth two and twenty sometimes sometimes being worth two and twenty I I would say that is way less than five percent the van is worth two and twenty that is really that's getting that's getting very rare indeed”

0.63

Enterprise software development must be approached as an ongoing process rather than a one-time event, requiring a mindset of change management and continuous upgrade capability; a sufficient licensee base is needed to fund proactive R&D that evolves products to manage technological change.

normativehigh valueestablishednovelty 0/4durability 3/4· Stephen Michael Jones

“I think a key responsibility is to get technology change working for us and our customers rather than against us and it and it takes um Advanced planning and and investment to engineer software um with with with with change over time in mind and so it's inherently upgradeable and I think this model works works great if you can establish a sufficient licensee base to fund that that that proactive r d to evolve products in a way that manages technology change”

0.63

Population growth predictions have consistently been wrong: experts like Paul Ehrlich predicted population disaster, but populations in advanced countries have instead declined due to prosperity increasing birth rate decreases, with Japan experiencing population shortages rather than surpluses.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 0/4durability 3/4· Charlie Munger

“if you'd looked at the way things that happened in the past you would have concluded like Paul there like did that the world's headed for an absolute population disaster but what actually has happened is quite different what's happened is that as the world has gotten more and more prosperous including in places like China the birth rate has gone down down down down and so that there's actually sort of a population shortage in a place like Japan”

0.62

Stock buybacks should not be taxed; when companies repurchase their own stock, they are doing something good for shareholders, not something deserving of extra taxation; a 4% tax on stock buybacks is a big mistake in policy.

normativehigh valuecontestednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Charlie Munger

“I'm strongly opposed because I think if you're you're a good culture has a lot of people that are good fiduciaries and it is like stealing to do something dumb of the corporate money once you can get more advantage to your show or so buy back your own stock and I like encouraging morality and decency and honor and so on your dealings with the people you're the fiduciary for”

0.62

More inflation over the next 100 years is inevitable given the nature of democratic politics; all politicians in a democracy tend to favor printing money and spending it, which causes some inflation over time that will do more harm than good going forward.

forecasthigh valuecontestednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Charlie Munger

“I think more inflation over the next 100 years is inevitable with given the nature of democratic politics politics in a democracy so I think we'll have more inflation that's one of the reasons The Daily Journal owns Securities instead of government bonds Owens Common Stocks instead of government bonds when you say the nature of democratic policies and I I forget exactly how you worded it are you talking about the Democratic party are you talking about democracism that was bigger than the Democrats did yeah all Democratic all politicians in a democracy tend to be in favor of printing the money and spending it”

0.62

Most large companies practice excessive stock-based compensation without buying in shares to offset dilution, treating options accounting as a non-expense to inflate reported earnings; this is human nature and widespread despite being economically wasteful.

factualhigh valuecontestednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Charlie Munger

“many a corporation everybody would vote to being allowed to have stock-based compensation you didn't count in Computing the earnings they just want any damn way of making the earnings appear higher it's just human nature of course they want their it's like your little kid goes off to school they want a very own good grades not bad grades”

0.62

Many large companies including Meta and insurance companies are self-insuring against liabilities (directors and officers liability, business risks), and carried to extremes over time, this could create potential systemic issues.

factualhigh valuecontestednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Becky Quick (reporting shareholder question)

“many large companies including meta which owns Facebook and various insurances are choosing to self-insure against liability either for directors or for the business risks if it's carried to extremes it would know as it no doubt will be over time this could cause potential systemic issues”

0.62

There is systemic racism in the United States, though racism has gotten way better in Munger's lifetime; he argues that racism is going down a lot rather than being a permanent structural feature.

factualhigh valuecontestednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Charlie Munger

“I suppose we've got some sure of course you're going to have a certain amount of animosity one group toward another and the whole history of the human race we've had a certain amount of that I think it's gotten way better in my lifetime however I would argue the racism is going down a lot”

0.60

Ben Graham said: if it's a good investment, it may be a good speculation; Munger mostly doesn't do short-term speculation, but the principle suggests good long-term investments can occasionally have speculative merit.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 0/4durability 4/4· Charlie Munger

“Ben Graham used to say if it's a good investment it may be a good speculation and I think that's generally true but I don't do those short-term speculations at least not very often”

0.60

Kodak's collapse is remarkable: it dominated photography globally, invented the technology that replaced it, yet the entire company went to zero—an example of how even dominant incumbents can be completely wiped out by disruptive technology.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 0/4durability 4/4· Charlie Munger

“imagine having Kodak die it was one of the great trademarks of the world there was nobody who didn't use film they dominated film they knew more about the chemistry of film than anybody else on Earth and of course the whole damn business went to zero”

0.60

Investment management fees are morally depraved: approximately 95% of investment managers consistently fail to beat the indexes after costs, yet they charge fees for worthless advice, including to widows who cannot afford it, creating billions in uncountable agency costs that nobody will face because it benefits fee-collectors.

normativehigh valuecontestednovelty 1/4durability 4/4· Charlie Munger

“how many managers are going to beat the indexes all costs considered I would say maybe five percent consistently beat the averages everybody else is living in a state of extreme denial they're used to charging big fees and so forth for stuff that isn't doing their clients any good it's a deep moral depravity”

0.60

Cryptocurrency is 'rat poison,' 'cryptocrab,' massively stupid, and entirely worthless; national currencies were essential for enabling human civilization and exchange, while cryptocurrency offers no comparable benefit and is dangerous and anti-social.

normativehigh valuecontestednovelty 1/4durability 4/4· Charlie Munger

“it isn't you can think of hardly nothing on Earth that has done more good to the human race than currency National currencies they were absolutely required to turn man from a goddamn successful ape model modern successful humans in human civilization does it enabled all these convenient exchanges so if somebody says I'm going to create something that sort of replaces the national currency it's like saying I'm going to replace the National Air you know it's it's as an eye it is it isn't even slightly stupid it's massively stupid”

0.57

The hostile withdrawal of former Chinese President Hu Jintao at the October 2022 Party Congress shows Xi Jinping has consolidated power; this suggests he thinks differently about the role of business in Chinese society, raising concerns about business investors.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 0/4durability 2/4· Charles T. Munger

“several people including me were taken aback by the forceful withdrawal of former president hujin Tao at the October 22 annual Congress president XI seems to have Consolidated power and his actions have indicated that he thinks very differently about the role of business in Chinese Society”

0.57

Climate change will be less important than many people think, which doesn't mean it will be unimportant; it's not likely to be an absolute full horror scenario with no possibility of adaptation, and Munger isn't certain about insurance industry impacts.

forecasthigh valuecontestednovelty 1/4durability 2/4· Charlie Munger

“I think there's a good chance that climate change will be less important than a lot of people think that doesn't mean it'll be unimportant but I think it won't be an absolute full one horror capacity with no possibility into a just oh”

0.56

Executive compensation has gotten worse and more excessive in the last 50 years; when Munger was young, executive compensation wasn't a major complaint, but now it's criticized in the investment world as having gotten too high in many cases.

factualhigh valuecontestednovelty 0/4durability 3/4· Charlie Munger

“when I was young it wasn't so bad why this is something that's happened in the last 50 years I don't know it's just the history of the way things came up and the greater hardship and the pioneering ethos or God whatever it was when I was young executive nobody complained about executive compensation now practically everybody in the investment world thinks in many cases executive compensation has gotten too high”

0.56

American healthcare costs are completely out of control at 20+ times the cost of Singapore's system, and nobody has been able to fix it; the costs are driven by numerous entrenched interests (hospitals, pharmaceutical companies, insurance companies, medical device manufacturers) who benefit from the high-cost system and will resist reform.

factualhigh valuecontestednovelty 0/4durability 3/4· Charlie Munger

“if you go to Singapore you will find that they do the whole thing better than we do and it costs 20 of what we pay”

0.56

The single most important quality that has helped Munger in life is rationality: if you're simply not crazy and avoid foolish behavior, you have a significant advantage over 95 percent of people; combined with delayed gratification and consistently satisfying commitments to others, rationality creates enormous improvements in life outcomes.

normativehigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 4/4· Charlie Munger

“that's easy rationality if you're just not crazy you have a big advantage over 95 percent of the people because most people have all kinds of crazy patches if you just are consistently not crazy you had a you get a big advantage in life and here patient and uh gratification defer in addition to being not crazy then it's practically a cinch and then if you're exceptionally good at satisfying your commitments to other people then you've got you you just automatically improved your resources and your chances in life enormously”

0.56

The secret to a happy life is having low expectations and advancing one inch at a time; dreams of extreme success often fail, but consistent incremental progress with delivered commitments leads to success and respect.

normativehigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 4/4· Charlie Munger

“of course you want to live a life where by and large you're meeting me reasonable expectations of other people that's what civilization requires of all of us”

0.55

China made the correct decision to ban cryptocurrency while the US government was wrong to permit it; cryptocurrency is cheating and gambling with enormous house odds where the operators cheat in addition to the betting being rigged.

normativehigh valuecontestednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Charlie Munger

“the guy who made the correct decision on this is the Chinese leader the Chinese leader took one look at crypto and he says not in my China well there isn't any crypto in China he's right and we're wrong”

0.55

Self-insurance is superior to buying insurance for risks you can afford to absorb; Munger never carried collision insurance on cars and stopped carrying fire insurance on houses once wealthy, saving enormous amounts by avoiding fraud, claims processing, commissions, and time waste inherent in insurance transactions.

normativehigh valuecontestednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Charlie Munger

“I'm a big self-insurer and so is Warren it's ridiculous for me to carry fire insurance on my houses because I can so easily rebuild a house that would burn down so why would I want to bother fooling around with the claims process and all kinds of things so if insurance you should ensure against things you can't afford to pay for yourself”

0.55

California's high state and federal combined tax rates make it a very business-unfriendly state that actively drives wealthy individuals and corporations out, unlike states with no income taxes that deliberately use that as a lure.

factualhigh valuecontestednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Charlie Munger

“California is trying to force its wealthy people and its wealthy corporations out of the state and I must say it's working fine they're leaving just whatever now”

0.55

Greg Abel at Berkshire is arguably as good as Jim Senegal and is running utilities as if he were the regulator rather than the executive, exemplifying the highest fiduciary principles by making decisions that align with broader stakeholder interests.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Charlie Munger

“I'll tell you somebody else for a job that of the kind he has Greg Abel in a way it's just as good as Greg sent on but Senegal was yeah he has the kind of a genius for the way he handles people and so forth and problems”

0.55

Great department stores once seemed eternal—they dominated their communities with convenience, multiple floors, elevators, credit services—yet they are essentially all dying or dead now, showing how structural retail changes can destroy seemingly impregnable businesses.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 0/4durability 3/4· Charlie Munger

“think of all the great department stores think of how long they were the most important thing in their little community they're way ahead of everybody in Furnishing credit convenience in all seasons you know convenience back and forth you the same Banks of elevators and so forth multiple floors it looked like they were eternal and they're basically all dying or dead”

0.55

Rising interest rates are hostile to stock prices, but rates should go up and cannot stay at zero forever; investors must adapt to higher interest rates as one of many headwinds they face, alongside inflation.

causalhigh valueestablishednovelty 0/4durability 3/4· Charlie Munger

“there's no question about the fact that as the interest rates have gone up it's it's hostile to stock prices and but they should go up but we couldn't have kept them Forever at zero and and I just think it's just one more damn thing to adapt to and investment life is that there are there are headwinds and their Tailwinds”

0.55

Democracy has historically failed relatively frequently, leading to dictatorships and 'awful things'; the worst outcome of Munger's lifetime was an advanced civilization like Germany being taken over by a dictator due to the Great Depression, which made World War II inevitable.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 0/4durability 3/4· Charlie Munger

“if you take the history of democracy in the world and go back far enough it fails a lot and gets succeeded by dictatorships and all kinds of awful things and as a matter of fact the worst thing that happened to the human race in my lifetime was an advanced civilization like Germany was taken over by a dictator as awful lucido Hitler that happened as a consequence of a big worldwide depression”

0.55

IBM, which was the most admired company in America during Munger's youth with a record of marching from triumph to triumph, has now slipped and is falling behind competitors like Apple and Google, demonstrating how even tech giants can lose dominance.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 0/4durability 3/4· Charlie Munger

“I'd say one of the most interesting things that happened in my lifetime was the rise of IBM and the fall of IBM IBM was the most admired company in America where most of my young life they just marched from triumphs and Triumph of the triumph and you know in the last 10 or 15 years they've slipped and they've their falling back in relation to other people in their field let's see the apples and the Googles and so forth came ahead”

0.55

The U.S. government demonstrated wisdom and generosity in the post-WWII Marshall Plan approach: instead of punishing Germany and Japan after their defeat, America helped them rebuild and made them into allies, which was done on a bipartisan basis and reflects credit on American civilization.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 0/4durability 3/4· Charlie Munger

“what makes me proudest of my own government is the way we handle the sequel to World War II instead of punishing the Germans and the Japanese we made them into some of our best friends on earth now that was a stunt and it was to the credit of our country that that was done and it was done a bipartisan basis and I think we can all be proud of that that was a smart thing to do”

0.53

Wealth and age make people 'more so'—whatever personality traits a person has tend to become amplified with success and age, for better or worse.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 4/4· Charlie Munger

“whatever you are age and wealth makes you more so”

0.52

Berkshire Hathaway and Daily Journal Corporation maintain fiduciary virtue by avoiding pervasive fee-taking and agency costs that characterize most businesses; Munger gave his own shares to Daily Journal for employee compensation instead of having the company issue new shares, a practice he learned from BYD's founder Wang Chuanfu.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Charlie Munger

“I don't think Berkshire does that and I don't think we've Garen and I did it as a Daily Journal Karen and I never took a dime in salary or director's fees or anything and if I have business I talk on my phone or use my car I don't charge it to the Daily Journal that's unheard of it shouldn't be unheard of”

0.52

Munger used leverage to purchase BYD shares at a favorable time despite his long-standing philosophy of avoiding leverage, justifying this exception by the extraordinary quality of the opportunity; leverage is appropriate when the opportunity is great enough.

normativehigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Charlie Munger

“I operated with no leverage for long stretches of my old age and Warren's the same way and and recently I did use a little bit of Leverage here in another place because the opportunities were so ridiculously good I thought it was desirable to do that”

0.52

The best investment Berkshire ever made was paying an executive recruiter to identify a specific employee (Ajit Jain), whose return compared to the recruiting fee is larger than even the BYD investment.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Charlie Munger

“we paid an executive recruiter to get us a an employee and he came up with Aussie chain the return that rajeed has made us compared to the amount we paid the executive recruiter that was our best investment at Berkshire which was I'm paying the executive recruiting for him to get a get us a chain”

0.52

For every person who succeeds through aggressive ambitious behavior, there are thousands of failures; most people should avoid ambitious dreams, which is understandable but underappreciated truth.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 4/4· Charlie Munger

“there's always somebody who's a little nuts and who succeeds but that's but for every guy who's exceeds their thousand failures”

0.52

Underpromising and overdelivering is essential for social success; making commitments and failing to meet them is the most guaranteed way to make people hate you; meeting reasonable expectations is what civilization requires of everyone.

normativehigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 4/4· Charlie Munger

“of course who in the hell is Right mine would like going around making a lot of commitments and failing Time After Time After Time and doing what you'd promise to do everybody would hate you right there's no more guaranteed way to make people hate you than to fail them in their reasonable expectations so of course you want to live a life where by and large you're meeting me reasonable expectations of other people that's what civilization requires of all of us”

0.52

BYD's founder Wang Chuanfu is the eighth son of a peasant who was recognized as a genius by his older brother; the older brother sacrificed himself to get the younger into a good engineering school; Wang became an engineering professor and entrepreneur.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 4/4· Charlie Munger

“he was the eighth son of a peasant had an older brother that recognized this young kid was kind of a younger brother was a genius and the older brother sacrificed himself to get this peasant Sun into some good engineering school and he became an engineering professor and then an entrepreneur”

0.52

You can expect both right and wrong governmental decisions to occur in the future; there will be similar episodes of success and failure, suggesting government performance will remain mixed rather than improving or deteriorating systematically.

forecasthigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 4/4· Charles T. Munger

“and I don't think our future Behaviour will lack similar episodes of some kind black similar episodes something's very right and something's very wrong that's our that's the way it happens”

0.52

Movie business is a hard place to make money as an investor despite being a good place for actors, writers, musicians, and other creators; the structural economics are unfavorable for capital providers.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 4/4· Charlie Munger

“it may be a very good place to make a living as an actor or a writer or something or a musician but it's a hard place to make money if you're an investor”

0.52

For teaching undergraduate personal finance and corporate finance to non-majors, the most important thing is developing good judgment; good judgment develops gradually over time through making bad judgments that don't work out badly, coupled with constant effort to improve.

normativehigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 4/4· Charles T. Munger

“well it's that's a good question because it's a big question and if you have good judgment your life will work a lot better than if you have bad judgment and you get good judgment gradually over time partly they're making bad judgments and having them not work out poorly um so my counsel has always been to start trying to be better and keep doing keep trying to improve all your life”

0.52

Academia throws out people who can't keep up, which is how it produces such good results at the top; this model of selectivity (rather than trying to lift everyone up) is how top institutions maintain excellence.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 4/4· Charlie Munger

“that's the way most Education Works they just throw out those who can't keep up that's the way Academia works that's the reason it gets so good at the top”

0.52

The logical answer to the question 'what percentage of your net worth should you put in a stock if you think it's a cinch' is 100% or maybe 150%, but nobody in finance teaches people to think that way, which represents a gap between theoretical optimization and practical education.

normativehigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 4/4· Charles T. Munger

“I sometimes ask myself a mental question I say what is the appropriate percentage of your net worth you should put it in the stock if you think it's an absolute sense well if you're a kind of fellow who's right and when you think something is a cinch the answer is 100 percent maybe 150 percent but nobody in that nobody teaches people to think that way and finance”

0.52

Xi Jinping has done a lot right including an anti-corruption drive; every government makes decisions that don't work well, and you shouldn't expect perfection anywhere in the world (7 is a sorrow/sorrowful grade); democracies also make mistakes regularly, so it's natural to have misdecision everywhere.

normativehigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 4/4· Charlie Munger

“he's done a lot right too and and you know he would let a big anti-corruption Drive he's done a lot of things right so and I don't know where this man lives where is there a place where the government is perfect in the world that's seven sorrow the democracies aren't that regularly run either so it's natural to have some decisions made by government that don't work well it's natural to have decisions in each individual life that don't work very well we live in a world of sin sorrow and misdecision that's that's what that that's what human beings get to cope with”

0.52

A good teacher can best teach people who already know something and are hanging on the edge of understanding; if they're far from understanding, even a great teacher can't help them; this limitation applies to teaching finance to college students.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 4/4· Charlie Munger

“I used to say I could only teach with the other person almost knows then I can just trim over the brink when he's hanging on the edge but if a guy is not within miles of even starting I never make any any public I never succeed”

0.52

Rationality becomes harder to maintain with age, success, and wealth, but practice improves it; most people cannot be educated to do deferred gratification automatically, which is why some children with 10 children will be more successful than others at it.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 4/4· Charlie Munger

“is it harder with success age wealth to hold on to rationality I think it's it's always hard but you get better at it if you get good at Young keep practicing but it's it's never easy I don't think you can educate your children to do it automatically that's why you have 10 children you'll have some that are a lot better than others doing”

0.51

Intel, which once dominated the semiconductor industry globally and invented the business, is now so far behind its competitors that it's not clear whether Intel will have a very decent semiconductor business going forward; government incentives to build plants in the US (via the Chips and Science Act) do not fully solve the capital intensity problem.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Charlie Munger

“I remember when Intel on the world intel was once the Taiwan semiconductor business of the world yeah they invented the damn business and they dominated it for decades and and until it's not clear to me that Immortal Intel's going to have a very decent semiconductor business getting as far behind as they are now it's my answer is it's not so damn foolproof as it looked even with the incentives to build plants here in the United States it's like Intel is doing in Ohio”

0.51

Jack Ma's decision to publicly criticize the Chinese Communist Party's competence was politically reckless and hurt Alibaba's prospects; he essentially 'poked a bear in the nose with a sharp stick,' showing that smart investors must account for geopolitical risks and relations with government.

causalhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Charlie Munger

“Jack ma was a dominant capitalist in Alibaba and one day he got up and made a public speech where he basically said the Communist party is full of milwaukee they don't know their assemble arable they're no damn good and I'm smart and of course the Communist Party didn't particularly like his speech and pretty soon he just sort of disappeared from view”

0.51

The government is becoming increasingly hostile to business, and this trend will continue; combined with starting valuations that are already higher than in the past, the investment environment will get harder for everyone over the next 5-20 years.

forecasthigh valuecontestednovelty 1/4durability 2/4· Charlie Munger

“I think basically the culture of the world will become more and more anti-business and the big democracies and and I think taxes will go up not down so I think the investment world is going to get harder for everybody”

0.50

The Florida governor's recent conflict with Disney over self-governing authority is an example of how Disney faces tougher competitive and political conditions than in its heyday, reflecting broader industry challenges affecting ESPN profitability and movie production.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 0/4durability 2/4· Charlie Munger

“practically every business that Disney has has gotten tougher than it used to be again welcome to human life think about Disney once owned the world Lion King was running the long run on met on the Theater District of New York they went from triumphs around marching marching marching all of a sudden I'm practically every front it's more difficult”

0.48

Daily Journal Corporation holds a large equity portfolio worth over $310 million in marketable securities, accumulated from excess profits during the publishing business's heyday, which provides downside protection and is being held rather than sold due to California's high state and federal capital gains taxes on the unrealized gains from purchases made at the bottom of the foreclosure crisis.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Charlie Munger

“a 420 million dollar market cap with a total Equity portfolio value of over 310 million dollars”

0.48

Even Sequoia Capital has occasionally made mistakes, though it has an exceptional overall record; being in the top tier of investors doesn't eliminate error, it just dramatically reduces the frequency.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Charlie Munger

“even Sequoia makes even Sequoia makes an occasional mistake they you know everybody does but overall you still think it's worth it yeah okay so how many people have a sequoia-like record I don't think there's one in a hundred thousand”

0.48

Jim Senegal at Costco is one of the most remarkable executives in business history: he started working at age 18 in a store and rose to become CEO under founder Saul Price, achieving remarkable success in one business throughout his entire lifetime through mastery of every aspect of the business.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Charlie Munger

“Jim Senegal at Costco was about as well adapted for the executive care he got and by the way he didn't go to Wharton he didn't go to the Harvard Business School he started to work at age 18 in a store and he rose to be CEO at Costco and in effect he was a founder under a man named Saul price and I would argue that what he accomplished in his own lifetime was one of the most remarkable things in the whole history of business in the history of the world”

0.48

Warren Buffett's Berkshire partnership regularly used leverage to finance 'Jewish treasury bills' (Ben Graham's term for arbitrage opportunities like merger arbitrage and liquidations), which were independent banking-like businesses uncorrelated with the market, demonstrating that leverage can be appropriate for specific strategies.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Charlie Munger

“the Buffett partnership used Leverage regularly every every year of its life what Warren would do is he would buy a bunch of stocks and then he'd borrow and slow stocks and he'd buy into these uh they used to call it event Arbitrage liquidations mergers and so forth and that was not didn't go up and down with the market that was like an independent banking business”

0.48

Alibaba was one of Munger's worst investment mistakes: he was charmed by the company's dominant position on the Chinese internet but failed to recognize that Alibaba was fundamentally still a retailer competing in an inherently competitive business, not a monopoly.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Charlie Munger

“I regard alibaba's one of the worst mistakes I ever made in in thinking about Alibaba I got Charmed with the idea of their position on the Chinese internet I didn't stop to realize there's still a goddamn retailer it's it's going to be a competitive business the Internet it's not going to be a Cakewalk for everybody”

0.48

Wang Chuanfu at BYD is a genius who thinks about the right things 17 hours a day his entire life—a workaholic who can accomplish things that ordinary human beings cannot, and this extraordinary dedication is key to BYD's success.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Charlie Munger

“Juan chonpu and by the way in his case it wouldn't have happened if Juan John Foo hadn't been so unusual unusual how he's a goddamn it is a damn genius and he's been thinking about the right things 17 hours a day all his life he's a workaholic auntie he can do things that ordinary human beings can't do”

0.48

Costco manages stock-based compensation perfectly: the company buys in stock to offset issuance, creating no net dilution while still incentivizing employees; this contrasts with high-tech companies that issue stock without buying it back.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Charlie Munger

“places like Costco I would say the compensation system is damn near perfect it's it's and and there's a fair amount of stock but we always buy in enough stock in Costco to pay for the stock we're issuing”

0.48

Coca-Cola was run for years by a man with a severe mental impairment whom directors assumed was just drunk, yet he ran the company well because Coca-Cola is such a wonderful business that it can be run successfully even by a mentally defective manager.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Charlie Munger

“sometimes Coca-Cola was run for years by a man with a very severe mental impairment and the directors just assumed he was drunk and let him stay there year after year now that's my idea of a wonderful business that you can you can be mentally defective and rather pretty well that was Coca-Cola and it's heyday how far back were we talking oh well 25 years”

0.48

If Daily Journal succeeds in the software business, it will all come good in the end; if it fails, it has a crutch under it in its real estate and securities holdings, meaning it will not lose as much from a present market price decline.

causalhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Charlie Munger

“if we succeed in this software business it will all come good in the end and if we fail we have a crutch under us in our real estate and our Securities which means we won't lose so much from the president market price so it's not a crazy thing to to own now the market valuation”

0.48

Munger's greatest contribution to BYD's success was his warning (along with Li Lu) against entering the auto business—the founder ignored the advice and succeeded brilliantly, making $2 billion+ in profits, which shows the value of luck and exceptional talent in business.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Charles T. Munger

“I want to tell people the great contribution I made to the success of byd I we got into it through lilu and and there was a little company that knocked off the Japanese cell phones and the chairman who's got a genius say I want to buy a bankrupt little crappy autoplay and we're going to the auto business from dead scratch when he's making cell phones little tiny nothing company and both Lilo and I started talking about it please don't do this dumb thing if you get your head handed until you're going to the old business little byd and so forth well last year they made more than two billion dollars in the auto business”

0.48

Gambling with modest amounts on a Super Bowl game is not particularly harmful, but crypto is far worse than even legalized gambling, and betting should always be done with a friend rather than with a bookie.

normativehigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Charlie Munger

“it's not as bad as crypto ship I I I I don't think there's much harm and betting a modest amount you can afford on a supermarket ball game that that strikes me as pretty you know I'm telling you if you do it with a friend and not with a bookie and so I I don't I don't have the same feeling”

0.48

There is still some old-fashioned capitalist virtue left in Daily Journal and Berkshire Hathaway and at BYD, but in most places everybody is trying to take what they need and rationalizing whether it's deserved or not, leading to widespread moral failure in capitalism.

normativehigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Charles T. Munger

“there is some of this old-fashioned capitalist virtue left in the Daily Journal and there's something left in Berkshire Hathaway and there's some left at byd but but most places everybody's trying to take what they need and just rationalizing whether it's deserved or not”

0.48

Munger finds American corporations with very good incentive systems and others that are too liberal and too narrowly designed, reflecting normal human variety; some corporations want to count stock-based compensation in a way that inflates reported earnings.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Charlie Munger

“I think you will find in American corporations very good incentive systems and others that are too liberal and others that are too narrowly and what else would you expect of human nature but a certain amount of variety and I I agree that some of this yeah and many a corporation everybody would vote to being allowed to have stock-based compensation you didn't count in Computing the earnings they just want any damn way of making the earnings appear higher”

0.48

Daily Journal's publishing business generated approximately $30 million in excess cash during its profitable heyday, which came from the foreclosure boom when the company had an information monopoly on appellate court decisions in California, but the internet destroyed this monopoly and circulation collapsed.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Charles T. Munger

“we made a lot of extra money out of the publishing business and it's heyday and that was about 30 million dollars and that was a all made in the Foreclosure boom and of course in the old days we had a information Monopoly on publishing the appellate Court's decisions daily and newsprint and the internet came along it destroyed our our position our circulation went way down”

0.47

Elon Musk is talented but peculiar and paradoxical—despite his genius, he faces formidable competition from companies like BYD, demonstrating that even genius-level entrepreneurs cannot guarantee business success in capitalism; Musk should not be bought or shorted but merely observed as unusual.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 2/4· Charlie Munger

“my policy and Elon Musk is that he's a very talented man but also could peculiar and so I I don't buy him and I don't sell them short I just say well he's a very unusual person”

0.47

Journal Technologies' business model of responding to RFPs (requests for proposals) from courts is intentionally slow and difficult, but this is actually an advantage because large tech competitors hate this kind of granular, bureaucratic work and prefer easier, higher-margin business, leaving Journal Technologies with few direct competitors.

causalhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Stephen Michael Jones

“it's a long slow slog where you deal with a lot of bureaucracies in response to rfps a request for proposals and it's just a very slow difficult business”

0.47

Munger doesn't have a big opinion about how well wealth should be distributed in the country and doesn't know the answer; he thinks a capitalistic system is needed for a productive economy and civilization advancement, though the government's distribution of wealth is a legitimate area of political disagreement.

normativehigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 0/4durability 4/4· Charlie Munger

“I I I don't have a big opinion about how well thought to be distributed in the country I think I don't know the answer I do think we need a capitalistic system if we want to have a productive economy that makes civilization advance”

0.45

Index funds' growing voting power is a serious issue because they control enormous amounts of capital; Vanguard has wisely retreated from trying to use index fund voting to reshape corporate and national politics, and Munger has some hope that Larry Fink (BlackRock) will follow.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 2/4· Charlie Munger

“because it's an enormous amount of power and for a while all these index funds got the feeling they were suddenly made god-like to clean up the world and but Vanguard has retreated from that policy and I think wisely so and I have some hope that Larry think will follow”

0.45

BYD's total manufacturing space for car production in China would amount to a large percentage of all the land in Manhattan Island, yet most Americans have never heard of BYD, indicating its enormous scale and concentration in Chinese market dominance rather than global brand recognition.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 2/4· Charlie Munger

“if you look at byd which no mostly y'all never heard of if you count all the manufacturing space they have in China to make cars it would it would amount to a big percentage of all the land in Manhattan Island and nobody ever heard of them”

0.44

China's reduced likelihood of invading Taiwan after witnessing Russia's difficulties in Ukraine makes Chinese investments more attractive, as geopolitical risk has decreased and Chinese companies remain cheaper relative to their quality compared to US companies.

causalhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 2/4· Charlie Munger

“I would argue that the chances in a big conversation from China have gone down not up because of what happened in the Ukraine I I think that the Chinese leader is a very smart practical person and it doesn't Russia went into the ukrainians that looked like a cakewalk I don't think Taiwan looks like such a cakewalk anymore I think it's off the table and sat on for a long long time and I think that helps the prospects of investors who invest in China”

0.43

Munger has deliberately avoided movie business investments his entire life—he doesn't like the unions, agents, lawyers, movie stars, or musicians in the industry, and fundamentally dislikes the culture; despite living near Paramount Studios, he has never made a movie business investment.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Charlie Munger

“I have avoided the movies like the plague as an investor all my life I've never made an investment in a movie business in any way shape better or form it always gives me the will it was I don't like the unions I don't like the crazy agents I don't like the goddamn crazy lawyers I don't like the crazy movie stars I don't like the people who sell dope to them musicians I mean everything about it is not my culture”

0.41

Munger obviously doesn't think people should have a gambling compulsion or bet against bad odds; the money you've lost in your life betting against odds should be modest (Munger claims only a few thousand dollars in his entire life).

normativehigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 0/4durability 3/4· Charles T. Munger

“I I I I don't have the same feeling I I I obviously don't think you should have a gambling compulsing door around begging against odds if you take all the money that I have bet against odds in my whole life I don't think it's more than a few thousand dollars”

0.40

A shareholder from China asked for advice on elderly family members during the pandemic; Munger did get COVID after being vaccinated but only had a tiny sniffle for about 10 minutes; his main health advice is to be cautious about falling by using walkers/wheelchairs rather than canes.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 0/4durability 2/4· Charlie Munger

“I did get covered but I got it after I was vaccinated and I had like a tiny sniffle for about 10 minutes and that was Mike Ovid but I tested positive during that time and and in terms of of the general idea of cautious adjustment I had so a lot of elderly friends who either died or had terrible injuries from Falls and so when I got old myself and it got time to use something to avoid falling down people tried to sell me on the cane but I noticed that my friends who used canes would fall down occasionally so I did I never used the goddamn cane instead I bought one of these modern Walkers and wherever I was worried about falling down I pushed my Walker I did that for six and a half years I never fell down once in six and a half years”

0.40

As an old person, Munger uses a wheelchair now but prefers this to being dead; he finds it instructive to compare himself to FDR, who ran the entire country from a wheelchair for 12 years, putting his own mobility challenges in perspective.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 0/4durability 2/4· Charlie Munger

“I step out of my bed these days and been sit down in my wheelchair so I am paying some price for old age but I prefer it to being dead and and whenever I feel sad maybe in a wheelchair I think well you know Roosevelt ran the whole damn country for 12 years in a wheelchair so I'm just trying to make this filter thing last as long as Roosevelt did it”

0.40

Taiwan Semiconductor Manufacturing Company (TSMC) is the strongest semiconductor company on Earth and has achieved something incredible, but Munger lacks expertise in semiconductors and doesn't feel confident about the industry despite respecting TSMC's execution.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 0/4durability 2/4· Charlie Munger

“I do think Taiwan semiconductor is the strongest selling conductor company on Earth so I I'm a I'm a big admirer of what they've achieved it's just incredible of what they've achieved it's just incredible of what they've achieved speaking of things you like better and by the way it may be a wonderful investment the fact that I don't like it because I'm an old man and I don't like learning new tricks that doesn't mean it isn't right for some younger person that understands it better than I do”

0.40

Berkshire's recent position in Occidental Petroleum and Chevron in the Permian Basin is likely to be a pretty good long-term holding because of the companies' strength and the value of the underlying resources.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 0/4durability 2/4· Charlie Munger

“having a big position in the Permian Basin through those two companies is likely to be a pretty pretty good long-term hold so I like that aspect of that position”

0.40

Both Occidental Petroleum and Chevron are admirable companies; Occidental in particular evolved from being 'a sleaze bag' run by Armand Hammer 30-40 years ago into a wonderful company through management changes.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 0/4durability 2/4· Charlie Munger

“I kind of admire both places a lot both accidental and Chevron are very admirable places and by the way oxy didn't start like that yeah if you go back 30 or 40 years Aki was on my crook and you know it it's a it's evolved into a wonderful place but it started as a sleaze bag running it 30 or 40 years ago a man named Armand Hammer”

0.40

Daily Journal's board composition reflects a Berkshire-like structure: three of five board members own zero shares and a fourth owns only 100 shares, but they are pretty damn smart and all rich, thinking like capitalists, though this represents a shift from the old guard when Garen and Munger were the two biggest shareholders who took no fees.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 0/4durability 2/4· Charlie Munger

“what happens is we used to have Garen and Munger and we were the two biggest shareholders and of course we'd been partners for years and years and we took no fees no no directors fees no expenses no nothing and so it was a very user-friendly Berkshire type place well Garen died finally at age 90 so and and so now we're down to one last survivor of the Old Guard and of course we need a certain number of new directors and our new directors are pretty damn smart and they're all rich by the way so it's still a very berkshire-like board a smart and Rich and and thinking like a capitalist”

0.40

Berkshire sold part of its BYD position about a year prior to this meeting at a much higher price than BYD's then-current price; the stock is worth more than the entire Mercedes Corporation market capitalization at 50x earnings, which is very expensive but justified given BYD's likely continued 50% auto sales growth.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 0/4durability 2/4· Charlie Munger

“we sold part of ours by the way years ago not years but about a year ago at a much higher price than the selling for now and uh no we're not a mini Berkshire we're not going to have a big correlation between us and what Berkshire does and you can you can understand why some people will sell Burgers byd stock at 50 times earnings at the current price of byd stock uh uh little byd is worth more than the entire Mercedes Corporation market capitalization so it's not a cheap stock on the other hand yeah it's a very remarkable company and by the way I want to tell people the great contribution I made to the success of byd I we got into it through lilu and and there was a little company that knocked off the Japanese cell phones and the chairman who's got a genius say I want to buy a bankrupt little crappy autoplay and we're going to the auto business from dead scratch when he's making cell phones little tiny nothing company and both Lilo and I started talking about it please don't do this dumb thing if you get your head handed until you're going to the old business little byd and so forth well last year they made more than two billion dollars in the auto business from that standing start at zero it's unheard of but Lee Lou tonight is there all the credit because we tried to get them we tried to talk about them doing what worked so well”

0.40

Berkshire's buyback program has bought back a substantial amount in recent years (Munger notes $3 billion in Q1 2022, slowing to $1 billion in Q2 and Q3); Munger doesn't scrutinize how they do it but is thoroughly satisfied with the overall buyback program despite the current tax proposal.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 0/4durability 2/4· Charles T. Munger

“I never pay any attention to how they do it they they're they're cautious and careful people and I but if you take the amount that's been bought back in the last three years it's a lot and I thoroughly approve what we're doing and I don't consider it all fair that we're being taxed we're doing something good for our own shareholders”

0.40

Warren Buffett and others including Munger tried to fix American healthcare through various initiatives but failed because the system is too entrenched; Munger's characterization is that 'the tapeworm won'—the parasitic interests prevailed over reform attempts.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 0/4durability 2/4· Charlie Munger

“somebody asked Warren what happened when their experiment with JP Morgan Chase and Amazon and so forth and they were going to change they improve the what was wrong with the American medicine and its cost and and when they gave that up as a total failure Warren just said the tapeworm won”

0.39

Daily Journal owns common stocks instead of government bonds because Munger expects inflation and believes it's preferable to own equities, which have pricing power and better inflation protection than fixed-income bonds.

causalhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 0/4durability 3/4· Charles T. Munger

“that's one of the reasons The Daily Journal owns Securities instead of government bonds Owens Common Stocks instead of government bonds”

0.39

Munger was early in recognizing that paying up for great businesses was obvious and rational; he identifies himself as someone who is 'good at doing obvious things' and recognized that owning great companies was preferable to buying cheap mediocre ones.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 0/4durability 3/4· Charlie Munger

“why do you think that you so early on were willing to to come up with this idea of paying up for for great businesses well because it's so obvious and I'm good at doing things that are obvious of course it was obvious if you wanted to have particular numbers all you got to do a great company you know I I recognize that greatness was good you know big deal Charlie Munger genius recognizes greatness is good of course greatness is good”

0.38

Rick Guerin was Munger's longtime friend and business partner for several decades; they met in 1961 both poor and struggling as young men, which created a bonding experience, and Munger misses him terribly after his death approximately one year before this meeting.

factualestablishednovelty 0/4durability 4/4· Charlie Munger

“he was just terrific as a person investor and I miss him terribly of course we were together for years and years and years and we were poor together and that creates a bonding when we met uh in 1961 we were both poor and struggling and Young so we had a long ride together and but all things end you know that's that's the same that's the nature of The Human Condition”

0.38

The BYD investment at $270,000 is worth approximately $8-9 billion today, representing Munger's best individual investment return outside of Berkshire; Munger has not made comparable investments multiple times, emphasizing the rarity of finding such exceptional opportunities.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 0/4durability 2/4· Charlie Munger

“I have never helped do anything in Berkshire that was as good as byd and I only did it once our our 270 000 investment there is worth about 8 billion now or maybe nine and that's a pretty good rate of return”

0.38

We will have waves of inflation interspersed with periods of deflation in the future, similar to pre-Volcker patterns; Volcker stepped in and dramatically raised interest rates to break the inflation cycle, and such cycles are likely to repeat.

forecasthigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 0/4durability 2/4· Charlie Munger

“well that's a very I have almost no exercise except when the Army Air corps made me do exercise I've done almost no exercise on purpose in my life if I enjoyed the activity like tennis I would exercise but for the first 99 years I've gotten by without doing any exercise at all and you're not planning on changing that anytime soon no no I I'm not changing it other people's mileage may vary yeah looking for one question that somebody wrote in because I I want to word it properly and it has to do with what you've just been talking about and find it there's a lot of questions in here uh oh here it is somebody said this came from adidi Gone in Australia what would the 100th day of your life look like and how would you want to spend it when you step out of bed in the morning well I step out of my bed these days and been sit down in my wheelchair so I am paying some price for old age but I prefer it to being dead and and whenever I feel sad maybe in a wheelchair I think well you know Roosevelt ran the whole damn country for 12 years in a wheelchair so I'm just trying to make this filter thing last as long as Roosevelt did it's a good plan I like it um somebody else wrote in this is Adam Mead and he said Charlie in your 1995 talk the psychology of misjudgment you listed senescence as a cause of misjudgment you said old people like me get pretty skilled without working on it at disguising age-related deterioration because social convention like clothing hides much decline you went on to say that such decline was inevitable he says you're my hero Charlie and I offer you this question with the utmost respect but feel it needs to be asked would 71 year old Charlie trust the judgment and mental capacity of 99 year old Charlie well there's no question about the fact that you lose some mental acuity as you get older but some people get Schroeder at adapting to their limitations and they do pretty well and so far I I've had plenty of decline but I'm pretty shrewd about the way I handle it and so far the results have not been that bad in my old age as evidence that's actually would be a different subject well I will point out to people we have not given you any of these questions in advance so you're taking blind questions for yeah that's all right yeah for a large stretch of time on this too uh okay how do I follow that up this one's another question this gets back to investing what we were just talking about a minute ago but Michael worked early writes in and says given the increasing rate environment what are the ramifications of moving away from a close to zero interest rate policy Warren and yourself if frequently spoken about Aesop and a bird in the hand is worth two in the bush to describe the essence of investment decision making so what do you do now that the interest rate environment is changing well there's no question about the fact that as the interest rates have gone up it's it's hostile to stock prices and but they should go up but we couldn't have kept them Forever at zero and and I just think it's just one more damn thing to adapt to and investment life is that there are there are headwinds and their Tailwinds and one of the headwinds is inflation and I think more inflation over the next 100 years is inevitable with given the nature of democratic politics politics in a democracy so I think we'll have more inflation that's one of the reasons The Daily Journal owns Securities instead of government bonds Owens Common Stocks instead of government bonds when you say the nature of democratic policies and I I forget exactly how you worded it are you talking about the Democratic party are you talking about democracism that was bigger than the Democrats did yeah all Democratic all politicians in a democracy tend to be in favor of printing the money and spending it and that will cause some inflation over time it may have played a few recessions too it may not be all bad but it will do more harm than good I think from this point forward okay on that point Ron uh tree rotola Ron tree rotola says should we may continue to maintain a debt limit the adjustment process seems to be a very simple and mechanical process however such a measure only seems to create an environment Rife with political jocking and sniping what's the purpose if we continue to budget beyond our means and then the bill comes due well if you take the history of democracy in the world and go back far enough it fails a lot and gets succeeded by dictatorships and all kinds of awful things and as a matter of fact the worst thing that happened to the human race in my lifetime was an advanced civilization like Germany was taken over by a dictator as awful lucido Hitler that happened as a consequence of a big worldwide depression it would never have happened if we hadn't had the big depression and once Hitler got in and that meant we were World War II was inevitable and that could have worked out a lot worse than it did for the people like the United States so the these things are quite important and and they're not going to be done perfectly in the future no more than they were done perfectly in the past so so of course you've got to expect a certain amount of future trouble in the world and your government's going to do some things that aren't exactly right on the other hand I would argue that the U.S government did some things magnificently right I have said on many an occasion that if the thing that makes me proudest of my own government is the way we handle the sequel to World War II instead of punishing the Germans and the Japanese we made them into some of our best friends on earth now that was a stunt and it was to the credit of our country that that was done and it was done a bipartisan basis and I think we can all be proud of that that was a smart thing to do it took some generosity we had to give up some of our money to help them rebuild and it was it was it was a credit to our species that we behaved that well on that occasion and I don't think our future Behavior will lack similar episodes of some kind black similar episodes something's very right and something's very wrong that's our that's the way it happens yeah that's very churchillesque right they'll try everything all the wrong wrong things until we do the right thing no I would I will keep doing both wrong and right as far ahead as you can see um Charlie Al pitten writes in from Chicago and wants to know if you think we might have on and off waves of inflation like we did prior to when volcker stepped in at the Fed of course it will happen some in the future yes I think we'll have some of that in the future do you think we'll have it immediately right now with what the Jay pal is dealing with I don't I don't I don't I I don't regard myself I think I'm pretty good at long run expectations but I don't think I'm going to short-term wobbles I don't know the famous idea is what's going to happen short term”

0.37

Daily Journal started experimenting with AI in the summer for certain types of writing and article production and is tracking the impact closely; for complex work it is a long way off, but for routine activities, AI will likely be disruptive over a relatively short time horizon, similar to how technology severely disrupted Daily Journal's publishing business.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 0/4durability 1/4· Stephen Michael Jones

“through the lens of Daily Journal Corporation AI is something that we started experimenting with in the summer in the summer for certain types of writing of certain types of Articles that's something we're certainly tracking very closely I think in terms of complex work I think it's a it's a long way off uh but for many types of activities especially routine things I I think we'll I think it'll be fascinating to see how disruptive it is over a relatively short time Horizon for for many types of work and and activities”

0.35

Munger does not buy or sell Daily Journal stock and believes the valuation is not crazy given what everything else is selling for these days, rejecting the notion that it is at foolishly high valuations due to some crazy mystique.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 0/4durability 2/4· Charlie Munger

“I don't buy it and I don't sell it so that's what the mongers have been doing you know what we now have audio it's not a crazy evaluation considering what everything else is selling for these days so have no feeling that it's almost foolishly high on some crazy Mystique”

0.35

Berkshire previously held a position in Exxon and then exited fairly quickly; the company thought it was a good alternative to cash at the time, but it was not intended as a long-term holding.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 0/4durability 2/4· Charles T. Munger

“Berkshire previously took a position in Exxon and then exited fairly quickly if I recall correctly he says I believe you had stated that Berkshire thought it was a good alternative to cash at the time”

0.35

Stephen Michael Jones believes the parallels between his former software company (which he built with no background in publishing) and Journal Technologies are remarkable, and he expects he can add value and has clarity on the company's long-term approach later this year.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 0/4durability 2/4· Stephen Michael Jones

“I found it and helped grow a geography software company with no background in publishing or the legal and Court sector and what I can say now is that the parallels between the software company I built and journal technology is our are remarkable and I believe I can add value I like the business and the potential for it so I expect we'll have Clarity on our long-term approach sometime later this year”

0.35

Journal Technologies can turn out similar to BYD—not as fast, not as great, but with similar potential if the founder maintains the right mindset and the company executes well in the court automation market.

forecasthigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 0/4durability 2/4· Charlie Munger

“well it won't be as fast that I guarantee you and I won't be as great I can also all rightly guarantee that”

0.27

President Biden said that ~90% of executives are paid at least in part with stock compensation, and the best way for executives to increase their own compensation is to buy back shares; this helps executives and shareholders but hurts employees and other constituents.

factualestablishednovelty 0/4durability 1/4· Charlie Munger

“the president laid out the case today I think he said something like north of 90 percent of executives are paid with stock compensation at least in part he said maybe this was yesterday that he said this he said that that's not fair the best way to Goose your own compensation is to buy back your share so it helps the executives it helps the share the shareholders but it doesn't help the employees or other constituents”

0.22

Private equity and Berkshire cannot predict which deals will work out; 3G Capital has had some successful deals but also recent failures that haven't worked as well as ideal—'welcome to human life' where outcomes are uncertain.

factualspeaker onlynovelty 0/4durability 2/4· Charlie Munger

“like every other human being on Earth some deals work out better than others for 3G and they would love to have a way of going back and turning all their bad deals into good deals Berkshire would like to have the same option if we don't get it either averaged out through 3G did pretty well but recently there they've had some their approach hasn't worked as well in recent years is it as would be ideal again welcome to human life it isn't so damned easy”

0.20

Tough love is an old saying; 'dumb as for dumbest forever dumb' means that some people can't be improved and must be left behind rather than slowing down the institution for their sake.

factualspeaker onlynovelty 0/4durability 3/4· Charlie Munger

“tough love it's an old saying dumb as for dumbest forever dumb”

0.20

Munger acknowledges he has no suggestion for how to fix compensation problems in places where they are excessive; it's a difficult issue that he can't solve.

factualspeaker onlynovelty 0/4durability 3/4· Charles T. Munger

“and but I haven't any I have no suggestion as to how to fix the places where it's successive it's a difficult issue really difficult”

0.19

Munger has made only three short sales in his entire career, all over 30 years ago—two stock trades that netted one profit and one loss (canceling out), and one currency bet that made $1 million but was irritating and not worth repeating due to margin calls and anxiety.

factualspeaker onlynovelty 0/4durability 2/4· Charlie Munger

“I don't short I that isn't great I have made three short sales in my entire life and they're all more than 30 years ago and and and one was a currency and and there were two stock trades in the two stock trades I'm I made a big profit on one and made a big loss on the other and they canceled out and I and my currency bet I made a million dollars but it was a very irritating way to make a million dollars”

0.19

Elon Musk shares Munger's view that shrinking population is a bigger threat to humanity than population growth, which Munger partially agrees with, characterizing Musk as 'a smart man sometimes' but acknowledging that even smart people sometimes get it wrong like everyone else.

factualspeaker onlynovelty 0/4durability 2/4· Charlie Munger

“the same camp with Elon Musk he's made some of the same arguments that it's really shrinking population that's a bigger threat to humanity those I said he's a smart man sometimes sometimes like all the rest of us”

0.17

Berkshire does not take guidance from index funds on how the company should behave; Munger is not interested in their views on Berkshire's strategic direction.

factualspeaker onlynovelty 0/4durability 2/4· Charlie Munger

“to the extent they asked Berkshire to do this or that I wish they'd stop ask Marsha to do what to oh to follow their their guidance I'm just not interested in their views as to how Berkshire should behave”

0.17

Top professors at great law schools are remarkably smart and talented, showing that academia at the top is quite competitive; Munger spoke with a law professor at a prestigious institution via Zoom who was exceptionally impressive.

factualspeaker onlynovelty 0/4durability 2/4· Charlie Munger

“I talked yesterday on Zoom with a law professor at a great place oh my God this is an admirable guy and he's just so goddamn smart and balances incredible but he's a very senior law teacher one of the great law schools of the world so I would expect them to be pretty good but he was more than pretty good he was awesome and I thought my God Academia is quite competitive”

0.17

Munger regards Jay Powell as about as good as anyone has any right to expect; Powell is honorable, intelligent, and doing his best with an extremely difficult job; Munger doesn't know anyone else who would do significantly better.

factualspeaker onlynovelty 0/4durability 2/4· Charlie Munger

“I'll tell you the way I feel about Jay Paul is that I feel he's about as good as we have any right to expect I think he's honorable and intelligent and doing the best he can and I have no feeling that I know a lot of people who do it a lot better”

0.17

A Missouri court awarded $5.2 million in compensation for an STD infection contracted in a Geico-insured vehicle, which Munger considers a potentially outrageous verdict that illustrates the inevitable problem of occasional crazy verdicts in the legal system that only appellate courts can address.

factualspeaker onlynovelty 0/4durability 2/4· Charlie Munger

“a Missouri court awarded a victim 5.2 million dollars in compensation from Berkshire subsidiary Geico after a woman was infected with an STD in a car that was insured by Geico auto insurance”

0.17

Munger has gotten by without exercise his entire 99-year life except for mandatory military exercise, and is not planning to start now; others' mileage may vary, but he hasn't found exercise necessary for longevity.

factualspeaker onlynovelty 0/4durability 2/4· Charlie Munger

“I have almost no exercise except when the Army Air corps made me do exercise I've done almost no exercise on purpose in my life if I enjoyed the activity like tennis I would exercise but for the first 99 years I've gotten by without doing any exercise at all and you're not planning on changing that anytime soon no no I'm not changing it”

0.17

Munger would prefer investing in Los Angeles right next to his house for convenience, but he can't find that many investments there, so he's investing in China and other foreign countries for better opportunities.

factualspeaker onlynovelty 0/4durability 2/4· Charles T. Munger

“it's like we prefer being in some foreign country of course I'd rather be in Los Angeles right next to my house you know it'll be more convenient but I can't find that many Investments you know right next to my house”

0.17

While Munger disagrees vehemently with the buyback tax (though not as vehemently as his crypto stance), he is a Republican but sometimes votes for Democrats; the buyback tax is a big mistake but not as bad as cryptocurrency.

factualspeaker onlynovelty 0/4durability 2/4· Charlie Munger

“I'm not vehement because it's not as bad as cryptocurrency it's a forgivable error but yes I I disagree strongly I think it's a big mistake to to adopt that policy but you know I'm a republican I I sometimes vote for Democrats but I am a Republican”

0.13

The question that ChatGPT generated asking about the most challenging bias to overcome was a good question, suggesting the AI is capable of formulating decent queries, even if Munger regards cryptocurrency and other aspects of AI as problematic.

factualspeaker onlynovelty 0/4durability 1/4· Becky Quick

“Peter Ferlin wrote In from Oakville Ontario and he had a question that he asked he asked chat GPT to come up with a question to ask you Charlie and here's what chat GPT came up with Mr Munger you've spoken about the importance of avoiding mental biases and decision making in your experience what's the most challenging bias to overcome”