What this covers

The talk, given to the Oxford Mises Society, is largely a political and historical argument rather than a purely climatological one. Monckton, a former adviser to Margaret Thatcher, starts with the 1970s and 1980s. He says Soviet intelligence targeted British energy supply through union strikes, which he credits with bringing down Edward Heath's government, and that it funded and trained Arthur Scargill for the 1984 miners' strike. He then traces what he calls Disinformation as Strategic Warfare to a KGB directorate and to the defector Ion Mihai Pacepa, who he says described the environmental movement as the next tool once union tactics failed. These are his claims, and several are contested or fringe. He also sketches Thatcher's grounding in Mises and Hayek, and a brief digression on Putin's rise.

The scientific and economic sections cover a lot of ground. Monckton attacks the 97% consensus figure by going through the data behind Cook et al., and he accuses the IPCC of repeatedly lowering its sea-level projections. He argues that climate deaths have fallen, that Susan Crockford's counts show polar bear numbers rising, and that satellite data show CO2 greening, including in the Sahel. On the economics, he cites McKinsey's $275 trillion capital estimate for Net Zero by 2050. He argues that wind and solar need full thermal backup and that Western industry is being priced out. He points to a Bremen blast furnace closure, and says that 70% of energy growth comes from nations exempt under the Paris treaty. The section on China's lithium dominance and its railway debt is the most geopolitical turn in the economic discussion.

Sharpest takeaway

Lord Monckton argues that net-zero climate policies are economically irrational and scientifically fraudulent, driven by communist disinformation rather than genuine environmental concern, and that even global compliance would abate less than 0.4°C of warming at costs exceeding $400 trillion.

  • The 97% scientific consensus claim is fabricated; only 0.3% of papers actually endorse the catastrophic warming hypothesis
  • Corrected climate physics shows equilibrium climate sensitivity is ~1.1°C per doubling of CO2, not 3-4°C as IPCC models claim
  • Even if the entire world achieved net-zero by 2050, it would abate only 0.375°C of warming at a cost of $400-800 trillion ($1-5 millionths of a degree per billion spent)

The claims · ranked59 claims · weighted by value

This asset isn't compiled yet

You're seeing its claims, ranked. Compile it to build the argument threads, weight them, and check each claim against your library — the full view.

0.80

The Sicilian scientist Al-Ghazali (11th-century Iraq) established the principle that the seeker of truth must subject claims to 'scrutiny, investigation, verification and checking' rather than accepting consensus; this was the foundation of the scientific method, which climate alarmism explicitly rejects.

definitionhigh valueestablishednovelty 2/4durability 4/4· Christopher Monckton, Viscount Monckton of Brenchley

“al-hisa the Newton of the east in 11th century Iraq who wrote that the Seeker after truth and that is what he called a scientist a Seeker after truth not a peddler or reciter of propaganda but a Seeker after truth does not put his faith in any mere consensus however widespread however venerable however apparently plausible instead he subjects what he has learned to it of it to scrutiny and investigation and verification and checking and checking and checking again”

0.80

In 1945, following Hitler's defeat, the MGB (predecessor of the KGB) captured Nazi records from Joseph Goebbels' ministry and founded a new KGB directorate called the Dis-Information Directorate whose primary job was to trash the personal reputations of Western anti-communist figures.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 2/4durability 4/4· Lord Christopher Monckton

“in 1945 the Allies hung back from invading the center of Berlin... the MGB as it then was the predecessor of the KGB got the lot and they were fascinated how do we know because within one month they had founded a new division or as they call it a directorate of the KGB or the MGB as it then was it was to become the KGB within a year or two and that directorate was called the Des information directorate”

0.80

Monckton's team disclosed Scargill's Moscow training to individual miners through The Times newspaper and a wealthy businessman who drove 29,000 miles visiting mines to brief nearly 100,000 miners individually; this led to formation of the National Working Miners Committee which organized the return to work ballot.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 2/4durability 4/4· Lord Christopher Monckton

“so we put it in the times and I then recruited a friend of the Prime Minister who was a very wealthy businessman who could afford to take a year off and in his new Mercedes he drove 29 000 miles that year visited every pit in Britain from Kent up to Scotland and across to Wales and individually spoke to as many miners as he could and told them what he has but what I have just told you and he gave them the cutting from the times”

0.78

The 2013 Environmental Research Letters paper by Cook et al. claimed 97.1% of 11,944 climate science papers endorsed anthropogenic global warming, but when the authors' own data file was examined, only 65 papers (0.5%) were listed as explicitly endorsing the consensus, and upon reading all 65 papers, only 41 (0.3%) actually endorsed even the mild consensus proposition that recent warming was mostly man-made.

factualhigh valuecontestednovelty 3/4durability 4/4· Lord Christopher Monckton

“the authors of the original paper from Australia had themselves listed only 65 papers or 0.5 percent of the original 11944 as having explicitly endorsed the consensus position... we then read all 64 of those papers or 65 and we found that only 41 or 0.3 percent not 97.1 percent not 0.3 percent had actually endorsed even that milk test consensus proposition that global warming of recent decades was mostly man-made”

0.73

Soviet intelligence transferred approximately $20 million to the National Union of Mineworkers through an Eastern European embassy to fund the 1984 miners' strike, channeling money through a pipeline that Pacepa had revealed to British intelligence.

factualhigh valuecontestednovelty 3/4durability 3/4· Lord Christopher Monckton

“a certain Eastern European Embassy still then under the control of Moscow was the the vehicle the pipeline through which money 20 million of it that we could trace came to the miners to fund the strike”

0.72

In the 1960s, the Soviet Union deliberately targeted British energy supplies through communist-led trade union strikes in order to destabilize the Western economy, eventually bringing down Edward Heath's government in 1974 through miners' strikes.

factualhigh valuecontestednovelty 2/4durability 4/4· Lord Christopher Monckton

“they captured the leaderships but not significantly the memberships of the trade unions and they concentrated chiefly on Britain because of our links with America the Commonwealth and Europe... they began organizing a series of strikes led by communist Trade union leaders... Edward Heath's government fell in 1974 as a direct result of Soviet interference in our politics”

0.69

Margaret Thatcher was 'the best economically prepared prime minister' Britain had ever had because she had read and annotated hundreds of economics books by von Mises, Hayek, and other free-market economists, and her government's policies reflected this training in promoting free markets over state management.

normativehigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Christopher Monckton, Viscount Monckton of Brenchley

“seeing how intensely Margaret Thatcher had read every line of every book and had marked it and learned it and inwardly digested it she was probably the best economically prepared prime minister we had ever had and it showed in the economic performance of the country which had been languishing near the bottom of the Western countries league and ended up very near the top”

0.68

Climate-related deaths have plummeted over recent decades despite the world population tripling, while general natural disaster deaths from earthquakes, tsunamis, and volcanoes have remained constant, demonstrating that warmer weather is not catastrophic but beneficial for human life.

causalhigh valuecontestednovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Lord Christopher Monckton

“the annual climate-related deaths it has plummeted and it's a tiny tiny fraction that little star at the right hand end in blue that's the 2020 figure that's the most recent figure those data data sets will produce”

0.68

Satellite data measuring chlorophyll fluorescence shows a staggering 15-30% increase in net primary productivity of plants and trees over the last 30-40 years, despite mainstream media reports of deforestation and destruction of green biomass.

factualhigh valuecontestednovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Lord Christopher Monckton

“it's very nearly 30 percent in some authorities 15 I think is the kind of average in most authorities in just the last 30 or 40 years in the net primary productivity of plants and trees which means how much green biomass is there now”

0.68

As far back as 1981, Nicholson et al. reported that the total land area of the Southern Sahara (the Sahel) had returned to vegetation that had last been present 7,000 years ago, covering an area equivalent to 300,000 square kilometers, demonstrating that CO2 fertilization is reversing desertification.

factualhigh valuecontestednovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Lord Christopher Monckton

“as far back as 1981 Nicholson etel reported that the total land area of the Southern Sahara the Sahel which had returned to the vegetation that had last been there seven thousand years ago you're too young to remember but at that time there was vegetation right across what is now the Sahara and that has now come back on an area equivalent to 300 000 square kilometers”

0.68

Dr. Susan Crockford's count of polar bears using flying, satellite imagery, and tagging methods shows there are now approximately 2.5 times as many polar bears as in 1960, and roughly 7 times as many as in the 1940s, contradicting the narrative of polar bear endangerment.

factualhigh valuecontestednovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Lord Christopher Monckton

“Dr Susan crockford of the University of Victoria decided to go and count them as best she could using a variety of methods from flying over it to satellite imagery to tagging polar bears to see where they went and then following them to find the groups they were with and she is probably the world's ranking expert on this and her conclusion is that there are now something like two and a half times as many polar bears there's some uncertainty but it's certainly a lot more than there were in 1960 and seven times approximately as many as there were in the 1940s”

0.68

The IPCC has repeatedly and progressively downward-adjusted its sea level rise predictions over time, and the late Tom Weismuller's meticulous analysis accounting for isostatic recovery found sea level rising at only approximately 1 millimeter per decade globally.

factualhigh valuecontestednovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Lord Christopher Monckton

“here are what they have had to do to adjust their sea level predictions one of the points you raised sir they have had to relentlessly bring them down and down and down and down”

0.68

The Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change was founded by 'a former Canadian oil magnate who was a communist and decided to make his home in communist China' and who persuaded the UN to establish it, placing its founding under communist influence.

factualhigh valuecontestednovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Lord Christopher Monckton

“ipcc ipicac the intergovernmental panel on climate change founded by a former Canadian oil magnate who was a communist and decided to make his home in communist China from where he persuaded the UN to establish the intergovernmental panel on climate change”

0.66

Between 2000-2003, Putin conducted a 'silent coup' against Boris Yeltsin, offering him a choice between signing power over to Putin or facing imprisonment, establishing the current authoritarian system in Russia.

factualhigh valuecontestednovelty 1/4durability 4/4· Lord Christopher Monckton

“in 2000 Putin mounted a silent coup against his predecessor Boris Yeltsin who went away on holiday and came back and was arrested was taken to Putin who said sign this document transferring all power to me and I will let you go to your data and drink yourself to death if you don't sign it you'll go straight to the lobby anchor and you can bring yourself to death there that's the choice so Yeltsin fumbled for his pen and signed”

0.64

Lieutenant General Ion Mihai Pacepa, who had been the head of the KGB Dis-Information Directorate for 32 years starting in 1945, defected to the West in 1978, revealing that the Soviets planned to use the environmental movement as a means of destabilizing Western economies after trade union tactics failed.

factualhigh valuefringenovelty 2/4durability 4/4· Lord Christopher Monckton

“the person who had 32 years previously in 1945 been appointed by the MGB as the head of the then new disinformation directorate lieutenant general eon mihai pachepa who had formerly been the head of the security the dreaded secret police in charge of Romania suddenly woke up one day and realized that everything he was doing was morally wrong... he suddenly realized he woke up when I say I'm not doing this and so he to our astonishment approached our intelligence services and said um can I please defect”

0.64

In 1979, Arthur Scargill sailed on a Polish freighter from Tilbury to Leningrad, took a train to Moscow, attended the Patrice Lumumba University of terrorism for 3 weeks, then the Lenin Institute for 5 months where top terrorist leaders were trained, and returned in December 1979.

factualhigh valuefringenovelty 2/4durability 4/4· Lord Christopher Monckton

“in late 1979 he sailed on a Polish freighter from Tilbury to what was still then Leningrad he took a Serial train from there like Lenin before him was met by the Communists in Moscow like Lenin before him and was taken first to the Patrice lumumba University of terrorism where he spent three weeks his handlers realized he was a cut above your typical sort of blow yourself up terrorist grunt so they transferred him to where the Jerry Adams is and the yes Arafat and the Really top terrorist leaders were trained that was the Lenin Institute and he spent five months there and then in December of 1979 he took an aeroflot plane to Paris”

0.64

McKinsey and Company estimated the capital expenditure alone for global Net Zero by 2050 at $275 trillion, equivalent to half of all global corporate profits, and correcting for current account costs brings the total to approximately $400-800 trillion.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 2/4· Lord Christopher Monckton

“McKinsey and Company is the world's leading consultancy firm and I used to go to them when I was at 10 Downing Street to ask about questions of this kind and they always gave me proper data and properly researched answers and they've produced a report about a couple years ago saying that the cost of the whole world just in capital expenditure alone that's what spending on physical assets means is 275 trillion dollars to go to Global Net Zero”

0.63

When global warming emerged as a climate issue, Pacepa contacted Monckton again to say the Soviets recognized it as exploitable and redirected the environmental movement leadership—which Pacepa claimed were 'very largely communist'—to falsely claim warming is disastrous and exclusively the West's fault, requiring Western shutdown and reparations.

factualhigh valuefringenovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Lord Christopher Monckton

“when global warming came along again pachepo got in touch he said well they've seen Hansen's paper they've realized this is exploitable and they're now going to redirect the environmental movement via the leaderships of it who are very largely communist and I've met several of them and they are and they are going to pretend that global warming is a disaster and it's all the West's fault exclusively and therefore the West must be shut down in order to and must pay reparations as Denmark is now doing as of last week for its sins of emission in the past”

0.62

China has accumulated unsustainable debt funding high-speed railway networks whose ticket revenue doesn't even cover debt interest, so China has been buying lithium deposits globally and now controls 90% of lithium carbonate and lithium hydroxide extraction and supply.

factualhigh valuecontestednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Lord Christopher Monckton

“the entire annual ticket revenue for the entire Chinese Rapid Transit Railway network does not even meet the interest payment on the debt that China accumulated in order to build that Network... they've been quietly going around the world buying up pretty well all the deposits of lithium they can get their hands on they now control 90 percent of all lithium carbonate and lithium hydroxide extraction and Supply throughout the world”

0.62

Arsenal Mittal was forced to close a blast furnace in Bremen and a direct reduction plant in Hamburg due to tenfold increases in gas and electricity prices caused by climate policy that eliminated competing power sources, forcing reliance on expensive Siberian gas.

factualhigh valuecontestednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Lord Christopher Monckton

“Arsenal mittal whose chairman Lakshmi mittal will be listening to my talk next week with more than usual interest has had to close a blast furnace in Bremen for plate steel and his direct reduction plant at Hamburg because they can't afford the tenfold increase in gas and electricity prices which of course arises chiefly from the global warming policies”

0.62

Wind and solar power are not real additions to the grid but require 100% thermal backup (coal, gas, nuclear) because wind and sun are intermittent, so every MW of installed wind/solar must be matched by running thermal capacity in reserve, making 'renewables' a net cost with no emissions reduction.

causalhigh valuecontestednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Christopher Monckton, Viscount Monckton of Brenchley

“when the wind goes down and the sun goes down and any sailor in the room will know that those two tend to happen most evenings then you have to rely upon thermal generation for a hundred percent of your power so every time you add windmills or solar panels to the grid it is not necessary to the grid it is simply a feel-good factor for those who think that they're being green but the crippling cost is only now becoming apparent”

0.62

Western governments have allowed themselves to be 'inveigled into' committing 'economic harakiri' through climate policies that will destroy their competitiveness while developing nations continue fossil fuel expansion.

causalhigh valuecontestednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Lord Christopher Monckton

“we're going to have to go back to 1945 and this is going to be 10 minutes of history and then we're going to take questions in 1945 the Allies... it's not a question of saying we have to go onto a wall footing shut down all the economies of the West and still let the rest of the world go on burning coal and so forth in the hope that somehow that would save the planet”

0.61

Seventy percent of primary net energy growth in recent years has come from nations (China, India, other developing countries) who are entirely exempt from emissions obligations under the Paris climate treaty, making Western unilateral climate action futile.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Lord Christopher Monckton

“70 percent of primary of contribution to primary net energy growth in recent years have come from Nations who because of the way the Paris and related climate treaties are drafted are entirely exempt from any obligation legal moral or other to do anything whatsoever to Abate their emissions”

0.61

Twenty-six UN climate conferences have produced zero reduction in CO2 emissions or fossil fuel consumption; all fossil fuel consumption (coal, natural gas, oil) has increased steadily over the last 30 years despite climate policy efforts and trillions spent.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Lord Christopher Monckton

“we've had Now 26 conferences of the state's parties to the United Nations framework convention on climate change the last one was in Glasgow last year and they have been plotted by Jennifer Morrissey here on a graph showing the change in CO2 concentration over the same period all those talks all that chattering all those various elaborate promises all those trillions squandered and there is absolutely no flicker of a downturn in the CO2 trend”

0.61

James Hansen's 1984 prediction of 3-4°C of warming per doubling of CO2 due to feedback response is a priori nearly impossible and fantastically implausible, and current CMIP6 models predicting 3.9°C are internally self-consistent but inconsistent with real-world observations.

causalhigh valuecontestednovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Lord Christopher Monckton

“James Hansen who in 1984 an appropriate year concluded that there would be three or four times as much final warming for every one degree of warming from a doubling of CO2 and the reason why you get the extra warming is what's called feedback response... that is a priori very nearly impossible and it's certainly fantastically implausible”

0.61

Global cereal crop yields have increased dramatically over 60 years from roughly the same land area due to mechanization, artificial fertilization, and CO2 fertilization, with CO2 contributing to both the primary productivity of plants and drought-proofing them through reduced stomatal density.

causalhigh valuecontestednovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Lord Christopher Monckton

“CO2 is essential to photosynthesis but here co2's increase is a contributor to the increase in productivity which arises for instance from mechanization from fertilization using artificial fertilizers but also to some degree from the additional CO2 in the atmosphere”

0.60

The reason climate science and policy communities fail to ask basic cost-benefit questions about net-zero is intentional—they know that asking them would expose the absurd cost-per-degree figures and destroy political support for climate policies.

causalhigh valuefringenovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Lord Christopher Monckton

“if a kid knows to ask that question and if the entire academic Community worldwide is not asking that question and they're not asking it because if they did they'd get this answer this or thereby it's not going to be much different from this the question is why are they not asking this question and there's a reason for that and I'll tell you why later”

0.60

Putin's invasion of Ukraine is motivated by desire to raise commodity prices (nickel, chromium, cobalt, lithium, grain) which Russia supplies, not territorial conquest, as evidenced by the massive increases in commodity prices and Russia's economic windfall.

causalhigh valuefringenovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Lord Christopher Monckton

“do you think for a single moment Putin cares about Ukraine he doesn't want Ukraine he wants the prices of the Commodities that he sells the nickel the chromium the Cobalt the lithium that goes into every electric Buggy's battery and all the grain that everybody needs 15 of that comes from Russia 10 from Ukraine he wanted those prices to go up”

0.60

Queensland police investigated the Cook et al. 2013 consensus paper and concluded that a deception had occurred, but could not prosecute because the lead author had left Australia; police also stated they would have found it difficult to quantify the damage done to people's livelihoods from the belief in a non-existent scientific consensus.

factualhigh valuefringenovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Christopher Monckton, Viscount Monckton of Brenchley

“a citizen of Queensland was deeply upset when he saw Lee gates at Al and realized what cook at Al had done so he went to Queensland police and he swore out a complaint... the Queensland police investigated and they reported back to that citizen that a deception had occurred but the social scientist concern who'd written this paper had by then left Australia and so there was nothing they could do they also said they would have found it difficult to quantify the sheer magnitude of the Damage Done to people's pockets”

0.60

Denying Africa access to coal-fired power stations in the name of climate policy is a form of neo-colonialism that perpetuates poverty and prevents the literacy and intelligence improvements that accompany electrification and economic development.

normativehigh valuecontestednovelty 1/4durability 4/4· Christopher Monckton, Viscount Monckton of Brenchley

“it's all very well for us in the prosperous surroundings of an Oxford College to think that the mere workers and shopkeepers of our nation of shopkeepers don't matter and if they're going to be poor well that's tough luck because we'll be all right and that really is the approach of the greens”

0.60

Freedom of speech and thought are being systematically suppressed at universities and in mainstream media through 'psychological warfare' campaigns pursued over decades by authoritarian regimes, preventing the academic discussion necessary for proper scientific debate.

normativehigh valuecontestednovelty 1/4durability 4/4· Christopher Monckton, Viscount Monckton of Brenchley

“through the most ruthless well-organized and unfortunately successful campaign of psychological warfare over a period of decades that has ever been waged against the West Western governments have tumbled into this stupidity and have not asked the very Elementary questions”

0.59

Climatologists fail to account for the fact that the sun is shining when calculating system gain factors; feedback responses at any given moment respond equally to all components in the reference temperature including solar forcing, not just to CO2 perturbation, which reduces the system gain factor from 3.6 to 1.077.

causalhigh valuefringenovelty 3/4durability 3/4· Lord Christopher Monckton

“the Sun was shining I sometimes think that all climatologists must be Scottish because they hadn't realized the sun is shining and therefore the vast majority of the feedback response at any given moment in the climate is feedback response to the fact that the sun is shining so you have to correct that equate Hanson didn't know this and I have had huge arguments with numerous climatologists they do not understand this but I have several professors of control theory on my team and they tell me that this is correct”

0.58

Western governments have tumbled into climate policy stupidity through decades of ruthless, well-organized psychological warfare—a communist campaign now called 'woke' because the word 'communist' polls negatively, but ultimately the same resurgent totalitarian ideology.

factualhigh valuefringenovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Lord Christopher Monckton

“through the most ruthless well-organized and unfortunately successful campaign of psychological warfare over a period of decades that has ever been waged against the West Western governments have tumbled into this stupidity... this problem of resurgent but invisible communism it now calls itself woke because they know the word communist poles negatively but it won't be long before even the word Communists won't Pearl negatively anymore as the Western economies implode”

0.57

Life expectancy in Africa is 65 years with average IQ two standard deviations below global average (~70); in Europe, life expectancy is 80 with average IQ ~100; however, African immigrants to the West show rapid IQ increase (already at 85, one standard deviation below) due to better nutrition and living conditions, suggesting the gap is environmental, not genetic.

factualhigh valuecontestednovelty 1/4durability 2/4· Christopher Monckton, Viscount Monckton of Brenchley

“Europeans live 80 years and we have a global average IQ it's about a hundred Africans live 65 years and their IQ on average is two standard deviations below ours but if they come to the West then already there's a process which is fascinating the epidemiological statisticians in this and the psychologists gradually the Africans who come here their IQ goes up it's already at 85 one standard deviation below us”

0.57

Han Chinese average IQ is one standard deviation above the global average (~110); this was also the cognitive advantage of Homo sapiens over Homo neanderthalensis, making intelligence the primary predictor of long-term geopolitical dominance.

factualhigh valuecontestednovelty 1/4durability 2/4· Christopher Monckton, Viscount Monckton of Brenchley

“the average intelligence of anyone from China particularly if they are Han Chinese is one standard deviation above ours and if you go back in the history of intelligence to the time when Homo neanderthalensis was interbreeding with homo sapiens Homo sapiens for physiological reasons had an advantage of one standard deviation in intelligence over Homo neanderthalensis and look what happened to Homo neanderthalensis”

0.57

Dr. Susan Crockford was dismissed from the University of Victoria for reporting that polar bears are actually thriving, similar to how Dr. Peter Ridd was pushed out of an Australian university for stating the Great Barrier Reef is doing fine, demonstrating institutional suppression of climate dissent.

factualhigh valuefringenovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Lord Christopher Monckton

“the University of Victoria dismissed her because her result was inconsistent with the Communist party line on the climate that also happened to Dr Peter ridd when he was chucked out of one of the universities in the antipodes because he had he was one of the world's greatest experts on the Great Barrier Reef and he said actually it's doing fine”

0.56

Monckton's team had to decide whether to reveal classified information about Scargill's Moscow training to the miners to prevent them from striking, risking exposure of British agents, or to expose the agents and protect national security by informing miners of Scargill's Soviet control; they chose the latter.

causalhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 4/4· Lord Christopher Monckton

“we had to make sure that the miners knew all that I have just told you because of course that was very highly classified information at the time so we had to decide do we let the miners know this in which case the Russians will know we know it and our agents who told us this will be at risk or do we get rid of I'm not going to tell you how many but it was quite a lot of Agents get them out which you know was disruptive to our intelligence gathering behind the Iron Curtain but we had to do it and we decided in the end that it was necessary”

0.56

Scientific inquiry requires asking elementary questions rationally, as exemplified by a child asking how many candy canes he can afford with his money, yet the academic community worldwide fails to ask the basic cost-benefit question about climate policies.

normativehigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 4/4· Lord Christopher Monckton

“a small boy going into a Swedish shop standing outside and seeing candy canes in the window he asks the same questions we have how many candy canes do I want do I want them anyway if I do want them how many has he got and how many can I get with this money and he goes in and puts his sticky coins on the counter and says gee Miss how many candy canes can I get for this now if a kid knows to ask that question and if the entire academic Community worldwide is not asking that question”

0.56

The KGB initially did not detect the strategic importance of Dinorwig load equalization station because Thatcher's government advertised it publicly through Pearl and Dean cinema adverts before films, which made the Soviets think it was harmless rather than strategically crucial for breaking the miners' strike.

causalhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 4/4· Lord Christopher Monckton

“so the Riddler committee... decided to advertise it and there were adverts before the film in each movie and there was an outfit called Pearl and Dean and those of you who was ancient to me will remember the ghastly jingle at the beginning of the pearlandine adverts and there was a whole pearlandine advert devoted to the building of this load Equalization station we didn't say quite where it was it was shown being built at night and it was a rather vague explanation of what it did but because we advertised it the KGB we've seen their reports on this actually thought that it was harmless they didn't realize that that would be part of our strategy”

0.56

Margaret Thatcher's government set up the Ridley Committee which secretly prepared for the miners' strike by: (1) building the Dinorwig load equalization station to replace coal-fired power during peak demand; (2) arranging secret coal-bunkering at Felixstowe port with Polish supply arrangements; (3) ensuring non-union port access to prevent communist disruption.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 4/4· Lord Christopher Monckton

“Margaret Thatcher first became leader of the conservative party in 1974. Heath Was Defeated as prime minister and so what she did was to set up a committee under Sir Nicholas Ridley... he set up that committee and while in opposition managed to nudge the central electricity generating board then nationalized into choosing de norweg as the location for a load Equalization station”

0.55

Methane influence on climate is virtually unchanged despite increases in atmospheric methane, contributing negligibly to climate forcing, contradicting efforts to regulate cattle and beef industries based on methane reduction claims.

factualhigh valuecontestednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Lord Christopher Monckton

“methane they're now trying to kill off yet another Western industry which is the cattle industry in the beef industry which would have catastrophic effect on Diabetes level if they got away with it but methane virtually unchanged influence even though there's more of it in the atmosphere there's hardly any of it anyway and so it doesn't make much difference to our effect on the climate”

0.55

Western climate policies that shut down coal and nuclear power created dependency on Russian gas, which was the precondition for Putin's invasion; had Ukraine been allowed to join NATO like Lithuania, Estonia, and Latvia, Putin would not have dared to invade.

causalhigh valuefringenovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Lord Christopher Monckton

“he had to make sure via the environmental movement that particularly the sappy European Union which is to a very striking degree has long been under the thumb of the Kremlin would close down the co-filed power stations remove the competition from Russian gas so that then if he ever wished to invade Europe and send all the commodity prices Sky High he could because there was only one thing that could possibly have stopped him and that was if we had allowed Ukraine as we have allowed Lithuania Estonia Latvia and several other countries to join NATO”

0.55

Pope Pius XII was the first major target of the KGB Dis-Information Directorate, which successfully convinced the West he was a Nazi-loving Jew-hater despite intelligence showing this was false; Monckton saw the intelligence papers confirming the claims were baseless.

factualhigh valuefringenovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Lord Christopher Monckton

“his first Target was of all saintly people Pope Pius XII who was made out to be a Nazi loving Jew hater how do we know that that wasn't true when I was at the evening standard 20 years ago everybody thought it was true we actually published an op-ed to my Fury saying it was true and I said no it isn't and they said how do you know I said because I've seen the intelligence papers”

0.54

IPCC models are entirely incapable of telling us anything about how much global warming human activity may produce because the system gain factor and feedback strength are unknown to sufficient precision to narrow the prediction interval.

causalhigh valuefringenovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Lord Christopher Monckton

“the models are entirely and I mean entirely incapable of telling us anything whatsoever about how little or how much global warming we may produce because we do not know feedback strength and hence the system gain factor to a sufficient precision to get it down to as narrow an interval as this”

0.53

If continuing warming continues at current rates with constant feedback regime compared to 1850, the expected warming by end of century would be only 1°C (or as little as 0.9°C), representing a gentle and manageable change not an existential threat.

forecasthigh valuefringenovelty 2/4durability 2/4· Lord Christopher Monckton

“if this continues to be the case we get just continuing gentle warming then there is no particular change in the feedback regime compared with 1850 and that means that the amount of warming we can expect per doubling of CO2 or by the end of this Century... all we're going to see is one Celsius of warming by the end of this Century in fact doing a more exact calculation possibly as little as 0.9”

0.52

Margaret Thatcher stayed in office only 4 years after Monckton's work on energy policy and was replaced by 'the wet' (moderate conservatives), preventing the planned abolition of income tax and elimination of national debt that would have secured Britain's economic independence.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 4/4· Lord Christopher Monckton

“unfortunately the wet intervened and it didn't happen and look at the mess we're in now... when I was at turn Downing Street were planning to get rid of the national debt had Margaret Thatcher stayed another four years the way we were running the economy the national debt would have been gone and we were going to abolish income tax because there was no need for it”

0.52

Monckton was moved into 10 Downing Street as a policy advisor in 1982 and worked with Pacepa to prepare for the expected 1983 miners' strike, but Moscow delayed it by one year due to the political effect of Margaret Thatcher's victory in the Falklands War.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 4/4· Lord Christopher Monckton

“I was moved into 10 Downing Street ostensibly as a policy advisor in 1982. we had expected the strike to begin in 1983 but the electrifyingly political effect of the victory of Margaret Thatcher over the Argentinian dictators in the Falklands War meant that Moscow told Scargill that he had to wait for another year until that effect of the victory had worn off so it was in 1984 that he started the miners strike”

0.51

The totalitarian axis now includes Russia, China, and Middle Eastern oil countries working together to keep Western energy prices high through environmental policies and to destabilize Western economies through manufactured energy crises.

factualhigh valuefringenovelty 1/4durability 2/4· Lord Christopher Monckton

“and all of this was originally driven by Moscow and is now being driven not only by Moscow but also by P King which has joined in the Fun Since Xi Jinping became the head of the Communist Party in China so you now have a totalitarian axis which includes Russia China and also the Middle Eastern Oil countries”

0.51

The EU is under long-standing Kremlin influence and has been deliberately weakened by Russian pressure for environmental policies that shut down coal and nuclear power, making Europe dependent on Russian gas and vulnerable to price manipulation.

causalhigh valuefringenovelty 1/4durability 2/4· Christopher Monckton, Viscount Monckton of Brenchley

“particularly the sappy European Union which is to a very striking degree has long been under the thumb of the Kremlin would close down the co-filed power stations remove the competition from Russian gas so that then if he ever wished to invade Europe and send all the commodity prices Sky High he could”

0.51

There has been no global warming for eight to nine years, as shown by the University of Alabama at Huntsville dataset, contradicting the catastrophic warming narrative.

factualhigh valuecontestednovelty 1/4durability 2/4· Lord Christopher Monckton

“there hasn't been any for eight years and this is the data set of the University of Alabama at Huntsville... if I had chose chosen the had crude four days that had five data set I'm sorry they've just updated it then that make that nine years without any global warming at all”

0.50

The lithium Yuan exchange rate was 70 only 3 years ago but has moved toward China as Taliban control of Afghanistan was secured with Chinese assistance and Biden withdrew US forces, allowing China to take control of Afghanistan's vast lithium deposits—the largest in the world, making Afghanistan the 'lithium Saudi Arabia.'

factualhigh valuefringenovelty 2/4durability 2/4· Lord Christopher Monckton

“the market is denominated in Yuan and it was 70 only three years ago but then with China's assistant the Taliban retook Afghanistan having and China told Biden just move your people out because we're moving in and he said yes sir and did putting them Gravely at risk and of course now making the Afghans live once again under this terrible Grim dictatorship and in a reward for that the Chinese were given control of the vast lithium fields in Afghanistan which are the largest such deposits anywhere in the world Afghanistan is the lithium Saudi Arabia just the Saudi Arabia's oil Afghanistan is to lithium China Now controls that”

0.49

China announced another 43.2 gigawatts of new coal-fired power stations, yet environmental activists do not protest China's coal expansion as they protest Western energy use, revealing selective application of climate activism.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 2/4· Lord Christopher Monckton

“China in particular is going to go on as it did last week or the week before announcing another 43 2 gigawatt coal-fired power stations and do you hear the environmental activists out on the streets protesting about China's vast increase in co-fart power I see no hands no you don't”

0.49

When correcting the climate sensitivity error and doubling the McKinsey cost estimate to account for post-Ukraine commodity price increases, the cost-benefit improves to 1-5 millionths of a Celsius degree per billion dollars—an even worse ratio.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 2/4· Lord Christopher Monckton

“if you make those two adjustments you correct for the actual amount of global warming that has happened and is observed to have happened in the mid-range estimate of that and you correct by doubling mckinsey's cost that's a very generous small amount of increase compared with two years ago it's probably more like six or eight times minimum but we'll just double it one five millionth of a Celsius degree for each one billion dollars spent”

0.48

The economic calculation showing net-zero costs of $400-800 trillion for 1-5 millionths of a degree Celsius of warming abatement is unimpeachable because it depends only on three mainstream pieces of data (NOAA, IPCC, McKinsey), making it impossible for critics to greatly alter the numbers.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Lord Christopher Monckton

“that economic calculation which depends on only three unimpeachable mid-range mainstream pieces of data is unimpunable there is no way of very greatly altering the numbers you do when you do that calculation and they have been desperate to make sure that nobody tells you any of this”

0.47

Over 30 years of anthropogenic greenhouse gas forcing has increased by one unit; if emissions go in a straight line to zero by 2050, only half a unit of additional forcing will be abated, preventing 3/8 of one degree Celsius of warming even if the entire world achieved net-zero.

causalhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Lord Christopher Monckton

“30 years of man-made forcing one unit abated straight line to Global Net Zero by 2050 we're not going to Abate it all straight away then it will be one unit we've got to get there in a straight line and here's a straight line we've seen that so half a unit about it”

0.46

Al Gore confidently claimed in 2007 in Bali that by 2013 all ice in the Arctic would be gone by summer, but there is very little sign of this happening as of 2023, demonstrating that alarmist predictions lack scientific basis.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 4/4· Lord Christopher Monckton

“if the worst that would happen if the whole of the Arctic melted which by the way we were told confidently by Al Gore I was there in 2007 when he said it in Bali he said by 200 2013 all the ice in the Arctic will be gone by the summer and there's very little sign of that happening and we're not 2013 we're coming out to 2023”

0.43

A sub-postmistress's village post office faces an energy cost increase from 7,000 pounds to 56,000 pounds annually (eightfold increase), making closure inevitable—this is happening across Britain due to climate policy-driven energy costs.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Lord Christopher Monckton

“a sub postmistress just last week who got hold of her local newspaper and it eventually made the national press she said last year I paid seven thousand Pounds in energy costs for My Little Village post office and Shop next year I have been told it will be 56 000 pounds eight times as much and I won't be paying that because there will no longer be a village shop and that is going to happen right across Britain”

0.43

Middle Eastern oil countries benefit from Western climate policies that shut down competing oil and gas production because they can then sell their oil at inflated prices; Saudi Arabia has rebuffed Biden's requests for increased oil production because their strategy is to keep prices high.

causalhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Lord Christopher Monckton

“what's in it for them well Mr Biden who is strikingly naive has tried twice to go to Saudi Arabia saying please could you let us have more oil so that we can be good boys and stop all the fracking in Britain stop it all in America and we're we're being good about global warming and you can you can sell us oil instead and they said no and he couldn't understand why because the reason why is that the whole purpose of the special military Massacre”

0.41

Three-quarters of research respondents in the room (a university audience) initially believed net-zero climate policy was necessary before Monckton's presentation; this suggests public opinion is manipulated rather than evidence-based, and that freedom of thought and speech are being suppressed.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 1/4· Christopher Monckton, Viscount Monckton of Brenchley

“two-thirds of you in this room because I took a poll before we started is yes we do need to Abate It Anyway”