What this covers

This is a long conversation between Shane Parrish and Joel Greenblatt, founder of Gotham Capital, Columbia Business School lecturer and author. It begins with how he thinks about investing and moves outward to education, monetary policy and market conditions. A recurring distinction is between simplicity reached before understanding a subject and simplicity reached after mastering its complexity. Much of the investing material comes from Warren Buffett: you don't have to swing at every pitch, a fat wallet hurts returns, and the Coca-Cola purchase showed how to pay a seemingly high price for a dominant, cash-generative business.

On the investing side, Greenblatt covers accounting as a way to see economic reality, with transparency valued over any particular rule. If the numbers are murky, he moves to the next company. He looks for a durable franchise rather than a one-off trade, and he uses Costco's flywheel as an example. On management, he argues that past capital-allocation record predicts future behavior better than stated plans. He also argues that stock options are a real cost to shareholders. His own method leans on Capital Preservation Primacy: if you don't lose money, most other outcomes are good. He also describes learning from others' mistakes and drawing on experience to place a new situation among past ones. An aside on how his in-laws bought art compares a painting's price with recent sales of the same artist's work, so no one has to predict the next Picasso.

Two parts of the conversation go beyond stock picking. Greenblatt describes co-founding Success Academy, and cites the college-graduation gap for low-income and minority students, test results at a Brooklyn school, and the limits of philanthropy against roughly $1 trillion in annual education spending. He also links the diversity of a workforce to company profitability, which bears on alternative certification for teachers. The most contested territory is macro: he argues for heavy government spending during COVID, financed at low long-term rates, while warning that money printing could become inflationary, possibly first in asset prices. The episode closes on what he fears in today's market, including Fed intervention and large IPOs of unprofitable companies.

Sharpest takeaway

Joel Greenblatt argues that successful investing requires simplicity of thought, patience to wait for obvious opportunities, proper position sizing based on downside risk rather than position percentage, and learning from great capital allocators like Warren Buffett—not from complex analysis or trying to predict the future.

  • The best investment opportunities are simple and obvious when viewed from the right angle, not requiring complex spreadsheets or page-40 analysis
  • Position sizing should be based on how much you can realistically lose, not the percentage of portfolio, enabling larger positions in asymmetric opportunities with limited downside
  • Great investors share common traits: ability to think simply, passion for problem-solving over money, willingness to skip hard-to-value opportunities, and learning from studying management capital allocation track records rather than assessing them in meetings

The claims · ranked58 claims · weighted by value

This asset isn't compiled yet

You're seeing its claims, ranked. Compile it to build the argument threads, weight them, and check each claim against your library — the full view.

0.74

Companies create long-term value through treating employees well, serving customers well, being good community members, and avoiding pollution—not through short-term tricks or quarter-focused decisions, and properly-structured stock options should reinforce long-term thinking rather than short-term value extraction.

normativehigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 4/4· Joel Greenblatt

“you don't create long-term value by cheating your customers you don't create long-term value by not treating your employees well or being a good member of the community or providing a service that people really want or polluting the environment or you don't create long-term value that way it might create the appearance of short-term value which may be reflected in a stock price which may affect your stock options because you tricked somebody in thinking you you did well but that's not the way to create long-term value so i think if we just adjusted things both in stock options like you asked or even in uh what is the role of a good company a company has to the role of companies to create good long-term you know uh as much long-term value as possible and the only way to do that is to treat employees well to treat your customers well to treat the environment well”

0.69

Learning from other people's mistakes through reading about past events and how smart people think is preferable to learning only from personal mistakes, allowing an investor to avoid repeating those mistakes while making different ones.

normativehigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Joel Greenblatt

“and you know i it is it's true it's great to learn from your own mistakes and you really don't learn unless you're really investing your own money and feeling how it feels to be wrong and lose a lot of money so all those things are true but the more you can learn from other people's mistakes and the things that you know learn from the past and reading how smart people think uh it's only helpful i'd rather not make those mistakes myself i'd rather they made their mistakes and make different ones you know you add those all up and maybe you try to avoid over time”

0.69

Experience provides contextual understanding that helps distinguish between new opportunities and past patterns, allowing an experienced investor to say 'I've seen 10 or 20 years of these and this ranks in the top 10 or 20' rather than being uncertain about each new situation.

normativehigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Joel Greenblatt

“so it's a lot of patience some of that comes from experience too you know being able to say hey i've been doing this for 10 years and this ranks up there in the top 10 or 20 of things i've seen and if you have that ability to contextualize uh with a little experience that's always helpful”

0.69

Research shows that having a more diverse workforce actually makes companies significantly more profitable, so investing in alternative certification pathways is not only a moral imperative but also directly advantageous to companies' bottom lines.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Joel Greenblatt

“there's a lot of studies done saying that having a more diverse workforce actually makes you a lot of money”

0.69

Buffett's principle that you don't have to swing at every pitch means that missing opportunities is acceptable as long as you do well on the ones you do swing at; this removes pressure to analyze everything and allows focus on high-conviction opportunities

normativehigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Joel Greenblatt

“you don't have to swing at every pitch you can swing at one of 20 pitches but as long as you do a good job with that one it all works out it doesn't mean you it doesn't matter that you missed out on them”

0.69

Accounting and financial statement analysis should be approached as understanding economic reality rather than memorizing rules; the goal is to homogenize accounting across different standards and companies to reveal underlying business economics

normativehigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Joel Greenblatt

“accounting is like a sideshow you know it's as buffer would say the language of business and you have to understand accounting but i never and i was a county major by the way at wharton i don't know what i did i mean you know you have sales you have expenses you have income you know here's what you have here's what you owe here's you know i don't know what i did for four years uh doing that and i don't try to memorize every accounting rule out there”

0.69

When looking for investment ideas, the goal is to find franchises, brands, networks, or other durable competitive advantages that can be continuously exploited, rather than one-off trades

normativehigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Joel Greenblatt

“i'm looking for successful capital allocators usually not like i said a story just because i'm not good at that i don't know who the next picasso is but i i uh if there is a franchise or a brand or a network or something that they can continue to exploit uh i want to i want them to be thinking sort of along those lines”

0.63

Warren Buffett's purchase of Coca-Cola was instructive to Greenblatt because it demonstrated how to pay a seemingly high price (when viewed through traditional cheap-valuation lens) for a truly dominant, cash-generative business with high returns on capital.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 0/4durability 3/4· Joel Greenblatt

“one of the best things i ever learned from was when he bought coca-cola uh and analyzing how he could pay at that time what i thought was such an astronomical price for a fairly uh mundane business uh it had great franchise obviously it was growing reasonably but still based on you know just my cheap gene of buying things cheap and trying to learn from someone who wanted to buy good and cheap uh how much could you pay”

0.63

Costco's business model is a 'flywheel' where selling products at cost and profiting on memberships makes it very difficult for traditional for-profit competitors to compete, as customers preferentially buy from a membership club selling at cost over competitors with markups.

causalhigh valueestablishednovelty 0/4durability 3/4· Joel Greenblatt

“you know they they very straightforward we don't make money on our business we make more money from our memberships and uh you know it's uh you talk to jim collins so it's a flywheel where if you can sell people uh products at cost it's very hard for people who are trying to make a profit to beat you but if you can make all your money on the memberships just selling more and more memberships for the ability to buy it cost very simple model not so hard to understand and uh the the more members you get the better you can do the more business you can do”

0.63

Stock options should be fully accounted for as a cost of compensation because they represent a real cost to shareholders through dilution, even though accurate accounting is difficult due to stock volatility.

normativehigh valueestablishednovelty 0/4durability 3/4· Joel Greenblatt

“i do think that they should be fully accounted for the cost of paying your people it's clearly a cost it's not an invented cost it's clearly a cost um it's an expensive way to pay people if you have a really good business at a good price it's uh you could probably do it more cheaply but as long as it's accounted for correctly and i've always been for uh management being responsible to shareholders in such a way that they their bread is buttered the same way so i have no inherent problem with incenting people the same way the shareholders are incented”

0.63

The Success Academy charter school network, cofounded by Greenblatt and partner John Petry and run by CEO Eva Moskowitz, serves 20,000 predominantly minority and low-income students across 47 schools in NYC, and ranks as the top district school system in the city by achievement metrics.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 0/4durability 3/4· Joel Greenblatt

“my partner john petry and i uh hired a woman named diva moscowitz uh to be the ceo of uh success academy and uh the idea behind it there are now 20 000 kids in 47 schools and they would be the top district in new york city and most of the kids uh 87 are minority uh low-income kids and that yet they beat all the wealthiest school districts”

0.61

Buffett's principle that 'a fat wallet is the enemy of high investment returns' means that excess capital forces poor allocation decisions and dilutes returns, making capital constraints a feature not a bug for achieving superior long-term performance.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Joel Greenblatt

“buffett said you know fat wallet is the enemy of high investment returns that's just true”

0.60

There is a critical distinction between simplicity before understanding complexity (naive simplicity) and simplicity after understanding complexity (mastery simplicity), which can be distinguished by whether the person truly understands the underlying mechanisms or has just superficially grasped them.

definitionhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 3/4durability 4/4· Joel Greenblatt

“if you think of simplicity there's simplicity before understanding complexity and then there's simplicity after understanding complexity how do you distinguish between the naive simplicity versus the mastery simplicity”

0.57

Monetary printing becomes counterproductive when it creates inflation, but timing is uncertain and depends on how inflation is measured—asset price inflation (stocks, homes, securities) may occur without traditional consumer price inflation being recorded.

factualhigh valuecontestednovelty 1/4durability 2/4· Joel Greenblatt

“how do you measure inflation because you might you know i don't think the these stocks levitating you know all these uh specs and ipos and everything levitating at high prices you know and going up five and ten times in a year that doesn't factor into the inflation number but that's where the money is going um so it depends how you measure inflation you know does it get inflate asset prices of homes or other things uh stocks uh securities and it doesn't count inflation but are we having inflation are we not it depends how you define inflation”

0.56

The most important principle in investing is 'if you don't lose money, most other alternatives are good'—meaning capital preservation through limiting downside is more important than chasing maximum upside, and this enables asymmetric return opportunities.

normativehigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 4/4· Joel Greenblatt

“one of the one of the best things i think i ever wrote was you can be a stock market genius i wrote uh if you don't lose money most of the other alternatives are good”

0.56

The best rule of thumb for evaluating management teams is that if they have been good at capital allocation in the past, they will likely continue to be; if they have been poor at it, they will likely continue to be, regardless of their current stated plans or how smart they seem.

normativehigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 4/4· Joel Greenblatt

“the best rule of thumb that i learned was if this management team was good at allocating capital before i walked in the door the assumption that they would continue to be good was a really good assumption and if they were really bad at it no matter what story they told and how smart they seemed and how logical what they planned to do was the better assumption would be that they would continue to be bad at it so i would not rely me personally rely so much on what a management team my assessment of the management team but my assessment of what they've done in the past uh is very valuable”

0.55

Private giving ($1-2 billion on education) is a 'drop in the bucket' relative to $1 trillion annual spending, so philanthropy alone cannot move the needle on educational inequality—systemic change is needed.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 0/4durability 3/4· Joel Greenblatt

“so you know if you have a if you're a billionaire and want to throw in a billion dollars into this current system you know soviet style system that we have that's not going to move the needle unfortunately yeah so there's got to be another way i really appreciate all the work that you've done there and the results sort of speak for themselves and hopefully it starts to catch on soon well i appreciate that so uh uh one of the things that i was hopeful would catch on and that some of the major companies were talking about uh not it's the responsibility but something they can do to help themselves meaning get more diverse talent yeah”

0.55

Greenblatt prioritizes transparency in accounting over specific accounting rules; management should disclose how they're calculating metrics (e.g., EBITDA) rather than hiding adjustments, and if accounting is unclear he moves to the next company rather than trying to understand intentional obfuscation.

normativehigh valueestablishednovelty 0/4durability 3/4· Joel Greenblatt

“i guess i'm just more for transparency uh you know even when people say oh you know uh you know ebitda not including the cost of our inventory or our labor or something you know if they come up with new measures like that i think the importance is to say how much you paid for labor and to say how much you you paid for uh your inventory and so i think just providing enough information and it is helpful to hear how management is thinking about those things but if they're just trying to use them to goose up their short-term returns by not counting expenses or something like that then i'd like to see that too”

0.54

Government should spend as much as necessary during one-off crises like COVID because the economic damage is unprecedented and temporary, and if borrowing can be done at low interest rates (1.3% over 30 years), the inflation-adjusted cost approaches free.

normativehigh valuecontestednovelty 1/4durability 2/4· Joel Greenblatt

“i do believe that whatever the repercussions you know we've had covet right and so the question is you know people think we're going to get through it and you know what should the government have done you know during this time and i'm a firm believer the government should uh spend as much money as necessary to keep the consequences slow because this really is a one-off hopefully the next you know maybe or won't happen again for 20 or 30 years or maybe it won't be as bad but i think that there really is a big loss of jobs and there's a big loss of ability to do business”

0.54

Only 1 in 11 low-income and minority students in major urban centers graduate college, representing a 90% failure rate in the current system; this tragedy is compounded by evidence showing that with proper supports, nearly all such students could achieve high levels academically.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 0/4durability 2/4· Joel Greenblatt

“the real problem is that uh you know only if if you are a uh low-income minority uh or minority low-income or minority in a major one of our cities your chance of graduating college now or one out of 11. so that's a 10 out of 11 failure rate in the current system”

0.54

A district school in Brooklyn where 99% of students passed the math exam and 94% passed English (metrics for students with disabilities that are 4x better than traditional schools, and English language learners at 90% pass rate vs 9% in other district schools) demonstrates that the gap is not capability but support systems.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 0/4durability 2/4· Joel Greenblatt

“i wrote about uh a district school where 99 of the kids uh passed the uh math test and 94 past the english tests the regular district school one of the poorest sections of brooklyn but the stats i just gave you were for the kids with disabilities okay now the kids with disabilities do you know it's four times better than the kids with disabilities do in the regular school the english language learners in that same district school percent can pass the english these are english language learners 90 past the english exam where nine percent ten times better of english language learners passing in the other district schools”

0.53

The current market exhibits unprecedented Fed intervention in securities markets and widespread IPOs of unprofitable companies trading at valuations exceeding $100 billion, representing potential irrational speculation.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 0/4durability 1/4· Unidentified Speaker — What makes a GREAT INVESTOR? | Episode 111 Joel Greenblatt [8ZiLLjtAtyU]

“i would nearly unprecedented at least from my point of view fed intervention in the markets and also the other thing is it seems like there's lottery tickets now with a lot of these companies going public that don't generate cash for equity owners it just seems to be a share price where you have ipos at 100 billion companies that don't actually generate returns”

0.52

The ability to distinguish between luck and skill in investing requires evaluating investors' thought processes—specifically whether they can explain their investment theses simply and whether they are motivated by passion for problem-solving versus financial gain.

normativehigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Joel Greenblatt

“one it's really just the thought process uh do they can they make it simple can they really explain in a very simple way what it is about this particular idea or investment that makes sense to them and you can see that very quickly after looking at a lot of them what makes a good investor is a combination of being able to do that and passion”

0.52

Writing is valuable for learning because it forces the writer to understand whether they actually comprehend what they think they do, and teaching/preparation similarly forces clarity of thought that speaking extemporaneously does not provide.

normativehigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Joel Greenblatt

“i find writing is the process by which you learn that you don't understand as much as you think you did”

0.52

The best investment opportunities for great investors come from finding situations others are not looking at or viewing a problem from a different angle than the market consensus, not from being smarter at analysis or having better information access.

normativehigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Joel Greenblatt

“it's more like you can see that too so it's really simplicity of thought being able to boil things down to a simple a few simple concepts of what makes this attractive and also passion for figuring it out and the other is it's not on page 40. it's really you're looking at things you're tilting your head in a different way it's not that there are a lot of smart people out there uh a lot smarter than me but if you look at things from 40 000 feet or from a different angle or that's where i've tended to to have my most success where i just yes everyone is looking at it this way but i think that's not the right way to look at it”

0.52

Greenblatt's in-laws had an advantage in art buying by finding paintings off the beaten path at auctions and yard sales, then checking if the same artist had recently sold works at double or triple the price elsewhere—a method that doesn't require predicting if an artist will become the next Picasso, only finding mispricing relative to known comparables.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Joel Greenblatt

“when i got started you know and uh and i wrote you can be stock market changes about it i opened up that book by talking about my in-laws uh who used to have a weekend house in connecticut and they would spend their weekends going to country auctions at uh uh yard sales and uh um you know galleries off the beaten path and when they found a painting that they liked their question was not is this painter going to be the next picasso that's really hard their question was is there a painting by this same artist uh that just went up for auction at double or triple the price that i can buy it for here”

0.52

Great ideas come naturally when you're reading things that interest you and not deliberately searching for ideas with a specific formula; combining prior experience with current observations helps identify when a new situation reminds you of past patterns.

normativehigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Joel Greenblatt

“well uh i read things that are interesting to me so i'm reading all different publications i'm reading things off the internet i'm getting news feeds all day long and i'll just pick and choose things that are interesting uh to me sometimes i won't do things come to you when you're not really looking if you're sitting there uh with a green eye shade you know and trying to find ideas that's not what i'm doing i'm reading things that are interesting to me i'm looking at developments of the world that are interesting to me and occasional occasionally i'll have a good idea from from doing that and i just enjoy the process of learning about and trying to understand what's going on in the world outside and and uh i think more experience helps you having seen a lot and being able to say hey this thing reminds me of that thing and this is how that thing played out”

0.52

The biggest positions Greenblatt takes are not those expected to return 5-10x, but rather those where he is confident he cannot lose much money—positions are sized based on downside risk, not upside potential.

normativehigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Joel Greenblatt

“the biggest positions i've had are not my best ones the ones that i think will go up five or ten times i'm really looking down not up when i take a big position so in other words i will size the position larger if i don't think i can lose much money it's not like the thing that's going to pay 10 or 20 times obviously if you have a 10 stock that's sitting with nine dollars in cash and no debt and they have a little business attached you can buy a lot of that one as long as you don't think they'll dissipate the cash uh as long as there's a chance for a big upside you're looking for asymmetric returns”

0.52

Position sizing should be based on realistic downside risk (how much a reasonable investor can lose if able to wait a couple of years to sell at their chosen time), not on catastrophic downside or the absolute size of the position in the portfolio.

normativehigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Joel Greenblatt

“it's looking at how much can you lose from that position when i lose when i say lose crazy things happen whether it's covid or 2008 you know lehman goes down or something like that where over a short period of time stocks or other securities can trade at any price that's not what i'm talking about how much i'm risking as long as you're uh don't leverage too much and you can wait it out what i'm talking about is if a reasonable person won't lose much money if they can pick their spot to sell it over the next couple of years that's what i'm viewing is how much i have at risk if i can be patient sell it when i want to sell it over the next couple of years what's the worst i really think i'm going to do that's how much i'm at risk for”

0.52

When facing a large field of hard-to-evaluate opportunities (like which unprofitable companies will succeed), the rational approach is to acknowledge what you can't figure out and skip those investments, putting them in the 'too hard pile' rather than speculating.

normativehigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Joel Greenblatt

“so you pick the ones you can't figure out so for the most of the ones you you take a pass you throw it as buffett was saying the too hard pile i think anyone who's honest about it would say hey i can't know all these industries i can't know all the prospects for these businesses the world is changing very quickly you know tick tock or whatever it's called didn't exist now they got billions of followers and you know where does that take business out of and you know everything else so very hard to predict you know which ones will be the winners you know if you have a particular expertise in an area have a particular vision or you know something seems simple to you uh i'm not going to argue against it there will be those but one person is not going to know hundreds of those uh to pick and so i think you just have to know yourself know what what you're good at”

0.52

Success Academy's model was built on the principle that fourth-grade learning of different subjects should be replicable across schools, and cannot depend on hiring only top-1% teachers; instead, it requires providing supports and training to average teachers to become great teachers.

normativehigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Joel Greenblatt

“the idea really was based on a business idea uh that you know fourth grade learning the different subjects should be pretty similar across schools so if you could do it well in one uh the model cannot be just hiring the top one percent of teachers because you run out of those the model has to be giving the supports necessary and the training necessary to an average teacher to become a great teacher that that had to be the model and also if you could do it in one two or three schools what can you do it in a replicable way”

0.52

Major corporations (Google, Microsoft, Amazon, JP Morgan) could set hiring standards for skills/certifications obtained outside traditional college degrees, which would create demand for alternative credentialing pathways and support services to help low-income workers access high-paying jobs.

normativehigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Joel Greenblatt

“all they really would have to do is say you know what tests what courses what certificates in lieu of a college degree can you pass or do well on what test courses or certificates can you get outside of a college degree that we will give you a high paying job and let's say the microsoft hr department or you know some other department just set the standards and then a whole ecosystem once there's a buyer a whole ecosystem of uh supportive services whether they're online or tutoring services can be an alternate way for people to gain those credentials and all you're doing is setting standards i'm not saying these companies would need to take tests or give tests just set standards”

0.52

The worst mistake investors make is being 'too timid on the few good ideas that come your way,' failing to size positions appropriately on high-conviction, high-opportunity-set investments, which can result in an otherwise excellent investment (10x or 100x) being your worst-performing investment due to inadequate position size.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Joel Greenblatt

“position sizing is the most important thing and that being too timid on the few good ideas that come your way is like the biggest mistake people make”

0.50

Waiting for an obvious investment opportunity is preferable to attempting to predict multiple moves ahead in the market (like chess), because success comes from patience and recognizing when something is simple and obvious rather than from superior foresight.

normativehigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Joel Greenblatt

“well it's definitely not like chess i'm a terrible chess player and uh i'm not good at looking forward a lot of moves uh i i think it's simpler than that it's it's really maybe it comes from your one of your previous questions it's sort of patience you know looking uh waiting to see something that's so simple and obvious to you anyway and it doesn't mean you don't miss a lot of things that should have been simple and obvious at the time and you always i'm sure you're familiar with when you just say ah why didn't i think of that or that was so clear after the fact and so it's fine to miss lots of those it's just having the patience to wait until you do have that aha moment saying oh i think this is the better way to look at it and only pulling the trigger uh when when you see that it's almost the s buffett would put it again you know the errors of omission aren't so important it's the uh if you can miss a lot but if the the fee you know i should have swung at seven out of 20 pitches but if i swing at one and it was a good pitch to swing at that works out well too”

0.49

Historically, buying unprofitable companies has been the single worst investment strategy, but the world and business structure have fundamentally changed as companies now expense customer acquisition costs and development spending that used to be capitalized, changing how accounting reflects true business investment.

normativehigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 2/4· Joel Greenblatt

“that's your strategy buy everything that loses money now i have a lot of statistics to say that buying that group of companies is the single worst strategy you could concoct in the past will it be the single worst going forward i would say there will be definite winners from that group that lose money and the world has changed and the business world has changed in this way that many of those businesses are investing in their future it looks like not an investment you know it used to be you know you build a factory or you invest in capital equipment or whatever it is and you could see it on the balance sheet here uh you know a lot of that gets expensed”

0.48

The ability to wait for good investment pitches requires limiting outside capital under management, as running large amounts of capital forces managers to deploy it and prevents the selectivity needed to wait for obvious opportunities; Greenblatt returned outside capital from Gotham Capital after 10 years to maintain this discipline.

causalhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Joel Greenblatt

“you know i i as uh buffett would say you don't want to get outside of your circle of confidence so uh i think you're right that a lot of these off the beaten path opportunities uh you can't run a lot of capital so when i started gotham capital in 1985 i read it for five years we did well we returned half our outside capital that's what we literally did to make it you know keep ourselves in the right space and then after 10 years in business we had done well we had done well enough to keep our staff but we turned all the outside capital uh and that was really just a way to force ourselves to have limited amount of capital”

0.48

SalesForce spent approximately $50,000 to convert a client from a legacy system, betting on 8-10 years of customer lifetime value, which appears as an expense rather than capital investment in accounting, obscuring the true nature of customer acquisition as business investment.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Joel Greenblatt

“i'm just thinking like we just switched over to salesforce for instance is a simple example so salesforce is a software program that you know many firms use to track all their marketing and sales and you know it's pretty much all over the place and salesforce actually and i don't remember the exact number but paid 50 000 or something to some third party to convert whatever system we were on before but convert us you know our business on to their uh process and i don't know what we pay for salesforce but not fifty thousand dollars a year yeah but their bet is that the lifetime value of us as a customer you know will last eight or ten years and that payoff is going to be huge over time”

0.48

Using a house purchase as an analogy, if an investor can contextualize that they're realistically only at risk for 10-20% of the house purchase price (not the absolute dollar amount), it becomes psychologically easier to take the risk, as the risk is smaller than the nominal commitment appears.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Joel Greenblatt

“if you then can say you know what i think i'm only at risk for 10 or 20 of whatever i pay for my house realistically uh that maybe makes it more sleepable you know you don't want to bed you know you want to be able to sleep well”

0.48

Amazon's strategy of not reporting profits through expensing content spending and reinvestment allows it to keep money that it earns from its core profitable businesses to reinvest in customer acquisition and retention rather than pay it out in taxes, which is misunderstood when critics claim 'Amazon doesn't pay taxes' when the reality is more nuanced capital deployment.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Joel Greenblatt

“well they keep taking all the money that they earn from all their great businesses reinvesting in their business in you know customer retention customer acquisition you know it's all from creating things that they think they'll get paid off over the long term but i don't think the accounting world has has kept up with that”

0.48

It only takes one or two major corporations to start alternative certification programs to create a flywheel effect where success breeds adoption and the practice spreads industry-wide, similar to how successful innovations typically diffuse.

forecasthigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Joel Greenblatt

“it'll just take one or two and then it'll start going”

0.45

In 2019, there were 299 companies with market caps exceeding $1 billion that lost money, and buying all 299 would have returned over 100% through November of that year, compared to the median stock return of 47%, despite historical data showing this is the worst possible investment strategy.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 1/4· Joel Greenblatt

“we looked up a statistic uh along the lines of what you're suggesting uh last year a few there were there are now uh 299 companies that lost money in 2019 so this is pre-covered so there were money losers in 2019 uh with a market cap now over a billion dollars and if you bought every single one of those money losers those 299 companies with market caps over a billion dollars now uh you would be up over 100 percent so far this year and the median stock is up i think 47 you know through the end of november anyway”

0.45

Over 90% of Success Academy students are reading and doing math on grade level, and when that standard is met, schools raise expectations further, creating continuous improvement

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Joel Greenblatt

“and you know over 90 of the kids reading and doing math on grade level and then if they do that then raise the standards some more you know uh so that you keep uh improving”

0.45

Success Academy proves that the goal of education reform should be making district schools work, but has struggled to get the current NYC administration to learn from and adopt their model despite the evidence

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 2/4· Joel Greenblatt

“in some ways at least in new york city with this mayor it's kind of failed to say hey what are those guys doing yeah and what can we learn and how can we help each other uh that part which i thought would be automatic just with a logical business mind especially for non-profit and you know we're all have the same goals in mind”

0.45

The indexes (like S&P 500) are dominated by large profitable tech companies (Amazon, Google, Microsoft, Apple) with genuinely great business models and growth trajectories, so high valuations of the overall index may not be irrational even if individual speculative stocks are overvalued.

normativehigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 2/4· Joel Greenblatt

“it's very hard you know it's a market of stocks not a stock market so uh most of the big indexes are driven by the amazon google microsoft apple and those businesses don't seem very irrational to me those are some of the greatest businesses that man has ever created partially due to the internet interconnectedness of the world you can name it the types of franchises they can create i don't think we've seen the quality of and the growth trajectory and sort of the unlimited growth trajectory of some of these businesses before and so those uh prices make sense to me uh or they're not like wildly overvalued like the internet bubble i think they're actually perhaps reasonably valued and perhaps good investments we own a lot of those uh businesses”

0.45

The key question about money-losing companies valued at high multiples is whether 'everyone realizes' they're betting on becoming the next Amazon/Google/Microsoft and is already pricing them as such, making most such companies poor investments despite occasional big winners.

normativehigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 2/4· Joel Greenblatt

“everyone realizes that and everyone is assuming that these guys are going to be the next amazon google microsoft and there will not be there'll be a handful of big winners like that but those 299 companies are getting credit as if they will be the next amazon google microsoft seems unlikely that all of them or even a big percentage of them will”

0.45

The market does give credit to genuine long-term visionaries like Bezos and companies investing for future value, as seen in valuations of unprofitable companies with real vision; however, the market also rewards short-term noise and manipulation, suggesting selective rather than perfect rationality.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 2/4· Joel Greenblatt

“the market values that i mean if you have a guy like jeff bezos who's really only thinking long term and then you think of all those companies that are losing money that people are giving value because they see the future it's not that the market is trying to be short-term oriented they see when they see the real deal they do give credit for it and so i don't think they're counterproductive you know i got to make the next quarter i got to look good i think i like i'm watching elon musk even you know who's been obviously incredibly successful i don't want to take anything but worrying about how we look over the next quarter uh yet he's a visionary you know a decade out i i see that as troublesome that they don't they don't uh look at one another”

0.45

Greenblatt is concerned about Elon Musk's approach of worrying about quarterly optics and short-term appearance over long-term vision, despite Musk being an incredible visionary, because this focus on quarterly perception is 'troublesome' and misaligned with his actual strengths.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 2/4· Joel Greenblatt

“i like i'm watching elon musk even you know who's been obviously incredibly successful i don't want to take anything but worrying about how we look over the next quarter uh yet he's a visionary you know a decade out i i see that as troublesome”

0.44

Jeff Bezos is the best capital allocator Greenblatt observes, because he envisioned the strategy of investing in long-term customer lifetime value over near-term profits 25-27 years ago, which was decades ahead of most other business leaders.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 0/4durability 3/4· Joel Greenblatt

“the best in the world has been uh jeff bezos i mean he was a visionary back in the early 90s when he envisioned at least a big chunk of his success and you know this whole thing i'm talking about is investing in your business and not worrying about profits now and you know building long-term value of customers that was his vision 20 whatever it was 27 years ago which is you know at least a few decades ahead of most other people who have uh thought that way”

0.43

Ted Turner's purchase of MGM was misunderstood by most because people valued MGM by traditional metrics, but Turner was essentially buying a film library that he could reuse repeatedly on his TBS network across the country via satellite, fundamentally changing the value proposition.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Joel Greenblatt

“ted turner when you hear him talk i mean he bought the atlanta braves and said he looked at it like well you know that's game takes three hours so that's three hours of broadcasting i get that i own that i can do that he owned a very small uhf at the time which was you know not even on the main dial of a tv set for those old enough to know what uhf was uh so he had like a you know the fourth or fifth biggest station in atlanta and then figured out uh so he bought all his programming including the atlanta braves and figured out how to stick it up on a satellite but only paid for you know the andy griffith show or whatever was some old sitcom uh for broadcasting in atlanta but was able to beam it up across the country on a satellite across many you know he created tbs and figured out all these things that you know a baseball team's really software and uh it's creating um three hours you know 162 times a year of uh things that people can watch that alone and so he figured out that mgm was really a film library that he could use over and over again on his station so he paid an astronomical amount according to the way most people were looking at but he was looking at it a different way”

0.43

The US should extend the maturity of its borrowing from approximately 6 years average to 30 years while interest rates are low, locking in low rates for longer and reducing refinancing risk.

normativehigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Joel Greenblatt

“i think that's a smart thing to do i think we can afford to do it as long as we now we're not borrowing that money over 30 years i think our average maturity is like six years so i think that's insane i think we should borrow it over 30 years for free um so that would be my one suggestion to anyone listening uh we should extend our maturities when they're lending us money for free”

0.43

Exceptional visionaries like Ted Turner and Steve Jobs can be recognized as such when they speak about their vision and explain their logic in a way that is clearly 'brilliant' and 'obviously' demonstrates they understand the whole picture, but such visionaries are rare and Greenblatt has made little money specifically from betting on visionary CEOs.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Joel Greenblatt

“uh go back to the story i told about ted turner like i didn't really know you couldn't really tell uh from looking at the numbers and then i just heard him speak for about an hour and a half once he was presenting to a group of analysts why he was doing i think was the mgm deal i just watched him speak and understand his logic and how brilliant he was and said well uh that was just obvious”

0.41

Greenblatt invested in Turner's preferred securities from the MGM deal at 60 cents on the dollar because the security was 'covered six times over' by Turner's existing business cash flows, making it safe even if Turner's vision was wrong, and the security recovered to par within months.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 0/4durability 3/4· Joel Greenblatt

“i figured out he's going to pay this paper and i also figured out that look he only paid 50 in cash so as long as he didn't overpay by double uh i was backed by all the business that he had already and so it was just a big picture way of looking at that preferred saying hey this is covered six times over and this guy's a genius and everything else and i bought i bought this preferred at 60 cents on the dollar that people figured it out a few months later and i got my dollar so it was uh i was kind of proud of that one because people thought this guy's a nut and i just went through the big picture and say even if he's a nut he's still not going to go broke and i'm going to get fully paid”

0.39

Speculative plays like SPACs and unprofitable companies at high valuations (e.g., Nikola) represent froth that will 'end badly' but won't crash the entire market or economy because their market cap is small relative to mega-cap companies like Apple and Amazon.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 1/4· Joel Greenblatt

“this other speculation uh in you know all these spacks and all these companies that are losing money that are given you know i was looking at uh just for curiosity i was looking i don't know how to pronounce it nicola or uh nikola however you pronounce it you know that trump company electric truck company i was just looking after it's turned out that it appears to be mostly a fraud and they really haven't come up with anything that they've promised uh still has a market cap of six and a half billion”

0.39

Greenblatt hired his partner Rob Goldstein right out of college in 1989 because Goldstein was very poor at interviewing in a way that reminded him of himself, but within the interview said things that made total sense, indicating intelligence beneath poor communication.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 0/4durability 3/4· Joel Greenblatt

“my partner rob golson joined me in 1989 i hired him right out of uh college and uh and he was so bad at interviewing he was so bad he reminded me of myself and that's why i hired him because he said something within the interview that made total sense to me and that's why i hired him so it wasn't like he totally flubbed it but he did remind me of how bad i was on my interviews and uh and endeared him to me uh because he did have those nuggets of clarity that made me see that there was something behind the bad interviewee”

0.34

Greenblatt wrote his first book 'You Could Be a Stock Market Genius' in 1997 by boiling down his thinking to the simple concepts he had when executing trades at Gotham Capital since 1985, rather than creating elaborate theses—capturing the elemental truth of why investments worked or didn't work.

factualestablishednovelty 0/4durability 4/4· Joel Greenblatt

“i kept when i wrote my first book in 97 it really boiled down to what was i really thinking why i enjoyed a book called you could be a stock market genius in 1997. and the great thing about writing that book it was really just a series of war stories about you know what i had done at uh my firm gotham capital since uh uh with my partners since 1985”

0.29

Observing that stocks had different 52-week highs and lows (e.g., 100 to 42) contradicted the efficient market hypothesis taught in business school, suggesting markets are irrational and create opportunities for investors who understand this irrationality.

factualestablishednovelty 0/4durability 3/4· Joel Greenblatt

“every year that happened for every stock and it didn't make sense to me that the value of the business was right at all those times that in november it was one thing and february was another thing and they were both right so just simple powers simple again observation said gee what they're teaching me doesn't make any sense at all to me”

0.24

Greenblatt was inspired to become an investor after reading a one-page Forbes article about Ben Graham's stock-picking formula while he was in business school and studying for law school, which made sense to him whereas the efficient market hypothesis taught in business school did not.

factualspeaker onlynovelty 0/4durability 4/4· Joel Greenblatt

“i read an article in forbes uh about ben graham which is warren buffett's teacher and it was just a simple formula he had for picking stocks and showed how it worked over a long period of time and i hadn't heard of ben graham and i started reading you know i was in business school when we were learning about stocks and what we were learning is you know markets kind of random and people are really smart and it's the market's efficient so eventually uh you know uh stocks will be priced exactly and they didn't even say eventually stocks are priced at the right price and that didn't make sense to me because i read the paper and i saw that uh well at one time during the year stock was at 100 they used to have something called the 52 week high low in the newspaper and so they would show every single stock really the high for the year was 100 the low for the year was 42 and every year that happened for every stock and it didn't make sense to me that the value of the business was right at all those times”

0.20

Warren Buffett demonstrated extraordinary graciousness when Joel brought his Columbia class to visit him approximately 13 years ago, treating the students with genuine care and a real desire to teach them by example rather than dismissing them as people with nothing to offer him.

factualspeaker onlynovelty 0/4durability 3/4· Joel Greenblatt

“i got to take my columbia class to visit buffett back probably 13 years ago or so and i had never met him before...i can't think of anyone who's ever been more gracious with me you know uh not even in that position i'm saying anyone who has been more gracious with me and the students and and really the desire to teach them by example”