
Trump’s plan to force Iran to surrender is a fatal error | David Hearst | MEE Opinion
What this covers
This is a ten-minute MEE Live commentary in which David Hearst, Middle East Eye's editor-in-chief, takes on the idea that Donald Trump can repeat his Venezuela move against Iran. The piece is a sustained comparison. Venezuela had "no regional cards to play" when Maduro was seized, while Iran has plenty, and Hearst works through what separates the two cases: geography, command structure, economics, and historical memory.
The longest stretch is about the Islamic Revolutionary Guard Corps (IRGC)). Hearst describes it as comparable in size to the US Marine Corps, with the Basij militia on top of its ground, naval, and air personnel. He also presents it as an economic actor: an international banking channel, a gold and crypto trader, a controller of roughly half of Iran's oil exports, and an operator of ghost tankers. That is the basis for his mockery of Marco Rubio's supposed expectation that it would hand its budget to the US Treasury. The same logic covers Khamenei's religious authority and China's dependence on Iranian crude. The Strait of Hormuz and the wider axis of resistance are offered as reasons any war could not be kept local.
The second half is more contentious. Hearst goes back to the 1953 coup against Mohammad Mosaddegh and compares Trump's oil ambitions to the oil arrangements that followed it. He contrasts Iran's choreographed, warned response after the killing of General Qassem Soleimani with what he expects now: an unconstrained, asymmetric reply aimed at Israel's partners such as the UAE and Azerbaijan. He also argues that Trump and Netanyahu want different things, limited decapitation versus regime overthrow. Hearst further claims that Trump's need to see Iran visibly fold rules out the concession Iran demands, a stand-down of the US armada, and that Iran has already taken its ballistic missiles off the negotiating table. Several of these are the speaker's own inferences rather than established fact.
Trump's plan to strike Iran and force regime submission through military coercion will fail because Iran, unlike Venezuela, possesses deep regional power, an entrenched revolutionary leadership structure, historical resistance to foreign pressure, and the capability to wage an unconstrained asymmetric war that neither Trump nor Netanyahu can control.
- Iran has regional reach extending from Caucasus to Yemen with embedded proxy networks the US cannot easily eliminate
- The IRGC is a 150,000+ force with independent economic infrastructure, making regime decapitation militarily and politically impossible
- Iran has 70 years of historical experience resisting foreign intervention and will interpret a US strike as existential, not tactical
This asset isn't compiled yet
You're seeing its claims, ranked. Compile it to build the argument threads, weight them, and check each claim against your library — the full view.
Iran is fundamentally different from Venezuela because Iran possesses substantial regional power and strategic assets, whereas Venezuela had no regional cards to play when Maduro was seized.
“It is worth stating a very obvious fact. Iran is not Venezuela. Venezuela had no regional cards to play when Maduro was seized. Iran abounds in them.”
Ayatollah Khamenei has direct control of the Islamic Revolutionary Guard Corps (IRGC), which is the second major structural difference between Iran and Venezuela that makes regime change militarily impossible.
“Ayatollah Khamenei also has direct control of the Islamic Revolutionary Guard Corps. And that's the second major difference from Venezuela.”
The IRGC is not just a paramilitary police force, army, navy, and air force rolled into one, but also an economic powerhouse that serves as Iran's international banking system, engages in cryptocurrency mining and gold trading to circumvent international sanctions, controls about 50% of Iran's oil exports, and manages a fleet of ghost tankers.
“The IRGC is not just a paramilitary police force, army, navy, and air force rolled into one. It's also an economic powerhouse. It's Iran's international banking system, including cryptocurrency mining and gold trading to circumvent international banking controls. It controls about 50% of Iran's oil exports. It manages a fleet of ghost tankers.”
Iran has a historical memory extending at least 70 years, going back to the overthrow of Iran's democratically elected Prime Minister Mohammad Mosaddegh in a coup organized by MI6 and the CIA in 1953, which removed Iran from democratic governance and established the Shah.
“This collision course is nothing new for the Islamic Republic, which has a historical memory deeper than anything floating around in Trump's head. It goes back at least 70 years. A year after the overthrow of Iran's democratically elected Prime Minister, Mohammad Mosaddegh, in a coup organized by MI6 and the CIA in 1953, control over Iranian oil was given to the Seven Sisters.”
The IRGC can block the Strait of Hormuz unilaterally using naval mines, fast attack boats, and drones, which is a critical strategic capability because this strait is a maritime chokepoint through which 20 million barrels of crude oil, condensates, and refined petroleum products pass daily through a 33 km wide passage, and 22% of the world's trade in liquefied natural gas.
“It can block the Straits of Hormuz all on its own. It has the naval mines, fast attack boats, and drones to do it. This strait is considered a maritime choke point. 20 million barrels of crude oil, condensates, and refined petroleum products pass each day through a stretch of water 33 km wide at its narrowest. Through them, too, goes 22% of the world's trade in liquefied natural gas.”
Ayatollah Ali Khamenei is not merely the head of state and commander-in-chief of Iran's armed forces, but also the supreme political and religious authority and the spiritual leader of tens of millions of Shia Muslims around the world, including millions of the 36 million Shia living in the Middle East, which makes him impossible to remove through military strikes.
“The supreme leader, Ayatollah Ali Khamenei, is not just head of state, commander-in-chief of its armed forces, its supreme political and religious authority. He is also the spiritual leader of tens of millions of Shia Muslims around the world, including millions of the 36 million Shia who live in the Middle East.”
Trump's plan to seize or redirect Iran's oil flow would have critical geostrategic implications because China has bought approximately 90% of Iran's crude oil and condensate in recent years, and Iranian crude accounts for around 14% of China's total seaborne oil imports, making Iran a more important supplier to China than Venezuela.
“Trump's plan to seize or redirect Iran's oil flow would have geostrategic implications. It would directly impact China, which has bought in recent years about 90% of Iran's crude oil and condensate. Iranian crude accounted for around 14% of China's total seaborne oil imports, making Iran a more important supplier than Venezuela.”
The IRGC is a massive military force composed of 150,000 ground troops, 20,000 naval personnel, 15,000 air force personnel, plus the Basij militia, making it comparable in size to the US Marine Corps.
“Whereas a small Delta Force armed with a blowtorch was enough to seize Maduro, a very different prospect awaits any invader who tries to neutralize the IRGC, a force as large as the US Marine Corps. The IRGC can count on 150,000 ground troops, 20,000 naval personnel, 15,000 strong air force, plus the Basij militia.”
A war between the US and Iran would be impossible to limit geographically because Iran has reach extending from the Caucasus to Yemen, from Lebanon to Afghanistan, and the 'axis of resistance' has embedded components in Lebanon, Iraq, and Yemen that remain operational despite the loss of Syria.
“A war like this would be impossible to limit geographically. Iran has a reach which extends from the Caucasus to Yemen, from Lebanon to Afghanistan. The axis of resistance may have been dented by the loss of Syria, but its core components remain in place in Lebanon, Iraq and Yemen.”
Trump relies on two sources of information about Iran: his own intelligence assessments, which have a documented track record of being completely wrong (citing Iraq, Syria, Libya, Yemen as examples), and Israeli intelligence, which has a different geopolitical agenda focused on regime change rather than limited strikes.
“Trump has two sources of information: his own intelligent assessments, which as we know from Iraq, Syria, Libya, Yemen, you name it, have a 100% track record of being wrong. And also from the Israelis, but they have a different agenda. Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu wants regime change, not a token or limited round of air strikes.”
Israel's 2024 actions show the Israeli Air Force is no longer self-constrained before potential military action, demonstrated by its operations before the third Gulf War, indicating that any military operation with Israeli participation will likely escalate beyond original parameters.
“Last year, the Israeli Air Force showed it is no longer constrained before the kickoff to the third Gulf War.”
Neither Trump nor Netanyahu has the power to stop a Third Gulf War once started, even though both have the power to start one, because regional escalation and proxy networks would make the conflict uncontrollable.
“A third Gulf war is in Trump's and Netanyahu's power to start, but it would be neither man's power to stop.”
Iran would interpret a US military strike not as a limited tactical response comparable to past incidents, but as an existential attack on the Islamic Republic itself, which means its response would be unconstrained by any attempt to grade or limit the subsequent war.
“But the biggest difference with Venezuela is that Iran would think and react very differently than it has in the past if attacked again. It would interpret Trump's action not as a rap over the knuckles, but as an existential attack on the Islamic Republic itself. This means its response would be unconstrained by attempts to grade or to limit the war that would follow.”
An Islamic revolution that has survived eight years of war, gas attacks by Saddam Hussein, sanctions, and assassinations will not fold like Venezuela did in response to Trump's military threats, because Iran has deep institutional strength and ideological resilience that Venezuela lacked.
“Does anyone imagine that an Islamic revolution that has survived eight years of war, which included gas attacks by Saddam Hussein, which has survived sanctions and assassinations, will fold like a pack of cards as Venezuela did?”
Trump is the latest iteration of a colonial bully that Iran has been dealing with for 70 years, and this pattern shapes Iran's interpretation of and response to Trump's current threats as part of a long-standing pattern of Western intervention.
“Trump is just the latest configuration of a colonial bully that Iran is only too familiar with.”
Trump must surely refuse Iran's demand to stand down the US armada because for Trump, Iran must be seen to be folding under duress, similar to how Trump now imagines NATO to have done over Greenland—Trump's psychological need for visible submission makes compromise impossible.
“Trump must surely refuse. For him, Iran has to be seen to be folding under duress as he now imagines NATO to have done over Greenland.”
Iran's acceptance of talks is heavily caveated and Iran intends the meeting to be just the start of a long, protracted process, while Trump has no patience for negotiations and operates on a 'take it or leave it' basis with no willingness for extended diplomatic processes.
“Iranian acceptance of the talks is also heavily caveated. As ever, Iran intends the meeting in Oman to be just the start of a long, protracted process. Trump has no patience for negotiations. For him, it's take it or leave it.”
Trump's current plan to seize Iran's oil and force submission is structurally similar to the 1953-1954 arrangement where Western oil companies took control of Iranian oil, making Trump's plan a replay of historical colonial extraction patterns that Iran has already experienced and will resist.
“How similar this looks to Trump's board of peace.”
Iranian senior diplomats have stated that Iran's response to a new US strike would be asymmetric and would specifically target Israel's regional partners such as the United Arab Emirates and Azerbaijan.
“Its senior diplomats have already said its response would be asymmetric. And it would guard Israel's regional partners, such as the United Arab Emirates or Azerbaijan, as particular targets.”
Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu wants regime change in Iran, not just limited air strikes, which creates a divergence of objectives between Trump (who wants limited decapitation followed by submission) and Netanyahu (who wants full regime overthrow).
“Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu wants regime change, not a token or limited round of air strikes. He has said for some time that Hamas and Hezbollah function as the aircraft carriers for Iran.”
Iran's past responses to US military action have been restrained and choreographed to minimize casualties; five days after Trump's assassination of General Qassem Soleimani in 2020, Iran launched 12 missiles at Al Asad airbase in Iraq and another airbase in Erbil, but warned the Iraqi government first to limit casualties. This restraint will not occur again in response to a strike interpreted as existential.
“This means no more choreographed sending of messages. Five days after Trump ordered the assassination of Iran's chief military strategist, General Qassem Soleimani, in his first term as president, Iran launched 12 missiles at the Al Asad airbase in Iraq, as well as another airbase in Erbil that the US military were using. But to limit casualties, it warned the Iraqi government first. It would not do that this time.”
Iran has already removed its ballistic missile fleet from the negotiating table because surrendering it would leave the country defenseless, while Trump and Israel demand that missiles be included in negotiations.
“Iran has already taken its ballistic missile fleet off the negotiating table. To surrender it would leave the country defenseless. Trump and Israel demands that it's on the table.”
Iran will not negotiate while facing the threat of military attack and will demand the standing down of the US armada as proof of good faith before making any progress on uranium enrichment negotiations.
“Nor will Iran negotiate with the sword of Damocles hanging over its head. At some point in the negotiation, it will demand the standing down of the US Armada as proof of good faith before any progress or offer can be made on their uranium enrichment project.”
Trump should study history before making what could prove to be the costliest foreign policy mistake of his presidency, because historical precedent suggests Iran will not submit and the conflict would be uncontrollable.
“Trump should read history before making what could prove to be the costliest foreign policy mistake of his presidency.”
Secretary of State Marco Rubio's assumption that the IRGC would submit Iran's annual budget to the US Treasury for approval after a US strike is delusional because the IRGC owns an elaborate global infrastructure specifically designed to circumvent international sanctions and maintain independence.
“So, what does Rubio think would happen the day after a US strike? Does he imagine that the IRGC, the owner of an elaborate global infrastructure to circumvent international sanctions, would submit Iran's annual budget to the US Treasury for approval? If so, he is dreaming.”
Trump's envoy Steve Witkoff and son-in-law Jared Kushner have communicated to regional powers Trump's plan for Iran, which involves a quick but limited air strike designed to decapitate the regime while leaving it in place, followed by a deal in which Iran surrenders both its nuclear program and its oil to the US in exchange for allowing Boeing back into Iran.
“His envoy, Steve Witkoff, and his son-in-law, Jared Kushner, have told one regional power what Trump thinks he can do to and with Iran. A quick but limited air strike, which decapitates the regime, but leaves it in place. This is followed by a deal in which Iran surrenders both the nuclear program and its oil to the US, in return for which Trump will kindly allow Boeing back in.”
The prospects of talks averting a war with Iran are approximately one in ten because the fundamental incompatibilities between Trump's negotiating approach and Iran's position make peaceful resolution extremely unlikely.
“With all this in mind, I'll put the prospects of talks averting a war at about one in 10.”
By 1973, the Shah was moving toward full nationalization of Iranian oil through a new agreement giving the National Iranian Oil Company operational control, setting the stage for complete Iranian ownership, but this process was interrupted by worker strikes that preceded the Iranian Revolution.
“The Shah was setting the stage for nationalization, but all of this was too late as a series of worker strikes preceded the revolution.”
The Seven Sisters was a consortium of the world's leading oil companies (BP, Mobil, Chevron, Exxon, Texaco, Shell, and Total) that was given control of Iranian oil following the 1953 CIA-MI6 coup that overthrew Mosaddegh.
“This was the name given to a consortium of the world's leading oil companies, the companies that were later to become BP, Mobil, Chevron, Exxon, Texaco, Shell, and Total.”
The Shah of Iran, Mohammad Reza Pahlavi, got only half of the profits from the 1954 oil agreement giving national oil company operational control, which was inadequate compensation for national resources and was the beginning of the end for the Shah's legitimacy.
“The Shah of Iran, Mohammad Reza Pahlavi, got only half of the profits from the 1954 agreement. And by 1973, even he was wearying. A new 20-year agreement was signed giving the National Iranian Oil Company operational control.”
Trump's authority domestically may be damaged after the shootings of two white Americans in Minnesota, but he maintains influence internationally and has used military threats and diplomatic pressure to advance US interests in multiple theaters including NATO negotiations over Greenland, pressure on Europe to increase defense spending, seizure of Venezuelan President Nicolás Maduro, and now plans to strike Iran.
“Donald Trump's authority may be in shreds after the shootings of two white Americans in Minnesota, but on the international stage, Trump still thinks he is Mr. Big. He bullied NATO into a framework for a future deal over Greenland... He's got Europe to pay for more of its own defense. He seized President Nicolas Maduro... now he's assembled an armada of ships and bombers to strike Iran for the second time in a year.”
Trump's Gulf allies have expressed massive concern about potential war with Iran. Talks between Iran and the US were held in Iran on Friday and have been stuttering on and off for three days, with initial plans for an international forum of foreign ministers in Istanbul to prevent negotiations from becoming a direct power struggle between Trump and Khamenei.
“The concern of Trump's Gulf allies is massive. Talks between Iran and the US were held in Iran on Friday, and they've been stuttering on and off for the last 3 days. They were scheduled to be held in Istanbul, and the initial plan by Turkey's foreign minister, Hakan Fidan, was an international forum of foreign ministers. The idea was to prevent negotiation becoming an arm wrestling match between Trump and Khamenei.”
Ayatollah Khamenei objected to Turkey's proposal for an international forum and insisted on bilateral talks with only the US focused exclusively on the nuclear enrichment issue, while the US then objected and threatened to pull out, sparking a major regional lobbying effort involving at least nine different countries trying to keep negotiations alive.
“However, the supreme leader objected and just wanted talks with the US and only on the nuclear enrichment issue. The US side then objected and threatened to pull out. This sparked a huge regional lobbying effort involving at least nine different countries. The phones must have been ringing in the Oval Office.”
Both Trump and Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu are power-drunk, believe they are masters of the universe, have pilots with real-time targeting information, and have stopped thinking there are any constraints on what they can do militarily.
“Both men are power drunk. Both believe they are masters of the universe. Their pilots operate off real-time information, almost to the minute, on where targets can be located and eliminated. So, they have long since stopped thinking there are any constraints on what they can do.”
Trump believes the Islamic Republic has been weakened by US air strikes ordered last year and by a major wave of national unrest that was suppressed only at significant cost in lives, making now the opportune moment to strike Iran.
“Trump is also convinced that now is the time to strike. He thinks the Islamic Republic has been weakened both by the air strikes he ordered last year and a major wave of national unrest, which was suppressed only at the cost of thousands of lives.”