
Students Destroy International Competition with Eurodollar Knowledge [Ep. 245 Eurodollar University]
What this covers
This episode is a conversation between host Jeff Snider, Emil Kalinowski, and the Pine Richland High School team that won the International Public Policy Forum (IPPF)) debate. The students are Amish Sepui, Miles Brown, Cali Scholz, Andrew Knee and Matt Farmer. They are joined by their advisor Matt Roberts and by John Urban, a refinance professional who helped explain the subject to them. Much of the first half is logistics. The topic was whether dollar hegemony harms the world economy. Teams argued both sides in written rounds from October to March, then the finalists met for oral rounds in a single day, with questioning from judges that grew harder as the experts took over. The written panel was about 300 coaches, professors and past champions.
The middle of the conversation covers how the team found its edge. Their first real introduction to the eurodollar system was a 2014 Vanderbilt Law Journal article on the "monetary fifth column", which tied reliance on one currency to credit multiplier effect spillovers. The students also describe judges who first took "eurodollar" to mean dollars used in Europe, while opponents stayed confused. Their conclusion was hedged: hegemony is detrimental, but no better alternative exists, and the structural problems look insoluble. Snider adds Michael Pettis's argument that the dollar's "exorbitant privilege" is really an "exorbitant burden."
The closing stretch turns contentious and general. Roberts argues that education at every level has a paradigm problem. Urban says people from outside an industry are better at challenging its status quo. Snider says monetary scholarship has dried up and that anyone who wants to be heard must work outside economics as a discipline. The team's mixed backgrounds, which include philosophy, neuroscience, engineering, history and computer science, are offered as a possible advantage. Urban says he learned about eurodollars by listening to Eurodollar University, not through formal training.
A high school debate team from Pine Richland won an international championship by deploying the eurodollar system as a counterintuitive argument about dollar hegemony, demonstrating that grassroots independent research outside mainstream economics can outcompete orthodox thinking.
- The team discovered the eurodollar system through independent research and found it was largely unknown to their competitors and judges
- Their success came from questioning mainstream economic consensus rather than accepting established frameworks
- The team's diversity of academic backgrounds and outsider perspective gave them advantage over conventional economics training
This asset isn't compiled yet
You're seeing its claims, ranked. Compile it to build the argument threads, weight them, and check each claim against your library — the full view.
A Vanderbilt Law Journal article from 2014 titled "The Monetary Fifth Column: The Eurodollar's Threat to Financial Stability and Economic Sovereignty" was the team's first major introduction to the eurodollar system and broke down how over-reliance on a single exchange currency can lead to credit multiplier effects and spillover effects as large as the 2008 recession.
“there is an article in the vanderbilt uh law journal in 2014 called the monetary fifth column the euro dollar threats financial stability and economic sovereignty uh that was our first major introduction to euro dollar and it really broke down in detail through small examples how an over-reliance on a single exchange in dollars can lead to a credit multiplier effect that can lead to spillover effects are as large as the 2008 recession”
The Pine Richland High School debate team won the International Public Policy Forum, an international (not just national) championship debate competition.
“you are the international champions not national champions but international champions of this particular debate contest that's correct world champions”
The eurodollar system was central to the team's argument about dollar hegemony, representing a largely unknown but critically important aspect of global monetary architecture that gives the United States disproportionate power through sanctions capabilities.
“when you look at it there's definitely significant harms such as like the entire euro dollar system such teams say gives the united states too much power with sanctions”
The ability to challenge the status quo and think critically about established systems is a rare and valued skill in professional environments, particularly in the financial services industry, and is more likely to be possessed by people who come from outside the industry rather than people trained within its traditions.
“if there's one skill set that i have that i that i would say that is the reason for my employment right now in the financial services industry it's because i challenge the status quo every single day um so i would certainly say that that is a very rare uh rare skill to have um and i think i possess it only because i don't come from this industry i came into it so um so for the same reason that you guys were outside of mainstream um you know economics and you trounced your competition in the debate i think you guys could bring that same mindset into any industry”
Dollar hegemony was commonly taught to be beneficial to the United States through the concept of 'exorbitant privilege,' but economist Michael Pettis argued in an article that dollar hegemony is actually an 'exorbitant burden' on the United States.
“i remember the first time i ever came across the idea that dollar hegemony is back bad for the united states i was always taught that dollar hegemony is good for the united states and there are great benefits that's the exorbitant privilege i remember reading for the first time uh an article by michael pettis an economist and historian out in china and he wrote that it's in fact the opposite that it's an exorbitant burden”
The healthy function of an education system includes challenging students who demand more and push the system to question orthodox ways of thinking.
“there's definitely a lot more people like them in their generation that are doing that that are placing demands on the educational system um that are healthy right because again as as jeff said we don't know enough about this”
The written debate rounds were judged by previous IPPF champions, debate competitors, professors from NYU, and NYU debate team members - a total panel of about 300 debate coaches, economics professors and advisors - requiring teams to balance debate and technical jargon while maintaining content accuracy for diverse judge backgrounds.
“so it was previous champions of the international public policy forum other order competitors we had a couple of professors from new york university and then also a lot of the new york university debate team so it was about 300 uh debate coaches economics professors and advisors so you had a real plethora of people that you had to balance between using debate and technical jargon and also really making sure you're sticking true to the content so that um you could appeal to apparel judges”
High school debate team members Cali Schulz, Andrew Knee, Matt Farmer, Miles Brown, Amish Sepi, and a sixth unnamed member are all Pine Richland High School seniors heading to prestigious universities (University of Pittsburgh Honors College, Brown University, Olin College of Engineering, Grinnell College, University of Pennsylvania, Cornell).
“i'm cali scholz scultz i'm going to be going to the university of pittsburgh honors college... andrew knee i'll be going to brown university... matt farmer and i'll be going to the olin college of engineering... miles brown i'm majoring at in majoring in history at grinnell college... amish sepi and i will be attending the university of pennsylvania... we have one more member who's not here missing one uh who will be going to cornell”
The oral rounds had a structured format consisting of: a 5-minute introduction speech for top 8 (expanding to 8 minutes for top 4 and top 2) laying out the general case, a questioning period between teams, a 5-minute rebuttal speech from the second speaker, 10-20 minutes of questioning from judges that became progressively harder as more expert judges evaluated later rounds, and a final 5-minute summary speech - with all three rounds (top 8, top 4, finals) occurring in a single day.
“as for like the oral rounds uh that was from top eight on so top eight top four and then the finals those were all oral rounds in new york and the format for that was you had a introduction speech for five minutes that laid out your general case for top eight and then for top four and top two that was eight minutes long and then both sides would give that and then there would be a questioning period uh from both teams where you ask each other questions to try to poke holes in each other's cases and then after that the second speaker on our team would give a five-minute speech kind of rebutting their points and uh going over like the questioning that gone on between the both teams after that there was then questioning from the judges that was like 10 to 20 minutes long and that actually got progressively harder as it went on since there was more experts that knew about dollar hegemony as we've gone on through the rounds so that actually became one of the most important parts of the debate the questioning from the judges themselves because you could really tell what they liked about your case and what they didn't”
The debate topic was whether dollar hegemony is detrimental to the world economy, requiring students to argue both pro and con sides over a six-month period from October to March, culminating in a 10-page essay and multiple rounds of written debate.
“the international public policy forum was a debate that's both essay and oral arguments and so for about six months starting in october and going to around march we were given the topic that dollar had gen mini is detrimental to the word economy and it was our job to create a case on both the pro and con side of that argument which we laid out in about a 10-page essay”
Judges in the first two debate rounds were initially confused about what the eurodollar system was, thinking it referred to dollars used in Europe, giving the Pine Richland team a competitive advantage because opponents remained confused while judges gradually understood.
“we ran the euro dollar argument in our first two rounds and our opponents both times didn't know what it was they thought it was like dollars used in europe and i had no clue what they're arguing but like we kept going we re-explained it and eventually we were able to get to a boy where we were able to have the judges understand it but not the opponents which was pretty good for us ended up working out”
The current education system at all levels (K through doctoral) has a paradigm problem that results in significant ignorance about important topics like the eurodollar system and dollar hegemony.
“we don't know enough about this and we have this sort of paradigm that clearly is the result of a k through doctoral level education system so what are we doing and what are we doing wrong as an education system”
The eurodollar system's inherent problems with the global monetary system cannot really be solved currently, making it an insoluble structural problem that the team identified.
“it plays such a large role in the international market outside of the us and i kind of think that's why we centered most of our case around it because we realized oh this is a big deal and it has ramifications for the global economy that honestly like right now can't be really solved for so it's like inherent problems with um the global monetary system”
The final decision of the Pine Richland team was that dollar hegemony is detrimental but there is no current better alternative, making it still the best available option despite its problems.
“i feel like i'd say it is detrimental but there's no current better alternative it's kind of like i think it concludes with all kind of breeds because when you look at it there's definitely significant harms such as like the entire euro dollar system such teams say gives the united states too much power with sanctions but when you ask the question a simple question what are we going to do about it it seems like there's no solution to the problem so i think yes detrimental but for now it's the best thing we have”
Monetary scholarship has dried up significantly over the past many decades, limiting available research on important topics like dollar hegemony and the eurodollar system.
“you know this thing is so huge it's so important but yet monetary scholarship of any type dried up so many uh so many decades ago”
The Pine Richland team's accomplishment is remarkable precisely because these are young people who grew up without experiencing a real booming economy yet are taking initiative to understand and critique the economic systems that will shape their futures.
“you're the ones who've grown up without having any idea what a really booming economy looks like and yet you're you're taking the ball and running with it and moving uh into different uh different disciplines”
The unique strategy of using specialized, unfamiliar arguments is considered 'number one key to success' in debate competitions because catching opponents off guard with arguments they haven't encountered provides competitive advantage.
“in a debate competition what we believe is like the number one key to success is uniqueness you want to catch your opponents off guard with the argument that they haven't heard before”
One of the main frustrations for those like Jeff and Emil who work on monetary topics is that they must go outside of economics as a discipline in order to get their message heard and make a difference, and the Pine Richland team has had to do the same.
“we have to go outside of economics in order to get the message heard in order to make a difference and the fact that you guys have run into the same problem and accomplish the same sort of thing is incredibly incredibly hopeful”
The team's diversity of academic interests and backgrounds (Politics/Philosophy, Neuroscience, Biomedical Engineering, History, Computer Science) may have been advantageous compared to a team composed entirely of economics students, because it allowed them to approach the topic from a fresh, non-paradigm perspective.
“i just think that's a really important point that this is a group with a lot of diverse interests and sitting here listening to them talk to each other and the things they were referencing that that played out i think in this whole process if you had put a bunch of kids who are all going off to college to major in economics together i don't know that they would have gone to this point um their diversity of interests really played to their advantage here”
Society is being moved forward by people avoiding economics as a major and instead approaching economic topics from outside the discipline.
“society is being moved forward because they're avoiding yes but that's that's i think the overall frustration”
The research process for the debate required accessing in-depth academic journals and academic sources that aren't accessible to people outside the economics major because they use technical terminology, making background research and searching necessary to understand the relevant literature.
“i think in some ways that might have been the hardest part because a lot of the in-depth analysis and journals that we're looking into really aren't accessible to people that aren't in the economics major because they use a lot of technical terms so it took a lot of background information and searching to really get what we're looking for”
John Urban knows about the eurodollar system because he listens to Eurodollar University podcast, and learned about it through that independent research rather than through formal training or institutional education.
“um yeah as mr robert said um it came up over a backyard fire and euro dollar system is not not a topic you expect to hear in that setting maybe for your background backyard fires jeff or emils but not for us so it was um kind of shocking that that came up and that question came up but i mean everything that i know about it i know because i listen to this show um so it was you know i was floored that the question was posed in such a way”
The debate team's success was a group effort that depended on support from multiple teachers, advisors, parents, and the sixth team member (Tyx) who is not present in the recording, and the students want to publicly thank all these people for their support.
“one final time we want to thank mr roberts mr baiko mr urban and everyone else that's made it possible especially our parents i know tyx not here we also want to thank him um it's it's really a group effort and i mean it's our ability to push forward and have the support that we had you know staying up late nights like our parents let us do that being able to talk to mr roberts and being able to bounce ideas off of it all of that really allowed us to push forward and go to the next level and um it wouldn't be possible without them so we just like to end with a major thank you to everyone”
The eurodollar system was introduced to the team and educators through a serendipitous chain of events: Mr. Roberts mentioned the debate topic to his neighbor John Urban (a refinance professional) during a backyard fire conversation, and John Urban then volunteered to meet virtually with the team to help explain the eurodollar system.
“i happen to be sitting with mr urban with john around the fire in my backyard john is my neighbor and uh is involved in refinance and i was telling him about this wonderful group of young people and what they're working on and how successful they've been and john said oh yeah i know all about that and just started going off talking about eurodollar and so he volunteered to meet with this group virtually and sort of help all of us wrap our heads around the euro dollar system um and that was hugely beneficial”
Matt Roberts is a champion of the public education system and believes that groups of great students in the right environment can do wonderful things, and he has been amazed by many groups of students throughout his career but considers the Pine Richland team to be particularly outstanding.
“no i'm just always a champion for you know the public education system in america and how you know a group of great students like this in the right environment can do wonderful things and i mean it's i'm amazed every year i have a group of students that amazes me but these guys are really up there i won't ever forget this group”
The Pine Richland debate team relieved that none of the members are pursuing economics, viewing the discipline as problematic or insufficiently rigorous for their purposes.
“i'm relieved to hear no one is studying economics yeah no one's pursuing that good that's what we're gonna say”
The team created a 'block file' - a massive document containing all possible arguments and rebuttals from all opponent cases - by reviewing the prior cases written by all competing teams before the oral rounds, allowing them to quickly access pre-prepared rebuttals during the debate.
“he created what i guess in debate is known as kind of a block file where we try and go through all of the team's cases because before the oral rounds in new york city we got all of the teams prior cases that they had written in this competition so we spent a lot of time going through those and seeing okay what is just about every possible argument that could be made and then how can we respond to it so you put that in a massive document and so essentially in the middle of the debate if they kind of try and come up with a certain argument you can quickly go oh okay we have this in our file here's what we can rebut with it and have it lined up that way”
Once the team arrived at the finals in New York City, the stress level decreased and they felt 'really happy to just make it there in the first place,' which freed them to 'really just give this our all' with a more relaxed approach to competition.
“i feel like i can speak for i don't know you guys that it got a little almost less stressful going like once we got there because i mean we were really happy to just make it there in the first place and so then i think we kind of decided you know what we're really just gonna like give this our all and really like just see what we can do um and kind of take that attitude towards it”
A frustration in the research process was finding points they wanted to prove but then having difficulty locating evidence for them, and additionally finding that evidence for dollar hegemony benefits often came from US-influenced sources like the IMF, raising questions about bias in the available literature.
“i think from a research perspective something that was like very frustrating for us was just like sometimes we had points we wanted to prove and then we were just like trying to kind of find the evidence for it so you spend so much time like scrolling through articles uh looking for something and then also you know you would find a lot of articles on the benefits of dollar hegemony but um but it would come from like the imf or something like that that's like you know pretty us run and so it's like oh like this is the stat we need but like you know how biased is that”
John Urban has the opportunity to serve as a mentor and model to the debate team, demonstrating how challenging the status quo in the financial services industry can lead to career success and professional value.
“i think you guys could bring that same mindset into any industry and uh and have the same effect so yeah be optimistic about that”
The most terrifying aspect of the eurodollar system to one student was understanding how much power unregulated banks have and that trillions of dollars of the global economy are based on trusting banks without federal regulation to oversee transactions with near-complete freedom, which can lead to financial crises like 2008 and potentially much worse ones in the future.
“especially with the euro dollar it's kind of just terrifying to understand like how much power banks have and how trillions of dollars of our economy are just based on the idea that we are trusting banks without any federal regulation to oversee transactions with almost uh complete or complete freeness and like a lazy affair level that led to the 2008 recession and could be significantly worse in the future was a bit alarming”
The Eurodollar University audience and community will particularly appreciate and value the Pine Richland team's achievement and research on the eurodollar system.
“we need to get you guys more recognition from the euro dollar community in particular which is why we wanted to have you on here because if there's one place that's going to love what you guys did and the accomplishment here it's going to be eurodollar university and our audience”
The entire team contracted COVID-19 and had to quarantine for a week during the competition, during which they wrote an essay, but the isolation also eliminated distractions and allowed them to develop major research points and arguments.
“uh the phone uh for the six of us all got covered so we all had to go to quarantine and like get a week to write an essay um so that was chaotic time um but the one bad news about foreign warranty is that you're stuck in your room but the good news is there's not many distractions so uh that single week in our room we actually uh got some major points and uh developed a lot of research in that time period so i guess adapting to online life for a second time was probably the hardest difficulty”
The team's primary motivation evolved from wanting to achieve progression through the bracket to the goal of winning an all-expenses-paid trip to New York City, which seemed initially elusive but became more tangible with each round advancement.
“i think i think also at the beginning it was really just you know getting into top 64 and then there was this like looming oh there's this possibility of new york city which um on like an all expenses paid trip which seemed very like elusive at the time but each round like we kept getting a little closer and so it's like you know we would have late nights but it would be like okay push through it because because like new york city we'll get like we really want to get to new york city and finally you know we got there”
The team adopted a more dignified, research paper tone rather than sarcasm or humor in their written submissions, learning from opponents who used sarcastic approaches and lost.
“i'd argue more of like a research paper tone kind of like putting in the jokes it was kind of funny our opponents kind of took that approach of sarcasm like you're arguing about like the arms of like debt and like china's death trap diplomacy and they responded in like a written format quote oh the horrors of chinese dead trash diplomacy but they try to take that sarcastic approach and they lost so i think we kind of learned from that and trying to be a lot more dignified and formal in our tone i think that kind of helped us throughout the written rounds”
The team spent 'hours and hours' scrolling through JSTOR and other academic sources, searching for articles and building comprehensive documentation, representing the necessary but unglamorous labor underlying intellectual work.
“the biggest part was just scrolling hours and hours through saving different articles and like jstor and these other academic sources to get everything together”
The team strategically changed its argument for the final round based on the judge panel composition (which included former Federal Reserve chair John Sexton and other mainstream economists), switching from the eurodollar argument to arguing that US dollar hegemony is beneficial—a decision that resulted in an unprecedented 5-0 unanimous judge vote.
“for our final round we had people like dr john sexton former chair of the federal reserve william brewer the nra like we had various like mainstream people for that so for those rounds what we decided to was we picked the side where you don't have to argue a dollar we argue that united states government and germany was good and like strategically that worked because we went on a 5-0 unlike all the judges voted for us it's like the first time that's ever happened”
The team's preparation and research process exemplifies the 'very definition of independent study' and 'grassroots research,' precisely the methodology that Eurodollar University and its hosts prioritize over mainstream media and establishment sources.
“the grassroots nature of this this is not something that's being taught in schools this is it this is the very definition of independent study very definition of grass grassroots research which is what emil and i do all the time you know we're not we're not interested watching cnbc or watching the mainstream bloomberg channels or reading pardon me the council on foreign relations view on the us dollar we want to dig into the details we want to get into the research”
The team's success required significant parental support—allowing them to stay up late nights for research, financing their competition participation, and supporting the all-expenses-paid NYC trip—without which 'it wouldn't be possible.'
“we want to thank mr roberts mr baiko mr urban and everyone else that's made it possible especially our parents i know tyx not here we also want to thank him um it's it's really a group effort and i mean it's our ability to push forward and have the support that we had you know staying up late nights like our parents let us do that being able to talk to mr roberts and being able to bounce ideas off of it all of that really allowed us to push forward and go to the next level and um it wouldn't be possible without them”
All team members have been involved in debate since their freshman year, indicating sustained engagement and development over a multi-year period.
“this is a team that he has sort of fostered and helped to grow since they were freshmen i think everybody here has been involved in debates since freshman year is that correct yeah yeah yeah”
Mr. Baiko, the debate club sponsor and English teacher, had fostered the team since they were freshmen and retirement in the same year as their championship win was a high note on which to end his teaching career.
“i'm actually not the debate uh club sponsor um that's mr baiko who is just an outstanding educator here at prime ridgeland and he's retiring this year so it was a huge triumph for him uh to have a team like this that you know goes all the way i mean literally as high as you can go and wins and it's been a fantastic year for him to go out on that high note retire from teaching”
Andrew Knee will attend Brown University to study neuroscience under an eight-year program of liberal medical education that leads directly to medical school.
“hi my name is andrew knee i'll be going to brown university to study neuroscience under their program of liberal medical education which is like an eight-year program so i'll end up going to medical school directly”
Matt Farmer will attend Olin College of Engineering and will major in Biomedical Engineering.
“hello my name is matt farmer and i'll be going to the olin college of engineering and i'll be majoring in biomedical engineering next year”
Miles Brown is majoring in History at Grinnell College on the Founders Scholarship.
“hi my name is miles brown i'm majoring at in majoring in history at grinnell college on the founders scholarship”
One team member (not present in the recording) will be attending Cornell, completing a six-person team.
“and we have one more member who's not here missing one uh who will be going to cornell”
Cali Scholz is attending the University of Pittsburgh Honors College as a Chancellor Scholar and will major in Politics and Philosophy.
“so hi i'm cali scholz scultz i'm going to be going to the university of pittsburgh honors college is a chancellor scholar and there i'll be doing a politics and philosophy major”
Miles Brown's parents called him throughout his oral debate day in New York to get updates on his performance.
“my parents have been invested in like me and my sister and debate for a really long time they obviously like allowing us to go to new york they were kind of hesitant about that in the beginning just because like it's a trip without them but they obviously supported that and they're calling me throughout his miles talking about the day getting updates”
The team's advancement through each round was celebrated by the family, with each round advancement treated as a major milestone worthy of celebration, similar to March Madness tournament bracket advancement.
“i imagine it was like march madness right every time you advance around and you gotta you gotta throw the major the big party and the cut down i don't know you don't there's no nets to cut down but it was you know like tournament play every time you advance for another round further you know you have to stop and celebrate right yeah exactly”
Miles Brown's sister also participated in the competition and made it to the top 16 before being eliminated, creating a family dynamic where Miles eventually surpassed her achievement.
“my sister also did the competition and she got to top 16 and got out so she was actually mad but it was great because while she was mad my parents love me more now obviously i'm the favorite child”
The team received recognition from Pine Richland High School in the form of a poster, which they describe as 'very fun,' though they acknowledge limited broader institutional recognition beyond the school poster.
“we got a shout out from the school it was it was really nice um we got uh a little poster that was it was very fun um so no i we got in recognition we're happy with it”
Jeff Snider went from not having read the specific Vanderbilt Law Journal article on eurodollars to asking the team to help expand the research community's understanding of it, demonstrating openness to learning from younger researchers.
“there is an article in the vanderbilt uh law journal in 2014 called the monetary fifth column... uh that was our first major introduction to euro dollar... jeff have you ever read that article i don't know if i've ever run across it be honest with you we've got to get yeah i think i do”
Generation X parents love the younger generation, presumably more than they loved Generation X members based on the contrast Emil makes.
“so but now you guys are the younger generation you guys i believe you might still be millennials or you're on the cusp of that new generation that hasn't been made i'm not sure but generally it's my sense that parents love you guys love you guys”
Generation X parents were suspicious of their children and contributed to trouble-making behavior, whereas the younger generation (the debate team) represents a contrast in being highly accomplished and driven without these problematic behaviors.
“and emil and i are both members of generation x and our parents didn't care for us they were suspicious of us we are up to trouble all the time it's all true all the worst stories are heard it's actually worse so but now you guys are the younger generation”