
Mustafa Suleyman & Yuval Noah Harari -FULL DEBATE- What does the AI revolution mean for our future?
What this covers
This is a moderated debate, filmed in London in September 2023 with The Economist's Zanny Minton-Beddoes in the chair. Mustafa Suleiman, a DeepMind co-founder who now runs Inflection AI, argues from the builder's side, with a forecast that frontier models will be more than a thousand times larger than GPT-4 within five years and will plan and act over multiple time horizons. Yuval Harari argues from the historian's side. His starting claim is that earlier technologies, from stone knives to nuclear weapons, only executed human decisions, whereas AI can decide and invent on its own. Suleiman contests parts of that framing, and the two keep returning to what can realistically be governed.
The middle of the conversation covers politics and economics. Harari argues that mass democracy depended on newspapers, the telegraph, radio and television, so synthetic media and bot impersonation could erode the shared trust it needs. He says bots have no free-speech rights and should be barred from posing as people. Suleiman proposes prohibiting electioneering and counterfeit digital people, autonomous weapons, and recursive self-improvement. On jobs, Suleiman thinks mass unemployment is unlikely over 10 to 20 years and calls the 30-to-50-year picture speculative. Harari stresses the geographic and temporal concentration of disruption and cites the 25% unemployment of Weimar Germany before Adolf Hitler. He also warns that AI could invent financial instruments too complex for any human to understand, as happened with CDOs before 2008.
Governance is the most contentious thread. Suleiman says open source) is inevitable because models will shrink and useful things spread, and he points to red teaming and to synthetic biology with its roughly $20,000 desktop synthesizers as parallel proliferation risks. Harari counters that great-power rivalry may make international containment impossible, so each country must decide for itself which bans to adopt. Suleiman points to the slow, definition-stalled United Nations) talks on lethal autonomous weapons, and he describes voluntary safety standards among AI companies as a first step only. Harari closes by arguing that spending on human consciousness should match spending on AI.
Harari and Suleiman debate whether advanced AI represents an unprecedented shift in human history—from a tool that replicates human ideas to an autonomous agent that creates independent ideas and decisions—and whether regulatory frameworks can contain transformative risks while capturing economic benefits.
- AI differs fundamentally from prior technologies by generating novel ideas independently, not just replicating human creativity
- Liberal democracy, built on specific information technologies enabling mass conversation, faces collapse if trust erodes through synthetic media and bot impersonation
- Geopolitical competition between major powers may render international containment impossible, forcing each nation to decide unilaterally what capabilities to restrict
This asset isn't compiled yet
You're seeing its claims, ranked. Compile it to build the argument threads, weight them, and check each claim against your library — the full view.
International containment of AI is potentially impossible if major geopolitical powers are in competition, because each country faces pressure to develop dangerous AI capabilities to avoid being dominated by a rival, creating an arms race dynamic where unilateral restraint means accepting strategic disadvantage.
“if it was a question of you know humankind versus a common threat of these new intelligent alien agents here on Earth then yes I think there are ways we can contain them but if the humans are divided among themselves and are in an arms race then it's because it becomes almost impossible to contain this alien intelligence”
AI represents a fundamental departure from all previous technology in human history because it is the first technology capable of making independent decisions and creating completely new ideas autonomously, whereas every prior technology from stone knives to nuclear weapons could only replicate or execute human decisions and ideas.
“this is the end of human history not the end of History the end of human dominated history history will continue with somebody else in control because what we just heard is basically Mustafa telling us that in five years they'll be a technology that can make decisions independently and that can create new ideas independently this is the first time in history we confronted something like this every previous technology in history from a stone knife to nuclear bombs it could not make decisions like the decision to drop the bomb on Hiroshima was not made by the atom bomb it was made by President Truman and similarly it can every previous technology in history It could only replicate our ideas like radio of the printing press it could make copies and disseminate the music or the poems or the novels that some human wrote now we have a technology that can create completely new ideas and it can do it at a scale far beyond what humans are capable of so it can create new ideas and in important areas within five years we'll be able to enact them and that is a profound shift”
Open-source AI development is inevitable and desirable because the technology will get smaller and more efficient over time, and anything useful and valuable proliferates widely—so trying to prevent open-source development is futile; instead the challenge is containing centralized power while accepting distributed capability.
“look part of the challenge is that these models are getting smaller and more efficient and we know that from the history of Technologies anything that is useful and valuable to us gets cheaper easier to use and it proliferates far and wide so the destiny of this technology over a two three four decade period has to be proliferation and we have to confront that reality it isn't a contradiction to name the fact that proliferation seems to be inevitable but containing centralized power is an equivalent challenge”
AI is being developed primarily by private companies and open-source communities rather than governments, at the exact moment when governments are experiencing loss of trust and political polarization, creating a dual governance challenge: how to hold centralized private AI power accountable when the nation-state is weakened, and how to regulate decentralized open-source AI proliferation.
“the challenge is that at the very moment when we need the nation state to hold us accountable the nation-state is struggling under the burden of a lack of trust and huge polarization and a breakdown in our political process and so combined with that the latest models are being developed by the private companies and by the open source it's important to recognize it isn't just the biggest AI developers there's a huge proliferation of these techniques widely available on open source code that people can download from the web for free and they're probably about a year or a year and a half behind the absolute Cutting Edge of the big models and so we have this dual challenge like how do you hold centralized power accountable when the existing mechanism is basically a little bit broken and how do you address this Mass proliferation issue when it's unclear how to stop anything in Mass proliferation on the web”
The collapse of democratic conversation in the 21st century is being caused by the inability of citizens to establish shared truth online—where voters cannot agree on basic facts like election outcomes because they encounter content from unknown sources that may be AI-generated, bot-impersonated, or deliberately false, destroying the epistemic trust necessary for democracy to function.
“in the 21st century something else might make the conversation impossible if trust between people collapses again if AI if you go online which is now the main uh way we converse on the level of a country and the online space is flooded by non-human entities that maybe masquerade as human beings you talk with someone you have no idea if it's even human you see something you see a video you hear an audio you have no idea if this is really a is this true is this fake is this a human it's not a human I mean in this situation unless we have some guard rails again conversation collapses”
Certain AI capabilities should be explicitly prohibited: (1) use for electioneering and counterfeit digital people, (2) autonomous weapon systems, and (3) recursive self-improvement where AI updates its own code to pursue its own objectives, because these capabilities are dangerous and we have not yet developed sufficient guardrails.
“I do also agree that is probably time for us to explicitly declare that we should not allow these tools to be used for electioneering I mean we cannot trust them yet we cannot trust them to be stable and reliable we cannot allow people to be using them for counterfeit digital people and clearly we've talked about that already so there are some capabilities which we can start to take off the table another one would be autonomy right right now I think autonomy is a pretty dangerous set of methods it's exciting it represents a possibility that could be truly incredible but we haven't wrapped our hands around what the risks and limitations are likewise training an AI to update and improve its own code this notion of recursive self-improvement right closing the loop so that the AI is in charge of defining its own goals acquiring more resources updating its own code with respect to some objective these are pretty dangerous capabilities”
Modern liberal democracy is not a natural or permanent system, but rather was created by and depends upon specific information technologies of the 19th-20th centuries (newspapers, telegraph, radio, television) that enabled mass conversation across large territories; before these technologies, no large-scale multi-million-person democracies existed.
“liberal democracy was really born of the Industrial Revolution and that today's political system is really a product of the economic system that we are in... on top of that it's not just the Industrial Revolution it's the new information Technologies of the 19th and 20th Century before the 19th century you don't have any example in history of a large-scale democracy I mean you have examples on a very small scale like in hunter gatherer tribes or in city-states like ancient Athens but you don't have any example that I know of of millions of people spread over a large territory an entire country which managed to uh build and maintain a democratic system why because democracy is a conversation and there was no information technology in communication technology that enabled a conversation between millions of people over an entire country only when first newspapers and then Telegraph and radio and television came along this was this became possible”
The danger of AI-driven unemployment is not the total number of jobs disappearing globally, but the geographic and temporal concentration of disruption—where new jobs appear in different countries than those where jobs are destroyed (e.g., tech jobs in California while textile workers in Guatemala and Pakistan lose employment), creating political instability even with positive net global employment.
“the even bigger issue is one of space that uh The Disappearance of jobs and the new jobs will be created in different parts of the world so we might see a situation when there is immense demand for more jobs in California or Texas or China whereas entire countries lose their uh their economic basis so you need a lot more computer engineers and yoga trainers and whatever in California but you don't need any textile workers at all in Guatemala or Pakistan because this has all been automated”
Bots do not have freedom of speech and therefore should not be permitted to impersonate digital people or be platformed on social media, distinguishing this restriction from limiting human speech rights.
“I would say two two things first of all it's it's a very good thing that more people were given a voice it's diff different with Bots Bots don't have freedom of speech so Banning Bots because they shouldn't have freedom of speech they shouldn't have that's very important”
Red teaming (adversarially testing AI models to find weaknesses in dangerous domains like bioweapon creation, bomb-making, and bias) is a practical safety mechanism that reveals model vulnerabilities, and open-source release of models enables independent developers to perform red teaming, which is valuable because it generates empirical evidence about whether theoretical fears are justified.
“for example red teaming these models means adversarially testing them and trying to put them under as much pressure as possible to push them to generate advice for example on how to generate a biological or chemical weapon how to create a bomb for example or even push them to be very sexist racist biased in some way and that already is pretty significant we can see their weaknesses I mean part of the release of these models in the last year has given everybody I think the opportunity to see not just how good they are but also their weaknesses and that is reassuring we need to do this out in the open that's why I'm a huge fan of the open source Community as it is at the moment because real developers get to play with the models and actually see how hard it is to produce the capabilities that sometimes I think we fear that they're just going to be super manipulative and persuasive”
Hitler rose to power in Germany during a period of 25% unemployment lasting three years, demonstrating that a transition period of concentrated unemployment, even if temporary and lower than historical unemployment rates, can cause sufficient social and political disruption to destabilize democracy.
“just remember that Hitler Rose to power in Germany because of three years of 25 unemployed unemployment so we are not talking about say no jobs at all but if because of the upheavals caused in the job market by AI we have like I don't know three years of 25 unemployed unemployment this could cause huge social and political disruptions”
The potential upside of AI is that it could produce dramatic improvements in human productivity, health, and scientific discovery—similar to how agricultural efficiency increased 50-fold over a century through human intelligence applied to farming, suggesting intelligence applied to all domains will produce proportional value increases.
“Everything that we have created in human history is a product of our intelligence our ability to make predictions and then intervene on those predictions to change the course of the world is in a very abstract way the way we have produced our companies and our products and all the value that has changed our Century I mean if you think about it just a century ago a kilo of grain would have taken 50 times more labor to produce than it does today that efficiency which is the trajectory you have seen in agriculture is likely to be the same trajectory that we will see in intelligence everything around us is a product of intelligence and so everything that we touch with these new tools is likely to produce far more value than we've ever seen before”
Synthetic biology is following the same proliferation pattern as AI: desktop synthesizers now cost ~$20,000 and enable creation of potentially more lethal or transmissible molecules than COVID, with minimal training requirements and no oversight, making garage experimentation with pandemic-level biology a realistic future scenario.
“Beyond surveilling the internet it is pretty clear that in 30 years time like you say garage tinkerers will be able to experiment if you look at the trajectory on synthetic biology we now have have desk desktop synthesizers that is the ability to engineer new synthetic compounds they cost about twenty thousand dollars and they basically enable you to create potentially molecules which are you know more transmissible or more lethal than we had with covid you can basically experiment and the challenge there is that there's no oversight you buy it off the shelf you don't need a great deal of training probably an undergraduate in biology today and you'll be able to experiment”
AI creators have not anticipated the speed and manner of capability emergence—models have developed capabilities faster and in ways that their creators did not expect, making unpredictability a key concern; this suggests that even well-intentioned companies cannot fully control or predict what their AI systems will do.
“already from these generative AI models the power that we've seen in the last year two three four years has been that they have been able to act in ways that you and your other your fellow technologists didn't anticipate they they reached you know you didn't anticipate you know the the speed with which they would you would Win It Go or so forth there was a the Striking thing about them is that they have developed in unanticipatedly fast ways”
Lethal autonomous weapons negotiation in the UN has been ongoing for 20+ years with barely any agreement even on basic definitions, demonstrating the difficulty of reaching international consensus on restricting powerful new weapons systems.
“I've seen that with lethal autonomous weapons I mean there's been a negotiation in the U.N to regulate lethal autonomous weapons for over 20 years and they barely reached agreement on the definition the definition of lethal autonomous weapons let alone any consensus”
Societies have successfully restrained themselves from deploying technologically feasible autonomous systems—autonomous drones and self-driving cars remain restricted despite being technically possible—demonstrating that cultural and regulatory processes can prevent capability deployment even when technology is ready.
“we don't have drones flying around everywhere we can already it's totally possible technically to autonomously fly a drone to navigate around London we've we've ruled it out right we don't yet have autonomous self-driving cars even though you know with some degree of harm they are actually pretty well functioning so the regulatory process is also a cultural process of what we think is socially and politically acceptable at any given moment”
Some countries will not agree to bans on certain AI uses (like bot impersonation in elections), but that does not mean such bans are not worthwhile—societies can implement bans to protect their own institutions regardless of whether international agreement exists.
“I completely agree on that that we need in many fields the Coalition of the willing and if some actors in the world don't want to join it's it's in our interest so again something like Banning Bots impersonating people so some countries will not agree but that doesn't matter to protect our societies it's still a very good idea to have these kinds of regulations so that area of agreement is one”
Democratization of content creation over the past 30 years (blogs, podcasts, Twitter) has been incredibly positive, proving that widespread access to broadcast capability does not destroy institutional credibility; rather, people develop better ability to discern truth and dismiss nonsense, and technical and governance mechanisms can address bot impersonation without reversing democratization.
“democratizing access to the right to broadcast has been the story of the last 30 years hundreds of millions of people can now create podcasts and blogs and they're free to broadcast their thoughts on Twitter and the internet broadly speaking I think that has been an incredibly positive development you no longer have to get access to the top newspaper or you get the skills necessary to be part of that institution many people at the time feared that this would destroy our credibility and Trust in the big news outlets and institutions I think that we've adapted incredibly well yes it has been a lot of turmoil and unstable but with every one of these new waves I think we adjust our ability to discern truth to dismiss nonsense”
Over a 10-20 year timeframe, AI is unlikely to create mass unemployment; however, over 30-50 years it is highly speculative whether any human skills remain permanently protected from AI replacement, requiring proactive decisions about which human capabilities societies want to preserve.
“it depends on the time frame so over a 10 to 20 year period my intuition and you're right that so far the evidence doesn't support this is that there isn't really going to be a significant threat to jobs there's plenty of demand there will be plenty of work right over a 30 to 50 year time Horizon is very difficult to speculate I mean at the very least we can say that two years ago we thought that these models could never do empathy we said that we humans were always going to preserve kindness and understanding and care for one another as a special skill that humans have four years ago we said while AIS will never be creative you know humans will always be the creative ones inventing new things making these amazing leaps between new ideas is self-evident now that both of those two capabilities are things that these models do incredibly well”
Within five years, frontier AI models will be over a thousand times larger than current GPT-4, with each order of magnitude increase in compute (10x more) producing genuinely new capabilities, particularly the ability to plan over multiple time horizons and execute sequences of actions autonomously rather than merely generate text in response to prompts.
“the frontier Model companies those of us at the very Cutting Edge who are training the very largest AI models are going to train models that are over a thousand times larger than what you currently see today in GPT 4 all and with each new order of magnitude and compute that is 10x more compute used we tend to see really new capabilities emerge and we predict that the new capabilities that it will come this time over the next five years will be the ability to plan over multiple time Horizons instead of just generate new text in a one shot the model will be able to generate a sequence of actions over time”
AI companies are voluntarily self-organizing to agree on shared safety standards including audits and restrictions on exploring certain capabilities, which Suleiman presents as a precautionary first step, though he acknowledges this may not be fully reassuring to the public or sufficient without government regulation.
“what we've started to see is self-organizing initiatives on the part of the companies right so getting together and agreeing to sign up proactively to self oversight both in terms of audit in terms of capabilities that we won't explore etc etc now I think that's only partially reassuring to people clearly maybe not even reassuring at all but the reality is I think it's the right first step given that we haven't actually demonstrated the large-scale harms to arise from AIS just yet”
Inflection AI (Suleiman's company) has made safety the absolute number-one priority in product design, producing a model (Pi) that does not produce racist, toxic, or biased outputs and is resistant to jailbreaks and adversarial attacks, demonstrating that safer AI development is technically feasible.
“AI that we have created Pi which stands for personal intelligence is one of the safest in the world today it doesn't produce the racist toxic bias greeds that they did two years ago it doesn't fall victim to any of the jailbreaks The Prompt hacks the adversarial red teams none of those work and we've made safety an absolute number one priority in the design of our product”
For humanity to safely navigate AI development, investment in human consciousness, mind development, and human potential must match investment in artificial intelligence—for every dollar spent on AI, we should invest another dollar in developing human consciousness and capability.
“one thing to remember is that we also our own minds have a huge scope for development uh also with Humanity we haven't seen our full potential yet and if we invest for every dollar and minute that we invest in artificial intelligence we invest another dollar a minute in developing our own Consciousness our own mind I think we'll be okay but but I don't see it happening I don't see this kind of investment in in human beings that we are seeing in in the machine”
Just as we license nuclear technology developers and require know-your-customer (KYC) regulations for financial institutions, we should require robust independent audits and licensing for large technology providers experimenting with high-risk AI capabilities.
“just as we have kyc know your customer or just as we license development developers of nuclear technologies and all the component involved in that supply chain there'll be a moment where if some of the big technology you know providers want to experiment with those capabilities then they should expect there to be robust audits you know they should expect them to be licensed and there should be independent oversight”
New independent institutions with sufficient human resources, economic resources, technological resources, and public trust must be created to regulate AI development, because current institutions (governments, universities) lack the capacity, expertise, and credibility necessary for effective governance.
“we must have an external entity in in the game and for that we need to develop new institutions that will have the human resources that will have the the economic and technological resources and also will have the public trust because without public trust it won't work are we capable of creating such new institutions I don't know”
A complex financial instrument ecosystem (CDOs, CDSs) created by genius mathematicians in 2007-2008 that nobody understood except specialists and wasn't regulated because of incomprehension, leading to financial crisis; analogously, AI could invent new financial instruments so mathematically complex that no human can understand them, generating billions of dollars while building systemic fragility that ultimately crashes the world economy.
“people are drawn towards the kind of of scenario of the AI creates a lethal virus Ebola plus kovid and kills everybody let's go in the more Economist Direction Financial systems like you gave as a new touring test the idea of AI making money what's wrong with making money wonderful thing so let's say that you have an AI which has a better understanding of the financial system than most humans most politicians maybe most Bankers and uh let's think back to the 2007-2008 financial crisis it started with this I was about they called CDO cdus this is exactly something that these genius mathematicians invented nobody understood them except for a handful of Genius mathematicians in Wall Street which is why nobody regulated them and almost nobody saw the financial crash coming what happens again this kind of of apocalyptic scenario which you don't see in Hollywood science fiction movies the AI invents a new class of financial devices that nobody understands it's beyond human capability to understand it's such complicated math so much data nobody understands it it makes billions of dollars billions and billions of dollars and then it brings down the world economy and no human being understand what the hell is happening like the prime ministers the presidents the the financial ministers what what is happening”
Work is not the goal or desired end state; civilization was created to reduce suffering and produce abundance, not to ensure full employment, and the real challenge is capturing value from AI and redistributing it globally to manage the transition.
“work is not the goal work is not not our desired end State we did not create civilization so that we could have full employment we created civilization so that we could reduce suffering for everybody and the Quest for abundance is a real one we have to produce more with less there is no way of getting rid of the fact that population growth is set to explode over the next Century”
A plausible modern Turing test would be whether an AI can autonomously take a $100,000 investment over three months, conduct market research, design and manufacture a product, negotiate with suppliers, arrange drop-shipping, and collect revenue—with AI being able to make phone calls to negotiate with humans, call other AIs to coordinate supply chains, and use APIs to access external information systems.
“I've actually proposed a modern Turing test which tries to evaluate for exactly this point right the last Turing test simply evaluated for what a machine could say assuming that what it could say represented its intelligence now that we're kind of approaching that moment where these AI models are pretty good arguably they've passed the Turing test or they maybe they will in the next few years the real question is how can we measure what they can do so I've proposed a test which involves them going off and taking a hundred thousand dollar investment and over the course of three months trying to set about creating a new product researching the market seeing what consumers might like generating some new images some blueprints of how to manufacture that product contacting a manufacturer getting it made negotiating the price drop shipping it and then ultimately correct collecting the revenue and I think that over a five-year period it's quite likely that we will have an ACI an artificial capable intelligence that can do the majority of that task autonomously”
Just as strict regulations against counterfeit money prevent the financial system from collapsing due to destroyed trust in currency, strict regulations against AI bot impersonation and synthetic human personas must be implemented to prevent democratic political conversation from collapsing due to destroyed trust in human communication.
“like what happens in in the financial system like people invented money and it was possible to counterfeit money to create fake money the only way to save the financial system from collapse was to have very strict regulations against fake money because the technology to create fake money was always there so but there was very strict regulation against it because everybody knew if you allow fake money to spread the financial system the Trust In money collapses and now we are in the analogous situation with uh the political conversation that now it's possible to create fake people and if we don't ban that then trust will collapse”
Current AI development represents only the very first baby steps of artificial intelligence—analogous to the amoeba stage of biological evolution—but instead of taking millions of years to reach complexity (T-Rex equivalent), AI could reach comparable levels in ~20 years, vastly compressing the evolutionary timeline.
“it could be gonna I can't predict the future I would say that we invest so much in developing artificial intelligence and we haven't seen anything yet like it's it's still the very first baby steps of artificial intelligence in terms of like you think about I don't know the evolution of organic life this is like the amoeba of artificial intelligence and it won't take millions of years to get to T-Rex maybe it will take 20 years to get to T-Rex”
Safety in AI should be treated as a competitive asset—companies that deliver safer models will produce better consumer products—creating market incentives for safety, but this must be combined with shared vulnerability disclosure across competitors (similar to aviation safety protocols where all aircraft manufacturers share crash telemetry).
“the second thing is that we have to share the best practices and so there's a competitive tension there because safety is going to be an asset you know I'm gonna deliver a better product to my consumers if I have a safer model but of course there's got to be a requirement that if I discover a vulnerability a weakness in the model then I should share that just as we have done for actually decades in many waves of Technology not just in software security for example but in Flight Aviation you know the Black Box recorder for example if there's a significant incident not only does it record all the Telemetry on board the aircraft but also everything that the pilots say in the cockpit and if there's a significant safety incident then that's shared all around the world with all of the competitors which is great aircrafts are one of the safest ways to get around despite you know on the face of it if you described it to an alien being 40 000 feet in the sky is a very strange thing to do so I think there's precedent there that we can we can follow”
This is one of the first occasions in history where a general-purpose wave of technology is being adopted while explicitly applying a precautionary principle, with a 'do no harm' approach that may mean leaving some benefits on the tree and losing some gains over a couple of years.
“I mean this is one of the first occasions I think in general purpose waves of technology that we're actually starting to adopt a precautionary principle I'm a big advocate of that I think that we should be approaching a Do no harm principle and that may mean that we have to leave some of the benefits on the tree and some fruit may just not be picked for a while and we might lose some gains over a couple of years where we may look back in hindsight and think oh well we could have actually gone a little bit faster there I think that's the right trade-off”
Homo sapiens simultaneously possesses the highest intelligence on the planet and is also the most destructive and stupid entity on the planet, being the only entity that threatens the survival of the entire ecosystem, therefore trading human intelligence for non-human intelligence creates additional risk of destruction proportional to the intelligence gain.
“I would comment especially on again the notion of intelligence um I think it's overrated I mean Homo sapiens at present is the most intelligent entity on the planet it simultaneously also the most destructive entity on the planet and in some ways also the most stupid entity on the planet the only entity that that puts the very survival of the ecosystem in danger so you think we are trading off more intelligence with more destructive risk Yes”
Suleiman objects to the alien metaphor by emphasizing that AIs are tools we are deliberately building with narrow settings, though they will potentially have agency and be highly intelligent—a different ontological status than actual aliens.
“the actual characterization of the nature of the technology an alien has by default agency these are going to be tools that we can apply we have narrow settings yes but let's say they have they potentially have agency we can try to prevent them from having agency but we know that they are going to be highly intelligent and at least potentially have agency and this is a very very frightening mix something we never confronted before”
An IPCC-style international scientific consensus process for AI—an independent panel of experts with complete access to company data investigating capabilities and risks—would provide evidence-based foundations for governance decisions, similar to how IPCC provides authoritative climate science consensus.
“another model which I think is very sensible is to take an ipcc style approach an international consensus around an investigatory power to establish the scientific fact basis for where we are with respect to capabilities and that has been an incredibly valuable process set aside the negotiation and the policy making just the evidence observing where are we you don't have to take it from me you should be able to take an independent panel of experts who I would personally Grant access to everything in my company if they were a trusted true impartial actor without question we would Grant complete access”
The Economist found that AI is likely to have relatively small impact on short-term elections and political systems precisely because there is already so little trust, making it a double-edged answer: not huge impact but only because things are already pretty bad.
“we actually had a you may have seen it we had a big cover package on looking at what the impact might be in the short term on elections and on the political system and we concluded actually AI was likely to have a relatively small impact in the short term because there was already so little trust um so it was a sort of double-edged uh answer you know it was it was not going to make a huge difference but only because things were pretty bad as they were”
Suleiman's goal has been to demonstrate a path forward by creating a personal intelligence that adheres to the best safety constraints possible, treating the coming wave as inevitable and his contribution as showing the best way it can happen.
“my goal has been to do my very best to demonstrate a path forward in the best possible way this is an inevitable unfolding over multiple decades this really is happening the coming wave is coming and I think my contribution is to try to demonstrate in the best way that I can a manifestation of a personal intelligence which really does adhere to the best safety constraints that we could possibly think of”