
Capitalism is in crisis | Martin Wolf on Democracy, China and more (part 1)
What this covers
This is a conversation on stage in London between Martin Wolf and Mervyn King, the former Bank of England governor. It is the first part of a two-part event. King asks the questions, and Wolf makes the case for Democratic Capitalism as a fragile but still valuable system. The opening ground is historical: the wave of democratization from about 1980 into the early 2000s, followed by what Wolf calls the democratic recession, in which figures such as Erdogan and Orbán emerged. Wolf finds it especially striking that the United States, which was decisive in preserving liberal democracy in the mid-twentieth century, is now central to that reversal. He also describes how an elected autocrat can dismantle the checks on executive power and so let a democracy "eat itself from within."
The conversation then turns to political selection. King argues that opening leadership choice to wider party memberships gives disproportionate weight to the most fanatical members. His examples are the Conservative choice of Liz Truss over Rishi Sunak and the US primary system, citing research by Rick Pildos on how party leaders once screened presidential candidates. He also notes that Americans used to accept the winner of an election as their president, and now rarely do. Wolf's surprise at the rise of right-wing rather than left-wing populism, and his reading of Brexit as an assault on elites, belong to this part of the discussion. So does his comparison with the disarray of the 1920s and 1930s.
The last stretch is about China and autocracy. Wolf claims that autocracies inherently breed crony capitalism, because the legal system is subverted and every businessperson depends on the ruler's favor. He reads Xi Jinping's anti-corruption campaign as a response to officials being bribed by wealthy capitalists. He describes China as the only fully institutionalized autocratic system, and argues that managing US-China relations is harder than managing the Cold War with the Soviet Union, because China is so deeply entangled in the global economy. He also criticizes American manichaeism and says no Western politician is focusing hard enough on the scale of the China challenge.
Wolf argues that democratic capitalism is in crisis because the economic system is not delivering satisfaction to citizens in high-income democracies, which has broken the reciprocal relationship between democratic politics and market economies, leading to the rise of autocratic and populist leaders who worsen the problem.
- The economic system is failing to deliver what citizens want in terms of life satisfaction and societal governance
- This disillusionment drives citizens toward autocratic leaders who make the crisis worse in a vicious cycle
- Autocratic systems inherently produce crony capitalism and undermine competitive markets, while democracies provide better competitive constraints
This asset isn't compiled yet
You're seeing its claims, ranked. Compile it to build the argument threads, weight them, and check each claim against your library — the full view.
The deep question about democratic systems is who should choose party representatives for legislative bodies and who should choose leaders, and this question has been transformed in supposedly democratic ways with results that are unsatisfactory to the wider public.
“the Deep question is who should choose the party's representatives in the house of Congress or in the house of Parliament and who should choose the leaders and that is something that's been transformed in both cases in an ostensibly Democratic way and the result is not necessary to the satisfaction of The Wider public”
In the 1950s and 1960s, when Americans were asked about the previous presidential election, those who had voted against the winning candidate said they wished the successful candidate well because he was their president; such a response is almost nonexistent today.
“if you go back to the 50s and 60s when people interviewed American citizens about the previous presidential election the question was did you vote for the successful candidate and when people said no the question was well what's your reaction to the winning candidate back in the 50s and 60s the reaction was I wish him well because he's our president well I don't think you'll get many people who say that today almost nobody”
US-China relations are significantly more difficult to manage on multiple fronts than Cold War US-Soviet relations because China is 'inexorably intertwined' with the entire world economy as the world's biggest manufacturing exporter with extensive global trade relations.
“far more difficult on multiple fronts than the relationship with the Soviet Union because China is so inexorably intertwined it's the biggest manufacturing exporter in the world uh with the entire world economy and has so many important trade relations”
Democratic recession refers to a reversal of the wave of democratization that occurred between roughly 1980 and the early 2000s, during which time important authoritarian figures like Erdogan in Turkey and Orbán in Hungary began to emerge.
“in the period between roughly 1980 slightly before that and the early 2000s there was an enormous wave of democratization across the world obviously in the in the former Soviet Union and its Empire but also in many developing countries notably in Africa uh um um dictatorships were replaced by democracies and it was becoming obvious already in that early period that this was beginning to reverse you could see important figures like erdogan in Turkey Auburn in beginning to emerge in Hungary”
Democracy works better than autocracy in the long run because politics is inherently competitive, which constrains leaders and prevents the pathologies of crony capitalism.
“it's one of the reasons why I think in the long run democracy works better because politics is competitive”
The relationship between democratic political systems and market economies can be mutually supportive in important ways but can also be mutually destructive, and that mutual destruction is where the world now finds itself.
“the relationship that has broken down is a reciprocal relationship between a democratic political system and a market economy and which can be mutually supportive and in some important ways is but can also be mutually destructive and that is I think now where we are”
Despite the Tiananmen Square suppression being widely interpreted as ending reform in China, this was actually the opposite of the truth, illustrating China's capacity for unexpected reversals.
“I can say that after the chin and Men uh crime the the the the brutal suppression of gentleman a protests everybody thought reform was over and that was actually the opposite of the truth”
Capitalism as an economic system is highly malleable and can be adapted to work within various political systems, from cuddly Danish capitalism to American capitalism to Chinese capitalism, but the political system within which it operates materially affects how it functions.
“capitalism as an economic system is quite proteome and it can be made to fit in with all sorts of political systems and will work better well it can be you know put in in a very cuddly way with incredibly successful Danish economy it can be it can be American and it can sort of be Chinese or Turkish as it is now I'm just choosing this as an example um but the interactions are very important they affect how it works”
The economic system as currently run is not delivering to the peoples of high-income democracies, including notably the US, what they want to feel satisfied with the way their lives are going and with the way their societies have been governed and led.
“the economic system as it is now run is not delivering to the people's of our countries including all the high income democracies and notably including the US what they want to feel satisfied with the way their lives are going and with the way their societies have been governed and led”
Profound disillusionment and skepticism about the system leads citizens to entrust their future to scoundrels and worse, who then in a vicious circle make the problem worse and make citizens angrier.
“this has led them to profound disillusionment and skepticism and that in turn leads them to entrust their future to Scoundrels and worst who then in a vicious circle make the problem worse and them angrier”
The rise of right-wing populism rather than left-wing populism was surprising to Wolf, though some manifestations of it appeared frighteningly similar to the economic and political disarray of the 1920s and 1930s.
“the characteristic this is taking is right-wing populism which is itself rather surprising to me um rather than left-wing populism though we had the corbyn interlude in in here and some of it began to look to me frighteningly similar to what had gone on though there were many differences which I discussed in the 1920s and 30s in a similar not as bad but not as it's nothing like it's bad but a similar period of Economic and political disarray”
Autocratic systems with leaders controlling the military, police, and security services inherently produce crony capitalism because the legal system is subverted by the autocrat, making any businessperson completely at the autocrat's mercy regardless of wealth.
“the legal systems are subverted by the autocrat because what's the point of being an autocrat if you can't tell the judges what to do so uh so that means the the protection of since the autocrat controls the Army and the police and the security service all the other Security Services anybody who's in business however rich is completely at his Mercy yeah obviously unless he escapes and all of his property so he basically has to do whatever the autocrat tells him to do so he becomes a crony”
The United States being critically important in the democratic recession is particularly striking because the US was the decisive country in preserving liberal democracy in the middle of the 20th century.
“the country where they think it's got in the developed world where they think it's got worse most badly is the US uh of the the big hurricane countries and obviously that's incredibly important because the US has been and the bubble was in the middle of the 20th century the decisive country in preserving uh liberal democracy”
While Russia has become increasingly similar to other authoritarian autocracies, China has reaffirmed its Communist nature very strongly under Xi and become considerably more internationally assertive because of its power.
“of course in the meantime we have a set of challenges because here is a communist China which is reaffirmed very strongly under she its communist nature it has become it's considerably more internationally assertive because of its power”
Britain's 2016 Brexit campaign was essentially an assault on the elites and the establishment, and similar right-wing populist movements emerged across many countries at roughly the same time.
“In Britain we were engulfed in The brexit Campaign which was essentially assault on the elites The Establishment uh which went through a head and we were seeing similar things like go through many other countries”
China represents the only fully articulated, institutionalized autocratic system in the world, which has developed a form of capitalism that operates without normal legal constraints.
“China's is the one fully articulated institutionalized autocratic system um whatever you call it and they have actually developed a sort of capitalism that goes with this uh but it's become very obvious in the last 10 years and indeed in some senses what she was about that he thinks it went too far that the capitalists got too rich in a lawless economy it's an economy that doesn't operate with normal legal constraints”
Rick Pildos's research in New York found that when major parties were choosing presidential candidates, party leaders ensured candidates were sensible and credible, but the shift to primaries moved selection toward candidates from the extremes, with worse results.
“his analysis is that it used to be the case when the two major parties were choosing their presidential candidates that the leaders of the party people behind the scenes ensured that they were sensible credible candidates and the more they move towards primaries that is a so-called Democratic approach the worse it became people moved to the extremes”
Both the UK Conservative party's election of Liz Truss over Rishi Sunak and similar movements in other countries show that opening leadership selection to broader party membership has given enormous weight to the most fanatical elements in political communities.
“the throwing it open to a much wider group of members our uh in the UAE of supporters in the U.S through the primaries and in the UK of throwing open the leadership to uh from the house the the people that were actually in elected to the house into the membership of the parties hadn't had a rather similar respect effects or intended you which is they've given enormous weight to the most fat fanatical elements in our political communities”
The UK Conservative party's selection of Liz Truss over Rishi Sunak was obviously going to be a disaster to anyone who knew anything about it, and while fortunately the UK system allowed relatively quick removal of this disaster, the American system cannot do this.
“the choice by the conservative membership of Liz truss over Rishi sunnak um which crashed and burned fortunately relatively quickly but it was pretty obvious to anyone who knew anything about this that this was going to be a disaster now a fortunate our system we can get rid of disasters relatively quickly and that was I think a good thing but in the American system they can't”
Democratic systems can 'eat themselves out from within' when autocratic leaders are elected democratically and then systematically destroy the checks and balances that constrain executive power.
“so what the danger is that the democratic system eats itself out from within and most of the autocracies we now have have that characteristic it's not a coup by the army or anything those are basically gone even in Latin America it's a it's a hollowing out of the system from within and it's capture by a leader who has been democratically elected but then destroys all the checks and balances in the system”
In China, capitalists get rich by bribing officials, a system that Xi Jinping believes subverts the Communist Party's integrity and erodes public confidence in the Party, leading to his decade-long anti-corruption and anti-capitalist campaign.
“it's an economy that doesn't operate with normal legal constraints that means they get rich by bribing officials of course they do we all know that everybody knows that in China so the uh and he thinks that subverts the Communist party and because it's subverting the Communist Party it erodes confidence of the people in the Communist Party big time so we had this anti-corruption campaign”
China's increased international assertiveness has created a reaction, particularly in America, which has a tendency toward manichaeism, viewing international relations as a struggle between good and evil, causing relations to break down.
“that has created a reaction particularly in America which has a tendency towards manicism uh to view the to to take the verse for you so relations are breaking down”
No Western politician is focusing hard enough on the magnitude of the China challenge, which is likely to be significantly more important than the Russia issue.
“I just feel that no Western politician is really focusing hard enough on how much bigger an issue that ultimately is likely to be than Russia though of course that rules out assumes that we're not going to end up in a nuclear war”
From roughly 1980 to the early 2000s, there was an enormous wave of democratization across the world, particularly in the former Soviet Union, its empire, and in developing countries like those in Africa, where dictatorships were replaced by democracies.
“in the period between roughly 1980 slightly before that and the early 2000s there was an enormous wave of democratization across the world obviously in the in the former Soviet Union and its Empire but also in many developing countries notably in Africa uh um um dictatorships were replaced by democracies”
When the Berlin Wall fell in 1989, people assumed democratic capitalism had achieved its ultimate triumph, making the current framing of democratic capitalism as being in crisis unthinkable at that time.
“when the Berlin Wall fell in 1989 people assumed then that this was the Triumph the ultimate Triumph of Democratic capitalism at that point the idea that the word crisis would enter the same be on the same page as Democratic or capitalism was unthinkable”
China is capable of extraordinary rapid transformations, such as the shift from Maoist ideology in the early 1970s to Deng Xiaoping's reforms; this historical precedent suggests future transformation is possible despite current conditions.
“if you look at the history it can make extraordinary changes very quickly and one of the most striking was from the maois maoism of the early 70s to what Don trippings did I do it's a real incredible transformation”
China's autocratic capitalist system, despite being inferior to competitive capitalism, has advantages over crony capitalist autocracies because it operates within a very dynamic society that can generate extraordinary economic change.
“that's also a bad system though he's operating within a very Dynamic Society um so those are the compo that's the competition and that's the danger um uh we face”
The core challenge China faces is maintaining the integrity of the Communist Party system with Xi Jinping at the top while simultaneously operating a dynamic, progressive, internationally integrated market economy.
“it's very very clear that the system is struggling with the question is how do we maintain the Integrity of what we think of as that communist system with me at the top in the case of she why now having a dynamic Progressive internationally integrated market economy”
No senior Republican party leaders believe Donald Trump is even a borderline credible president, but this does not matter because his supporters rather than active party members vote in primaries and select him over their objections.
“essentially there is nobody who runs the cons Republican party at any seniority who thinks that Donald Trump and I've known quite a few of them is an even borderline credible president but it doesn't matter because the people who vote for him who are not active members of the party they're just his supporters turn out in the primaries and appoint him over their heads”
Political parties should ideally be organizations that belong to their members, with members choosing party representatives and representatives choosing leaders, which is the traditional approach that worked reasonably well historically.
“how do we think political parties should fit into a democratic system and the uh there are two views I think essentially on this which is that political parties belong ultimately to their members their organizations their Association that belong to their members the members should choose who their parties representatives are with uh uh um and that works pretty well when the and and the sorry and the representatives should uh then choose the leaders so that's the traditional way we worked”
The West will face stupendous challenges in managing potential conflicts with China while cooperating on major global challenges without ending up in war, while simultaneously preserving economic and military security.
“I think we are uh going to have to manage potential conflicts uh we have to do so without ending up in war we have to cooperate on major Global challenges not just the environment which is obvious but also development where both sides are deeply involved and we have to do so to do all this while preserving our basic economic and Military security and all I can say is it's in that is a stupendous challenge”
Freedom House documentation over the last 16 years consistently shows that democratic metrics have gotten worse, with the United States among developed countries being where democratic deterioration has been most severe.
“Freedom House is documented uh basically over the last 16 years it's very consecutive and I've got some quotations that essentially it's got worse all the time uh and strikingly given where they are the country where they think it's got in the developed world where they think it's got worse most badly is the US”
The United States is not as far away as one might wish from being in danger of democratic self-destruction through an elected autocratic leader, and this danger would be particularly acute if Trump becomes president.
“I don't think they were all that far away from that in the US and they I don't think if Trump becomes president of the game which is perfectly possible that they will be all that way far away from it then”
Wolf does not believe anyone truly knows how China will evolve, despite having visited once or twice yearly for 30 years and having senior connections, because China has historically made extraordinary transformations very quickly.
“I really don't think anybody knows how China is going to evolve um I've thought about that I'm sort of I'm a complete ignoramus in a sense but I'm fascinated by the country and have been there basically once or twice a year for the last 30 and I have quite a few senior friends but I wouldn't claim to know it at all but if you look at the history it can make extraordinary changes very quickly”
Xi's decade of war against capitalists has gotten worse (in terms of subduing capitalist excess) until only recently when he reversed course; this has terrified capitalists, causing many to leave China and stop investing, while all new investment has gone into useless real estate, slowing China's growth.
“it's got worse until just now when he's reversed it from our God knows how long it's terrified the wits out of all the capitalists and lots of them have left and they stopped investing and all the investment now has been in useless real estate and China's growth is slowing”
In 2016, Trump became a likely presidential candidate for the Republican party, which Wolf found unthinkable just 2-3 years earlier, catalyzing his thinking about political upheaval.
“well it was really 2016. um Donald Trump it was already obvious when I started thinking about this was likely to be the presidential candidate for uh uh the Republican party I might become president quite Unthinkable three years before two or three years before”
Wolf wrote his globalization book in response to critics in the late 1990s who argued globalization was destructive to developing countries, which Wolf believed was a serious mistake, and subsequent developments in China, India, and other countries proved his skepticism correct.
“the globalization book you mentioned which focus on globalization and development very important was in reaction to many critic critics in the late 90s who argued that globalization was utterly destructured destructive of developing countries and blighted and ruined their hopes and that seemed to me quite a serious mistake and I think what's happened since then in China and India many other countries suggested that was wrong”
The 2007-2008 financial crisis was worse than Wolf expected, and despite knowing there were significant problems, he needed to understand how such a crisis could have occurred.
“Shifts and the shocks came out of the biggest financial crisis of my lifetime and my reaction was how did this happen it was formal firework much worse than I'd expected I knew there were problems big runs and I wrote about them so why did that happen”