
What this covers
The conversation begins with Sam Harris explaining why he quit Twitter. He says that even light use was making him a worse person, and he describes a family vacation in Hawaii cut short after attacks from Reza Aslan, Glenn Greenwald, and Ezra Klein arrived within an hour of one another. From there it moves to the episode behind those attacks, his decision to host Charles Murray. Harris says he had no interest in measuring intelligence or comparing populations. His aim was to discuss facts that have been walled off from politics.
Much of the talk concerns Murray himself. Harris recalls that he once assumed Murray had a white supremacist agenda and avoided projects associated with him. He changed his mind after the incident at Middlebury College, where Murray and the professor who invited him were physically attacked. Harris also describes the Southern Poverty Law Center (SPLC)) listing and the wider deplatforming of Murray. He gives his own account of The Bell Curve, including its worry about cognitive stratification and its hedged remarks on racial IQ gaps. He calls those remarks what any honest scientist would say, though that characterization is contested.
The second half widens into two connected questions. The first is whether the left treats psychometric testing and behavioral genetics as racist at the level of the data as well as the policy. The second is what a society owes people who differ in ability. Harris offers Elon Musk and a Starbucks employee as an example of equal political standing despite unequal capabilities. Rogan brings in the Asian students suing Harvard over higher admission standards, and a point about how a grandfather's work as an indentured railroad laborer shapes later outcomes. Both sit uneasily with a simple "Asian privilege" story. The Harvard point is also tied to a contested argument about what the Bell Curve data implies.
The speaker argues that honest scientific discussion of intelligence, genetics, and group differences is being suppressed by ideological intolerance, and that this suppression prevents us from separating factual inquiry from political implications—a distinction necessary for both scientific honesty and ethical policymaking.
- Charles Murray was deplatformed and attacked not for promoting white supremacy but for acknowledging that genetic and environmental factors both contribute to observed group differences in IQ, a position any honest scientist holds
- The political left conflates factual inquiry about group differences with racist intent, making it impossible to have good-faith debate about data or policy without accusations of racism
- A healthy society can acknowledge statistical differences between groups while maintaining political commitment to treating individuals as individuals and engineering policies that 'raise all boats'
This asset isn't compiled yet
You're seeing its claims, ranked. Compile it to build the argument threads, weight them, and check each claim against your library — the full view.
One's grandfather working as an indentured servant on California railroads creates a form of privilege that trickles down generationally, implying that attributing current differences in outcomes to simple 'Asian privilege' ignores historical context
“asian privilege yeah your grandfather was working on the railroads in California as an indentured servant and my privilege trickled down there's obviously a lot of factors that lead to IQ to hierarchy but to ignore what those are to ignore it completely to dis yes exactly”
As we understand ourselves better genetically and environmentally, we will inevitably discover differences between groups, whether we are looking for them or not, and the political end game should be to deny those differences have political implications rather than denying the differences exist
“I see what's coming I see the fact that that the more we understand ourselves genetically and environmentally the more we will if we go looking or even if we're not looking we will discover differences between groups and the end game for us as a species is not to deny that those differences exist or could possibly exist it's to deny that they have real political implication”
Even with relatively low engagement, the speaker found that checking Twitter was 'clearly making me a worse person' by causing them to react to things they didn't need to react to and amplifying certain voices and ideologies that need not have been amplified
“it was one it was clearly making me a worse person imagine it was I was I was reacting to stuff that I didn't need to react to and it was amplifying certain mice's UM's and and voices which need not have been amplified”
Murray's book chapter on race 'went off like a nuclear bomb' and caused him to be vilified, leading to his deplatforming and assault when he attempted to give a talk at Middlebury College approximately 25 years after the book's publication
“I mean that was just so that was such a I mean it's it's the most I saw and at the time I never read the book I just thought this had to be just racist course Murray would be vilified and he's been vilified ever since and ever since you know I've ignored him there's any deep platformed and was assaulted recent yeah so that's what happened so he went to Middlebury to give a talk you know twenty some odd years twenty five years after he wrote this book”
When Murray went to speak at Middlebury, both he and the liberal professor who invited him were physically attacked by students; the professor suffered a concussion and neck injury that persisted over a year later, and an SUV they were in was struck with a concrete-laden stop sign pulled from the sidewalk
“Charles was was not hurt his host this female professor got a concussion and a neck injury that that still persists and this is now more than a year later so it's like sure that she was a registered like this no doubt and and they're driving out in an SUV where that gets I mean someone pulls a stop sign out of the the sidewalk and I still got the concrete ball on the end of it and that this SUV gets smashed with this you know concrete laden stop sign I mean this was this is happening at one of the most liberal privileged colleges on earth”
Asian students suing Harvard are arguing that higher admission score requirements are unjust because they reflect assumptions that Asian students are inherently smarter, demonstrating unequal standards between racial groups
“there's a group of Asian students that are suing Harvard because they're discriminated against because they're required to have higher scores because they're assumed to be smarter so there's standards for Asian students and during into Harvard is higher than white people”
There are obviously many factors that contribute to IQ and hierarchy, and these factors must be examined rather than ignored; ignoring them completely is to operate purely on ideology rather than facts
“there's obviously a lot of factors that lead to IQ to hierarchy but to ignore what those are to ignore it completely to dis yes exactly only ideology and this idea that you cannot look at statistics you cannot look at facts”
In 'The Bell Curve,' Murray's discussion of racial disparities in IQ was unusually cautious and mealy-mouthed even for the 1990s, simply stating that 'undoubtedly there are environmental and genetic reasons for this and we don't understand them' and that 'we're not in a position to know what the mix is of influences,' which the speaker characterizes as the 'virtually any honest scientist's take on the matter'
“The claim about the source of those disparities was by even the standards of the time but certainly the standards of today an incredibly tepid mealy-mouthed just hand-waving it was not this you know here comes the third reich declaration of white supremacy it was undoubtedly there are environmental and genetic reasons for this and we don't understand them you know it was just like to think that is one or the other we're not in a position to know what the mix is of influences now and that is virtually any honest scientists take on the matter and certainly today”
Charles Murray is listed by the Southern Poverty Law Center, which contributed to deplatforming and violent protests against him at Middlebury
“by the way he's also listed by the Southern Poverty Law Center oh and so that that that's what contributed to the D platforming and the violent protests against him at Middlebury”
The speaker was on vacation in Hawaii with their family when they saw Twitter attacks from Reza Aslan, Glenn Greenwald, and Ezra Klein directed at them within a span of an hour, which caused them to abandon their vacation commitments
“I'm in the middle of like the first vacation taking with my family for in a very long time was at least a year and Wow and what so I you know we're on Hawaii and just like I'm supposed to put everything down to be the best father and husband I can be right and that was my intention that's what was happening it happened for a good solid 24 hours and then I pick up my phone and I see that that razor Aslan and Glenn Greenwald and Ezra Klein had all attacked me in the space of an hour”
Societies should engineer times that 'raise all the boats' through laws and institutions that protect and support human flourishing, with legitimate debate possible about which social policies will achieve this
“when it comes time to to write laws and create institutions that protect you that that support human flourishing we we have to engineer times that raise all the boats and so you know and and you know they're legitimate debates about the social policies that will do that”
We can have good-faith debate about scientific fact, psychometric testing results, and behavioral genetics relevant to questions of intelligence, AND good-faith debate about social policy that should follow from the data, but what is currently happening on the left is that at either of those tiers of conversation, there are straight-up allegations of racism
“and they're legitimate debates about facts so we can debate scientific fact and and you know the the results of you know psychometric testing or or behavioral genetics that are relevant to this question of intelligence and we can have a good faith debate about the data and then we can have a good faith debate about social policy that should follow from the data but what's happening on the left now is on either at either of those tiers of conversation there are just straight-up allegations of racism that hit you the moment you touch certainly the facts”
One cannot even discuss the fact that certain races demonstrate lower IQ without being accused of racism, despite the fact that discussing the causes of such differences is a legitimate scientific and policy question
“this is an ideological issue and that you you it's almost like an impossible subject to breach like you can't even discuss the fact that certain races demonstrate low IQ and then let's look at what could be the cause of those even discussing that somehow or another is so inherently racist that it must be ignored or must be silenced and that you you must first concentrate on all the various and justices that have been done to those people who have this lower IQ”
There is an argument that 'The Bell Curve' data actually 'proved' Asian racial superiority, as demonstrated by the fact that Asian students are now suing Harvard for discrimination based on having to meet higher admission standards than white students
“what's crazy is the whole thing is a propaganda for the superiority of the Asian race and everyone's far above I mean that's basically what his book proved and you know they're suing Harvard now there's a group of Asian students that are suing Harvard because they're discriminated against because they're required to have higher scores because they're assumed to be smarter so there's standards for Asian students and during into Harvard is higher than white people”
Political tolerance and support for one another is not predicated on denying individual differences or even statistical differences across groups, because societies like ours maintain equal value for individuals who have vastly different capabilities (example: Elon Musk versus a Starbucks employee) without treating one as politically more valuable than the other
“our political tolerance of one another in support of one another is not predicated on denying individual differences or even statistical differences across groups it can't be because we know that there are people walking around like you know Elon Musk who gets out of bed in the every morning and does the work of like 4,000 people right and people who just are struggling to work at Starbucks and hold down a job and our political system I mean this we don't say one person is more valuable politically and socially than another even though one person is capable of doing massive things that that many most other people aren't”
The speaker had 'zero interest in intelligence as measured by IQ' and 'truly zero interest in establishing differences between populations with respect to intelligence or anything else,' but invited Charles Murray because they wanted to discuss facts and break the firewall between reality and politically fraught topics
“I had zero interest in intelligence as measured by IQ although yeah I mean it's an interesting subject but I hadn't you know I hadn't spent much time focused on that and I had truly zero interest in establishing differences between populations with respect to intelligence or anything else but I see what's coming I see the fact that that the more we understand ourselves genetically and environmentally the more we will if we go looking or even if we're not looking we will discover differences between groups”
The speaker initially believed Charles Murray had a white supremacist agenda and had declined to work on projects associated with him, but changed their view after learning about the Middlebury incident and seeing Murray as 'the canary in the coal mine' for politically fraught topics that cannot be discussed
“I had actually I felt guilty because I had declined to be a part of at least one project because his name was attached right because I just thought this guy is radioactive he's got some white supremacist agenda I had believed the the the the lies about him and then I saw this I thought okay well maybe he's the canary in the coal mine or certainly one of the Canaries in the coal mine that I had ignored”
Charles Murray published 'The Bell Curve' in the 1990s, a book about IQ and success in Western societies that expressed concern about cognitive stratification, where society is increasingly selecting for a narrow band of talents well-captured by IQ measures
“Charles Murray on my podcast a year ago and charles murray is this this social scientist who published the bell curve back in the 90s which it was a book about IQ and and success in in western societies like our own and it's a book where he worries a lot about the cognitive stratification of society we have a society that is selecting more and more for a narrow band of talents that are very well fairly well captured by what we call IQ”
The speaker has never used Facebook as a social platform, only as a publishing channel, and has never engaged with Facebook comments
“I've never used Facebook as I've never I just used Facebook is kind of a publishing channel I never engaged with comments”
The speaker considers themselves someone who was not highly engaged with or addicted to Twitter, having approximately 6,000-7,000 tweets over many years and being fairly disengaged from the platform
“I don't consider myself someone who had a a real pathology with it I mean I was you know I have I don't know 6,000 tweets or 7,000 tweets over the course of many years so I'm not I was not tweeting that much I was not even looking that much I was I was fairly disengaged”