
How Donald Trump destroyed the conservative movement
What this covers
This is a 44-minute conversation hosted by Civita, in which interviewer Eric Lecchia questions Charles Murray about where American conservatism stands after Trump. Murray first argues that Donald Trump was never a conservative by any recognizable definition. He calls him a rent-seeker who is ignorant of American history and has no reverence for the Constitution. The more unsettling part of the argument is why working-class voters stayed loyal to a man who embodied none of the traits they traditionally prized. Murray ties this to the upper-class isolation and contempt he described in Coming Apart. He also holds that the conservatives who came before Trump were thinner than they looked. He sets Ronald Reagan, who had read Hayek and Milton Friedman, against later Republican leaders through Mitt Romney, whom he accuses of lacking an ideological grounding or a willingness to make the case for their policies. Lecchia suggests that Sarah Palin on the 2008 ticket was an early omen of the populist turn.
The second half moves from the party to the country. Murray cites Gallup figures on collapsing trust in federal government and predicts that red regions will become harder to govern because compliance is voluntary. He also compares today's hatreds with those of the Civil War, and entertains, with some qualification, a comparison to Weimar's "stab in the back" myth. He forecasts that Trump's supporters will read any prosecution as persecution, and that Kinzinger and Cheney will struggle to win reelection. He is also critical of the left, arguing that woke ideology and talk of systemic responsibility breed backlash rather than persuasion. He expects a 51-50 Senate to pass major legislation without Republican votes, and he expects another cycle of overreach and backlash, as after 2010. He sees no institutional fix. He does not claim that a unifying, charismatic figure is likely, only that one could help. He expects the US may drift toward European-style social democracy within a decade, which he opposes, and he still urges principled advocacy of limited government.
Charles Murray argues that Donald Trump has destroyed the intellectual conservative movement in America, and the country now faces a deeper polarization and legitimacy crisis than at any point since the Civil War, with no clear path to reconciliation without an exceptionally charismatic leader.
- Trump attracted working-class support despite embodying none of the character values conservatives traditionally valued, revealing that principled conservatism had already lost its grip on the Republican base
- Trust in federal government has collapsed from 75% in 1958 to 15% today, creating a legitimacy crisis where red states no longer feel moral obligation to obey federal law
- Contemporary polarization exceeds even the Civil War era in hatred between sides, with no institutional or policy solution available—only the unlikely emergence of an exceptionally attractive, unifying leader
This asset isn't compiled yet
You're seeing its claims, ranked. Compile it to build the argument threads, weight them, and check each claim against your library — the full view.
Trump's appeal to blue-collar working-class voters was shocking because Trump embodied none of the character traits that American blue-collar workers traditionally valued—loyalty, honesty, respect for women, and trustworthiness in crisis—yet these voters showed intense personal loyalty and enthusiasm for him.
“he was attracting all the support from blue collar white males blue collar meaning working in in low-skilled jobs or skilled jobs but with their hands donald trump is the absolute opposite of what a man is supposed to be to american blue-collar workers a guy is supposed to be loyal he's supposed to be honest he is supposed to treat women right um he's supposed to be a guy that if you get in a bar fight you can trust him to stick with you donald trump is none of those things”
Trump supporters will interpret Trump's legal convictions as persecution by the government rather than legitimate legal consequences, viewing prosecutions as politically motivated rather than as genuine legal threats to Trump.
“they will they will see it that way”
Principled conservatives in positions of power from George H.W. Bush through Mitt Romney were fundamentally unprincipled in terms of conservative philosophy—they lacked coherent ideological grounding in Hayek, Friedman, or Adam Smith, and were unwilling to make the case for conservative policies by acknowledging both benefits and costs.
“none of them is what i would call a principled conservative they had principles they had moral principles but i i don't think you'd get any one of those four into a discussion about hayek's uh road to serfdom and probably none of them read it and if they had read it uh they would probably think well that's going a little too far”
The comparison between current American polarization and Weimar Germany is not unreasonable in terms of people losing allegiance to the established order and creating mythological explanations (theft of election, voter fraud) for political losses analogous to Weimar's 'stab in the back' myth.
“i don't think the comparisons with weimar are crazy a very different situation we face now but if you just look at it in terms of people who no longer feel allegiance toward the established order there's a similarity there and there is also the sense of not trusting the institutions in weimar they did they have been the stab in the back of the of the army and now there is the theft of the election with widespread voter fraud for which there is no evidence but people believe that there is”
Red states and Trump-supporting regions will become harder to govern from Washington because federal regulations cannot be enforced without voluntary compliance, and citizens in these areas no longer feel a moral obligation to obey federal law due to intense alienation from the federal government.
“you are going to have a lot of the red states in the middle and the ones that were strongest for trump they are going to be looking for going to be harder to govern from washington we have uh lots and lots of regulations that come out of washington dc and they affect farmers ranchers small town organizations they affect everybody all the businesses and they can't possibly be enforced unless most people comply with them voluntarily and most people have historically done that because that's what you're supposed to do if you're a citizen you have lots of people now in the red states who do not feel the same moral obligation to obey a law just because it's a law their sense of alienation from the federal government is intense”
Polarization and hatred between American political sides today may be worse than during the actual Civil War, where Lincoln refused to demonize Southerners, Lee refused to call opponents 'enemies,' and both sides cared for each other's wounded rather than committing atrocities.
“you can see all the ways big and small in which the two sides were not nearly as hateful of each other as uh they are now i mean they're things like abraham lincoln throughout the war refused to to to describe the the the south uh southerners as awful people he he he didn't do that he wouldn't do that robert e lee the the confederate general would never use the word enemy when he was talking about the other side he would talk about those people but it wouldn't it he would not use the word enemy to describe them you did not have atrocities i'm sure there were exceptions but but there was vicious fighting in the civil war you do not have one side massacring uh wounded men”
The pattern of the Obama administration overreaching with legislation passed without Republican support likely led to Republican gains in 2010, and the same cycle may repeat in 2022 with Democratic legislation, further cementing majoritarian rather than consensual governance.
“if i were a cynic what will happen in 2022 is what happened in 2010 two years after barack obama was elected the the obama administration also passed a lot of legislation with no republican support and they they overreached and so in the 2010 election the republicans got big majorities that could very well happen in 2022 but at this point we will have gotten used to a situation in which the sides that can do something politically because they have a bare number of votes will go ahead and do it and that is antithetical to the way the united states has always functioned”
The principles of human freedom and limited government are objectively true, and human flourishing is best achieved through these principles, so principled conservatives should continue advocating for them because truth ultimately prevails.
“the way i look at it is this is it objectively correct to say that the principles of uh human freedom that we believe in are they true uh is is a system of limited government in which people are free to take responsibility for their own lives is that the best way to achieve human happiness for the most people and the highest levels of human happiness if that is true if what we believe is true then point number one is we shouldn't give up”
The American conservative movement has been completely demolished under Donald Trump, eliminating what was once a real intellectual force that emphasized principled conservative ideas within the Republican party.
“donald trump has destroyed the conservative movement what used to be a real force an intellectual force for conservative ideas [0:07] often emphasized in the republican party has under donald trump been completely demolished”
People in the 1850s did not foresee the coming Civil War even though divisions were severe, suggesting we should take seriously contemporary warnings about civil conflict because people who lived through actual catastrophe typically did not see it coming.
“i'm beginning to feel the force of that statement when i have heard in the you know the past few months people saying maybe it's the 1850s all over again and we are heading toward a civil war i stopped laughing at that because i said to myself you know in the 1850s very few people saw that war coming they knew they had problems they knew that this is a very divisive issue hardly any of them said we're going to have a war in which half a million men get killed well right now very few people think that there will be a catastrophe that may be because we don't know how it's going to turn out and we are unaware aware of the danger we're in”
Critical race theory, anti-fascist movement, and woke ideology contribute to deepening polarization by telling white Americans they are 'irredeemably racist' and 'systemically' responsible for harm, which creates anger and backlash rather than persuasion.
“what you have with that ideology is one part of the population saying to the white population you are evil you are irredeemably racist america is systemically racist uh it's your fault you've been doing all these awful things and you better change your ways or else well you know you don't usually change people's minds by insulting them”
Donald Trump is not a conservative by any recognizable definition—he is a rent-seeker who used government for personal enrichment, is not fiscally conservative, does not revere the Constitution, and is ignorant of American history and political philosophy.
“it's hard to think of any single way in which he was recognizably conservative uh he made his fortune by being a rent seeker and using government uh to get special uh breaks on his uh buildings uh to get special regulations passed and zoning and he was he he loves government as a way of enriching himself he um he certainly is not fiscally a conservative he is not a conservative in the sense of of revering the constitution”
The American upper class looks upon ordinary Americans with contempt, and ordinary Americans understood and felt this contempt, which contributed to their alienation and receptivity to Trump.
“they also looked out in many cases on ordinary americans and ordinary americans understood that they understood the contempt that a lot of the new upper class feels toward them”
There is no systemic solution to current polarization, but an 'extremely attractive candidate' with Reagan's goodwill, Kennedy's charm, FDR's political skill, Eisenhower's grandfatherly appearance, and Clinton's personality could unify the country.
“i don't think there is a systemic solution out there i think the the solution and this is not something you can plan for is that an extremely attractive candidate comes along i don't care whether he's democrat or republican but an extremely attractive candidate who can project the same kind of good will that ronald reagan did”
Adam Kinzinger and Liz Cheney, despite their principled stands on the Constitution and rule of law, likely cannot get reelected because Trump voters dislike them and they don't command followership based on coherent ideological principles.
“i'm not even sure that the people you mentioned could get reelected because a lot of trump voters don't like them and they also don't form a a core in the sense of people flock to them because of principal positions”
The probability is good (within a decade) that the United States will become like Europe with social democracy, which some Americans view as desirable but which Murray opposes because he wants America to preserve its historical emphasis on human freedom and dignity.
“if i had to make a guess the chances are good that uh in a decade we're going to be just like europe now mind you there are a lot of people in the united states who think that's great you know social democracy a wave of the future norway sweden look at them we can be just like norway and sweden so there are a lot of people say fine like we're going to be like europe and much as i loved my trip to norway and much as i want to come back i don't want the united states to be like norway you know we have our virtues you have your virtues i want america to still be recognizably of what it has been in the past which is an emblem of a certain way of looking at human freedom and of human dignity that i think is really important”
The American upper class is isolated in communities where everybody is like them, shares the same tastes in child-rearing, food, and vacation destinations, and maintains a separate culture from ordinary Americans, as documented in Murray's book 'Coming Apart.'
“i documented the extent to which the new upper class in the united states was isolated from the rest of the country they live in in communities where everybody else is like them they share the same tastes in child rearing practices and food and where they take their vacations and it's a whole culture that is very separated from ordinary american culture”
Ronald Reagan was a genuinely principled conservative who had read Hayek's 'Road to Serfdom' and Milton Friedman's 'Free to Choose' and possessed a coherent set of ideological beliefs, unlike subsequent Republican presidents, making him exceptional in this regard.
“ronald reagan did have a coherent set of beliefs behind his his political behavior and his political behavior was in many ways very wise...unlike the others he not only had read wrote to serfdom he had also read milton's friedman's free to choose i'm sure he had read uh adam smith and the others he he was a thoughtful and uh very well-read principled conservative”
The working-class plumber who makes enough to support his family but is not rich, who has worked hard to achieve his position, and who gets along well with his Black and Latino coworkers does not experience the white privilege or systemic racism that woke rhetoric attributes to him, creating legitimate grievance.
“much of the american white americans are saying what do you mean white privilege i make my living as a plumber i'd make enough money to keep my family comfortable but i'm not rich and i've got what i've got because i just worked really hard where's this white privilege where's my racism i have black co-workers i have latino co-workers i get along with them i respect them i'm friendly with them they're friendly with me what's this white racism business this systemically racist”
Sarah Palin as McCain's 2008 running mate may have been an early omen of the populist turn that would fully emerge in the Trump candidacy.
“i had the pleasure of being a volunteer for john mccain's election in 2008 i spent three four weeks i have some family in in minnesota i had some reservation about sarah palin but but still maybe she was an omen for for for what to come”
If the 2000 Florida election recount had been decided 50-50 close, American institutions would not have held, suggesting current institutional strength in the face of polarization is fragile and dependent on luck.
“if it were just as close as in 2000s in florida i'm not sure it would have held just as much”
Trust in federal government to do the right thing collapsed from nearly 75% in 1958 to approximately 15% in the present decade according to Gallup polling, representing a fundamental legitimacy crisis.
“the gallup poll is a big polling organization the united states and since 1958 a long time ago they have been asking americans how much do you trust the federal government to do what is right all of the time most of the time or only some of the time and in the first time you asked the question in 1958 almost 75 percent of americans said they trusted the government to do the right thing most or all of the time and uh for the last decade that's been in the region of 15 down from 75”
Trump lacked the attention span and capability to effectively use presidential power, and he was not competent enough to orchestrate a true coup, which is fortunate because a more capable Trump could have undermined American institutions far more severely.
“what we should all be very grateful for eric is that he was not very good in the use of power i mean using presidential power effectively is is difficult um he didn't really understand that and some say also that he have didn't have the attention span to really orchestrate a coup or whatever you would call it...if he had been really capable in the uses of power he could have gone a lot farther than he did in undermining uh american institutions”
Democratic control of Senate at 51-50 (relying on VP tiebreaker) is enabling passage of major legislation without Republican support, which is unprecedented in American history where major social legislation has required substantial bipartisan support.
“every single piece of major social legislation in the new deal and throughout american history has passed with substantial support from both parties what we're seeing now is unprecedented”
Principled conservatives should view themselves as a 'remnant' keeping intellectual ideas alive until conditions change, similar to how Hayek and others kept classical liberal ideas alive in the 1930s-40s when they were politically marginal.
“as an individual i think we have to look upon ourselves who are still principal conservatives as a remnant and the remnant is a fur phrase that used to be used you know when when very few people held these these ideas in the 1930s very few in the 1940s a few did and they kept the flame alive and so that it was free the the freddie kayak wrote rode to serfdom in 1943 and he and and you already had not a political force but you had an intellectual force”
The Senate filibuster has been historically essential to the American system because it requires major legislation to build broad coalitions rather than pass on bare majorities, and eliminating it fundamentally changes the nature of the Senate.
“they may get rid of what we call the filibuster which fundamentally changes the nature of the senate”
Donald Trump's future political role is uncertain and may be overstated because: (1) his health is declining (obesity, poor diet), (2) his mental faculties are slipping, and (3) his legal troubles and financial difficulties with his organization will consume his attention.
“i am not everybody treats donald trump in 2022 and 2024 as if he's going to be alive that he's going to be mentally you know competent and i don't think either one of those two things is a given you've got an obese man with a with a very unhealthy diet of who has mentally has been slipping i think for some years and also look i'm 78 i'm his old i'm older than he is even i know what the energy level is like at 78 versus 58 and it's different and it's less”
Joe Biden has adopted the framing that America is 'systemically racist,' which is a consequential departure from acknowledging that racism still exists and is different from claiming systemic racism.
“joe biden now talks of america as being systemically racist which is a very different thing from saying does america still have races sure um that's very different from saying it's a systemically racist country”
Murray knew about upper-class isolation and contempt from his research, but did not foresee the amount and intensity of anger among working-class Americans and their readiness to grasp onto any leader willing to speak their language.
“i knew about that what i did not foresee was the amount of anger that was being felt uh and the readiness that they had for grabbing on to any leader who looked like they would speak their language”
Mitch Daniels (former Governor of Indiana) was a candidate who could have filled the role of unifying national leader, but that opportunity has passed.
“you don't manufacture those people we had a person who i think was like that in the form of mitch daniels uh which you you know as you've spent a lot of time around american politics uh he was governor of indiana he was a case of a person who i think actually could have filled that role but that chance passed us by”
The 1964 Reagan landslide victory was undermined by Nancy Reagan's desire for Reagan to win every state, which meant he didn't campaign on specific policy proposals, limiting his ability to claim a mandate for conservative policies in his second term.
“the great tragedy there was the 1964 election where he i think it was nancy reagan wanted him to get a landslide when every state which he almost did but not he didn't have a mandate he didn't campaign he he had a popularity in 1984 that had he said okay here's what i want to do in my second term he could have done a lot of stuff”
The principled conservative tradition developed during the 1950s and gained prominence through figures like William F. Buckley and National Review, reaching a peak with Barry Goldwater's 1964 presidential campaign.
“principled conservatism based on the writings of hayek and of friedman and adam smith and the founders and so forth that really developed during the 1950s bill buckley and national review gave it a major platform by 1964 we had barry goldwater running for president”
Lecchia emphasizes that even informed friends on both the conservative and liberal sides of American politics tend to discuss how bad the other side is rather than discussing solutions, suggesting a failure of constructive dialogue.
“when i talk to my my friends and on the conservative side in the us and also on the liberal side or or friends who are democrats they always talk about how bad the other side is instead of talking about what they have as solutions”
Microsoft and other corporate elites have embraced critical race theory and committed to diversity targets (e.g., achieving specific percentages of minority middle management), representing elite capitulation to woke ideology.
“the elites have been filled with remorse so you know uh microsoft says oh yes we're going to change our ways we're going to have x percent of our middle management be minorities within 10 years”
Robert E. Lee refused to use the word 'enemy' when referring to the other side during the Civil War, instead saying 'those people,' demonstrating rhetorical restraint and refusal to dehumanize opponents.
“robert e lee the the confederate general would never use the word enemy when he was talking about the other side he would talk about those people but it wouldn't it he would not use the word enemy to describe them”
William Yeats' poem line 'the center cannot hold' is metaphorically applicable to contemporary American democracy where extreme positions dominate and centrist positions lack power.
“second coming from william beth the eighth was so quoted as hundred years ago when he wrote the center cannot hold you get that feeling in the u.s today this center cannot hold”
Lecchia notes that politicians from both sides (even principled conservatives and Republican elites) have been opportunistically adopting Trump's script rather than opposing him on principle.
“people like marco rubio even nikki haley has gone so far in in just excusing him and just getting under trump script it's it's that's really the shocking part for me”
In the 1970s, principled conservatives became 'chic' and 'fashionable' because they had more new ideas and exciting ideas than liberals who were exhausted, suggesting that ideological appeal can be a competitive advantage.
“in the 1970s people on the principled right actually became chic fashionable because we had more new ideas and more exciting ideas than the liberals who were out of energy”
Ronald Reagan appointed three principled, capable intellectual conservatives to the Supreme Court, which was good but was done as a political bargain rather than from personal principle.
“he appointed three principled and very capable uh conservatives intellectual conservatives to the supreme court that was good but he didn't do it because of any personal principles he did it because that was part of the political bargain he had with uh with people”
Trump made his fortune through rent-seeking behaviors including obtaining special breaks on building projects and favorable zoning regulations through government influence.
“he made his fortune by being a rent seeker and using government uh to get special uh breaks on his uh buildings uh to get special regulations passed and zoning”
Trump's illegal refusal to accept the 2020 election results—specifically calling for votes to stop being counted in states he was ahead in while continuing in states where he was behind—was obviously ridiculous and difficult to understand how any informed person could believe the election was stolen.
“after the election when he when in my view he he kind of tried to orchestrate a coup d'etat with saying that they should stop counting the votes in in pennsylvania georgia uh all the states he weren't were ahead while he said they should keep counting in the states that he were behind which is like it's it's so obviously ridiculous i have some problems thinking anybody can see through it”
Ben Sasse comes closest among current politicians to being both a principled conservative intellectual and a successful politician who can give voice to conservative principles.
“ben sasse is close i mean i like ben sasse a lot and maybe that's as close as we have to somebody who could give voice to conservative principles and and be a successful politician as well we will see but i'm not optimistic about it”
Lecchia worked as a volunteer for John McCain's 2008 presidential campaign in Minnesota and had some reservations about Sarah Palin, but didn't recognize her as an omen for Trump.
“i had the pleasure of being a volunteer for john mccain's election in 2008 i spent three four weeks i have some family in in minnesota i had some reservation about sarah palin but but still maybe she was an omen for for for what to come”