
Four Horsemen - Feature Documentary - Official Version
What this covers
The film is a feature-length documentary built from interviews with 23 economists, advisors, and financial insiders, stitched together by a narrator. Its first move is historical and cultural rather than technical. It describes how the Cold War stopped both communism and capitalism from criticizing themselves, and argues that after communism failed, the West carried on in triumphalist mode even though both systems pursue the same impossible goal of growing forever. It then asks why this goes unchallenged, answering that elites hold power by controlling the "cognitive map," meaning what stays undebated and unsaid. It sets Hollywood's story structure, the Gutenberg press, and the internet against that idea.
The middle ground is wide. The interviewees discuss a world that has gone from relatively empty to relatively full, and an America whose habit of "making the pie bigger" now runs into limits. The film also covers the argument that material growth has decoupled from life expectancy and happiness, and that consumerism is really about status and alienated relationships. The housing material is concrete. It follows property ownership pushed under Reagan and Thatcher, money flooding into housing, new mothers pushed back to work to service mortgages, and bankers who in about 2000 exploited the poor's belief that debts must be paid. A German comparison shows a culture that does not tie ownership to democracy.
Some turns are contentious. One speaker says the "terrorists" he has known were displaced farmers, not zealots. Others compare the fading West to declining empires, and cite the Industrial Revolution view, which Lincoln shared, that workers should own the mills. The film also stops to say that talented, risk-taking entrepreneurs are a legitimate product of free markets. It closes on Gandhi on need versus greed, a distinction between democracy and plutocracy, and Nietzsche on purpose.
The film argues that Western economic and political systems have been systematically corrupted to serve financial and corporate interests over the majority, creating conditions for inevitable systemic collapse unless fundamental reforms to money, taxation, banking, and democratic structures are implemented.
- Private banks create money from nothing and lend at interest, concentrating wealth upward through fiat currency systems that collapse under unsustainable debt
- Political systems have been captured by financial interests through lobbying and campaign contributions, making governments unresponsive to public will
- The pursuit of infinite growth on a finite planet combined with extreme inequality is generating the Four Horsemen: financial predation, organized violence, mass poverty, and resource depletion
This asset isn't compiled yet
You're seeing its claims, ranked. Compile it to build the argument threads, weight them, and check each claim against your library — the full view.
Elites stay in power not merely by controlling the means of production (the money) but by controlling the cognitive map—the way we think—particularly through controlling what remains un-debated and unsaid.
“Most societies have an elite and the elites try to stay in power. And the way they stay in power is not merely by controlling the means of production, to be Marxist, i.e. controlling the money, but by controlling the cognitive map, the way we think. And what really matters in that respect, is not so much what is actually said in public but is what is left un-debated, unsaid.”
Before 1989 there was a battle between communism and capitalism where neither side would criticize the flaws in their own system due to Cold War competition; communism failed first due to inefficiency and lack of human rights, so capitalist West continued triumphalist mode—but both systems are trying to do something fundamentally impossible: grow forever.
“Before 1989 we had a battle between communism and the market. And in that battle there was a sense of 'let's not expose the flaws in the market economy.' This is too important of a battle that you don't criticize 'our team' while we're fighting 'their team'. And their team, social authoritarianism, with a failure to deliver wellbeing to their society, it was very clear that if you had to choose between these two, which was better? Communism failed first for various reasons: it was inefficient, human rights lack of respect and so-forth. So capitalist West has been continuing in a triumphalist mode thinking 'Our adversary has failed, that means we're doing everything right'. Both systems are trying to do something which is fundamentally impossible: Grow forever. And they're both going to fail. One failed first. Capitalism's going to fail... later. Or it's failing now.”
When you organize human society, some people get ahead and others struggle—that's natural mechanism—but saying 'we must have inequality therefore Goldman Sachs must exist in current form' is a complete non-sequitur.
“It is true that if you... when you organise human society, some people get ahead and some people struggle. That's a natural mechanism. But saying: 'Oh, we've got to have inequality therefore Goldman Sachs must be organised along the following lines', that's a complete non-sequitur.”
We have moved from a relatively empty world to a relatively full world—empty of humans and stuff to full of humans and stuff; world population has tripled in the speaker's lifetime, and populations of cars, houses, boats also vastly more than tripled.
“What's happened is that we have moved from a relatively empty world to a relatively full world - that is empty of us and all of our stuff, to now full of us and all of our stuff. In my lifetime the world population has tripled. And the populations of other things, of cars, houses, boats... all these other things that put a load on the environment too, just like human bodies, those have vastly more than tripled.”
Consumerism is driven by extraordinarily social nature—we want stuff to look good in other people's eyes through feelings of shame, embarrassment, or pride; goods mediate alienated hierarchical relationships.
“Consumerism is driven by our extraordinarily social nature, that we want to have the stuff so we look good in other people's eyes. It's because I experience myself through other people's eyes, their feelings of shame and embarrassment or pride, and... maybe feeling envied, all those things. So... the goods are just a way of, if you like, mediating the relationship between yourself and others in this extraordinarily alienated hierarchy.”
What's really suffered is human relationships, family life, the things that really matter—only thing that makes humans happy isn't money; past certain level you only get marginal gains from wealth, but relationship with other people is being damaged by last 30 years.
“What's really suffered is human relationships, family life, the things that really matter to us. And in the end the only thing that makes human beings happy, isn't money, it's very clear that past a certain level you only get marginal gains from wealth. What really makes us happy is other people. It's our relationship with other people that's really being damaged by the last 30 years.”
Individual isolation and achievement confined to glass jar with limited height—encapsulating, ending in death of lack of oxygen; humans are alive because they seek attachment and propelled by affection.
“The idea was: 'Make your own life, be individually aspiring, and then you'll be individually achieving, and then you'll be individually prosperous, and then you'll be individually happy.' You end up doing that in a glass jar and the glass jar has a limited height, and it is encapsulating, and in the end you die of lack of oxygen. Human beings are alive because they seek attachment, and because they're propelled by affection.”
One of most powerful cultural frameworks shaping Western thinking is Hollywood film construction with beginning, middle, end, drama, tension, resolution, goodie and baddie, and story holding humans together.
“One of the most powerful cultural frameworks that shapes the way we think today in the West is the Hollywood film construction. And it follows a particular cultural pattern in that there is a beginning, there is a middle, and an end. There is drama, tension, there is resolution, there is usually a goodie and a baddie and there is usually a story to hold the medium of human beings.”
In Germany, people don't see connection between owning property and being democratic and are comfortable renting, but Reagan and Thatcher pushed property ownership before people were ready, pushing dubious loans on them, leading to subprime crisis.
“It's interesting, if you talk to people in Germany, for example, they don't see a connection between owning a piece of property and their being inclined towards being democratic. There are lots of people who rent their housing there and they are perfectly comfortable with that arrangement. But it is true that in somewhat different contexts both Mr Reagan and Mrs Thatcher pushed for more people to own housing, and actually this is part of the problem because if you push people to buy housing before they are ready, if you push very dubious loans on them, and they don't understand what they're getting themselves into, you can have huge adverse repercussions. Exactly what led to, in part, the subprime housing crisis in the United States.”
Mankind is disposed to suffer while evils are sufferable rather than abolish the forms to which they are accustomed, as stated in the American Declaration of Independence.
“All experience has shown that mankind is more disposed to suffer - while evils are sufferable - than to right themselves by abolishing the forms to which they are accustomed. American Declaration of Independence.”
Gutenberg's printing press wrestled control of the cognitive map away from ecclesiastical and royal elite in the 16th century, and today the internet is beginning to change governments, finance and media in similar fashion.
“For centuries gatekeepers have manipulated our cognitive map. But in 1989 a computer scientist by the name of Tim Berners-Lee implemented the first successful communication between an HTTP client and server. The World Wide Web was born. It has since unleashed a tsunami of instantly accessible, freely available information. Just as Gutenberg's printing press wrestled control of the cognitive map away from an ecclesiastical and royal elite, today the internet is beginning to change governments, finance and the media.”
A great power destroys itself by persisting in trying to do the impossible—empires do not begin or end on a certain date but they do end, and the West has not yet come to terms with its fading supremacy.
“All a great power has to do to destroy itself is persist in trying to do the impossible. Stephen Vizinczey... Empires do not begin or end on a certain date. But they do end, and the West has not yet come to terms with its fading supremacy.”
America has historically existed on the assumption that resources could be expanded—Go West, make the pie bigger so everyone gets a bigger piece—but is now facing a world where resources are constrained and must divide the pie and inflict pain on people, something it is not well prepared for.
“America right now is in a very interesting position. Because in the past 200 - 300 years of its history it's a culture and country which has almost always existed on the assumption that resources could be expanded. If there was a problem you always tried to deal with it by expanding the pie, 'Go West young man'. Make the pie bigger so that everyone has got a bigger piece. Now it's facing a world where possibly resources are beginning to be more constrained, and where it's going to have to divide up that pie, and inflict pain on people. And that's something which it is not well prepared for.”
The speaker has known many 'terrorists' and never met one who wanted to be a terrorist—they wanted to be with families back on farm; they're driven to terrorism because their farms were destroyed by hydro projects or oil derricks or fishing waters destroyed.
“I've known a lot of 'terrorists', quote-unquote. I've met them, I've interviewed them for books, I've known them since I was an economic hit man, I've never met one who wanted to be a terrorist. They all wanted to be with their families, back on the farm. They're driven to terrorism because they've lost the farm. It's been inundated with water from a hydro-electric project, or with oil from oil derricks. Their farm has been destroyed. They can't make a living for their kids.”
While there may be a few crazy people like Osama bin Laden, terrorists do not get a following unless there's terrible injustice and people are starving and deprived—then they will follow crazy people because they offer an alternative.
“Now there may be a few crazy people, there are a few crazy people, people with their nuts loose, there'll always be serial killers, there'll always be crazy people, maybe Osama bin Laden is one of them, but they do not get a following unless there's a terrible injustice going on, and people are starving and they're deprived, and then they will follow these crazy people because they seem to offer an alternative.”
Newly created money entered the housing market creating unprecedented inflation—house prices rose, forcing new mothers back into workplace to service huge home loans, making the Anglo-American dream about land speculation rather than ownership.
“All this newly created money entered the housing market and created unprecedented inflation - house prices rose and rose. New mothers were forced back into the workplace to service huge home loans and the Anglo-American dream became all about land speculation.”
Around 2000, bankers discovered that poor people are honest—if you're poor you believe debt is debt and must be paid even if the debts are not valid or much more than expected, which banks exploited through predatory lending.
“The breakthrough that occurred around the year 2000 in the U.S. was when bankers found out that the poor are honest. They realised that if you're poor, if you're not rich, you have a different set of values and you think that a debt is a debt and it's something that has to be paid. And the people will try to pay the debts that they are stuck with, even if the debts are not valid. Even if the debts are much more than they expected, even if they really can't pay the debts.”
For hundreds of years the best way of raising real quality of human life was raising material living standards—driven huge rises in life expectancy and happiness; but all have now become detached from economic growth.
“For hundreds of years the best way of raising the real quality of human life has been to raise material living standards. And that's what's driven the huge rises in life expectancy and increases in happiness and other measures of well being. But all those have now become detached from economic growth. And although life expectancy continues to rise in the rich world, it's no longer related to the amount of economic growth a country has at all. And the same is true for measures of happiness and measures of well-being.”
During the Industrial Revolution, workers believed that workers should own the mills they work in, not just temporary wage labor—this was deep in working class culture as fundamental right of free citizens, not exotic view but Abraham Lincoln's view and Republican Party principle.
“Perhaps we should also resurrect another timeless principle for workers that was promoted during the Industrial Revolution. The idea that people who work in a plant ought to own it, is just deeply built into working class culture. So right around here at the early Industrial Revolution in the late 19th century, working people simply took for granted, that yes, of course, the workers should own the mills in which they work. Anything else is an attack on our fundamental rights as free citizens. They also took for granted that wage labour is hardly different from slavery...One of the ways you can be free is by owning your own plant. That was not an exotic view - that was Abraham Lincoln's view. In fact it was a principle of the Republican Party in the late 19th century.”
Within any species all members have same needs so might fight for food, shelter, territory—but human beings have other possibility: humans can be best source of support, love, and cooperation much more than any other animal.
“In any species, in almost any animal, there is always the potential for huge conflict, because within any species, all members of that species have the same needs. So they might fight each other for food, and shelter, and nest sites and territory and sexual partners, all that kind of thing. But human beings have always had the other possibility. We have the possibility to be the best source of support and love and assistance and cooperation. Much more so than any other animal.”
The world has enough for everybody's need but not for anybody's greed, as Mahatma Gandhi said—the problem is not scarcity but a fundamentally flawed system.
“The problem is not that there is not enough in the world. People say that there is poverty we have to create more wealth. There is enough in the world for everybody's need - as Mahatma Gandhi said, but not for anybody's greed. But is it just greed, or does it go deeper than that? Is the problem systemic?”
Democracy is government by the people; plutocracy is government by the rich with high economic inequality, low social mobility, and continuous exploitation making it nearly impossible for workers to climb out of poverty.
“Democracy is government by the people. Plutocracy is government by the rich. In a typical plutocratic state economic inequality is high, social mobility low, and, because of continuous exploitation of the masses, workers find it nearly impossible to climb out of poverty.”
Oil companies are drilling miles under the sea because world's easily-accessible oil has been found and largely consumed—not only oil supplies dwindling but major new metals discoveries becoming increasingly rare.
“The reason oil companies are drilling miles under the sea is that the world's easily-accessible oil has already been found and, largely, consumed. Not only are oil supplies dwindling, major new metals discoveries are becoming increasingly rare.”
If genuinely talented people earning big money bring something new and tangible to the world and take personal risks with their own money bringing greater prosperity—that's legitimate and the brilliance of free market.
“Can there be any objection to genuinely talented people earning big money if they bring something new and tangible to the world, if they take great personal risks with their own money, and actually bring greater prosperity for all? In a free market, if I have a brilliant idea that I can run an automobile on grass clippings, as an example, and I produce that car, my motivation might be to make money. But if the market says: 'My goodness, this is the greatest automobile ever invented by mankind', and I make a billion dollars, I've not only served myself but I have served everyone else that needs transportation. And that is the brilliance of our free market, is that paradox that you can serve yourself and simultaneously serve others.”
To understand something is to be liberated from it—which requires context from people who speak truth in the face of collective delusion.
“To do that we need context from people who speak the truth in the face of collective delusion because to understand something is to be liberated from it.”
Purpose in life must be outside yourself—must be positive value added to society; if pursuing yourself you're pursuing the abyss as Nietzsche said, ending in abyss.
“In order to find a purpose in life it has to be outside yourself. It matters not how you construct it outside yourself as long as it is a positive value added to society pursued. But it has to be outside yourself, it can't be yourself. If you are pursuing yourself you are pursuing the abyss as Nietzsche said, you are going to wind up in the abyss.”
Since 1971 when President Nixon took the U.S. off the gold standard, the world has operated under fiat currencies where the dollar, pound, and euro exist as government law enforced through taxation.
“But how is it that we've ended up with a system in which banks have the power to create money? Since 1971, when President Nixon took the United States off what was left of the gold standard, the world has operated under a system of money known as 'fiat'. The dollar, the pound, the euro are all government fiat currencies. Fiat is a Latin word meaning 'let it be so'. It is the law that this government currency be money.”
Banks were given money to help lending to others but instead decided to use it to pay themselves bonuses for record losses, which was reprehensible.
“What the banks did was reprehensible. That was why there was the outrage at the greed of the bankers when we gave them money that was supposed to help them lend to others but they decided to use that money to pay themselves bonuses - for what, for record losses?”
At the end of World War II the U.S. had 50% of the world's GDP and was making 54,000 airplanes and 7,000 ships per year—we recognized ourselves as the new Rome and devised a power management scheme in the 1947 National Security Act, but we haven't adapted since and that's a sign of our inability to grasp the new world.
“At the end of World War II, we had 50% of the world's gross domestic product, we were making 54,000 airplanes a year, 7,000 ships, etc etc. We were the new Rome. And we recognized it, and devised a power management scheme in the 1947 National Security Act to, we thought, manage it and it worked fairly well during the Cold War. But we haven't done anything since and I think that is another sign of our inability to grasp the 'new world', if you will.”
The Roman denarius was debased from a silver standard to a copper coin, with plating washed off in circulation, until Rome's senators represented only their own wealth theft—demonstrating how currency debasement accompanies imperial collapse.
“Rome was no different. So it started on a principle that was very sound and it was on a silver standard. But as it corrupted further and further and further the Roman denarius got to the point where it was basically a copper coin and they learnt how to plate and it was washed in silver and in circulation the plating came off. And at the end all the senators that really did at one time represent the people only were interested in representing how much wealth they could steal at the top.”
A commercial bank creates money from nothing and then lends it to you at interest—what would be counterfeiting if done by an individual or 'cooking the books' if done by an accountant is perfectly legal when a bank does it.
“The fact is most people think that what a bank does is lend you money that someone else has put in the bank previously. But what a bank actually does, what a commercial bank does, is to create money from nothing, and then lend it to you at interest. If I do that, if I manufacture money in my own home it's called counterfeiting. If an accountant creates money out of nothing in the company accounts, it's called 'cooking the books', but if a bank does it, it's perfectly legal.”
Over the last 30-40 years capitalism has taken an extreme form, going back to economist Milton Friedman from the Chicago School and Ronald Reagan and Margaret Thatcher, encouraging huge debt, privatization, smaller governments (though bigger militaries), deregulation, and removing rules governing corporations.
“Over the last 30 to 40 years capitalism has taken this extreme form, and a lot of it goes back to the economist Milton Friedman, from the Chicago School and Ronald Reagan, and Margaret Thatcher, and others buying into these policies, that really encouraged people to take on huge amounts of debt, encouraged privatisation, smaller governments supposedly, although bigger militaries, so actually... ...the government spending goes up. U.S. Military Spending. deregulation, getting rid of rules that govern the people who run our institutions, especially our corporations.”
In 1932 after the Great Stock Market Crash, the Glass-Steagall Act separated ordinary banking from investment banking to protect society; in 1999 under Larry Summers and Robert Rubin, President Bill Clinton repealed it, allowing banks to gamble with depositors' money.
“In 1932, in the aftermath of America's Great Stock Market Crash, a piece of legislation was passed to protect society. The Glass-Steagall Act was introduced to separate ordinary high street banking from investment banking. 67 years later, in 1999 - under the influence of Treasury Secretary Larry Summers and his predecessor Robert Rubin - President Bill Clinton repealed the Glass-Steagall Act. Once again banks could take ordinary depositors' money and speculate with it on virtually anything they liked.”
Wells Fargo, one of major lenders, targeted minority communities, put borrowers into unaffordable subprime loans, and their foreclosures significantly impaired progress in developing African-American communities.
“These were loans which were made by one of the major lenders in the city and in this country, Wells Fargo, in which Wells Fargo targeted minority communities in the city; put borrowers into loans that they could not afford, put borrowers into loans that were of the subprime variety, therefore more expensive and less advantageous to the borrowers... Many of the communities in which African-Americans live in the city, were establishing momentum, there was development activity that was occurring, we were seeing signs of vitality in many of these communities, and... the results of the Wells Fargo foreclosures and the subprime lending practices of that lender, and others, has significantly impaired that progress and brought it to a halt.”
The people of Rome were constantly distracted by gladiatorial events; whenever there was unrest among the people politicians created a huge event with many gladiators—a common trait of declining empires visible today through television and sports.
“The people of Rome were constantly being distracted by the gladiatorial events and the politicians knew that they did this. Whenever there was unrest among the people they had a huge event going on and they created a new event with lots and lots of gladiators. And every day, we're doing that. That is a common trait of declining empires. And so today, in the U.S. for example, you find a tremendous emphasis on all kinds of television programmes that distract people from what's really is going on. Sports is a big part of that, as it was in gladiator times.”
Those with power to issue money (governments and banks) and those receiving money early can spend before prices rise, getting assets cheaply; but those at the bottom receive money late when prices have risen, their savings buy less, wages stay flat, forcing them back to banks through debt—money creation only redistributes wealth upward.
“Of course, those that have the power to issue money: governments and banks. Then, those companies and individuals that get this money early. They can spend it before the prices of the things they want to buy have risen to reflect the new money in circulation. In other words, they get services, products or assets cheap. But prices soon rise, so holders of assets, such as houses or shares, will then see gains without there necessarily being any improvements to the company or house in question. Often this can lead to speculative bubbles. But what about those at the bottom of the pyramid? Those on fixed wages or incomes, those who live in remote areas or those with savings? By the time this newly created money has filtered down to them, the prices of the things they want to buy have increased, their savings buy them less however, and their wages remain largely unchanged. In some cases they have to take on debt just to be to afford the things they were previously able to buy, which means they have to go back to the banks. In reality, this process of creating money only redistributes wealth from the bottom to the top of the pyramid.”
Adam Smith's 'invisible hand' theory is widely misused—Smith was aware businesses conspired against the public interest, monopoly harms, importance of education, and private sector limitations, but modern followers forgot these caveats.
“Adam Smith didn't really say that. That is, Adam Smith was very much aware that businesses when they got together conspired against the public interest, raised prices, he was aware of monopoly, he was aware of the importance of education, that the private sector couldn't provide, so he himself is aware of all of the limitations, but his latter day descendents have forgotten all those caveats.”
The word 'terrorist' means what they do to us, not what we do to them—what we do to them could be worse than 9/11.
“When we talk about terrorism it means what they do to us. Not what we do to them. And what they do to us can be pretty ugly, although... it's not even a fraction of what we do to them.”
West is coming to realization that its human project is failing—pushed people to achieve as individuals assuming accumulated achievement would make successful society, but individual achievement without vulnerable community incorporated is a myth.
“The West is coming to the realisation that its human project is failing. The West was so convinced that if you push people to achieve as individuals, that accumulated achievement of individuals would make for a successful society. And what the West is now beginning to realise is that the individual achievement, without incorporating the vulnerable community is a myth.”
When the taxpayer foots the bill for banker speculation, instead of the economy serving the human being, the human being is now in perpetual service to amoral financial organizations.
“When the taxpayer is footing the bill for the misplaced speculation of bankers then suddenly instead of the economy serving the human being, the human being is now in perpetual service to amoral financial organisations.”
As long as you allow fraud to be legalized, all kinds of problems will pop up in the economic system that you cannot fix—bank money creation from nothing, when taught to economics students, seems absurd and rightfully so, but it is how banking actually works.
“And so long as you allow fraud to be legalised then all kinds of problems are going to pop up in the economic system you can't do anything about. Private banks create money out of nothing and lend it at interest. Now, that sounds absurd. When I teach sophomores, you know, about money and banking, and how banks... they never believe it. And so you have to go through it again and again, 'Yes, banks really do create money, they really do, here is how it happens.' And it's absurd! And they're right to doubt that that could possibly be what's really going on. But it is!”
The banking lobby wants to convince people that wage claims are too high and speculation is driving inflation—not that banks are creating money from nothing and pumping it into the system.
“Now if the banking lobby is very strong, they're going to say: 'Well, we don't want to change this system, we're making so much money out of it. What we have to do is: Try and convince the people that it's their fault, that their wages claims are too high and that's why we're having lots of inflation,' or 'People are speculating on housing and that's why house prices are going up.' What they're not going to say is that this is happening because banks are creating money out of nothing and pumping it into the system, and that's why prices are going up.”
When you combine fiat money currency with fractional reserve banking, you compound debt faster than you can possibly produce to support it—eventually you end up back in debt slavery, which is what's happened in the U.S.
“Well... when you get off the gold standard and you go into a fiat money currency combined with a fractional reserve banking system, you end up compounding debt faster than you can ever possibly produce to support that debt. So eventually you are going to find yourself back into debt slavery. And that's what's happened in the U.S.”
President Obama wants to invest $7.5 billion in Pakistan infrastructure to alleviate poverty and reduce anti-American sentiment—but this kind of help is actually a hindrance that will make matters worse and bring contrived war on terror into rural areas.
“President Obama, I understand, wants to invest $7.5 billion in Pakistan's infrastructure to alleviate poverty and, you know, take away all the divisions, and all the anti-American sentiment over here. But whatever his reasons are, we can do without it. In fact it's the worst possible thing he can do. This kind of help is actually going to be a hindrance; it is just going to make matters worse, it will bring this contrived war on terror into our rural areas.”
Growth economy demands consumption as way of life—'he who dies with the most toys' became ambition and retail replaced spiritual satisfaction; unsurprisingly anti-depressant sales skyrocketed.
“The growth economy demands that we make consumption a way of life. He who 'dies with the most toys' became the ambition and retail replaced spiritual satisfaction. Unsurprisingly, sales of anti-depressants sky rocketed.”
The Baby-Boomer generation has broken the unspoken intergenerational contract through unfettered consumerism, spiraling house prices, and desire for eternal youth, squandering future generations' inheritance.
“The Baby-Boomer Generation were born into this Age of Decadence. Perhaps unwittingly they've broken the unspoken intergenerational contract. Through unfettered consumerism, spiraling house prices, and a desire for eternal youth, the Baby-Boomers have squandered future generations' inheritance.”
Drone attacks not only failed to stop terrorism but created extremism—every time you kill ten terrorists you create 500 more because they see attacks as attacks on sovereign state; this is deliberately destabilizing Pakistan.
“The drone attacks not only failed but they've created extra extremism. They've helped in radicalisation of youth in the North West Frontier and also in certain parts of Punjab and Pakistan. And because time after time... And sometimes, you know... There's a feeling that America does this deliberately, to de-stabilise Pakistan. I am not so sure about that, but I certainly think those people who actually support this policy, every time you kill ten, the so called 'terrorist', you create 500 more, because they see the drone attacks as an attack on the sovereign state of Pakistan.”
Politicians must become 'un-beholden' to corporate interests—Democrats and Republicans are both beholden to them, and until they do we will never have a well-governed republic.
“The Democrats and the Republicans are beholden to corporate interests, and until they become un-beholden to those corporate interests we will never have a well-governed republic.”
Political leaders are confused why the public allows them to create this systemic injustice—the answer is that political processes are badly flawed due to dependence on lobbyists and campaign contributions.
“But the public are now confused as to why our political leaders have allowed this to happen and quite naturally, now ask: Why? Because our political processes are badly flawed. They are badly flawed because of the dependence on lobbyists and campaign contributions.”
Wall Street became a casino with massive negative repercussions on society—not just losing money on wild nights but causing massive job losses as those organizations lose their money, impacting whole society.
“Wall Street has become a very particular type of casino. And it's unfortunately not the kind of casino they have in Las Vegas which is, you know, a perfectly legitimate form of entertainment. It is a casino that has massive negative repercussions on the rest of society. So it's not just losing your money on a few wild nights, it's about the way in which those organisations lose their money impacting the whole of society leading to a massive loss of jobs.”
Despite 50-70 years of economic activity and industrialization since WWII, humanity has not managed to solve poverty, deprivation, hunger, and malnutrition—millions go to bed without food while others waste food, creating simultaneous waste and deprivation.
“In spite of all the economic activities of last 50, 60, 70 years, since the Second World War, and all the industrialisation, we have not yet managed to solve the problem of poverty, deprivation, hunger, malnutrition. Millions of people every night go to bed without food, and millions of people are throwing away their food. Waste on the one hand, and poverty and deprivation and hunger on the other hand.”
Only the government has the power to issue fiat money, but banks can create it through lending—over the last 40 years the supply of money has grown exponentially, the greatest growth in history.
“Only the government has the power to issue fiat money, but banks can create it through lending. Over the last 40 years, since this system of fiat money became the global norm, the supply of money has grown exponentially. In fact, we've have seen the greatest growth in the supply of money in history.”
Banks with flexible interest rate mortgages knew in the beginning that problems would come later when people couldn't afford them, but proceeded anyway, knowing people would take food from refrigerators and kids out of higher education.
“The lending and banking institutions, when they drew up contracts with interest rates, with flexible interest rates, I think they knew in the beginning that these problems were going to come back later on when folks weren't going to be able to afford the mortgages. As the interest rates increased, they put a lot of people in situations where they were taking food out of refrigerators, taking kids out of higher education, they're not able to afford college anymore, and it is making a really, really bad situation worse.”
The financial lobbying industry employs five lobbyists per congress person to persuade legislators to pass favorable legislation, while poor people can't hire any—creating an unlevel playing field in democracy.
“Not an accident for instance, that we had the deregulation of our financial industry that was such a disaster. The lobbyists of the finance industry amount to five per congress person. They pay five people for every congressman to explain to them, persuade them, that they should pass legislation that is favorable to the financial industry. The poor people who are devastated don't have the money. They couldn't hire five per congressman. So the way our democracy works - it's an unlevel playing field.”
When the bailout came after Lehman Brothers collapsed, 80% of the population opposed it, yet Congress passed it anyway—showing that government is really under control of banking interests, not reflecting good democracy.
“I mean if people need any proof as to who is controlling Washington, when the bailout came after Lehman Brothers collapsed, 80% of the population were against the bailout. Notwithstanding that, the Congress passed the bailout just showing, in my view anyway, that it's really under the control of banking interests. It's not a reflection of good democracy when a company, a group of companies, an industry, says: 'Our interests are more important than the national interest.'”
Goldman Sachs claimed to do 'God's work' and is one of the most influential investment banks, with alumni occupying positions of great influence in governments and central banks globally.
“Famous for claiming it did 'God's work', Goldman Sachs is one of the most influential investment banks in the world. Its alumni often occupy positions of great influence in governments and central banks.”
In September 2008 barely a month before the stock market crash, Goldman Sachs changed its status from investment to commercial bank to become eligible for state protection—'socialism for the rich'.
“In September 2008, barely a month before the stock market crash, Goldman - supposedly a pillar of the free market - changed its banking status from investment to commercial. This meant it was now eligible for state protection. Socialism for the rich, right there.”
Trickle-down economics or 'Horse and Sparrow' theory claims extreme wealth concentrated in minority will trickle down to everyone, but it doesn't work—by the time money reaches bottom, it's lost purchasing power.
“Lord Griffiths advocates ruthless individualism to push this idea that if bankers get rich then we get rich too through a process known as Trickledown economics or Horse-and-Sparrow theory. If you feed the horse enough oats some will pass through to the road for the sparrows. The idea is that extreme wealth concentrated on small minority will eventually trickle down to everyone else. But it doesn't work. Because by the time the money reaches the people at the bottom of our money pyramid, it has lost its purchasing power.”
Shell has posited two scenarios: Blueprint (planned corporate structure where leaders think about energy transformation and resource dwindling) and Scramble (chaos as people fight for resources)—both scenarios in 2075 reach same place, just Blueprint leaves less blood on floor.
“When I look at the world, I look at it much the way Royal Dutch Shell looks at it. They have one of the best strategic entities in the world, private or public, and Royal Dutch Shell has posited two scenarios. One is called Blueprint, and is obviously a planned corporate structure where world leaders get together and they think about things like energy transformation, planetary warming, and dwindling fossil fuels, and so forth. The other is called Scramble. And Scramble is pretty much what it sounds like too... it's a mess. Interestingly enough, in 2075 - the ending year for these scenarios, as I recall - we get to about the same place. It's just that Blueprint leaves a lot less blood on the floor.”
Goldman Sachs got away scot free with the massive subprime heist—now back bigger than before, richer than before, biggest profits in history, and huge bonuses.
“Riding the Big Short in 2007 made billions of dollars for Goldman. And so far, they've got away scot free with this massive heist. So they're now back, bigger than before, richer than before, biggest profits they've had in history, huge bonuses... They're doing great!”
The German economic miracle of 1947 cancelled all domestic and international debts except those owed employees and basic working balance, wiping slate clean and returning property ownership free and clear without banking obligations.
“The classic example, most recently of a debt cancellation, was the German economic miracle in 1947. The Allies cancelled all domestic and international German debts except for the debts that employers owed their employees for the previous few weeks, and except for a basic working balance that everybody was able to keep in the bank in order to buy food for the next few weeks or so.”
Roman charioteers like Gaius Appuleius Diocles amassed fortunes of 35 million sesterces in prize money—equivalent to several billion dollars today—just as modern sports stars earn vast sums, a pattern of empire decline.
“Just as our sports stars today earn vast sums, so did Roman charioteers. In the 2nd century one by the name of Gaius Appuleius Diocles amassed a fortune of 35 million sesterces in prize money - equivalent to several billion dollars today.”
Senator Carl Levin called Lloyd Blankfein to Senate to testify under oath, and Blankfein claimed Goldman didn't have a massive short and didn't bet against clients—contradicted by the Big Short profit.
“Senator Carl Levin called Goldman Sachs Chief Executive Lloyd Blankfein to a Senate subcommittee to testify under oath. Much has been said about the supposedly massive short Goldman Sachs had on the U.S. housing market. The fact is, we were not consistently or significantly net short the market in residential mortgage-related products in 2007 and 2008. We didn't have a massive short against the housing market, and we certainly did not bet against our clients.”
Hank Paulson told Congress 'We need $700 billion now or else'—requiring the bailout, which reveals that capitalism is not truly capitalism but rather socialism for the rich and capitalism for the poor.
“And this is what Mr Hank Paulson did in the U.S. Congress. He just went there one day and he told them: 'We need $700 billion, and we need it now - or else.' Is this system we call capitalism really capitalism? In a capitalist system government is supposed to be small. But today the state is more bloated and invasive than it's ever been. Individuals and companies are supposed to operate in a free market. Good enterprise is rewarded with profit and flawed enterprise with failure. But during the 2008 banking crisis the people saw the Western economic system divided in a way they were told could never happen. Socialism for the rich, capitalism for the poor.”
We must restructure political processes to give more voice to ordinary citizens and less to interest groups, money groups, and those who shaped tax code and regulations.
“So that's why my view, and a view of I think a lot of people, is that we have to restructure our political processes to give more voice to the ordinary citizen and less voice to the interest group, to money groups, to those who have taken such a large role in shaping our tax code and our regulations and so forth.”
The 2008 financial crisis occurred when banks with debt and obligations larger than GDP of entire countries became 'too big to fail'—the West was unprepared and bankers told governments they needed bailouts or millions would lose everything and face revolution.
“This unfettered gambling pushed the entire global financial system to near collapse. With balances and debt obligations larger than the GDP of entire countries, the banks had become too big to fail. The West was unprepared and bankers met their reeling and disorientated governments: 'You have to bail us out, we need money, if you don't give us the money the whole thing goes down. And what are you going to do with millions and tens of millions of people who have lost everything in their bank account? You will have a revolution on your hands. So fork over the money.”
Debt is now regarded as normal but it is not—it is a form of slavery, and the world should question debt and its role in maintaining social control through perpetual obligation.
“With modern man made monetary processes, a chronic excess of debt has built up at every level of society. Debt is now regarded as normal. It isn't. It's a form of slavery. But how much do we question our debt? And what should we now do about it?”
Much of what Goldman does has almost nothing to do with benefiting the economy—perhaps all of it—because it adds no genuine new tangible value to the world.
“A lot of what they are doing has, in fact, probably... maybe all of it, has almost nothing to do with the benefit of the economy.”
The Reagan-Thatcher revolution was a big transfer of wealth and opportunity within the well-to-do, not from poor to rich—the financial sector became vastly more profitable with base salaries and bonuses rising dramatically, creating unprecedented transfer from non-financial to financial economy.
“The Reagan revolution, as it's called in the U.S., obviously the Reagan-Thatcher revolution, to think about it more globally was a big change in power structure and a big transfer of opportunity and wealth. Now it's not that the poor gave it to the rich, it was a transfer within the well-to-do, so that the financial sector in particular in the U.S. for example, but also in the UK and some other places, became vastly more profitable, and wages in that sector went up a lot, we focused on bonuses, but also base salaries went up - overall compensation. So there is a transfer from the non-financial part of the economy to the financial part of the economy that actually is unprecedented as far as we can see in any of the available data to us and I'm talking about all of the recorded human history.”
Bankers discussing 5 million African children dying from debt can ignore moral impact and continue with loan deals for Tanzania because they're disconnected from consequences.
“'So what if 5 million kids died in Africa because of debt last year. You know I got a bonus of a million pounds, and...' If I have that conversation, I have had it with some... bankers who've been in the business a long time, and... they listen politely, they are very polite, very charming, and at the end they say: 'Well, Tarek it's very lovely meeting you again', and they go back to the office and do another loan deal for Tanzania or something.”
We are governed by corporations today, often by corporations that don't have very much interest in the United States of America.
“We are governed by corporations today. often by corporations that don't have very much interest in the United States of America.”
The Romans, Ottomans and Spanish all made celebrities of their chefs as empires declined—a typification of the end of an empire where accumulated greatness creates one last momentum surge before people search for greatness elsewhere.
“Strangely, perhaps, there is another profession that is disproportionately hallowed as an empire declines. The Romans, the Ottomans and the Spanish all made celebrities of their chefs. And this again is typifying the end of an empire, where things were so great we have this last oomph of momentum, that we used to be great, and we felt great, and we don't feel it anymore.”
Goldman Sachs uses profits to buy influence in Washington to change laws to make money on Wall Street—a self-reinforcing malfeasance machine continuing to grow as a parasite in the economy, killing the host.
“The Goldman Sachs machine is one of using profits to buy influence in Washington, to change laws to make it easier to make money on Wall Street, to be used to buy influence in Washington. So it's a self-reinforcing malfeasance machine that is continuing to grow as a parasite in the economy and continuing to kill the host.”
American financial firms make most money when countries are at the cusp of change—they want markets that are changing structurally but not too free and transparent because they make money when markets are opaque.
“Because the reality is that American firms tend to make most money when countries are at the cusp of change, certainly American financial firms, and in a sense, they want markets that are changing structurally but not too free and too transparent because they make money when markets are a bit opaque.”
The world is full of man-made capital and becoming empty of natural capital; we are the first generation in rich developed world to reach the end of real benefits of economic growth.
“So the world is very, very full of what we might call man-made capital. And it's becoming more and more empty of what used to be there, what we might call natural capital. We are the first generation; we in the rich developed world are the first generation to have got to the end of the real benefits of economic growth.”
The paradox is the more we grow, the more poverty we create—our self-interested economic system seems to continually miss the trick.
“The paradox is the more we grow, the more poverty we create. Our self-interested economic system seems to be continually missing a trick.”
We've endured the so-called 'free market' for centuries but far from being free, it has led to destruction of nature and each other—the notion that the market has a scientifically defined boundary is false propaganda.
“We've endured the so-called 'free market' for centuries. But far from being free it's led us to destroy nature and each other in a vain attempt to progress. It's absolutely ludicrous to suggest that somehow there's a scientifically defined boundary of the market that we should never change. And of course that is what the free market economists want you to believe.”
Alan Greenspan, Head of the Federal Reserve, after 9/11 slashed interest rates to encourage lending—bankers needed new participants to keep cash flowing into a system that had become a global pyramid scheme.
“It was the Head of the Federal Reserve Bank, Alan Greenspan who, after 9/11, slashed interest rates to encourage lending. Bankers needed new participants to keep cash flowing into a system that had become a global pyramid scheme.”
The Fed is essentially the lobbyist for the commercial banking system—turning regulation over to the Fed means financial sector is self-regulated, and Wall Street has veto power over who becomes Fed chair.
“The Fed is essentially the lobbyist for the commercial banking system. When you say you want to turn regulation over to the Fed, you are saying the financial sector and Wall Street should be self-regulated. And Wall Street has veto power over whoever is going to be the Head of the Federal Reserve.”
We have a system where rich people who make mistakes don't get punished while poor people get punished even when they don't make mistakes—they're forced to pay for the mistakes of the rich.
“We have a system which isn't even a proper capitalist system; rich people make mistakes, they don't get punished, poor people make mistakes and they get punished, or even worse, that they don't make any mistake and they are forced to pay for the mistakes of the rich.”
The most important element of tax system is basing it on land taxation and land value (the 'unearned increment' or income landlords make in their sleep), which the 19th century classical economists expected, because land and natural resources are not products of human effort.
“The most important element of a tax system is to do what everybody expected to be done in the 19th century, and that is to base the tax system on land taxation, on the free lunch of land value, and on what John Stuart Mill called the 'unearned increment'. The income that landlords made in their sleep, as he put it. Who made oil in the ground, coal or iron ore? These are things which are not the product of human effort, of course extracting them is, but their existence is not. And so the rents from natural resources are a wonderful source of taxation.”
Benefits of communal sense of fellowship, responsibility, and purpose in life driven by production not consumption would lead to happiness and satisfaction—but have modern consumerist lifestyles made us happy?
“The benefits of a communal sense of fellowship, responsibility and purpose in a life driven by production, not consumption would lead to happiness and satisfaction. Indeed we must ask: Have our modern consumerist lifestyles made us happy?”
When plunder becomes a way of life for a group of men living together in society, they create for themselves a legal system authorizing it and a moral code glorifying it.
“When plunder becomes a way of life for a group of men living together in society, they create for themselves in the course of time a legal system that authorises it and a moral code that glorifies it. Frederic Bastiat”
Empires last about 250 years or ten generations, from early pioneers to final conspicuous consumers who become a burden on the state, progressing through six ages: Pioneers, Conquests, Commerce, Affluence, Intellect, and Decadence.
“An empire lasts about 250 years, or ten generations, from the early pioneers to the final conspicuous consumers who become a burden on the state. Six ages define the lifespan of an empire. The Age Of Pioneers The Age Of Conquests The Age Of Commerce The Age Of Affluence The Age Of Intellect Ending with bread and circuses in The Age Of Decadence.”
We have a flawed democracy that functions as an advanced oligarchy where the main control mechanism is convincing people they need the 6 biggest banks in their current form, claiming awful things would happen if we change—this is blackmail dressed as necessity.
“We have a flawed democracy. This is an advanced oligarchy, in the sense that its main mechanism of control, if you like, is through convincing people that you really need, for example, the 6 biggest banks in the United States, in the particular form they exist today, with the very light level of regulation. And if you don't have them, if you try to change that, all kinds of awful things will happen. And this is not really blackmail. It sounds like blackmail, but they convince you it's not blackmail, it's just the way the world is, there's nothing you can do about it.”
American evangelism of democracy is riddled with contradictions—promoting democracy at the point of a gun and opposing regimes which are democratic but not in the way America wants; American promotion of free market capitalism is also contradictory.
“America's evangelism of democracy is riddled with contradictions, not least of which this idea of promoting democracy at the point of a gun, or opposing regimes which are democratic, but not in the way that America wants. So too this idea that America has been promoting free market capitalism has also been riddled with contradictions.”
If we want to eliminate terrorism and have homeland security, we must recognize the whole planet is our homeland and solve global injustice.
“If we want to do away with terrorism, if we want to have what we in the U.S. call 'Homeland Security', we've got to recognise that the whole planet is our homeland.”
The people who orchestrated the first 9/11 in Chile were right in Washington and London, but that doesn't count—there is a principle of ideology that we must never look at our own crimes while exalting in crimes of others and our own nobility in opposing them.
“Who was involved in that first 9/11? It's not hard to find them. They were right in Washington and London, and so on. But that's off the agenda, that doesn't count. There is a principle of ideology that we must never look at our own crimes. We should on the other hand exalt in the crimes of others, and in our own nobility in opposing them.”
Developed nations fight in underdeveloped countries because many make so much money without ever witnessing consequences of their actions.
“Is it any wonder developed nations are fighting in underdeveloped countries when so many are making so much money out of it, without ever really having to face up to or even witness the consequences of their actions?”
In 19th century if told 100 years later people would live in extraordinary wealth with central heating and throw away high proportion of food, would imagine extraordinary social harmony; remarkable contrast between material success and social failure of modern societies.
“I think if one had been living in the 19th century and somebody had told you that 100 years later people were going to be living in this extraordinary wealth and comfort, you know, with central heating, and being able to throw away such a high proportion of our food as we do, we'd imagine that we'd be living in a state of extraordinary social harmony, and... everything would be rosy. And it's really quite remarkable the contrast between, if you like, the material success of our societies and the social failure.”
40% of the world's agricultural land is seriously degraded and ever-more volatile yields continue to be unevenly distributed; looming environmental threat may not be global warming but exhaustion of world's resources.
“40% of the world's agricultural land is seriously degraded and ever more volatile yields continue to be unevenly distributed. It may be that the looming environmental threat is not global warming but the exhaustion of the world's resources.”
Most of the current system problems can be substantially improved by making societies more equal and reducing income differences, which also helps solve environmental problems.
“I think what we have to take away from this, is a recognition that... most of these problems can be very substantially improved by making our societies more equal, reducing the income differences. And that also helps us to solve the environmental problems.”
World economy over last decades has been built on military or producing items most people don't need and don't even want, yet we all have to have them.
“The fact is that the world economy over the last few years, a good share of my lifetime has been built either on the military, or on producing items that most people don't need. And really don't even want if you come right down to it, but we all got to have them.”
The breakdown in the Great Depression and 2008 occurred because much was taken out of the system by those who contribute very little—multinational corporations and banks will always want to grow without compensating those whose work produces surplus.
“The breakdown we saw in the Great Depression and witnessed again at the beginning of the 21st century occurred because - in the name of growth - much was taken out of the system by those who contribute very little. Multinational corporates and banks will always want to grow without having to compensate those people who actually do the work to produce the surplus.”
Of the money in the world today, 97% of it is debt—as French philosopher Voltaire said, all paper money eventually returns to its intrinsic value of zero.
“Of the money in the world today, 97% of it is debt. The French philosopher Voltaire once said, 'All paper money eventually returns to its intrinsic value - zero'.”
When rich people tell you they specifically need to be rich through egregious rip-off mechanisms, that's self-serving propaganda and should be disregarded.
“When rich people tell you that they specifically have to be rich through these egregious rip-off mechanisms, that's just self-serving propaganda and it should be disregarded.”
In America the banks that got in trouble got bailed out by government (socialism), while people argue against socialism—making America probably the most socialist country in the world right now under this definition.
“And in America for example the banks that got in trouble got bailed out by the government, that's socialism. And they... people are arguing against socialism in America, and yet this is probably the most socialist country in the world right now.”
Apathy is engineered through absence of public media discussion of systemic problems because public media is owned by real estate and financial interests that don't want the FIRE sector (finance, insurance, real estate) integration to be understood.
“Well the apathy is sort of engineered because you don't have any discussion of this in the public media. Hardly by surprise, the public media are owned by the real estate and the financial interests, and they are not going to explain to people the integration between the financial, insurance and real estate sectors - the FIRE sector.”
Neo-classical economics is taught in all Ivy League universities despite being ideological rather than scientific, functioning as mass mind control preventing students from learning alternative frameworks.
“Education can be a form of mass mind control and it's astonishing that today neo-classical economics continues to be taught in all Ivy League universities. I do get letters from students in economics departments at other universities. They're in some graduate programme or something, and they say: 'I have just read such and such that you wrote, and this is the kind of thing that interests me. I'm stuck in this programme here in which I can't even talk about any of that.”
Gold has specific properties as natural money: all gold ever mined (~size of 2.5 olympic pools) still exists, above-ground stock grows 1.5% per annum (equal to population growth and wealth creation), keeping supply-demand balanced and maintaining purchasing power consistency.
“All of the gold that has been mined throughout history still exists in it's above ground stock. It's about the size of 2 ? olympic swimming pools, if you put all that gold together in one place. The key is that this above ground stock of gold grows by about 1 ? % per annum, which is approximately equal to new world population growth, and is approximately equal to new wealth creation. So, the net result of this is that... you have this very good consistency in gold's purchasing power over long periods of time because the supply-demand equation is very much in balance.”
Banks engaged in criminal conspiracy charging more to Blacks and Hispanics, and backed Bush administration to block state prosecutions of racial lending in order to exploit and charge minorities more.
“The banks engaged in what was a criminal conspiracy, to charge more to the Blacks and Hispanics. The banks got together, backed the Bush administration, to block the state prosecutions of racial lending in order to exploit and charge more to the minorities.”
Goldman Sachs sold mortgage securities they knew were worthless while betting they would fail through credit default swaps with AIG, making massive profits on both sides.
“In the recent years they have been selling securities put together from mortgages that they knew were worthless, so they are selling these things to unwitting consumers, making a ton of money out of it. Meanwhile, they are betting that they're going to fail because they know that what they are peddling is rotten. So they placed bets with credit defaults, and lots of other things with the huge insurance company AIG, and that was insuring Goldman Sachs against the failure of the stuff they are peddling.”
Goldman Sachs Vice-Chairman Lord Griffiths defended extortionate bankers' bonuses by arguing we must tolerate inequality as a way to achieving greater prosperity and opportunity for all—a fundamental Christian, Islamic, and Jewish view is that wealth must be shared.
“It was against the holy backdrop of St Paul's Cathedral in London that Goldman Sachs Vice-Chairman and mouthpiece Lord Griffiths, gave insight into how certain bankers really think. The devoted Christian defended extortionate bonuses: 'I am not a person of despair, I am a person of hope. And I think that we have to tolerate the inequality as a way to achieving greater prosperity and opportunity for all.' A fundamental Christian view, and I would say of Islam as well, and certainly of Judaism, is that wealth is to be shared. Money has to be shared. You can't take it with you.”
Military operations in Swat created 2.3 million internally displaced persons from 1.8 million population district when surgical commando operation targeting militants would have been necessary—militants were allowed to escape.
“If they really wanted to flush them out, there was no need for a huge military operation in Swat, causing the entire district to become internally displaced persons. The population of Swat is 1.8 million, there are 2.3 million refugees in the country, the whole district has been emptied. This wouldn't have been necessary if they had carried out a surgical commando operation to get the militant leaders. But they allowed them to escape, all of them.”
On September 11, 1973 democratically elected Chilean President Salvador Allende was overthrown in a coup; Augusto Pinochet's dictatorship ruled until 1990 with systematic suppression, imprisonment, and murder of political dissidents.
“On 11th September 1973 the democratically elected Chilean President Salvador Allende was overthrown in a coup. A dictatorship under Augusto Pinochet was established that ruled Chile until 1990. There was the systematic suppression of all political dissidence. Thousands were imprisoned and murdered.”
Greek philosopher Plato argued the ratio of earnings between highest and lowest paid employee in any organization should be no more than 6:1; JP Morgan in 1923 declared 20:1 was optimum; today's salary ratios can be 500:1 or 1000:1.
“It was the Greek philosopher Plato who said the ratio of earnings between highest and lowest paid employee in any organisation should be no more than 6:1. In 1923 banker J.P. Morgan declared no more that 20:1 was optimum. Yet today's salary difference between top and bottom earners in global corporations can be higher than 500 or a 1,000:1.”
Other people can be your worst rival or best source of support—in progressive society to meet common economic, social, cultural needs we must move from globalization to localization.
“And so other people can be the best or the worst. You can be my worst rival or my best source of support. In a progressive society to meet our common economic, social and cultural needs we must move from globalisation to localisation.”
The first financial beneficiary of America's military campaigns in Iraq, Afghanistan, and Pakistan is the military's arms and equipment suppliers; the military has won battles but failed at eradicating terrorism.
“The first financial beneficiary of America's foreign policy is the military. In particular, those who supply it with arms and equipment. The military has won wars, but how successful has it been in its bigger aim to eradicate terrorism?”
Milton Friedman and the Chicago Boys' neoclassical ideology beat out the classical approach to economics, becoming the framework for modern capitalism, but neoclassical models are divorced from reality, based on 'what ought to be' rather than 'what actually is'.
“Milton Friedman, his protégés, the Chicago Boys, and the neoclassical ideology beat the classical approach to economics and became the framework for what we today call capitalism. There are two main competing economic approaches which determine how we humans manage the world and distribute wealth. These are the classical and neoclassical schools. The classical school favours less government interference, more personal autonomy and recognizes that humans cannot function without natural resources. The neo-classical school, which has a more dismissive view of natural resources, thinks government should rule the economy, solve social problems and leave the free market to look after the distribution of wealth. The neo-classical school emerged around 100 years ago due to vested interests' desire to protect their assets. This meant that neo-classical mathematical models and assumptions were divorced from reality. They are based on 'what ought to be' instead of the classical models which are based on 'what actually is'.”
What happened in Baltimore is just one example of what is happening all around the world—predatory lending and foreclosure targeted at minorities is a global phenomenon driven by profit, not accident.
“What happened in Baltimore is just one example of what is happening all around the world. One way to frame this injustice is by branding it a race issue. But when we look really closely we can see that there is something at play here that transcends race. Profit.”
The financial sector acquired enormous power partly through political contributions (buying favors) but mostly through ideological control—convincing people that finance is good, more is better, and unregulated is best—the cornerstone of the Wall Street-Washington corridor.
“The financial sector has acquired enormous power, partly through political contributions, so buying favours, but mostly through ideological control, convincing people that finance is good, more finance is better and unregulated finance without limit is best. And that is really the cornerstone of this, what we call in the U.S., the Wall Street-Washington corridor.”
Economic hit men have created the world's first truly global empire primarily without military—they arrange huge loans from World Bank to resource-rich countries, but money goes to Western corporations building infrastructure that benefits only wealthy families and corporations, leaving countries with massive debt.
“We economic hit men have created the world's first truly global empire. And we've done it primarily without the military. We work many different ways, but perhaps the most common is that we'll take a Third World country that has resources our corporations covet, like oil, and then arrange a huge loan to that country from the World Bank or one of its sister organisations. However, the money never actually goes to the country. Instead it goes to our own corporations to build infrastructure projects in that country, power plants, highways, industrial parks, things that benefit a few wealthy families in that country, as well as our corporations, but don't help the majority of the people at all.”
As long as banking empires chase infrastructure and debt deals in pursuit of profit, the West will continue to export injustice through finance—millions more will be displaced, terrorism will thrive, and neocolonialism will continue ending more lives.
“As long as banking empires chase infrastructure and debt deals in pursuit of profit, the West will continue to export injustice through finance. Millions more will be displaced, terrorism will thrive, and neocolonialism will continue to end more and more lives around the world.”
Systems have been subtly modified, manipulated and corrupted over centuries to serve the interests of the few, and humans' ability to adjust to virtually any conditions—the trait that enabled survival—has also suppressed us.
“Over centuries, systems have been subtly modified, manipulated and even corrupted often to serve the interests of the few. We have continually accepted these changes and, because man can adjust to living under virtually any conditions, the trait that has enabled us to survive is the very trait that has suppressed us.”
Human beings are inconsistent and paradoxical—capable of acting in ways making it likely or certain our grandchildren face disasters while consciously accelerating that likelihood, yet claiming to love our grandchildren.
“Human beings are inconsistent and paradoxical. We hope for peace and immortality, but continually invent new ways to destroy each other. We're capable of the kindest, most noblest acts; and the most horrific atrocities. Human beings are complex creatures. I mean for example we're capable right now, at this minute, of acting in such a way as to make it likely, if not certain, that our grandchildren are going to face terrible disasters, and we are consciously acting to accelerate that likelihood even though we all love our grandchildren.”
It took significant effort to drive worker ownership ideas out of people's heads, but they remain relevant today and should be resurrected as core principle for economic organization.
“It's taken a lot of effort to drive those ideas out of people's heads, but they're still there and they are very relevant.”
Land value taxation in developed countries would address housing and debt crisis by untying housing from speculation, and in developing countries would allow resource wealth to remain with citizens instead of flowing to Western extractors.
“In developed countries it would begin to address our housing and debt crisis and unleash the kind of entrepreneurship needed to refloat our economies.”
Understanding that the 2008 crisis was systemic rather than caused by individual villains is very hard for people to grasp and impossible to depict as a good story, creating a feeling of helplessness because the real problem is not understood.
“The idea that it was a systemic flaw is something which is very hard for people to grasp, and even harder to depict as a good story. Perhaps there is this feeling of helplessness because we don't understand what the real problem actually is.”
If the monetary system is not reformed, we are headed toward the end of industrial civilization (not humanity, but absolute collapse of the world as known) because the system cannot function on fiat money.
“If the monetary system of the world is not reformed then we are headed towards the end of industrial civilisation. I won't say that we are going to the end of humanity, but it's just going to be absolute collapse of our world as we have known it, because it can not function on fiat money.”
People should not assume because they lack background in economics or law that these issues are too complex—they are not complex, they are very simple: it's about power and democracy.
“You should not assume because, you know, you don't have a background in economics or in law, that these issues are somehow too complex for you. They're not complex at all, it's very simple. It's about power, and it's about democracy.”
The West is at an epochal shift where it could either tip into complacent redundancy or play a decisive role in the future.
“We are at an epochal shift. We're at a point where the West could tip into a complacent and quite well off redundancy or we could play a decisive role in the future.”
Goldman Sachs are extremely efficient at what they do—making money—like bank robbers but it's legal because the system is set up to allow it.
“Goldman Sachs are extremely efficient at what they do. Their task is to make money, they make bank robbers like Willie Sutton look like modest amateurs. They're huge bank robbers, but it's legal. The system is set up so that they can do it.”
The current system taxes labor (income) but should tax consumption instead, or better yet, tax natural resources and land values (the 'unearned increment'), which would be more progressive and not penalize productivity.
“Our system of taxation also needs addressing. Currently we're taxed on what we produce. Perhaps it would be more progressive to tax what we consume. How many American people realise that the Founding Fathers never intended Americans to be taxed on their labour? In other words, they weren't meant to pay income tax. The tax system that was exported from Britain, a relic of colonialism, has duped the world.”
Common features of the Age of Decadence include undisciplined overextended military, conspicuous display of wealth, massive disparity between rich and poor, desire to live off bloated state, obsession with sex, and most notably the debasement of currency.
“There are common features to every Age Of Decadence. An undisciplined, overextended military, the conspicuous display of wealth, a massive disparity between rich and poor, a desire to live off a bloated State and an obsession with sex. But perhaps the most notorious trait of all is the debasement of the currency.”
We are entering the Age Of Consequence characterized by a rapacious financial system, escalating organised violence, abject poverty for billions, and looming environmental fallout—all converging when governments, religion, and mainstream economists have stalled.
“We are entering The Age Of Consequence. A rapacious financial system, escalating organised violence, abject poverty for billions and the looming environmental fall-out are all converging at a time when governments, religion, and mainstream economists have stalled.”
To achieve human liberty, you need sound money, and gold is the only way because only gold is outside the control of politicians—modern man-made monetary processes have created chronic excess debt at every level of society.
“To achieve human liberty you really need to have sound money, and gold is the only way to do that because only gold is outside of the control of politicians. With modern man made monetary processes, a chronic excess of debt has built up at every level of society.”
We live in depressed societies convinced there's nothing that can be done, that there is no alternative, that environmental and social problems are unsolvable, and that dog-eat-dog society is inevitable—a manufactured consensus of hopelessness.
“In a sense I think we are rather depressed societies. We've got used to the idea that there's nothing that can be done, there is no alternative, that, you know, we are never going to deal with these environmental problems and we live in a dog-eat-dog society, and that's it.”
When salary inequality reaches 500:1 or 1000:1, the rich and poor become almost different species—no longer members of same community, losing commonality of interest and making it difficult to form community and friendly relationships across such large class differences.
“When you are up in the range of 500:1 inequality the rich and the poor become almost different species - no longer members of the same community. Commonality of interest is lost, and so it's difficult to form community and to have good friendly relationships across class differences that are that large.”
Once free market economists convince you that market boundaries are scientifically defined and they have the truth as PhDs, you're forced to accept whatever they tell you—this is where we have to challenge them.
“Because once they convince you of that, and claim that - on top of that they claim that they have the truth, because they are PhD's in economics - then they can tell you whatever they want and then you'll have to accept it. But that's where we have to take these guys on.”
Every time too much was taken by those who contributed little, people rose up to halt violent practices enacted by a tangible enemy—but today with a formless enemy (finance system) pervading every element, the question is whether it can be done again.
“In the past every time too much was taken by those who contributed little people rose up to halt the violent practices enacted by a tangible enemy. Today the question is: With such a formless enemy pervading every element of our economic and democratic process, can it be done again?”
You can never get enough of what you don't need; what is needed is strong moral conviction pervasive throughout society where integrity reigns—but there is vast apathy and amoralism preventing this.
“But you can never get enough of what you don't need. What you need is a strong moral conviction that is pervasive throughout the society... and integrity reigns. There is a vast apathy. There is a vast amoralism, even a political nature to it, that is to say there are vast numbers of people who don't give a damn.”
There is natural entropy—like any living organism, empires die over time—the question is whether death comes through violent cascade of events or over long period.
“There is this - natural, I suppose - entropy, any living organism which an empire is of course, over time dies. The question is: How does it die? Does it die in a violent cascade of events? Or does it die over a long period of time?”
Those responsible for the fiat system do not want to admit it, but the fiat system is a man-made law that has been abused, and gold is a natural form of money that maintains consistent purchasing power across long periods.
“And none of those who are responsible for this want to admit it, but that is the fact. The fiat system of money is a man made law, and it's been abused. Is there a form of money whose law is not set by man? When you look at natural law and gold... I sort of describe gold as being a natural form of money.”
An individual might not be able to change the system, but they can change themselves; if we're not offered proper education, we must begin our own, starting with becoming re-acquainted with classical economists.
“An individual might not be able to change the system, but they can change themselves. If we're not offered proper education, we must begin our own. And a good place to start is to become re-acquainted with the classical economists.”
When wealthy people defend excessive earnings, they move debate to psychological realm quoting Herbert Spencer's 'survival of the fittest' to justify excess, but competition must occur on level playing field—monopolists game rigged systems.
“When the public do vent their outrage at inappropriate earnings, the common defense is to move the debate to the psychological realm and quote mercurial British economist Herbert Spencer. He coined the phrase 'survival of the fittest' and his words are now used to justify excess. Competition in business is a good thing, but the playing field must be level. Monopolists have too much because the system they game is rigged.”
Politics is about drawing the boundary of the market; historically many things were taken out of the market (human slavery, child labor) and there's nothing wrong with redrawing boundaries again.
“Politics is about drawing the boundary of the market. I mean, when you think about it, a lot of things have been taken out of the market over the last two, three centuries. Two, three centuries ago you could... buy and sell human beings, child labour, a lot of things that you didn't imagine you could buy and sell today. So, I mean, over time we have re-drawn this boundary and there is nothing wrong with re-drawing the boundary again.”
Capitalism broadly understood as market economy has a future and is necessary for global future; the question is 'what kind of capitalism' and what kind of market economy—one based on independent money, consumption tax, and employee-owned businesses.
“Capitalism, more broadly understood as market economy, not only has a future, I can't see the future of the world without it. But the question is: What kind of capitalism? What kind of market economy? A system of reformed capitalism built on independent money, a tax system based on consumption, not income, and employee-owned businesses would begin to build an economy that's not dependent on constant growth to service its debt.”
Things considered absolutely reasonable in the 1850s (selling unregulated chemicals as pharmaceutical drugs) are now serious criminal offenses—the same will be true of active money management in 100 years, viewed as obviously criminal.
“Things that were considered absolutely reasonable in the 1850's like selling any chemical on the street corner and telling you that it's a pharmaceutical drug that maybe good for you, things like that, that were absolutely commonplace then are now serious criminal offences. The same thing will be true of active money management in a 100 years.”
It can be done again because it's a cycle—finance rises, becomes organized, people make money, buy politicians, but democracy's essence is repeated confrontation, and in the 1830s Jackson beat the second bank, 1900s TR beat Morgan and Rockefeller, 1930s FDR beat Wall Street, so it can be done now.
“Of course it can be done again. Look it's a cycle, I mean... we're not debt peons, we may be rats running around a little wheel in somebody's big cage somewhere. The finance rises, finance rises, finance becomes organised, you make a lot of money in banking, it's easy to go out and buy politicians, but the essence of democracy, the essence of American democracy is this repeated confrontation, a repeated showdown, and in the 1830's Andrew Jackson beat the second bank in the U.S., in the early 1900's Teddy Roosevelt beat J.P. Morgan and Johnny Rockefeller, in the 1930's Franklin Delano Roosevelt, FDR, beat everyone from Wall Street. And now we have to do it again.”
What is taught in economics programs is something you will have to oppose; while some is useful, the reason to learn the rest is 'know your enemy'—students should learn heterodox economics to resist orthodoxy.
“What they're teaching you is what you're going to have to oppose, a lot of it. I mean some of it's useful, go ahead and learn it, and the reason for learning the rest of it is: know your enemy.”
If you don't come into the heart of communities and see the actual impact of lending practices, you won't understand the trouble—you're only looking at the cover of the book, not the real story inside.
“They don't come into the heart of it. Like you in the heart of it so you see, they don't really see the trouble if they don't come into the heart of it, they stay on the outside of it. That's like looking at the cover of a book and seeing the outside of a book but if you don't go inside the book, then you will never know what the book is about.”
The general public has not achieved greater prosperity through banker bonuses, demonstrating that modern banking does not operate under the free market principle of alignment between self-interest and collective benefit.
“But how many of the general public have achieved greater prosperity through a banker's bonus?”
Cleansing a few 'bad apples' will not rectify the flaws at the heart of the Western economic system because the system itself enables the Four Horsemen (rapacious finance, organized violence, poverty, resource exhaustion) to ride with vengeance.
“Cleansing a few 'bad apples' will not rectify the flaws at the heart of the Western economic system. A system that should be protecting people is in fact the very thing that's enabling our Four Horsemen to ride with such vengeance.”
The solution is not getting rid of capitalism but of getting rid of 'this terrible form of capitalism'—capitalism itself is viable but requires reform to remove monopolistic corruption.
“I'm a capitalist. I think capitalism can do it. It's not a question of getting rid of capitalism. It's a question of getting rid of this terrible form of capitalism.”
The speaker is a capitalist and business person who believes in basic principles but is completely appalled at seeing those principles destroyed by monarchs and monopolists who have totally destroyed the system from within on Wall Street, making it unacceptable.
“I'm a capitalist. I'm a business person. I believe in the basic principles. That's why I'm completely appalled by seeing these principles destroyed by monarchs, monopolists, who have totally destroyed the system from within, on Wall Street, and this is completely unacceptable.”