What this covers

This is an interview on Wealthion in which host Andrew Brill talks with Brett Rentmaster of Windrock Wealth Management. Rentmaster begins by separating CBDCs (Central Bank Digital Currencies)) from cryptocurrency. He calls them near opposites, one built on centralized monitoring and enforcement and the other on not needing a middleman. Brill adds that modern money is already mostly digital, since governments create it through ledger entries. Rentmaster draws the conclusion that the real novelty of a CBDC is not digitization but programmability. He quotes Augustine Carstens of the Bank for International Settlements on central banks having "absolute control" and the technology to enforce it.

The middle of the conversation covers the mechanics of control and the incentives behind it. Rentmaster cites account freezes without trial, pointing to Canada's action against trucker protest funders), and China's tie between digital money and social credit. He also lists what governments might gain: direct tax collection, expiring money, and negative interest rates. He argues that benefit recipients would be pushed into CBDCs, and that public rejection in Nigeria shows adoption would need a crisis to force it. He points to U.S. House and gubernatorial resistance as a sign the topic has moved from fringe to mainstream.

The range then widens to monetary history and alternatives. Rentmaster traces the dollar's drop in purchasing power from Bretton Woods to 1971, contrasts Bitcoin's 21 million cap with unlimited CBDC supply, and notes crypto uptake in countries with collapsed currencies. He is candid that crypto has fallen alongside equities in past downturns, so its crisis protection is unproven. The closing stretch turns to the U.S. debt burden, which he puts above $200 trillion with unfunded liabilities included. He argues that any reset implies a currency cramdown, and he discusses gold and silver as stores of value, including Zimbabwe's gold-backed currency and the open question of its reserves.

Sharpest takeaway

Central bank digital currencies (CBDCs) represent a fundamental threat to financial freedom because they enable programmable money under centralized control, whereas decentralized cryptocurrencies offer an alternative path that preserves individual autonomy—and society must choose between these competing visions before a debt-driven crisis forces adoption of CBDCs.

  • CBDCs are programmable money with absolute control and enforcement technology, allowing governments to restrict spending by category, carbon footprint, or social credit score
  • Cryptocurrencies eliminate the need for trusted middlemen by using decentralized consensus, fundamentally threatening government control over monetary systems
  • A coming debt crisis will likely force CBDC adoption unless populations are educated enough to reject it and choose alternative stores of value like gold, silver, or cryptocurrencies

The claims · ranked35 claims · weighted by value

This asset isn't compiled yet

You're seeing its claims, ranked. Compile it to build the argument threads, weight them, and check each claim against your library — the full view.

0.80

Central bank digital currencies should not be thought of as cryptocurrency because they are almost the polar opposite—CBDCs have centralized control, monitoring, and enforcement technology, while cryptocurrencies are decentralized and premise themselves on not needing a government or middleman to develop trust between transacting parties.

definitionhigh valueestablishednovelty 2/4durability 4/4· Brett Rentmaster

“it's a mistake to think of cbdcs as crypto because they're almost the polar opposit so on one hand cbdcs have control they've got monitoring you know centralized power controlling everything right the premise of cryptocurrencies by and large is decentralized we don't need a middleman we don't a government sitting in the middle anymore we've got a self-executing program maintained by a user community”

0.75

Augustine Carstens, Director General of the Bank for International Settlements, stated that 'central banks will have absolute control on the rules and regulations that will determine the use of' CBDCs 'and also we will have the technology to enforce that'—meaning CBDCs enable both total control and technological enforcement mechanisms.

normativehigh valueestablishednovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Brett Rentmaster

“you had Augustine Carstens who was the director general of the bank of international settlements which is commonly thought of the Central Bank of central banks basically say this about Central Bank digital currencies the quote was central banks will have absolute control on the rules and regulations that will determine the use of that expression of Central Bank liability it's referring to cbdcs and also we will have the technology to enforce that”

0.75

Cryptocurrency adoption has been fastest in countries that have hyperinflated or destroyed their currencies (Nigeria, El Salvador, Argentina, Zimbabwe), where citizens naturally seek alternatives to currency collapse.

normativehigh valueestablishednovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Brett Rentmaster

“we're seeing countries like El Salvador and potentially Argentina starting to use them in fact some of the biggest adoption of cryptocurrencies is in countries that have blown up their currencies and it makes sense right if if if you're used to high inflation or a currency massively devaluing and you have a choice of owning whatever that is relative to something with limited Supply people are eventually going to get the hint and move into things that they think will hold value”

0.75

With CBDCs, banks and governments could theoretically lock people out of their money immediately and without trial, bypassing the due process currently required—for example, freezing accounts due to mistakes, lawsuits, or government claims, as demonstrated by Canada's actions against truckers protest funders.

causalhigh valueestablishednovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Brett Rentmaster

“it seems if it's a central bank digital currency they kind of put a padlock on your account and say okay you can't spend any more money until we figure this out it doesn't happen that way right now because they can't unless you've gone through a process and you've ignored them long enough they can't really put a lean on your bank accounts but this would make it a lot easier for them to to make mistakes even and in essence lock people”

0.74

Bitcoin's fixed supply of 21 million coins contrasts sharply with CBDC supply, which has no limit since governments can print unlimited amounts, making Bitcoin a potential store of value while CBDCs inherit inflation risk from fiat currencies.

causalhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 4/4· Brett Rentmaster

“we've got Bitcoin with a different premise it's going to be volatile but there's a fixed amount whereas government cbdcs you know the sky the limit is just like we're at today I mean how much money can can a government print I mean it's it's we've gotten into tens of trillions”

0.74

When countries need money, they don't print physical currency—they make journal ledger entries, which demonstrates that money is already fundamentally digital in modern economies.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 4/4· Andrew Brill

“when the country needs more money they don't print it they actually make J Ledger entries”

0.70

If systemic crisis occurs and debt resets are necessary, some wealth destruction through currency cramdown (e.g., 1,000 units of old currency exchanging for 10 units of new currency) is mathematically inevitable.

causalhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 4/4· Brett Rentmaster

“if we go to that kind of system first they have to right rightsize the debts there has to be a crisis and some kind of reset where they give you less somebody's got to pay you know a price or or give up something for them to reset a system to move forward”

0.69

Regulatory attitudes toward cryptocurrency in the U.S. and other countries have shifted dramatically from hostile crackdowns to cautious acceptance, with even China acknowledging that 'the cat's out of the bag' and crypto cannot be stopped globally.

normativehigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Brett Rentmaster

“the regulatory stand in the US has changed dramatically from a couple years ago even China you know these countries that were really cracking down and didn't want to see it succeed are all of a sudden saying hey it's all over the world the cat's out of the bag we can't really stop it so we either adopted at some level or we're left behind you know technologically”

0.69

China represents the front edge of CBDC-like control, where digital money is not just a transaction tool but intertwined with social credit scores that can restrict access to funds and services based on government behavioral assessments.

normativehigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Brett Rentmaster

“we think of China maybe as the front edge of this where it's not just your money it's some kind of social credit score working against you”

0.69

During past market downturns, cryptocurrencies have typically fallen alongside equities (down 30-50%), so it is uncertain whether crypto would actually provide protection in a major financial crisis.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Brett Rentmaster

“in the past when you had big market downturns and equities were down 30 40 50% cryptocurrencies probably followed down so it's it's a question mark I think there might be a day in the future where things are down and cryptocurrencies are up but are we there yet it's it's tough to say”

0.68

Zimbabwe, despite hyperinflation and economic collapse, has recently adopted a gold-backed currency, suggesting that even failed states understand the need for asset-backed money—though trust questions remain about whether they actually hold the claimed gold reserves.

normativehigh valueestablishednovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Brett Rentmaster

“even Zimbabwe that's gone been a basket case of hyperinflation they now have a gold-backed currency now do you trust that they have all the gold it's it's all those questions”

0.66

The U.S. dollar has lost approximately 95% of its purchasing power since 1913, illustrating the real cost of inflation and why houses that cost $5,000-$10,000 in 1960 cost $800,000 today—the magnitude of currency devaluation is often missed because it's a slow decline.

normativehigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 4/4· Brett Rentmaster

“the original Dollar in 1913 has lost you know 95% of its value right so that's why the house in 1960 that was $5,000 to $10,000 is now $800,000 right so the dollar is not stable either but because we're used to it and it's a slow decline in purchasing power we kind of Miss we we miss the magnitude of it”

0.66

The US moved from gold-backed currency (with a fixed gold-dollar ratio) in 1944 (Bretton Woods) to fiat currency in 1971, losing an accountability mechanism and enabling unlimited monetary expansion—a cautionary lesson for CBDC adoption.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 4/4· Brett Rentmaster

“we kind of came up with this system where the dollar was going to represent money around the world but it was backed with a certain rate ratio of gold until we got called on that in 1971 and basically moved away from that obligation and now you know for the last you know 50 plus years we we've been with kind of a blank you know checkbook and not honoring where it started”

0.64

U.S. House of Representatives has voted to prevent the Federal Reserve from creating a CBDC without Congressional approval, and governors like Ron DeSantis are working to forbid CBDCs, signaling political pushback against unilateral CBDC deployment.

normativehigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 2/4· Brett Rentmaster

“House of Representatives voted um that the Federal Reserve could not create a cbdc without approval of Congress and you've had um people from Ronda santis to others trying to put things in place to forbid them”

0.64

Six months before the interview, discussion of CBDCs was considered fringe thinking worthy of conspiracy theorist accusations, but recently CBDCs have entered mainstream political debate, moving from the fringe to public light.

normativehigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 2/4· Brett Rentmaster

“as recently as maybe even six months ago I'd say the discussion of cbdc was very fringed thinking and people might even accuse you of being a conspiracy theorist or something but it's really come into the Limelight”

0.60

Gold has maintained its purchasing power across 50 and 100 year spans, purchasing the same basket of goods today as in the past, unlike the dollar which continuously erodes in purchasing power.

normativehigh valueestablishednovelty 0/4durability 4/4· Brett Rentmaster

“gold pretty much has held its purchasing power it's bought the same basket of goods today that it did 50 years ago that did 100 years ago you can't say that about the dollar it it just kind of slowly erodes right”

0.60

In the U.S., official debt is approximately $35 trillion, but when including unfunded liabilities and pensions, the actual obligation exceeds $200 trillion, creating an unsustainable debt burden that central banks know will eventually go out of control.

normativehigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 2/4· Brett Rentmaster

“in the us alone I was just looking on usdebtclock.org of course we all know we have about $35 trillion of official debt but there's all these unofficial things that just don't get added to that unfunded pensions and liabilities uh Etc and that by that s's measure is greater than 200 trillion”

0.60

CBDCs are unlikely to be adopted voluntarily in most countries, as evidenced by public rejection in Nigeria and other pilot jurisdictions, which is why governments would need a systemic crisis to force adoption.

normativehigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 2/4· Brett Rentmaster

“they've tried this in Nigeria and other places and by and large the public rejects it”

0.56

The debate about money moving from reserve currency transitions (Portuguese to English to American dominance over ~100 year periods) represents changes in power but not fundamental changes in money itself, whereas cryptocurrency represents a fundamentally different idea: that the state doesn't need to issue money at all.

definitionhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 4/4· Brett Rentmaster

“there were periods where you know the English had the reserve currency and it moved on to the Americans and before that it was the Portuguese ET and those were 100-year roughly periods but this time we're talking about something fundamentally different it's saying well maybe we don't need the money that the state issues maybe a peer-to-peer thing PE people can handle that”

0.52

Government incentives to adopt CBDCs include ability to directly enforce tax collection (taking money from accounts), control inflation through expiring money (people forced to spend within time windows), and implementing negative interest rates (charging people to hold money).

causalhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Brett Rentmaster

“what central Bankers like about the concept is it allows them to pull a lot of levers they might say hey inflation's too high um we're GNA disin people to spend money or you know they might want negative interest rates again and now you're locked into this thing and instead of earning 5% interest today they're charging you 5% you know to hold the money there”

0.52

The premise of CBDCs is being marketed as 'digital money similar to cryptocurrency that will be easy to transact in and cheap,' but this framing is misleading because most money is already digital—the real innovation is programmability, not digitization.

causalhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Brett Rentmaster

“what it's being buil as let's start with that is oh this digital money you know kind of similar to cryptocurrencies that are people are getting used to and it'll be easy to transact in and cheap great let's all use it it'll be on your mobile phone okay however we already have as you pointed out digital money you know most of the money out there is not $100 bills changing hands it's digits on a ledger at a bank going from one account to another so it's a little misleading in my opinion to to just say it's an improvement in digital money”

0.52

If the fiat system collapses, the resulting crisis would be global and affect all major currencies simultaneously (dollar, yen, euro), not just one, so cryptocurrencies offer a hedge that transcends national currency failure.

causalhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Brett Rentmaster

“the True cryptocurrency Believers would would probably argue that if the root of the problem ends up being Fiat or or government issued currencies that one it's likely Global in nature so it's probably not just a problem with the dollar it's probably with the dollar the Yen the Euro it's it's kind of a run on the system”

0.52

Fictional scenario: In a CBDC system, a 'Code 5' error could prevent spending on non-essential items by locking down a category of purchases for 30 days based on algorithmic determination of what counts as non-essential.

forecasthigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Brett Rentmaster

“imagine a world like this again fiction you're using this and all of a sudden on your phone code five pops up what's code five you've overspent your allocation on non-essential items and will be precluded from buying anything in that category for 30 days”

0.52

A key takeaway from education on CBDCs should be understanding them as 'programmable money'—this single reframing is more important than detailed technical knowledge because it clarifies what people are actually accepting.

normativehigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Brett Rentmaster

“I think the biggest risk is the control factor and it's the first time again cbdc we should think programmable money if people walk away with one thing that that's what it is”

0.52

The CBDC exploration by central banks is fundamentally a power grab because governments and 98% of central banks globally are working on CBDCs to reclaim control they are slowly losing to cryptocurrency, and because they know behind the scenes that the fiat system is in trouble and the debt-based economy can only go so far.

causalhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Brett Rentmaster

“I think it's a power grab in the sense that I think all of these governments globally and 98% of the central banks are working on a cbdc so this not you know again it's not a fringe idea you know they all have a similar uh backdrop which is they're slowly losing control a little bit of this cryptocurrency phenomena but also I think behind the scenes they know that the Fiat system is in trouble and this debt-based economy we've built can only go so far”

0.52

Social Security and welfare recipients would likely be forced to accept CBDCs because if government benefits are issued only through CBDCs, people dependent on those payments would have no choice but to use them, creating a trapped population.

causalhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Brett Rentmaster

“what if the scenario is that's the only way you get Social Security or Medicare payments or um welfare payments you know if they kind of force it into the system there's going to be a pretty large percent of people that probably are going to adopt it because it's their only choice”

0.52

Cryptocurrency volatility (20% swings) is significant, but investors should view this as acceptable risk because cryptocurrency believers argue limited supply will make it valuable long-term despite near-term price swings.

normativehigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Brett Rentmaster

“cryptocurrency is still more of a wild card... yes it's going to be volatile yes I shouldn't put all my wealth in it but I believe that enough smart people will look for something of a limited Supply that might be part of the future I think that's the premise but you have to approach it very much Eyes Wide Open relative to the volatility and risk”

0.52

CBDCs should be thought of more like Venmo or Zelle in their user interface simplicity, but differ fundamentally because they would eventually include control mechanisms that traditional digital payment apps lack.

definitionhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Brett Rentmaster

“could very much see a system rolling out and at first it seems great it's like zel or venmo and you know there there's none of these hitches but over time things you know the hooks start coming in in certain situations”

0.52

Brett forecasts that a 'crisis of confidence' in fiat currencies will occur due to unsustainable debt levels, after which governments will offer CBDCs as a 'solution,' but enough people will be educated about the dangers to reject them in favor of free-market alternatives like gold, silver, or cryptocurrencies.

forecasthigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 2/4· Brett Rentmaster

“I do think the world is heading towards um I'll call it a crisis of confidence it probably comes down to the debt levels and the Fiat currencies... I think there's going to be a moment of Crisis I hope not but... governments are going to react with something that they have that they hope people will accept Central Bank digital currencies they might work for a little bit but I think enough people are awake to the dangers and they'll ultimately kind of fail”

0.48

To protect themselves against CBDCs, people should create financial resilience by diversifying outside government control: cryptocurrency, precious metals held outside banks, certain real estate investments, farmland, and energy assets—tangible hard assets that can't be printed.

normativehigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Brett Rentmaster

“you have to create resilience in your own life and not be totally dependent on the hand of government... where you can look to have another foot outside that system and that might be things like we're discussing cryptocurrencies that might be precious metals held outside you know the banks and brokerage firms that might be certain Niche types of real estate um the right kind of rental properties in the right markets Farmland could be energy and other tangible assets generally tangible hard asset type Investments that can't be printed out of thin air”

0.47

The US government operates without a budget, spending money in every direction without constraint, which appears unsustainable and mirrors the collapse of the Roman Empire—an indication of impending system failure.

causalhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Brett Rentmaster

“we don't even have a US budget and it seems like we'll spend money in every direction at this point so it feels a little bit to me like maybe it's the end of Rome and it's just you spend while the spending's good and then you know there's something coming”

0.42

The choice between CBDCs and cryptocurrencies represents a fundamental civilizational choice between control-based and freedom-based financial systems, similar to choosing between '1984' and decentralization, with long-term implications for human liberty.

normativehigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 0/4durability 4/4· Andrew Brill

“you just put me back in high school when I read 1984 and I'm like okay maybe big brother is watching and it it it it gives you that feeling like oh my God people are really trying to control us”

0.30

Stable coins represent an intermediate cryptocurrency category between pure speculation (volatile crypto) and fiat stability (CBDCs), attempting to create stable exchange rates while maintaining some decentralization, though this space is still experimental.

definitionestablishednovelty 1/4durability 2/4· Brett Rentmaster

“there's another segment within decentralized cryptocurrencies um that aren it maybe as decentralized as Bitcoin but I referred to as stable coins where they're premise is to be more of a stable exchange rate so to speak”

0.17

CBDCs have not yet been fully rolled out, so security risks and practical implementation problems cannot be definitively assessed, but the control factor represents the biggest known risk regardless of technical security.

factualspeaker onlynovelty 0/4durability 2/4· Brett Rentmaster

“it's not fully rolled out I can't really answer that... maybe if you're on the good side and I'm on the bad side you're going to have some added to your account I'm going to have some taken away”

0.13

Andrew Brill hosts the 'Wealth On' podcast and works with Windrock Wealth Management, a firm with registered investment advisors who provide portfolio reviews and financial resilience services.

factualspeaker onlynovelty 0/4durability 1/4· Andrew Brill

“hello and welcome to wethan I'm your host Andrew Brill”