What this covers

This is a single-presenter video in which Lance Hedrick reports his own controlled testing of 6 versus 9 bar espresso on lighter-roasted coffees. He is explicit that it is not a definitive test. He had one trained co-taster, a Portuguese national barista champion, so two people in total, and the sample is too small for population-level claims. He also notes that online arguments on the subject usually offer no methodology, and some admit to dialing the shots in differently, which voids the comparison.

The method gets real attention. Both samples were equilibrated to within 0.5°C, near 52°C, to remove temperature as a confound. Order was randomized within each round, and the tasters wrote down their preferences independently. They scored acidity, finish, texture and sweetness. The raw data is linked publicly.

The results split by coffee. On the washed Colombian and the washed Ethiopia pulled at traditional 27-30 second times, the two pressures gave near-identical pull times, extraction yield and TDS, and the blind tasting results looked random. The natural Ethiopia was too erratic to read, with pulls ranging from 22 to 27 seconds. The surprise came when the washed Ethiopia was pulled fast, at 22 seconds. Both tasters picked the 9 bar shot five times out of five, but only after calibrating with each other beforehand. Hedrick attributes this to low puck resistance letting pressure drop change the flow rate, not to the pressure number itself.

Several caveats and practical points follow. Spring lever machines behave differently from pump machines, so the findings do not carry over to them. Fines migration is treated as speculation without proof. A machine reading 9.7 bar instead of 9 is unlikely to taste different. Hedrick's advice is that home users should not fret over the pressure setting and should leave a working workflow alone.

Sharpest takeaway

Hedrick argues that pressure setting (6 bar vs 9 bar) is largely a red herring in espresso extraction; what actually matters is the flow rate through the puck and how pressure drop affects puck resistance during the shot.

  • Blind tastings showed no consistent preference between 6 and 9 bar shots when extraction parameters were controlled
  • Differences appeared only when puck resistance was low enough that pressure drop affected flow; static pressure had minimal effect on cup quality
  • Flow rate and puck resistance are the actual variables that matter, not the absolute pressure setting on the machine

The claims · ranked29 claims · weighted by value

This asset isn't compiled yet

You're seeing its claims, ranked. Compile it to build the argument threads, weight them, and check each claim against your library — the full view.

0.66

These findings (from pump-driven espresso machines) do not apply to spring lever machines, which have completely different pressure dynamics—spring levers peak at stated pressure then immediately lose pressure regardless of grind size, whereas pump machines maintain their set pressure.

normativehigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 4/4· Lance Hedrick

“I don't think we should take these results and apply them outside of this for instance on a spring lever there are completely different dynamics that play there this is trying to maintain nine or six bar whatever I have it set at whereas a spring when it's fully compressed can do whatever the stated pressure is assuming you have sucked all the air out so it will Peak out of pressure but then immediately it will start losing pressure regardless of your grind size”

0.61

Natural-processed Ethiopian coffees are problematic for rigorous testing because extraction yields and taste vary wildly shot-to-shot even with identical puck prep, with pulls ranging from 22 to 27 seconds and erratic results, whereas washed Colombian coffees extract uniformly with minimal variation between cups.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Lance Hedrick

“with the natural curado which is the first one we tested the results were interesting and is also a bit of proof as to why I tend to never use Naturals when I do testing you can have one shot pull at 22 the next at 27 and you could do the same Puck prep it can be very erratic the extraction yields can be all over the place and the taste can be kind of wild that's why I usually use higher quality like washed colombias or something like that that tend to be easier on the extraction tend to be very uniform”

0.55

The blind tasting methodology in this experiment was not designed to definitively prove or debunk 6 vs 9 bar claims; with only one trained taster and the channel host (two people total), the sample size is too small to make population-level generalizations.

normativehigh valueestablishednovelty 0/4durability 3/4· Lance Hedrick

“I did not do this with any intent of debunking completely the claims that some people make or of proving the claims that people make because this is nowhere near enough sensory participants but I do think it's a pretty solid experiment that I can present to you”

0.55

Hedrick and his tasting partner (Portuguese national barista champion, highly trained palate) controlled for temperature differences between 6 and 9 bar shots during blind tastings by equilibrating both samples to within 0.5°C (around 52°C), believing temperature differences would be an obvious confound that would bias the tasting.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 0/4durability 3/4· Lance Hedrick

“I did not want a temperature offset in the taste test because that is going to to be a dead giveaway for which one is which so I took my fluke thermometer with thermoprobe on it I shoved it into both of them and I ensured that I had equalized temperature... I got it within 0.5 Centigrade of each other usually around 52° C when we were doing our taste tests”

0.48

Online discussions about 6 bar vs 9 bar espresso often claim scientific backing but present no actual testing, methodology, or controlled comparison—just subjective tasting claims, and some admit to dialing shots in differently, which invalidates the comparison entirely.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Lance Hedrick

“I just Googled six first n Bar and I saw like 15 differ opinions all claiming they had scientific backing not a single one of them showed any type of testing or methodology or anything beyond we tasted this we tasted this this was different and in fact in some of them where they said they had a lot of tasters they admitted to dialing them in differently”

0.47

Flow rate and puck resistance, not absolute bar pressure, are the primary determinants of espresso extraction quality and cup taste.

causalhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Lance Hedrick

“it seems more so that the first two shots were essentially staying at their static pressure throughout the whole extraction we had ground finely enough to allow the same flow rate through the puck regardless of the pressure so the pressure could have been six could have been seven could have been eight could have been nine and that flow rate's not being affected the pressure doesn't have enough of an effect it would seem to change the flow rate through that puck”

0.47

Pressure is not the primary determinant of espresso flow rate through the puck when the puck has high resistance; instead, puck resistance and the resulting pressure-resistance relationship determine flow rate, meaning machines set at 6 bar vs 9 bar will produce similar flow rates if the grind is fine enough to maintain high puck resistance throughout extraction.

causalhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Lance Hedrick

“so it seems that it wasn't necessarily the pressure causing the big differences in the cup but the resistance the waning Puck resistance and the correlating flow rate going through the puck so it seems more so that the first two shots were essentially staying at their static pressure throughout the whole extraction we had ground finely enough to allow the same flow rate through the puck regardless of the pressure so the pressure could have been six could have been seven could have been eight could have been nine and that flow rate's not being affected the pressure doesn't have enough of an effect it would seem to change the flow rate through that puck”

0.47

When puck resistance is low (coarser grind, faster extraction), pressure does affect flow rate and cup quality, but the effect is primarily through pressure drop over the course of the shot—not the absolute pressure value itself.

causalhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Lance Hedrick

“now when the puck resistance is lower it does seem to have an effect the pressure does but it's less about the pressure and more about the pressure drop whenever you have a puck that is on the cusp of losing its resistance that pressure can affect the porosity of it and the flow of the water through”

0.47

With high puck resistance (fine grind, traditional shot lengths), shot pull times are stable and extraction yields are similar whether pulling at 6 or 9 bar, and blind tastes between 6 and 9 bar shots are random or indistinguishable, indicating pressure has no practical effect on cup quality.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Lance Hedrick

“with this one we had a coarser grind size we had the water flowing through a little bit more readily the resistance let up a lot more quickly and so you had a faster pressure drop and so it seems that it wasn't necessarily the pressure causing the big differences in the cup but the resistance the waning Puck resistance and the correlating flow rate going through the puck so it seems more so that the first two shots were essentially staying at their static pressure throughout the whole extraction”

0.47

The initial fill rate of the puck (how water enters and saturates the puck at the start of extraction) and the pressure drop profile during the shot both have large effects on final cup quality, whereas the absolute bar pressure setting has minimal effect when puck resistance is high.

causalhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Lance Hedrick

“the fill rate of the puck and the initial part of it has a big play on the final cup and then the pressure drop seems to have a big play on the Final Cut”

0.44

At 9 bar, puck pressure deteriorates faster than at 6 bar, causing the nine-bar shot to experience a steeper pressure drop mid-extraction, which quickens the flow rate and may degrade puck integrity compared to a six-bar shot, which holds more stable pressure and maintains a consistent, slower flow rate.

causalhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 2/4· Lance Hedrick

“there has to be a reason why we chose 100% the same cup five times in a row on that washed alaka and because it peaked at that nine bar I think it quickly was dropping some of that pressure and allowing a quickening flow rate through the puck as it tries to maintain the pressure but it simply can't whereas with the six bar because six bar of pressure is not potentially deteriorating it as quickly because we are obviously at this cusp of deterioration where pressure could do something to it it is going to hold that six bar longer than the nine could hold nine so The Nine's dropping as that six is staying pretty static”

0.43

Both tasters (Hedrick and the Portuguese national barista champion) were calibrated to each other before tasting the fast-extracted Ethiopia Alaka, meaning they achieved perfect agreement on 6 vs 9 bar identification only after pre-testing together.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Lance Hedrick

“because it peaked at that nine bar I think it quickly was dropping some of that pressure and allowing a quickening flow rate through the puck... every time H and I again were perfectly calibrated and we chose the nine bar shot over the six bar shot after the first three tastings”

0.43

Fines migration (small coffee particles moving through the puck) may vary with pressure, but there is no proof that fines migration is more affected at 9 bar than 6 bar; it could have different thresholds or operate at completely different bar pressures, making speculative claims about fines as a mechanism unreliable.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Lance Hedrick

“there may have been less fines migration in the six bar shot because there's less agitation during that ramp up but that's just speculative that's what lar zoko tends to say happens with six bar that's what some people have said but I don't even know if that's necessarily true there's no proof that findes migration is somehow more affected at 9 bar than six it could be at a threshold at four bar we don't really know”

0.43

A machine's actual pressure output (e.g., a Breville Dual Boiler reading 9.7 bar instead of the stated 9 bar) is unlikely to produce a perceptible taste difference, as long as the set pressure is in the normal operating range for pump machines.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Lance Hedrick

“if you're pulling shots at home and you're worried that oh my brevel dual boiler says it's 9.7 bar but stock says it'll be at 9 it's probably not going to taste any different my friend”

0.43

Flow rate through the puck varies based on puck integrity even at the same set pressure; for example, on a Bianca machine set to pump 3 mL/second, some coffees extract at only 1 mL/second flow rate while others reach 2.5 mL/second, suggesting that inherent puck integrity affects the machine's ability to achieve its theoretical water debit.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Lance Hedrick

“I've done tests on my Bianca with this where I'll open it to what I've measured at 3 m a second water debit and on some coffees it'll get up to 2.5 m a second on others it'll only hit 1 misec even if I run it for like 10 hours and I think some of that's from the inherent Puck Integrity”

0.43

On the fast-extracted Ethiopia Alaka (22 seconds, low puck resistance), both Hedrick and his tasting partner successfully identified 9 bar vs 6 bar shots 100% of the time (5 out of 5 tastings), consistently preferring the 9 bar shot for its smoother texture and finish.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Lance Hedrick

“there has to be a reason why we chose 100% the same cup five times in a row on that washed alaka and because it peaked at that nine bar I think it quickly was dropping some of that pressure and allowing a quickening flow rate through the puck”

0.43

On the washed Colombia Leon Aabi and washed Ethiopia Alaka (at traditional 27-30 second extractions), the 6 and 9 bar shots looked identical during pulling, had very similar pull times, very similar extraction yields, and very similar TDS (total dissolved solids), making them indistinguishable on paper.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Lance Hedrick

“they pulled beautifully they looked identical and it was very difficult to tell the difference on paper between the two different shots they both pulled at the same times with a very tiny P value”

0.43

Hedrick recommends that home users not worry about precise bar pressure settings on their machines, as variations within normal operating range will not produce perceptible taste differences if puck resistance is adequately managed through grind adjustment.

normativehigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Lance Hedrick

“if you're pulling shots at home and you're worried that oh my brevel dual boiler says it's 9.7 bar but stock says it'll be at 9 it's probably not going to taste any different my friend if you have a machine that's oh it's it's only Seven bar well that may be fine”

0.39

The natural Ethiopia Kado shots showed no real correlation between results and pressure settings; two of the five blind tastings showed different preferences, but overall the preferences were random, and extraction times ranged wildly (22-27 seconds), making the comparison inconclusive.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 0/4durability 3/4· Lance Hedrick

“the six bar was a bit faster than the nine bar but I would not read too far into that again because this is only five shots you have a lot of fines production with Ethiopia so there may have been less fines migration in the six bar shot because there's less agitation during that ramp up but that's just speculative... there's no proof that findes migration is somehow more affected at 9 bar than six... there is texture differences but those seem to be more from not perfectly uniform extractions there was no real correlation between the results and anything to be done with the pressures”

0.39

Hedrick recommends against changing your espresso workflow based on these findings if it's already working for you (e.g., if you're pulling 6 bar shots at your café or using a 6 bar spring lever, don't feel you need to switch).

normativehigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 0/4durability 3/4· Lance Hedrick

“I'm not saying throw away your six bar Spring if you got one for the gaja I'm not saying stop pulling six bar shots at your shop if that's what you're pulling I'm not saying that at all”

0.34

The tasting criteria used to evaluate espresso shots were: acidity, finish, texture, and sweetness.

definitionestablishednovelty 0/4durability 4/4· Lance Hedrick

“we were looking for acidity we were looking for finish for texture uh sweetness and we would notate what those different things were for each cup”

0.34

Blind tastings require oscillating (randomizing the order of tasting samples) between pressure settings within each round to avoid order bias affecting taster preference.

normativeestablishednovelty 0/4durability 4/4· Lance Hedrick

“we would oscillate it though in order to ensure as much randomization as possible so I did nine bar then six bar and then I had the next round of taste test we did six bar than 9 bar”

0.34

The two tasters independently wrote down their cup preferences to avoid one taster biasing the other during the tasting round.

normativeestablishednovelty 0/4durability 4/4· Lance Hedrick

“we had which one we preferred on paper so that we were independently writing away from each other so there was no bias instilled from one to the other”

0.20

All raw data from the testing is available for public access on a web page linked in the video description, allowing anyone to reanalyze the data or create alternative charts.

factualspeaker onlynovelty 0/4durability 3/4· Lance Hedrick

“I have all of the raw data Down Below in the caption on a web page for anyone to access feel free to go check it out you can run it through your own charts”

0.20

Hedrick brought in Houie (Portuguese national barista champion) to assist with testing, providing additional validation through a trained, independent taster.

factualspeaker onlynovelty 0/4durability 3/4· Lance Hedrick

“I called my buddy houie who helps me with a lot of my testing he's the Portuguese national barista champion good pallette good coffee skills brought him over and we did a lot of shop pulling a lot of refracting and a vomit amount of tasting”

0.17

The dark-roasted commercial espresso blend (fourth coffee tested, one-shot tasting due to quantity limits) showed different extractions between 6 and 9 bar, which Hedrick attributed to it being a ~47,000 bean blend with high variability rather than a clear pressure effect.

factualspeaker onlynovelty 0/4durability 2/4· Lance Hedrick

“I did do a fourth coffee I did not do five shots of I physically was not able to It was a commercial coffee that was a very dark roasted blend and it's because I wanted to throw something into the mix that wasn't light medium like the one from Alchemist tasted it the two times were different the extractions were different but what can you expect from a probably a 47,000 Bean blend I don't know”

0.17

The 6 bar shot trend was popularized by the turbo shot paper a few years before this video, and Hedrick made an earlier video on the topic.

factualspeaker onlynovelty 0/4durability 2/4· Lance Hedrick

“I know that six bar shots got quite famous I guess you could say after the turbo shop paper a few years ago which I did a video two or 3 years ago”

0.17

Six bar shots seemed slightly faster than nine bar shots on the natural Ethiopia, but this difference was only observable across five shots and was not statistically meaningful enough to draw conclusions about a pressure effect.

factualspeaker onlynovelty 0/4durability 2/4· Lance Hedrick

“the six bar was a bit faster than the nine bar but I would not read too far into that again because this is only five shots”

0.17

Hedrick used a Linea Mini R espresso machine with a pressure screw adjustment system that allows switching between 6 and 9 bar without removing the portafilter, and a Eureka Monolith grinder with SSW burrs to avoid heat-up confounds from duty cycles between shots.

factualspeaker onlynovelty 0/4durability 2/4· Lance Hedrick

“I would take my linear mini R which has a nice little screw on top where I can switch easily between nine bar and six bar of pump pressure and I use a Cofe monolith with the ssw burs because I don't want to worry about heat up times with a cheaper grinder so that I don't have to worry about Duty Cycles and things like that to skew shots”