
Are you ready for the mother of all blow-off stock market tops? | Investing tips from Brent Johnson
What this covers
This is a weekend episode of the Milkshakes, Markets, Madness show, in which Brent Johnson talks with host Jon Kutsmeda about the previous week's market action. It starts with the dollar, which Johnson says has traded sideways for five to seven years, then moves through equities, bitcoin and precious metals, and the US election. Most of the half hour goes to what could happen to stocks over the next six months. He treats the choice as binary: a sharp drop into September, or a runaway rally.
The market picture is one of divergence. Johnson notes that the Mag Seven are up roughly 50% this year while the Russell 2000 is flat and the S&P 500 is up about 8%. He reads that concentration as a sign of fragility. He also points to record-low volatility, a low put-call ratio and thin markets in summer, and to the historical clustering of crashes around September and October. The Federal Reserve's July minutes leaned hawkish, but he expects softer data to give the Fed cover to cut in September. He also expects a stronger dollar to accompany any bout of volatility. The "violently sideways" framing comes up as a way that bulls and bears can each find evidence for their view.
The episode also covers several other topics. Johnson describes bitcoin as a pure play on global liquidity and attributes its early-July weakness to distribution of Mt. Gox coins, which he defends as rational profit-taking. He stays bullish on precious metals over the long run, including a possible $40-60 for silver, while favoring options trades to buy pullbacks. On politics, Kutsmeda argues that Biden's debate performance could reduce election volatility by making a Trump win look more likely. The last stretch turns to temperament: staying detached, keeping a sense of humor, and avoiding permanent attachment to either a bull or a bear narrative.
Johnson and Brent argue that markets face a binary outcome in the next 6 months—either a sharp correction in September following Fed rate cuts amid economic softening, or a spectacular 20-30% blowoff top—because current conditions of extreme complacency (low volatility, record highs, thin summer markets) cannot sustain gradual sideways movement without releasing pressure.
- Markets priced to perfection with no risk perceived cannot continue grinding higher without volatility forcing a correction
- Historical pattern shows Q3-Q4 crashes, and with thinning summer markets, any small risk event triggers outsized moves
- Fed minutes showed hawkish tilt expecting longer rate-hold, but coming volatility will give Fed cover to cut in September
This asset isn't compiled yet
You're seeing its claims, ranked. Compile it to build the argument threads, weight them, and check each claim against your library — the full view.
The US dollar has essentially traded sideways for the last 5-7 years between 100-105 on the dollar index, excluding the post-COVID liquidity spike and the 2022 move to 30-year highs, suggesting the dollar may continue to move sideways for the next several years rather than rally dramatically.
“if you take out the the move down subsequent to covid that was you know as a result of all the liquidity that was pumped into the market and if you take out you know the six to n the 6 to n month run it had in 2022 you know back to its 30-year High you take those two time periods out and it's really gone sideways for the last five or six seven years um you know it's at I think it's at 104 105 today and you know for a long time it's just been bouncing between 100 and 105”
Markets do not move in straight lines, even in massive bull markets; they require periodic pullbacks deeper than expected before resuming strength, and attempting to grind steadily higher without volatility increases the severity of eventual corrections.
“markets don't go in a straight light even if you get the most massive bull market in history again look at the last 20 years of the equity Market if you look at the last 20 years of the E mark that's a hell of a bull market but there were really hard pullbacks along the way right markets just don't go in a straight line they they they you know they run higher than they think they should they pull back further than you think they should and then they make a run again”
The headline employment number often beats expectations but revisions to prior months often take away those gains, creating a pattern where markets react positively initially then retreat as revisions are released.
“I and to me it's just more the same we've seen this a lot this year where the headline number comes in and beats expectations but then the revisions take it all away right there's been a number of time even with inflation is some of the inflation data you know people have been expecting inflation to come in Weak it comes in at or beats but then the revisions are are are are lower and so you kind of get these these knee-jerk initial Reactions where it jumps one way and immediately goes the other”
Historical patterns show that market crashes and crises disproportionately occur in September-October (Q3-Q4 transition), and with current thin summer markets combined with extreme sentiment, this historical precedent makes a Q3 crash likely.
“the fall you know third quarter is often or I guess it's like September October time frame so end of third quarter beginning to fourth quarter is often for whatever reason throughout history where you get these like many crashes or disasters or crises um and so I I think it I to me it'd be pretty surprising if we make it all the way to the election without some kind of volatility before then”
Current market conditions show extreme complacency (record low volatility, all-time high stock prices, low put-call ratio) that historically precede sharp corrections, making it necessary to maintain cash reserves, put protection on positions, and contingency plans rather than assuming continued smooth gains.
“I don't think that you need to position your portfolio for an absolute disaster crash but this is the type of environment where you know the put call ratio is low volatility is at at alltime low stocks are at alltime high you know I feel like these are the times where you at least want to have some cash on the sidelines you want to have some kind of put protection when you buy it when it's cheap uh you want to have some kind of a plan if things don't go well”
When markets are priced to perfection with extreme complacency (record low volatility, all-time highs, thin summer trading), any small risk event can trigger outsized market moves because liquidity is low and positioning is one-directional.
“when these all these signals I look at when sentiment is super high when relative strength is super high when the put call ratio is was really low when vix is at its all-time low and we're in summer kind of thin markets you know people are going to start going on vacation it's July July and August are typically thinner markets because you know people aren't around as much and so you know you don't need to have that in that type of a market when everything is kind of priced to Perfection and there is no risk to be seen it doesn't take that much risk showing up to cause a big move in markets”
The disasters that investors constantly predict (global currency collapse, loss of dollar reserve status) do NOT occur when the dollar declines, but rather when the dollar strengthens, making predictions of imminent dollar collapse based on structural arguments misguided about the timing and direction of systemic risk.
“the disasters that everybody always predicts and talks about are when the dollar goes higher so if you think we're going to have this imminent Global catastrophe that's the dollar going higher not lower”
US equity markets will significantly outperform rest-of-world markets for extended period due to structural advantages, but this outperformance cannot sustain at current growth rates without correction, suggesting either downside or blowoff before normalization.
“the US Equity markets are for the most part outperforming the rest of the world so I you know continue to believe that this is a market that isn't necessarily going to crash uh but I also don't think that we can continue at this rate of growth in in in just a few sectors without having some kind of a a correction or some kind of a pause at some point”
Approaching financial markets with a sense of humor and emotional detachment from outcomes prevents investors from over-committing to single narratives and allows them to pivot when market conditions change, whereas ideological attachment to one view (e.g. permanent bear market, permanent bull market) leads to large drawdowns.
“one of the things that is interesting about how you articulate and conversate with people in the financial World especially on Twitter is your ability to have a sense of humor no matter what the circumstances are and and I think too often people approach the markets like it's a sports team or a religion and they get really really worked up on on one side of the table and they lose their sense of humor”
When crises occur (foreign sovereign debt stress, geopolitical shocks, etc.), capital will flee lower-yielding sovereign bonds globally and flow into US equities, pushing US stocks higher because the US remains the safe-haven destination, meaning some crisis scenarios are actually bullish for equities despite causing volatility.
“I think that when the crisis happens whatever the next Crisis is whenever the next Crisis comes I think it's going to be at the Sovereign level and think when Sovereign bonds starts to get rejected I think the money that flows out of sovereign bonds will flow into US equities and I think that actually pushes them higher than many people believe but I don't think that that happens without a correction first”
US equity markets show dramatic divergence with the Mag Seven (tech-heavy index) up ~50% year-to-date while Russell 2000 is roughly flat, the Dow up 2-4%, S&P 500 up ~8%, and NASDAQ up ~20%, indicating unhealthy concentration and unsustainability of current gains without significant correction.
“the Russell 2000 is basically flat for the year I think the Dow is up two or three maybe 4% for the year S&P is probably up eight or % I think the nasdaq's maybe up 20 um but the MA 7 is up like 50 right so you got these major divergences in US Equity markets”
The Federal Reserve's July minutes revealed a hawkish tilt—officials expected to wait longer before cutting rates and needed to see more economic softening—but because the minutes released after market close on July 3, the market did not price in this hawkish signal in real time.
“the FED minutes came out it came out after the market closed so the market closed early on Wednesday typically the the the FED minutes come out when they're still a couple hours left to go in the market but because it was uh July 3rd they came out after the market closed early on July 3rd the minutes came out of and you know the they were they weren't super hawkish but I think they were more hawkish than doish”
The Dow Jones index has largely moved sideways (up but not dramatically) over the last couple years, Russell 2000 has gone sideways for 2-3 years, while S&P 500 and NASDAQ show much stronger performance, indicating broad market weakness masked by mega-cap concentration.
“the Russell 2000 has largely gone sideways for I don't know two or three years now maybe it's up a little bit the Dow has largely gone sideways no it's up but but it's not up dramatically um you know over the last couple years the S&P is up pretty good and the s and NASDAQ is up uh very good”
Holders of Mt. Gox bitcoin who were forced to hold for 7-10 years due to theft and are now seeing 100x returns should rationally sell to realize gains and convert to fiat currency, making their selling legitimate profit-taking rather than irrationality or lack of faith in bitcoin.
“so now that they're they're they're waking up this morning and they have a 100x on their position so if that if it is them that are selling you know I raised my congratulations to you guys you you you made your bet you were forced to hold it for 10 years but it paid off and you know congratulations so now you're getting some liquidity in US dollars”
Investors should approach markets with humor and perspective, viewing setbacks as learning opportunities rather than personal failures, and should enjoy life outside markets rather than becoming obsessed with short-term price movements.
“hopefully you know with these conversations that's some of the grounded voices that we're we're hoping to provide is no one knows the future we're trying to navigate these things day by day week by week but do try to approach it with a historical perspective and a fundamental perspective and at least you know take a moment to laugh at yourself once in a while”
Bitcoin functions as a pure play on global liquidity rather than a long-term store of value or currency, explaining why bitcoin and precious metals diverged in early July when precious metals rallied on expected liquidity while bitcoin declined as Mount Gox settlement coins were distributed.
“I think Bitcoin is just a pure play on global liquidity now I think the explanation that you know these uh longtime I guess holders not out of the um not out of choice but out of necessity who've been holding Bitcoin because it got stolen from them and they've seen a subsequent you know 100x move on their position”
Higher volatility in the second half of 2024 versus the first half will coincide with higher US Dollar Index (DXY) levels, because historical pattern shows every crisis or volatility event in the last 20 years has coincided with dollar strength.
“I have a hard time believing the next six months are as low volatility as the last six months now I can't say that's impossible it's possible I just think it's unlikely and when you typically have a higher level of volatility you typically have a higher dollar that goes with it again part of the reason I'm bullish on the dollar uh long term is because every time we've had any kind of crisis at all for the last 20 years it has coincided with a rising dxy the Dollar Rising versus other foreign currencies so I don't see why it would be different this time”
Biden's clear cognitive decline on display during the June debate, if he continues to run, could paradoxically reduce election volatility by making it clear to markets that Trump will likely win, eliminating the high-uncertainty scenario where neither candidate is accepted as legitimate.
“Biden for a very long time was just not cognitively there that was on full display this time and so then all kinds of conversations came out about well what are the Democrats going to do clearly Biden's not in in a place to continue to run”
The 'violently sideways' market narrative means that bulls and bears both have something to point to as evidence of their correctness, with different market segments (tech up, small caps flat, commodities volatile) each allowing supporters of different viewpoints to find validation.
“in these violently sideways markets it creates a little bit of of a win or something on both sides of the table to flex about or talk about the Bulls have something the Bears have something”
Major financial markets divergences (equities, commodities, crypto behaving differently) and unprecedented concentration in mega-cap tech require air to be let out of the balloon through tactical volatility rather than continuing to grind higher, or else the result will be a total pop and catastrophic crash.
“I kind of feel like for that to continue we need to have a little bit of the air L out of the bubble and or the balloon and if you don't let a little bit of the air out of it then it's going to totally Po and there's a lot of people who believe we are past the point of being able to let a little air out I actually believe that we can let a little bit of air out and then go higher over the next couple years”
A significant market correction in the next 6 months is preferable to the alternative of a sustained blowoff top, because corrections reset sentiment and allow markets to consolidate before going higher sustainably, whereas blowoff tops precede severe bear markets and systemic crises.
“I think if we get a blowoff top from here because remember my base case is not that we're going to have one of these you know magnificent crashes in bare markets that last for two or three years I don't think we're going to have another Global financial crisis over the next 6 months I can't rule it out that's not my base case what I do think though is I think we could get a correction of the last at six months and then we you know Back Off to the Races again um and so I think the best thing for my base case would be some kind of a correction”
Markets will face a binary outcome in the next 6 months: either significant downside into September when the Federal Reserve cuts rates in response to economic softening, or a mother of all blowoff tops driving equities up 20-30% in six months, with neither a gradual sideways grind nor modest 5-10% gains being likely.
“so I think we're either going to get downside into September when we get a rate cut or we're going to get the mother of all blowoff tops and I mean it is just going to go up 20 or 30% from here over the next six months”
The Fed will likely cut rates in September only if economic data softens between now and then, as current Fed guidance (per minutes) suggests they expect to hold longer; economic volatility gives them political cover to cut and allows them to claim they were correct that the next move was easing.
“I again I don't think that they will if if markets are just going to continue to do what they have done I don't think that they will cut in September but because I think we're at a level where we're going to have I think we are going to have some pullback or at least some Slowdown a little bit between now and then I think that they are likely to cut”
Despite bullish long-term views on precious metals (potential for silver to reach $40-60 per ounce in years ahead), this is not a straight line move, and tactical pullbacks using options trades provide opportunities to reduce average cost while maintaining conviction.
“I think silver probably has the potential to go to 40 50 60 bucks in the years ahead uh but I don't think it'll be a straight line and if we get some volatility and you know we get uh lesser liquidity um I think we probably get volatility in all asset classes”
Gold and silver can appreciate simultaneously with a rising dollar, a scenario that has begun to materialize over the past 12 months, contrary to conventional assumptions that dollar strength requires precious metals weakness.
“and it's not that you can't have a rising dxy with Rising gold price that's one of the things I predicted six or seven year five years five six years ago and we've seen that start to happen over the last 12 months”
The specific scenario of volatility in late July-August, no Fed rate cut in late July, harder sell-off in August on thin vacation markets, followed by Fed cut in September would be consistent with Brent's thesis and would allow rallying into year-end.
“we could have some volatility the second half of July people would expect people start to think we're going to get a rate cut we don't get a rate cut and then things sell off harder into August when you know the really thin markets people are away on vacation and then the FED comes out and cuts in sep that would not surprise me at all and you know that would perhaps you know maybe that that would be what we need and then to then rally into the end of the year”
In July/early August markets typically perform decently, but between early August and end of August volatility tends to pick up as markets thin out with vacationing traders, which could then create conditions for Fed rate cut in September.
“I kind of feel like what's going to happen is that you know maybe we have another couple weeks of you know okay you know typically ju July is typically a decent month for markets or at least the first couple first few weeks of July are typically pretty good in the markets wouldn't surprise me to continue to see some of that at least heading into CPI next week but I think I think between now in the FED meeting or certainly between now and the end of August I think we're going to get enough of volatility”
The June employment report showed mixed signals (unemployment ticked up slightly, revisions negative for prior months, job beats expectations), typical of violently sideways labor data that provides no clear directional catalyst for markets.
“non-farm payroll uh was let's call it I guess soft I mean their unemployment ticked up slightly there was big revisions to the previous two months slightly beat expectations on current job ads”
Tech stocks and NASDAQ rallied ~1% on the employment report day despite Nvidia declining, while Dow and Russell 2000 were essentially flat, showing continued concentration of strength in mega-cap tech rather than broadening of market gains.
“it was pretty quiet I get te Tech did really well it's kind of surprising to me that the Nvidia was down on the day but yet Tech was up almost 1% or the NASDAQ was up almost 1% and some of the other chips were up um but again the Dow was basically flat the Russell 2000 was basically flat”
CPI report in the coming week will be the last major economic data release before the Fed meeting a couple weeks away, and will have significant impact on Fed rate decision expectations.
“I think next week will be interesting with the with the CPI that has the CPI until the FED meeting is probably the last big data release and the FED I can't remember was the FED meeting last week in July or first week of August but it's a couple weeks away”
Economic data (jobs, inflation) is currently showing softening signals, which is what the Federal Reserve wants to see in order to justify cutting rates, but the Fed is waiting for more evidence before moving.
“the economy continues to kind of show sides of softening which is what the FED wants to see is they they think as the as the economy softens a little bit then inflation comes down and then they'll eventually have to cut rates”
Trump becoming president and implementing deregulation, interest rate cuts, and increased government spending would stimulate the economy for 1-2 years, potentially supporting equities and other risk assets in that window before longer-term consequences emerge.
“maybe if we had that volatility and then you know what you suggest happens that would allow us to then you know Trump comes in and is business friendly and you know deregulates some markets and probably Cuts interest rates and I'm sure we'll spend a heck of a lot of money and you know that gooses the economy for another year or two”
Silver prices spiked 4-5% in early July week and are approaching May/June levels where Brent placed a put trade, with technical signals also reverting to near-extreme levels, suggesting potential repeat short silver trade may be warranted if price rises further into CPI announcement.
“the thing that struck out to me this week was the fact that you know we've had Precious Precious Metals had a very good week you know silver was up four or five% this week I think gold was up one or two% the miners did pretty well um they're getting pretty close to back where they were in May and early June”
The portfolio positioning Brent employs (equities, short-term fixed income, gold) reflects both bullish stance and expectation of higher volatility, with the fixed income and gold serving as volatility dampeners while equities provide growth exposure.
“my plan hasn't really changed you know we own equities we own some short-term fixed income we own gold uh but you know we're we're prepared for some kind of a a higher level of volatility in the second half of the year than we had in the first half of the Year”
The show 'Milkshakes, Markets & Madness' will be rolling out new projects, deep dives, think pieces, and a new 'Milkshakes Markets Master Class' in the coming weeks with announcements to follow.
“as many of you know from listening to us um throughout the last couple weeks Brent and I have been rolling out some new projects stay tuned for more information on that we have been working very hard on some uh New pieces some new deep Dives new think pieces and the uh milkshakes markets Master Class we'll have some updates and announcements coming soon”