
Economist fact-checks Galloway's doomer take on America's young
What this covers
Money & Macro's Joeri Schasfoort, an economist, works through the claims in a TED talk by Scott Galloway and follows the talk's own order: income, cost of living, transfers from young to old, and wellbeing. The first and longest section covers the claim that young Americans earn less than earlier generations on an inflation-adjusted basis. Galloway leans on a study by Raj Chetty and colleagues, which found that the share of people earning more than their parents at age 30 fell to about 50% between 1940 and 2016. Schasfoort treats that study as credible but argues that it is one study, and that social science normally wants several. He sets it beside Federal Reserve and NBER) work that looks at other ages and at average and median income, and he explains why the three can disagree without contradicting each other.
The middle of the video covers costs and housing. Schasfoort says Galloway offers no figures weighing education costs against income gains, and that the Fed study finds the extra income more than covers them. He notes that College Board data show college cost inflation recently turning down. He also traces housing affordability through the 1980s, the 2000s bubble and the 2010s, when it improved. On wealth transfers, he argues that a large generation simply holds more wealth as it ages, so the pattern does not show a transfer from young to old. He also points out that people aged 45 to 65 pay the largest share of US taxes.
The last stretch looks at the wellbeing graphs: self-harm, teen depression, overdoses, obesity. Schasfoort sets them against national indicators that moved the other way, among them pollution, lead exposure, youth victimization and high school completion. He concedes that lower-income Americans may be stalling and that children face serious problems. He still finds no evidence that children are worse off overall.
Scott Galloway's TedTalk claiming young Americans are worse off than previous generations relies on selective evidence, misrepresented data, and cherry-picked studies, failing to meet academic standards despite addressing some legitimate concerns about housing and education costs.
- Galloway's income comparison uses unverified calculations at age 25 while ignoring credible Federal Reserve and NBER studies showing younger generations still earn more overall
- His wealth transfer evidence conflates demographic aging of Baby Boomers with intergenerational wealth transfer, a fundamentally flawed interpretation
- His wellbeing claims selectively present negative trends while ignoring improvements in child poverty, pollution, violent crime, and high school completion rates
This asset isn't compiled yet
You're seeing its claims, ranked. Compile it to build the argument threads, weight them, and check each claim against your library — the full view.
Between 45 to 65 years old, people pay the largest share of taxes in the US, suggesting transfers from working-age to young and old may be more complex than Galloway suggests
“But more importantly, despite Scott Galloway branding himself as prof. G there's really nothing academic about these arguments. He's just giving us random examples of transfers from young to old, without giving us any insight into how big these transfers are and whether or not they are offset by other big transfers. The other way around. So just, for example, 45 to 65 years old, people paying the largest share of taxes in the US.”
Age 25 is an inappropriate comparison point for intergenerational income analysis because previous generations did not attend college as extensively and therefore tended to earn more at such a young age.
“previous generations typically did not go to college and therefore tended to earn more at such a young age”
The Federal Reserve study reports that the higher income of younger people may be skewed by the fact that younger generations are increasingly living with and relying on their parents well into their 20s, suggesting income comparisons may not reflect full living standards.
“Finally, while the NBER study finds that on average and at the median, young Americans are doing better than previous generations, this is not the case for the poorest in US society, where progress has stagnated. So, in short, the second piece of evidence given to us by Prof. G is valid. However, for a university professor. It is really quite disappointing that he only picks a single study that seems to confirm his point while ignoring the other recent respectable studies that go against it. Luckily, Prof G still has a third piece of evidence, which is a this chart that clearly shows that there has been an enormous transfer of wealth where people over the age of 70 used to control 90% of household income, versus people under the age of 40 used to control 12. Their wealth has been cut in half.”
Galloway shows graphs of self-harm rates among children 10-14 (especially girls), increased teen depression (especially girls), reduced sexual activity among young men, increased gun deaths for young children, increased youth obesity, and increased overdose deaths as evidence that young people have lower wellbeing.
“To back up this claim, Prof G shows us a bunch of graphs all headed up into the right. The first graph shows us that self-harm rates among children from 10 to 14 have exploded, especially amongst girls. The second is that teens and especially girls are increasingly depressed. Then young people, and especially men, are having less sex. Cumulative gun deaths are way up for very young children. Youngsters are more obese. And finally, in this depressing list, overdose deaths among the young are way up”
The presentation discusses welfare wages, where wages compared to stock market returns barely register, indicating capital has significantly outpaced labor returns over decades.
“Well, what about wages? Right. They've gone up. Well, if you compare them to the S&P, they barely register. It's been an amazing time to own assets”
The Federal Reserve study finds that the extra income younger generations earn is more than enough to cover the increased cost of education because increased education costs are typically incurred for only a few years while financial benefits accrue over decades.
“Finally, while one study is not enough evidence to be sure, the fed study that I mentioned earlier does find that the extra income younger generations earn is more than enough to cover the increased cost of education, because these increased costs are typically only incurred for a couple of years. While the financial benefits of an education accrue over decades.”
A Federal Reserve study comparing average and median incomes across generations at ages 36-40 finds that new generations still earn more than those before them, contrasting with the Chetty study's findings.
“The first, this study from economists from the Federal Reserve that compares both average and median incomes across generations for multiple ages, but with a focus on ages 36 to 40”
When taking a scientific approach and reviewing key national indicators of child well-being from the US Federal Inter-Agency Forum on Child and Family Statistics, many important graphs remain fairly stable, including child poverty, which Galloway briefly mentioned.
“However, if you take a more scientific approach and take a look at the key national indicators of child well-being from the US federal Inter-Agency Forum on Child and Family Statistics long name, we can also find many important graphs that remain fairly stable, like child poverty, which poverty briefly mentioned in this talk.”
The Federal Reserve and NBER studies do not invalidate the Chetty study; rather, the three studies reach different conclusions because they differ in methodology: the age groups examined, whether they account for taxes and transfers, and whether they look at individual earners versus average and median income across generations.
“No. In fact, both of these studies cite Prof. Chetty's study with respect and don't claim that their results invalidate that study. So why are then these conclusions so different? Well, I found three big differences between these studies”
Housing affordability was very bad in the 1980s when interest rates were high and home prices low, and in the early 2000s during the housing bubble, but improved in the 2010s due to low interest rates and lower house prices after the 2007 crash.
“house affordability was very bad in the 1980s, when interest rates were super high, and in the early 2000, when the U.S. was in the middle of a housing bubble. But where actually, you know, it got a bit better in the 2010s thanks to super low interest rates and lower house prices after the crash in 2007.”
Key national indicators show improvements in child wellbeing including less air pollution, less asthma, less water pollution, less lead in children's blood, fewer youth victims of serious violent crimes, and more young adults finishing high school.
“However, if you want to sell a story that kids are better off than their parents, we may also find many graphs that show that the life of children got better, such as a less air pollution, less asthma, less water pollution, a less lead in the blood of children, less youth, victims of serious violent crimes, and more young adults finishing high school.”
Lower income people in America are no longer progressing and may not be doing as well as their parents
“Yes, extensive studies suggest that the rate of progress has decreased, that lower income people are no longer progressing, and that many people don't do as well as their parents.”
The Chetty study examines age 30 while the Federal Reserve and NBER studies examine older ages (36-40 and 26-34 respectively), and age matters because younger generations stay in school longer and therefore start their careers later.
“Firstly, the Chetty study cited by Prof. G looks at a very specific age and a relatively young age 30, while the other two studies looked at ages above 30 as well. 30 is probably more representative than 25, which Prof G looked at. However, it still suffers from the same problem to a certain extent, which is that the younger generations stay in school longer and therefore start their careers later in life.”
College cost inflation, which was a terrible trend, has recently turned a corner and begun to decline, according to College Board data.
“He also doesn't tell us that, luckily for our children, the terrible trend that colleges got way more expensive has recently turned a corner. As we can see here in this graph from the College Board.”
Despite Galloway's claims about education difficulty, younger generations are more educated than those before them, a trend holding up for Generation Z according to Pew Research.
“Indeed, as you can see here, younger generations are more educated than those that came before them, a trend that is, according to Pew Research, holding up for generation Z so far.”
A Harvard study by economist Raj Chetty and colleagues, published in the prestigious journal Science, finds that from 1940 to 2016, the percentage of people earning more than their parents at age 30 dropped to about 50%.
“Evidence number two comes from a study by Harvard professor Raj Chetty and colleagues that was published in the prestigious journal Science. This study finds that from 1940 to 2016, the percentage of people that earned more than their parents at the age of 30 drops to about 50%.”
When inequality increases, a scenario where five children earn slightly less than their parents while five children earn significantly more results in the Chetty metric showing decline (50% earners more) while average and median measures show improvement.
“To see why, just imagine a simple scenario where five children earn a little bit less than their parents, while five children earn a lot more. In this case, the Chetty study outcome would be that American prosperity is slowing down. However, the other researchers would find that both the average and median incomes have still improved.”
As people age, they accumulate wealth, so when a large generation gets older, people in older age groups will control more wealth even without intergenerational transfer.
“What likely makes this affect even bigger is that as people get older, they build wealth. So if a really big generation gets old, old people overall will of course control more wealth.”
Scott Galloway claims young Americans today are earning less than previous generations on an inflation-adjusted basis, presenting this as evidence of generational decline.
“claiming that the young in America today they're doing more poorly than previous generations”
Galloway claims education costs have skyrocketed and college admission has become more difficult, but provides no evidence quantifying the impact on young people relative to income gains.
“However, does give us any evidence that it does. He just mentions that an education is now much more expensive than it was when he was young. On top of that, he tells us that it's now more difficult to get into a good college. Both of this is true.”
The Chetty study is a credible piece of evidence because it was published in a prestigious journal by a respected author, meaning it has been examined by many people and generally holds up to scrutiny.
“Less well-known research in a from a good journal by a respected author. These are all good signs because it means that the study has been seen and examined by a lot of people. And overall, it seems to hold up.”
In social sciences, accepting something as potentially true typically requires multiple credible studies rather than relying on a single study, and Galloway violates this standard by citing only the Chetty study.
“However, it is just one study, and typically in the social sciences, we'd like to have multiple credible studies before we accept something as potentially true. Sadly, Prof G only cites this one study”
Senior poverty is way down while child poverty is roughly stable, which Galloway cites as evidence of policy favoring elderly over children.
“or that senior poverty is way down while tied to poverty is roughly stable”
There is no evidence that children today are overall worse off than previous generations, even though they face some very big problems
“And there is no evidence that kids today are overall worse off than the generations before them, even though they have some face some very big problems.”
The narrator selectively chose six graphs that go against Galloway's point to demonstrate that Galloway acts like a politician pushing a narrative rather than a professor uncovering truth
“Where you may have noticed that I selected six graph that go against Prof. G's point to prove a point, which is that prof G is not acting like a prof in this video, but rather like a politician trying to push a certain message.”
Galloway's age-25 income comparison is based on calculations attributed to 'Profs calculations' with no source transparency, methodology documentation, or available verification from the speaker despite direct request.
“The source for this table is profits calculations. But property doesn't tell us anything about these calculations other than that he chose to compare income at the arbitrary age of 25”
Galloway's third piece of evidence—a chart showing people over 70 control 9% of household income while people under 40 control 12%, representing an alleged wealth halving—is more plausibly explained by demographic aging of Baby Boomers rather than intergenerational wealth transfer.
“But does this chart really show that there has been an enormous transfer of wealth from young to old? No it doesn't. Instead, it probably shows us that America has gotten older.”
Galloway shows a long historical housing affordability graph starting in 1985 (when interest rates were high and home prices low) but only compares mortgage costs between 2019 and 2024, a selective presentation that artificially makes recent housing more expensive.
“But isn't it a bit suspicious that he shows us a long historical graph starting in 1985, when interest rates were really high and home prices low? But then he only looks at 2019 and 2024 for the mortgage cost comparison.”
While Gen Z had a promising start on homeownership, the post-pandemic surge in interest rates and home prices might spoil that trend, potentially creating a genuine challenge for the youngest generation.
“And while Gen Z had a promising start, but post-pandemic surge in interest rates and home prices might spoil that.”
To Galloway's knowledge, his wellbeing charts are correct, but they are very selective, meaning he looks at what he wants to push as a story and finds only graphs supporting that point while ignoring others that don't.
“Again, Prof. G's charts are, to my knowledge, correct. But they are also, again, very selective, meaning that much like a politician, Prof. G just looks at what he wanted to push as a story and then went out finding only graphs that supported that point well, ignoring others that don't.”
The narrator has made videos addressing the housing crisis in the Anglo-Saxon world and the fact that due to stagnant wages and inflation, the US economy looks great on paper but doesn't work for many people, suggesting they share some of Galloway's substantive concerns.
“Given that I myself have made videos addressing the housing crisis in the Anglo-Saxon world, or the fact that due to stagnant wages and inflation, the US economy may look great on paper, but really does not work for a lot of people.”
The narrator did not receive a response from Scott Galloway at his NYU email address or his team before publishing this video, despite reaching out for comment.
“because while I did reach out for comment to Prof. This NYU email address, as well as his team before publishing this video, I did not receive a response.”
To keep the main video watchable for a general YouTube audience, the narrator focused on Galloway's main arguments and main pieces of evidence, making judgment calls about which graphs about transfers from young to old were relevant to the main argument.
“Lastly, I want to note that to keep this video watchable for the general YouTube audience, I wanted to stick to Prof G's main arguments and main pieces of evidence that supported it. But of course, I went through all of his evidence, and for each graph about transfers from young to old, I made a judgment call whether or not there was any good and whether or not it was part of his main argument or just a side note.”
The analyst made a follow-up video on Nebula examining all of Galloway's wealth transfer graphs in detail, many of which are flawed or irrelevant, but didn't fit into the main YouTube video.
“However, if you really love debunking and want to get an exclusive insight into how I make these decisions which point to include and which to leave out, or if you want to make sure I did not cherry pick my points, I heartily recommend checking out my brief exclusive follow up video on Nebula. Economist nit picks Scott Galloway's anti boomer Ted talk a nerdy video in which I go through all of these graphs about wealth transfers from young to old, many of which are very flawed or irrelevant”