
This Boring Business Made him a Billionaire
What this covers
This is a conversation between host Shane Parrish and the founder of Filterbuy, who left Goldman Sachs to bootstrap an air-filter manufacturer that now does roughly $250 million in annual revenue. The filters cost about $2 to make and sell for around $12 on average, which leads him to call the company a logistics business rather than a product business. The early stretch covers his non-traditional route into Goldman, how he decides quickly, and the one-way versus two-way door distinction he credits to Jeff Bezos.
The business material is the most concrete. He argues that most "direct-to-consumer" brands are really contract-manufactured goods sold online, and that real DTC requires vertical integration. He separates branding, meaning ownership of search terms and customer identity, from marketing, and says ignoring Amazon means ignoring most buyers, though he fills those orders himself. On operations, he describes hitting a "ceiling of brute force," hiring executives who have already solved his problems, running the company on EOS, Traction, and Rockefeller Habits, and using values like bias to action as a coaching tool. He is openly anti-private-equity, thinks the HVAC industry has room for a transparent national brand, and admits to losing over $8 million on freight and HVAC acquisitions.
The last stretch turns personal and more contested. He prefers obsession to willpower and treats momentum as binary: a business is either gaining or losing it. He also warns against envy-driven lives and says money is not freedom, since freedom comes from being able to rebuild from zero. He describes a "crisis of self" in which he weighed selling against pursuing his mission of building the leading indoor-air-quality company, and a weekly executive coach as his main accountability structure. The episode closes on the traits he sees in successful entrepreneurs and the hardest moments of building.
Building a disproportionate outcome in life requires obsession, focus, and persistence—not money—and the entrepreneur must personally master the fundamentals of their business before scaling, while maintaining a clear mission that provides purpose beyond financial success.
- The limiting factor for most people starting businesses is not money but skills, curiosity, and willingness to compound knowledge over time
- An entrepreneur must understand their business deeply before hiring others to manage it, and cannot delegate system-building until they've built it themselves
- A clear mission and purpose are essential to sustaining obsession and maintaining the expansive mindset needed to build something big, more so than money itself
This asset isn't compiled yet
You're seeing its claims, ranked. Compile it to build the argument threads, weight them, and check each claim against your library — the full view.
Willpower is not a reliable strategy for sustained behavior change; obsession (where the goal becomes all-consuming) is superior to willpower because it requires no discipline—the behavior is intrinsically motivated.
“eventually everybody loses the battle with willpower willpower is not a strategy you know that's why kind of going back to your to your obsession point the people that are thinking are really successful are obsessed because um when you're obsessed with something you're not like you don't need willpower because it's just it's all consuming for you and that's what you do”
Branding and marketing are two distinct things; building a brand means owning specific search terms and customer identity (e.g., being Nike rather than competing on 'shoes'), which stands the test of time and creates less competition than generic product categories
“branding and marketing are two very different things to me um and you know we can go as deep as you'd like on it but I actually would like to start with the brand a little bit in that I from the very beginning was focused on building a brand... if you look at any big company that stands the test of time or has you know real value it's really the brand you know nobody is searching for or there are people that are searching for shoes and there are people that are searching for Nike you want to own the company that is Nike because then people you have no competition”
Pantaleo distinguishes between one-way doors and two-way doors in decision-making: two-way doors allow quick reversal and can be decided quickly with less caution, while one-way doors are irreversible decisions that require careful consideration and awareness
“Jeff Bezos has this concept of oneway doors versus two-way doors you know so you have to be like with two-way doors where you know that you can always get out of it very quickly like I make decisions quicker than anybody and then manage that and don't worry so much about it but I'm also hyper aware of those oneway doors where you need to be super careful doing something that you know you know is irrevocable more or less”
The limiting factor for most people starting a business or doing something new is not money, but rather the skills, curiosity, and willingness to learn and compound knowledge over time
“people always talk about money being the limiting factor in starting a business or doing something new I think that the reality is the limiting factor for most people is the skills and the Curiosity”
Millennials and younger generations want different things from service providers than older generations: transparent pricing (not haggling), professional service, trust from an established brand; the HVAC market operates in an old-school way and there is room for a national brand built around these values
“my belief is that the way that um Millennials and younger are um want to interact with their service people is very different than how the older generation did like generally now people do not want to haggle on price um they do not they want transparent pricing they don't want opaque pricing um lots of factors like that you know the HVAC service business is actually um operates in kind of an old school way and I think that there's room for a you know National brand that you know has the trust and the reputation um backing behind it”
Most so-called 'direct-to-consumer' brands are actually just brands using e-commerce as a sales channel; they manufacture products overseas with contract manufacturers, put their name on them, and use third-party fulfillment—this is not true vertical integration or DTC
“basically every direct to Consumer quote unquote brand that I'm aware of is effectively you know manufacturing their product with an with a overseas contract manufacturer um putting their name on it and and maybe they're doing some innovation in the product itself I don't know but they're put they're putting their their name on it and then they're um bringing it into the US and using third party fulfillment to to sell it and um that's not direct a consumer that's just a brand using e-commerce as a primary sales Channel”
Self-awareness about who you are and what you need to be fulfilled is the biggest cheat code; many people are trying to live someone else's life (driven by envy), which leads to misery; the modern influencer culture makes it easy to envy and want other people's lives
“ultimately really self-awareness and knowing like what you need out of life is a huge cheat code um I think a lot of people are trying to live somebody else's life and um I think and then they're wondering why they're unhappy and it's because they're trying to live somebody else's life and that's what's so dangerous about the modern influencer culture because it's so easy to want to live somebody else's life”
If you want to do anything big or have a disproportionate outcome in life, you have to be obsessed, because if not you're competing with somebody who is, and competing with obsessed people without obsession yourself is naive
“if you want to do anything big or if you want to have a disproportionate outcome in life you have to be obsessed because if not you're competing with somebody who is”
Pantaleo fulfills 100% of Filterby's Amazon orders himself, so he owns the customer data (address) but not the email or name (Amazon withholds that); however, he views it wrong to try to convert Amazon customers to direct-to-consumer sales—the goal should be selling wherever customers are
“we we fulfill 100% of our orders on Amazon so you get all the customer data I mean we get their address I mean we have to ship it to them do you get their email address and stuff no you don't get their email address but I know the question you're asking and I think it's the wrong question”
A brand takes a lifetime to build and one second to ruin, much like reputation; Pantaleo focused on branding from the beginning through packaging differentiation and product quality, rather than treating branding as an afterthought
“it takes a lifetime to build and it takes a second second to ruin you know um and that's just true but from the beginning you know we really focused on I really focused on branding and you know there's lots of nuances that that that go into that but as simple things like how we package all of our products”
Marketing without a good product or customer experience is wasteful, especially in high-CAC (customer acquisition cost) recurring revenue businesses where repeat purchases are essential; brand building must start with product excellence and customer experience
“marketing without a good product or without a good experience is completely wasteful um because especially if you're in a high um customer acquisition you know type business that that you need that recurring Revenue or that repeat Revenue in order to be able to to make it into a business um you have to have a good product and a good customer experience so it so it so a brand all starts with that”
Momentum is essential to life and business; you are either progressing or regressing, never in a steady state; loss of momentum is difficult to recover from because it's easy to let momentum atrophy and much harder to rebuild than to maintain
“momentum is everything um and it's such an intangible thing at the same time in life you know and in anything um you're either progressing or you're regressing you know there's really no um there's there's really no steady state in reality... you either are improving and building on something day in day out or you're declining”
Pantaleo positions himself as anti-private equity because PE-backed companies lack clear vision, focus on financial engineering and exit strategy rather than long-term value, and are miserable places to work; most management hires come from PE companies and describe hating it
“I consider myself anti- private Equity... they're really is no Clear Vision no clear Direction you know they're just looking to optimize to um Financial engineer to be able to sell it to the next next person up I mean like not going to say that's all private Equity but that's a lot of private equity and the people that are working for them um are miserable often times”
Humans are wired to need purpose and meaning at work; people who have received money without earning it suffer from scarcity mindset and misery because they lack a reason for existing; fulfillment comes from purpose and contribution, not material wealth
“we as human beings need to um have a purpose in life and have a reason to to wake up every day... I've seen that you know both at high level um executive type people all the way down to um people that work on manufactur ing lines that really take their job seriously and really find meaning and fulfillment”
Pantaleo compares people who work for others to those who build their own enterprises: working for someone else doesn't build the confidence that entrepreneurship does because you're relying on external validation rather than creating your own outcomes
“I see so many people so many friends even like that from my finance days that you know you look at and make they made a lot of money money um on a relative basis and um some of them you know still make a lot of money but don't have the the the confidence and I think it's because when you're working for somebody else or relying on other people to you know pay you or validate you that you never really get the confidence that you can build as an entrepreneur when you're kind of out there making things happen on your own”
Pantaleo thinks most people don't spend time thinking about what they actually need out of life to be fulfilled; this self-exploration is critical but widely neglected
“I think it's the thing that most people don't spend any time actually thinking about”
Money does not equal freedom; freedom comes from having the skills and confidence to rebuild anything from zero; the speaker has found more real freedom as a bootstrapped founder controlling his entire business than he could ever find in high-paying employment at Goldman or elsewhere
“I always push back so much on people that um think that money in and of itself gives freedom I've seen so many um examples where it's actually quite the opposite”
Successful entrepreneurship is not a single 'aha moment' but a slow evolution and compounding of skills and knowledge over a long period with consistent focus that is difficult for people to hold both aspects simultaneously—that it takes a long time to compound to something meaningful.
“people are always looking for that cheat code or you know that that aha moment that's going to then change their life forever and you know if that happens for people I've certainly never experienced it um for me it's more of a slow Evolution um and a compounding of skills and a compounding of knowledge over a long period of time um but with a consistent Focus that's long-term that that that is immutable”
Core personal principles that Humphrey lives by are: (1) Focus on a singular mission, not distracted by shiny objects, (2) Persistence and patience—things take longer than expected, (3) Resilience—belief that all business problems are solvable, (4) Accountability—building external accountability structures.
“the very first one which I recommend for everyone but I I whenever I say these things is really a reminder to myself more more than it is advice although I think it is great advice but it's Focus time and again in my life um or really as an entrepreneur I should say um is I I've had the tendency to get distracted by a shiny object”
Filterby's core values include bias to action; these values are used as a coaching mechanism with employees—when an employee makes a mistake, the conversation reframes it around the value (e.g., 'we have bias to action, so what additional action could you have taken?') rather than accepting excuses
“biased action is one of our core values um in it's core value that I have in my life and um sometimes like if an employee makes a mistake like that it's like oh Joe didn't call me back so therefore I couldn't get this do this thing right like you know that would be an excuse that somebody may come and give you but then you're like okay how do I actually um coach you on this... if you have a core principle or of core value of bias to action then you can say well you know we at filterby have a bias to action and like and what that would mean is in this example um you need to call him if he didn't call you back”
Filterby manufactures air filters for about $2 and sells them on average for $12; the business is fundamentally a logistics company, not a product manufacturing company, because cost optimization in delivery is the core competency and competitive advantage
“we manufacture an air filter for about $2 and sell it on average for 12 um the you know unfortunately that's not all um just profit between the two there's a lot of logistics involved in getting that product to the End customer but because we've optimized all of that you know I know that there's basically nobody that can compete with us um on price”
Humphrey had a 'crisis of self' about 2 years ago (triggered by working with executive coach) where he asked whether to sell Filterby at $250M+ revenue and retire, or continue with mission to build the world's leading indoor air quality company; he chose the latter because anything less would leave him miserable.
“about two years ago and really when I started working with Dr gner I was you know having a little bit of a um crisis of Self in that you know what do I want out of life um could sell the business and um you know have more money than I could ever spend or my children could ever spend um and be I would have been 40 years old or just about to turn 40 could have hundreds of millions of dollars”
Humphrey's most critical accountability structure is meeting with an executive coach (Dr. Gainer) weekly for ~1 hour; this forces him to articulate problems, examine root causes, and come to conclusions through conversation rather than staying in self-deception, and is indispensable for his business growth.
“the most important thing that I get from her and I would recommend from for anybody um to consider is first of all I'm a bootstrapped entrepreneur I own my whole business I don't have a board of directors and so I don't have accountability that's baked in right and I ultimately have the power to make effectively any decision within my business and you know and and that's great super important for me but also accountability is very important and having her in my life was me forcing that accountability”
Lifestyle creep is a real danger for people who rely on a single income stream (e.g., finance professionals making millions per year); when that income dries up, they lack the skills or confidence to rebuild, and they're trapped by a lifestyle they can't afford—the solution is to build undeniable skills and confidence that you can earn your way back, not to restrict spending
“you wake up one day and maybe um you know you're you're not as marketable as you as you were before and you don't have any other skills and you don't have the muscle of building um those new skills um and then you're in trouble”
Section 179 tax code allows accelerated depreciation of equipment purchases; if you buy $1M of trucks, you can write off $1M against that year's taxable income, effectively borrowing from banks against future tax savings; the policy is designed to incentivize capital investment
“in US tax code is a bit of an aside there is a section that basically allows for accelerated depreciation and what that means is that if you bought a million dollars of equipment like trucks then you could write off that million dollars against your taxes in that year um oh wow and it's actually it actually still exists currently this year you can only do 60% with Trump back in office my guess is it'll go back up to 100%”
Operating systems for companies (like Traction and Rockefeller Habits) vary in rigidity and approach to distributing responsibility, but the most important commonality across all of them is having a clear vision and mission that cascades down to all employees
“you have some that are way more rigid and others that are um more pushing um responsibility down down through your teams um the thing that I think is actually most important or the thing that was most impactful for me that I took away from all of these operating systems was it all starts with a Clear Vision and a clear mission for the business that then has to roll down to all of the people that are working for that business”
That expansive mindset and the ability to do big things requires built confidence, which Pantaleo argues is one of the most important foundations for entrepreneurial success and accomplishment
“that's really the the mindset that it takes to do something big I think and you know that just comes from building the confidence and that muscle over time that you get more and more confidence as you build”
Filterby manufactures 300 different standard air filter sizes and has a team of 50-70 people dedicated to manufacturing custom filters, ship them same-day, allowing them to serve customers with non-standard sizes that competitors cannot offer
“we manufacture 300 different sizes um as standard and we have a team you know in aggregate of 50 or 70 people that make custom filters all day every day so like if you have a crazy size filter which in the US is quite common you know that you don't have a you can't go to the store and buy and if it's not one of even the 300 sizes that we have then we will make it for you and still ship it same day um so you get it next day or two days depending on where you are”
Pantaleo's business model is limited not by manufacturing but by the entrepreneur's ability to understand all business functions; hiring people who don't understand your business well enough to build systems is almost impossible when smaller, so the entrepreneur must do it themselves
“if you really want to do something big and if you want to do something different that there's not an established playbook for which is which is what we have done then it's your it's your responsibility as the entrepreneur to go and figure all of that out”
Pantaleo burned all his boats by going public with his personal brand and commitment to building Filterby into the world's leading indoor air quality company, deliberately eliminating any alternative options to force complete commitment and accountability
“a big motivation for me going so public with my personal brand in the last couple months is really about burning the boats behind me because you know I'm on a mission to build the rules leading indoor air quality company and you know I don't want there to be any other option for me”
Obsession in Pantaleo's lived experience means thinking about the business 7 days a week, 52 weeks a year, without hobbies, while maintaining good relationships with family—requiring both complete commitment and deliberate prioritization of personal connections
“I have own filter by for 12 years more or less and there's not a day I don't wake up um and it's the first thing I'm thinking about s days a week you know if I go on vacation there there's there's no you know not checking in or no no not thinking about it”
It took Pantaleo 3-4 years to achieve profitable manufacturing of air filters; before that, it would have been cheaper to buy filters from a large manufacturer and repackage them, but he persisted because he knew scale required vertical integration of manufacturing
“it really took me three to four years to get to the point where we could manufacture a product profitably and what I mean by that is until that three or four year period it would have been cheaper for me to buy the product we were selling from a large manufacturer of air filters and just repackage it”
For the first 3 years of building Filterby, Pantaleo traveled from New York to Alabama every Monday morning, drove 2 hours from Atlanta to Talladega, and stayed Monday through Friday building manufacturing during the day while doing programming, marketing, and finance work at night, while his wife worked as a radiologist at NYU
“I was living in New York City at the time my wife was a or still is a radiologist at NYU and um so we were living here and I would travel um every Monday morning to Alabama I actually kept a car in Atlanta at the you know parking go where I would um go there a Monday morning and then drive from Atlanta to Talladega it's about a two-hour drive and I would stay there Monday through Friday and come back”
Pantaleo is best when building new systems and frameworks and getting them solidified to a point where others can manage and improve them; this is his core strength and operating mode
“I think that I'm at my best when I'm out there you know building new systems new Frameworks and getting them started to the point that and and solidified to the point that then I can bring in other people to actually manage them and improve them going forward”
The second key thing Dr. Gunner provided is helping Pantaleo become self-aware about what he deeply knows is the right answer, because people are easily fooled by themselves and believe things they want to believe rather than truth; talking it out weekly helps access gut knowledge
“the second part of it is having somebody to bounce around things that are maybe going on in my head and help me to become self-aware about you know what I deep down know the right answer is because I think so often we know in our gut and like the actions that we need to be taking... the easiest person to fool is yourself... we know in our gut like the actions that we need to be taking... by talking it out with her every week then it allows me to get to that truth um and make those decisions quicker”
Values must be authentic and lived by the founder first; if they are aspirational but not actually practiced, they become meaningless; Pantaleo is willing to part ways with high performers who are inconsistent with stated values, which signals true commitment
“the key is they have to really be true like you can't just make them up I think that so many people go through the exercise and it's aspirational and it's great to be aspirational but if you're not willing to actually live by that you yourself first but then also you know if you have somebody that maybe is a high performer but is but is clearly not consistent with your values you have to be willing to part ways with them”
Pantaleo has been an entrepreneur since age 10 and developed online business and marketing skills over decades through side hustles (computer assembly and sales on eBay, affiliate marketing, drop-shipping office supplies) before founding Filterby
“I've been an entrepreneur since I was probably 10 years old and I was born in 1983 and you know really came of age in the 90s when the internet was just starting to come up... I was basically assembling computers and selling them on eBay and my my eBay screen name was um momentum Corp”
About 60% of the revenue from Pantaleo's drop-shipping office supplies business (MyOfficeDelivered, $6.5M in 2009) came from air filters from a small company in Crozat, Alabama called FiltersNow, which planted the seed for founding Filterby
“2009 sold you know $6.5 million do or so of office supplies primarily on Amazon and when I looked at the actual underlying data of it about um 60% of that was either air filters from a small company in crola Alabama called filters now or ink cartridges”
Pantaleo shut down MyOfficeDelivered around 2009 when his finance career accelerated because he couldn't give both ventures the energy they required, illustrating the importance of focus and inability to split effort between two growing businesses
“the financial crisis is ended up being great for me from a career perspective and I got promoted and my career really took off and I ended up shutting down that business because I didn't have the the energy to do to continue to do both so I I shut it down”
3M and competitors primarily distribute through retail (Walmart, Costco) rather than direct-to-consumer or online; they ship product through retailer distribution networks, adding multiple steps and costs to their supply chain, whereas Filterby delivers directly
“3M you know best I can tell andan they can they can refute it if they want but like B they mostly sell through um retail so places like Walmart Costco and whatnot and like that is their Major Distribution Channel... when they sell online they're basically doing it through Amazon and Walmart and and you know other retailers which means they're effectively Trucking in product to a distribution center then that distribution is taking it off the truck un taking it out of the Case Case um packed boxes likely then moving it around the country to their distribution Network then putting it back on the shelf and then picking it again and putting it in another box and sending it to an end user all of those are steps that we do not have in our supply chain”
Pantaleo had a critical breaking point when manufacturing laminator machines failed due to humidity in Alabama; the cold glue wasn't drying, causing 50% of raw materials to be wasted daily; he found a hot glue laminator in Indiana, spent his last $55K, drove overnight to get it, and trained the team on Saturday morning
“there was a May in Alabama when it was super humid and it was super humid in our manufacturing facility and the glue was not drying... the rolls were ultimately getting stuck to each other because it hadn't dried properly and it became unusable and so we were wasting about half of our raw material any given day”
The laminator crisis was Pantaleo's turning point; afterward, he built the muscle and confidence to handle larger problems; he now knows that any problem is solvable and that he can step up to meet any challenge, which is one of his superpowers
“that was really the turning point for us because after that we things started really coming together um but you know that was two and a half years into my entrepreneurial journey... I would not have had the financial or quite frankly mental staying power to continue to do it it if that um if I had not been able to find that solution”
Some of Pantaleo's confidence and determination come from his nature and upbringing (he was born with certain traits and had loving, supportive parents); he doesn't claim these are universal or recommendable to everyone
“where does that confidence come from you know some of it is you're born with it probably if I if I'm honest I mean I I don't know the alternative I I'm just uniquely determined in a lot of ways... I had two loving wonderful parents that um you know you know I think were very helpful for that”
People who are information gatherers and hands-on builders develop more confidence over time because they actually understand how systems work and can see how to turn those systems in their favor; doing leads to confidence
“the more you know how things work the uh more conf you become that you're able to kind of turn the system in your favor I guess you know so I think that there's there's a lot of Truth in that I mean like I I definitely have proven that to myself time and time again”
Charlie Munger is Pantaleo's greatest virtual mentor; Munger taught that the world is driven by envy, not greed; envy is more destructive because it makes people want what others have rather than what they actually need
“Charlie Monger probably my greatest virtual Mentor had is saying that you know the the the um thing that drives the world isn't greed it's Envy it's Envy Envy is the the real problem because people um always want what somebody else's ha has”
Key lessons from Goldman Sachs that shaped Pantaleo's entrepreneurial approach: the ability to make decisions quickly, own those decisions completely, and manage the risk associated with them, rather than second-guessing or reversing course
“it's really the ability to make a decision quickly and then own that decision and manage the risk of that decision... when I fast forward to my business career like one of the things that I think that I excel at is making decisions quickly and owning those decisions and not um you know second guessing or not kind of like once I make a decision I make a decision and I and I move on”
Because of vertical integration and operational excellence, Filterby can operate profitably at a price point where competitors could not, giving Pantaleo the staying power in intent-based marketing to dominate all relevant search terms without competitors being able to match spend
“I knew that because of that I had the kind of staying power from a marketing perspective and an intent-based marketing um perspective to suck all the oxygen out of the rest of the market and I did that even when it was hard early on but I knew that if you if you were searching for an air filter something related that we needed to be the obvious choice based off of the you know taking over all the ad spots”
Pantaleo experienced a crisis when his wife (unaware she was choosing incorrectly) ordered Filterby air filters on Amazon instead of directly, which taught him that trying to convert Amazon customers to DTC is a fool's errand and he stopped spending energy on it
“there's a funny story um she'll maybe get mad at me for telling it but I will about 2 years ago we needed some air filters at our house and my wife actually ordered our air filters on Amazon and it really irritated me at the time because I said how in the world why in the world would you go on Amazon and buy our air filters but for her she was just doing a chore and she was looking for the easiest way to or she wanted to solve that problem and and we buy a lot of stuff on Amazon and so she just went and clicked order on Amazon”
Pantaleo realized that he had not articulated a clear mission statement and company values until this year (2024), even though the business had grown to $250M+; he spent 2-3 months on this exercise and now considers values the most important element of organizational structure
“I think one of the things that we lacked as a business and might big takeaway from doing all the research around these operating systems was ultimately the operating system doesn't matter as much as like like what are you looking to accomplish... we had not done a great job of articulating that to our employees... I never really put any thought into that... the first step for me after doing this research was really building out a mission statement and our values and I spent two or three months really soul searching on that”
The HVAC acquisition failed because Pantaleo moved too quickly without building an operational playbook first; he has since learned to build playbooks internally before scaling through acquisition, which is why he's now building FilterBy HVAC Solutions methodically before rolling it out nationally
“I had not built my own operational Playbook yet that I was was comfortable with going out and doing it scale I hadn't really done the work to to deserve that yet I was just trying to buy somebody else's and for me at least that just doesn't work”
On his deathbed, Pantaleo believes he will regret only the things he didn't try or failed to attempt due to fear; this prospect of regret drives his decision-making and is why he is willing to go public with his ambitious goals, despite initial fear
“when I'm making a decision or deciding to go into something like um am I going to regret not trying it and so like that's why this personal brand thing I was Private for so long and I I really was scared of of going out and being so public... I know that if I Didn't Do It um on my deathbed I would say to myself oh I wonder only if and that is just not acceptable to me”
Pantaleo no longer wants to be considered a 'direct-to-consumer brand' because the term is limiting; he wants to be an 'indoor air quality brand' that operates across multiple channels (retail, online, commercial) without channel exclusivity
“I actually have no interest in being any anymore I do not want to be considered a director consumer brand I want to be an indoor air quality brand I mean that that's really what I want to be because I think direct to Consumer is so limiting um and I think you know words and Cate categorization matters”
He made the decision to open FilterBuy's Ogden, Utah manufacturing facility in May 2020 because FedEx capped trailer capacity from their Talladega location during COVID demand surge, and Amazon stopped third-party seller warehouse inbound—this forced geographic diversification from a position of scarcity, which was a one-way door that unlocked the trajectory from $70M revenue in 2019 to $250M in 2024
“about two to three weeks into that process of of working with it Amazon stopped um third party Sellers from sending product into their warehouses and at the exact same time FedEx made the decision to cap the number of trailers that we were able to ship from our talladega location because they were getting overloaded basically saying you know we can't take any more business and I was faced with the decision um do I either expand U my Geographic footprint”
When hiring, look for people who have recently solved the exact problem you're trying to solve; historically Pantaleo made the mistake of hiring aspirationally based on energy and potential, but this repeatedly burned him and he has shifted to hiring based on proven, recent relevant experience
“I want somebody who's done this at 100 because you're trying to build a bill ion Dollar business... I realized you need to find people that have done the task that you're looking to get done today or before at like maybe it Rhymes maybe it's not exactly but like if you want to hire a CFO for example um I want to find somebody that has done the things that I know we are lacking before”
Pantaleo intends to build a nationwide HVAC service business, which currently does not exist; his benchmark is whether the business would be effective if he ran a Super Bowl ad, since it would need to reach all viewers; the market is currently fragmented among mom-and-pop operators without national consolidation
“my intention is to build a nationwide HFA service business which in the US does not currently exist and so my Benchmark for that is could I um if I wanted to run a superbow ad and have it be effective because it it touches every all everybody that would be watching it right that's what a nationwide HVAC service business is”
Filterby's original business model was built almost exclusively on intent-based marketing (Google, Amazon, Bing searches for air filter products); the strategy was to suck all the oxygen out of the market by dominating all relevant search terms and ad positions
“the business originally was built almost exclusively on what I would call intent-based marketing and so you know basically if you search for air filter or any iteration of an air filter like 20 x 20 X1 air filter... then you know you're are going to see us and that's been the case for about a decade early on my strategy was I wanted to suck all the oxygen out of the market”
Pantaleo spends most of his marketing budget ($38-42M annually) on intent-based ad campaigns he launched 10-12 years ago, which have changed little over the years; most money is still on ad campaigns he built from the beginning of the business
“our budget next year is $42 million for our Marketing in general so like we spend about it's a $42 million line item for us at least going to next year I think it was $38 million this year so it's a big line item for us and we managed most of it internally but that but what's so interesting still to me my marketing team may not like like to hear me say it but it's like most of that money is still built on ad um campaigns that I effectively launched 12 years ago when own over over that period or 10 years ago”
70% of air filtration is for commercial use; 70% of air filters purchased are for commercial settings, but most online retailers and many consumer-facing brands ignore the commercial market, limiting themselves to residential demand
“70% of air filtration is actually commercial um and so 70% of air filters that are purchased are purchased for a commercial setting and so I think online one of the reasons why we have been able to gain so much market share is because you know a lot of those commercial people see that”
Humphrey experienced a major Amazon Prime Day technical outage in summer 2024 that cost $2M+ in incremental revenue; despite this setback, he continued executing fundamentals and the business returned to over-indexing performance within months, demonstrating the importance of momentum as a manageable muscle.
“we had a big Prime deal that was running and by some glitch of the system um I got a call at 3:00 in the morning um from someone at Amazon that deal was not running and um they were looking at fixing it I um got up started monitoring it and by 9:00 in the morning like still nobody could purchase any of our product that was on a deal on Amazon and I had to kill I had to kill that deal”
In 2008, during the financial crisis at Goldman, the speaker started an affiliate marketing side business using Craigslist spam + Vietnamese team to drive traffic to StubHub and made ~$500K that year, proving to himself that there was significant money in affiliate/online marketing—this seed experience later informed FilterBuy's go-to-market strategy
“in 2007 I had just moved to the trading desk from my economics research desk and um that was the beginning of the financial crisis and I saw a lot of turmoil and saw a lot of people around me starting to get fired and I was convinced I was going to lose my job”
The speaker's next marketing frontier is top-of-funnel brand awareness (moving beyond intent-based search advertising); FilterBuy is investing heavily in brand awareness campaigns including monthly giveaways (e.g., Jeep giveaway), personal brand building by the founder, and recruiting others to represent the FilterBuy brand to different demographics
“one of my big goals personally you know like I really am going all in on brand and on building the worlds leading into air quality company and we're getting into the service business and doing some other things and so for me the next kind of Step of marketing is building um topof The Funnel brand awareness”
Customer acquisition cost in HVAC services is very high (e.g., $500 per customer for replacement units); Pantaleo's advantage is he already has relationships with 8 million homes, reducing CAC through brand awareness and existing trust rather than needing to rebuild customer relationships
“customer acquisition cost in the HVAC service bace is very high I mean um you may be paying $500 for a new customer um on average if you're looking for a for a replacement or what not of an HC unit but that's an area where we at filter by Excel is something that I'm obsessed with”
Pantaleo took a non-traditional path to Goldman Sachs by excelling as an economics student, writing a paper on predicting currency crises using a diffusion index, which impressed professors who forwarded it to someone within Goldman's economics research department, leading to his hiring through the back door
“I went to the George Washington University and about my sophomore junior year I really decided I wanted to go into finance and the premier place to work was Goldman Sachs... there's no pathway from the George Washington University to Goldman Sachs at least not at the time... I studied economics and statistics in college... I did a paper on predicting currency crisis um using a diffusion index kind of geeky geeky thing and my professors were really impressed by it and kind of ended up forwarding it to somebody within Goldman”
Despite tradeoffs, Pantaleo believes he likely spends more time with his children than many people who work less, because he prioritizes that time and is home by 6:30pm and in the mornings before school; time prioritization beats time availability
“I mean I think I spend more time with my kids and a lot of people that work way less probably and but it's because I prioritize that it's it's important to me”
Pantaleo has a scar on his finger from almost cutting it off on the hot glue laminator machine when training the team on Saturday morning; he views this as a physical reminder of the transformative experience
“you won't be able to see it here but I actually have a a scar on my finger where I almost cut off my finger on that um machine you know when I was training them as I made a mistake and and like I literally almost cut off my finger that Saturday morning when I got back so I have the scar to to remind myself of of that experience”
Humphrey was determined to work at Goldman Sachs from sophomore year onward despite not having an Ivy League background or family finance connections, and he manifested this through sheer focus and obsession, treating it as something he had idolized and made happen in his life.
“you said you felt like an outsider at Goldman why did you stay so long well I'm stubborn and honestly I had manifested my job at Goldman in a way like I really it's something that for years I had idolized and made happen in my life you know I didn't go to an Ivy League school I didn't come from a rich Northeastern type family that had you know family and private equity and all the traditional feeders that lead to a finance career normally”
60% of product searches start on Amazon; any brand that chooses to ignore Amazon is leaving 60% of potential buyers on the table and is naive to ignore this channel
“60% of product searches start on Amazon that's just a fact so like if you you know are selling a product that um you you know for whatever reason say oh I don't want to sell on Amazon then you are basically ignoring 60% of your potential buyers”
Pantaleo has scaled Filterby from zero to $250 million in annual revenue and intends to take it to a billion dollars plus in the next 5 to 10 years, positioning it as the world's leading indoor air quality company
“I scale from 0 to $250 million a year and in the next 5 to 10 years I intend to take that to a billion dollar plus”
84% of retail transactions still happen in physical stores; any strategy that ignores retail and focuses only on online sales is short-sighted and leaving significant customer access on the table
“84% of um retail transactions still happen in store so you know I can sit here and say oh I'm just going to sell online because I want to be a pure director consumer um company um and that's fine but to me that um is very short-sided and you're losing a lot of potential um customers in that process”
Pantaleo started a freight business during COVID because freight was expensive and scarce, he believed he could optimize it, and there was tax benefit from equipment depreciation (Section 179 acceleration); he bought 50-60 trucks for $6-7M and operated them unprofitably before liquidating in late 2023 for a $3-4M loss
“in Co um sry in 2020 Freight became um very hard to source and it was very expensive um because there was just so much demand to to to move this stuff and again a bit hubristic I would argue if I was looking back at it um I thought well you know I'm so good at this business thing right how do how hard could uh um running a Freight business be be and I have a lot of um demand for Freight so I can just do my own Freight”
Pantaleo hired his first marketing employee 4 years ago (8 years into the business) and handled all marketing for the first 8 years; he recently hired a CMO approximately 18 months ago; he views management-level hiring as something he only recently learned to do well
“there's one person there that I hired four years ago and they were my first marketing hire so like I'd had some some people that it kind of helped along the way... the there were a few other people that came in and out but I effectively did all of the marketing for the first eight years”
Pantaleo has been married to his high school sweetheart since he was 17 years old (she was 16); they have been together for about 24 years and have three young children; his wife doesn't try to change him and trusts him completely
“I actually married my high school sweetheart we've been um together since we were 17 years old actually she was 16 I was 17 and we've been together that whole time um and you know 20 20 four years now I guess and um you know I got three young children and I have a great relationship with them”
Pantaleo launched Filterby in Walmart 2.5 months before this conversation (approximately late 2024), selling across 505 Walmart locations as a test before national expansion
“here I am we as laed in 505 Walmarts and um really have a big retail strategy going forward”
Filterby is now selling 10,000 to 20,000 units per week in Walmart during the test phase, representing 10,000-20,000 new potential customers to the brand weekly and a major customer acquisition channel
“for a brand we we now are selling between 10 and 20,000 units a week in Walmart and that's 10 to 20,000 new potential new to Brand customers a week that we are reaching”
Filterby does all marketing internally; they work with one agency for some ad account management on autopilot, but Pantaleo built all intent-based ad campaigns and manages most internal marketing functions
“it's mostly internal we do have an agency that we work with that um I hired a few years ago that does manage some of our ad accounts that are more on autopilot but it's just keeping best practices and keeping you know things together like I built out all of our like all of our intent-based ad campaigns”