
86% Plunge: China’s Stock Market Woes | Can China’s BRICS Kill the USD? | India-China
What this covers
This is a 15-minute solo briefing from Tony of China Update, split into three parts: China's equity market and the surge in share buybacks, the run-up to the BRICS summit in Kazan, and the India-China border agreement. The market segment starts with a history. Stock trading reached Chinese households only in the early 1990s, and it has never been a dependable way to build wealth. The market is volatile and tightly controlled, and it tracks the real economy only loosely. Households put most of their money into property, about 70% of assets, which is why the housing crisis hurts as much as it does. Mainland IPO proceeds were down 86% by mid-September, and buybacks hit a record 235 billion RMB, more than double last year's figure, as part of Beijing's largest stimulus since the pandemic.
The buyback policy is contested. Michael Pettis is cited arguing that it lifts prices briefly but adds leverage to an already indebted economy and ties balance sheets to low interest rates, as in Japan. The video also cites a Goldman Sachs estimate of more than 2 trillion RMB returned to shareholders annually.
The BRICS section asks whether the bloc can challenge the dollar. Tony's answer is mostly no, at least for now. Members have moved away from a shared currency and toward payment rails, led by CIPS), which has 142 direct participants against more than 11,000 banks on Swift). He notes that the RMB's share of global reserves fell to 2.3%, and that nearly a third of central banks plan to buy more gold. The framing is "non-West" rather than "anti-West."
The last segment covers the patrolling and disengagement deal on the Line of Actual Control), announced by Vikram Misri. It covers the 2020 clashes, the troop buildups that followed, India's restrictions on Chinese apps and investment, and the caution that remains in New Delhi.
China is deploying stock buybacks and international financial infrastructure (BRICS, CIPS, RMB internationalization) to address domestic economic weakness and position itself as an alternative to US-dominated global finance, while simultaneously reducing border tensions with India ahead of the BRICS summit.
- Stock buybacks reach record 235 billion RMB in 2024 as government stimulus, but mask underlying economic slowdown (GDP 4.6% vs 5% target)
- BRICS expansion and new payment systems aim to create non-Western financial alternatives, though dollar dominance remains secure near-term
- India-China border agreement signals strategic coordination within BRICS despite historical tensions
This asset isn't compiled yet
You're seeing its claims, ranked. Compile it to build the argument threads, weight them, and check each claim against your library — the full view.
Stock trading is a relatively new phenomenon for Chinese households, introduced in the early 1990s as part of economic reform, but has not proven to be a reliable wealth-generating vehicle because the market is volatile, heavily controlled, most competitive Chinese companies were unwilling or unable to be listed domestically, and there is little correlation between market performance and China's economy.
“stock trading is a relatively new game in town for Chinese households the People's Republic of China introduced stock trading in the early 1990s part of the country's economic reform experiment now there are more than 200 million trading accounts in China stock market and virtually all are individual investors China's stock exchanges have not turned turned out to be wealth generating Ventures for the Chinese public however who have largely avoided the market because it was too volatile because the stock market was heavily controlled most of China's most competitive companies were largely unable or unwilling to be listed in their home country there was little correlation between the Market's performance and China's economy”
BRICS members have turned their attention away from pursuing a shared currency and toward new cross-border payment systems with the goal of creating a more multi-polar financial system, with China leading this effort by accelerating development of the Cross-border Interbank Payment System (CIPS).
“bricks members have turned their attention away from a shared currency and towards new crossborder payment systems with the goal of creating a more multi-polar financial system China has led this effort by accelerating its development of the crossborder interbank payment system cips”
In Q4 2023, the share of the RMB in global foreign currency reserves dropped to 2.3% from its peak of 2.8% in 2022, despite Beijing's active support of RMB liquidity through swap lines, as reserve managers may be perceiving the RMB as geopolitically risky due to China's economy, position on Russia-Ukraine war, and increased tensions with the US.
“in the last quarter of 20123 the share of GB in global foreign currency reserves dropped to 2.3% from its peak of 2.8% in 2022 despite beijing's active support of JB liquidity through swap lines Reserve managers might be perceiving the G andb as a geopolitically risky currency because of concerns about China's economy beijing's position on the Russia Ukraine war and increased tensions with the US and G7”
Michael Pettis, professor of Finance at Beijing University, argues that stock buyback stimulus will boost stock market prices in the short term but increases corporate leverage in an already highly leveraged economy, reinforces price volatility, and makes corporate and local government balance sheets dependent on keeping interest rates low, similar to Japan's situation.
“as peing University professor of Finance Michael pentis explains quote this will certainly boost stock market prices in the short term but it also has two other effects first it increases corporate leverage in an economy where there is already an awful lot of Leverage and of course leverage reinforces price movements both up and down second it makes Chinese corporate and local government balance sheets even more dependent on changes in interest rates and as we saw in the case of Japan this can put pressure on the central bank to keep interest rates low in quote”
The surge in share repurchases is part of Beijing's broader economic stimulus efforts, the largest since the COVID-19 pandemic, aimed at rejuvenating China's Equity Market which has experienced a sharp decline over the past five years.
“The surge in repurchases is part of beijing's Border economic stimulus efforts the largest since the co9 pandemic aimed at rejuvenating China's Equity Market over the past month”
China's strategy for BRICS includes leveraging the organization to form alternative financial infrastructure separate from the US-led West, as evidenced by official Chinese messaging about reforming the international financial and monetary system and advancing RMB internationalization.
“State media ran with this theme too as well as China's strategy to leverage the loose organization to form alternative Financial infrastructure from that of the US lead West”
Negotiations around an intra-BRICS system of payments are in early stages, with members having reached bilateral and plurilateral agreements on cross-border wholesale central bank digital currency and currency swap agreements, though these agreements may be difficult to scale due to regulatory and liquidity issues.
“negotiations around an intra bricks syst of payments are in the early stages but the members have reached bilateral and plurilateral agreements with one another with a focus on crossb wholesale Central Bank digital currency and currency swap agreements these Agreements are likely difficult to scale due to Regulatory and liquidity issues but may form the basis for a currency exchange platform over time”
India has taken a hard stance against Chinese influence since the 2020 conflict, banning numerous Chinese apps and imposing strict restrictions on Chinese foreign investment, with some Indian business people arguing this is hampering the country's manufacturing growth.
“India has also taken a hard stance against Chinese influence in the wake of the 2020 conflict it has banned numerous Chinese apps and imposed strict restrictions on Chinese foreign investment with some Indian business people saying it is hampering the country's manufacturing growth”
Chinese households have invested primarily in real estate rather than equities, with real estate comprising approximately 70% of China's household assets, making the current housing crisis especially destructive for household wealth and confidence.
“people invested in real estate which makes up 70% of China's household assets as such the current years long housing crisis has been especially destructive for household wealth and confidence”
India and China have a long history of border tensions including a major war in 1962, with the LAC stretching for nearly 3,500 kilometers across rugged and high-altitude Himalayan terrain that has remained a persistent geopolitical flashpoint.
“India and China have a long history of Border tensions including a major War in 1962 the Lac which stretches for nearly 3,500 km across some of the most rugged and highest train in the Himalayas remains a hot spot for geopolitical conflict”
Both India and China have engaged in infrastructure development along their border, with China building villages in Tibet and India launching its 'vibrant Villages' program, reflecting broader competition over border control and symbolic sovereignty.
“both countries have engaged in infrastructure development along the border with China building villages in Tibet and India launching its so-called vibrant Villages program”
The Modi government has insisted on deescalation at the border as a prerequisite for normalizing relations with China, though specifics on the area covered by the new agreement are not yet clear, suggesting ongoing caution despite the agreement announcement.
“the Modi government has insisted on deescalation at the border as a prerequisite for normalizing relations with China while specifics on the area covered by the new agreement are not yet clear this development could lead to a significant easing of Border tensions”
Share buybacks on China's Mainland stock exchanges have reached an all-time high in 2024, totaling 235 billion RMB, more than double last year's figure of 107 billion RMB and surpassing the previous record of 133 billion RMB in 2022.
“share buybacks on China's Mainland stock exchanges have reached an all-time high in 2024 driven by a government push to revive the country's struggling stock market by encouraging companies to return cash to shareholders”
BRICS members are reiterating that any new global payment system they develop will be 'non-West' rather than 'anti-West', intending to provide alternative choices in global payment systems rather than directly challenge Western systems.
“the brics members have been reiterating that the global payment system brics will develop will not be anti-west instead it will be non-west the bricks members just want to provide the world with more and better choices when it comes to global payment systems”
CIPS direct participants can clear transactions without relying on Swift or the dollar, though transactional indicators of RMB use may be under-counting actual value of transactions.
“since the direct CPS participants could clear transactions without relying on Swift or the dollar transactional indicators of YB use may be under counting the actual value”
Chinese companies both onshore and offshore have collectively returned more than 2 trillion RMB to shareholders annually through buybacks and dividends over the past 3 years according to Goldman Sachs estimates.
“Goldin Sachs estimates that Chinese companies both onshore and offshore have collectively returned more than 2 trillion R&B to shareholders annually through BuyBacks and dividends over the past 3 years”
Nearly one-third of all central banks plan on increasing their gold reserves in 2024, indicating a broad move by reserve managers toward gold as a hedge against geopolitical risk and currency instability, representing a shift away from both dollars and alternative currencies like the Euro.
“nearly a third of all central banks plan on increasing their gold reserves in 2024 while the Euro was once considered a competitor to the Dollar's International role it continues to lag far behind and is weakening as an attractive Reserve currency the 2022 sanctions on Russia signaled to reserve managers that the Euro exposed them to similar geopolitical risks as the dollar those looking to Dr risk away from the dollar have turned to Gold”
IPOs on mainland China have plummeted dramatically, with total amounts raised by mid-September 2024 down 86% compared to the previous year, raising only 5.5 billion RMB, marking the lowest amount for any comparable period excluding 2023 when regulators temporarily halted new listings.
“IPOs in mainland China have plummeted with the total amount raised by mid-september down 86% compared to the previous year according to deal logic IPOs raised only 5.5 billion during this period marking the lowest amount for any comparable period excluding 2023 when Regulators temporarily halted new listings”
India and China have reached an agreement on patrolling and disengagement along the Line of Actual Control (LAC), signaling a potential reduction in border tensions between the two nuclear-armed nations, announced by India's Foreign Secretary Vikram Misri ahead of the BRICS summit.
“the Indian government announced that the two countries have reached an agreement on trolling and disengagement along the line of actual control Lac signaling a potential reduction in tensions between the two Nations these tensions have strained diplomatic and trade relations between the nuclear armed neighbors for years India's foreign secretary Vikram mistri made the announcement ahead of the summit of the bricks leaders in Russia”
Following deadly clashes in 2020 along the LAC that resulted in at least 24 soldiers' deaths (primarily Indian), both India and China deployed an additional 50,000 troops along the border, with India redirecting troops from the Pakistani border and China being accused of blocking previously patrolled areas.
“one such incident in eastern ladak in 2020 resulted in the deaths of at least 24 soldiers primarily Indian following the deadly clashes in 2020 both Nations deployed an additional 50,000 troops along the La India redirected troops from the Pakistani border and accused China of blocking areas previously patrolled by Indian forces”
Ongoing diplomatic and military negotiations between India and China over the past several weeks have led to the border agreement on patrolling, with talks between Chinese diplomat Wang Yi and India's national security adviser Ajit Doval previously establishing conditions for improving bilateral relations.
“Myy highlighted that ongoing diplomatic and Military negotiations between the two Powers over the past several weeks have led to an agreement on patrolling in Border areas allowing for disengagement and addressing issues from 2020 although China's foreign Ministry has not officially commented on this development Chinese foreign Ministry spokesperson linen emphasized beijing's commitment to strengthening bricks cooperation and enhancing tires with the global South during a recent press briefing this agreement follows earlier talks between Chinese Diplomat wangi and India's national security adviser Ajit doel”
Between June 2023 and May 2024, the Cross-border Interbank Payment System (CIPS) added 62 direct participants and now comprises 142 direct participants and 1,394 indirect participants, compared to Swift which remains dominant with more than 11,000 connected banks.
“between June 2023 and May 20 4 cips added 62 direct participants and now comprises 142 direct and 1,394 indirect participants Swift is still by far the dominant player with more than 11,000 connected Banks”
The US dollar's role as the primary global reserve currency is secure in the near and medium term, with the dollar continuing to dominate foreign reserve holdings, trade invoicing, and currency transactions, while all potential rivals including the Euro have limited ability to challenge the dollar in the immediate future.
“the Dollar's role as the primary Global Reserve currency is secure in the near and medium term the dollar it argues continues to dominate foreign Reserve Holdings trade invoicing and currency transactions globally all potential Rivals including the Euro have a limited ability to challenge the dollar in the immediate future”
Xi Jinping will attend the 16th BRICS Summit in Kazan, Russia in person, and China's foreign ministry signaled that this year marks the beginning of greater BRICS cooperation and is the first summit after the expansion of BRICS membership.
“next up today Tuesday Begins the 16th bricks Summit in Kazan Russia at the invitation of Russian leader Vladimir Putin Xi Jinping will attend in person”
A BRICS payment system is important for reducing global reliance on Western-dominated monetary and payment systems, preventing weaponization of global financial infrastructure, promoting economic cooperation among BRICS members, strengthening financial autonomy of emerging economies, supporting sustainable development, and reforming the global financial system.
“the establishment of a bricks payment system is key to promoting Global Financial system reform and helping build a more just and reasonable International Financial order it is therefore clear that the introduction of a bricks payment system is important for reducing the global Sals dependence on the west dominated Global monetary and Global Payments systems and stopping some powers from further weaponizing the Global Financial infrastructure it is also important for promoting economic cooperation among bricks members and strengthening their financial autonomy supporting the sustainable development of emerging economies and reforming the Global Financial system”
China's official GDP growth rate was 4.6% year-on-year in Q3 2024, falling short of the government's 5% target and representing the slowest rate in six quarters, indicating economic slowdown despite stimulus efforts.
“official data show that GDP grew 4.6% year on-ear in the third quarter of 2024 falling short of the government's 5% Target and the slowest rate in six quarters”
Parts of the Indian government are considering easing restrictions on Chinese influence and investment, suggesting potential policy reversal despite the continued hard line stance.
“however there are indications that parts of the Indian government are considering easing these restrictions”
The shift in commentary from calling China 'the largest developing country by population' to 'the largest developing country by economic size' reflects India's displacement of China as the largest developing country by population, marking a notable rhetorical shift.
“we've noticed that commentators in recent years have moved away from saying China is the largest developing country that is by population to the largest developing country in terms of economic size this is of course because now India is the largest developing country when measured by population size”
There are currently no direct flights between India and China, reflecting the broader diplomatic and economic freezing between the nations, though this may have changed since the speaker last checked.
“I also believe that there are currently no direct flights between India and China this may have changed since I last checked but is worth noting”