
What this covers
This 12-minute video from Wall Street Millennial, a channel tied to a short-selling research firm, examines Rivian's third-quarter 2024 numbers and what they imply for the company's finances. A single narrator carries it, and it follows the publisher's chapters: a long middle section on the route to gross profit, a short section on the Q3 results, and a closing look at the balance sheet. The argument is built on unit economics. In Q2 2024, cost of goods sold (COGS)) was about $117,000 per vehicle against a sale price near $84,000, a gross loss of roughly $33,000 on each car. Cost per vehicle fell from more than $200,000 at launch as fixed cost was spread over more output, then plateaued around $120,000 in 2023.
The middle section asks whether volume can close that gap. The narrator says the variable cost of labor and materials already exceeds the price, so scale alone does not fix it, and even a 20% material cost cut would not be enough without much higher output. He covers Rivian's plan to redesign the R1T and R1S and renegotiate supplier contracts, and the aim of gross profitability by Q4 2024. He also dismisses regulatory credits ($18 million in H1 2024) as too small to matter, and calls the planned R2 and R3 launches fantasy if the $70,000-plus R1 line can't make money. He does credit the product, noting that the R1T topped JD Power's 2024 satisfaction ranking.
The Q3 section is the sharpest turn. After the April–May retooling of the Normal, Illinois plant, production came in at 13,157 vehicles and deliveries at 10,018, well below expectations, and full-year production guidance was cut from 57,000 to 47,000–49,000. The closing section covers cash. Rivian has burned over $16 billion since a $100 billion-plus IPO, has about $8 billion left, and the narrator reads the pace as roughly 18 months of runway. He also examines the structure of Volkswagen's up-to-$5 billion commitment, which is staged in tranches, with some going to a joint venture and some arriving as dilutive equity.
Rivian's path to profitability is illusory because it depends on production volume increases that demand growth cannot support, while their negative contribution margins mean losses persist regardless of scale.
- Rivian has negative contribution margins—variable costs exceed selling price, so volume increases cannot achieve profitability
- Q3 2024 revealed demand collapse: 10,000+ unsold vehicles stockpiled despite factory retooling designed to boost production
- Cash burn of ~$5B/year with only $8B remaining means ~18 months of runway, far shorter than the multi-year timeline to reach profitability
This asset isn't compiled yet
You're seeing its claims, ranked. Compile it to build the argument threads, weight them, and check each claim against your library — the full view.
Rivian's path to profitability relies on massively increasing production, but without sufficient demand from customers, increased production will only worsen the cash burn problem by accumulating more unsold inventory.
“a large part of rivan's path to profitability relies on massively increasing production with the recently disclosed Parts shortage it's unclear when they'll have the technical capability to do this but even if they can ramp up production this won't do them any good if there are not enough customers willing to buy the cars at full price”
Rivian's average selling price per vehicle is about $85,000, but their cost to produce each car remains stubbornly high at around $120,000 in 2023-2024, resulting in per-unit losses exceeding $30,000.
“the average selling price of a rivan car is about $85,000 when rivan first began deliveries their cost to produce each car was more than $200,000 as they ramped up production their fixed costs were absorbed across a larger number of units and their cost per car steadily declined throughout 2022 however in 2023 their cost per car plateaued it has stayed stubbornly high at around 120 ,000 they are thus losing more than $30,000 for each car they sell”
Rivian's planned future launches of mass-market R2 and R3 vehicles are fantasy if the company cannot achieve profitability on its $80,000 R1S vehicles.
“rivan has Grand plans to eventually launch its mass Market R2 and R3 vehicles but if they can't even turn a profit on their $80,000 r1s this is all just a fantasy”
Rivian has negative contribution margins: the variable labor and material costs needed to build each car exceed the selling price, meaning that no matter how much they ramp production they will never achieve gross profitability at current pricing.
“as it turns out rivan had negative contribution margins the variable labor and material costs needed to build each car is greater than the selling price of the car thus no matter how much they ramp up production they will never achieve gross profitability”
Rivian's path to profitability must come primarily from reductions in fixed and variable costs, not revenue enhancements.
“if rivan wants to become profitable it will need to come from reductions in fixed and variable costs”
Even with assumed 20% material cost reductions, Rivian would need to substantially increase production to absorb fixed costs and achieve profitability, but Q3 results show this did not happen.
“in the second quarter of 2024 rivan incured a gross loss equal to 39% of Revenue by their own projections they're only going to achieve a 20% decrease in material costs that alone is not enough to achieve profitability thus if they are able to achieve positive gross margins they need to substantially increased production to better absorb their fixed cost”
Rivian announced in 2024 that it would redesign the R1T and R1S by simplifying designs and renegotiating supplier contracts to lower production costs, with a goal of achieving gross profitability by Q4 2024.
“in 2024 they announced that they'd be redesigning the r1t and r1s they would simplify the car's designs and renegotiate contracts with suppliers to drastically lower production costs the company boldly projected that these changes would allow them to achieve gross profitability by the fourth quarter of 2024”
Rivian achieved a valuation of over $100 billion at IPO in November 2021, right at the peak of the EV bubble.
“rivian ipoed in November of 2021 right at the peak of the EV bubble they achieved a valuation of over $100 billion”
Since going public, Rivian has burned more than $16 billion in cumulative negative free cash flow.
“since going public rivan has burned more than $16 billion”
In the most recent quarter (Q2 2024), Rivian incurred a gross loss of almost $33,000 for every car sold.
“in the most recent quarter they incurred a gross loss of almost $33,000 for every car they sold”
In Q3 2024, Rivian produced 13,157 vehicles, a 6% decline compared to Q1 2024, contradicting expectations for massive production increases from the May retooling.
“on October 4th the company disclosed that had produced 13,1 157 vehicles in the third quarter a decline of 6% compared to the first quarter”
Rivian delivered only 10,018 vehicles in Q3 2024, a shocking 26% decline compared to Q1 2024 deliveries.
“they delivered 10,18 Vehicles which is a shocking 26% decline compared to the first quarter”
In Q3 2024, Rivian stockpiled over 10,000 unsold vehicles despite only producing 13,157 total vehicles, indicating they are not supply-constrained and unable to sell inventory at current prices.
“rivan only delivered 10,8 cars to customers this is about 3,000 less than the number of cars they produced despite the supply problems rivian stockpile of unsold inventory actually increased they now have over 10,000 unsold cars piled up in their parking lots this indicates that rivan is not supply constrained even at a relatively low level of production they're unable to sell all their inventory”
Rivian's initial cost per vehicle was more than $200,000 when deliveries began, declined throughout 2022 as fixed costs were absorbed across larger production volumes, but plateaued in 2023 at around $120,000.
“when rivan first began deliveries their cost to produce each car was more than $200,000 as they ramped up production their fixed costs were absorbed across a larger number of units and their cost per car steadily declined throughout 2022 however in 2023 their cost per car plateaued it has stayed stubbornly high at around 120 ,000”
Most critics praise Rivian's cars for quality and performance, but the company has yet to achieve profitability.
“While most critics praise their cars quality and performance rivan is yet to turn a profit”
Rivian decreased its full-year 2024 production guidance from 57,000 vehicles to 47,000-49,000 vehicles following Q3 results.
“they also decreased their full-year production guidance to between 47,000 and 49,000 Vehicles they had previously forecasted production of 57,000 Vehicles”
Rivian's R1T starts at $70,000 and R1S starts at $76,000 (for standard battery with 258 mile range), and there are insufficient wealthy customers willing to spend $70,000+ on a new car.
“the r1t starts at $70,000 and the r1s starts at $76,000 that's for the standard battery pack with only 258 Mi of range there just aren't that many people who can afford to spend 70 plus, on a new car”
According to JD Power, the Rivian R1T had the highest customer satisfaction rating of any car in the US in 2024.
“according to JD Power the rivan r1t had the highest customer satisfaction rating of any car in the US in 2024”
Rivian's regulatory credit sales in H1 2024 generated only $18 million, representing less than 1% of total revenue, making this revenue pillar too small to matter for profitability.
“the first half of 2024 rivan generated $18 million from the sale of regulatory credits this was less than 1% of their total revenue it's frankly too small to matter”
In Q2 2024, Rivian's cost of goods sold was $117,000 per vehicle while they sold each car for $84,000, creating a $33,000 per-unit gross loss requiring $33,000 in cost reductions to achieve break-even.
“in the second quarter of 2024 it cost them $117,000 to produce each car they sold each car for $84,000 leading to a $33,000 loss to achieve gross profit Break Even they need to decrease their cost per car by $33,000”
In June 2024, Volkswagen Group agreed to invest up to $5 billion in Rivian, but the investment is structured in five $1 billion tranches: first tranche already received as dilutive convertible note, two tranches going to joint venture, and final two tranches as dilutive equity in 2025-2026.
“there was a lot of excitement back in June when the Volkswagen group agreed to invest up to5 billion in derivan however it's important to look at the fine print the investment is split up into five tranches of $1 billion each so far ravan has only received the first tranch which took the form of a dilutive convertible note two of the tranches will be paid out in a joint venture the two companies plan to create finally there are two tranches of dilutive equity investments in 2025 and 2026”
Rivian's share price has declined more than 90% since IPO, and market cap has fallen to $10 billion, creating a situation where annual cash burn is ~50% of market cap—unsustainable for very long.
“since going public rivian's share price has declined by more than 90% their market cap has fallen to just $10 billion their annual cash burn is now about one half of their market cap such an extreme level of cash burn cannot be sustained for very long”
Rivian shut down its Normal, Illinois plant in early April 2024 for retooling, completing the retooling by May 10th and resuming production of Gen 2 R1 vehicles.
“in early April they shut down their plants in Normal Illinois for retooling by May 10th the retooling was complete and they started producing the second generation of their R1 cars”
Since going public, Rivian has burned cumulative negative free cash flow of over $16 billion at a rate of roughly $5 billion per year, leaving approximately 1.5 years of runway with $8 billion in cash.
“since going public rivan has burned over 16 billion dollars of negative free cash flow... as of the end of the second quarter rivan had $8 billion of cash in equivalence on their balance sheet they burned cash at a rate of roughly $5 billion per year so at the current rate they'll run out of cash in about a year and a half”
Excluding money allocated to the VW joint venture, Rivian is only receiving $1 billion per year from VW—covering only ~1/5th of its ~$5 billion annual cash burn.
“if you exclude the money going to the joint venture Ravine is only receiving $1 billion per year that it can use to fund its existing operations this only covers about 1/5th of their cash burn”
Rivian blamed Q3 production shortfalls on a shortage of a certain component, but the real problem is an apparent collapse in demand for their cars.
“rivan blamed the poor production numbers on a shortage of a certain component while the component shortage is certainly concerning it's not even rivan's biggest problem the biggest problem is an apparent collapse in demand for their cars”
Rivian's promised path to profitability was based on projecting positive gross margins by end of 2024 through vehicle redesigns, renegotiated supplier contracts, and factory retooling.
“as rivan stock plummeted the company attempted to calm investors by outlining a supposed path to profitability projecting positive gross margins by the end of 2024 they promised cost reductions through vehicle redesigns renegotiated supplier cost contracts and Factory retooling”
Q3 2024 delivery numbers reported October 4th cast serious doubt on Rivian's path to profitability.
“disastrous Q3 delivery numbers reported on October 4th cast serious doubt on the supposed path to profitability”
Based on assumptions of 20% material+labor cost reduction and 46% fixed cost reduction from increased production, Rivian's modeled cost savings equal approximately $22,000 per vehicle—requiring about $11,000 in additional unaccounted savings to reach the $33,000 break-even target.
“if they achieve a 20% reduction on variable cost that saves them about $16,000 per vehicle if they achieve a 46% reduction in fixed cost that saves them about $6,000 per vehicle that would get them to $32,000 of total savings which just about gets them to Break Even thus it would appear that about half of the planned cost savings must come from greater fixed cost absorption”
At an investor day on June 27th, Rivian claimed Gen 2 redesign would lower material costs and fixed costs, and increase revenue per unit through regulatory credit sales and vehicle remarketing.
“on June 27th rivan hosted an investor day where they gave more details about their path to gross profitability they said the Gen 2 redesign will have lower material costs and lower fixed cost they also expect to make greater Revenue per unit thanks to regulatory credit sales and remarketing of trade in vehicles”
Rivian does not disclose revenue from remarketing used traded-in vehicles, and this revenue is likely too small to materially impact profitability.
“they do not disclose how much revenue they generate from remarketing and it's probably too small to matter”
Rivian claims the Gen 2 R1 redesign will have 20% lower material costs compared to the first generation vehicle.
“in total they say that the second generation of the R1 cars will have 20% lower material costs compared to the first generation”
In an August 2024 CNBC interview, Rivian CEO RJ Scaringe claimed the factory now operates with a 30% higher line rate (production throughput) compared to pre-shutdown levels.
“RJ scaringe said the factory now has a 30% increased line rate compared to what it had before the shutdown 30% greater production means 23% lower fixed cost per car”
Given Rivian's disastrous financial performance and the lack of a viable path to profitability, it is unclear whether the company will even exist 2-3 years from now.
“given their disastrous financial performance it's unclear if rivan will even exist 2 or 3 years from now”
Rivian currently produces three vehicles: the R1T pickup truck, the R1S SUV, and an electric delivery van.
“rivan currently produces three cars the r1t pickup truck the r1s SUV and the electric delivery van”